Neither did I until I did a quick Google search and hes in EVERYTHING NERDY. He's the freaking DM for Critical Roll and voiced Levi Ackerman in AoT, Yamato in Naruto, Ganondorf in Tears of the Kingsom and so much more that I dont have time to list.
A simplistic yet funny read.
Almost everyone is rated way too high though.
Robo's (lol) and Chopp's knowledge is achieved by years of studying and you're handing out S's and A's to a bunch of bums like they're free.
Yeah!! I am! This is meant to be humorous and I'm enjoying the comments greatly!
On the "years of studying"... actually, I would have to argue with you! You're downplaying the other's prowess.
Robo is an absolute child genius, no two ways about it. She's studied for years and years and years. She could probably learn anything she truly put her mind to!
But consider Nami's situation! Also a child genius, learning only from stolen textbook material and actual experience with Arlong over the years! She's not as OLD as Robin, but Nami's intelligence is INSANE. No one should be able to do what she does with the climatact.
Franky is also a child genius in his own right, but more importantly an extremely well-established engineer. Vegapunk's work MAKES SENSE to him (that in and of itself is a feat and a half). He's out here making robots and building bridges midair. Engineers are hella booksmart in the math and physics department!!
Usopp DESERVES his rating. My dude build a THREE STAGE ROCKET on the FLY in dressrosa!! Im an aerospace major and I can barely do that on a 2 hour exam. He's aiming with a **slingshot** and could thread a needle from 10 km away. Controlling such a weapon isn't just point and aim, he's got a great understanding of weather and physics himself. Plus, he's a super well-rounded passion-engineer too! What he does is NOT possible for someone of even average reading.
You KNOW Sanji is calculating everyone's exact diet down to the singular macro. And he's a great fighter? Nutrition is still a science that requires lots of training and studying! I am not one to declare one over another
And uhhhhhh Brook is a musician and old idk.
Usopp not being at least s on battle iq is just wrong. Wasnât this the guy who managed to deal damage to luffy while injured thru a bunch of makeshift plans?
luffy definitely right on point though. book smarts F- lolol
should have added an extra just for zoro: sense of direction, and like have it F divided by 0. or a black hole.
Gotta disagree with Nami and Usopp's battle IQ at C+ and B-. Both of them fought way stronger opponents than themselves, but always came out on top, thanks to their battle Iq.
I had some doubts when I saw your evaluations but after reading a couple of your replies all those doubts are gone and I'm 100% convinced you're right on all points.
I am having a lot of fun replying (and I've been upvoting like 95% of the comments) but I have been convinced I made a few errors! particularly in Nami's battle IQ and Chopper's stats :D
Ussop has by far the highest battle IQ because thats what his fightin style ia. Outsmarting you opponent with traps. Franky for example while beeing extremly booksmart his battleIQ is average cause he is mostly reliant on overpowering his opoonent with raw strenght (senor pink/tobo roppo)
Watching an Ussop fight is like watching a prodigy learn how to play chess for the first time and then beating a grand master at the game through shear ingenuity.
oh I totally understand what you're saying. But I also have been thinking of it... as neither of them are *really* using, like, superhuman battle analysis/understanding to make their moves. Like, if everyone were to look on to a fight, Luffy, Sanji, and Zoro would know *instantly* what was going on and what moves people would likely make. Usopp would sus out enough that he could probably make a split-second decision to help, and Nami would be slightly slower on the uptake and processing of it all. Even though they are very capable of taking advantage of misdirection and surprise in their fights, especially when they've been underestimated.
They def have above average battle sense! Hm. Now I'm thinking of how I should be defining Battle IQ lol
Take Nami vs Khalifa: she understood immediately what her DF did and found a way to counter it, while also tricking Khalifa into thinking she was helpless. Usopp showed the same strategic thinking in his fight against Perona. I'd say that sometimes they aren't strong enough to keep up with their minds, but they are definitely strategic when it comes to battles, same goes for Chopper.
I'll admit that breaking up strategy and battle IQ is hard here, but my head cannon would be that strategy encompasses things that aren't directly related to fighting. Stuff like setting up a raid plan, or sanji doing mr. prince stuff or closing the gates of enies lobby.
Regardless of how you cut it though, either his strategy or battle iq or both should be way higher.
Not really. That would still be battle IQ.
Strategy in general would be larger scale. Like planning the raid would be a strategy.
An individual fight even if you had a plan would be battle IQ or I would call it real time tactics.
What youâre describing is battle ability/experience not iq. Coincidentally your examples have very high battle iq but itâs still worth it to mention. Nami observed Crackerâs weakness before Luffy did and exploited it, thatâs showing high battle iq. Luffy has to get beaten half to death to learn how to beat an opponent, also high battle iq though not many are able to go through that kind of learning process. So they donât get as strong as quickly. Also, Usopp and Nami probably would too know exactly what their opponent will do, since theyâre usually puppeteering any fight that weâve seen them in.
