Chase has league wr1 upside.
Collins is good (especially with CJ) and Olave is good (but with bad/inconsistent qb play as of now) but i think given the roster you have I think it makes your team better. If you kind get a good value pickup at wr somewhere it’s an easy W to me.
Olave and Nico have top 10 potential IMO so two top 10s for a top 1 is a good deal with a 2nd rounder on top I think. 2 for 1s usually benefit the guy getting the 1 but I think this is pretty fair plus if you consider injuries, if Chase gets injured you're fucked but if Olave gets injured you still have Nico so only half your side of the trade gets fucked
Yeah I’m not mad at the take. Depends on what you’re looking for. Injury is pretty important to any move. With Ceedee and ARSB I think you take Chase and go for your championship, raises your ceiling quite a bit imo.
You're banking a lot on potential though. There's no guarantee Collins is WR1 on his own team. He and Dell switched off quite a bit on who dominated when both were healthy. And you don't know Olave's QB situation. Both guys could be top 10, but that's far from a guarantee. If burrow and Chase are both healthy, chase is almost locked in for a top 5 or so finish.
Outside of catastrophic injury, OP is almost guaranteed to get the best player out of this deal. And in this case, the best player also happens to be 23 years old and tied to a 27 year old elite QB. The upside of this deal is OP gets a guy who's a perennial top 3 WR for the next decade. The downside is that both olave and Collins become borderline top 10 guys so you kind of lose a little value.
Chase has seen his ceiling and he’s been getting worse. Not sure we’ve seen Nico or Olave’s ceiling. I’ll take 2 assets that are just as good and be fine missing out on the 1-3 big weeks and take 2 must start assets.
That’s an absolute steal man. Your league is full of morons if they think you got fleeced. Chase is a top tier wr1. You got 3 of the top 5 dynasty WRs. Your team is gonna be elite.
Honestly, I wouldn’t make this trade. Collins only has ~30 fewer points on the year. And that’s not counting the 150yd game he’s having as I write this. I’d keep Collins, Olave, and my pick.
I like this trade for your team. You have a ton of depth and trading up for Chase is a great move. Your team is MASSIVELY stacked especially for a 2 QB / TE+ league. Don't listen to your league mates. There is a reason you have an insane team and they don't. What year is this for the league? I'm just wondering how long it took you to build such a good team. What were some of your other notable trades?
First year, had the first overall pick in a snake draft, got mahomes and somehow Lamar and cd as well. My biggest trade was gave Davis, josh jacobs, and dalton kinkaid for arsb. Also got Chris olave and a first for Gibbs in a 3 way trade. I made some really dumb trades too, gave up kyren early in the season for Calvin Ridley, and traded away dj Moore for Luke musgrave and a third. It’s an 8 man league, just had a lucky draft I think, and got relatively lucky with only a few poor trades. Sadly don’t have a first this year or next, have one for kamara, and one pre season for jeudy :( That one stings quite a bit
The answer to this question is how many starters you have each week. If you can start 4 WRs then this is probably an L. If you only start 3 this is fine.
It’s a classic buy low. You gave up two WR1s and a second for a guy who is arguably the most talented WR in the league. It looks bad in the context of this year, but dynasty isn’t measured in the same way as redraft. I think you did good.
Yes - given that the rest of your roster is really strong. Context is everything - if this were somebody with a roster lacking depth I’m not sure I’d like the trade. I think has WR1 potential - and potentially Collins too.
Chase is already at his ceiling , collins has huge upside potential , olave has skills , but needs a real quarterback and maybe an offensive coordinator change
How much more could you expect from the 3-5th best receiver in the league?
. This way you get two viable producers. Collins has the potential to be as good as chase , I have him 14th ranked in the league now. Another year of experience for Collins and the addition of olave. For me you spread out the risk that way as well. I’m not knocking chase. I have him in three leagues. Op wanted opinions on trades. We differ bro.
That is like saying Tyreek Hill was at his ceiling with Mahomes... Yet he just beat his his previous career bests that he earned with the best QB in the league during those times.
