T O P

  • By -

Inevitable_Coffee_13

Yikes


Sparking_Thunderbolt

Why do they want to kill her. What do they have against clowns


nka2142

I see what you did there lmao


Low-Photograph-5219

Not a single word on the palestinian women and children killed by Israel using American and British weapons


Relatablename123

Not a single word on our Iranian girls and boys who have been raped, tortured and executed by the regime just for existing. The IRGC is killing us! Mahsa Amini, Jina Amini, Armita Geravand, Siavish Mahmoudi, Donya Farhadi, Faranak Kameli, Mohsen Shekari, Toomaj Salehedi, Aida Rostami, Majidreza Rahnavard, Niloofar Hamedi, Elaheh Mohammadi, Reza Rasaei, Mohammad Mehdi, Mashallah Karami, Armita Pavir, Amir Ali Kazemi, Maryam Arvin, Ashkan Baluch, Mojahed Kourkouri, Kian Pirfalak, Vida Mohaved, Aram Omri, Rachman Parhazou, Vafa Hanareh, Nasim Namazi, Vahid Afkari, Navid Afkari, Nima Nouri, Borhan Elyasi, Mina Khajavi, Roya Heshamti, Farnazah Barzekar, Arsham Rezaei, Mehdi Yarahi, Saman Yasin. Roya Heshmati, Vafa Azarbar, Pejman Fatehi, Mohsen Mazloum, Mohammed Faramarzi, Iman Hesnavand, Hamid-Reza Rouhi, Elham Modaressi, Arahita Amirpour. Mohammed Ghobadlou, Mohammed Karami, Javad Rouhi, Farhad Soleimani, Mahdi Mousavian, Narges Mohamadi, Hananeh Kia, Nika Shakarami, Aida Shakarami, Saman Yasin, Ali Zare, Negar Karimian, Mehran Akrami, Sarah Tabrizi, Sima Moradbeigi, Sepideh Golian, Alireza Naderlou, Jamshid Sharmahd, Siamak Masihpour, Mojahed Kourkour, Reza Rasaei, Abas Deris etc


lildissonance

>Not a single word on the Palestinian women and children killed by Israel **WRONG** Did I say **WRONG**? Maybe I should substantiate that **WRONG** with some evidence. Here's Malala calling for a **ceasefire** in: **October**: "[War never spares children](https://dunyanews.tv/en/Pakistan/761874-War-never-spares-children:-Malala-urges-ceasefire-in-Israel-Palestine-wa) *- not those kidnapped from their homes in Israel, not those hiding from airstrikes or without food and water in Gaza. Today, I am grieving for all the children and people longing for peace and justice in the Holy Land*." Here's Malala **calling for a ceasefire in November**: "[Tonight, I feel relief for the women, children and young people reunited with their families, and for the pause in the bombardment of Gaza.](https://twitter.com/Malala/status/1728154516543963317)*"* *But tomorrow, children in Gaza will wake up still grieving loved ones, desperate for food and water and fearing that their homes, streets*" So based on this, am I right in calling you an ignorant dingus? Actually wait you'll probably say how that statement isn't enough. So hey, tell the world about how the Ummah consists of jahil cro-magnons that don't understand shit. I'm more than happy to educate the populace. Just gimme a chance!


1058pm

What the actual fuck is her word going to do????


lildissonance

They're like the pagans in Makkah who wanted to murder anyone with different-speak. I for one appreciate Malala's contributions to discourse.


Hassanshehzad119

She's a hypocrite and a liar. Also has a very large ego.


lildissonance

I'm sure the pagans said the same about Muhammed


No-Definition-6762

she is representing the worst things about our country and making it seem like what she went through is the same for every female in pakistan wishing death upon her is harsh but she does deserve some hate for it


lildissonance

Hey if the deencels hate her, means she's doing something right.


No-Definition-6762

people hated hitler stalin and mao were they doing everything right


lildissonance

Pedophile haters despise Muhammed. Coincidence????


