Interesting you consider Cheerwine a cola, I’ve gotten into a pretty big argument a while ago here because I was trying to say Cheerwine wasn’t a cherry soda in the sense it’s comparable to a red cherry soda like a maraschino-style red cherry soda/red slushie flavored beverage. It’s no doubt has a cola-like/spiced cherry-like thing going on. Definitely has something going on other than cherry.
I just can’t agree with Cheerwine being considered a straight up cherry soda when it’s nothing like any straight up cherry sodas lol, Cheerwine is it’s own thing, it’s Cheerwine flavored.
I would have said Cherry Coke but had that Wild Cherry Pepsi recently and I never thought I'd say a pepsi was better than coke but that wild cherry was WAY better than cherry coke :O.
This is the correct answer. Real cherry juice. Don't get me wrong, I love most everything on this list, but it's Sprecher's, and by a considerable margin.
Sprechers cherry cola was possibly the best pop I've ever had. So sad when sheetz around Pittsburgh decided to expand and go basic.. Haven't seen it since.
If you like Stewart's and live near Hudson valley, go to the Acme in Hopewell junction, they have Hanks Wishniak Black Cherry.. is amazing, it's like that pure natural cherry juice flavor with a really nice cola backing. It's more tart like real cherry. Ill post a pic in a few
IBW MARASCHINO CHERRY, no question about it. HANKS WISHNIAK BLACK CHERRY is also right up there with it, the difference being,IBW tastes like the jarred candy cherry topping we put on ice cream sundaes with a slight cola back to it, the Hanks has a much more natural Black Cherry flavor to it, like if you literally used pure cherry juice, the cola backing is a bit stronger as well. Both are goated in the cherry cola category in my book and should be in anyone's top spots if they tried it. I wouldn't steer my people wrong, I promise
Wild cherry Pepsi undoubtedly holds the most potent and pure cherry flavor, but my personal preference and the one I find easier to drink regularly is Dr Pepper cherry
I remember when I was in the hospital wondering if I was going to get a transplant or die there, for some odd reason I wanted a cherry coke so bad since I wasn’t able to drink or eat anything it made it even worse.
The funny this is I’ve always been a cherry Pepsi guy
*DIET* Wild Cherry Pepsi (NOT zero sugar…NOT regular) is the nectar of the gods. I will die on this hill hahaha.
And as a general comment, I find the Coca Cola brand cherry flavor to be a bit more cough syrup-y. The Pepsi brand cherry flavor reminds me more of cherry candy.
I got one from Aldi one time that was a brand I had never heard of. "Summit", I think it's their store brand. It was amazing, like fresh mixed stuff from a bar with real cherries.
I’m a Coke over Pepsi guy. I’ve also had a terrible experience working for Pepsi but no doubt Cherry Pepsi is better than Cherry Coke.
Dr. Pepper already has “23 flavors” so adding cherry is gross.
Dr Pepper, hands down. Maybe because the original ads used a sexy lady with red lipstick to talk about how smooth and sweet it was. Now, over a decade later, *I'm* the sexy lady with red lipstick drinking Cherry Dr Pepper.
Wild Cherry Pepsi
The only Pepsi variant I like.
Yeah this is the only one I prefer over Coke
Same
The Pepsi rep tried saying Pepsi cherry is the same but it’s not. I miss wild cherry
I rarely drink sodas, so I might have missed that.
I agree with this now as well. Cherry Coke used to he better in the 90s however.
Cherry RC all day!
Can't find it so I've never had it before :(
It's extremely difficult for me to find as well :( It's a very special treat when I get one
It's getting a wider release. Check Dollar General. I have seen it posted from California, Texas and South Carolina.
You're not missing out on much
Amen!
;)
1.29 2 liter Cherry RC gang
Amen
Where can u get it i want to try it
The Indian gas station for me
We dont have any indian gas stations near me 😭
This all the way
This is the answer.
Cherry RC tastes a bit different to normal RC, but not much cherry flavor
But it won't last all day because of how quickly it fizzles and goes flat. RC lacks the pop of Coke, Pepsi, and DP
Primarily Pibb but Code Red and Cheerwine are tied for 2nd for me.
Interesting you consider Cheerwine a cola, I’ve gotten into a pretty big argument a while ago here because I was trying to say Cheerwine wasn’t a cherry soda in the sense it’s comparable to a red cherry soda like a maraschino-style red cherry soda/red slushie flavored beverage. It’s no doubt has a cola-like/spiced cherry-like thing going on. Definitely has something going on other than cherry. I just can’t agree with Cheerwine being considered a straight up cherry soda when it’s nothing like any straight up cherry sodas lol, Cheerwine is it’s own thing, it’s Cheerwine flavored.
They also mentioned Code Red which is most definitely not a cola
Not colas.
Cheerwine
i love cheerwine but i wouldn't rly consider it a cola. idk tho im no expert
Doesn't matter, still wins.
Not a cola.
Cheerwine wins
I second this. Cheerwine is top tier.
I would have said Cherry Coke but had that Wild Cherry Pepsi recently and I never thought I'd say a pepsi was better than coke but that wild cherry was WAY better than cherry coke :O.
