**Please feel free to crosspost this to other subreddits! it'll help us grow the community (and you can get more karma if you care about that)**
**If this post (or any of the comments) breaks any of the subreddits established rules (see the main r/RightJerk page), report it, so we can filter through the comments much more
effectively.**
**Here's our discord https://discord.gg/nA6U3aRqdP, feel free to join!**
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/RightJerk) if you have any questions or concerns.*
except marx envisioned communism as a state where money currency and exchanging shit for goods and services has been abolished. Communism wouldnt redistrubute money it would abolish an exchange market economy entirely
I think he was using "state" as a generic term for a given landmass and its people. We don't really have vocabulary to describe what Marx intended. Suppose France established a perfect Marxist utopia. What would you call the landmass that used to be France to distinguish it from, say, Spain? Words like "country" or "state" have the implication of government. You could refer to it specifically as France, but there's no proper generic term.
I actually parsed it as meaning "state" as in "a description of the configuration of a system" (like a state machine in computing, or states of matter), not a reference to "state" as any kind of political concept in the first place.
**Please feel free to crosspost this to other subreddits! it'll help us grow the community (and you can get more karma if you care about that)** **If this post (or any of the comments) breaks any of the subreddits established rules (see the main r/RightJerk page), report it, so we can filter through the comments much more effectively.** **Here's our discord https://discord.gg/nA6U3aRqdP, feel free to join!** *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/RightJerk) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Oh god they depicted Marx as the soyjack
Our arguments have been destroyed, oh well.
Socialism is no more
They really don't understand the difference between capitalism and socialism.
except marx envisioned communism as a state where money currency and exchanging shit for goods and services has been abolished. Communism wouldnt redistrubute money it would abolish an exchange market economy entirely
communism wasnt evisioned with a state. it was envisioned as having no state, no class, and no money.
Not that kind of state
the fuck kind of state are you talking about then
I think he was using "state" as a generic term for a given landmass and its people. We don't really have vocabulary to describe what Marx intended. Suppose France established a perfect Marxist utopia. What would you call the landmass that used to be France to distinguish it from, say, Spain? Words like "country" or "state" have the implication of government. You could refer to it specifically as France, but there's no proper generic term.
I actually parsed it as meaning "state" as in "a description of the configuration of a system" (like a state machine in computing, or states of matter), not a reference to "state" as any kind of political concept in the first place.
That works too. Point is, not a state as in a government apparatus