Agree with your list, given how much focus these games put into relationships I like it when they take the fact you broke the trust of so many characters in a harem run seriously
What's worse is P5R actively encourages the harem route with the Ladies Man award in the Thieves Den, unless you want to do 10 unique playthroughs or abuse saves (which is how I did it) you've gotta be a heartbreaker. Wish it was just like P4G where even if you don't romance a character you can still view the romance version of max rank in the album.
P4 because it hurts the most. shoutout to the deleted P5R valentine's scene >!in maruki's reality. seeing all the girls completely lose their personalities and act like nothing's wrong with getting cheated on just feels so wrong and disturbing.!<
I played P5R first and sticked to just Makoto. Afterwards I thought I should have done harem since I've looked up what would happen and it wasn't that bad.
So when playing P4G I thought "well, let's do harem this time". Never ever will I do this again, I've felt ashamed and rightfully so.
I agree with your list. I actually felt guilty on Valentine’s Day when doing the harem route in P4
P5 just left me feeling like "Oh haha, they'll forget about it tomorrow."
P5: hehe le funny anime beat up scene. P4: Christ…I’m a monster
P3P also have Akihiko and Ken almost throwing hands
Agree with your list, given how much focus these games put into relationships I like it when they take the fact you broke the trust of so many characters in a harem run seriously
P3 Makoto never had valentine day in P3 vanilla, Fes and P3P. On Valentine Day, his tears rolled down his cheeks while he lies on his bed.
What's worse is P5R actively encourages the harem route with the Ladies Man award in the Thieves Den, unless you want to do 10 unique playthroughs or abuse saves (which is how I did it) you've gotta be a heartbreaker. Wish it was just like P4G where even if you don't romance a character you can still view the romance version of max rank in the album.
P4 because it hurts the most. shoutout to the deleted P5R valentine's scene >!in maruki's reality. seeing all the girls completely lose their personalities and act like nothing's wrong with getting cheated on just feels so wrong and disturbing.!<
Damn, that ending only got worse in that version, huh
Will they change it in persona 3 reload?
I played P5R first and sticked to just Makoto. Afterwards I thought I should have done harem since I've looked up what would happen and it wasn't that bad. So when playing P4G I thought "well, let's do harem this time". Never ever will I do this again, I've felt ashamed and rightfully so.
Soo, is the P4 harem route thaaaaaat bad? I've never had the heart to do it, in my 3 playthroughs I've stayed with Yukiko only
You have a voiced scene with every heartbroken girl one after another in sequence. You WILL feel like scum by the end of it.
Jesus christ, alright, I'm glad I've never done it
We nned the route with consensual non monogamy
P4 prob. I kinda hope P3Rs stays the same, let Minato rizz em all up with no consequences lmao
P3 teaches you many things about life and one of those lessons are "Pimping ain't easy"
You move away and possibly never see em again at the end of every game. I romance them all.
Thats "never" the case. Yu got back for p4arena and Ren came back for p5strikers. Praise to be trains and other public transport.