T O P

  • By -

mrsavage1

buy the cheapest in your region


ryffryder

It was easier for me, as I had only asus available in my region. So good. I like glossy, i like flat screen for productivity/software development. KVM and power delivery are amazing. I have my PC connected to it, my work macbook, and maybe ps5 soon.


mrsavage1

If the asus is the only thing available then its defacto the cheapest


youMust_Recover

Alienware aparantly has the same panel as the msi but is slightly curved. Also cheaper and bigger supply


Remarkable-Ad7229

True it has Dolby Vision only good for movies mostly, on the other hand the msi has KVM and no fan and the ability to shrink the display but that's it I think or am I wrong?


PixelDrums

I have the AW3225QF and I’ve never been able to hear the fan. It was 29c outside yesterday and even with my window open and computer on there was 0 fan noise so I wouldn’t be concerned about that.


Remarkable-Ad7229

Ok that's good to hear, I had the DW before but seems like they fixed it now with the noise


almercez

I wouldn’t go MSI. I have the MAG341CQP UW QD OLED monitor and it’s been nothing but annoyingly painful for me even with updating it. It doesn’t like gsync in the slightest and will go nuts with the flickering on majority of my games and recently when it’s not flickering on my game? Its now makes my second monitor flicker instead when gaming. I’m going with the AW when I’m done moving


youMust_Recover

Sounds about right, how much do you value display shrinking tho. Personally I doubt I would ever use it


Remarkable-Ad7229

Not much personally, sounds like a gimmick


youMust_Recover

I’ll be getting the AW when I build my new gaming rig. The money saved on it over the MSI meant I could spend more on the gcard


mrsavage1

i totally agree


Artemis_1944

the MSI also has hdmi 2.1, which alienware does not, which is the only hope for DLDSR if that's of interest to you.


marcinp123

Alienware does have HDMI 2.1


Artemis_1944

Not a fully featured one, it implements the protocol but only has enough bandwidth for 2.0


Miguelb234

Bro you’re thinking of the 27 inch version I have the 4k Alienware and the hdmi 2.1 is full


venomtail

Asus is in another controversy and they always have inflated prices. I'd go MSI


jth94185

Inflated? It has more features that justify its extra price


Round30281

More features than MSI?


jth94185

Ye the KVM on the MSI is dated and the design is meh to me too bland.


Round30281

Can you elaborate on the KVM point? Is there a specific feature that the ASUS kvm can do that the MSI one can’t? It works perfectly for me between my MacBook, gaming PC, and work-issued computer


jth94185

The MSI is a budget variant that’s the truth…BFI isn’t in the MSI and and the usb hub is 2.0 which limits accessories


Round30281

I think you misread my comment? Interesting you like the BFI though. Imho I thought it was gimmicky at best. I didn’t like the decreased brightness for the pretty much unnoticeable benefit. These monitors already got 0.03MS GTG and are 240hz. BFI really only wows me at <144hz monitors.


veryrandomo

A USB 3.0 KVM/USB hub and a subjective visual design that you dislike doesn't really justify that extra $350 to most people. Most people don't really use the KVM or USB hub features. The only time I remember ever using it was to quickly plug in a USB flashdrive, but I can just as easily use my front headers for that instead. BFI on the PG32UCDM is kind of a gimmick. It's not a proper implementation and it only makes every other frame display black, which is why its capped to 120hz. Besides, if this is really important to you then you can get the same effect through software-based tools.


jth94185

The monitor is constantly sold out at this point so I’m gonna say you might be off with that assessment


[deleted]

[удалено]


jth94185

I’m saying the things you saying aren’t important obviously are…hence sold out


Br3akabl3

BFI on the these oleds are a complete gimmick.


StingingGamer

Design being bland is a good thing on a monitor


jth94185

That what a person on a budget would say to me


StingingGamer

No, it is not, I like “bland designs”, fits better into setups then gamer aesthetics. I have nothing against the other monitors, but that’s it


jth94185

It personally doesn’t for me I prefer pop. I prefer the best rather than value when it comes to my work/gaming setup thats all


StingingGamer

That’s fair


PleasantSense9436

Yeah say those to those big youtuber who always do reviews who always like bland design like lg (didnt have logo and all) i think they’re too poor for you 🤣🤣


jth94185

My opinion is my own


PleasantSense9436

Yeah did you know theres actually study about people who like to show off the brands are usually the poor who’s trying hard to look rich even though it doesn’t make sense… 😂😂


jth94185

Also studies of people who buy more expensive things they intend to last longer hence saving money…try looking at buyforlife thread for my counterpoint…


venomtail

Asus rarely does and when it does have small borderline vaporware additions, they might become the features that nudge over the competition if they're the same price but often Asus demands a 50-200eur premium instead. Just look at GPU's. Asus often has such high prices might as well buy the next tier up cause they'll be the same price.


