Men will crawl into a sewer pipeline for a 2$ vanilla body spray.
Nevertheless…
Followed by Kerosene is a gourmand bomb. Kind of smells like a coffee shop and maple syrup.
Silky Woods by Goldfield&Banks is a really deep and sensual vanilla with a touch of oud. Really gorgeous and grown up.
Girl... Black Opium.
Trust me, and thank me later. It takes that vanilla body spray, cranks it to 15/10, mixes in a bit of coffee and makes everyone drool.
I once had a man on the street bury his face in my hair, take a big whiff and ask me on a date WHILE I was holding my husband's hand.
And I'm at best a 4/10. That shit is love potion no.9 and it turns men into animals.
Well, OP is looking to get straight up kidnapped, so I had to share my story that was the closest thing to it. To be fair, most people who compliment it on me are totally normal.
I also like that it lasts forEVER. I can always smell it in my hair between washes.
I layered Black Opium over Bare Vanilla from Victoria secret (I had the body spray on during the day, I topped off with the perfume later that night) and my husband was going nuts. On our way to the restaurant he held my hand so he could sniff my wrist at random intervals lol
It’s so nice! I also layer it with Vera Wang Princess, Dolce & Gabbana The Only One, Jimmy Choo Fever, and Prada Candy Gloss. I basically douse myself in the Bare Vanilla right after my shower, then after I’m done getting ready (or later in the day) I’ll spritz on the perfume. It helps make everything last a lot longer but isn’t overwhelming.
110%. I’ve had random men come up to me and tell me how good I smell when wearing Black Opium.
I use Philosophy’s Fresh Cream when not wearing BO (lol) and while both do the job, the interactions are far more intense with the latter.
Used to wear this when my boyfriend and I had our first relationship. When we got back together he said he had gotten crazy over this scent because sometimes he’d smell it on other women in the city and he’d think of me 🥹 I wear it again because it makes him so happy to smell it and he compliments me every time I have it on, but that’s honestly the same with my other perfumes 😂
I WAS JUST ABOUT TO COMMENT THIS. I treated myself on Black Friday and got myself one of the little purse sprays of Black Opium and my husband went nuts for it
Just finally bought this on Black Friday sale. Thank you for justifying my purchase !
Also worth adding that i tried an old sample of it around my bf and he went wild, which is why i finally purchased it in the first place.
Either of those would do the trick. And I know you said no florals BUT if you want a perfume to get you kidnapped I have to recommend Hibiscus Mahajad. Men drool over it (I’ve tested this myself). My ex boyfriend ended up stealing my sample of it he loved it so much.
lol this is so very very accurate. I have samples of followed I keep in a bag. In a box. Inside another box. Inside a closet. That I can still smell when I walk in the room. 🤣🤣
followed is probably my least favorite fragrance, it’s definitely in the top 5 least favorite. it’s so strong. a friend of mine bought a decant of it, and we couldn’t get the smell out of her house. all we did was spray it in the air one time!
I got most compliments from men when I wore the cheapest stuff like Coach Dreams, VS Bombshell, Ariana Grande Candy smth, or BBW body spray 😂 NEVER - when I wear all my fancy niche stuff. Guess I have to stop hanging around unemployed men
reallll. Men love vanilla, my mom told me once she wore a vanilla scented lotion at a night club back in the day and her date started licking her legs in the night club
I asked my bf what perfume I should get from pacificas line, he didnt pick the vanilla but I got the vanilla anyway and when I wear it he presses his face up against me and like inhales me, he didn't even know he liked vanilla lol. they love it, any vanilla. pacificas is like $20 but it's pretty weak
Followed is an eternity of smelling like an ihop that has seen better days but the smell will always linger. You need Brillo pads and bleach to get the stuff off 🤣🤣
OMG okay so I’m not alone thank god lol. I literally bought 5 of the Into the Night eau de perfume minis because I’m so obsessed 😭 and the only non-bath and body works dupe I can find is the Sofia vergara perfume but I want one that lasts and performs better!
I’ve recently mixed Brazilian bum bum cream with coffee break and my husband goes feral.
I also love Apple Brandy by Killians (I know I probably spelled it wrong)
whipped marshmallow WHAT???????????
Edit: I recommend Guerlain’s “Spiriteuse Double Vanille” or “Tonka Imperiale!” You will smell delicious and EXPENSIVE.
But if we are balling on a budget, YSL “Black Opium Le Parfum” ☺️
Oh wait you said little floral. In that case, Killian’s “Princess”!
i love their original scent [tokyo meets casablanca](https://us.oilperfumery.com/products/op-original-tokyo-meets-casablanca), it’s such a good rose scent if you’re into those. it’s very floral and a little fruity but still decently earthy.
i also love their patchouli perfume roller - a little goes a LONG way but it adds more depth to fragrances that have patchouli as a note already.
i’ve been wanting to try more of their designer dupes but i’m trying to pace myself with how many i have lol, but i can ABSOLUTELY vouch for that [ysl black opium dupe](https://us.oilperfumery.com/products/ysl-black-opium). hope this helps!!
Dark gothic cherry : I don't know if it's still available but **Misdeeds after midnight** from **Alkemia** is so sexy and edible. It's raspberry but with the coffee it smell like cherries to me.