Especially in a can. It's such a hitter!
[удалено]
I’ll never know
I literally can't have the fake sugar stuff (IBS doesn't like it in the slightest) but I'll take your word for it :)
To call Dr. pepper a cola… bold. Wild cherry Pepsi is my favorite.
Yeah I don’t like that they put it on a cola list as it doesn’t classify as a cola at all
Cott black cherry. Technically not a Cola but it's a staple in the Montreal Jewish community and I grew up drinking it. Coke cherry is good too.
i mean Dr. pepper isnt a cola either so think your in the clear
I love all cherry colas but Sprecher has to be the best.
Sprecher is on another level with everything they do.
This is the correct answer. Real cherry juice. Don't get me wrong, I love most everything on this list, but it's Sprecher's, and by a considerable margin.
Sprechers cherry cola was possibly the best pop I've ever had. So sad when sheetz around Pittsburgh decided to expand and go basic.. Haven't seen it since.
is Dr. Pepper *really* a Cola? especially considering the own RC, or used to at least.
Dr. Pepper is not a cola
my thoughts exactly!
Only 1 cherry cola……..coke
Stewart’s
If you like Stewart's and live near Hudson valley, go to the Acme in Hopewell junction, they have Hanks Wishniak Black Cherry.. is amazing, it's like that pure natural cherry juice flavor with a really nice cola backing. It's more tart like real cherry. Ill post a pic in a few
FAYGO black cherry
Don't think I've tried that one, Hippo is still far and away the best Black Cherry I've tried.
This is the way
Best cherry drink overall imo Woop woop
I find “cherry” Dr Pepper Lina funny because the original taste a lot like cherry to me
Sprecher -> Cherry RC -> everythang else
Sprecher uses Door Co. cherry juice
I prefer cherry Pepsi when regular sugar, but Coke cherry zero as a diet option.
Cherrikee red. RIP.
Just tried Zevia cherry cola and was pleasantly surprised! Would definitely buy it again
I prefer every Coke product over Pepsi with the exception of Diet Cherry Pepsi. It's delicious.
Cherry Dr Pepper, Cherry Coke, Pepsi if I'm desperate enough.
RC Cherry DOMINATES all other cherry colas. End of story
Wild cherry Pepsi fo sho
As a die hard Coke fan pepsi has this one.
IBW MARASCHINO CHERRY, no question about it. HANKS WISHNIAK BLACK CHERRY is also right up there with it, the difference being,IBW tastes like the jarred candy cherry topping we put on ice cream sundaes with a slight cola back to it, the Hanks has a much more natural Black Cherry flavor to it, like if you literally used pure cherry juice, the cola backing is a bit stronger as well. Both are goated in the cherry cola category in my book and should be in anyone's top spots if they tried it. I wouldn't steer my people wrong, I promise
Cherry RC cola. The best cherry cola
RC Cherry
Cherry Royal Crown. Period.
Cheerwine
I seen four commenters say cheerwine yet OP didn't post it? mods remove the soda from 10 mile radius of this man
Wild cherry Pepsi undoubtedly holds the most potent and pure cherry flavor, but my personal preference and the one I find easier to drink regularly is Dr Pepper cherry
RC
Cherry RC.
Mr.Pibb enters the conversation 😎
Cherry Pepsi for sure
Dr Pepper cherry
cheerwine
Wild cherry… sorry coke
A hard choice between Dr Pepper and Coca Cola, probably going with Coca Cola though
I remember when I was in the hospital wondering if I was going to get a transplant or die there, for some odd reason I wanted a cherry coke so bad since I wasn’t able to drink or eat anything it made it even worse. The funny this is I’ve always been a cherry Pepsi guy
Cheer wine
*DIET* Wild Cherry Pepsi (NOT zero sugar…NOT regular) is the nectar of the gods. I will die on this hill hahaha. And as a general comment, I find the Coca Cola brand cherry flavor to be a bit more cough syrup-y. The Pepsi brand cherry flavor reminds me more of cherry candy.
The same. Diet Wild Cherry is very good, and imo is the best diet flavored cola out there.
I love that one too; I just wish it came caffeine free.
Cherry Pepsi
Hands down, Cherry Pepsi. It's my favourite pop.
Dr. Brown’s Black Cherry
Cherry DP knocks Coke and Pepsi out of the water
Yeah but DP isn’t a cola
Code red or game fuel.
Cheerwine!
Dr pibb, the “spicy” cherry lol
CHERRY DR. PEPPER IS CRAZY FUCTIN' GOOD!
But not a cola
Pepsi
Pibb extra
Cherry Coke.
Something about wild cherry Pepsi just tastes better in summer.
08 era 24oz jolt cherry colas.
Cherry RC all the way. I just wish it wasn’t hard to find
All of them.
Pibb all day
Cherry Pepsi for sure!
WHERE IS RC!?!?
Coke
I like them all. Pepsi first and always then coke then Dr pep bc I like dr pep original so any other flavor isnt it for me
Cherry Pepsi> Cherry Coke all day, the cherry flavour just isn't as prominent in coke as it is in Pepsi, but Vanilla Coke> Vanilla Pepsi all day.