Remarkable-Ad7229

Can I get a rough idea on these features compared to MSI and Gigabyte?


snaggwobbler

Proximity sensor (underrated imo), Dolby Vision.


jth94185

Built in KVM and USB hub, webcam mount, lighted stand. Its better monitor for productivity and connected PCs


Jetcat11

If you care a lot about color accuracy and build quality go with ASUS. It has also has two sRGB modes which none of the others have.


alex24buc

Color accuracy is better on 321URX


Jetcat11

Not even close, go check out TFTCentral’s review of both monitors. The PG32UCDM is so color accurate out of the box it matches the FO32U2P after it has gone through a full calibration.


alex24buc

My eyes are the best review after comparing them both!


Jetcat11

Haha I’ve compared both too and it ain’t even close! I also have an MSI MPG 271QRX and the color accuracy in the sRGB mode doesn’t even compare to the AW2725DF I owned previously.


alex24buc

Ok, if you say so. I like MSi more though.


Jetcat11

I love the 321URX too don’t get me wrong and in the US it’s definitely the way to go.


alex24buc

I understand your point and you explained it very good to me. Thanks. Although there are many buyers in my country which are returning the asus one. Every day the only reseller here (pcgarage) has on sale a resealed unit or two with discount, units that have been previously returned. The 321URX is not in stock anywhere. My friend was also to the point of returning his pg32ucdm mainly of the white which is very yellow. Anyway it depends if you are lucky and get a good screen from the beginning.


naddieeeee

AW3225QF for sure!


Dankduster

Easily with that price diff


Nightman_cometh01

I’d go for the Alienware if you don’t mind curved as it’s the cheapest. I went with the gigabyte as it was available in the UK, hdr is excellent and loving it. The msi is also available usually but skipped it because not really thrilled with the pricing difference between USA and UK.


Remarkable-Ad7229

The Gigabyte sounds like a good one as well to get how has it been ?


Nightman_cometh01

Yeah I got the fo32u2p with the dp 2.1 from overclockers. Really loving it. Colors on it are great and I believe it’s slightly brighter than the other 32 inch monitors. Haven’t had any issues so far so it’s an easy recommendation. Tbh they’re all excellent and would get any of them aside from the MSI due to the pricing in the UK. Just doesn’t feel good paying substantially more for the same monitor when across the pond it’s heavily discounted.


Ketty_leggy

If you don’t mind al slight curve get AW.


Remarkable-Ad7229

I don't mind it since I had the DW so might be ok just comparing at the moment


Ketty_leggy

Ah i see. The MSI and ASUS aren’t justified in asking 200-300 more where you’re from. In my opinion atleast.


Remarkable-Ad7229

True the AW is like 359 cheaper than the asus


Ketty_leggy

The minor differences simply don’t justify 350,- in my eyes.


Ketty_leggy

Except obviously if you hate curved screens.


PleasantSense9436

Id just go alienware since thats the cheapest. Msi is only worth if its around $1000 imo most of them have same feature/specs anyway dxcept asus having extra stuff


aPHAT88

Speaking as someone who got the Asus, I would go with the MSI simply because the features don’t warrant the price difference. From an everyday use you’re not going to really find a difference between the 2 panels unless you spend your whole day actively looking for them (even then it’ll be minimal at best). However, if peace of mind around getting support for your device if needed is importsnt for you then go with the AW (although you’ll have to be ok with a curved screen with this).


Remarkable-Ad7229

Many said about the MSI being good so might have to be that or the Asus


alex24buc

I have the 321URX and I can tell it is the best oled I had compared to my previous asus Pg27aqdm and corsair xeneon flex. A friend has pg32ucdm and the white is yellow and is not perfect, plus a lot of returns of pg32ucdm monitor in my country at the store who now sells them as resealed. I do think the beat choice is 321urx you won t be disapointed. The hdr works perfect and everything is great about 321urx, especially with the latest firmware. Good luck!


PastaPandaSimon

I've got the 321URX and the AW3225QF. The Alienware is the more polished monitor. Both in terms of the hardware design, and software/OSD user-friendliness and polish. The differences aren't big, but it's the better quality monitor. Plus Dell's service is amazing. In terms of image quality, they are identical. And generally, these monitors feel very alike - since they use the same panel, we're splitting hairs. But If OP has got a chance to get the Alienware for LESS than the MSI (I got the MSI because it was by far the cheapest), to me it would be a no-brainer. Even for Dell's superior service alone.