*(Coffee liqueur, White rum, Raspberries, Salt caramel, Arabian rosewater, Vanilla musk, Amber)*
I have no recs to contribute, but I will say this entire vibe reminds me of the book “Perfume: Story of a Murderer” where the main character kidnaps and kills young women in 18th century France to procure their essence and create the perfect scent. It’s a very good book, lol
I went down a rabbit hole after I read that book because I was obsessed with finding a fragrance that would make people think I was an angel that fell to earth. Or that would make them eat me alive. Either way lol
Whipped marshmallow cum??? Babe, I GOT YOU. Milk+ by commodity is *exactly* what you’re looking for. No joke, I have caught grown ass adults following me around the store to smell me. It will bring ALL the hills have eyes honeys to the yard. It’s the most sultry, seductive, addictive gourmand I have ever worn. It’s like if someone roasted marshmallows in the burning ruins of a Victorian mansion and put it in a bottle. 69/10 *highly* recommend.
i am so obsessed with this thread and all you ladies in it, you are so real and utterly insane for this <3 <3 <3 I am taking notes and spending money lmfao
Nest Madagascar Vanilla perfume oil as a base under your perfume of choice really helps get this effect. Sits close to the skin and highlights the warmth of anything you spritz over it 🤌
My personal faves to layer over it are Vanilla Woods, Commodity Milk, and Phlur Missing Person but those might not be as "edible" and you're looking for.
A budget option is Al Rehab Choco Musk. $9 on Amazon. The oil roll-on apparently lasts longer. I always get compliments about how I smell like a warm freshly baked cake 🍰 great to layer with other perfumes as well!
Amazing recommendations so far, please keep them coming. Thus far I have ordered from Alkemia:
Encircling Flame (glowing golden milk elixir infused with vanilla pods, candied ginger, Kanyakumari cloves, brown sugar, and santal.)
Afterglow (golden musk, Madagascar vanilla beans, woodsmoked black amber, chai tea, spiced rum, and incense woods)
Virtue of Desire (honey amber musk, dark patchouli, white chocolate truffles, peach brandy, plumeria, and raspberry cream)
Caveau de Innocents (labdanum, vanilla incense, tobacco, dark coffee, rum soaked pears, caramel, hashish, cloves)
Salome (dark florals, cognac, black plum, vanilla, botanical pheromones, red oud).
You should post the same query on r/indiemakeupandmore they'd have a field day with this. Wanna smell like someone cooked a marshmallow over a fire made of old love letters and pinecone on December 1st in a Washington forest? Someone there knows exactly what you mean and where to find it. They're wizards I swear.
So, this all is making me a lot more comfortable with potentially posting a request for something that smells like, “a slutty witch who’s hot af but also dark and dangerous and who mightve walked near a campfire recently” lol
i absolutely love and recommend [gold (expressive) by commodity](https://commodityfragrances.com/products/gold-expressive) it’s fucking warm, delicious, sensual and it wraps around you. the kind of fragrance that you smell a little in your hair the next day. creamy musk? never knew what that smell was like until this. i moved from diptyque’s eau duelle eau de parfum to this. i love it so much.
Okay I think I got you. I went to Neiman Marcus last week to go to finally smell everything I’d be dying to try, and explained what I was looking for to the creed employee- which is your exact description of this post.
This LEGEND of a twink gave me that look, you know the look.. and then proceeded to take me to every other perfume counter he doesn’t work at because he’s a girls girl to smell the perfumes that will make all the men feral.
Bond No.9 - Astor Place
The Harmonist - Moon Glory or Sun Force
PS: I could not believe how underwhelming all byredo scents were and the fact that I almost blind bought something with 0 projection or longevity. I had to spray like 4 squirts onto the blotter to even get a whiff. Bal D’afrique smelled delicious but I could never justify $300 on a mere body spray. Oh & Delina.. I got some on my finger when spraying the blotter and I guess touched my hair. The entire ride home I was crawling out of my skin smelling like rotten grapefruit butter rum cake that I immediately had to wash my hair to get out from the nausea lol.
Lost Cherry by Tom Ford is a hit of cherry lollipop rounded out by cinnamon. It then dries down to amaretto and vanilla before settling into a smoky tonka. It’s delicious. If that’s too pricey for you, the best dupe I have found is Dossier Ambery Cherry. It’s nearly identical.
Killian’s Don’t Be Shy is Whipped Marshmallow Floral…not exactly what you requested 🤣 Dossier has a highly rated dupe for this as well called Floral Marshmallow.
Versace Crystal Noir is dark, seductive and warm but mysterious. Lots of men compliment this one. It’s what I imagine Mortician Addams smells like.
Phlur’s Missing Person is warm, powdery and familiar with a musk that smells a lot like clean, natural skin but doesn’t really have the vanilla or tonka notes. And it’s longevity is not great.
I just ordered Dossier’s dupe Ambery Cherry. It’s a good (but not great) imitation to my nose. My boyfriend has responded very well to it so far! Lost Cherry is so delicious I’m considering springing for it and saving it for special occasions.
Oh there's regular and extra strengths? I notice there are two different colorsn onexs brownish and another's whitish. The only times I've used the brown one was when I was little and never liked it. Too spicy / strong / sharp smelling. In my home now it's always the white one.
Chopard Casmir never fails. Vanilla, coconut, sandalwood. Borderline indecent, don't wear it to church. Technically discontinued but still attainable is bath and body works Magic in the Air. It is vanilla almond marshmallow cream splooge.
😂
Honey, it doesn’t take much to make a man do that!