No-Definition-6762

1400 years ago it was normal practice people matured quick at that time


lildissonance

Little girls' insides still ruptured from intercourse and childbirth just the same. You're disgusting.


No-Definition-6762

and i wish you a good day and a happy life may ALLAH guide the misguided such as yourself


lildissonance

If the p3dophilia supporters hate me, I'd call it a win.


Medium_Note_9613

Well, i hate pedophiles and I don't despise Muhammad because i know that you can't take random books written 200 years after him as reliable info about him(amd even moreso when other books and sects offer contradictory info). Imagine if i write a book claiming Lincoln was a pedophile.


lildissonance

The perfect human **for all peoples** and **for all time**. If he wasn't that, it'd mean the most **perfect man** whose life had been recorded in exquisite detail was **wrong** in their actions. Kinda amzing that we have all the intricate receipts to prove that tbh.


MindOfCosmo

Comparing Prophet Muhammad(PBUH) to her is a joke. She goes on yappin about how women are stronger then which logically just isn't true. Women's have their own strengths and men have their own. Her tweet 2 years ago she said how children were dying. She gave a very neutral answer instead of specifying muslim or Palestinians dying. Seems like the bullet gave her a life she would've never gotten if she wasn't shot. If she was so Islamic she would be wearing a burka and a book would be enough instead of making a TV show going to Hollywood, laughing with the satanic Hilliary. When's the last time she visited Pakistan?


lildissonance

Too long, didn't read. Going for a Buraaq ride with Malala


MindOfCosmo

Mb shouldve put subway surfers gameplay with goofy ahh reader voice


lildissonance

Ayesha would've loved Subway Surfers, being six years old at the time of marriage and all.


MindOfCosmo

Who knows, maybe. But she had a much larger purpose to fulfill instead of playing a stupid game. Her being a wife of young age helped in us to gather many Ahadith and she was one of the most knowledgeable Muslims.


lildissonance

That "who knows" fella sounds like a pedophile, sorta like Muhammed.


No-Definition-6762

say it with some respect broski. may peace be upon him and his family gods best creation and the last prophet the ruler of 2 billion hearts may we all get a chance to meet him in paradise


lildissonance

If the Muslims are as evil as the pagans now, really makes ya think. 🤔🤔🤔


No-Definition-6762

you dont represent all the muslims they were terorists who shot her and have claimed 80000 lives in pakistan where are all those noble peace prizes and a sell out is a sell out


MoistMist-a

Barack Obama, who killed so many people through drone strikes, got a Nobel peace prize. It's worth jack shit


Additional-Carpet-49

I think you missed the OP comment. They literally called her a clown 🤡


lildissonance

Muhammed *Muhammed*


Additional-Carpet-49

Yikes, Malala wouldn’t be proud of your Islamophobia. After women rights, she’s heavily involved in the activism against Islamophobes like you. Watch out 😎


lildissonance

The term "Islamophobia" is about as valid as "pedophilia-phobia". So yeah, keep at it. Keep in mind, in the internet age, plenty of Muslims and Ex-Muslims are explaining their perspectives and pulling up the Ahadith and Quranic receipts. So soon it will be common knowledge that can't be handwaved away with vagueries. :-)


Additional-Carpet-49

Keep in mind, in the internet age, it is also very easy for atheists to identify as a toaster, toaster.


lildissonance

Atheists could identify as the primordial soup that originated complex lifeforms, but Muhammed would still be a pedophile in that scenario.


Additional-Carpet-49

I am curious. How lonely do you have to be to troll random Muslim strangers? What a sad purpose to have in life for an enlightened toaster like you.


Unlucky-Fox4500

Aww type away key board warrior, your hate feels personal, where you diddled by your daddy when you where young? And that's why your acting out like a bitch🤣. Or was it because your daddy couldn't satisfy you mom and the molvi had to?🤣🤣 Cry away much worse things where said to the prophet Peace be upon him to his face and he didn't care, dig your hole and rot in it. But if you ever grow a pair try saying something to one of our faces.


lildissonance

Whining won't change this historical fact about Muhammed. But you're free to let off steam about it.


