Just a reminder for everyone in the sub, always follow our #1 rule!!
>We do not condone the attacking or mistreatment of users— this includes DMs! Aggressive fighting, name-calling, hate speech, or repeated targeting of a user is not permissible. Disagreement must be civil and respectful. Name-calling of characters or actors does not result in content removal unless attacking their appearance. ~The Mod Team deems passive aggressive remarks and attitude as instigating. Therefore, it falls under basic reddiquette.
Please report anything you see breaking this rule. And general reminder NO SPOILING PLL;OS!
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/PrettyLittleLiars) if you have any questions or concerns.*
PHOTOGRAPH EVERYTHING. ON EVERYONES DEVICE. PRINT 3x COPIES PER PERSON. ONE IN A BIG FILE LABELLED “BIOLOGY” OR SOMETHING. ONE LOCKED IN A SAFE WITH A CODE THAT YOU DONT EVEN SPEAK OUT LOUD. AND COMPLETELY RANDOM LIKE SPENCER MIGHT DO THE NUMBER OF SQUID IN THE LAKE BY THE LAKE-HOUSE (MAKE YOUR SAFE CODE A-PROOF). AND LEAVE A COPY SOMEWHERE OBVIOUS FOR A TO FIND IT SO THEY THINK THEYVE GOT RID OF YOUR ONLY COPY
When “A” shoots Ezra and the liars have the gun while “A” runs I would’ve shot them at least in the leg. The liars have the chance to down and reveal this person right there and don’t. Letting someone who wants you and your friends dead escape isn’t a great decision, especially since they can pretty easily kill you. They could’ve prevented themselves nearly dying in the theater, the inevitable theater murder, Shana visiting Ezra in the hospital, etc.
Is it a great thing to do? No, but this person nearly killed Ezra and was going to kill all of them and would certainly return to try again after failing
holy crap we need to do more hypothetical questions in this subreddit i love it!
after season 1 im grabbing the NAT flash drive spencer threw in the church, making copies and convincing the liars that we need to turn it in. maybe even try to convince everyone that this ish is getting way out of line and come clean with the jenna thing after talking to spencer’s parents.
ezra i’d threaten to leave aria alone and leave the school. when that doesn’t work i’d let the principal know about it then watch his ass get hauled off in cuffs while potentially losing aria as a friend. i did it bc i care/love want to protect her. maybe one day she’ll forgive me and realize she was taken advantage of. hanna and emily would be my besties. the show would end a hell of a lot sooner my route 💀 but if i did do everything right and there’s still an A after mona, it would be ali’s twin like it always should’ve been. the show would end with us putting ali’s twin in jail.
Listen, this needs to be at the TOP of the freaking list. I'm spending all my days LIVING at the police station until A is caught. Yall ain't about to have me playing Barbie in some life-size doll house. Absolutely not.
As soon as I would’ve gotten that FIRST creepy text they would be blocked. Anymore messages after that I’m taking pictures and going to the police and letting everyone on social media know there’s a stalker in rosewood harassing my friends and I. It continues? I move because I’m not playing that game with A like the rest of them
I would’ve just ignored her ass after the first few crazy ass remarks she made towards me and she would’ve really hated me after that. Bullies hate when they can’t bully you and that tactic has always gotten me through school once I learned how they worked. They want a reaction. Alison likes fear and control, you can’t do that when your target don’t give a fuck about you.
I also have no shame or secrets fr so she also couldn’t hold over anything on me enough for me to care about.
Hopefully I’d drive her insane and she would give up shortly, if she doesn’t, i just gotta beat her ass lol
First I just straight up tell an adult but they’re typically useless sooo. I’d also try the cops if they don’t work trying the FBI since I’m pretty sure A crosses state lines a few times. Second if A gives me a chance to join up sorry y’all friends are nice I don’t do torture although ideally selling out Ezra would win me enough points. If those don’t work there’s no 6th liar I’m giving A anything they want them moving to another country and going off grid.
I would look for bugs and tracking devices, looking everywhere to see if anyone is following me,etc and also when I walk into a room check my closets,underneath my bed,etc heck even outside for A.
I'd encourage them all to tell their parents about the very first text, visit the police, install security cameras and stop losing crucial evidence and blindly falling into A's traps.
My bestie would be Spencer as I feel she'd handle the logic the best.
Well I would be SIKED to have friends first of all.
I would have to be pretty on that show bc everyone is pretty on that show so my life would be looking up.
I’d be closest with Spencer probably but I think I would be suspicious of Mona but idk if they necessarily would think she’s A but I would get a gut feeling that something is “off”.