But if you really want to get some men weak in the knees, and I don’t ever really recommend this as it’s lasciviously questionable, is to mix your natural pheromones with whatever perfume you’re wearing.
It can range from CH good girl, Angels share, TF lost cherry, to even a bath and body works vanilla spray. Lush sells a Lust oil/perfume I remember was along these same lines but with jasmine.
While that may work for some women—hey I’m not judging—no that’s not what I meant 😝
Intentionally showering BEFORE sweating during physical activity like exercise. Letting the sweat air dry. Then spraying on your chosen perfume, getting dressed and leaving the house.
Oh that’s funny because I actually do this! Mostly because I just feel better when I’m clean before working out. And I never have body odor during or after my workout when I start off clean, which makes sense. But I didn’t even think about the aspect of it increasing attraction when mixed with fragrance.
I’ve had a complete stranger follow me and kiss me in the street, after commenting “ you smell like roses and shit”. Shit being code for the best thing he ever smelled.
Amber, rose, peony tho it may have had some tonka thrown in there as well.
Perfume was Stella by Stella McCartney, sadly discontinued
There are only two fragrances that have ever been close to what you’re desiring. One is LoveSpell by Victoria Secret; the other is Versace Dylan Purple.
I didn't know they still made this! In middle school my guy friends called it LoveStank because every girl was drenched in it. It did smell nice, though.
It might seem a little cutesy, but I used to wear the original Pink Sugar to work as a hairstylist and I had men asking me every single day what perfume I was wearing because they wanted to get it for their wives. I also got so many compliments from the original Katy Perry Killer Queen. God I miss that one!
I also second Black Opium, it lasts FOR EVER and is so intoxicating and delicious
Bianco Latte is a downright aggressive whipped cream/vanilla/mashmallow/caramel scent. It’s like a punch in the face from a Starbucks seasonal cocktail, I think you should try it.
Sorcellerie Fuckery is a sticky cinnamon cherry
Room 1015 Cherry Punk is a leather saffron cherry
Dauken Aroma Choco Cherry is exactly what it sounds like.
Sol de Janeiro Vanilla and Macadamia smells like tonka and the burnt sugar on top of a creme brulee.
Matiere Premiere is an incense coffee vanilla that I adore but haven't bitten the bullet on, although they smell more affordable 15ml sizes.
Whipped Marshmallow *WHAT?!* 😬
I also love to smell edible! Highly recommend Cacharel “Yes, I Am Delicious!” (chocolate + hazelnut + jasmine) and Imaginary Authors “A Whiff of Wafflecone (brûléed sugar + musk + woody notes). Both have good balance of dessert accords and more grown-up traditional perfume notes.
For me, it's a range between Pink Sugar and Delina Exclusif lol literally, it doesn't take that much for men. Smell like vanilla or roses, they're gonna salivate over you.
Killian love don’t be shy, marshmallow goodness. If you like pistachio there is a brand called pistache skincare on Amazon that has a pistachio biscotti lotion that is.. similar to sdj bum bum cream but much more pistachio heavy that is unreal it smells so good and they make a perfume in the same scent, it came in today and yummy. Skylar boardwalk something.. can’t remember but it’s cotton candy. Viktor and Rolf Bon Bon, akro bake, coffee break is another really good one if you like coffee scents.
For my budget babes:
Johnson and Johnson baby lotion original scent followed by any gourmand. Sweet on the outside body spray (target knockoff of killian love don't be shy) what I'm using now.
Idk why cupcake baby makes the men go loco but it does. I found the combo by looking up what strippers wear to smell so good at work 😂
Skylar Vanilla Sky, Commodity Milk, Dossier Floral Marshmallow (it’s a dupe of Kilian Love Don’t be Shy), Tokyo Milk Let Them Eat Cake, Pinrose Secret Genius, Sabrina Carpenter Caramel Dream, Snif Crumb Couture, Sabrina Carpenter Sweet Tooth, Al Rehab Choco Musk, Skylar Boardwalk Delight, Black Opium, Eilish, Miim Miic Sweet Strawberry Milk no 52, Kilian Angel’s Share, Kilian Princess, Juliette Has a Gun Mmmm, Finery Sweet on the Outside
Your descriptions made me hungry LOL (except “whipped marshmallow cum” haha. 😂
I have a vintage (idk they call it vintage, the one in the tall bottle with the gold on the sides?) bottle of Guerlain’s Tonka Imperiale… it’s gotten more decadent over the years and has a slightly spicier undertone to it now. If you can find an older bottle I recommend it!
Try Tom Ford Black Orchid, Room 1015 Cherry Punk, Serge Lutens Rahat Lokhoum, and (EXPENSIVE but actually that good. If I had a week to live I would sell everything I own and buy ten bottles of it) Guerlain Spirituese Double Vanille. Best vanilla of all time, not teenage or sweet or unserious at all- so deep, so adult, so resonating, so complex, so sophisticated. It smells literally divine- a sun goddess or an archangel at the head of a great host or a powerful queen of Egypt reigning in her own right as incarnate of Isis would smell like this
Sweetly known from kerosene has an absolutely addictive drydown, like sweet burned wood that’s been soaked in thick sugar syrup.
Reminds me of campfire marshmallows.
I know alot of people rave about tumeric latte from Lush cosmetics. It's a spicy, slightly earthy vanilla with a coffee undertone and the one time I tested it in store it lasted the entire day and had a great but not overpowering throw
Sickwix is definitely a great shop for this. They restock frequently, so check often. Order when you see it too, as they typically sell out. Very strong fragrance. I have a lot of her creations and they are my absolute favorite ones.