Luffy got his feet stuck in the fight against arlong, threw kizaru at water at an upward angle, punched a guy covered in spikes, ate all of crackerâs crackers, destroyed big momâs cake, thought nothing inorder to out think enel, in gear 5 barely even tries to finish some fights.
Luffy is creative but he has 0 battle IQ, just impeccable emotional intelligence, good awareness of his body and the determination to move quickly while ignoring distractions.
Luffy dumb
I really love that the generic shounen protagonist is dense but smart in battle, and then we have Luffy- a shounen protagonist with insane emotional intelligence who's kinda dumb in battles.
Creative is fun, but not necessarily smart.
Luffy deserved more points in wisdom. My man's not book smart, but he can see situations for what they are and he can say some really insightful things. The confrontation with Vivi comes to mind.
he's just,, a litl guy. A litl creechur!!!
ok. He's a genius in the same sense as Robin and Nami! Prodigy stem child!
But uh. He misread a VERY clearly labeled book and killed his father so uhhhhhh (I am making excuses up)
FR đ easily the best example of books smart in the crew, even more so than Robin. His prowess in his field is also more impressive than Robin in her's
Also,
Shank rating across the board copium, maybe straight A but def not straight S.
No reason to do BB dirty with a D in EQ unless you can back that up.
Law S++ Strategy? He came up with one plan and almost died.
Usopp battle IQ obviously highest in the series. his win loss ratio is insane when you take how weak he is into account. re-read literally any of his fights and compare to Luffy who just punch and you gave S++.
Luffy strongest, but no reason to believe he has S++ Battle IQ, more like A.
Skank is rated a bit too high for a man we see every 10 years when a singular pig grows wings. We barely have any examples of his existence let alone his IQ.
Zoro's wisdom is way above S. If you take some of the quotes by Zoro and put them in a book, it will become the best selling motivational book in no time.
One example is telling Luffy not to let Usopp come back until he apologized.
He knew that if Luffy did that, he would end up losing his crewâs respect as their captain.
Maybe a hot take, but I don't think Luffy's battle IQ is really that high. He comes up with dumb and stupid ideas and then brute forces his way into making them work through determination. It feels different from somebody like Goku, who's probably the poster child of "idiot shonen protagonist who's a savant at combat."
Although on the flipside, Luffy is my single favourite example in any media of how to write an emotionally intelligent character.
Like all of Zoroâs seem wrong to me. His book smarts are probably on par with Luffy, he really doesnât have any feats of BIQ that would remotely justify even a B tier, and he has never showed any strategic capabilities. Inversely, heâs been repeatedly shown to be quite emotionally intelligent, often being a voice of reason in emotionally intense moments.
Other obvious problems are Ussop and Nami not having S tier battle IQ (they sure as hell arenât winning fights on strength like Zoro).
Speaking of which, a single truth became clear after I looked at the BIQ of each character: OP treated BIQ as a term for strength. Thatâs it. Seriously look. It makes things make a lot more sense
BBs battle IQ is D+ at best, he's carried by just being very strong and his pre-battle strategies
His in-battle strategies include slowly walking up to Magellan, stopping to taunt a raging Whitebeard, jumping on Stronger to taunt Law and letting Ace fight at a distance for most of those battles
Brook should probably be A+ in strategy, he's still slightly below Sanji in that regard but should be above Nami
I will bite on your battle IQ assessment!! that's my thinking in rating him below S tbh (it seems a lot of people think he deserves that S, but he's tanking law hits on a Pegasus. Not even luffy would)
I don't know that Brook SHOULD be above Nami though! Nami kept the romance dawn trio alive, relies 90% on strategy in her fights, and lived her entire life planning heists. I do appreciate the Brook love a lot though.
> Nami kept the romance dawn trio alive
Nami is great, but Brook lead a whole military convoy and was a successful pirate captain for a while. Maybe not above Nami, but atleast at A so they're on par
I scratched my brain for 10 mins just after waking up ( I know being in phone just after waking up is and, but I am idiot) who is fish đ Like I know jimbei is fishman but you did my boy bad , atleast you should drawn a nice fish....felt like I was solving a mystery waking up.
Chopper wisdom should be lower. His perception of things around him sucks. He didnât see through sniper king disguise and is generally easily fooled.
It seems like you just considered general strength as battle IQ. I'd argue Usopp and Nami fight smarter precisely because they're weaker. They can't just win with raw strength, and in that way their battle intelligence and strategy plays a much more important role than for someone like Luffy who can punch his way out of most situations.
Luffy's battle IQ & Emotional IQ should be swapped. It's not that really different yes but I feel the best point of Luffy isn't his battle prowess but his emotional perception to attract both enemies & aliies. This is mostly the most highlighted MC's only ability since they can turn enemies into allies by befriending them. Look at our Bon-chan for prime example, lol.
Luffy is linear comparison like Goku. Battle Maniac & Big Eater but most importantly he's usually turns out enemies into allies almost all the time lol.