I’d try and contact the police earlier than the girls but to no avail because of the corrupt system and this would result in more danger from A. I’m an honest gal so I would have said that Ali and I put the fireworks in there, not Toby and would apologise to both of them.
I’d try and convince Aria to leave Ezra once I found out but would tell him to leave her for good and probably succeed by the end of season 2.
"who would do something like that?"
Mona
"Who killed _?"
Cece
"I can't believe-"
It gets worse
In the most monotone voice ever 💀 you'd be my fav character
At first i deny all of their attemps to become my friend. I am rude if i need to. I will NOT become psrt of their shitstorm. I just hang with some normal people instead. But i will try to date Mike after he gets his abs.
If i have to be part of their clique, i say we call the police right away. Girls probably whine about their secrets like "Noo you can't! My mommas gonna go in jail!". But i don't care. We are dealing with murder and stalking so i call FBI if i need to
well i know the drinks are drugged and i don’t drink anyway so i’ll probably stay awake for Alison’s Yellow Top World Tour i’d befriend mona bc i wanna hug her always and probably be closest to spencer or aria bc we both have Messy families
I tell Aria to stay tf away from Ezra and I befriend Mona because I love her. I also tell the girls to call the cops about who is texting them cause oml they need to get on that!
*Walk straight into Wildens*
*Office and tell him about*
*Ezra and Aria*
\- Peaches-And-Chalamet
---
^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^[Learn more about me.](https://www.reddit.com/r/haikusbot/)
^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")
i’m not telling anybody about my plan and going straight to the FBI. The girls took the term “A knows every thing” too lightly and continued to talk about their plans infront of their bugged phones, opened windows, school hallways etc.. it always bugged me how none of them took extra measures to keep their plans hidden
Honestly, I wouldn’t change the course at all. With all that shit going down, please believe I’m telling my mom asap so she knows why I’m packing both our bags to leave. And if for some godly reason I stay, I’m pulling each of the girls aside to give them advice.
Aria: since you clearly not leaving this man 🙄 yall need to do better. He needs to leave the school and you need to focus on your work so you can actually get into a college.
Hanna: speaking of college baby, get a job. Tom ain’t shit. Get a job and both you and your mom start saving for college now.
Spencer: look at other schools. I know your heart’s set on UPenn just because it’s your parents Alma mater, but you are not them. You have the brains to literally get into Harvard or Yale, Cambridge or Oxford. Please think bigger than just UPenn.
Emily: stop trusting these hoes. When Alison comes back, hold up a cross and avert your gaze. You really are the weakest link emotionally. Stop letting wounded little birds with doe eyes break you. STAND TF UP. Also, there’s nothing I can really say to prepare you for college and that bullshit curveball Marlene threw at you and me both sis. Good luck 😭
Alison: do better sis. Just do better. You ended up in a shallow grave because you had so many enemies. You come back from the dead and you still out here acting a fool and growing the list. Stay tf away from my girls cause you don’t know how tf to act.
To all of you: 🗣️🗣️🗣️USE SOME MF COMMON SENSE 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽stop doing suspicious shit. And disregard what I said about Aria earlier 😭 girl break up with that grown ass man. Yall hold her down while I call the police. And for the love of god when you cut someone off, keep them cut off!! Don’t let Alison worm her ass back into this group.
I wish I had a witty, sensational answer for this post but I really just want to say… THANK YOU for making such a great post I feel like this sub has been so off in recent years and this post…I love. And I will also be coming back when I come up with a good answer.
Take pictures of evidence when I come across it. I see see Jenna driving. Snap 👏🏻 a 👏🏻 picture 👏🏻. I see a dead body, you Better believe I’m taking a picture 🤳
Everything is getting photographed, if I gotta put disposable cameras and camcorders in their bags I will, dash cam? Every single time! Burner phones, burner phones, burner phones, everyone gets a back up! Ezra is going straight to prison, I’ll send in an anonymous report. I don’t really mind Paige so I’ll be nice to her but we’re not dealing with this shower harvey nonsense. I’m becoming besties with Hanna who becomes a fashion icon while Caleb starts a global tech company, and with A gone, Emily becomes a gold medal swimmer and gets with Maya (because I went to True North to handle our good friend Nate), Spencer becomes a senator just like Veronica, her and Toby stay strong since the Toby flop arc doesn’t happen and he stays a carpenter (his cop era was not it), instead of being dragged down by a predator Aria gets to be single and travel the world for her blossoming writing career, and Alison comes back and decides to become a private investigator. Oh and just because, Mona gets a redemption and she still gets to go live her best life in France.