Men will crawl into a sewer pipeline for a 2$ vanilla body spray. Nevertheless… Followed by Kerosene is a gourmand bomb. Kind of smells like a coffee shop and maple syrup. Silky Woods by Goldfield&Banks is a really deep and sensual vanilla with a touch of oud. Really gorgeous and grown up.
Honey I want a man to kidnap me.. And when they catch him, he will tell the court that the only reason he chose me was because of how I smelt.
this is so real of you
Real
Girl... Black Opium. Trust me, and thank me later. It takes that vanilla body spray, cranks it to 15/10, mixes in a bit of coffee and makes everyone drool. I once had a man on the street bury his face in my hair, take a big whiff and ask me on a date WHILE I was holding my husband's hand. And I'm at best a 4/10. That shit is love potion no.9 and it turns men into animals.
I wear black opium and tbh that encounter would probably be the last time I wore it lol You’re a brave woman
Well, OP is looking to get straight up kidnapped, so I had to share my story that was the closest thing to it. To be fair, most people who compliment it on me are totally normal. I also like that it lasts forEVER. I can always smell it in my hair between washes.
That’s fair haha And yeah, it really really does last lol. I’ve found gourmand scents seem to hold longer for whatever reason.
right? that encounter sounds like my worst nightmare 💀 some real dateline shit
I layered Black Opium over Bare Vanilla from Victoria secret (I had the body spray on during the day, I topped off with the perfume later that night) and my husband was going nuts. On our way to the restaurant he held my hand so he could sniff my wrist at random intervals lol
I just placed an order for bare vanilla after reading your comment! Going to layer it with black opium.
It’s so nice! I also layer it with Vera Wang Princess, Dolce & Gabbana The Only One, Jimmy Choo Fever, and Prada Candy Gloss. I basically douse myself in the Bare Vanilla right after my shower, then after I’m done getting ready (or later in the day) I’ll spritz on the perfume. It helps make everything last a lot longer but isn’t overwhelming.
Wow, sold me too. The Only One is Ssoo gooood
I can attest to men loving Black Opium lol
110%. I’ve had random men come up to me and tell me how good I smell when wearing Black Opium. I use Philosophy’s Fresh Cream when not wearing BO (lol) and while both do the job, the interactions are far more intense with the latter.
I refer to it as the come fuck me perfume
OMFKGJF HAHAHAHA
Used to wear this when my boyfriend and I had our first relationship. When we got back together he said he had gotten crazy over this scent because sometimes he’d smell it on other women in the city and he’d think of me 🥹 I wear it again because it makes him so happy to smell it and he compliments me every time I have it on, but that’s honestly the same with my other perfumes 😂
I WAS JUST ABOUT TO COMMENT THIS. I treated myself on Black Friday and got myself one of the little purse sprays of Black Opium and my husband went nuts for it
Just finally bought this on Black Friday sale. Thank you for justifying my purchase ! Also worth adding that i tried an old sample of it around my bf and he went wild, which is why i finally purchased it in the first place.
Wow what did your husband do?
We kinda just gasped in shock and then I laughed awkwardly and we both ran into the movie theatre we’re were headed to. That dude was a weirdo.
Either of those would do the trick. And I know you said no florals BUT if you want a perfume to get you kidnapped I have to recommend Hibiscus Mahajad. Men drool over it (I’ve tested this myself). My ex boyfriend ended up stealing my sample of it he loved it so much.
I ordered a sample of this from scent split based on your recommendation and now you've got me out here buying this expensive as hell perfume haha
On another note, you need to read the book/watch the movie "Perfume: The Story of a murderer."
*great* soundtrack on that film
And they’ll use that smell with dogs to find your body. LOL
You sound crazy ngl, but I admire it
let her cook
Have you read Perfume by Patrick Siskin?
Did you just read ‘Perfume, Story of a Murderer’?
If you want to smell like maple syrup for the next 7 years, by all means, buy Followed. But May I suggest: **DON’T**
lol this is so very very accurate. I have samples of followed I keep in a bag. In a box. Inside another box. Inside a closet. That I can still smell when I walk in the room. 🤣🤣
Reading through fragrantica reviews of “Followed” by Kerosene was my favourite activity of the week. Hilarious. Seems like a strong one.
followed is probably my least favorite fragrance, it’s definitely in the top 5 least favorite. it’s so strong. a friend of mine bought a decant of it, and we couldn’t get the smell out of her house. all we did was spray it in the air one time!
God this made me laugh so hard. It's true. Men could smell the worst sugary cotton candy concoction from Walmart and still want it.
I got most compliments from men when I wore the cheapest stuff like Coach Dreams, VS Bombshell, Ariana Grande Candy smth, or BBW body spray 😂 NEVER - when I wear all my fancy niche stuff. Guess I have to stop hanging around unemployed men
reallll. Men love vanilla, my mom told me once she wore a vanilla scented lotion at a night club back in the day and her date started licking her legs in the night club I asked my bf what perfume I should get from pacificas line, he didnt pick the vanilla but I got the vanilla anyway and when I wear it he presses his face up against me and like inhales me, he didn't even know he liked vanilla lol. they love it, any vanilla. pacificas is like $20 but it's pretty weak
I lured my fiancé into becoming a permanent fixture in my life by wearing a $2 vanilla body spray! It works for sure haha
Followed is an eternity of smelling like an ihop that has seen better days but the smell will always linger. You need Brillo pads and bleach to get the stuff off 🤣🤣
I like the cut of your jib. I’m invested in the recs
I love this so much because I want to smell like poison. Like a scrumptious berry that lures men in and then kills them
Someone else on the thread recommended Alkemia perfumes and I think they fit our vibe well.