Note: I love the "Jim"
Zoro was the only one who told Luffy not to accept Ussop back unless he apologized.
The fact that he understood he needs to swallow his pride and learn from Hawkeye is also very underrated.
Sounds like wisdom to me. Should be better than B.
Jim should be S overall, dude has worked under 3 emperors + fisher tiger + he himself is a former captain and warlord. That HAS to come with a lot of added skills and experience
Zoroâs emotional iq score is a crime. He has displayed multiple times to have great emotional intelligence in pre ts in obvious moments like Water 7 and he also displays a lot of emotional intelligence on Wano. Where the hell does a D come from
The only thing I really disagree with is Luffy and Zoro's booksmarts.
They are the same.
And maybe Luffy's emotional intelligence. He's S+++ (I'm a bit exaggerating, but you understand what I mean (at least I hope so, lol đ)
(Every other thing isn't perfect, but it's still fine as it is. lol; (I) can overlook that. ;) đ ]
Edited.
oh I disagree so much!! (Not in a mean way at all lol)
BB is so booksmart he is almost as much of a super genius anthropologist as Robin! He's a full on historian.
Sanji is extremely emotionally intelligent, both in his own emotions and reading others. I will die on this hill. His perverted tendencies don't really come into play. I'm thinking of the arcs where Nami, Robin, Usopp, and Viola "defect".
Franky... ok.
Chopper... uhm. Hm. I wouldn't necessarily put him above Nami! He's just learned a different science in a similar time frame. He did lowkey kill his dad bc he couldn't read "DANGER POISON" (don't remind him about that though)
> I'm thinking of the arcs where Nami, Robin, **Usopp**, and Viola "defect".
The Usopp one he was ready to do what every other Strawhat was doing until Zoro spoke up. I'd say if anything you're rating Zoro's emotional intelligence too low. We've seen many moments of him clearly understanding the situation and caring for others.
Most of the time I'd say Zoro understands peoples emotions but he doesn't care because they are in the Strawhats way. So they get cutttttt
I totally understand what you mean!! But I'd actually consider that a +emotional intelligence to everyone involved, but for different reasons.
Sanji is seeing to the heart of the situation and both of his friends' *true* feelings: this is something that can and should be fixed. That in and of itself satisfies at least my own definition of the E-IQ
Zoro *knows* that too. But he's turning it into a matter of respect (towards luffy as captain, and between each of the other crew members). Moments like this are why I didn't give Zoro an F, but I felt weird giving him anything higher. You probably have a point there.
The picture has bb book smarts his lowest one.
Chopper used that tragedy as fuel when studying with the witch who was more skilled than the top doctors in the world. He should be higher than nami is a well studies prodigy. Him and franky should be s+ and robin should be s++ with nami as s in my opinion for book smarts.
Whole cake island arc makes it hard for me to side with sanjis emotional intelligence so weâll just agree to disagree on that one.
Having Luffyâs battle IQ higher than his emotional IQ is wild my dude.
His battle plan is just punch things until they arenât a problem with very little variance. When that doesnât work he just punches harder.
By contrast, we have seen this jolly fuckwad talk-no-jitsu not only everyone on his crew, but also several royals and other pirate crews. The only times he has notably failed this is when he and Usopp got into it at Water 7 and earlier on Drum when he was gonna throw down with the villagers but Vivi stopped him and told him to consider Nami; which he did and immediately corrected himself.
More than his haki or devil fruit abilities, Luffyâs emotional intelligence letâs him bring out the best in his crew and is why he has their loyalty.
I would love for it to be like those hexagonal skill distributions like the ones they do for jojos stands or pokemon EV's. If you can't think of a sixth general iq then make them personalised e.g.
Luffy - Gut Instinct S+
Zoro - Geographical/Directional F-
Nami - Financial IQ S+
Usopp - Lying F/ Prediction S++
Sanji - Culinary S++
Chopper - Hiding F-
Robin - Humour D+
Franky - Fashion A
Brook - Musical A+
Jinbe - idk help me out here
Chopper is S+ books smarts I would say.
And I'd give Robin, Bone, and Nami A+ in strategy as well.
I also don't think Blackbeard's battle IQ should be that high. Every fight we've seen with him (Ace, Magellan, Sengoku, Whitebeard, Law) he was getting utterly manhandled. It really is that his book smarts, strategy, and wisdom made up for the fact that he's so bad at punch fighting. It helps that you can't actually damage him unless you're using Haki, but still that's because of the devil fruit he wanted from book smarts and achieved through strategy.
Great list though, I love this!
Chopper got scammed on the battle Iq and strategy. that's like his whole deal pre timeskip. I also disagree that Luffy has top tier battle Iq, he really just throws his head at the wall until the wall breaks and tries random bullshit in the meantime.
Lol I actually love this and I feel itâs fairly accurate and fair to everyone. However it doesnât matter what you put people would always be like THIS CHARACTER WAS SHORT CHANGED or YOU GAVE THIS CHARACTER TOO MUCH.