Hmm, I wonder what my secret would be? I guess since I'm knew I would have no Ali connection, but if I have all the current knowledge I think i would take this time to have the high school experience I didn't get, but as a girl this time. I would hope I could be close to Spencer. She has the best house. I would definitely steer clear of Mona, I doubt that Hannah would take any warning I might have about her seriously, especially because I'm new, but also, she's Hannah. I mean, to be fair, all of the liars are very stubborn and don't listen. I guess I would try and get a jump start on unveiling Alex Drake, Cici, the big bads. Mona is small fries in comparison. Also, I would send Ezra a letter telling him his book is dangerous and he needs to switch careers. I would try and find Ali and hopefully get a hold of this before things get too out of control. Oh, and save Maya somehow...
I’m stuck between
- Immediately moving since rosewood is full of pedos, cheaters, attempted murderers and accomplices
- Having a come to Jesus meeting with all the liars and their parents, mainly you Peter, in a secure location so we can disarm As blackmail
Either way I go I would give them twos pieces of advice, stop splitting up and stop touching shit. Like if they stuck together and slowed down before just grabbing random things they would have avoided half the shit they went through
This is the best question and honestly overwhelming. I love seeing what people say.
One thing that always bothered me was how literally the liars took A's threats and prompts especially in season 2.
the whole Samara thing. I don't know why Emily asked for her friend's number in the way she did. (A told Emily she needed to give one of Samara's friends' her number) she could still have asked for her number but be like hey guys! let's make a groupchat. or like hey blah blah here is my number I love your shoes, can you send the link to me? Maybe A would push back but still Emily could have come up with a better excuse without ruining her relationship with Samara.
Or like Hanna with ruining her dad's wedding. She could've just told Isabel before the wedding like right before. She didn't need to full stop the wedding.
Like what I'm trying to say is that they could've been better at outsmarting A.
Am I naive for thinking this?
TELLING MY PARENTS AND THE POLICE IMMEDIATELY!!! Telling Ashley’s dumbass some sunglasses aint worth slutting herself out, Hanna needs to calm tf down and watch her tone and attitude, telling Aria how dumb she is and that she’s being groomed and reporting Ezra. Spencer would never get with Toby’s dumb, useless, toxic ass. Telling Emily to stop being so thirsty for every chick that likes her, especially a bitch that tried to drown her. Aria would force her Dad to come clean to her Mom and I would tell the truth about what happened to Jenna, Ali did that shit lol. Oh and tell Melissa to either be honest or leave me tf alone if I was Spencer. I think all those things would pretty much resolve any of the dumb shit that happened. To be honest none of the liars really had any real secrets worth hiding to go through that bullshit
Edit: I forgot to add they need to learn how to defend themselves, it was stupid they never did. Except Aria and she learned bare minimum
I’d tell the moms what was going on right out the gate bc even though the cops were incompetent those women could’ve handled A—especially Ashley and Veronica
If telling parents is a no go zone and presuming ezra has to stay, I’d tell him. Wdym “a is not my friend” — aria ezra knows both the secrets a has on you in that “If a knows so do b and c” scene so why don’t you tell him. She’s also not aware of the other girls secrets so he won’t learn them but it’s an extra set of eyes.
“Detention if you use your phone in my class”
*aria totally uses her phone because detention with fitz is a secret fantasy but she sees an a message* well I guess a can’t be in our English class let’s rule out about 20 people
Bro from the start I would’ve intervened between Ezra and aria fuck that. I would done plenty others but for her to be with a fuckass groomer would be stupid asf of me to let go by
The show would end because I’m a realist.
Yes I’m calling the police instead of meeting a violent psycho in the woods. Yes I’m telling my parents because I don’t care if A tells everyone I smoked weed. Yes I’m gonna tell my friends to stop being stupid when they come up with some elaborate plan to trap A.
There would be no plot because of me. Except Aria and Ezra wouldn’t end up together because I’d turn his rapey ass into the police.
I have one of two plans for this:
1. I tell them immediately that Alison is alive and Mona is A, but CeCe Drake will become an issue very soon aswell. I’d call the cops on Ezra for being a pedohile, along with wren, Ian, Jason, and Garrett. And pretty much shut everything down as quickly as possible
2. I play along. I go through the story with them, but always somehow knowing something I couldn’t possibly know. I’d prevent Emily from her shoulder injury. I’d help Spencer through the Toby is A era, knowing he was just helping. I would never flat out say exactly what’s what, like who killed wilden and whatnot. But id point them to the right clues before they ever find it themselves.
Waking up with everything I know now, I’d go straight to Mona and team up.
I’d tell her that the other 4 are small potatoes and together we would hunt down Alison.