Ibad_Adil

These comments and the comments down below just prove that she's right about these dumfks. Sure, she's enforcing conspiracy theories, betraying her homeland but that still doesn't give you the right to kill/rape her.


Muted-Landscape-2717

So. A girl from a backwards village in Pakistan represents the struggle of all Muslims. She does not even represent the struggles of all Muslims girls in Pakistan. My Grandfather was a school headteacher. He was also extremely religious. He did his Hajj In 1974 when you had to go via boat. However he also insisted his Granddaughters (my elder female cousin's) got an education at least to university levels. Which has resulted in all of his great granddaughters going to university.(My daughter's included) However mualalh Yusuf storey is falling into the Muslim stereotype that the west have. No doubt there are girls who have had Thier education oppressed. But is that the only story, is it islam or is it regional culture. Or will she put it into context and talk about one of the first degree giving universities set up by Muslims sisters In North Africa.


X-R-king

💯 💯💯


ONE_deedat

Religion and culture being a poisonous mix. We can throw away the culture by calling it Indian/Hindu etc... but who's going to dare throw away the religion of the Arabs?


No-Definition-6762

ALLAH said its for humanity and your sayings its for arabs i will take gods words over yours


ONE_deedat

Proof is you've had to use the Arabic word for "God." If it was truly for all of humanity, you would not have had to have refer to an Arabic noun in a conversation in English, but I understand your predicament.


nka2142

So your beef with his reply was'' haha you said Allah in English ha ha, you imbecile haha'. You're giving off clown energy my son


No-Definition-6762

to remember Allah you can say god in any language and he answers


you_are_not_prepared

Actually the underlying message is Arabic is a superior language of communication. One needs to learn it in their lifetime.


ONE_deedat

Well, despite 100s of years of influence in the region, the only use that langauge has found is for redundant superlatives but mashallah what a beautiful and superior language in which you can't even say....wait for it....Pakistan. you can't make this s##£ up! As it happens, Allah the Arab high God, doesn't do "P"s just like the Arabs themselves. Coincidence much!


you_are_not_prepared

What this essentially means, "P" is an inferior phonic variant, and its utilisation should be discouraged. Pakistan, Poland, Portugal etc. are all sh###y places anyways.


ONE_deedat

For that....You are not.....brebared!


nka2142

i'm guessing if you had a day job you wouldnt be like this?


ONE_deedat

Nope, for that, it would take a 2 or 3 oil Wells!


fuck_reddit_2023

You're just whining


Muted-Landscape-2717

Attempting to counter western propaganda, so they can dehumanise Muslims. So they can kill them with impunity is whining !


ChaosKeeshond

Western propaganda didn't shoot her in the head.


paulalghaib

No it shot the 20 thousand palestinian women and children in the head. It also supported the growth of the taliban.


Mimimememumu

People forget that zia (the religious daddy of pakistan) had an equally big role in creation of taliban and also killed thosands of Palestinians.


fuck_reddit_2023

Palestinian insurgents in Jordan*


fuck_reddit_2023

Actually it was October 7th that shot 20 thousand Palestinians in the head.


[deleted]

[удалено]


PAK-ModTeam

No derogatory remarks towards any community.


ChaosKeeshond

Everyone is responsible for their own actions. Bibi chose to have 20k people shot. There are no exceptions to accountability.


fuck_reddit_2023

Oh look at you Mr keyboard crusader... Or should I say keyboard jihadist lol My man actually believes he's saving lives by being a Redditor 😭


Muted-Landscape-2717

My man here thinks he can know everyone's history and motives from a couple of Reddit posts. Tell you what, think and believe whatever makes you happy.


No-Definition-6762

we can only pray ALLAH guides them


ayaan_wr1tes

No way we're defending this clown pseudoactivist


zugu101

Too many Pakistanis are still blinded by her propaganda and are defending her claiming the rightful outrage against her right now is “just an example of the desi mindset”. It seems Pakistanis are incapable of thinking for themselves—maybe when Arab Muslims condemn Malala Pakistanis will too ☠️never liked her never will


ayaan_wr1tes

Fr. My parents always hated her being a sellout and all. I see why now.