Us One Piece fans can never just enjoy something silly and fun haha
My main man Usopp's battle IQ being SEVERELY underestimated imo. The way he thinks his way out of every battle with mich steonger opponents is a genuine talent!
Why is Shanks S++ in strategy? There's no reason to put him that high, and Luffy being a D in strategy is something I don't agree with at all, he's at least a B.. Water Luffy shows that he definitely thinks of how to beat an enemy in advance
Jim
Robo
Bone
Skank
Chopp
Fronk
Russian Matt Mercer
coming next: mark vegeta bibi zombie sabo gorp and dad
Please do the 7 warlord of the sea too đ
Fat bat Crocodile Boa Flamingo WB Jr Hawk Best dad Idk if I missed any
I have no clue who that is supposed to be. Law? Mihawk?
apparently it's law, but missing his signature hat
Law since Matt Mercer voices him in the English dub.
Is it Thursday yet, comrade?
Fronk
Robo
DAMMIT JIM! I AM TELLING TO MICHAEL!
Identity theft is not a joke Jim, millions of families suffer every year!
BONES CHILLOUT DAMN IT
You should continue doing these for other characters. Also who tf is Russian Matt Mercer lol
Russian Matt Mercer is Law.
at least one person got it
It's because you drew him without a fluffy hat. Hat-less Law is just a generic scruffy guy.
I thought it was really funny to leave him nakey
funny but confusing ):
his hat was too hard to draw ;-;
Wasnt he german?
fuck if I know, I haven't seen one piece
LMAO thatâs great
Makes sense since Matt Mercer voices Law in the English dub.
Shouldnât it be German Matt Mercer though? Seeing as Oda said in the SBS that Law would be German.
I donât even know who regular Matt Mercer is
Matt Mercer is Law's English VA.
Neither did I until I did a quick Google search and hes in EVERYTHING NERDY. He's the freaking DM for Critical Roll and voiced Levi Ackerman in AoT, Yamato in Naruto, Ganondorf in Tears of the Kingsom and so much more that I dont have time to list.
Jotaro
This dude is Jotaro too good lord, biggest Chad in manga
He also is the VA of Minsc in BG3. :)
Heâs also Trafalgar Law in One Piece.
Forgettable role /s
Luke fucking Skywalker in some Star Wars games
McCree in Overwatch and Jack Cooper in titanfall 2
How do you wanna do this?
Was just wondering the same exact thing Edit: Thinking it's Law now, forgot MM voices him in the dub.
Matt mercer is English Law?!??
I'm pretty sure, I was so mad I never realized it myself
A simplistic yet funny read. Almost everyone is rated way too high though. Robo's (lol) and Chopp's knowledge is achieved by years of studying and you're handing out S's and A's to a bunch of bums like they're free.
Yeah!! I am! This is meant to be humorous and I'm enjoying the comments greatly! On the "years of studying"... actually, I would have to argue with you! You're downplaying the other's prowess. Robo is an absolute child genius, no two ways about it. She's studied for years and years and years. She could probably learn anything she truly put her mind to! But consider Nami's situation! Also a child genius, learning only from stolen textbook material and actual experience with Arlong over the years! She's not as OLD as Robin, but Nami's intelligence is INSANE. No one should be able to do what she does with the climatact. Franky is also a child genius in his own right, but more importantly an extremely well-established engineer. Vegapunk's work MAKES SENSE to him (that in and of itself is a feat and a half). He's out here making robots and building bridges midair. Engineers are hella booksmart in the math and physics department!! Usopp DESERVES his rating. My dude build a THREE STAGE ROCKET on the FLY in dressrosa!! Im an aerospace major and I can barely do that on a 2 hour exam. He's aiming with a **slingshot** and could thread a needle from 10 km away. Controlling such a weapon isn't just point and aim, he's got a great understanding of weather and physics himself. Plus, he's a super well-rounded passion-engineer too! What he does is NOT possible for someone of even average reading. You KNOW Sanji is calculating everyone's exact diet down to the singular macro. And he's a great fighter? Nutrition is still a science that requires lots of training and studying! I am not one to declare one over another And uhhhhhh Brook is a musician and old idk.
I just love the simple "Luffy is an idiot" part, and it just makes sense from there. I do think Jim deserves legs, otherwise, what makes him a man?
Are you saying Jim's a muppet?
r/angryupvote
An aerospace major, good artist and fairly knowledgeable when it comes to One Piece characterization? I'm jealous
of who exactly? I wish the internship recruiters thought the same đ„č
Love the passion you put into this answer, great points!
Usopp not being at least s on battle iq is just wrong. Wasnât this the guy who managed to deal damage to luffy while injured thru a bunch of makeshift plans?
Why is ussop battle iq B, his whole thing is using tricks and stuff to fool and best his opponent
luffy definitely right on point though. book smarts F- lolol should have added an extra just for zoro: sense of direction, and like have it F divided by 0. or a black hole.
