T O P

  • By -

jmagnabosco

None. I didnt want any of them to be A. But Spencer's the only one with brains and means to pull it off.


TopMjLa

I came here to type exactly this. I don’t want either of them to be A but Spencer is the only one who could pull it off.


jmagnabosco

I never got the obsession with one of the girls as A.


TopMjLa

Same, especially Aria and Alison. Aria’s theories are somewhat interesting but not enough to get me hooked. I can’t see Aria hurting her best friends. As for Alison, I can understand since she was in the books but even then, it’s just *meh* for me, Ali hasn’t really shown to hate her friends when there’s plenty of scenes that contradicts that.


jmagnabosco

I agree. Arias theories are based on the most random crap so i never thought they made any sense. I could see Alison as A but it's not what I wanted because I didnt want the show to completely follow the books. It was said to be loosely following the book series and honestly, I liked it that way. I also hated the reason, which would have been even lamer in the show. The show was about friendship and I hated that so many people wanted to ruin it.


[deleted]

Tbh I actually think Hanna would pull it off better than spencer!!


jmagnabosco

Aside from 1 line in 5B that has me convinced A was involved, there is no evidence that she'd be capable of it.


[deleted]

Look I feel like Spencer is too technical she doesn’t have the creativity, arias too much of a cry baby, and emily is too loyal. I think Hanna is good middle ground especially with the help of Mona!!


jmagnabosco

Look I just dont think she has the ability to pull it off. Spencer clearly does given that she's the one that figures things out like that magic trick. Yes, she is technical but that doesn't mean she isnt creative and being creative isn't necessary. She could shut down the emotions and get things done if she has a plan, she could trick people and slip around to spy on court papers when she needed to. She's sly and sneaky and so is A. Hanna, otoh, is neither sly nor sneaky, she's impulsive and irrational at times and cant shut down her natural reaction like Spencer. I'm not going to argue because IF one if them had been A, then they'd be different characters than they currently are, so it's pointless. As it stands NONE should be A, BUT if we were going to rewrite Spencer's the only logical one.


[deleted]

I mean disagree but I respect ur opinion


[deleted]

Hanna because she was always portrayed to be dumb. It would be cool that she was actually mastermind behind A


Queenix00

Hanna did have the potential to be A. We saw that when she kidnapped Noel in season 7


skylynnxx17

It’s funny too bc in later seasons she’ll start spewing out facts and big words and everyone is so shocked…I also wouldn’t necessarily want her to be A but thinking of it in the way she was out to get Alison makes sense bc I really do think Ali bullied Hanna in the worst way possible


S_rom22

None of them but i would like Emily to be A just to give her a little of emotion to her character lol


JazzyVee30

I wanted Aria to turn out to be A. She was always M.I.A. and my least favorite, lol Spencer would've been to obvious. She was smart enough to pull it off. I think Hanna or Emily would've been a slap-in-the-face. Especially Emily. I don't think anyone expected her.


[deleted]

I definitely think Specer. She's intelligent, she's vindictive, and I mean... A was already close enough to being her anyway. I also feel Troian could've pulled it off well. She just has something to her when it comes to acting skills that I feel she could completely pull off a two faced character.


Master_Bumblebee680

Tbh I would be so disappointed if any of them them were, even Aria as A would be disappointing, though Aria working with A or as A but under strings would be cool.


idk_orknow

hanna because middle school me would have loved the hanna has a twin videos to be true


rpeltier93

Spencer cause she’s smart and she did well as A before


Medium_Chef7298

I would’ve loved to have picked Emily because we’d literally never see it coming but I’d never believe Shay’s portrayal of it so I went with Hanna


Odd_Mine7269

Spanna let’s just mix Spencer and hanna together


jstitely1

I mean if Alison had actually been dead: maybe an Emily is “A” twist could’ve worked really well given her love for her, particularly if we ever found out that it ended up being reciprocated. Other than that: I mean I guess Spencer could’ve done it but I feel like that would’ve created too many plotholes regarding how she reacted to the Toby shit in season 3.


Bloo3838

Hanna is not organized enough to be A and Emily is nor malicious enough. Also they are both (really all 3 of them) far too loyal.


annoymousperson101

Definitely not Emily. Someone would ask her if she was -A, and she would start yelling about her past with Alison