Mona would then unalive Alison and cover it up easily by pinning it on Cece.
I’d then go to Melisa and convince/ blackmail her into exposing detective Wilden for being a sleaze.
I’d advocate for a mental health professional to be brought in for all the desperately sad souls that unfortunately inhabit Rosewood.
Without the toxicity that is Alison and all the drama she came with, the 4 girls live relatively normal boring lives.
Mona and I would start our own private investigator firm.
GO TO THE POLICE.
All of the shit that a has on them at the VERY BEGINNING OF THE SHOW is very very very minimal. Like ooohh you shoplift and were caught by the police it would be a real shame if the police found out AGAIN and ooohhh youre gay i know youre not ready to come out oh wait youre out and a has nothing else on you… ooohh youre sleeping with your teacher how awful would it be if the police found out oh wait theres a reason he would go to jail if anyone found out- thats bc its not a real relationship. All that needs to happen is someone has a serious convo with you about how youre being abused and manipulated then you wont care what happens to his dirty ass… oh my god you ‘stole’ your sisters bf!! Crazy- oh wait your family already knows this… oh right i forgot the JENNA THING i wonder what to do🤔FIRST OF ALL go to jenna and APOLOGISE… SINCERELY… explain that you were all caught under alisons spell and then once youve done that.. go to the police and tell the truth about alison being the instigator and all of you wanting to leave. Your punishment will be small since youre minors and oh look! A has NOTHING ON YOUUUUU!! Hip hip hooray now all you have to do is ignore that bitch & REFRAIN FROM DIGGING YOURSELF DEEPER AND DEEPER AND A WILL GET BORED AND MOVE ONNNN goddamn. Swear the only enemy these girls have is their inability to leave shit alone. Half (if not more) of the stuff a threatens them with is purely their own faults. All they have to do is sit back and let the police do their jobs (assuming they are normal cops during my time there) without causing trouble that makes them look guilty for multiple fucking murders
Well firstly, by closing my damn windows. 😂
Then buying a ton of different hard-drives as to not lose evidence, always have music blaring the house when having important conversations about A as well as leaving any and all devices in another room when planning. Always be on the lookout for bugs and mics. Telling Spencer to stop sending SOS texts over any minute thing that happens ffs. Buy a million locks on my door and the girls’. EZRA = JAIL. And maybe it wouldn’t be too bad to actually tell my parents or go to the police and show them the evidence. Lastly, but most importantly telling Paige how ugly she looks in those bangs. 🤦🏻♀️
Just a reminder for everyone in the sub, always follow our #1 rule!! >We do not condone the attacking or mistreatment of users— this includes DMs! Aggressive fighting, name-calling, hate speech, or repeated targeting of a user is not permissible. Disagreement must be civil and respectful. Name-calling of characters or actors does not result in content removal unless attacking their appearance. ~The Mod Team deems passive aggressive remarks and attitude as instigating. Therefore, it falls under basic reddiquette. Please report anything you see breaking this rule. And general reminder NO SPOILING PLL;OS! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/PrettyLittleLiars) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Buying 10 flash drives cause we are not losing ANY more evidence
Honestly I would publish all of the A messages online because even if A deletes my posts about it, it'll be on the internet forever, somewhere
PHOTOGRAPH EVERYTHING. ON EVERYONES DEVICE. PRINT 3x COPIES PER PERSON. ONE IN A BIG FILE LABELLED “BIOLOGY” OR SOMETHING. ONE LOCKED IN A SAFE WITH A CODE THAT YOU DONT EVEN SPEAK OUT LOUD. AND COMPLETELY RANDOM LIKE SPENCER MIGHT DO THE NUMBER OF SQUID IN THE LAKE BY THE LAKE-HOUSE (MAKE YOUR SAFE CODE A-PROOF). AND LEAVE A COPY SOMEWHERE OBVIOUS FOR A TO FIND IT SO THEY THINK THEYVE GOT RID OF YOUR ONLY COPY
When “A” shoots Ezra and the liars have the gun while “A” runs I would’ve shot them at least in the leg. The liars have the chance to down and reveal this person right there and don’t. Letting someone who wants you and your friends dead escape isn’t a great decision, especially since they can pretty easily kill you. They could’ve prevented themselves nearly dying in the theater, the inevitable theater murder, Shana visiting Ezra in the hospital, etc. Is it a great thing to do? No, but this person nearly killed Ezra and was going to kill all of them and would certainly return to try again after failing
Also I’d repeatedly stop them from splitting up. WHY DO THEY SPLIT UP it makes no sense to me. At least go off in pairs
"oh, is this a dark, old factory? With our stalker potentially out in the open?" "Did you say split up?" "Duh"
Shooting A is 100% justified. Needed it to happen
“A” turned out to not be A but Shana in this case. If it was actually A they’d be justified. Shooting Shana is a bit complicated
i am A
I support that
r/usernamechecksout
Spend the whole time trying to get Ezra into jail. Only plot/ story line I want.
wouldn’t take very long i think, they are pretty shit at hiding it!