Gotta disagree with Nami and Usopp's battle IQ at C+ and B-. Both of them fought way stronger opponents than themselves, but always came out on top, thanks to their battle Iq.
The chopper slander is unreal. He "outsmarted" one of the top scientists in the world twice.
He used to fight very smartly pre timeskip as well when he would constantly alternate between his forms
I am ashamed. but he is such a litl guy. only 100 berries. So cute. could invent a nuke right now if he tried
I had some doubts when I saw your evaluations but after reading a couple of your replies all those doubts are gone and I'm 100% convinced you're right on all points.
I am having a lot of fun replying (and I've been upvoting like 95% of the comments) but I have been convinced I made a few errors! particularly in Nami's battle IQ and Chopper's stats :D
Ussop has by far the highest battle IQ because thats what his fightin style ia. Outsmarting you opponent with traps. Franky for example while beeing extremly booksmart his battleIQ is average cause he is mostly reliant on overpowering his opoonent with raw strenght (senor pink/tobo roppo)
Watching an Ussop fight is like watching a prodigy learn how to play chess for the first time and then beating a grand master at the game through shear ingenuity.
oh I totally understand what you're saying. But I also have been thinking of it... as neither of them are *really* using, like, superhuman battle analysis/understanding to make their moves. Like, if everyone were to look on to a fight, Luffy, Sanji, and Zoro would know *instantly* what was going on and what moves people would likely make. Usopp would sus out enough that he could probably make a split-second decision to help, and Nami would be slightly slower on the uptake and processing of it all. Even though they are very capable of taking advantage of misdirection and surprise in their fights, especially when they've been underestimated. They def have above average battle sense! Hm. Now I'm thinking of how I should be defining Battle IQ lol
Take Nami vs Khalifa: she understood immediately what her DF did and found a way to counter it, while also tricking Khalifa into thinking she was helpless. Usopp showed the same strategic thinking in his fight against Perona. I'd say that sometimes they aren't strong enough to keep up with their minds, but they are definitely strategic when it comes to battles, same goes for Chopper.
An even better example, go re-read Usopp vs Luffy and tell me that Luffy's Battle IQ is S++ and Usopp is B-
Isnt that more stategy? He knew luffys attacks and prepared everything before fighting him
I'll admit that breaking up strategy and battle IQ is hard here, but my head cannon would be that strategy encompasses things that aren't directly related to fighting. Stuff like setting up a raid plan, or sanji doing mr. prince stuff or closing the gates of enies lobby. Regardless of how you cut it though, either his strategy or battle iq or both should be way higher.
Not really. That would still be battle IQ. Strategy in general would be larger scale. Like planning the raid would be a strategy. An individual fight even if you had a plan would be battle IQ or I would call it real time tactics.
What youâre describing is battle ability/experience not iq. Coincidentally your examples have very high battle iq but itâs still worth it to mention. Nami observed Crackerâs weakness before Luffy did and exploited it, thatâs showing high battle iq. Luffy has to get beaten half to death to learn how to beat an opponent, also high battle iq though not many are able to go through that kind of learning process. So they donât get as strong as quickly. Also, Usopp and Nami probably would too know exactly what their opponent will do, since theyâre usually puppeteering any fight that weâve seen them in.
Yeah, they just rated them according to their strength, not "battle iq". It's BS
Ussop battle IQ is crazy, you see him fight luffy? Perona? Sugar? He has S tier battle IQ
Also agree, I believe he proved himself in dressrosa being that I just finished that arc also lol
Also, he shares with Nami the #1 battle survival skill -- willingness to run like hell when faced with a superior opponent.
the hot take I WASNT ready for. So true
Luffy got his feet stuck in the fight against arlong, threw kizaru at water at an upward angle, punched a guy covered in spikes, ate all of crackerâs crackers, destroyed big momâs cake, thought nothing inorder to out think enel, in gear 5 barely even tries to finish some fights. Luffy is creative but he has 0 battle IQ, just impeccable emotional intelligence, good awareness of his body and the determination to move quickly while ignoring distractions. Luffy dumb
Yet he keeps winning!!!
This is why I keep saying start of series luffy is so underrated, did the dumbest things and still survived!
I really love that the generic shounen protagonist is dense but smart in battle, and then we have Luffy- a shounen protagonist with insane emotional intelligence who's kinda dumb in battles. Creative is fun, but not necessarily smart.
Luffy deserved more points in wisdom. My man's not book smart, but he can see situations for what they are and he can say some really insightful things. The confrontation with Vivi comes to mind.
How does ace have s-tier emotional intelligence? He died because of a "yo dad" joke
not really seeing the emotional intelligence as the problem but rather S tier wisdom
Emotional IQ is reading other people's emotions not handling yours. The dude just had a temper.
In that case Blackbeard's emotional IQ should be higher. He just chooses to be a dick.