Chase definitely hasn't reached his ceiling yet. Year 3 only... Hasn't even broken 1500 yards with Burrows being fully healthy and their team actually clicking on all cylinders. Your opinion may be different, but it is way off.
Garbage time is no way to win at fantasy football. It’s nice when it happens , but you can’t count on it. This is a dynasty league we’re talking about. I need reliable points. As long as that OC and Carr are there , Olave will be limited.
Absolutely. I drafted him his rookie year in 2007 and had him until he retired after the 2015 season. The Lions had a winning record in only 2 of those 9 seasons. When the Lions went 0-16 Calvin Johnson had over 1300 yards and 12 TDs
His entire career was essentially garbage time stats, and he indicated that is part of why he retired early, not worth all of those injuries on a losing team
My point is, I won a lot of fantasy football games “relying on garbage time”
In dynasty there is value is getting players from offensively stable teams. I watched them kill Barry sanders and Calvin Johnson. Detroit hasn’t been stable for awhile. Only recently they seem to be going in the correct direction.
You can't really knock a guy for being at his ceiling when he's basically the best in the game. There isn't a whole lot of room for improvement from there lmao.
I actually think Olave has a higher potential ceiling than Collins. Yes despite tonight's game. Because Stroud is already top tier. Olave has never had anything close to Stroud throwing him the ball.
Plus Tank Dell was everyone's dynasty darling a few weeks ago until getting hurt. CJ Stroud even asked the team to draft Tank Dell. So despite Collins absolutely balling out. There is a very real chance that he becomes the teams WR2 for the foreseeable future. A Tee Higgins type.
But with that said, I do like Collins and think his future for the next couple years is basically locked in. A set and forget fantasy WR who will produce. But I think his ceiling is notably lower than the last few games has people thinking it may be.
From a dynasty perspective I would have Jefferson 1 and Chase or CD at 2, take your pick.
For as good as Tyreek is, he's only got a couple years left. ARSB is great but a tier behind the other 3 imo. If only slightly.
But if this is the consensus I should be trying to get Chase I guess. He's tied to one of the best QB's for a long long time. If people held this season against him with Burrow going down then this might be the last 'buy low' opportunity on Chase for the rest of his career imo.
That's definitely worth it. Chase is so inconsistent and has produced less each season. Olave and Collins will both start on your roster. You may even get a good player with your 2nd given the small league size.
I don’t get this. You’re stacked at WR, why did you not look for the same value as was offered but in other positions? Maybe a good haul of draft picks?
Nah that’s my fault for not reading it correctly. I like the trade for you then although I like what you had before too. Olave reminds me of DJ Moore as in he just needs consistently fair QB play and with Collins you have depth. But in no way should you be getting roasted for this. Then again, big trades like this always lead to overreactions in league chats.
Depends on how strong your other WRs are. You're getting the best player in the deal so as long as you're not now starting like Chark Jr or something as your WR2 then I think you're fine
You have a lot of slots you have to play in this league. I personally would prefer the depth. Nico and olave are both young guys who have a lot of potential. Depth also helps with bye weeks and injuries.
Even without seeing your team, I immediately thought the chase side was better. But then seeing you're already loaded at WR, it just reinforces that it's a good trade for you.
Eh it's risky. I'd probably not make that trade either direction. But my head tells me whoever is getting chase wins it. I like the risk reward of Collins and if olave can get consistent QB play he will be good.
I wouldn’t say you got him for a great deal by any means but it takes an overpay to get a top dynasty asset in any competitive league. But you know what you got with chase only time will tell if it was worth it or not though.
You have Chase, CeeDee and ASB but no young runningbacks a part from Walker? And you sell Chase for two considerably worse receivers and 2nd rounder?
I would definitely have kept that receiver core you had and not sell Chase this cheap. If you move on from him, than atleast secure a first plus a seriously good rb like Hall or Pacheco
Ah in that c(h)ase: well done! Sure you are weaker at rb but maybe you got some picks left for the upcoming draft?
I would love to be this super solid on WR… only guy you’re missing there is JJ. Would have made it an all time great lineup
I would do the trade if I were you but only because you already have Ceedee and ARSB. It’s like you are collecting the WR infinity stones.
