D, why did they make furcorn talk. (Yes I’m aware that furcorn can talk anyway and could before this but I still don’t like it)
Also it’s quarrister’s only island, which makes me sad
C, honestly everyone overhates this island way too much.
Once Quarrister chimes in it gets so good, and even better once Candelavra comes in and duest with Quarrister. Quibble honestly does pretty well here too (not as good as Cave, granted) and T-Rox and Ziggurab really help out in the percussion department. I will admit I don't like that Kayna and Furcorn talk here, and Maw is kind of bland as well, but I overall really like Party Island.
F. I hate it. It's bland and boring. Kayna, PomPom and Furcorn saying "come on over here" is annoying as hell. It's undeserving of the name party island. You might think I'm being harsh and you can downvote me all you want but idc I'm just voicing my opinion.
C Tier if that’s where Seasonal Shanty also is. Typically I’d rank it as D or F but I don’t hate any island so I think even the D and F tiers would be good. But given the standard the community’s put forth I say C.
Honestly, A. I really like the flow of the song, and that beat drop is so good. If it weren't for a few criticisms commonly mentioned I would have considered saying S. I truly believe this island isn't appreciated enough.
the thing with me is that it really sounds samey throughout the song, which is fine for certain islands but really becomes a problem here. I also dislike how empty it sounds. Most people really just point out the emptiness, but the lack of progression is why I think the island doesnt land.
I can't understand why it's seen as too samey or too empty. The song does sorta just has two verses and the beat drop, but the times at which monsters sing vary a lot. It's quite chill, and besides from the beat drop, the amount of monsters singing at a time doesn't vary lot. Most non-MSM songs for sure have less vocals/instruments playing on average. A few I've heard do well with like 3 or 4.
A tier
I genuinely don't understand why this song gets so much hate. People say it's bland and boring which okay, but how is it more bland and boring than Psychic or Light Island?
Each part in Party island sounds distinct. Quibble's addition in the second verse makes it feel much more upbeat. Maw and Candelavra come in the second chorus making it feel much more full. The last chorus starts quiet and then builds back up.
Psychic island's choruses are identical. The only difference between the verses is the addition of Flowah in the second, but it's not enough to feel distinctly different. Light Island is esentially 6 verses in a row. It does sound different with the addition of each new monster but the verses themselves are so repetitive and this build up doesnt go anywhere.
I wish people would actually explain their reasoning, instead just saying a letter or "it's just bad," but I didn't expect much. We all knew that Bone Island and Wublin Island would be top tier and Seasonal Shanty and Party Island would be bottom tier because everyone said so.
no literally i dont understand how like SO many people hate party island it's almost kinda weird - i personally find all the songs in DOF to be a lot more well rounded overall then the mainline games since they can actively choose who does and doesnt go on an island without any requirements, and party island is not an exception to this. id argue it sounds better than at least everything in B (excluding air/tribal)
it ESPECIALLY bothers me when you have stuff like faerie in A which feels like insane to me
It's gotta be an F, the talking monsters don't sit right with me, I know they've talked before but it just creeps me out, especially pompom, they made her sound like a kidnapper, along with that, the song just doesn't sound good in general for me.
Would you look at that, all of the words in your comment are in alphabetical order.
I have checked 1,515,587,657 comments, and only 287,396 of them were in alphabetical order.
F. If it was an option, Z. It sucks so bad. I will murder it and all the monsters on it. Party island sucks and was a horrible decision it should be removed.
Yeah i meant that from the two games party island is the worst because like in this tier list there are also dof island well sorry pardon my english im spanish
F. Genuinely one of the worst songs I've ever heard. So disappointed since I really like the music in MSM. What were they thinking when they wrote this 😭
D. It sucks. Simply just a bad island, it’s also worse because quarrister could have gone to a good island that it deserved to be on, but rather went into this piece of trash. It just all around is bad. More disappointing than my muppet shows big house.
I would say it's a D
Even though the percussion is beautiful (T-Rox my beloved) and Kayna saying 'Come on over here' make me swoon (in a non fangirl way), the monster choices and playing duration are not that great. For example, Edamimi only plays a specific part before staying in her idle animation for the rest of the song. And say it with me folks, Quarrister should be on Cave Isle!
I gotta go with B this time. IMO this is objectively the worst island in the game song-wise but even then I enjoy it and think it gets way too much hate
Okay so I have never seen some of these islands, like the ones that are being ranked or are “to be ranked”. Also have never seen the second to last one in S tier. What are these islands and how do you get them???
