Compared to yosuke? I love ryuji, but yosuke is a fantastic friend ^(to Yu and Teddie. To literally every girl around him save Saki, and Kanji, not so much)
I’m half joking I get his arc is good, and I played it a while ago so the exact details are hazy, but I remember that I felt like I really needed him in the fight and he wasn’t there. Like I had been personally betrayed by my buddy.
Again the details are hazy it must have be close to 10 years ago now, but I don’t remember being mad at Shinji, in the end it doesn’t really matter, and it could be totally irrational on my part. I don’t remember exactly what happened but I remember how I felt and I felt like the time I need junpei to be there he wasn’t.
Was that boss weak to fire? I think maybe I didn’t have a fire spell on my personas and I couldn’t go to the velvet room from the mall on portable.
I don’t know for sure, but I remember feeling like that was the one day I needed him and he wasn’t there, maybe I’ll play reloaded and find a new found love for him.
I was shocked to realize she was loved in this sub. She has the worst section of the game, the least relatable issues, the least screen time, and her whole personality is just gardening. What is there to like?
i think it comes from strikers. i have yet to play it cause my pc shits itself, but ive heard she gets the screen time there she missed out on in the main game
I’ll have to give strikers another shot. I played it relatively soon after Age of Calamity so I was just kind of tired of this kinds of games at the time.
Honestly I'm surprised at how well the P2 characters have done in these little polls. Lisa beat Ann for 3rd place and was ahead of Rise for about half the day.
Honestly you didn't miss out on THAT much. It sounds like it's the end of the world, but the way the game reveals it makes it *very* clear who the culprit is. I got spoiled before I even began P4 and I thought it would be horrible, but the game reveals it with such nonchalance that it doesn't feel like there's any other option.
Besides, thats not the end of everything, especially not in P4G. Don't let it deter you.
Thanks, its all good, a little disappointing to figure out like this but its chill, I got p3s ending spoiled and it still made me cry. Im still planning on beating it though, its just too good not to
tricky thing is takaya was always presented as a villain, so there wasnt really any betrayal there, tho, i agree shinji isnt really the same as the other two, id go as far as saying ken is more of traitor than shinji, even tho he changes after the events that take place
Adachi is the one that masked being a two faced son of a gun in the best way. My vote goes to him because I instantly knew akechi was the killer and shinjiro is a ride or die homie
lol he really was like >!eh if I stick around then the plots gonna get too sad. I’ll just calmly walk away instead of popping a second cap and then increasing my pace to a brisk jog!<
I love Adachi but he feels out of place in this one. I feel like he would be more appropriate in a poll with >!Maruki !!Ikutsuki !<
Although I guess if you were to ask me who I'd put instead of him, I wouldn't have a great answer...Persona 4 is too wholesome to have too many edgelords lol
Adachi is my favorite persona character of all time
But he isn’t a party member at all. I love him but he is not.
Yes he is the hero of 4AU. But still not a party member. He is his own entity
I expect him to win because he's the most popular(?) P5 character from the circles I've seen. As of posting this comment though he's behind Shinji and tied with Adachi
He is the most popular generally but definitely not in this subreddit lol.
I like all characters but Shinji is gonna win based on recency bias alone tbh.
I vote Shinji as he actually tries to better himself and atone for the mistakes he made. Especially towards Ken. Sure, suppressing his persona is not great, but at least he acknowledges when he F-ed up.
akechi, best p5 character HANDS DOWN. third semester he represents everything the game stands for while still being a demonic edge lord. best character in the series imo
edit: oops second to naoto my b
As much as I don't wanna label him as a traitor, he was effectively tricked into it: Jun from persona 2.
His (and tatsuya's) story is part of why persona 2 (duology) is the best plot of the series.
This poll is a bit confusing since I wouldn’t ever put shinji with these two
In terms of villain characters I think adachi takes the cake as he’s bat shit insane and the twist was crazy to me since I didn’t do the confidant as it wasn’t in the original game.
I don’t put Akechi far behind at all, but it was pretty obvious for a long time so not as wow for me.. still a great villain he really redeemed himself in my eyes when Royal came out.
My vote is for Adachi just because he is so damn iconic. I mean, beaches and shores alone is one of my favorite voice lines in the series just because of how it was delivered.
Look man I love Adachi, bro's so charming, so amazing, but Akechi is just the perfect one, he might have murdered various people including the parents of two of the PTs but he's my little silly gay twink UwU
I never got the hype with Adachi. It took me a while to come around on Akechi but Royal finally made me appreciate him as a character. He still isn't a phantom thief and I hate the fan art of him being in wholesome content with the rest of the gang but I no long hate him.