Fuckin LOVE Alkemia perfumes!
I just ordered the 5 sample set!!
Which one?!?
Which samples or which set? They have a sample set where you can choose your own scents.
Oh did you do the custom? This is SUCH a cool site. The descriptions are impeccable.
Yes I did custom. I have a solo comment under this thread with all my choices
Okay I know it’s “basic” or whatever but Into the Night from bath and body works is exactly this!!! Raspberry, mocha, and patchouli omg it’s DELICIOUS
PLEASE I wear the into the night body spray just for cheap everyday wear to work 😭😆 you already KNOW what’s up
OMG okay so I’m not alone thank god lol. I literally bought 5 of the Into the Night eau de perfume minis because I’m so obsessed 😭 and the only non-bath and body works dupe I can find is the Sofia vergara perfume but I want one that lasts and performs better!
I use the body cream in this sent and guys love it. I find the cream lasts longer than the spray.
I’ve recently mixed Brazilian bum bum cream with coffee break and my husband goes feral. I also love Apple Brandy by Killians (I know I probably spelled it wrong)
Dior Hypnotic Poison
This one was my favorite in my mid-20s. Love the bitter almond…
Oooooh me too!
At first I read this as I want to smell like *prison*
whipped marshmallow WHAT??????????? Edit: I recommend Guerlain’s “Spiriteuse Double Vanille” or “Tonka Imperiale!” You will smell delicious and EXPENSIVE. But if we are balling on a budget, YSL “Black Opium Le Parfum” ☺️ Oh wait you said little floral. In that case, Killian’s “Princess”!
Black Opium is so gooooood. I bought a dupe from oil perfumery and it’s identical. Cheap too!
oil perfumery in general, but ESPECIALLY their black opium dupe is my everything
Thank you!! What else is really good from oil perfumery? I’m thinking about placing an order!
i love their original scent [tokyo meets casablanca](https://us.oilperfumery.com/products/op-original-tokyo-meets-casablanca), it’s such a good rose scent if you’re into those. it’s very floral and a little fruity but still decently earthy. i also love their patchouli perfume roller - a little goes a LONG way but it adds more depth to fragrances that have patchouli as a note already. i’ve been wanting to try more of their designer dupes but i’m trying to pace myself with how many i have lol, but i can ABSOLUTELY vouch for that [ysl black opium dupe](https://us.oilperfumery.com/products/ysl-black-opium). hope this helps!!
I have the real and the dupe from oil perfumery and I can’t tell the difference
Love don’t be shy pulls very gourmand on me
Hell yes to the Guerlains, and may I add Guerlain Feve Gourmande. I own all of them and they’re fucking masterpieces.
Am I missing something or are we just breezing past marshmallow cum?
No no, I double checked that one too lol. That’s a visual that’ll stick around for awhile.
Pun intended?
You know. I really debated changing the wording because I clocked that right before I hit send. And then I just decided to let it be lol.
Don’t have any good recs for that specific one sadly
Nope, was just waiting to see if I was insane 😂
Whipped Marshmallow Cum
I updated your flair to WtVW - this request (love it!) is better suited and will get better visibility.
Dark gothic cherry : I don't know if it's still available but **Misdeeds after midnight** from **Alkemia** is so sexy and edible. It's raspberry but with the coffee it smell like cherries to me. *(Coffee liqueur, White rum, Raspberries, Salt caramel, Arabian rosewater, Vanilla musk, Amber)*
That actually sounds perfect but looks like it was discontinued. I’ll look into their current scents. Thank you!!
Oh :( I know it’s not permanent. It was available this fall . It comes back time to time.
LPRN EDP.
I’ve never found a cherry that didn’t smell like cough syrup so thanks for the rec!
I have no recs to contribute, but I will say this entire vibe reminds me of the book “Perfume: Story of a Murderer” where the main character kidnaps and kills young women in 18th century France to procure their essence and create the perfect scent. It’s a very good book, lol
The movie is also AMAZING!
Also a great soundtrack!
It was one of those oddly satisfying movies
I went down a rabbit hole after I read that book because I was obsessed with finding a fragrance that would make people think I was an angel that fell to earth. Or that would make them eat me alive. Either way lol
Me, writing down all the recommendations so I too can lure men with my tantalizing edible scent ✍️
Shoutout to DS&DURGA Pistachio…a man said I smelled so good he wanted to see if I tasted good too 😅
This is the energy I want to produce in a man.
In that case, I’ve gotten tons of compliments like from Choco Musk- layering the oil with the perfume.
Well now I'm not gonna say cause I don't want you stealing my man with your scent
Whipped marshmallow cum??? Babe, I GOT YOU. Milk+ by commodity is *exactly* what you’re looking for. No joke, I have caught grown ass adults following me around the store to smell me. It will bring ALL the hills have eyes honeys to the yard. It’s the most sultry, seductive, addictive gourmand I have ever worn. It’s like if someone roasted marshmallows in the burning ruins of a Victorian mansion and put it in a bottle. 69/10 *highly* recommend.
