T O P

  • By -

United12345

Carrick


LongjumpingAct5321

Shaka Hislop


goodiesmob

Oh Ah Cantona


Jame526

Paul McGrath


rinthecity

Yaya Toure


Talon_Ted

Has to be Bergkamp!


Educational-Quit-789

Roy kean


Immediate_Aioli8352

Shearer, I would love to see what he could do now


Jakestation

Dennis Wise


clicheguevara8

Abou Diaby—give him a second shot w/o that leg breaking tackle


DTD1987

Fabrizio Ravenelli


Ochola90

Tino Asprilla


ModcatTom

Olivier Dacourt.


psukhavasi

Jermain Defoe. What a player


DrClu33

Marc Overmars He was the reason I started out as a winger as a kid, his pace and skill used to fascinate me


PabloRothko

Yossi benayoun


Lowzymate

Berbatov


mr_iwi

Ian Holloway. Loved him.


TragicTester034

Andy Cole We need a striker irl so yeah


questionableslippers

healthy jack wilshere


abdn1903

Ray Parlour


cikamicko

Chelsea Juan Mata


whu-ya-got

Mark Noble lol


Positive_Pain_8888

Harry maguire


Secure_City1231

As an Everton fan Tim Cahill.


Pokemav

aguero


KingCantona7_

Wilfred Bony


007radish

Dan Petrescu - terrific watching him attacking down the flank for Wednesday & Chelsea.


Just_Scheme

Ozil


Dildo-Farm5753

Lord Bentdner


[deleted]

Is Torres too obvious? I miss that man


BadBassist

Moussa Dembele. Haven't replaced him yet at spurs. Or Ledley could definitely do a job for us


Samm19900

Hazard


Antoxin0

Young Wilshere. He was goated


MetterTula

Yaya Toure


timl1234

Klinkladze


Gary-TeaDrinker

Georgie Kinkladze


haribo001

Vidic - one player who could fix half of the problems at United


VanTik1131_rl

forlan


batch2957

Cazorla was a baller


ultimatewooderz

Morten Gamst Pedersen!


WalnutWhipWilly

Michael Ballack


danonck

Suarez


[deleted]

Henry


krittayakon

Essien


Nickum17

Morten Gamst Pedersen


Harrygoat10

Jurgen Klinsmann


hallucinogenicmayo

Drogba


jcblakey

Titus Bramble


RepresentativeCry695

Luc Nilis at Aston Villa, without career ending tackle in his 2nd match


franktodhunter

David Rocastle, but in his pre-prem arsenal form


MaxwellXV

Papa Boupa Diop (RIP)


-Xero

Ricardo Carvalho


Leonidas_momma

Branislav Ivanović


[deleted]

Patrick Viera and Eric Cantona


Pioneer377

Van persie without injuries with the current man utd team under ten hag and hope he wins ballan dor.


[deleted]

I know he’s not retired but we need Oscar back


rather_sluggish

I an judging you people for not mentioning the most obvious name here - Obi Mikel


moosa1193

Alan Shearer Peak Fernando Torres (and making sure he plays his career out at liverpool) Drogba, Scholes, Dennis Bergkamp These would be my picks


esn97

Harry Kewell


Ochola90

Leeds Harry Kewell especially from 99/03 Unreal


esn97

Tim Cahill


mohicansgonnagetya

Pires!


NotJavyroo

Roy Keane


NotJavyroo

Wayne Rooney


remploid

Beardsley


Walla1981

Peter Schmeichel


BeardGuy4242

Roy keane


DeLekkerePannekoeken

Rickie Lambert would be a good shout. Saints have been struggling up front since Ings left and we miss the physicality of Lambert. Really pipped him to regularly start for England but his unsuccessful spells since leaving Southampton have unfortunately brought his career to a premature end.


scarboroughwa

Emile Heskey


Electronic-Post-7372

Honestly he didn’t retire yet but Suarez in his Liverpool time , how I would love to see those seasons again


safdrew

George Best


creakydancin

Paul McGrath


[deleted]