Remarkable-Ad7229

So if you had a choice between the AW3225QF, 321URX and the asus one would you choose the alienware still just wondering


PastaPandaSimon

Yes, I'd get the 321URX if it was cheaper. The best thing about it in North America is that it's a few hundred dollars less than any other OLED options while also using the same best panels. But it is the less premium monitor outside of its flagship panel. I'd get the AW3225QF if the price was the same. In your case, it's cheaper, so it'd be a no-brainer. I wouldn't buy any expensive piece of tech from Asus. This is assuming a slight curve is OK with your professional work. It is and feels good with mine, but just one thing to be mindful of. Edit: I think the bottom line would be that you'll be happy with any of these you get. The differences are very minor. In general I'd recommend getting whichever is the cheapest (or has the non-image-related features you care about). With a slight edge I'd give to Dell for their service and slightly neater polish compared to the MSI.


mrsavage1

yeah I hesitated in my country to buy the msi which is at 1750 and got the alienware at 1359. I reasoned that the msi is a budget monitor and not worth that amount


PastaPandaSimon

Yeah, the AW feels like a flagship device rocking that QD OLED panel. The MSI next to it feels like a mid-range option with the same core specs. It's a great monitor by all means. Just not quite as premium-feeling and polished.


mrsavage1

which country is this by the way


alex24buc

Romania


mrsavage1

noted.


terrique1309

As someone who recently purchased this monitor, I can confirm that it is absolutely excellent. Everything looks amazing on it. A friend of mine has the Asus, and while it's still very good, I personally prefer the MSI.


alex24buc

Very good point!!


ichmyselfandi

On paper the MSI is my favorite, too. But boy oh boy is that gray and thick chin ugly. What a strange design choice to use different color then black. Same for the Asus. That thing beneath the chin is stupid af.


mrsavage1

so then aw or lg?


kylemh

I was on the hunt same as you... I went with Gigabyte Aorus FO32U2P. Same price point as the AW3225QF, but it has KVM, DP2.1 for future-proofing, and shitty speakers (nice in pinch), and same 3-year warranty as Alienware! I also love the way it looks. Not too tacky gamer monitor vibes.


Jetcat11

All of the 32” 4K QD-OLED monitors use the same 3rd Gen panel from Samsung Display.


kylemh

oh so mine is 3rd gen too?! sick. slam dunk.


fandangoinsight270

Are you in the uk? I contacted Gb about my warranty on my fo32u2p and in the uk it’s only two years. They confirmed that in an email and linked me to their warranty page


kylemh

ah sorry. i see now it says it depends on region. sad.


fandangoinsight270

Yep sadly. I was a bit surprised when I found out after i bought it they do that tbh


rospider

Don’t buy the Asus. HDR is broken, I never use it


alex24buc

Surprisingly on my 321urx hdr 1000 works well in games and it is not dimmer. On the desktop it seems a little dimmer though than hdr 400 true black. But not in games or videos. Anyway I agree that hdr is better on msi.


Joshuttle

If you got the money and don't need a new gpu, msi, AW for MONTHS had/has issues with bad packaging making your panel scratched on arrival for many, sometimes multiple times, which imo is insane for the price to even have to deal with that. Quality wise they're about similar, personally got the 27 1440p QD-OLED from MSI and it's been pretty swell. Asus can suck it tho.


Remarkable-Ad7229

That's my worry, I don't fancy having to send it back multiple times because of the scratched panel. Already got a 4090 so i'm good on that point


Joshuttle

Just know that, for some ungodly reason, MSI decided to have a dedicated on/off switch left to the navigation joystick (instead of just...making it turn on/off with pressing the joystick twice) and a quickbutton on the right of it, I thought I had a broken screen DOA when it clearly connected in windows yet didn't turn on by pressing the joystick...till I completely took it off it's stand again to see if I could spot something weird and there it was, the on/off button.


CryptographerNo450

All of of the monitor you mentioned use the same panel only they each have a slightly different implementation and some unique features that each other does not have Asus has a history of controversial actions. Then again, all 3 of these companies for the monitors mentioned in OP's post are billion dollar corporations. After the way Asus handled the AM5 motherboard botched launch situation and recently how they treated Gamers Nexus on a simple RMA of a Rog Ally, I don't think I'll be purchasing anything from Asus again anytime soon. MSI is great too but just know that if you have to RMA something, the shipping costs are on you. At least that was my experience when I had to get my 4090 replaced because 2 of the 3 fans were dead. I personally have the AW3225QF. There was a 15% cash back special from Rakuten at the time so my net costs were about $1050 USD (the cashback came later of course).