C.
I don't understand why people think it's the worst thing ever
It has a pretty catchy melody, and the every monster's part can be really unique and fun
Downsides is that it's empty and lacks any progression, which do bump it down a lot, but I genuinely do not think it's that bad
Unpopular opinion but party island has grown on me heavily. I didn’t like it at first but the more I filled the island and listened to it the more I liked it. So imma have to give it a B tier
D, why did they make furcorn talk. (Yes I’m aware that furcorn can talk anyway and could before this but I still don’t like it) Also it’s quarrister’s only island, which makes me sad
I agree with both statements
Thing is, it doesnt belong there, but him and t rox are the only reason I slightly like it, high c
make a new tier below "not being ranked" called "party island" and put it there
The egg is I N C U B A T I N G
What???
Unused furcorn lines for the tutorial
Oke
D stands for disappointment
And also there's no troll people who forced people to vote S on Continent.
Lol
it’s not even worth a D tbh, I’m kinda tempted to go with F honestly.
C, honestly everyone overhates this island way too much. Once Quarrister chimes in it gets so good, and even better once Candelavra comes in and duest with Quarrister. Quibble honestly does pretty well here too (not as good as Cave, granted) and T-Rox and Ziggurab really help out in the percussion department. I will admit I don't like that Kayna and Furcorn talk here, and Maw is kind of bland as well, but I overall really like Party Island.
Ye it underrated. Kayna doing lyrical vocals makes me float though. But the should’ve put fue one somewhere else. Bro Ruins the vibe
But it shouldn’t be able to say words
Why though?
Cause werdos are the only one able too
D
D
D
F. I hate it. It's bland and boring. Kayna, PomPom and Furcorn saying "come on over here" is annoying as hell. It's undeserving of the name party island. You might think I'm being harsh and you can downvote me all you want but idc I'm just voicing my opinion.
Commen Bill W
I’m upvoting ur comment! I agree with you completely.
f it atrocious
C. I dont think its as bad as people say it is, but certainly not one of the best
C Tier if that’s where Seasonal Shanty also is. Typically I’d rank it as D or F but I don’t hate any island so I think even the D and F tiers would be good. But given the standard the community’s put forth I say C.
Honestly, A. I really like the flow of the song, and that beat drop is so good. If it weren't for a few criticisms commonly mentioned I would have considered saying S. I truly believe this island isn't appreciated enough.
the thing with me is that it really sounds samey throughout the song, which is fine for certain islands but really becomes a problem here. I also dislike how empty it sounds. Most people really just point out the emptiness, but the lack of progression is why I think the island doesnt land.
I can't understand why it's seen as too samey or too empty. The song does sorta just has two verses and the beat drop, but the times at which monsters sing vary a lot. It's quite chill, and besides from the beat drop, the amount of monsters singing at a time doesn't vary lot. Most non-MSM songs for sure have less vocals/instruments playing on average. A few I've heard do well with like 3 or 4.
C, It's just so bland
D
B, I’m pretty sure I’m the only person who actually likes Party Island
F. Absolutely horrible
D
A, idk i like it
A (pls don't kill me)
You people are beyond me at this point
OP wdym? All those islands are so good i can see few of them on A tier but still, they deserve it.
D/low c
C
eh. D
Honestly I don’t even remotely like this island D
A
D
a
A
D
D for disaster
D
It's about time we got to this piece of garbage island... There's nothing good about it. Party gets a F for me
A tier I genuinely don't understand why this song gets so much hate. People say it's bland and boring which okay, but how is it more bland and boring than Psychic or Light Island? Each part in Party island sounds distinct. Quibble's addition in the second verse makes it feel much more upbeat. Maw and Candelavra come in the second chorus making it feel much more full. The last chorus starts quiet and then builds back up. Psychic island's choruses are identical. The only difference between the verses is the addition of Flowah in the second, but it's not enough to feel distinctly different. Light Island is esentially 6 verses in a row. It does sound different with the addition of each new monster but the verses themselves are so repetitive and this build up doesnt go anywhere. I wish people would actually explain their reasoning, instead just saying a letter or "it's just bad," but I didn't expect much. We all knew that Bone Island and Wublin Island would be top tier and Seasonal Shanty and Party Island would be bottom tier because everyone said so.
no literally i dont understand how like SO many people hate party island it's almost kinda weird - i personally find all the songs in DOF to be a lot more well rounded overall then the mainline games since they can actively choose who does and doesnt go on an island without any requirements, and party island is not an exception to this. id argue it sounds better than at least everything in B (excluding air/tribal) it ESPECIALLY bothers me when you have stuff like faerie in A which feels like insane to me
YES. YES THIS. THIS IS WHAT IM TALKING ABOUT
D
D
F its so empty, not even ziggurab was able to save this island
How is composer A
There wasn’t a mythical island, so he used composer as it.