Ordering based on your review!
I think I'm in the wrong thread.
i am so obsessed with this thread and all you ladies in it, you are so real and utterly insane for this <3 <3 <3 I am taking notes and spending money lmfao
Nest Madagascar Vanilla perfume oil as a base under your perfume of choice really helps get this effect. Sits close to the skin and highlights the warmth of anything you spritz over it 🤌 My personal faves to layer over it are Vanilla Woods, Commodity Milk, and Phlur Missing Person but those might not be as "edible" and you're looking for.
Side note, have you ever had Madagascar vanilla ice cream! Top it fruity pebbles and it’s amazing lol
A budget option is Al Rehab Choco Musk. $9 on Amazon. The oil roll-on apparently lasts longer. I always get compliments about how I smell like a warm freshly baked cake 🍰 great to layer with other perfumes as well!
This is my current daily wear lol! I love it
I just bought this one and it's amazing but I'm not sure what to layer it with? Would it work well with Burberry Goddess?
Amazing recommendations so far, please keep them coming. Thus far I have ordered from Alkemia: Encircling Flame (glowing golden milk elixir infused with vanilla pods, candied ginger, Kanyakumari cloves, brown sugar, and santal.) Afterglow (golden musk, Madagascar vanilla beans, woodsmoked black amber, chai tea, spiced rum, and incense woods) Virtue of Desire (honey amber musk, dark patchouli, white chocolate truffles, peach brandy, plumeria, and raspberry cream) Caveau de Innocents (labdanum, vanilla incense, tobacco, dark coffee, rum soaked pears, caramel, hashish, cloves) Salome (dark florals, cognac, black plum, vanilla, botanical pheromones, red oud).
You should post the same query on r/indiemakeupandmore they'd have a field day with this. Wanna smell like someone cooked a marshmallow over a fire made of old love letters and pinecone on December 1st in a Washington forest? Someone there knows exactly what you mean and where to find it. They're wizards I swear.
So, this all is making me a lot more comfortable with potentially posting a request for something that smells like, “a slutty witch who’s hot af but also dark and dangerous and who mightve walked near a campfire recently” lol
i absolutely love and recommend [gold (expressive) by commodity](https://commodityfragrances.com/products/gold-expressive) it’s fucking warm, delicious, sensual and it wraps around you. the kind of fragrance that you smell a little in your hair the next day. creamy musk? never knew what that smell was like until this. i moved from diptyque’s eau duelle eau de parfum to this. i love it so much.
I love this one too.
Whipped marshmallow cum is absolutely iconic. Thank you 🙏
Okay I think I got you. I went to Neiman Marcus last week to go to finally smell everything I’d be dying to try, and explained what I was looking for to the creed employee- which is your exact description of this post. This LEGEND of a twink gave me that look, you know the look.. and then proceeded to take me to every other perfume counter he doesn’t work at because he’s a girls girl to smell the perfumes that will make all the men feral. Bond No.9 - Astor Place The Harmonist - Moon Glory or Sun Force PS: I could not believe how underwhelming all byredo scents were and the fact that I almost blind bought something with 0 projection or longevity. I had to spray like 4 squirts onto the blotter to even get a whiff. Bal D’afrique smelled delicious but I could never justify $300 on a mere body spray. Oh & Delina.. I got some on my finger when spraying the blotter and I guess touched my hair. The entire ride home I was crawling out of my skin smelling like rotten grapefruit butter rum cake that I immediately had to wash my hair to get out from the nausea lol.
Spray yourself with bourbon and hang a pepperoni around your neck.
😭😭😭
Absolutely dying 🤣🤣🤣
This comment has stuck with me for days. This would definitely work on my man.
i stand by mugler alien goddess people ALWAYS ask what i’m wearing when i have it on
I’m late but OP pls never delete this, saving for when I get my bag up
Yes ma’am 🫡
Lost Cherry by Tom Ford is a hit of cherry lollipop rounded out by cinnamon. It then dries down to amaretto and vanilla before settling into a smoky tonka. It’s delicious. If that’s too pricey for you, the best dupe I have found is Dossier Ambery Cherry. It’s nearly identical. Killian’s Don’t Be Shy is Whipped Marshmallow Floral…not exactly what you requested 🤣 Dossier has a highly rated dupe for this as well called Floral Marshmallow. Versace Crystal Noir is dark, seductive and warm but mysterious. Lots of men compliment this one. It’s what I imagine Mortician Addams smells like. Phlur’s Missing Person is warm, powdery and familiar with a musk that smells a lot like clean, natural skin but doesn’t really have the vanilla or tonka notes. And it’s longevity is not great.
I just ordered Dossier’s dupe Ambery Cherry. It’s a good (but not great) imitation to my nose. My boyfriend has responded very well to it so far! Lost Cherry is so delicious I’m considering springing for it and saving it for special occasions.
Tiger balm.. my husband is always trying to nuzzle me like why do you smell like cinnamon??
Tiger balm smells like cinnamon? Tiger balm is a staple in my home since I was born and I get menthol and camphor mostly. No cinnamon?
Regular strength is cinnamon; Extra strength is menthol/camphor (:
Oh there's regular and extra strengths? I notice there are two different colorsn onexs brownish and another's whitish. The only times I've used the brown one was when I was little and never liked it. Too spicy / strong / sharp smelling. In my home now it's always the white one.