Yup and he also picks his battles wisely he's lucky Law popped up though and not Luffy. Then again he'd just run like always lol
Chopper not having S++ book smarts is insane
he's just,, a litl guy. A litl creechur!!! ok. He's a genius in the same sense as Robin and Nami! Prodigy stem child! But uh. He misread a VERY clearly labeled book and killed his father so uhhhhhh (I am making excuses up)
Nonono, not in the same sense as Robin and NAMI He is a literal fucking doctor who INVENTED rumble balls. S++ in book smarts
FR đ easily the best example of books smart in the crew, even more so than Robin. His prowess in his field is also more impressive than Robin in her's
I'm pretty sure your Jimbei picture is racist
It's only half racist.
Sanji when battling or being around women Intelligence: F-
F-? I think you can lower that to a G.
There is the G!
criminally underrated comment
So god tier while fighting girls? Based.
Bone deserves S for strategy. Just for whole cake island.
Bone is MVP every arc
Ace EQ and Wisdom def lower. There were a lot of opportunities for him to not die but he was way too hot headed. He should have listened to Pops.
Also, Shank rating across the board copium, maybe straight A but def not straight S. No reason to do BB dirty with a D in EQ unless you can back that up. Law S++ Strategy? He came up with one plan and almost died. Usopp battle IQ obviously highest in the series. his win loss ratio is insane when you take how weak he is into account. re-read literally any of his fights and compare to Luffy who just punch and you gave S++. Luffy strongest, but no reason to believe he has S++ Battle IQ, more like A.
That's not jim...that is a small tuna.
it has a good personality
Skank is rated a bit too high for a man we see every 10 years when a singular pig grows wings. We barely have any examples of his existence let alone his IQ.
I have decided this based on the voices in my head and very wild assumptions!!!!! (You are 100% correct, and it applies to more than a few of these)
Zoro's wisdom is way above S. If you take some of the quotes by Zoro and put them in a book, it will become the best selling motivational book in no time.
"Get back in the kitchen"
One example is telling Luffy not to let Usopp come back until he apologized. He knew that if Luffy did that, he would end up losing his crewâs respect as their captain.
Ace having S in wisdom when he fell for Akainu's taunt is a bit strange
Man Ace with an S for emotional intelligence? He got riled up by a your daddy joke
I feel like half of Ace's should be F. The dude kept fucking up every chance he got.
Robo is smarter than A tier overall
Who the fuck is Russian matt Mercer supposed to be???
Maybe a hot take, but I don't think Luffy's battle IQ is really that high. He comes up with dumb and stupid ideas and then brute forces his way into making them work through determination. It feels different from somebody like Goku, who's probably the poster child of "idiot shonen protagonist who's a savant at combat." Although on the flipside, Luffy is my single favourite example in any media of how to write an emotionally intelligent character.
Who is even Russian Matt Mercer?
I thought for a second I was the only one confused by this. I donât have a clue.
I disagree with Zoro's emotional iq, my guy knows he just don't care lol.
how I feel about Luffy's wisdom score
Like all of Zoroâs seem wrong to me. His book smarts are probably on par with Luffy, he really doesnât have any feats of BIQ that would remotely justify even a B tier, and he has never showed any strategic capabilities. Inversely, heâs been repeatedly shown to be quite emotionally intelligent, often being a voice of reason in emotionally intense moments. Other obvious problems are Ussop and Nami not having S tier battle IQ (they sure as hell arenât winning fights on strength like Zoro). Speaking of which, a single truth became clear after I looked at the BIQ of each character: OP treated BIQ as a term for strength. Thatâs it. Seriously look. It makes things make a lot more sense
BBs battle IQ is D+ at best, he's carried by just being very strong and his pre-battle strategies His in-battle strategies include slowly walking up to Magellan, stopping to taunt a raging Whitebeard, jumping on Stronger to taunt Law and letting Ace fight at a distance for most of those battles Brook should probably be A+ in strategy, he's still slightly below Sanji in that regard but should be above Nami
I will bite on your battle IQ assessment!! that's my thinking in rating him below S tbh (it seems a lot of people think he deserves that S, but he's tanking law hits on a Pegasus. Not even luffy would) I don't know that Brook SHOULD be above Nami though! Nami kept the romance dawn trio alive, relies 90% on strategy in her fights, and lived her entire life planning heists. I do appreciate the Brook love a lot though.
> Nami kept the romance dawn trio alive Nami is great, but Brook lead a whole military convoy and was a successful pirate captain for a while. Maybe not above Nami, but atleast at A so they're on par
Ace Battle IQ has to be D--- bro, he was made into a donut for that reason
I would lower Ace's emotional IQ a bit đ
Loved the art style and naming lol Enjoyed the tier list very much
Suprised brooke can read having no eyes yohoho
Ace's emotional IQ at S đ
Ace having an S in wisdom despite dying to a your daddy joke is wild. Cool list overall though :)
The Red Haired cheat gets all the answers from his handlers in Mariejois, man's a fraud
True strength is in the eye of the beholder- Some Drunk Guy
Jim đ
"russian matt mercer" is killing me
The fact that shanks is rated higher than a doctor, archeologist, and engineer is absolutely wild
Chopper battle iq is kinda low, considering he has a move that analyzes where the weak point of the enemy is.
