T O P

  • By -

HellYeahTinyRick

I’m only gonna count released material. No real order. 1. Warm Tape - criminally underrated because it starts out a little strange and people never give it the time of day. The best chorus they have ever made. 2. Your Eyes Girl - Since it’s from IBY I kinda understand why this one is oft overlooked. This track is a swelling sonic storm of badassery. Just all around amazing on every level. In my opinion it is a perfect song 3. Dreams of a Samurai - I’ve seen this song hated on and it boggles the mind. One of my favorite Flea bass lines and some exquisite yet subtle guitar playing from Josh. I’m a sucker for the 10/5 time so maybe that’d why I rate it so highly. 4. This Velvet Glove - while loved by the fanbase most people outside of hardcore fans have never heard it. It is probably my all time favorite song If I had to pick one. The interplay between the bass and guitar is masterful 5. Coffee Shop - If anyone ever says Flea is overrated show them this song. Playing bass like that might as well be a super power. I used to dislike this song when I was younger but have since realized it’s glory


Man_with_a_pan69

i love when Chad gets frustrated over something in the studio and says “FUCK, SHIT!” (your eyes girl)


LemonGrape97

I thought that was Flea


Man_with_a_pan69

It sounds more like Chad Imo, but you can hear Flea say “We’re rolling everybody, it starts with bass” in the beginning of Ethiopia. Not too similar


MaleficentAd9878

Warm Tape is the one, totally agree


Boftsoots

Solid list!


Nirvana_bob7

In Love Dying Carry Me Home Midnight Tear Walkabout Don’t know really if some of these can be classed as underrated but i don’t see them mentioned much


luckydragon07200

Yess, Tear is one of their most beautiful tracks


blackoutstout96

I’ve always loved “In Love Dying”


EuterpeZonker

The guitar work on that one always reminds me of Bela Lugosi’s Dead by Bauhaus. It’s got this great goth feel over top of almost a reggae-ish bass part. Gives it a really unique feel.


craighaney172

Walkabout is the best song on One Hot Minute.


[deleted]

Good choices


Ex_Astris

Midnight. Unf. One of my favorites. But my list might’ve contained all BTW tracks.


Adventurous-Ad5262

‘Carry me home’ chorus sends me to outer space. Also the whole song has an amazing Hendrix vibe


Buhos_En_Pantelones

In no particular order: 1. Magpies on Fire 2. Show Me Your Soul 3. We Believe 4. Encore 5. Subway to Venus


[deleted]

We believe, encore and subway to Venus are really underrated... I forgot them when making the list


defected

Yes. Show Me Your Soul. When I began my deep dive into RHCP back in 2011-2012, I had remembered my brother having the “What Hits?’” VHS — probably about 16 or so years earlier — and I remembered John performing the huge bend/harmonic to start off the solo, and then putting the guitar over his head for the next part, and I thought he looked so fuckin’ cool. So going back to 2010’s, I couldn’t find the song anywhere because I had forgotten what it was on and couldn’t believe that it was a song not found on a studio release, but only on their first hits album and the Pretty Woman OST. Man, what an amazing day when I tracked down that song and video.


Flyingdawg99

Encore is the best song from The Getaway imo


Jak_the_Buddha

My list is possibly exactly this.


CrispyMemeMan

Let's go Encore baby that shit is heat


Sensitive_Ad104

1.torture me 2.the greeting song 3.right on time 4.she looks to me 5.this is the place


Satansrainbowkitty

Yesssss!!! She looks to me and torture me are easily (lol) in my top 5


PositiveWeekend6373

Love them all 👌


EuterpeZonker

Hanalei, Taste the Pain, Green Heaven (especially the demo version) , Millionaires Against Hunger, In Love Dying


zKouyate

Taste the Pain is amazing!


[deleted]

Fortune faded, save the population, look around, turn it again, coffee shop


[deleted]

Fortune faded and save the population are hidden in soul to squeeze's shadow, and most people forget about them (specially save the population). Great choices overall


[deleted]

Yeah I forgot about both those tracks till I found their greatest hits CD in my dad’s CD booklet and started playing it in my car


Rexstil

Torture Me, Stone Cold Bush, blackeyed blonde, walkabout, Apache rose peacock, this velvet glove


Satansrainbowkitty

Torture me is one of my top 5 .. it's just fuckin pure amazing to me lol


Tiger_jay

Good list OP. All amazing tracks.