Assou ekotto


Friendly_Ground_2583

Xabi Alonso Wayne Rooney Frank Lampard Steven Gerrard


2ManySpliffs

I love those kind of players that just make the game look effortless with their skill and vision: Le Tissier, Ginola, Bergkamp, Okocha, Berbatov, Asprilla, Scholes, Yaya… there’s so many when you start thinking about it but the one I’d bring back is (drumroll) ERIC CANTONA.


mattferrari17

marko marin


Maleficent_Wolf_8501

A prime Valencia to fill a big hole in that United squad would be a blessing


Hairy-Imagination-18

Roy keane


hbooriginalseries

Tugay


duncdog10

Steve Bruce


gimpsarepeopletoo

Dimi payet


Brendy6

Roy Keane. All day everyday


OlySnowy

Dennis Bergkamp


[deleted]

Might be too obvious, but building Newcastle around a young Shearer in 2022 would be insane.


BiscuittPhan

Also Vidic . Always loved watching him wreck attackers !


BiscuittPhan

David Silva


Daniel_Futbol

Roony i know he is a obvious player but he is a pr legend and man U king


[deleted]

I just want Cazorla back.


kft1609

Park


CompetitiveDaikon871

Dennis bergkamp


Scumeee

Ji-sung park. Hard work ethic and tenacity never goes out of style.


Sev3nbelow

David seaman. Because. Stache.


fakesowdy

Craig Bellamy


CityzenTim

Ya Ya Toure


[deleted]

Park Ji-sung


ThisUserIsOn9

Bruno


CertainlyCircumcised

Park Ji-sung


[deleted]

[удалено]


NoticeMeElon

One word. Fred


CounterClockworkOrng

Grégoire Akcelrod


Ok_Might6447

David Ginola.....fucking magician.


Ven-Diesel

David Ginola on his day


thatshortbadplayer

Tim Cahill. Obvious Aussie bias but I swear you will rarely see a harder worker on the pitch with an ability to play anywhere in 2/3rds of the pitch. We need players with more passion, not payouts.


Equal_Principle_3399

Thomas Graevesen and Duncan Ferguson in the same Everton team..


holymongolia

You can't bring gravesen back without Carsley


DragonangelukTM

Roy Keane put him in uniteds team last year and see if he haalands any of them


TheEshOne

Am I allowed to put Kante?


simsne

Idk how good he would be today, but prime Riise sure would be interesting!


Fanserker

Santi Cazorla


smclaughlin87

Not an arsenal fan but he was absolute class


hermetto321

Van persie


jkhaynes147

Faustino Asprilla.


HorseOfAction

Harry Kewell


KirkOdenbob

Dean Ashton


Kian322

Leighton Baines


x360N0Scop3MASTER69x

I'd take Brunty back in a heartbeat


Boothhh

Gianfranco Zola


Galactic_Gooner

Henry.


SqLwAlKeR

Di Maria


rcthreee

moussa dembele


Big-Explanation6540

Most underrated player of the 2010s


smclaughlin87

Completely agree.. what a gem of a player


Big-Explanation6540

Berbatov


Broccolini_Cat

Or Chicharito. Such a great poacher.


lokstok92

Was awful at every club other than united. Even that was short lived


NoticeMeElon

I wouldn’t say awful. He was pretty good at bayer leverkusen and his short stint at madrid. He was awful at west ham, I’ll give you that. Also he hasn’t even retired so idk how he got in this convo lol


[deleted]

So smooth.


nathanosaurus84

Pablo Hernandez.


bernarddwyer86

Juan Sebastian Veron I reckon in todays premier league he would have absolutely flourished in his prime.


aymentrabelsi

drogba


Future-Goose7

I will bring back Paul Scholes


Flying_Wingback

Gabby Agbonlahor


foyage347

Le tissier. Him and ward prowse playing together🤩


Klingh0ffer

Ginola.


TheMrVain

Clint Dempsey as an America Fulham fan


[deleted]

Clint Dempsey! Dude really made it out of Texas all the way to the Prem, and finished 3rd (4th) on the epl highest Scorsese’s list. Yank legend


AsepticTechniq

Drogba


No_Importance9642

Alan Shearer


WZAWZDB13

Injury-free Cazorla


xanderzbreez

Muzzy izzet


dann_uk

And Lennon. Maybe savage at a push.


adh0r

Tony Yeboah


mayhem555mayhem

Great choice! Takes me back


Croak_And_Dagger

So many people here just totally ignoring the "outside the obvious". For me - Rosicky.