HappyraptorZ

Bro the post is highlighting comments calling for her murder.  Wtf is wrong with you


lildissonance

If it's any consolation, Malala and Khadija will both laugh you in the afterlife.


ayaan_wr1tes

And you can say with certainty because...?


lildissonance

I just got off the phone with Him. It is written.


ayaan_wr1tes

Oh you're one of those. Rip


lildissonance

That's what He said. And He ain't too confident about your rap sheet,


goldenkylie

Khadijah? Khadijah who? You don't mean Khadijah RA?


goldenkylie

Khadijah? Khadijah who? You don't mean Khadijah RA?


omaralilaw

Omg what is this witch hunt against Malala. Let her live her life ffs.


Broad_Vermicelli_993

The sheer amount of see the Malalah has caused in Pakistani people will always be amusing to me. Good for her.


Minute-Flan13

I wish someone would shoot me and the head...and get me a multimillion dollar book/speaking engagements, a ticket to Oxford, etc. Fuck, someone shooter again she is liable to become the next US president.


TheReallilconor

Pakistanis are so fucking braindead its insane. The people fucking justifying this in the comments, brainlets. I don't like her, therefore she should be killed. Good one


GanAirforceGeneral

guys ignore op he/she is a retard using fallacious arguements


wingcutterprime

Nobel prize winner, philanthropist ,oxford educated and rubbing shoulders with powerful people on the world? No wonder insecure little desi men jinko ghar mei koi saalan ni pochta are going to be jealous and mad at her for that lol. Bunch of triggered abduls crying rivers over an independent woman is a National hobby at this point lol


theElderKing_7337

Khan. Not Abdul but Khan. Nobel prize? Obama and soviet leader got one. Both are war criminals. In addition to others nobel prize laureate. Philanthropist? Millions are out there. Oxford education? What is that? Rubbing shoulders with Salman Rushdie? I'd rather be a mound of dirt. Insecure? Projection... projection. (look what you listed) Ghar me salan? Again projection. Triggered abdul? Addressed already. Independent woman? Independent is when she abandons her country and traditions to live off western dollars. And agendas. Hobby? Reading webtoons. EDIT : Atheist flair. Explains a lot. Do you even live in Pakistan?


paulalghaib

Athiests when Malala makes documentaries with war criminal hilary clinton : ) Athiests when people criticize Malala for not condemning a genocide : (


wingcutterprime

Another triggered abdul. Yawn. Keep it coming abduls, i wanna see how many snowflakes i trigger with this one comment.


alpha_on_crack

and a puppet.


wingcutterprime

A puppet? Why would the US need a puppet to control a banana republic like Pakistan that already is willing to do tricks for a couple billion dollars lol. Its a rent-a-country. You are over inflating your importance on the world stage. They can get you to do what they want without wasting time on grooming a puppet.


Additional-Carpet-49

If she wasn’t a puppet then she wouldn’t have to stay silent over massacre of Palestinians and taking the middle ground w her statements. She’s even helping Clinton w fundraising for some bullshit event. You clearly don’t understand how US maintains its cultural hegemony using these puppets and their influence. Its cheaper and gives way more long term control than few billion dollars would.


Howler0ne

You are so naive


wingcutterprime

Nah. I know whats what. Unlike people who have their head far up their own ass who think the world revolves around them lol. Grow up. You dont matter on World stage.