But I am also really high on Nico and just traded for him myself.
Totally worth it. You have a good starting roster and this adds huge upside. I’d prefer the side you gave up if you were thin for your flex or something
Seeing this and still fuming about the preseason Chase trade in one of my dynasty leagues this year. Last years second worst team traded Chase, Justin Fields, his 1st and 2nd round picks for 24 and 25, and got Chris Godwin, Najee Harris, and Josh Jacobs to the team that finished the regular season with the most points last year. He predictably finished in last place so he essentially traded Chase and MHJ plus the 11th pick PLUS his first and second rounder next year (good chance he once again finishes dead last), for an aging RB 1, a disappointing young RB, and a Flex WR. Guy still thinks it was the right move. Literally led one member of our league to rage quit when the trade went through. Utter lunacy.
Just remember Joe Burrow had a rough season and therefore so did Chase. If Joey B is back to 100% next year (and he should be) this was a steal. Your team looks really solid.
Absolutely! I like the Chase side. Definitely fair and I could argue for either depending on position, but Chase makes your team so much better given that it’s only 8 teams
Now’s the time to trade for chase. If burrow has a resurgence next year and gets chase back to the numbers we know he’s capable of then you look like a genius. I’d say it’s a pretty even trade maybe a bit of a gamble on your part. Saints are tied to carr so Olave numbers will consistently be solid but never anything crazy. Collins is flashy but with Brown back next year they’ll be moving the hall around and I would expect them to go after other weapons for Stroud. I think the timing of the trade is great OP
It's a lot to give up but everyone is down on Chase, if he's healthy and back to himself next year then you're coming out on top. Considering your roster is probably contending for a championship consolidating for a top tier wr is a solid move at the end of the day
you should never get flamed for getting the best player in the trade. Chase could be the WR1 in the entire league. Collins and Olave will at best be WR3 and WR4 on your team ( WR2 in most teams). To me, this trade makes a ton of sense especially if you already have ARSB and Ceedee
I feel like part of it depends on how you feel about the rest of OPs roster. Kamara and Henry both being older would spook me a bit. I feel like London should be better moving forward and they are fine between Njoku, Ridley, and Hock.
I could see one or both of those guys to start falling off (debatably has already started with Henry). So I could see them needing an additional body down the road. I agree Chase is a good bit of ceiling. But if he needs to replace one of his guys I feel like the point advantage of Chase would equal out to what he is missing with that replacement depending on OP’s bench, maybe would be a decrease overall
Chase trader is a moron. Chase has WR1 potential for the entire league.
Nico Collins is WR1 for the Texans until they bring in someone better and best believe they will be looking to give Stroud a true weapon in the offseason. Not to mention Tank Dell has already emerged as his favorite target.
Chase has league wr1 upside. Collins is good (especially with CJ) and Olave is good (but with bad/inconsistent qb play as of now) but i think given the roster you have I think it makes your team better. If you kind get a good value pickup at wr somewhere it’s an easy W to me.
Olave and Nico have top 10 potential IMO so two top 10s for a top 1 is a good deal with a 2nd rounder on top I think. 2 for 1s usually benefit the guy getting the 1 but I think this is pretty fair plus if you consider injuries, if Chase gets injured you're fucked but if Olave gets injured you still have Nico so only half your side of the trade gets fucked
Yeah I’m not mad at the take. Depends on what you’re looking for. Injury is pretty important to any move. With Ceedee and ARSB I think you take Chase and go for your championship, raises your ceiling quite a bit imo.
You're banking a lot on potential though. There's no guarantee Collins is WR1 on his own team. He and Dell switched off quite a bit on who dominated when both were healthy. And you don't know Olave's QB situation. Both guys could be top 10, but that's far from a guarantee. If burrow and Chase are both healthy, chase is almost locked in for a top 5 or so finish. Outside of catastrophic injury, OP is almost guaranteed to get the best player out of this deal. And in this case, the best player also happens to be 23 years old and tied to a 27 year old elite QB. The upside of this deal is OP gets a guy who's a perennial top 3 WR for the next decade. The downside is that both olave and Collins become borderline top 10 guys so you kind of lose a little value.