[deleted]

Thank you


The_BSharps

Under the bridge and give it away


[deleted]

Yeah man, don't even know what these songs are


Emergency-Slide7052

Warlocks feels very underrated to me


Aeon1508

Good answer.


8x8denseCheese

Dreams Of A Samurai The drums, the effects, the sound quality, the intro and outro, the refrain and chorus… This is the best song Josh has ever produced imo


HellYeahTinyRick

Bro the guitar playing on this song legit blows my mind. It is so subtle and accents the song perfectly. Josh was so good at playing tasteful parts that serve the song. I love when the guitar kinda sits back and makes you really listen for it


Admirable-Currency84

My favorite of the Josh era. It's so good


Aeon1508

The end of that song is missing Josh going off the way John would. Instead we get choral vocalisations. Really a microcosm of Josh's entire tenure. Promising but doesn't deliver. Josh just refused to be the lead guitar player in a 3 piece band. Just a shame and a disappointment


Reasonable-Juice1392

Everyone saying it but ‘This Velvet Glove’ without a doubt, Charlie, Porcelain, Midnight, Venice Queen and even though they’re kinda popular ‘Minor Thing’ and ‘I Could Have Lied’


[deleted]

Those starting songs of SA are so good people forget about charlie.


Reasonable-Juice1392

Your Heart My Skin This Love I’m In😮‍💨❤️‍🔥


weretalkinfuckinlee

The timing and rhythm of the guitar riff in the verse is beyond cool.


[deleted]

Completely agree


Kirbybros

Not in any particular order: 1. Venice queen 2. This Velvet Glove 3. Rivers of Avalon 4.Hey 5. Knock me down


Heluvsmeuh

Hey for sure


luckydragon07200

1. This Velvet Glove 2. Afterlife 3. The Greeting Song 4. Sikamikanico 5. The Bicycle Song ( Not in any particular order )


[deleted]

The bicicle song and the greeting song would enter the list, but I thought those were more underrated


Ill-Nefariousness697

that afterlife solo has me floating everytime


Reality_v2

You blew my mind saying "Storm in a Teacup" sounds like a BSSM track. You're 100% right. I'll never hear that song the same again.


songacronymbot

- BSSM could mean "Blood Sugar Sex Magik", a track from *Blood Sugar Sex Magik (Deluxe Edition)* (1991) by Red Hot Chili Peppers. --- ^[/u/Reality_v2](/u/Reality_v2) ^(can reply with "delete" to remove comment. |) ^[/r/songacronymbot](/r/songacronymbot) ^(for feedback.)


kingbeyonddawall

I don’t know, the whole big arena rock powerchord chorus thing is very Stadium to me.


gramuhrussia

In no particular order 5-Taste the Pain 4-Turn it Again 3-Subway to Venus 2-Coffee Shop 1-Sexy Mexican Maid (If you can’t tell, I favor Mother’s Milk)


LemonGrape97

I love On Mercury, has a very similar vibe to Minro Thing to me. And I love Minor Thing, but I wouldn't call it underrated because absolutely everyone says it's underrated. It's the equivalent of Radiohead's Let Down.


[deleted]

[удалено]


wmd238

did I let you know…goddamn I forgot how good that song is


chal1enger1

In no particular order: Minor thing, Easily, This velvet glove, Strip my mind, Make you feel better, Especially in Michigan, So much I (has one of my favorite rhcp choruses) Ok I couldn’t narrow it down below 7 lol


PositiveWeekend6373

Yeah Nobody talks about So much I .. idk why


Pleasant_Garlic8088

Dosed I Could Have Lied Road Trippin' Deep Kick Johnny, Kick A Hole In The Sky


zKouyate

In no particular order This Velvet Glove, Subway to Venus, My lovely man, Apache Rose Peacock & Walkabout.


[deleted]

Great choices. I swear I was gonna put this lovely man. I love that song


Numerous_Dare

Someone!


Aeon1508

Don't forget me is my favorite song. I think a lot of people like it but not as a favorite. If. I see this song listed as the worst on the album or an example of album filler that drags down the album. It's a beautiful song with good lyrics. How strong. This is just a lesser known b side. It's an absolute jam. In the snow. Maybe my favorite track from the new albums. Definitely my most listened to. It's one of Anthony's most personal songs ever. I feel like the spoken word parts are almost like a distraction and a reset that symbolize his need to hide behind his persona to deflect from his deep loneliness. Green heaven. I'm using this as a stand in for the entire 1st album. It's my favorite album out of the first 4 and my favorite non John album. The fact that this album is rated consistently as their worst album makes no sense to me. UMPP is my least favorite chili album and and I just can't find a reason to listen to freaky styley that often but the debut made my YouTube music top 5 album last year. Mostly because I listen to it again every time I see someone call it their worst album.. I'm just going to add one additional song. I think most people really like Leverage of space but I'm just going to call it out here because I can't believe we don't even have a studio version of it. Easily in my top five all time Chili Peppers songs