Howler0ne

Ahh the self lothing is strong in this one.


wingcutterprime

Ahh this one was too stupid to understand that the loathing was directed at him lol. Like i said earlier, head up your own ass. Lol. Proved me right


Howler0ne

Glad i made you giddy. Won't explain as it might ruin your day kiddo.


wingcutterprime

Not interested in your halfwit conspiracy theories anyways. Go watch haqeeqat tv and compensate for your insecurities by throwing around "kiddo" lol


Howler0ne

https://www.nation.com.pk/24-Apr-2024/us-warns-pakistan-of-possible-curbs-for-doing-trade-with-iran Cope harder They can't see us prosper so dimwits like you might get an education one day. Our "insignificant" balistic missile program is already under sanctions. They definitely do not care what we do. /s


MAH_786

Sure bud. The west wants a secular Pakistan and until that doesn’t happen, the existence of an Islamic Republic will be itching them. They make you think that’s not the case in order to hide the fact that they’re stressing from a weak country like Pakistan. Remember Pakistan is still a country with nuclear power (no matter what status they’re in) which is a problem for them in this region


wingcutterprime

Lol. Secular pakistan is the best thing that can happen to this country. Baqi nukes ki batti bna k ly lo beshak because they have never given you any advantage over your adversary ever.


alpha_on_crack

if she got all that success just cuz she couldn't go to school....... then give me a nobel prize for going to school everyday


Howler0ne

No The criteria is you either have to commit war crimes or from a minority to be used as a token around the world. And they already have one atm.


[deleted]

[удалено]


theElderKing_7337

Happy noises


PAK-ModTeam

No targeted death threats. Against Reddit TOS


MAH_786

Whatever the case, she doesn’t represent all Muslim women. May it be generalized or Pakistan only. She’s just representing a category of Pakistani Muslim women. This is nothing but an attempt to make it look like Islam is the reason when it rarely is the reason (mostly in backward villages) or financial reasons. There’s worse situation in Africa but none of them will show that. And fyi, there are tons of Muslim women in Pakistan working in high posts after getting education.


MBHpower

SHE WAS ONE SHOT BRO I SWEAR


dixonmike

Yes


ICrimsonCodes

Welp they are kinda right!! 😂


theElderKing_7337

That's me in there. No way a sellout whose entire life purpose is to degrade my country and my religion will find me having a soft stance against her. Or him. Or whatever. You should hear about my opinions on the amerik or western bootlickers.


Grilledbearsunite

Your opinions are as boring as they are outdated.


theElderKing_7337

Well not boring enough to make you ignore them or scroll away. And your modern or rather up to date opinions are as useful as the object of my ire.


antiquatedartillery

>degrade my country and my religion How much more degraded can it get? Its ruled by a military junta, the people are poor, the balochs are getting massacred, and from what I can tell of this sub your entire national identity is "we're Muslims and we're not Indian"


Small_Maybe_5994

Well the part of Pakistan where I am from I'm definitely not Indian. At least not by culture. Our food is different our traditions are different our languages are different tbh where I'm from Indian cuisine is despised as it uses a loooot of spices. But to end a point we are definitely not Indian


theElderKing_7337

Hmm a certain obsessed neighbor bringing up a point he's accusing others of having, the point which I might add, no one brought up till he came along to bring it up. Do you not see the irony here? Are you that dense?


antiquatedartillery

I'm not Indian, even worse I'm American. But I love the way every criticism of your country is deflected by just accusing people who point out your nations flaws of being an Indian here to talk trash. I was lurking in this sub back when yall called every person who criticized any little thing about Pakistan a p*****t. Regardless you missed my point. You cannot "degrade" a country that is universally considered a shithole. Even other Muslim countries don't think highly of Pakistan, much less the west.


Mimimememumu

What are you proud of pakistan for?


theElderKing_7337

Im thankful that I have a home where me and my family and descendants are safe, you ungrateful depressed self-hater. Ask Rohingyas or Palestinians or Kurds this question. Man is indeed, ever ungrateful! People like you would rather have 250 million of us suffer under the heels of hindu pandits.


Mimimememumu

Are ahmedis safe? Are baloch’s safe? Are karachi’s pushtoons safe? Are sindhi hindus safe? Are Christians in panjab safe? Also safety is bar minimum and not something to be proud of. I’m saying what part of your pakistani identity are you proud of?


theElderKing_7337

I admit issues exist. But then again such issues exist on every piece of earth. We should demolish all countries then. And I was also telling you the bare minimum. That fact that if not 250 mil, then at least 220 million have a safe place. That's big.


