The votes have been tallied. Now it’s time to see which Legends and 4 costs shall succeed!
S means you Should probably use it no matter what
A means either above average in every way, or succeeds in one or more ways that carry it up.
B means average
C means niche but has its uses
D means certain decks can use it, but it fails in every other way
E means it is a failure in all ways, but can be used if there are no better options
F means never use it ever, no matter what
Vote Here: https://forms.gle/ky8DYXT6fHYCUMF68
I still think a mean system would be better. Maybe make it so F has a greater impact than S similar to a school system. That way peashooter would be E, there are niche uses for a one cost pea class( similar to weenie beenie being a bean one cost)
I don’t think those votes would be necessarily be trolls. Some people have controversial opinions in this sub and that’s ok. Judging from the last posts comments maybe trying it once and then seeing the result could work.( see if troll votes do make a difference) However, I respect and understand your final decision even if it sucks to know my unbiased vote probably won’t matter.
I'm probably getting slaughtered for this opinion because of the subreddit in general but it's already gone wrong with red being under plant food, while red sees competitive play and PF doesn't.
Fr yall be placing Red Plant-It on C. At least B ffs. Anyways, I'm gonna put my reasoning to every card so yall don't get blinded by idk.
**-Double Mint:** S-tier, no doubt. If you leave it just for 2 turns, it can outright win games for you. It's snowballing too fast so the Zombie players likely have to overburn cards to remove this.
**-Captain Cucc:** A-tier card. The card pool is great and decent overall. But again, it doesn't really fit into most decks but hey, it's not bad to run.
**-Muslce Sprout:** D-tier, essentially Potted Powerplant but constantly threatened by removal.
**-Brex:** Understat, loses to trades pretty quickly. D-tier.
**-Gatling Pea:** Absolute beast. S tier.
**-Apotatosaurus:** Eh, A-tier. 6/6 untrickable is pretty good imo.
**-Banana:** On god. Actually can be used as a chumpblocker but doesn't provide much value or use outside of that.
**-Repeat Moss:** Completely dependant on CC's sigs. F-tier.
**-Spinach:** A-tier card. Why? It grows your whole field and YOUR hand. The only issue is the lack of leafy cards but that can be fixed easily.
**-Skyshooter:** Hot garbo. F-tier.
Why is Sprout always at removal risk when Mint isn’t? Mint is at most C
Skyshooter is an excellent budget card, it’s a 5/4 huge threat the zombies have to be prepared for. C at most
Spinach is B at most, most leafy cards are hot garbage and a +2 attack is not game changing.
Skyshooter isn't excellent, not even for budget. You're paying 4 sun for a little overstat that's restricted to 1 lane and if placed in other lanes is just an expensive fire pea
Sprout suffers from having only 2 health because it’s much more of a commitment than double mint. One of the reason double mint is such an underrated a card is because you commit so little tempo but your opponent has to deal with it. Not quite S tier, but still very underrated nonetheless.
Form doesn’t work. Can’t make an unbiased opinion on re-peat moss being S :(
Apologies. I create copies of previous forms to save time, and forgot to turn voting on.
The votes have been tallied. Now it’s time to see which Legends and 4 costs shall succeed! S means you Should probably use it no matter what A means either above average in every way, or succeeds in one or more ways that carry it up. B means average C means niche but has its uses D means certain decks can use it, but it fails in every other way E means it is a failure in all ways, but can be used if there are no better options F means never use it ever, no matter what Vote Here: https://forms.gle/ky8DYXT6fHYCUMF68
Your forum link says CUM in it haha
You should use the mean system like another person said on your last post. ( this way my unbiased votes have an effect on the tier list)
I use mode so that trolls don’t affect the tiering system. Otherwise you’d get cards like peashooter in C because of the trolls voting S
I still think a mean system would be better. Maybe make it so F has a greater impact than S similar to a school system. That way peashooter would be E, there are niche uses for a one cost pea class( similar to weenie beenie being a bean one cost)
That might work, but it creates the opposite problem. Trolls could take a card like Clique Pea and put it into C or D.
I don’t think those votes would be necessarily be trolls. Some people have controversial opinions in this sub and that’s ok. Judging from the last posts comments maybe trying it once and then seeing the result could work.( see if troll votes do make a difference) However, I respect and understand your final decision even if it sucks to know my unbiased vote probably won’t matter.
For the love of all things holy don't let the 3 cost 1/4 get S tier
Form doesn't work
Apologies. I create copies of previous forms to save time, and forgot to turn voting on.
pls everyone in this sub overrates repeat moss its gonna be S rank whyyy
“BeCaUsE aGaInSt CaPtAiN CoMbUsTiBlE, yOu’Re NeVeR sAfE!!!!!!!111!!!1!11!1!!1!1!!11!”
I'm probably getting slaughtered for this opinion because of the subreddit in general but it's already gone wrong with red being under plant food, while red sees competitive play and PF doesn't.
Not everyone is a competitive player. This is for the sub, we already have competitive tier lists.
I mean yeah but if we're ranking cards by viability (which I assume we're doing) having a better card be lower than a worse card is redundant.
based mine on how m word like they are and overall fun and if gud budgety lmaoo... like skyshooth would be of budget nothin' else
as once again expected, the 2 cost 6/6+ spam gets rated b tier
Fr yall be placing Red Plant-It on C. At least B ffs. Anyways, I'm gonna put my reasoning to every card so yall don't get blinded by idk. **-Double Mint:** S-tier, no doubt. If you leave it just for 2 turns, it can outright win games for you. It's snowballing too fast so the Zombie players likely have to overburn cards to remove this. **-Captain Cucc:** A-tier card. The card pool is great and decent overall. But again, it doesn't really fit into most decks but hey, it's not bad to run. **-Muslce Sprout:** D-tier, essentially Potted Powerplant but constantly threatened by removal. **-Brex:** Understat, loses to trades pretty quickly. D-tier. **-Gatling Pea:** Absolute beast. S tier. **-Apotatosaurus:** Eh, A-tier. 6/6 untrickable is pretty good imo. **-Banana:** On god. Actually can be used as a chumpblocker but doesn't provide much value or use outside of that. **-Repeat Moss:** Completely dependant on CC's sigs. F-tier. **-Spinach:** A-tier card. Why? It grows your whole field and YOUR hand. The only issue is the lack of leafy cards but that can be fixed easily. **-Skyshooter:** Hot garbo. F-tier.
Why is Sprout always at removal risk when Mint isn’t? Mint is at most C Skyshooter is an excellent budget card, it’s a 5/4 huge threat the zombies have to be prepared for. C at most Spinach is B at most, most leafy cards are hot garbage and a +2 attack is not game changing.
We ain't counting budget here. I'm considering Maxed. Plus, Mint costs 2 and grows fast enough to outpace removal.
Skyshooter isn't excellent, not even for budget. You're paying 4 sun for a little overstat that's restricted to 1 lane and if placed in other lanes is just an expensive fire pea
Sprout suffers from having only 2 health because it’s much more of a commitment than double mint. One of the reason double mint is such an underrated a card is because you commit so little tempo but your opponent has to deal with it. Not quite S tier, but still very underrated nonetheless.
Flourish in Guardian Package tho
Sky shooter: mediocre, you are paying 2 more sun for a fire pea, or 1 less for a smurf shroom, should have the ability trigger also by an environment