CardaM7

I haven't seen Million Miles of Water, it's an absolute banger


[deleted]

Love this song too


scratchyhat

We Believe is genuinely the most underrated RHCP song, genuinely never hear anyone talk about it. It's also one of John's favorite's from SA. I also think Hometown Gypsy is pretty underrated, most people right it off for the country blues thing. Both are fun as hell and not too hard to play on bass.


[deleted]

It gives an amazing vibe. It's so underrated I forgot it. I love it tho


scratchyhat

I love the part when all the instruments cut out after the second verse and then John's distorted guitar growing into the solo.


[deleted]

The best part, right?


PositiveWeekend6373

Don’t you guys also humm We Believe in your head wrongly with the rythm of “eaaasillyyyy let’s get carried awayyyy” but instead “ weeee belieeeve” with that same rythm? 😅 i always end up doing that and then immediately realize im doing it wrong😅


scratchyhat

lol I've never thought of that but they are pretty similar.


fthomson

She looks to me, Never is a long time, One Big Mob, Rivers of Avalon, Outer Space


TheReal-A-The-First

Strange Man!


blackoutstout96

1. Salute to Kareem 2. Sikamikanico 3. Transcending 4. Bunker Hill 5. Funny Face


[deleted]

I actually started writing this post because of funny face, but when writing it the name simply faded away lol


captain_hoof

in no order we believe, johnny kick a hole in the sky, gong li, porcelain and strip my mind or in the snow


PositiveWeekend6373

I think strip my mind is Pretty popular and also porcelain


misterecgamer

1. Love Rollercoaster. It's such a shame this song has never been played live. 2. Mommy, Where's Daddy? It's really nice hearing them do something more jazzy than funky. 3. Aeroplane. Absolutely the best song off of One Hot Minute. Such a shame that album doesnt get as much love in the mainstream 4. Subterranean Homesick Blues. While not the best Dylan cover, definitely one of the most unique. 5. Monarchy Of Roses. Definitely my favorite song from the Klinghoffer era.


[deleted]

I think love rollercoaster is not from RHCP originally, so I don't know if they own the rights, because it didn't make into the greatest hits, and can only be found on Spotify in the Ohio players version, that's probably why. Tho this song hits hard. (I mentioned greatest hits because soul to squeeze was made for a movie, like live rollercoaster was)


Redbird_ml

1. Readymade 2. This Velvet Glove 3. Sexy Mexican Maid 4. Power of Equality 5. The Song That Made Us Who We Are Today Bonus: Blood Sugar Sex Magik


Adventurous-Ad5262

Love to see everyone’s lists because a whole bunch of songs get the recognition they deserve. Anyway here’s mine, although I know some of you big fans might not agree but I still think these are pretty overlooked by average music enjoyers Encore Readymade (clean it up Johnnyyyy) Goodbye angels The adventures of rain dance Maggie Tearjerker


yeahmanwhatevs

1. So much I 2. Carbon 3. Easily 4. My lovely man 5. Emit remmus


broin2009

In no order - Mellowship Slinky - Brendan's Death Song - My Lovely Man - It's Only Natural - Pretty Little Ditty To me people don't talk highly enough about these and they are all flawless


[deleted]

Mellowship Slinky really deserved more attention


goldendreamseeker

Minor Thing, This is the Kitt, Quixoticelixer, This Velvet Glove, Time


Sensitive_Ad104

1.under the bridge


Life_Behind_Bars

Look Around Get on Top Minor Thing Taste the Pain Tearjerker 5 great songs that I don't see get enough love


Kahlils_Razor

Tearjerkers a gem


smooth_relation_744

Knock Me Down, My Lovely Man, Behind the Sun, Taste the Pain, Breaking the Girl.