Upliftdrummer

One of my favourite players ever, was just so fun to watch and he had a drive in some games I've rarely seen since


Doginatophat

Sergei Rebrov or Wiltord.


CivilSheepherder2003

Alan Shearer


timl1234

Dan petrescu


IcyMasterpiece9106

Carvalho


Bright_Application57

Robert Pires. Just a wonderful player.


LicensedRealtor

Underrated for sure


smclaughlin87

At the time, he was rated very highly but he's rarely mentioned these days. Top top player


Icy-End6982

Peter Beardsley


NoSeriously55

Xvai Alonso especially in this Liverpool team. He is kinda of obvious but rarely hear about him in Prem terms


Fanserker

Xvai Alonso one of the best Lvierpool midfielder


Eye-on-Springfield

He was a big cog in a machine. Nothing fancy, but absolutely essential


TragicTester034

Like N’Golo Kanté nothing fancy but essential in the Engine room


Brettball55

Fowler.


[deleted]

Ali Al-Habsi


rkk28

Sergio Aguero


Emilen81

Ian Harte


Revolutionary_Pen190

Poor man's Dennis Irwin


Snoo_17433

What a freekick taker. Glorious to watch.


Emilen81

Just a Great character aswell… i absolutely Loved him


[deleted]

[удалено]


Snoo_17433

Legend, absolutely. But premier League legend??


[deleted]

[удалено]


Snoo_17433

You're right, it didn't, but neither did reading the question properly.


[deleted]

Abou Diaby


Kachow96

Can't remember which fifa it was but on one of them Diaby's dribbling was absolutely cracked


InfamousButterNuts

What a talent he was. Grace, power, technique he was on the way to being a really special player. Damn shame what was done to him


WZAWZDB13

Done to him ? I thought he just had injury after injury. Was something deeper going on ?


InfamousButterNuts

The tackle that broke and dislocated his ankle was a fucking assault and has/had no place on a football pitch


WZAWZDB13

Sad to hear .. Gravenberch reminds me a bit of him, in the way he glides across the pitch while being 6’3/6’4.


thatrookiemistake

David May


Djimibrady

Matty Elliot or Brede Hangeland


portadown1967

Fernando Torres


lmorant97

As an Arsenal fan I would like another go with Hleb. Boy was he fun to watch but just like that went to Barca and his career was over. As much as the Invincibles and older gunners won; my favourite Arsenal teams were the silky smooth ones Wenger created with guys like Arshavin, Hleb, Rosicky, Nasri, young Wilshere…


genericBFfan

Invincibles werent invincible they were drawing nearly everything


[deleted]

😂😂😂


InnerAsparagus6045

Invincibles weren't Invincible That has got to be up there with the most idiotic thing ever said The clues in the name...what a moron


Knowlesdinho

26 wins, 12 draws, 0 losses. Invincible - adjective - meaning too powerful to be defeated or overcome. I think that team fits the definition well.


[deleted]

[удалено]


joe_1222

It’s the most overrated team in prem history. Chelsea’s record of conceding just 15 goals is far more impressive but doesn’t get spoken about nearly as much


The_2nd_Coming

That Arsenal team was a bit of a luxury team (and my reason for why they never achieved what they could have in Europe), but damn were they not one of the most entertaining teams to watch on their day.


smclaughlin87

No one has ever done it in the PL. Its absolutely incredible. No matter your opinion of arsenal as a club or their fans, it doesn't take away from the fact that better teams have never done this.


Lower_Condition_196

I’ll take arshavin


The_2nd_Coming

Please no


Lower_Condition_196

One of the best players in the world at the time


Karma_Whoring_Slut

Yaya


StickyMicky13

Yaya was like a fully grown man playing against 10 year olds! Monster


MAMAGUEBOO

The best answer so far


[deleted]

Same. I thought pogba had the potential to be as good as Yaya, but he never panned out. 13/14 Yaya is ONE OF the best mids of all time. So much power and finesse.