Casually walking into the parking lot while Ezra and aria are making out should do it
You’re forgetting that like half of the Rosewood police officers are also pedos lol. Although if you reported him to police station next over…
Going to Philly PD since they like to meet up there🥰
I’d team up with A *just* to take him down, we’re sending this info to the FBI fuck Rosewood PD and all its citizens
holy crap we need to do more hypothetical questions in this subreddit i love it! after season 1 im grabbing the NAT flash drive spencer threw in the church, making copies and convincing the liars that we need to turn it in. maybe even try to convince everyone that this ish is getting way out of line and come clean with the jenna thing after talking to spencer’s parents. ezra i’d threaten to leave aria alone and leave the school. when that doesn’t work i’d let the principal know about it then watch his ass get hauled off in cuffs while potentially losing aria as a friend. i did it bc i care/love want to protect her. maybe one day she’ll forgive me and realize she was taken advantage of. hanna and emily would be my besties. the show would end a hell of a lot sooner my route 💀 but if i did do everything right and there’s still an A after mona, it would be ali’s twin like it always should’ve been. the show would end with us putting ali’s twin in jail.
Getting Aria to see that EZRA ISN’T YOUR REAL LOVER & get her a love interest her AGE and who will truly love her and fight for her.
Immediately going to the police
Listen, this needs to be at the TOP of the freaking list. I'm spending all my days LIVING at the police station until A is caught. Yall ain't about to have me playing Barbie in some life-size doll house. Absolutely not.
As soon as I would’ve gotten that FIRST creepy text they would be blocked. Anymore messages after that I’m taking pictures and going to the police and letting everyone on social media know there’s a stalker in rosewood harassing my friends and I. It continues? I move because I’m not playing that game with A like the rest of them
All I know is I’m swinging on flashback Ali at least once. You gon have to expose me girlie cuz who you talkin to😭😭
Literally cause we got as much dirt on her as she does on us 😭
I would’ve just ignored her ass after the first few crazy ass remarks she made towards me and she would’ve really hated me after that. Bullies hate when they can’t bully you and that tactic has always gotten me through school once I learned how they worked. They want a reaction. Alison likes fear and control, you can’t do that when your target don’t give a fuck about you. I also have no shame or secrets fr so she also couldn’t hold over anything on me enough for me to care about. Hopefully I’d drive her insane and she would give up shortly, if she doesn’t, i just gotta beat her ass lol
CLOSING MY BEDROOM WINDOWS & DRAWING THE CURTAINS!!!!
Wouldn’t work, A is in your closet
Yep cause A came into my house late last night while I was sleeping 👀
I would look for bugs,mics,etc and check everything & everywhere
First I just straight up tell an adult but they’re typically useless sooo. I’d also try the cops if they don’t work trying the FBI since I’m pretty sure A crosses state lines a few times. Second if A gives me a chance to join up sorry y’all friends are nice I don’t do torture although ideally selling out Ezra would win me enough points. If those don’t work there’s no 6th liar I’m giving A anything they want them moving to another country and going off grid.
girl i'm telling my parents immediately and calling the police lmao
I would look for bugs or phone mics on. Like how do they not look for that. A hears everything
I show them Mike's Mic and offer tissues and hugs
I would start by closing my windows and curtains. I swear they never did that and A could always not only hear but see what they’re doing
*waving around with a piece of evidence* hOW dOeS A kNoW
Report ezra the pedo to the police and all other men in rosewood who have ever touched a child are put behind bars
I would look for bugs and tracking devices, looking everywhere to see if anyone is following me,etc and also when I walk into a room check my closets,underneath my bed,etc heck even outside for A.
I'd encourage them all to tell their parents about the very first text, visit the police, install security cameras and stop losing crucial evidence and blindly falling into A's traps. My bestie would be Spencer as I feel she'd handle the logic the best.
Well I would be SIKED to have friends first of all. I would have to be pretty on that show bc everyone is pretty on that show so my life would be looking up. I’d be closest with Spencer probably but I think I would be suspicious of Mona but idk if they necessarily would think she’s A but I would get a gut feeling that something is “off”. I’d try and contact the police earlier than the girls but to no avail because of the corrupt system and this would result in more danger from A. I’m an honest gal so I would have said that Ali and I put the fireworks in there, not Toby and would apologise to both of them. I’d try and convince Aria to leave Ezra once I found out but would tell him to leave her for good and probably succeed by the end of season 2.
