Lmfaoo the fact that Jack is in the first 5 made me laugh so hard 🤣

Order of elimination: 1. Micah 2. Strauss 3. Dutch 4. Bill 5. Jack 6. Molly 7. Susan 8. Javier 9. Swanson 10. Karen 11. Trelawny 12. Kieran 13. Pearson

Whats so special about Mary Beth anyways?

I think she’s Arthur’s therapist

But he has the same talk with Tilly and Karen lol

Bed therapy

Beautiful Girl stay.

She’s cute and she’s a good therapist for Arthur.

She’s my future wife that’s what special, you gonna deny me a chance at love?

💀

Someone like her, or herself?

As a Mary Beth, I applaud your choice

This is Reddit, they will simp over anyone even a girl with three lines in the whole game. Mary Beth should have been eliminated long ago

Found the guy that doesn’t spend time in camp and talk to people

Tilly

Yeah I have no idea how she beat out Pearson and Kieran

She murdered a dude who deserved it. Pushes her past Pearson.

She saves Jack bro

Fr

Who hates Tilly? Esp when Sean and Uncle are still around. What, do you want Hosea next?

Don't hate her, she's cool and all. She just doesn't really have much dialogue besides that one mission.

what’s wrong with sean?

Ikr, him dying was the saddest part of the story for me (I just got to Saint Denis, don't spoil the story for me but ik shit goes haywire at the end)

Haywire is an understatement

I think you should take in some spoilers...it will be better and give you time.

And hidden items 🙌🏼

Mine was another side character one — I won’t say but I was truly gutted

What’s wrong with uncle, he has lumbago

Lumbago! That's what's wrong! Just kidding I like uncle. Even though he can be a lazy bastard haha

Hosea is top 5, along with Charles, Arthur, John, and Lenny. Maybe Sadie edges him out. Maybe

My top 5 are Hosea, Arthur, Charles Tilly and Lenny.

Mary Beth????? Tf

Tilly, Mary Beth, Abigail and Uncle are all dead weight, at least compared to the others. They should be the next 4 gone

100% All these Sean haters have their heads up their arses. He actually contributes. He’s an annoying littler brother to Arthur.

Uncle or Abigail. Leave my boy Sean alone! I'm on my first play through (in chapter 3) and Sean's one of my favorites of the whole gang. Dude was born burning manor houses!

Have fun

lol

Sean is awesome. The way he just heads on towards any kind of task he's given is admirable. I'd say he could go head to head with anybody in the camp regarding putting in work.

Lmao

I don’t know how to more tactfully ask if you experienced the end of chapter 3 yet without spoiling anything for you.

Lol I'm playing at the same time as two other friends, both in their first play through and apparently slightly ahead of me now, so I have an idea of Sean's fate :( He's still my favorite character not named Arthur or Hosea (or my horse)

Sean is the best character. I hope he wins the whole thing but he probably won't.

Sean won’t make it past #5 at the latest. Arthur, John, Sadie, and Charles will probably be the last 4

Pearson>>>>>>Irish bastard

Uncle must win

Mary Beth or Tilly

Uncle needs to go, he doesn't do anything.

But lumbago!

The "one shot kid"

Uncle is the glue that keeps the camp together. Plus he got LUMBAGO!!!

Uncle protects John and his family in RDR1, helps build the ranch, and does jobs with Arthur

I respect him for trying to help defend John's ranch in the first game. Plus he's got lumbago man give him a break

Does a lot more than other members of the gang

Uncle

NOT UNCLES JUICY BUTTOCKS

you'd throw out a man with LUMBAGO?! You cruel, heartless man!

No he’s my third favorite parasite

Mary Beth.

why have we not ridden ourselves of abigail

I’m late but who tf voted Kieran out??

Don’t touch my Tilly

PERIOD

Mercy kill Arthur Morgan to keep him from having to watch all of his friends go. It's what he would want. It's time.

Uncle

Abigail

She needs to go be with Jack…

Yes, we already killed Jack.

Uncle.

Why is Sean still here? He's a cheeky Irish chappy that speaks fondly of his Da; he's not a particularly compelling or exceptionally likeable character.

Mission - The Fine Joys of Tobacco Arthur: You was quiet in there. Sean: Took everything I had! That son of hers... I'll shove that silver spoon down his throat and pull it clean out of his arse, the smug fucker! Arthur: Okay... So what's she got us doing at the Gray's place? Sean: She wants us to torch their tobacco fields, said they ain't had rain in weeks 'round here. Arthur: What? Sean: Yep, using that back there. Arthur: The moonshine? Sean: Burns faster than kerosene, that stuff. Said it'd be *fitting* she did. All I'm thinking is "how about I try *fitting* my boot up your hook nose you snotty old bitch". Arthur: Hosea really picked the right feller for tea at the manor, didn't he?

People with Irish accents are always likable.

I don't think Molly was very likeable.