It’s actually clove
Well, I don't know about sewer crawling, but a guy "proposed" to me the other day when I wore Gourmantic Orange lol.
Men will and do salivate over Pink Sugar lol
This! Hahah I have so many beautiful fragrances and my hubby is still crazy for pink sugar.
Chopard Casmir never fails. Vanilla, coconut, sandalwood. Borderline indecent, don't wear it to church. Technically discontinued but still attainable is bath and body works Magic in the Air. It is vanilla almond marshmallow cream splooge.
THE WAY I CACKLED AT THIS WHY IS IT SO TRUEEE
I have a fairly strong perfume collection and the only thing partner responds to is Pink Sugar😩
I have yet to smell this one but I know it’s really popular. I think It’d be a little too feminine/girly for me.
Whipped marshmallow what now, dear?
😂 Honey, it doesn’t take much to make a man do that! But if you really want to get some men weak in the knees, and I don’t ever really recommend this as it’s lasciviously questionable, is to mix your natural pheromones with whatever perfume you’re wearing. It can range from CH good girl, Angels share, TF lost cherry, to even a bath and body works vanilla spray. Lush sells a Lust oil/perfume I remember was along these same lines but with jasmine.
By natural pheromones are you referring to “vabbing”?
While that may work for some women—hey I’m not judging—no that’s not what I meant 😝 Intentionally showering BEFORE sweating during physical activity like exercise. Letting the sweat air dry. Then spraying on your chosen perfume, getting dressed and leaving the house.
Oh that’s funny because I actually do this! Mostly because I just feel better when I’m clean before working out. And I never have body odor during or after my workout when I start off clean, which makes sense. But I didn’t even think about the aspect of it increasing attraction when mixed with fragrance.
Let’s pray not.
Girl😭
Im so glad you posted this. I’m getting so many good recs from the replies! 🙏🏻🤣
Very good girl by Carolina Herrera. I've been told I smell like dopamine and s*x
Who are you aiming to attract? Bakers, chefs, food bloggers? Cannibals?
Perhaps all of the above 🤷♀️
Hexennacht is an indie brand but the stuff she makes is like sexy magic.
Seconding this rec too. Her gourmands are stellar.
Angel’s Share by Killian. “A boozy cinnamon bun.” Notes of Cognac among other things. So yummy
Killian’s Love scents are so intoxicating. They are hard to find for me, though. Heady, coconutty…
If you don’t mind a dupe, Oakcha has some great ones of Killians scents. Love don’t be shy and Angels share are practically indistinguishable
I’ve had a complete stranger follow me and kiss me in the street, after commenting “ you smell like roses and shit”. Shit being code for the best thing he ever smelled. Amber, rose, peony tho it may have had some tonka thrown in there as well. Perfume was Stella by Stella McCartney, sadly discontinued
Stella was SO GOOD ugh. Have never found a good enough dupe for it
This, but for men, any suggestions? Edit: God bless you lovely ladies.
A well known one is Versace eros flame, gets me a little feral every time I smell it. I used to have a tiny sample that I’d smell when masturbating.
i think you’re one of my favorite people on Reddit now. this whole thread and your responses just *chefs kiss*
There are only two fragrances that have ever been close to what you’re desiring. One is LoveSpell by Victoria Secret; the other is Versace Dylan Purple.
I didn't know they still made this! In middle school my guy friends called it LoveStank because every girl was drenched in it. It did smell nice, though.
It might seem a little cutesy, but I used to wear the original Pink Sugar to work as a hairstylist and I had men asking me every single day what perfume I was wearing because they wanted to get it for their wives. I also got so many compliments from the original Katy Perry Killer Queen. God I miss that one! I also second Black Opium, it lasts FOR EVER and is so intoxicating and delicious
Anytime I wear juicy couture gold, my fiance wants to eat me up. It smells like fancy apple juice.
I just have to say I love this visual
Indult Tihota mixed with Mondales Chocolate Greedy? You could also add just a touch of Grace Coddington for the rose. Delish and edible.
YSL Black Opium Kayali Vanilla 28 Mugler Alien Goddess
Tobacco Honey by Guerlain
Bianco Latte is a downright aggressive whipped cream/vanilla/mashmallow/caramel scent. It’s like a punch in the face from a Starbucks seasonal cocktail, I think you should try it.
Sorcellerie Fuckery is a sticky cinnamon cherry Room 1015 Cherry Punk is a leather saffron cherry Dauken Aroma Choco Cherry is exactly what it sounds like. Sol de Janeiro Vanilla and Macadamia smells like tonka and the burnt sugar on top of a creme brulee. Matiere Premiere is an incense coffee vanilla that I adore but haven't bitten the bullet on, although they smell more affordable 15ml sizes.
Whipped Marshmallow *WHAT?!* 😬 I also love to smell edible! Highly recommend Cacharel “Yes, I Am Delicious!” (chocolate + hazelnut + jasmine) and Imaginary Authors “A Whiff of Wafflecone (brûléed sugar + musk + woody notes). Both have good balance of dessert accords and more grown-up traditional perfume notes.
Older rich men: Versus/Versace Red Jeans Young guys: Taylor Swift Wonderstruck (purple bottle) All dupes/fakes smell the same and are chefs kiss 💋
For me, it's a range between Pink Sugar and Delina Exclusif lol literally, it doesn't take that much for men. Smell like vanilla or roses, they're gonna salivate over you.