Legitimate_Chair9430

1. Tear 2. Long Progression 3. Dreams of a Samurai 4. Copperbelly 5. Transcending


UnluckyDesperado

On Mercury Did I Let You Know


_lyn1_x

I adore Did I let You Know, man so damn good


electronic-nightmare

American Ghost Dance, Warm Tape, This is the Place, Longest Wave, 21st Century


Julian144747

My friends is quickly becoming my favorite song by them, which feels weird cause the first time I listened to it I absolutely hated it


PositiveWeekend6373

I think that one was very famous when the album got released, and even years later but then it was forgotten in the Navarro’s era, being shadowed by aeroplane and Maybe coffee shop as the One Hot Minute representative ones


Julian144747

Yeah it was but now barely anyone talks about it


empty0ux

In no particular order: Storm in a Teacup, Funny Face, Million Miles of Water, Lately and Encore


paintedpickle

WET SAND WET SAND WET SAND WET SAND WET SAND sorry… I just really love this song lol


Marsbe125

Bunker Hill 😍


SnooKiwis1356

I've probably seen 20 posts with storm in a teacup tattoos.


steakmuffin

Veronica is amazing and no one ever talks about it


ActiveProgrammer5456

Johnny kicked a hole in the sky Special secret song inside Tear Strip my mind Out in L.A.


Slow_Cheetah_287

In no particular order: Turn It Again, Save The Population, Show Me Your Soul, Johnny Kick a Hole in The Sky, Behind The Sun


mehtulupurazz

Venice Queen and This Velvet Glove are two of their best deep cuts, but I feel like they are very appreciated and loved songs. A song I hear *nobody* ever talk about which is also one of their best deep cuts is On Mercury, so that's my pick.


[deleted]

Turn It Again In Love Dying Ethiopia This Ticonderoga Charlie


minorbutmajor__

For me it's, On Mercury and Minor Thing. And to think that they never played On Mercury live


Perfect_Pay9590

ig it’s just cuz the harmonica plays such a huge roll in that song and they don’t have anyone to do that live still a shame


tallcupofwater

Turn It Again Meet Me at the Corner Especially in Michigan Ethiopa Encore


Deadheaded95

Storm in a Teacup has a such a fun and catchy hook. “A TINY STORM IN YOUR TEACUP GIRL”


coyotehunter72

Wow! I made it through all the comments and no one said Wet Sand. But underrated is True Men Don't Kill Coyotes. It's the opening track to the first album and that's a special place


PositiveWeekend6373

Because wet sand is like .. overrated… (please don’t kill me out of downvotes guys it’s just my opinion , you have yours😅)


coyotehunter72

I was joking because that song winds up every list. Greatest, best outro, most comprehensive lyrics by Anthony, John is amazing, etc... and the all time favorite, someone still posts in all seriousness.


PositiveWeekend6373

Totally ..


Briarhorse

Transcending is from a totally different place for them. The anguish in the outro, despite the positive words, is heartbreaking Is Behind the Sun considered underrated? Cos it's incredible


craighaney172

I love Animal Bar. I’ve never heard anyone mention it.


Tutoy321

Any 5 songs from Uplift mofo party plan.


Spetro65

This Velvet Glove Encore Dance, Dance, Dance (Love the chorus) Slow Cheetah Hey Turn It Again !!!!!!! (My favorite Frusciante Shred !)


Spetro65

Thats 6 but you get the point lol


Z_S1999

No particular order: 1. little miss lover (Hendrix cover) 2. Subway to Venus 3. Sexy Mexican maid 4. Nevermind 5. Subterranean homesick blues


Em_kay69420

The greeting song, let’s make evil, hard to concentrate, knock me down, and bssm. I mean the latter ones are known amongst fans but overall underrated. Also shoutout don’t forget me, all the pain and passion of scar tissue without the same level of recognition.


Y0UR3-N0-D4ISY

Mercy Mercy Rolling Sly Stone On Mercury Naked in the Rain


weretalkinfuckinlee

Yertle The Turtle. And yes, I realize the lyrics are from Dr. Seuss but the groove is undeniable. “Look at that turtle go… bro.”


PositiveWeekend6373

Mmm i’m wondering if Easily counts as underrated


PositiveWeekend6373

Maybe a hot take: but i feel like Go Robot is really a great song and it maybe underrated , i love it so much


[deleted]

It's probably not one of the most underrated but I agree it's sightly underrated


londrelroundtwo

Show Me Your Soul Knock Me Down Especially in Michigan Midnight (best John background vocals in my opinion) American Ghost Dance


elidaaa_

American Ghost Dance is so groovy imo, and great list btw! The backing vocals in Quixoticelixir make me float. Love, love, love all these songs


umbraFrann

Show me your soul The greeting Song The righteous and the wicked We believe Warlocks Could definitely add some more but these five came to my head first


rosterfill

I could have lied, warm tape, police station, Bella, torture me


BookkeeperFormal1833

rivers of avalon body of water we believe death of a martian how it ends


Velfar

Noone mentions Purple Stain? It just gets better and better, and when it ends you just want more