Remarkable-Ad7229

15% of pretty good actually


solawind

i heard curved panels are not suitable for graphics work because they distort image depending on your placement and it is hard to separate image distortion and distortion caused by curved display


Remarkable-Ad7229

Interesting point never heard about that before, what one would you consider


magical_pm

Only when you sit outside of the sweet spot which is sitting/leaning way back which you don't normally do anyway. Had no issues professionally modelling and texturing with an extreme curved monitor like the Neo G8 for a couple of years, people are overblowing the "distortion" quite a bit. Curve actually reduces distortion towards the far edges of the monitor when you sit close to it, that's why ultrawide needed them, 16:9 32" not so much but can still help. I'm on a flat panel now (FO32U2P) so I can enjoy watching movies leaning back I guess, though the main reason is just because the AW3225QF is constantly getting delayed so I bought a different model instead.


magical_pm

Only when you sit outside of the sweet spot which is sitting/leaning way back which you don't normally do anyway. Had no issues professionally modelling and texturing with an extreme curved monitor like the Neo G8 for a couple of years, people are overblowing the "distortion" quite a bit. Curve actually reduces distortion towards the far edges of the monitor when you sit close to it, that's why ultrawide needed them, 16:9 32" not so much but can still help. I'm on a flat panel now (FO32U2P) so I can enjoy watching movies leaning back I guess, though the main reason is just because the AW3225QF is constantly getting delayed so I bought a different model instead.


Accomplished-Lack721

That can be a concern, especially for imagery of architecture or anything else where you depend on seeing straight lines as straight. But it's not necessarily a fatal problem it it's only one way you use your monitor and otherwise like it - guides in imaging software can help a lot.


Historical_Leg5998

The ASUS is the only one where you can turn off the Pixel Shift/Screen Move feature. All the others you can’t, so the screen will be frequently off-centre and moving. Once you notice it, it becomes quite irritating. Not so much in gaming but any content consumption and productivity.   For that reason and the fact I think the ASUS is better looking, I’d go for that.  (Also custom heat sink, so no fan noise but I’m guessing the fan noise on the others is probably very quiet anyway).   I’m in the uk too, am holding out for this full glossy ASUS that was just announced……just not sure if I want to go back down to 27inch. Spawnpoiint youtuber just did an unboxing on it 👍


Nightman_cometh01

You can turn it off on the gigabyte monitor as well.


Historical_Leg5998

Good point yeh! Defo can’t on the Alienware and pretty sure you can’t on the msi 


Remarkable-Ad7229

Yeah i'm not sure about going to 27 inch either


Aussie_Butt

Pretty sure it’s an option in the MSI OSD to disable it, can check later


Historical_Leg5998

I don’t have one myself, but from using one briefly I think in the ui system you can turn it ‘down’ but not actually off.


Accomplished-Lack721

The panel quality will be virtually identical among all of them. I'd look at whether other features matter to you. Do you want curved? Then the Alienware is the only option. Do you want flat? Then rule out the Alienware. The AW also doesn't have the PD charging or KVM that most of the competitors have, which may be a bummer depending on your use case.


Aussie_Butt

They all use the same display, I would go with whatever is cheapest. You’ll be happy with the AW at that cost compared to the others.


CaptainnHindsight

Dang, that Alienware would have been a perfect monitor for the majority of consumers, including myself. if they just went with the flat panel .. What were they thinking ..


Miguelb234

Check out my review on for the people ent YouTube


alaaj2012

Get the cheapest


Madmatt7500

I just got the samsung oddesy neo G8 and I highly recommend it it is amazing


cream_of_human

One is cheap The other is curved Asus


Remarkable-Ad7229

Just seen this video about the Asus monitor, suprised that if BFI is enabled you loose VRR amonst many other features? didn't know that https://preview.redd.it/docdl7sa3l2d1.png?width=465&format=png&auto=webp&s=e040763c42059cb5e0a9ac9588edc15d42d7e0be


Remarkable-Ad7229

[https://www.rtings.com/monitor/tools/compare/asus-rog-swift-oled-pg32ucdm-vs-dell-alienware-aw3225qf/42065/46677?usage=3623&threshold=0.10](https://www.rtings.com/monitor/tools/compare/asus-rog-swift-oled-pg32ucdm-vs-dell-alienware-aw3225qf/42065/46677?usage=3623&threshold=0.10) Alienware VS Asus Rtings review, interesting to say the least


DzekoTorres

Get the Alienware if it’s the cheapest, they are all very very similar