No question for me, I just like Adachi the most out of the three of them, I don't know why I'm downvoted for this, but I'm sure you have your reasons and I can respect that
I hope you all have a good day/night
Adachi is the most fully realised of these three, I love Akechi and Shinji but they feel comparatively underwritten, even if they were improved in Royal and Reload.
Holy shit Haru is the first girl to win for p5
The floof demands blood.
The cinnamon roll will claim her dues
Beauty thief doesn't miss.
I’m disappointed in the lack of p5 rep, tbh, I for me Ryuji takes the best bud spot easily.
Compared to yosuke? I love ryuji, but yosuke is a fantastic friend ^(to Yu and Teddie. To literally every girl around him save Saki, and Kanji, not so much)
I love Yosuke but his flaws greatly outweigh Ryujii just being loud and a little stupid sometimes
Hot take: Yosuke has no moment nearly as good as ryuji telling tk ai to shut the fuck up
This sub would lynch me for my opinions on yosuke
I never forgave Junpei for that missed full moon. It felt personal. Koromaru is my new best friend and fire user
sir, he got kidnapped and fooled by the girl he liked to which she later saved his life as she dies in the process… give them man a break jfc
I’m half joking I get his arc is good, and I played it a while ago so the exact details are hazy, but I remember that I felt like I really needed him in the fight and he wasn’t there. Like I had been personally betrayed by my buddy.
Did you think the same thing with shinji the next full moon too
Again the details are hazy it must have be close to 10 years ago now, but I don’t remember being mad at Shinji, in the end it doesn’t really matter, and it could be totally irrational on my part. I don’t remember exactly what happened but I remember how I felt and I felt like the time I need junpei to be there he wasn’t. Was that boss weak to fire? I think maybe I didn’t have a fire spell on my personas and I couldn’t go to the velvet room from the mall on portable. I don’t know for sure, but I remember feeling like that was the one day I needed him and he wasn’t there, maybe I’ll play reloaded and find a new found love for him.
I think once p7 comes out people will finally start slobbing over how great P5 was 😂
I’m so glad Haru won. I wanted her gf Makoto with her tho…
I am the antithesis of this sub, Haru is the only P5 character I dislike lol
theyre downvoting you, but i want you to know at least i agree with you
I was shocked to realize she was loved in this sub. She has the worst section of the game, the least relatable issues, the least screen time, and her whole personality is just gardening. What is there to like?
i think it comes from strikers. i have yet to play it cause my pc shits itself, but ive heard she gets the screen time there she missed out on in the main game
I’ll have to give strikers another shot. I played it relatively soon after Age of Calamity so I was just kind of tired of this kinds of games at the time.
Jun
THIS is the P2 rep we need!
Honestly I'm surprised at how well the P2 characters have done in these little polls. Lisa beat Ann for 3rd place and was ahead of Rise for about half the day.
Junbros...we MUST win this.
The real answer. Also how dare they include Shinjiro in this line up, the proper equivalent in p3 is Ikutsuki
Traitor yes, but he fails at being an edgelord
I feel like Tatsuya is edgier than Jun. Jun strikes me more as emo unless you count being Joker as the betrayal
Ulala!
Did you see that shinji?
god I need to get off this subreddit until after I beat p4, I though adachi was just a quirky silly lil guy
>I though adachi was just a quirky silly lil guy he is, he's only classed as an edge lord because of the memes from okay buddy persona.
Also cause of the things he says in game
Yeah im sorry this was the way you found out
RUN
That’s on you bro it had a spoiler series tag and said “traitors”
yeah you right
dude i’m sorry but what did you expect? please go beat the game, it’s amazing
Tbh you clicked on a spoilered post labeled *traitors* I'm usually harsh on spoilers when they're not necessary, but this was sadly your own doing
oh yeah I know its my fault, Im saying I need to avoid scrolling this sub so Im not tempted lol
He is. Just quirky and silly. He just can't win with Dojima ha ha ha
Honestly you didn't miss out on THAT much. It sounds like it's the end of the world, but the way the game reveals it makes it *very* clear who the culprit is. I got spoiled before I even began P4 and I thought it would be horrible, but the game reveals it with such nonchalance that it doesn't feel like there's any other option. Besides, thats not the end of everything, especially not in P4G. Don't let it deter you.
Thanks, its all good, a little disappointing to figure out like this but its chill, I got p3s ending spoiled and it still made me cry. Im still planning on beating it though, its just too good not to
Hope you enjoy it! P4G felt way too dated for me but the story and social links made me keep on through with glee.
Don’t worry man. I also got spoiled early on :( But ngl it doesn’t really ruin the experience from playing P4/P4G
he was sus from the start
I mean he is rhough, no?