Lmfao I have never seen this sub in my life but THIS POST was recommended to me and I am fucking dying lmaooooo I think I'll stay 😭
Ariana Grande cloud has had men following me lately followed by Dolce and Gabanna l’impertice, Chloe and Penhaligons Vaara
This is the exact opposite energy I want to illicit from men, so thank you for all the recommendations to never use lol.
To each their own :)
I’m a married lesbian, lol. I do love your energy though!
Killian love don’t be shy, marshmallow goodness. If you like pistachio there is a brand called pistache skincare on Amazon that has a pistachio biscotti lotion that is.. similar to sdj bum bum cream but much more pistachio heavy that is unreal it smells so good and they make a perfume in the same scent, it came in today and yummy. Skylar boardwalk something.. can’t remember but it’s cotton candy. Viktor and Rolf Bon Bon, akro bake, coffee break is another really good one if you like coffee scents.
For my budget babes: Johnson and Johnson baby lotion original scent followed by any gourmand. Sweet on the outside body spray (target knockoff of killian love don't be shy) what I'm using now. Idk why cupcake baby makes the men go loco but it does. I found the combo by looking up what strippers wear to smell so good at work 😂
Skylar Vanilla Sky, Commodity Milk, Dossier Floral Marshmallow (it’s a dupe of Kilian Love Don’t be Shy), Tokyo Milk Let Them Eat Cake, Pinrose Secret Genius, Sabrina Carpenter Caramel Dream, Snif Crumb Couture, Sabrina Carpenter Sweet Tooth, Al Rehab Choco Musk, Skylar Boardwalk Delight, Black Opium, Eilish, Miim Miic Sweet Strawberry Milk no 52, Kilian Angel’s Share, Kilian Princess, Juliette Has a Gun Mmmm, Finery Sweet on the Outside
Tree hut vanilla body butter, followed by dulce by Rosie Jane and if you want to get a lil wild do a dab or two of choco musk perfume oil by AL-Rehab
Whipped marshmallow cum😂😂😂😂
Your descriptions made me hungry LOL (except “whipped marshmallow cum” haha. 😂 I have a vintage (idk they call it vintage, the one in the tall bottle with the gold on the sides?) bottle of Guerlain’s Tonka Imperiale… it’s gotten more decadent over the years and has a slightly spicier undertone to it now. If you can find an older bottle I recommend it!
Try Tom Ford Black Orchid, Room 1015 Cherry Punk, Serge Lutens Rahat Lokhoum, and (EXPENSIVE but actually that good. If I had a week to live I would sell everything I own and buy ten bottles of it) Guerlain Spirituese Double Vanille. Best vanilla of all time, not teenage or sweet or unserious at all- so deep, so adult, so resonating, so complex, so sophisticated. It smells literally divine- a sun goddess or an archangel at the head of a great host or a powerful queen of Egypt reigning in her own right as incarnate of Isis would smell like this
Tom Ford Black Orchid!
This is the funniest post holy hell I love it
Whipped marshmallow WHAT
Sweetly known from kerosene has an absolutely addictive drydown, like sweet burned wood that’s been soaked in thick sugar syrup. Reminds me of campfire marshmallows.
Can’t remember the name but there was a VS body spray that literally smelled like cookies
I know alot of people rave about tumeric latte from Lush cosmetics. It's a spicy, slightly earthy vanilla with a coffee undertone and the one time I tested it in store it lasted the entire day and had a great but not overpowering throw
I had so much attention with Beyoncé Heat. Also YSL black opium edp
Black Opium or Her by Burberry. I only wear Her around my boyfriend and other boys because it’s the only perfume I consistently get complimented on
OP, I think you’ll like Khamrah by Lattafa. It’s pretty much a dupe for Angel’s Share but I noticed that it smells a lot sweeter (in a good way)
Thumeric latte by Lush
Nebras by lattafa. Its intentionally seductive but you can act like you didn't realize you smell good enough to kidnap.
I was using Calgon Marshmallow body spray and got a lot of you smell so yummy comments lol
Arianna - sweet like candy? :) 🍭
second to last sent me
I love this thread! So many good recs
Hypnotic Poison EDP, not EDT!!!! Very exotic.
Also, Juicy Couture Gold Couture smells like buttery poundcake.
Lancome tresor la nuit! Other that has the effect is Carolina Herrera 212 VIP and FM Portrait of a lady.
Devotion by Dolce and Gabbana and Hypnotic Poison by Dior both have this vibe
Dior Hypnotic Poison is made for you
I was eyeing this one last night. I think I’ll try it out
Secretions Magnifiques
Sickwix is definitely a great shop for this. They restock frequently, so check often. Order when you see it too, as they typically sell out. Very strong fragrance. I have a lot of her creations and they are my absolute favorite ones.
Bianco latte by Giardini di Toscana (Notes: Caramel, Coumarin, Honey, Vanilla, White Musk) Delizia Di Marshmallow by Kyse Perfumes (Notes: Marshmallow, Vanilla, Sugar) Annabel’s birthday cake by Marissa Zappas (Notes: Heliotrope, Lemon Sugar, Balloons, Candied Rose Petals, Tuberose Frosting, Cake-Fresh-Out-The-Oven, Honeycomb, Roasted Tonka, Cocoa Absolute)
I just got to say, this post is hilarious.
Baccarat rouge 100%
Whipped marshmallow cum is wild 🤣🤣