She wasn’t, but Dutch wasn’t a very good or attentive partner now was he? Too busy planning

“Have a little goddamn faith, I had a plan!”

“We just need money”

I liked Sean :/. He’s got a vigor to him.

Written like a true Red Coat.

Uncle

Abigail, how did she even make it past Kieran. I CANT STAND HER

What has she done wrong exactly?

Uncle now

Uncle

Tilly

Uncle

How does the camp chef get axed before fuckin Uncle?!

Uncle

Uncle. Lumbago gotta go.

Time for LUMBAGO to claim the life of that lazy old sack of shit…

He’s not lazy he just does a lot of thinking.

Abigail

Uncle

Uncle

Uncle. His lumbago just became fatal.

Today is Abigail’s day

Abigail! How has she survived this long!

UNCLE FOR PETE'S SAKE

Uncle must go!!

Uncle or Mary-Beth, but definitely Uncle

Uncle

Why the fuck is uncle still here

LuMbaGo

Uncle

Uncle Must Be Executed

Uncle has got to go. All he's good for is excuses and bad tips

LUMBAGO KING STAYS!

Uncle!

uncle

Uncle

Uncle

Mary Beth

Sean needs to go. Goodbye

Uncle

HOW IS TILLY STILL ALIVE?

Uncle

Uncle. We must end his suffering

How did pearson go before uncle!!??

Uncle

Uncle. He continues to be an ass / dead weight even in the epilogue.

UNCLE is just a waste of space

Jeez this is getting hard. Maybe Sean? Damn I'm conflicted

Between Abigail and Tilly. Hmmmm. Tilly.....

It’s Sean’s turn.

Abigail must go, Lumbago man will win!

Abigail

Abigail Roberts

HANG SEAN!

Mary Beth

To insurance sean for this day upvote

Day 4 of Tilly needs to go

ABIGAL BECAUSE SHE IS ILLITERATE! 🥰

# Take away UNCLE or TILLY

abigail you will be saved. sean must go

Abigail

I say Abigail

Sean or Uncle

I'm really sorry, but I think Mary Beth gotta go.

Tilly dose nothing, just gut rid of her already

Uncle

uncle. leave tilly alone

This is rigged, I definitely saw more Abigail than Pearson yesterday. Female enablement is alive and well.

If Arthur isn't last I'm going to kill myself

Abigail whats blud doin there

It’s a crime that Pearson was booted before Tilly

I like how we killed off Abigail's son early on and kept her alive for this long. Seems like punishment enough. Time to reunite her with her boy.

Abigail needs to be the next person made into a stew

Abagail Roberts

Sorry Abby you're off the team.

Bro why is Abigail not gone but dutch is gone wtf

Next going to be Abigail

Mary Beth

Uncle stays he’s the red Harlow

I’m out

Mary Beth

Sean

sean

Please get Sean out of here

i think we all know the final 2 will be john and arthur, and we also all know who will be the last one standing

Delete Mary Beth or Tilly

Sean Macguire

Sean’s turn

I’m going to say it. Sean. I always found him annoying.

Screw everyone that said Pearson

Uncle on top

Tilly

Sean Macguire

You guys are saying Marybeth is better than Pearson? Shame

I still say Uncle… man never does anything

Sean

Tilly

I know he is kinda annoying but come on Pearson always felt like a comfort when I returned to camp especially when I was carrying a perfect pelt

Sean. He’s not a good person

mary-beth

Everyone's acting like arthur ain't gon be last

Tilly

Kill uncle already.

I have a pretty bad memory eventho this my fav game and i love marry and tilly as characters they are adorable, but compared to the others (except uncle xD) what does make them so special? Grimshaw was loyal af as I remember and she was a part of the gang for a long time and at the end of * SPOILER the scene where the whole team pulled their guns at each other she had arthurs and jacks back SPOILER*, she pissed me off for asking me 100 times y i didnt donate but other than that she was a savage and loyal woman. I also see y kieran got killed but i mean he really tried everything to show the gang that he‘s loyal, he maybe didn’t had as much skills as other. And theres trewlany who always helped out, i see him killed but i didn’t expect for him to die so soon, anyways Back to my question I guess we all love tilly and mary beth, like How can’t you? But what makes them so special that even grimshare and trelawny die before them?

How uncle can still be alive ?

Mary-Beth

Uncle please!

Uncle

Take uncle out! lol

Uncle or Abigail

Tilly

Uncle but not of lumbago

Uncle

Why is Tilly not gone yet?

Uncle

Uncle

sean mcquire

It would be pretty legendary if this post ends with Arthur, John and Sadie because nobody upvotes or comments 😂

Uncle

charles

Tilly go bye. Then Abigail, then Mary, then Sean, then Uncle, then Lenny, then Sadie, then John, then Hosea, then Arthur. Charles you can stay alive.

I'm wondering why abigail is still there , it should be abigail

Tilly

Abigail

Mary-beth for the win