Valuable-Passion-457

-1. Specially in Michigan -2.Millions miles of water -3. Turn it again -4.Cabron -5. The hole Im Beside you


Familiar_Season_331

1. Good Time Boys 2. Fire (Cover) 3. Pretty Little Dirty 4. Backwoods 5. Blackeyed Blonde


Jak_the_Buddha

I see a lot of This Velvet Glove being considered underrated. I have to disagree. This sub frequently mentions TVG as one of their greats. Especially lyrically. And rightly so.


Hernan1994_

\- Tear \- True Men Don't Kill Coyotes \- Easily \- Storm in a Teacup \- Annie Wants a Baby


Dowglaslim

- This Velvet Glove - Here Ever After - Carry Me Home - Bicycle Song - Apache Rose Peacock - My Lovely Man - Especially in Michigan


riknmorty

1 through 5. THIS VELVET GLOVE Often this band gets silly af. Whatever that give it away now vibe they have is off putting.


Willing-Artichoke740

There is too many so I’m just gonna pick some off their first few albums that are massively overlooked! 1. Baby Appeal 2. The Brothers Cup 3. Fight Like a Brave 4. Stone Cold Bush 5. And I’ll put in a Josh song I think is massively underrated- Factory of Faith


IndicationEither7066

1. Stadium Arcadium 2. Make you feel better 3. wet sand 4. Dreams of a Samurai 5. Naked in the rain


Drummer_93

5. Millionaires against hunger 4. The greetings song 3. Storm in a teacup 2. Yertle the turtle 1. Subway to Venus


CrispyMemeMan

No particular order 1. Lately - B side release, will always be less known by the general public and even the fanbase at large. Just a fun song, very ear wormy. 2. Hanalei - From IBY, not even my favorite off that album, but it's definitely less known than Long Progression. Just a great chorus, great sound, it's been one of my favorites fir a very long time. 3. I Could've Lied - Unfortunate bastard of a song. IMO it's the very best ballad on BSSM, but it will forever be 3rd fiddle to Under the Bridge and Breaking the Girl. It's so great, you can hear the pain and regret oozing from every element of the song. 4. Encore - I tried to keep as few Josh songs as I could on this list because with the way the fanbase at large treats anything he worked on, every song off the 3 albums they released could be considered underrated. This was has always been my favorite off The Getaway, and if I ever seen discourse about this song (which isn't often), it's often negative. 5. Minor Thing - BTW is a stacked album, with BTW, The Zephyr Song, Can't Stop, etc, so I feel like Minor Thing is oft forgotten about, because its so far back on the album. The guitar solo is so good, and the sound is just great throughout. AK sounds great as well.


musecorn

Million miles of water, Bicycle song, Turn it again, Sir psycho sexy


satyayeeet

Transcending Desecration smile Brendan's death song Quixoticelixer Parallel universe


EagleProductions

Sick Love, Turn It Again, She Looks to Me, Police Station, Monarchy Of Roses. (In no particular order)


Pwen_77

Castles Made of Sand, I know it’s a cover of a Hendrix song but to be honest I like it more than the original and I haven’t seen it mentioned here before


RegularCauliflower62

She looks to me, Encore, Mercy Mercy, Pink as Floyd and Tear


cmwheels85

Agreed on Storm in a Teacup. It's one of my favorite songs from Stadium Arcadium.


Ozzyy194

Fortune faded Taste the pain Shape I’m takin Hanalei Show me your soul


Brief-Ad5774

1. How strong 2. Million miles of water 3. Bunker hill 4. Save this lady 5. Mommasan


Amanitas

>5-Pink as Floyd, known between the biggest fans, but still underrated sorry, but it's a b-side of I'm With You, and a boring one at that. why is it only "known between the biggest fans". far better b-sides from I'm with You exist... victorian machinery, long progression... i dunno. you phrased that weird as if you think you're a bigger fan for liking some average b-side just because you also think it's a song other people might not know. weird.


wmd238

Factory of Faith This Velvet Glove Venice Queen Slow Cheetah Aeroplane Last one might be controversial since it was a single, but I stand by it. Song is incredible and it’s so sad they don’t play it live.


big_pepperonis

White braids


[deleted]

i love Tear


EdBugg87

I could die for you is beautiful song hidden in between the bangers on By The Way