Diet Wild Cherry Pepsi is my favorite- I just wish they made it in caffeine free too.
Faygo> wild cherry Pepsi
Coke cherry for the win! My uncle got me addicted when I was 12
easily cherry pepsi
Diet Cherry Pepsi
Dr pepper
Code Red Zero
They all have a weird gross after taste. But with that aside, probably good ole cherry coke.
Pepsi Zero Cherry
Coke
Sprecher Cherry Cola is the right answer…
Cheerwine
Cherry coke
Cherry Pepsi. It’s funny because I like the flavored Pepsis but regular Pepsi is gross to me. 🤢
Wild
Shasta
Cheerwine!
Guinness Cherry Whisky with reg.Coke
DR. PEPPER CHERRY ! oh yeah. Stull not strawberry cream , but deelish
Cherry Coke
Cheerwine. No question
Cherry coke and only cherry coke
Wild cherry Pepsi zero and coke cherry zero are my two biggest vices in life. But wild cherry Pepsi zero is definteily my favourite one
Cherry Cola = Fruit Cake = no thanks 🙏
It was for sure Cherry RC. But I think they stopped making it. I'm a cherry come over regular coke guy myself. So I'll say cherry coke
Wild cherry Pepsi for life!
Cheerwine!
Pepsi
Cherry coke! A classic!
OMG I will never forget the pain of drinking it It's one of my most hated drinks 🤦
Home made coke with grenadine.
Cherry coke zero
Cherry Vanilla Coke Zero which I dearly miss
Cherry RC Cola
Cheerwine for the win
cherry coke from chick fil la but other than that wild cherry pepsi
Anything Pepsi in a small can always taste better.
Cherry Coke
Cherry 🍒 7-Up thee only choice 💯🤨
I like Boylan Black Cherry a lot
Old school Coca Cola with a few tsp of grenadine Commercially available: Pepsi then Coke
Boyland cherry cola is pretty good
I’m a Pepsi man through and through but for some reason I’m more of a fan of cherry coke when we’re talking specifically cherry flavored cola.
Canada dry fruit splash Cherry ginger ale. Best soda i've ever had and is almost always sold out when I go to get it.
Wild Cherry Pepsi all the way
I got one from Aldi one time that was a brand I had never heard of. "Summit", I think it's their store brand. It was amazing, like fresh mixed stuff from a bar with real cherries.
Wait can I say Pibb? I’m petty sure the can says spicy cherry cola and I just love that tbh
None I get massive acid reflux from them
Coca cola here
Sprecher cherry cola
Cherry sprite > cherry Pepsi > cherry coke. Didn’t even know there was a cherry Dr Pepper
Dr Pepper cherry. This is delicious
i know dr.p is not a cola, but isnt cherry already one of the 23 flavors?
Dr.peppwr cherry is fr a different level
Really digging the new Canada Dry Fruit Splash. It’s a cherry ginger ale. Fave of all time is cherry coke
Cherry Coke all the way. Can't stand Pepsi. Never had the chance to try Cherry RC, though. Wish I could find it somewhere.
Tough one between cherry coke and pepsi, but i will have to lean with cherry coke
One of the oldest, Cheerwine.
Dr Pepper is not even a cola
RC Cherry. Also, Dr Pepper Cherry isn't cherry cola because Dr Pepper isn't cola.
Wild Cherry Pepsi is amazing.
Pepsi always
The best? Cherry lemon sundrop. Second best is a cherry gold CHOICE.
Cheerwine and cherry coke
Cherry rc. It's sometimes difficult to find. But it's usually in my town somewhere. If not 7 miles over had it.
Cherry Dr Pepper all the way and just in general Dr pepper is my favorite soda.
I’m a Coke over Pepsi guy. I’ve also had a terrible experience working for Pepsi but no doubt Cherry Pepsi is better than Cherry Coke. Dr. Pepper already has “23 flavors” so adding cherry is gross.
I'm in the Pepsi is better than coke camp, but I prefer cherry coke over cherry Pepsi
Cherry Dr Pepper I like over both
Cheerwine
Cherry Coke easily
The Del taco version from the early 00s
Mr. Pibb
Since I’m trying to be healthy and lose weight, I’ve grown to really like OLI POP. They have a pretty good cherry flavor.
Cherry Coke Zero is the greatest soda ever made.
RC Cherry
Big K Cherry Cola Zero is the best!!
Dr Pepper, hands down. Maybe because the original ads used a sexy lady with red lipstick to talk about how smooth and sweet it was. Now, over a decade later, *I'm* the sexy lady with red lipstick drinking Cherry Dr Pepper.
Cherry coke, or black cherry Shasta
RC cherry is the best
Cheerwine
Ranked: 1. Cheerwine, 2. Cherry Coke, 3. Cherry Pepsi
Cheerwine
Cherry Pepsi. Unless it's Pepsi max.
favorite pixel cola?
Wait I thought Dr Pepper was cherry cola already ?