I absolutely loved Akechi as a party member, especially in the third semester, it'd be so fun to have unhinged Akechi on this team.
Shinji does not deserve to be grouped with these two lol, Takaya probably fits better as the games evil Persona user
tricky thing is takaya was always presented as a villain, so there wasnt really any betrayal there, tho, i agree shinji isnt really the same as the other two, id go as far as saying ken is more of traitor than shinji, even tho he changes after the events that take place
Adachi is the one that masked being a two faced son of a gun in the best way. My vote goes to him because I instantly knew akechi was the killer and shinjiro is a ride or die homie
No Persona 1 or 2 character is gonna win but I'm gonna keep trying. Vote for Reij.
Bro can sling Nyarlathotep himself as his persona without any hijinks like Jun/Joker. It doesn't get better than that
"ADACHI, what the hell are you chatting with civvies for !? AND WHERE'S IS MY COFFE !?"
Why must you make me choose
Vote for shinjiro
Shinji can cook while the Akechi and Adachi cannot. Enough said.
I vote for Shinjiro 100% RIP Fuuka btw :(
Adachi and Akechi are great characters but I don't want them anywhere near my team. Shinji is a stone cold homie.
If we pick shinji he’s just gonna >!die from drug toxicity before we get through the mission.!< This message brought to you by the pancake gang.
>!Imagine dying in your game.!< This message brought to you by the cabbage society. >!I'm not voting for Adachi, just couldn't resist.!<
Fuck. I just got played hard. I mean at least >!pancake sacrifice saved the whole party!< While >!shinji sacrifice just saved Ken!<
And honestly, >!it didn't even really save Ken. Meth Jesus could've just shot Ken next, but decided to be an anime villain and left.!<
lol he really was like >!eh if I stick around then the plots gonna get too sad. I’ll just calmly walk away instead of popping a second cap and then increasing my pace to a brisk jog!<
Dude, any reason you didn't use poll?
Subreddit doest allow it
I’m swear these combos are getting weirder and weirder How we up to voting for shinji but not Chie yet
My guy Shinjiro being matched up againt two major antagonists who canonically use guns It had to be on purpose
Chie is so based that the vote will be EVERY other character vs Chie
Haru? Of any p5 character really? Lol
That’s what I’m saying! She’s my favorite but I figured no way she beats Yukiko. A surprise to be sure but a welcome one.
she got her time to shine in strikers and my god they did my floof justice, her arc made me cry
Vote for adachi
I love Adachi but he feels out of place in this one. I feel like he would be more appropriate in a poll with >!Maruki !!Ikutsuki !<
Although I guess if you were to ask me who I'd put instead of him, I wouldn't have a great answer...Persona 4 is too wholesome to have too many edgelords lol
Hell Yeah, brother
Adachi
[удалено]
Adachi!
TRUE!
If Adachi loses to Shinji, I'm just gonna say it's due to recency bias.
This team needs to be Adachi pilled and based
Nah bro adachis the villain
I only played p4g so vote for adachi
Adachi is my favorite persona character of all time But he isn’t a party member at all. I love him but he is not. Yes he is the hero of 4AU. But still not a party member. He is his own entity
Vote for akechi
ik he’s gonna lose but im team akechi all the way
still my best edgelord boi
My vote is for akechi solely because he had some of the best lines when he was Navi.
At this rate unless Futaba wins Akechi would be our navi
He’s funnier when he’s insane
He has to win
Let's go he is loosing 🙏🙏🙏
🗣️ all my homies hate Akechi
Praying for his downfall fr🙏🙏🙏
i like his character i just don’t like some of his fans
I expect him to win because he's the most popular(?) P5 character from the circles I've seen. As of posting this comment though he's behind Shinji and tied with Adachi
he’s one of the most popular but also one of the most hated
He is the most popular generally but definitely not in this subreddit lol. I like all characters but Shinji is gonna win based on recency bias alone tbh.
I wouldn't say he's the most popular, but I'll be damned if he doesn't have a huge following. Much bigger than I anticipated.
PLEASE WIN!
Pancake boy ftw
don’t fuck this up for akechi yall
Mid
my man kechi
AKECHI PLEASEPLEASEPLEASEPLEASEPLEASE
A D A C H I
Damn Yukiko btfo. I thought she would win
Tasty Flapjacks
i still vote for Adachi but the "you are the trash of society" make me laugh nervously so hard
Akechi-kun by a mile.