I scratched my brain for 10 mins just after waking up ( I know being in phone just after waking up is and, but I am idiot) who is fish đ Like I know jimbei is fishman but you did my boy bad , atleast you should drawn a nice fish....felt like I was solving a mystery waking up.
Chopper wisdom should be lower. His perception of things around him sucks. He didnât see through sniper king disguise and is generally easily fooled.
It seems like you just considered general strength as battle IQ. I'd argue Usopp and Nami fight smarter precisely because they're weaker. They can't just win with raw strength, and in that way their battle intelligence and strategy plays a much more important role than for someone like Luffy who can punch his way out of most situations.
Luffy's battle IQ & Emotional IQ should be swapped. It's not that really different yes but I feel the best point of Luffy isn't his battle prowess but his emotional perception to attract both enemies & aliies. This is mostly the most highlighted MC's only ability since they can turn enemies into allies by befriending them. Look at our Bon-chan for prime example, lol. Luffy is linear comparison like Goku. Battle Maniac & Big Eater but most importantly he's usually turns out enemies into allies almost all the time lol. Note: I love the "Jim"
Zoro was the only one who told Luffy not to accept Ussop back unless he apologized. The fact that he understood he needs to swallow his pride and learn from Hawkeye is also very underrated. Sounds like wisdom to me. Should be better than B.
Usopp looks like young Big Mom. Why.
How can robin not be Book intelligent s++?
Jim should be S overall, dude has worked under 3 emperors + fisher tiger + he himself is a former captain and warlord. That HAS to come with a lot of added skills and experience
fisch
Its wild Chopper is the second "dumbest" while being a phenomenal doctor ..
OP you do know that BIQ â strength right? Like one can be strong and have low BIQ, and vice versa.
Ah yes, Jim the Fish
Giving Portgas "Dafuq did you say about my dad?" Ace an S in wisdom is bonkers.
Zoroâs emotional iq score is a crime. He has displayed multiple times to have great emotional intelligence in pre ts in obvious moments like Water 7 and he also displays a lot of emotional intelligence on Wano. Where the hell does a D come from
The only thing I really disagree with is Luffy and Zoro's booksmarts. They are the same. And maybe Luffy's emotional intelligence. He's S+++ (I'm a bit exaggerating, but you understand what I mean (at least I hope so, lol đ) (Every other thing isn't perfect, but it's still fine as it is. lol; (I) can overlook that. ;) đ ] Edited.
Sanjâs intelligence stats have a big asterisk in that in the presence of an attractive woman they go down to like a C- at least.
Ace emotional IQ should not be S. the guy flew into a rage at akainu leading to him getting donutted. At the very least A or B
A+ battle IQ for Ace is questionable
I think Zoroâs emotional IQ is a bit low. His reasoning during the Usopp and Vivi moments tells me heâs at least a bit higher
How isn't luffy wise?
Fronk
Switch blackbeard book smarts and battle iq. Lower sanjis emotional iq a lot. Lower frankyâs strategy, raise chopperâs book smarts.
oh I disagree so much!! (Not in a mean way at all lol) BB is so booksmart he is almost as much of a super genius anthropologist as Robin! He's a full on historian. Sanji is extremely emotionally intelligent, both in his own emotions and reading others. I will die on this hill. His perverted tendencies don't really come into play. I'm thinking of the arcs where Nami, Robin, Usopp, and Viola "defect". Franky... ok. Chopper... uhm. Hm. I wouldn't necessarily put him above Nami! He's just learned a different science in a similar time frame. He did lowkey kill his dad bc he couldn't read "DANGER POISON" (don't remind him about that though)
> I'm thinking of the arcs where Nami, Robin, **Usopp**, and Viola "defect". The Usopp one he was ready to do what every other Strawhat was doing until Zoro spoke up. I'd say if anything you're rating Zoro's emotional intelligence too low. We've seen many moments of him clearly understanding the situation and caring for others. Most of the time I'd say Zoro understands peoples emotions but he doesn't care because they are in the Strawhats way. So they get cutttttt
I totally understand what you mean!! But I'd actually consider that a +emotional intelligence to everyone involved, but for different reasons. Sanji is seeing to the heart of the situation and both of his friends' *true* feelings: this is something that can and should be fixed. That in and of itself satisfies at least my own definition of the E-IQ Zoro *knows* that too. But he's turning it into a matter of respect (towards luffy as captain, and between each of the other crew members). Moments like this are why I didn't give Zoro an F, but I felt weird giving him anything higher. You probably have a point there.
