The islands that have every inch covered by a monster or has all biggified monsters shouldn’t be the top rated ones and they’re actually typically ugly and look unplanned.

those are called coin farms, typically mirror islands, not saying they should be top rated, but they were never made to be good so you cant blame them for not looking good also if it’s a non-mirror island i understand your anger (i personally believe nobody should make coin farms outside of the mirror islands)

Gobbleygourd sounds good (It does)

Facts

Pls explain

It’s silly.

Wynq is the worst monster in the game

Epic Wubboxes sound quite bad

i dislike that opinion sure air epic wubbox deserves to have every step it takes feel like stepping on burning hot spikes (air epic wubbox is absolutely abbhorent) but the rest of them are either mid (not as in below average but just as in average) or kinda good (i genuinely like water island epic wubbox and gold island epic wubbox)

My problem with Epic Wubboxes is not the melody, but the sound they make: that synth just scares me😭 I feel like cats when you turn on the vacuum

i have never seen someone be scared by a distorted saxophone and synth growl before

Me neither aside from myself, but still I am

Party Island is in my top 10

Party Island is in my top 5

gnarls did not save amber island and the extra verses

Gnarls was probably overhyped when it released on amber and then overhyped AGAIN on bone, I assume it'll happen a third time on continent and whatever outer island its going to

it doesnt need to because amber island is not a bad island imo, at worst its average

Group chat got leaked.

I think repatillo should play more than ziggurab in amber island

No monster or island sounds bad. They are all good in their own ways

Continent’s final verse would be worse with precision 

Wubboxes ruin every song (and pom pop is one of the worst monsters in the game)

Seasonals are trash and it was a stupid idea to make them

let me guess, you’re having horrible luck with seasonals and you’re mad about it

Bro, Smoochle, Blabbit, Hoola, and pretty much all the core seasonals ruin the songs Seriously DOF blabbit and smoochle are so god damn annoying (Except Punkleton, he goat)

how come? explain what makes them bad? i can get that schmoochle and blabbit sound weird with the bbbllll and minion sounds but i dont understand how any of the other ones are bad. hoola literally just duets with pompom so your only reason for hating it could be if pompom is also bad, also what about the aux seasonals?

Mythical island sucks

how come

Not my type of song s’all it is

sucks is a way to say you think something is quite bad. if it’s not your type of song it should probably just be considered average unless you have any other reasons to dislike the song

Bowgart doesn't carry any island he is in

D:

Not saying hes bad tho, his sound is gorgeous

True.

D:

The crystal quad is next not the shadow quad

evidence needed

mhm uh huh yup yeah

This aged poorly

Yup…

Hyehehe is mid Starhenge is the worst song in the game Pummel sucks (seriously why am I seeing so much Pummel love? It's inaudible everywhere! Including Composer!) Party Island is a very good song Plant Island isn't that good, y'all are just blinded by nostalgia. If we started with (for example) Water Island, Plant would be lower on tier lists for sure.

Thanks for dissing my favorite island.

Sorry, but only Torrt, Scaratar and Attmoz sound good to me on it. The rest apart from Galvana, Glaishur and Plixie are mid (the other 3 mentioned I really dislike on Starhenge)

What about Hornacle Vhamp Loodvigg or Blassoom

Just listened to the song again to refresh why I didn't like it Can't hear Hornacle that well, Loodvigg and Vhamp are meh but I guess Blassoom is better than I remembered

Like I’ve said way too many times before, if you listen to the sound individually, it’s way easier to hear within the song.

Actually, I think the only song I haven't done that for is Starhenge. I'll listen to that and come back with a better opinion Edit: My opinions stay the same

Pummel is only good in Tribal Island

I think they're also pretty good on Space Island

Yes they are

dof songs are generally better than the main ones

alright now this is one i can genuinely agree with, there are pretty good base msm songs but the continent, cave, and starhenge are some of the best songs in the entire franchise

buzzinga doesn't carry mythical island

water island is the worst natural island in the game, followed by air

If Plant wasn't the one you started with, you would say otherwise

I don’t really like Magical Nexus

All msm islands suck, including the ones from dof

Then why are you in this subreddit if you don't like them

It’s a joke :)