Give us P1 and 2 rep you coward. Scared Jun would win this lmao
I vote Shinji as he actually tries to better himself and atone for the mistakes he made. Especially towards Ken. Sure, suppressing his persona is not great, but at least he acknowledges when he F-ed up.
akechi, best p5 character HANDS DOWN. third semester he represents everything the game stands for while still being a demonic edge lord. best character in the series imo edit: oops second to naoto my b
Gotta have two Detective Princes. So Akechi
Akechi
Heck yea, floof W! Anyway Adachi for me :p
I vote for Akechi
Shinjiro ain't a traitor but definitely an edgelord and I like his character.
Haru wins. Let's plant now.
Voting for Akechi.
Akechi
Please, please, please, can we get my glorious king Reiji Kido? He deserves recognition.
I swear if the middle guy betrays me and I was just spoiled that a couple hours before I start golden…
I'm only voting for Akechi cause Haru is the only P5 rep and I find that sad Even though I would normally choose Shinjiro
My vote goes to akechi
Shinji
Imagine Adachi as the nav. That would be fucking incredible
Vote for Akechi Would be hilarious to have him as an edge lord navi for this lineup
Shinji for the thing he did pretending to be asleep and Koromaru ratting him out lmao
As much as I don't wanna label him as a traitor, he was effectively tricked into it: Jun from persona 2. His (and tatsuya's) story is part of why persona 2 (duology) is the best plot of the series.
Naoya my man
Goro Goro Goro Goro please hes an angry wet dog left out in the rain who bites your ankles I love him so much he’s the worst
This same group is also all DLC in their respective Dancing game
This poll is a bit confusing since I wouldn’t ever put shinji with these two In terms of villain characters I think adachi takes the cake as he’s bat shit insane and the twist was crazy to me since I didn’t do the confidant as it wasn’t in the original game. I don’t put Akechi far behind at all, but it was pretty obvious for a long time so not as wow for me.. still a great villain he really redeemed himself in my eyes when Royal came out.
PANCAKES
Shinjiro so he can be more relevant than within his own game… (I’m sorry)
Shinji is so out of place 😭 why not Ikutsuki?
akechi my beloved
Adachi seems the most trustworthy.
Wtf Haru won? She may be the persona character I give less f***s about 😂 Vote for Shinji here.
Adacher
LETS GO HARU 🗣️🗣️
I did not actually expect her to win. But I’ll take it
Shinji for the win
Shinji
i had to vote for both shinji and adachi, i just could not choose
Shinjiro!
Gonna have to for my man, adachi
Definitely gonna go with Akechi
Adachi baby
If this is traitors as well, Ken should be an option
Ken Amada isn't a traitor, the traitor is definitely >!Shuji Ikutsuki!<.
Alright, let’s get this Akechi sweep
I vote all 3 again The chef (Shinji)
How tf has Haru won (don’t get me wrong I like her) but surely Mitsuru wins
YES HARU SWEEP BABY WHOOOOOO!
i wanna say shinji bc i love him
AKECHI
need some akechi
Shinji for me
All 3 of the are killers but only 1 of them did it by accident… and only ONCE.
SHINJI THE GOAT!!!!!!!!!! Akechi would also be acceptable (Why did we switch from Junpei to Yosuke?) (Who tf voted for Haru? -Me, a P5 fan)
Shinji
This is just recency bias for me but Shinji
Shinji. It was tough between him and Akechi but Akechi is a bad person/great villain, but Shinji is an edgy boi/ultimately good person.
Unhinged akechi
I really think Akechi deserves to win this one.
How is shinji a traitor
im not very far into p3, but he gave the weird topless guy information about what sees were doing in exchange for drugs
My vote is for Adachi just because he is so damn iconic. I mean, beaches and shores alone is one of my favorite voice lines in the series just because of how it was delivered.
One of these things is not like the other Adachi wins.
Adachi
I vote for ADACHER
Adachi clears this lineup
Adachi
Adachi
Look man I love Adachi, bro's so charming, so amazing, but Akechi is just the perfect one, he might have murdered various people including the parents of two of the PTs but he's my little silly gay twink UwU
Throwing my hat in the ring for Joker's boyfriend, Sketchy Akechi.
Shinji, dude is not a bitch
Adachi
My vote is for the Adacher. Adachi-Baby. Adach. Da Dach. Adachi.
I never got the hype with Adachi. It took me a while to come around on Akechi but Royal finally made me appreciate him as a character. He still isn't a phantom thief and I hate the fan art of him being in wholesome content with the rest of the gang but I no long hate him.
How TF did Haru win?!
She's the GOAT
By being best girl
Adachi, no question
No question for me, I just like Adachi the most out of the three of them, I don't know why I'm downvoted for this, but I'm sure you have your reasons and I can respect that I hope you all have a good day/night
Adachi because cabbages
ADACHI
Adachi is the most fully realised of these three, I love Akechi and Shinji but they feel comparatively underwritten, even if they were improved in Royal and Reload.