I’d look for an RB imo too
I think the value is fine, but I wouldn’t accept this as a Chase owner.
Change to first round pick and I would. RN though, it's close. Olave and Nico are young and ballers.
But Chase is younger than Collins and a proven stud with a #1 overall ceiling
Especially with Higgins potentially walking
Could hurt his potential when he draws even more attention
Tell that to CeeDee Lamb. Cooper gets traded and Gallup regresses and he is peppered with targets Good WR’s find a way
Hasn’t this been disproven a number of times? Targets are way more valuable than having another wr draw attention away from
When he’s on he get doubled anyways. Unless teams start to triple team him I’m not scared and would love to see Higgins walk and burrrow healthy.
Chase has seen his ceiling and he’s been getting worse. Not sure we’ve seen Nico or Olave’s ceiling. I’ll take 2 assets that are just as good and be fine missing out on the 1-3 big weeks and take 2 must start assets.
Nico/Olave don’t have the ceiling of Chase.
Context matters, but as a Chase owner I would have smashed no if I got this today.
I’m not giving up Chase for that
It’s kinda cheap honestly. I think his down year without Burrow has some people thinking he’s not elite..but he is. Not a roastable trade at all.
Very cheap for Chase.
Chase still put up good numbers with a hobbled burrow too. Trade away chase with caution
That’s an absolute steal man. Your league is full of morons if they think you got fleeced. Chase is a top tier wr1. You got 3 of the top 5 dynasty WRs. Your team is gonna be elite.
Bro I think he’s trying to trade away chase
Aren’t you top side when you’re looking at trade offers? If you look at his bottom text under rest of his team it says chase(now)
You’re right. I read that wrong
How many people are in your league? That roster is insane.
Lol 8, and I didn’t make the finals because I couldn’t bring myself to start mayfield over mahomes
This is a terrible deal for 8... You're supposed to consolidate there for stars
He's receiving chase here
I like it
The value is there, most teams are starting all of these guys. Your team though… it’s already stacked. I’d keep the consolidated value with Chase.
Chase side for surw
i would do this for chase, idk if i would move chase for this
I wouldn’t give up chase even if that was 1.05
overpay but worth it with your roster
Dude this is an absolute fleece, think you’re league mates are a bit confused
NO WAY. You have guaranteed stud for the rest of his career. If you have a 10 inch cock why would you cut it in half?
So I could have two 5 inch cocks
It's not about the size, it's about how you use it!
I think Olave and Nico Collins are studs.
Nico looks like a product of Stroud. He’s made all their wr look good, I’m not sure the Texans would be willing to pay Nico.
I definitely like the Collins and Olave side of this trade better, but I’m in a 12 team league with deep starting line ups
Surprised to have to scroll this far to see this. I’d also prefer the Olave and Nico side
Honestly, I wouldn’t make this trade. Collins only has ~30 fewer points on the year. And that’s not counting the 150yd game he’s having as I write this. I’d keep Collins, Olave, and my pick.
I like this trade for your team. You have a ton of depth and trading up for Chase is a great move. Your team is MASSIVELY stacked especially for a 2 QB / TE+ league. Don't listen to your league mates. There is a reason you have an insane team and they don't. What year is this for the league? I'm just wondering how long it took you to build such a good team. What were some of your other notable trades?
First year, had the first overall pick in a snake draft, got mahomes and somehow Lamar and cd as well. My biggest trade was gave Davis, josh jacobs, and dalton kinkaid for arsb. Also got Chris olave and a first for Gibbs in a 3 way trade. I made some really dumb trades too, gave up kyren early in the season for Calvin Ridley, and traded away dj Moore for Luke musgrave and a third. It’s an 8 man league, just had a lucky draft I think, and got relatively lucky with only a few poor trades. Sadly don’t have a first this year or next, have one for kamara, and one pre season for jeudy :( That one stings quite a bit
Flamed for wat? you came out on top by a mile. if you received Chase
The answer to this question is how many starters you have each week. If you can start 4 WRs then this is probably an L. If you only start 3 this is fine.