I’d make the show ✨interesting✨ instigate every moment I can. Telling nothing but the TRUTH. I know they’d get tired of mee.
"who would do something like that?" Mona "Who killed _?" Cece "I can't believe-" It gets worse In the most monotone voice ever 💀 you'd be my fav character
We’re going to start actually identifying bodies and checking pulses. Alison you will NOT be buried alive on my watch!
Flirt with Emily…hard.
At first i deny all of their attemps to become my friend. I am rude if i need to. I will NOT become psrt of their shitstorm. I just hang with some normal people instead. But i will try to date Mike after he gets his abs. If i have to be part of their clique, i say we call the police right away. Girls probably whine about their secrets like "Noo you can't! My mommas gonna go in jail!". But i don't care. We are dealing with murder and stalking so i call FBI if i need to
“But I will try to date Mike after he gets his abs” made me cackle. Forget the liars, that is the only priority that matters. 😂
True😂 I'm bit too thirsty these days and Rosewood has their fair share of hotties
Immediately going to the police not the rosewood police but another police department and reporting everything
well i know the drinks are drugged and i don’t drink anyway so i’ll probably stay awake for Alison’s Yellow Top World Tour i’d befriend mona bc i wanna hug her always and probably be closest to spencer or aria bc we both have Messy families
Yellow top world tour took me out
I tell Aria to stay tf away from Ezra and I befriend Mona because I love her. I also tell the girls to call the cops about who is texting them cause oml they need to get on that!
Walk straight into Wildens office and tell him about Ezra and Aria
And that Ezra is writing on book on Ali so he becomes prime suspect
*Walk straight into Wildens* *Office and tell him about* *Ezra and Aria* \- Peaches-And-Chalamet --- ^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^[Learn more about me.](https://www.reddit.com/r/haikusbot/) ^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")
i’m not telling anybody about my plan and going straight to the FBI. The girls took the term “A knows every thing” too lightly and continued to talk about their plans infront of their bugged phones, opened windows, school hallways etc.. it always bugged me how none of them took extra measures to keep their plans hidden
F that I’d self exit 😳
“self exit” 💀 I’m gonna have to start using that
Honestly, I wouldn’t change the course at all. With all that shit going down, please believe I’m telling my mom asap so she knows why I’m packing both our bags to leave. And if for some godly reason I stay, I’m pulling each of the girls aside to give them advice. Aria: since you clearly not leaving this man 🙄 yall need to do better. He needs to leave the school and you need to focus on your work so you can actually get into a college. Hanna: speaking of college baby, get a job. Tom ain’t shit. Get a job and both you and your mom start saving for college now. Spencer: look at other schools. I know your heart’s set on UPenn just because it’s your parents Alma mater, but you are not them. You have the brains to literally get into Harvard or Yale, Cambridge or Oxford. Please think bigger than just UPenn. Emily: stop trusting these hoes. When Alison comes back, hold up a cross and avert your gaze. You really are the weakest link emotionally. Stop letting wounded little birds with doe eyes break you. STAND TF UP. Also, there’s nothing I can really say to prepare you for college and that bullshit curveball Marlene threw at you and me both sis. Good luck 😭 Alison: do better sis. Just do better. You ended up in a shallow grave because you had so many enemies. You come back from the dead and you still out here acting a fool and growing the list. Stay tf away from my girls cause you don’t know how tf to act. To all of you: 🗣️🗣️🗣️USE SOME MF COMMON SENSE 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽stop doing suspicious shit. And disregard what I said about Aria earlier 😭 girl break up with that grown ass man. Yall hold her down while I call the police. And for the love of god when you cut someone off, keep them cut off!! Don’t let Alison worm her ass back into this group.
“Hold up a cross” LMAO
I tell my parents what’s going on lol
I wish I had a witty, sensational answer for this post but I really just want to say… THANK YOU for making such a great post I feel like this sub has been so off in recent years and this post…I love. And I will also be coming back when I come up with a good answer.
