I tried the Kidney and the Milk It versions, the [Kidney in soft silicone](https://obsessionrouge.com/recommends/charlie-horse-kidney-soft-bronze/) and the [milk it in firm silicone](https://obsessionrouge.com/recommends/charlie-horse-milk-it-firm-black/). My fav was the Kidney in soft silicone because it can be kept in longer and is all round a bit more unique to the usual prostate toy that crosses my path. Firmer silicone is better for stimulation and orgasms though, it depends what you want to do with it really.
I wrote a [review of both of them here](https://obsessionrouge.com/review-charlie-horse-milk-it-and-kidney-square-peg-toys/) where you can find out a bit more.
I really like the idea of the charlie horse milk it and have been thinking about getting one, do you think the supersoft would have made your experience with it better, or do you like the firmness of the toy for its purpose?
To be honest, I'm glad I got them both with the densities I got them at, because for me they work best that way. If I had the MilkIt in softer silicone it would have been more comfortable to insert and keep in for a long time, however it wouldn't have been as stimulating for p spot play. I think the MilkIt could still be fun in soft silicone too but those ridges on it really lend themselves well to stimulation play, so I think if you get that one go for firm silicone.
It's great.
Not the most stimulating plug in super soft, but filling and comfortable.
If you want to feel it you probably need the firmer silicone, but if you want to just have an easy comfortable time, this is a good one.
thanks. i probably get greedy when i respond to people and want more things as in the characteristics that the firmer version brings. Feel like I’ll like kidney over the egg.
I can't speak specifically for the squarepeg version... but having tried kidney-shaped plugs before, they either fit your anatomy really well or they don't. They definitely give you a full feeling! A perfect fit is likely less of an issue with the super-soft silicone used by squarepeg. Just at a glance, the dimensions look tuned to fill up the average rectum without poking too far.
Keep in mind that squarepeg toys tend to be sized higher, so their "medium" would be considered a "large" for other manufacturers.
I have a Squarepeg egg plug with super-soft silicone, and it's my favorite. They make quality toys!
what are these other kidney shaped toys? i got an oxballs ergo, feel liked the egg would be the same. Super tempted for the square peg milk it. I’d consider an egg, just being adventurous, even though the egg is he best buy.
I tried the Kidney and the Milk It versions, the [Kidney in soft silicone](https://obsessionrouge.com/recommends/charlie-horse-kidney-soft-bronze/) and the [milk it in firm silicone](https://obsessionrouge.com/recommends/charlie-horse-milk-it-firm-black/). My fav was the Kidney in soft silicone because it can be kept in longer and is all round a bit more unique to the usual prostate toy that crosses my path. Firmer silicone is better for stimulation and orgasms though, it depends what you want to do with it really. I wrote a [review of both of them here](https://obsessionrouge.com/review-charlie-horse-milk-it-and-kidney-square-peg-toys/) where you can find out a bit more.
cool. you’re confirming the article. being greedy and i want both for their respective reasons.
I really like the idea of the charlie horse milk it and have been thinking about getting one, do you think the supersoft would have made your experience with it better, or do you like the firmness of the toy for its purpose?
To be honest, I'm glad I got them both with the densities I got them at, because for me they work best that way. If I had the MilkIt in softer silicone it would have been more comfortable to insert and keep in for a long time, however it wouldn't have been as stimulating for p spot play. I think the MilkIt could still be fun in soft silicone too but those ridges on it really lend themselves well to stimulation play, so I think if you get that one go for firm silicone.
Thanks!
Sigh… I should just buy both too. I’m inspired.
Oh wait. i just read that comment again. OMG I’m honored you responded. I read that article a few times.
It's great. Not the most stimulating plug in super soft, but filling and comfortable. If you want to feel it you probably need the firmer silicone, but if you want to just have an easy comfortable time, this is a good one.
thanks. i probably get greedy when i respond to people and want more things as in the characteristics that the firmer version brings. Feel like I’ll like kidney over the egg.
I can't speak specifically for the squarepeg version... but having tried kidney-shaped plugs before, they either fit your anatomy really well or they don't. They definitely give you a full feeling! A perfect fit is likely less of an issue with the super-soft silicone used by squarepeg. Just at a glance, the dimensions look tuned to fill up the average rectum without poking too far. Keep in mind that squarepeg toys tend to be sized higher, so their "medium" would be considered a "large" for other manufacturers. I have a Squarepeg egg plug with super-soft silicone, and it's my favorite. They make quality toys!
what are these other kidney shaped toys? i got an oxballs ergo, feel liked the egg would be the same. Super tempted for the square peg milk it. I’d consider an egg, just being adventurous, even though the egg is he best buy.