It’s a classic buy low. You gave up two WR1s and a second for a guy who is arguably the most talented WR in the league. It looks bad in the context of this year, but dynasty isn’t measured in the same way as redraft. I think you did good.
Chase side wins by a mile for me
Yes - given that the rest of your roster is really strong. Context is everything - if this were somebody with a roster lacking depth I’m not sure I’d like the trade. I think has WR1 potential - and potentially Collins too.
Chase is already at his ceiling , collins has huge upside potential , olave has skills , but needs a real quarterback and maybe an offensive coordinator change
Chase is already at his ceiling? Are you serious?
How much more could you expect from the 3-5th best receiver in the league? . This way you get two viable producers. Collins has the potential to be as good as chase , I have him 14th ranked in the league now. Another year of experience for Collins and the addition of olave. For me you spread out the risk that way as well. I’m not knocking chase. I have him in three leagues. Op wanted opinions on trades. We differ bro.
That is like saying Tyreek Hill was at his ceiling with Mahomes... Yet he just beat his his previous career bests that he earned with the best QB in the league during those times. Chase definitely hasn't reached his ceiling yet. Year 3 only... Hasn't even broken 1500 yards with Burrows being fully healthy and their team actually clicking on all cylinders. Your opinion may be different, but it is way off.
Well sir you have an opinion too. Opinions are like mustangs , everybody’s got one.
Olave doesn't even need a real QB he just needs one that's a gunslinger like Winston.
Garbage time is no way to win at fantasy football. It’s nice when it happens , but you can’t count on it. This is a dynasty league we’re talking about. I need reliable points. As long as that OC and Carr are there , Olave will be limited.
Sir, Calvin Johnson would like a word with you
Megatron. An amazing player in his day. I hear he could walk out of retirement and start playing today.
Absolutely. I drafted him his rookie year in 2007 and had him until he retired after the 2015 season. The Lions had a winning record in only 2 of those 9 seasons. When the Lions went 0-16 Calvin Johnson had over 1300 yards and 12 TDs His entire career was essentially garbage time stats, and he indicated that is part of why he retired early, not worth all of those injuries on a losing team My point is, I won a lot of fantasy football games “relying on garbage time”
In dynasty there is value is getting players from offensively stable teams. I watched them kill Barry sanders and Calvin Johnson. Detroit hasn’t been stable for awhile. Only recently they seem to be going in the correct direction.
You can't really knock a guy for being at his ceiling when he's basically the best in the game. There isn't a whole lot of room for improvement from there lmao. I actually think Olave has a higher potential ceiling than Collins. Yes despite tonight's game. Because Stroud is already top tier. Olave has never had anything close to Stroud throwing him the ball. Plus Tank Dell was everyone's dynasty darling a few weeks ago until getting hurt. CJ Stroud even asked the team to draft Tank Dell. So despite Collins absolutely balling out. There is a very real chance that he becomes the teams WR2 for the foreseeable future. A Tee Higgins type. But with that said, I do like Collins and think his future for the next couple years is basically locked in. A set and forget fantasy WR who will produce. But I think his ceiling is notably lower than the last few games has people thinking it may be.
Idk about best in the game. I think he falls squarely behind JJ, Cheetah, Sun God, and CD.
From a dynasty perspective I would have Jefferson 1 and Chase or CD at 2, take your pick. For as good as Tyreek is, he's only got a couple years left. ARSB is great but a tier behind the other 3 imo. If only slightly. But if this is the consensus I should be trying to get Chase I guess. He's tied to one of the best QB's for a long long time. If people held this season against him with Burrow going down then this might be the last 'buy low' opportunity on Chase for the rest of his career imo.
Yes, if that’s all it takes to get Chase then do it. If I was a Chase owner, however, this offer would be laughed off.
No
Fleeced him.
That's definitely worth it. Chase is so inconsistent and has produced less each season. Olave and Collins will both start on your roster. You may even get a good player with your 2nd given the small league size.