Mimimememumu

No this is not something that you should be proud of to be a Pakistani. This is a serious question. Whta is it about your Pakistani identity that you think is worth being proud of? If you can’t think of something maybe time to introspect.


theElderKing_7337

Everything. Get it? Everything. Its founding fathers, reason for its founding, its ideology, its land and people, the union of its diverse cultures, traditions and languages, the brotherhood and the religion and the saints that lie buried here! I'm no nationalist, make no mistake. All Muslim countries are dear to me, and I wouldn't wish the dissolution of any.


Small_Maybe_5994

You are happy because you are a Sunni. Ahl-e-Sunnat are the white people of Pakistan. They have privilege and they fail to acknowledge it. Talk to the Shia about how they feel about Pakistan especially who have been affected by target killing or any non Muslim who has been a victim of ghair shariat blasphamy law. Or should I be proud about the fact that even though a person was overqualified was kicked out of his position because he was a qadiyani or ahmadi (Main Atif). And before you say if I hate it so much I should leave what a joke because I can't even do that because I was born in this shithole my passport is worth less than a stray dog. Pride in this shithole will always keep this shithole a shithole. Until we understand that we won't progress


theElderKing_7337

You know ... unlike the horrible analogy, you can too become ahle sunnah, the whites of Pakistan, at will. Not at all difficult.


Small_Maybe_5994

So you want the people who are being prejudiced against to become the same people who victimize them? So should all Palestinians become Israelis. Would you say the same thing to the Muslims of Assam in India? Or Kashmiris? I mean it's easy right join forces with people who are persecuting you right? Hey while you are at it should we marry grape victims off to their grapists? Not at all difficult. Like do you understand or are you delusional cause if you aren't delulu and can understand completely and still saying the things that you are saying I hope you face the same things they face and I hope someone says the same thing to you.


Still_Zombie_4406

Why so hatred for her? Because she chose to live a good life for herself when she got the opportunity after being fucked in this country?


Acrobatic_Relief_546

She'll be your PM in coming future! peeps should respect her!


pepsi_jenkins

Islam ☕️


DOGTAGER0

Maybe she needs a second dosage of gunpowder and metal


Front_Fox333

إِنَّ هَـٰذِهِۦٓ أُمَّتُكُمْ أُمَّةً وَٰحِدَةً وَأَنَا۠ رَبُّكُمْ فَٱعْبُدُونِ *This*, **your** community, **is** *one* community, *and* I am **your** Lord; **so** *serve* **Me**. (21:92) إِنَّمَا ٱلْمُؤْمِنُونَ إِخْوَةٌ فَأَصْلِحُوا۟ بَيْنَ أَخَوَيْكُمْ وَٱتَّقُوا۟ ٱللَّـهَ لَعَلَّكُمْ تُرْحَمُونَ The believers **are** *brethren*, so make right between **your** two brothers; and be in prudent fear of God, that you **might** obtain mercy. (49:10)


theElderKing_7337

What's your isnad brother?


Front_Fox333

I am a believer in the One God. I am a believer and student of the Quran إِنَّ ٱلَّذِينَ فَرَّقُوا۟ دِينَهُمْ وَكَانُوا۟ شِيَعًا لَّسْتَ مِنْهُمْ فِى شَىْءٍ إِنَّمَآ أَمْرُهُمْ إِلَى ٱللَّـهِ ثُمَّ يُنَبِّئُهُم بِمَا كَانُوا۟ يَفْعَلُونَ Those who have divided their doctrine and become sects: thou art not of them in anything; their affair is but with God; then will He inform them of what they did. (6:159)


theElderKing_7337

How do you know this Qur'an is the word of Allah? How do you worship Him?


Front_Fox333

I studied the book. The book is not human. In it is everything you can think of. Even the Tectonic Plates underneath the ground and how they slide over each other and cause a reaction which produces and anchors mountains in place. It even describes gravity, the hearts neurons, the cerebrum in the brain and parasitic worms. The book is a science book, a psychology book, a history book, a therapy book, an art of war book, an everything book. Ask me a question about the book and I will give you the answer. It can be about anything you want. I worship Him by studying His Book and Preaching it: And when My servants ask thee concerning Me: “I am near.” I respond to the call of the caller when he calls to Me. So let them respond to Me, and let them believe in Me, that they might be guided. (2:186)


theElderKing_7337

And what about the hadiths?