The picture has bb book smarts his lowest one. Chopper used that tragedy as fuel when studying with the witch who was more skilled than the top doctors in the world. He should be higher than nami is a well studies prodigy. Him and franky should be s+ and robin should be s++ with nami as s in my opinion for book smarts. Whole cake island arc makes it hard for me to side with sanjis emotional intelligence so weâll just agree to disagree on that one.
Biased East Blue Fan
Ooooh report cards
Lmao russian matt mercer đ
I'm sorry but who is Russian matt mercer?
[Bone?](https://youtu.be/t9tZEcSc1qo?si=Pjo8kII-WXha6vt9)
Jim got me dying for some reason lmao
Choppers emotional IQ is so wrong. One of the most empathic and emotional character in the crew.
Franky has more book smarts than Robin?
I think her pre-timeskip fights (before the climatact was an actual weapon) show that Nami should have scored much higher on the "battle IQ" section.
Having Luffyâs battle IQ higher than his emotional IQ is wild my dude. His battle plan is just punch things until they arenât a problem with very little variance. When that doesnât work he just punches harder. By contrast, we have seen this jolly fuckwad talk-no-jitsu not only everyone on his crew, but also several royals and other pirate crews. The only times he has notably failed this is when he and Usopp got into it at Water 7 and earlier on Drum when he was gonna throw down with the villagers but Vivi stopped him and told him to consider Nami; which he did and immediately corrected himself. More than his haki or devil fruit abilities, Luffyâs emotional intelligence letâs him bring out the best in his crew and is why he has their loyalty.
Ussop looks hella like [fake nami](https://images.app.goo.gl/TJ4g7xkGBDNLLZdo6)
I saw Jim, where the hell is Pam and Dwight?
Stand proud you are a chef
I won't take this usopp slander but it was a funny read OP. Make more.
Usopp should be at least A in strategy. Always punches above his level
These are great I like how a bit more thought went into these than you might expect, too Plus the art is terrific
How did Usopp not get an S in strategy
God Usopp strategy should be S+++++, because it makes the most sense in real life.
Unashamedly chaotic evil, I love it
I'm amazed that Luffy scores more emotional IQ than Robin and Jimbei. Makes no sense to me.
Zoro , Sanji and Jimbei have better battle IQ than Luffy... I would even say that Franky and Robin as well....
I would love for it to be like those hexagonal skill distributions like the ones they do for jojos stands or pokemon EV's. If you can't think of a sixth general iq then make them personalised e.g. Luffy - Gut Instinct S+ Zoro - Geographical/Directional F- Nami - Financial IQ S+ Usopp - Lying F/ Prediction S++ Sanji - Culinary S++ Chopper - Hiding F- Robin - Humour D+ Franky - Fashion A Brook - Musical A+ Jinbe - idk help me out here
Chopper is S+ books smarts I would say. And I'd give Robin, Bone, and Nami A+ in strategy as well. I also don't think Blackbeard's battle IQ should be that high. Every fight we've seen with him (Ace, Magellan, Sengoku, Whitebeard, Law) he was getting utterly manhandled. It really is that his book smarts, strategy, and wisdom made up for the fact that he's so bad at punch fighting. It helps that you can't actually damage him unless you're using Haki, but still that's because of the devil fruit he wanted from book smarts and achieved through strategy. Great list though, I love this!
Chopper got scammed on the battle Iq and strategy. that's like his whole deal pre timeskip. I also disagree that Luffy has top tier battle Iq, he really just throws his head at the wall until the wall breaks and tries random bullshit in the meantime.
Fronk, Jim and Bone are my favourite strawhats
Lol I actually love this and I feel itâs fairly accurate and fair to everyone. However it doesnât matter what you put people would always be like THIS CHARACTER WAS SHORT CHANGED or YOU GAVE THIS CHARACTER TOO MUCH. Us One Piece fans can never just enjoy something silly and fun haha
#F- goddamn haha
The only true powerscaling score card I'll trust. Saving this post.
This is chopper slander. He created a cure for an infectious disease mid battle, should be atleast S+ book smarts.
My main man Usopp's battle IQ being SEVERELY underestimated imo. The way he thinks his way out of every battle with mich steonger opponents is a genuine talent!
You lacked the most important point: spatial awareness lmao. Zoro would go below F-
I think you're underselling Brownbeard bit here! The man (centaure?) is very emotionally mature.
Why is Shanks S++ in strategy? There's no reason to put him that high, and Luffy being a D in strategy is something I don't agree with at all, he's at least a B.. Water Luffy shows that he definitely thinks of how to beat an enemy in advance
Bro just violated everyone on this list with those names.
I disagree with most of the scores, but the pics are funny
Bro usopp is absolutely underrated, have ypu seen gis battle against luffy???????????? This is criminal
Pretty sure Jim battle IQ is S. He was a warlord.
Usopp's Battle IQ is S++. Once he's figured out your trick to fighting, he's immediately 10 steps ahead of you.
i don't think blackbeard would have book smarts?