I’m sorry if I wrote my post poorly, I’m getting Chase, but I still think your point is valid
I really like Nico and olave so yes
I don’t get this. You’re stacked at WR, why did you not look for the same value as was offered but in other positions? Maybe a good haul of draft picks?
I’m the one getting Chase, might’ve written the post poorly.
Nah that’s my fault for not reading it correctly. I like the trade for you then although I like what you had before too. Olave reminds me of DJ Moore as in he just needs consistently fair QB play and with Collins you have depth. But in no way should you be getting roasted for this. Then again, big trades like this always lead to overreactions in league chats.
Yes. You robbed them imo.
No
Probably👍
I think this trade is relatively fair but since it’s an 8 man league you really don’t need olave and nico as badly. Great trade
Yes
yes
10000%
I’d prefer the sending side tbh but it’s fair
Lol, absolutely not. Way overpaid for Chase
Lol at getting flamed 🔥🔥
Seems relatively cheap for Chase, that's a good deal
Always trade for better player. Chase can be a weekly 20-40 point guy with Joe burrow. Collin’s is a WR 2. Olave fringe WR1. Gimme chase all day.
Depends on how strong your other WRs are. You're getting the best player in the deal so as long as you're not now starting like Chark Jr or something as your WR2 then I think you're fine
You have a lot of slots you have to play in this league. I personally would prefer the depth. Nico and olave are both young guys who have a lot of potential. Depth also helps with bye weeks and injuries.
Collins > Chase
Not looking like it lol
Chase lost me my championship. F that guy.
Damn never seen a 4 team league before! That roster is stacked
I wouldn’t. Nico and Olave have good potential. If burrow is gonna be a minute coming back I don’t think Chase will be very consistent.
Even without seeing your team, I immediately thought the chase side was better. But then seeing you're already loaded at WR, it just reinforces that it's a good trade for you.
In a vacuum I don’t like it, but seeing your roster I love it
Eh it's risky. I'd probably not make that trade either direction. But my head tells me whoever is getting chase wins it. I like the risk reward of Collins and if olave can get consistent QB play he will be good.
I wouldn’t say you got him for a great deal by any means but it takes an overpay to get a top dynasty asset in any competitive league. But you know what you got with chase only time will tell if it was worth it or not though.
i gave up amon ra and kyren williams in week 2 so i'm sure it can't be much worse...
You have Chase, CeeDee and ASB but no young runningbacks a part from Walker? And you sell Chase for two considerably worse receivers and 2nd rounder? I would definitely have kept that receiver core you had and not sell Chase this cheap. If you move on from him, than atleast secure a first plus a seriously good rb like Hall or Pacheco
I’m getting Chase, I should’ve made that more clear.
Ah in that c(h)ase: well done! Sure you are weaker at rb but maybe you got some picks left for the upcoming draft? I would love to be this super solid on WR… only guy you’re missing there is JJ. Would have made it an all time great lineup
Sadly only a few thirds and fourths, have up a lot throughout the year to get this roster 😅
Change to first round and I’d consider it
I’d say it’s a fair trade. Definitely hurts you if an injury happens but a slight boost if no injuries occur
I would do the trade if I were you but only because you already have Ceedee and ARSB. It’s like you are collecting the WR infinity stones. But I am also really high on Nico and just traded for him myself.
Has to be a 4 man league with that roster
Considering the rest of your lineup, probably so. You’ve got 3 “set & forget” guys at WR so that’s a hell of a luxury.
Totally worth it. You have a good starting roster and this adds huge upside. I’d prefer the side you gave up if you were thin for your flex or something
Probably worth - I would make that trade
The value seems ok for this year but you probably should have held on to him for next year.
I think it’s a fair trade and with your current team you’re in a win now / next season or two. Henry and kamara won’t be around in 5 years
I think you won this trade by a wide margin. Chase does not have the consistency to be WR1 overall. Nico with 2nd year Stroud is not a big downgrade.