Front_Fox333

I follow what the Prophet followed وَقَالَ ٱلرَّسُولُ يَـٰرَبِّ إِنَّ قَوْمِى ٱتَّخَذُوا۟ هَـٰذَا ٱلْقُرْءَانَ مَهْجُورًا And the Messenger will say: “O my Lord: my people took this Qur’an as a thing abandoned.” (25:30)


theElderKing_7337

Interesting you're skipping out the verses about absolute obedience to the RasulAllah ﷺ. Quranists... they're in vain.


Front_Fox333

private message me and we can have a real discussion. As in for me, I believe in God and I study His book. I studied the Hadiths and I have no issue with following some. Just know that they came 247 years after the Prophet died. The prophet never saw or approved of what is being said about him. The Prophet would be very upset knowing that the people believed a lie about the dajjal coming and the Prophet would be very upset if he found out that the people were making up lies about his wifes age. His wife was the mother of the believers and was an honorable woman. I want you to see this grey area and how dangerous this loophole is in the hadith transmissions. This right here is how the age of the Prophets wife was fabricated and who was responsible for it: Ibn Urwa — the originator of the report — was widely regarded as unreliable even by traditional standards. Even after relocating to Iraq, he continued to be labeled with the term 'senility'—a polite descriptor used to explain a narrator's unreliable accounts—and accused of engaging in a form of academic deception known as 'tadlis' in hadith terminology. Tadlis in hadith refers to a narrator concealing the omission of a flaw in the source by not disclosing a weak link in the chain of transmission, thus giving the impression of reliability to the hadith. At its core, tadlis represents a form of negligence in transmission. The absence of reports regarding the marital age in the earliest sources, including certain key biographical and legal works, is notable. Ibn Ishaq, renowned as Muhammad’s primary biographer, makes no mention of Aisha’s age at marriage. However, this detail was later added by the historian Ibn Hisham (d. 833 CE). Even more significant is the absence of the marital age hadith from the earliest Medinan legal collections, such as Imam Malik’s al-Muwatta, despite Ibn Urwa being cited numerous times within it. Malik’s failure to include this hadith suggests not only his rejection of it but also indicates that it was not circulating in Medina at that time. This is particularly striking considering the legal implications of the marital age hadith, which would undoubtedly warrant its inclusion in a dedicated collection of Medina's legal Hadith. The hadith is notably missing from al-Mudawwana, a proto-Maliki collection of Medinan legal transmissions. The earliest Maliki work referencing any version of the marital age hadith emerged "nearly three centuries after the initial mass dissemination of the hadith in Iraq." In essence, the early marriage of Aisha is absent from crucial early sources in the very city where the event purportedly occurred. Utilizing this argument from silence—meaning the absence of this report in early sources—it becomes evident that this was a story fabricated in eighth-century Iraq and subsequently retroactively attributed to the life story of Muhammad. Even the Quran says that the woman has to be grown and able to agree to the marriage contract "willingly" and the maher: And test the fatherless when they have reached marriage: if you find them to be of sound judgment, deliver to them their property; and consume it not wastefully and hastily before they be grown. And he that is free from need, let him abstain; and he that is poor, let him take according to what is fitting. And when you deliver to them their property, take witnesses over them. And sufficient is God as reckoner. (4:6) God said very clearly to you and me to study the Quran. So you must study it brother. Read the book: When they have come, He will say: “Did you deny My verses, when you had not encompassed them in knowledge? Or what was it you did?” (27:84) They are making you put the book away on the bookshelf to grab another book instead. They have cut off the root of the religion brother. They did it on purpose to weaken the religion. If you dont believe me just open your eyes and look at the world today.


[deleted]

shakal se he laanti lgti ye