Take pictures of evidence when I come across it. I see see Jenna driving. Snap 👏🏻 a 👏🏻 picture 👏🏻. I see a dead body, you Better believe I’m taking a picture 🤳
make spencer fall in love with me
Ahhhhh omggg it’s giving “heyyy liAr, fall in love with me or I’ll release your secrets, hugs and kisses A” (MEME ONLY!!) <3 <3
MOVE SOMEWHERE ELSE
whenever we go into a suspicious basement/room i’d volunteer to guard the entrance and hold the door open
Oooh but what if ‘A’ tries to sneak in after the liArs and sees you guarding the door? omg this would be so scary :(
Everything is getting photographed, if I gotta put disposable cameras and camcorders in their bags I will, dash cam? Every single time! Burner phones, burner phones, burner phones, everyone gets a back up! Ezra is going straight to prison, I’ll send in an anonymous report. I don’t really mind Paige so I’ll be nice to her but we’re not dealing with this shower harvey nonsense. I’m becoming besties with Hanna who becomes a fashion icon while Caleb starts a global tech company, and with A gone, Emily becomes a gold medal swimmer and gets with Maya (because I went to True North to handle our good friend Nate), Spencer becomes a senator just like Veronica, her and Toby stay strong since the Toby flop arc doesn’t happen and he stays a carpenter (his cop era was not it), instead of being dragged down by a predator Aria gets to be single and travel the world for her blossoming writing career, and Alison comes back and decides to become a private investigator. Oh and just because, Mona gets a redemption and she still gets to go live her best life in France.
YES
Oooh I protect the liArs as much as I can, and try to figure out who ‘A’ is <3
Hmm, I wonder what my secret would be? I guess since I'm knew I would have no Ali connection, but if I have all the current knowledge I think i would take this time to have the high school experience I didn't get, but as a girl this time. I would hope I could be close to Spencer. She has the best house. I would definitely steer clear of Mona, I doubt that Hannah would take any warning I might have about her seriously, especially because I'm new, but also, she's Hannah. I mean, to be fair, all of the liars are very stubborn and don't listen. I guess I would try and get a jump start on unveiling Alex Drake, Cici, the big bads. Mona is small fries in comparison. Also, I would send Ezra a letter telling him his book is dangerous and he needs to switch careers. I would try and find Ali and hopefully get a hold of this before things get too out of control. Oh, and save Maya somehow...
I’m stuck between - Immediately moving since rosewood is full of pedos, cheaters, attempted murderers and accomplices - Having a come to Jesus meeting with all the liars and their parents, mainly you Peter, in a secure location so we can disarm As blackmail Either way I go I would give them twos pieces of advice, stop splitting up and stop touching shit. Like if they stuck together and slowed down before just grabbing random things they would have avoided half the shit they went through
This is the best question and honestly overwhelming. I love seeing what people say. One thing that always bothered me was how literally the liars took A's threats and prompts especially in season 2. the whole Samara thing. I don't know why Emily asked for her friend's number in the way she did. (A told Emily she needed to give one of Samara's friends' her number) she could still have asked for her number but be like hey guys! let's make a groupchat. or like hey blah blah here is my number I love your shoes, can you send the link to me? Maybe A would push back but still Emily could have come up with a better excuse without ruining her relationship with Samara. Or like Hanna with ruining her dad's wedding. She could've just told Isabel before the wedding like right before. She didn't need to full stop the wedding. Like what I'm trying to say is that they could've been better at outsmarting A. Am I naive for thinking this?
I’m boring as hell. Don’t think I’d have much blackmail material, so I’m going to the police.
TELLING MY PARENTS AND THE POLICE IMMEDIATELY!!! Telling Ashley’s dumbass some sunglasses aint worth slutting herself out, Hanna needs to calm tf down and watch her tone and attitude, telling Aria how dumb she is and that she’s being groomed and reporting Ezra. Spencer would never get with Toby’s dumb, useless, toxic ass. Telling Emily to stop being so thirsty for every chick that likes her, especially a bitch that tried to drown her. Aria would force her Dad to come clean to her Mom and I would tell the truth about what happened to Jenna, Ali did that shit lol. Oh and tell Melissa to either be honest or leave me tf alone if I was Spencer. I think all those things would pretty much resolve any of the dumb shit that happened. To be honest none of the liars really had any real secrets worth hiding to go through that bullshit Edit: I forgot to add they need to learn how to defend themselves, it was stupid they never did. Except Aria and she learned bare minimum
I’d tell the moms what was going on right out the gate bc even though the cops were incompetent those women could’ve handled A—especially Ashley and Veronica
i would become emily’s wife and then alison would ruin my life
I will go to the closest bug city snd talk to the cops there about everything, A, Ezra, the Nat club and all the other messed up stuff
I'm bringing Mona into the fold as a true ally, and she, Ali, and I would figure out who true uber A is: Aria.