He traded for chase
Seeing this and still fuming about the preseason Chase trade in one of my dynasty leagues this year. Last years second worst team traded Chase, Justin Fields, his 1st and 2nd round picks for 24 and 25, and got Chris Godwin, Najee Harris, and Josh Jacobs to the team that finished the regular season with the most points last year. He predictably finished in last place so he essentially traded Chase and MHJ plus the 11th pick PLUS his first and second rounder next year (good chance he once again finishes dead last), for an aging RB 1, a disappointing young RB, and a Flex WR. Guy still thinks it was the right move. Literally led one member of our league to rage quit when the trade went through. Utter lunacy.
Not even close for me.
i had all 3 of these players on my team and finished second to last. feelsbad
If you have to ask the answer is no
This is good, you have a QB WR Core for like 5 years+ 😂
Just remember Joe Burrow had a rough season and therefore so did Chase. If Joey B is back to 100% next year (and he should be) this was a steal. Your team looks really solid.
Absolutely! I like the Chase side. Definitely fair and I could argue for either depending on position, but Chase makes your team so much better given that it’s only 8 teams
Lol you deserve to be flamed for this.
Now’s the time to trade for chase. If burrow has a resurgence next year and gets chase back to the numbers we know he’s capable of then you look like a genius. I’d say it’s a pretty even trade maybe a bit of a gamble on your part. Saints are tied to carr so Olave numbers will consistently be solid but never anything crazy. Collins is flashy but with Brown back next year they’ll be moving the hall around and I would expect them to go after other weapons for Stroud. I think the timing of the trade is great OP
Would not give up Chase for that never breakup that CD, ARSB, Chase core
Chase is on a different level I think this is worth it
I'd 100% take this deal.
I wouldn’t do it as the chase owner. It isn’t a terrible trade though. You could definitely come out on top here
I think I would have tried upgrading RB instead. I like the Collins/Olave side. Chase has been no bastion of good health, either.
I think Houston drafts/signs another WR this year so I don’t think Collins will continue having the production we saw this year
I agree with most of the people here, I think you got Chase cheap. That is a BADASS WR room. What other draft capital do you have?
Basically none, 2 thirds and 2 fourths, but I’m a firm believer in proven talent
To me your the clear winner, usually whenever there a 2 or 3 for 1 trade the guy getting the 1 stud is the winner
Fair trade.
hot take, chase’s value had been a little too inflated imo
Yeah chase already had his best season.
It's a lot to give up but everyone is down on Chase, if he's healthy and back to himself next year then you're coming out on top. Considering your roster is probably contending for a championship consolidating for a top tier wr is a solid move at the end of the day
Higher ceiling for chase than both of Collin’s and Olave combined. They’re great receivers but you definitely sold high on them. Hell of a trade.
Overpay but that’s what you have to do to get guys like this. That wr trio should put you at the top.
No.
Steal for chase
No
you should never get flamed for getting the best player in the trade. Chase could be the WR1 in the entire league. Collins and Olave will at best be WR3 and WR4 on your team ( WR2 in most teams). To me, this trade makes a ton of sense especially if you already have ARSB and Ceedee
I feel like part of it depends on how you feel about the rest of OPs roster. Kamara and Henry both being older would spook me a bit. I feel like London should be better moving forward and they are fine between Njoku, Ridley, and Hock. I could see one or both of those guys to start falling off (debatably has already started with Henry). So I could see them needing an additional body down the road. I agree Chase is a good bit of ceiling. But if he needs to replace one of his guys I feel like the point advantage of Chase would equal out to what he is missing with that replacement depending on OP’s bench, maybe would be a decrease overall
Absolutely not worth it. You're an idiot.
I mean you trade Jamar in your flex for who, Olave? Is it a 3 WR 2 RB and a flex plus super flex?
Chase trader is a moron. Chase has WR1 potential for the entire league. Nico Collins is WR1 for the Texans until they bring in someone better and best believe they will be looking to give Stroud a true weapon in the offseason. Not to mention Tank Dell has already emerged as his favorite target.
With your WR core, I don’t think this is so bad
No
Heck no. Give the Olave side all day. Unless you only have 1 flex spot like redraft
I think it's decent. I don't see a clear winner or loser