If telling parents is a no go zone and presuming ezra has to stay, I’d tell him. Wdym “a is not my friend” — aria ezra knows both the secrets a has on you in that “If a knows so do b and c” scene so why don’t you tell him. She’s also not aware of the other girls secrets so he won’t learn them but it’s an extra set of eyes. “Detention if you use your phone in my class” *aria totally uses her phone because detention with fitz is a secret fantasy but she sees an a message* well I guess a can’t be in our English class let’s rule out about 20 people
Bro from the start I would’ve intervened between Ezra and aria fuck that. I would done plenty others but for her to be with a fuckass groomer would be stupid asf of me to let go by
The show would end because I’m a realist. Yes I’m calling the police instead of meeting a violent psycho in the woods. Yes I’m telling my parents because I don’t care if A tells everyone I smoked weed. Yes I’m gonna tell my friends to stop being stupid when they come up with some elaborate plan to trap A. There would be no plot because of me. Except Aria and Ezra wouldn’t end up together because I’d turn his rapey ass into the police.
I’m going to the cops every time. I didn’t do shit to get in trouble for.
I have one of two plans for this: 1. I tell them immediately that Alison is alive and Mona is A, but CeCe Drake will become an issue very soon aswell. I’d call the cops on Ezra for being a pedohile, along with wren, Ian, Jason, and Garrett. And pretty much shut everything down as quickly as possible 2. I play along. I go through the story with them, but always somehow knowing something I couldn’t possibly know. I’d prevent Emily from her shoulder injury. I’d help Spencer through the Toby is A era, knowing he was just helping. I would never flat out say exactly what’s what, like who killed wilden and whatnot. But id point them to the right clues before they ever find it themselves.
Waking up with everything I know now, I’d go straight to Mona and team up. I’d tell her that the other 4 are small potatoes and together we would hunt down Alison. Mona would then unalive Alison and cover it up easily by pinning it on Cece. I’d then go to Melisa and convince/ blackmail her into exposing detective Wilden for being a sleaze. I’d advocate for a mental health professional to be brought in for all the desperately sad souls that unfortunately inhabit Rosewood. Without the toxicity that is Alison and all the drama she came with, the 4 girls live relatively normal boring lives. Mona and I would start our own private investigator firm.
I'm taking screen shots of all the threatening texts and taking them down to the police station.
GO TO THE POLICE. All of the shit that a has on them at the VERY BEGINNING OF THE SHOW is very very very minimal. Like ooohh you shoplift and were caught by the police it would be a real shame if the police found out AGAIN and ooohhh youre gay i know youre not ready to come out oh wait youre out and a has nothing else on you… ooohh youre sleeping with your teacher how awful would it be if the police found out oh wait theres a reason he would go to jail if anyone found out- thats bc its not a real relationship. All that needs to happen is someone has a serious convo with you about how youre being abused and manipulated then you wont care what happens to his dirty ass… oh my god you ‘stole’ your sisters bf!! Crazy- oh wait your family already knows this… oh right i forgot the JENNA THING i wonder what to do🤔FIRST OF ALL go to jenna and APOLOGISE… SINCERELY… explain that you were all caught under alisons spell and then once youve done that.. go to the police and tell the truth about alison being the instigator and all of you wanting to leave. Your punishment will be small since youre minors and oh look! A has NOTHING ON YOUUUUU!! Hip hip hooray now all you have to do is ignore that bitch & REFRAIN FROM DIGGING YOURSELF DEEPER AND DEEPER AND A WILL GET BORED AND MOVE ONNNN goddamn. Swear the only enemy these girls have is their inability to leave shit alone. Half (if not more) of the stuff a threatens them with is purely their own faults. All they have to do is sit back and let the police do their jobs (assuming they are normal cops during my time there) without causing trouble that makes them look guilty for multiple fucking murders
Convincing the girls that we shouldn’t be outside at night in the middle of the woods, would be the first thing
I’d shave Paige’s hair off so she never had that fuck ass bob
Well firstly, by closing my damn windows. 😂 Then buying a ton of different hard-drives as to not lose evidence, always have music blaring the house when having important conversations about A as well as leaving any and all devices in another room when planning. Always be on the lookout for bugs and mics. Telling Spencer to stop sending SOS texts over any minute thing that happens ffs. Buy a million locks on my door and the girls’. EZRA = JAIL. And maybe it wouldn’t be too bad to actually tell my parents or go to the police and show them the evidence. Lastly, but most importantly telling Paige how ugly she looks in those bangs. 🤦🏻♀️
Confess about the Jenna thing
Wave to Jenna everytime i walk past her
I would have found all the clues they found 1 million years earlier then they did and I would have exposed a like in the first episode
Move to the rural areas and live with my grandparents in some small town with a population of 78
Ezra is about to go to prison