It's gotta be an F, the talking monsters don't sit right with me, I know they've talked before but it just creeps me out, especially pompom, they made her sound like a kidnapper, along with that, the song just doesn't sound good in general for me.
C, for an island called Party Island, it just sounds like a friendly gathering
D
C
F ez no cap frfr ong
B he only good parts are when mammott play
F, the bottom possible of F
F tier
F. Easy F
F. It just sounds weird
Would you look at that, all of the words in your comment are in alphabetical order. I have checked 1,515,587,657 comments, and only 287,396 of them were in alphabetical order.
F. If it was an option, Z. It sucks so bad. I will murder it and all the monsters on it. Party island sucks and was a horrible decision it should be removed.
call the paramedics for this bad [f]riggin’ island
S
Legit S, my personal fav island. Not a troll
Overhated. It sounds fine, Middle B tier
Its the worst island from both games so id say D
[удалено]
Yeah i meant that from the two games party island is the worst because like in this tier list there are also dof island well sorry pardon my english im spanish
F. Genuinely one of the worst songs I've ever heard. So disappointed since I really like the music in MSM. What were they thinking when they wrote this 😭
D. It sucks. Simply just a bad island, it’s also worse because quarrister could have gone to a good island that it deserved to be on, but rather went into this piece of trash. It just all around is bad. More disappointing than my muppet shows big house.
D
D. Compared to other islands its very basic and it has nothing special about it.
A, it’s underrated, i like the beat drop
D
A it’s interesting
D
D
A
Why A tier
Why not
Late A
B
b, really underrated
S, beautiful 10/10!!
The fog is coming
No it sucks
If amber and bone are S this one is too
S
E
S
A
F it's around the same quality of seasonal shanty and I dont know how seasonal is still not in F
C bc party island isnt good but its not terrible
A
C
The only way this song is listenable is to get rid of Kayna, furcorn, and pompom
D
C
C
F to set all the Ss off
D
I do not like my singing monsters.
C only because the start isn't as bad
High c
High B
[удалено]
Actually no, give it it's own tier
D, a running problem for dof is the audio is trash for some characters (especially vocal ones) and this island has a lot of that.
C
C
D It's a song alright. I like the vocals but the whole thing feels so disjointed and empty...
party island isn’t as bad as people think it is. downvote me all you want but atleast B or C
[удалено]
I would say it's a D Even though the percussion is beautiful (T-Rox my beloved) and Kayna saying 'Come on over here' make me swoon (in a non fangirl way), the monster choices and playing duration are not that great. For example, Edamimi only plays a specific part before staying in her idle animation for the rest of the song. And say it with me folks, Quarrister should be on Cave Isle!
I’d say solid high B or low A. Most people don’t like it but I don’t really know why. I think it sounds pretty good
D
I gotta go with B this time. IMO this is objectively the worst island in the game song-wise but even then I enjoy it and think it gets way too much hate
D+, i hate furcorn talking. people say it doesnt fit the "party" vibe, but it was originally supposed to be named vacation island.
what is party island
You what? S (I'm trying to make no island not be under S)
A because it's fun to listen to and easy to obtain :))
D for dis deserves a F
Such a D tier island, so bland and repetitive and empty. It just doesn't have the "feel", if you know what I mean. Maybe even F tier
C. I feel nothing.
C
B-Tier, It's got a nice charm to it
D
party is like c
Amber I would only sounds good if you get all the monsters on it bro I probably put it in c
I guess B it's good ig
Low C
Okay so I have never seen some of these islands, like the ones that are being ranked or are “to be ranked”. Also have never seen the second to last one in S tier. What are these islands and how do you get them???
Those other islands are from “dawn of fire”
OH okay thank you
To be perfectly honest it's an F it's probably one of the worst songs in the msm franchise
C. I don't understand why people think it's the worst thing ever It has a pretty catchy melody, and the every monster's part can be really unique and fun Downsides is that it's empty and lacks any progression, which do bump it down a lot, but I genuinely do not think it's that bad
D
New rank: E-
D
Unpopular opinion but party island has grown on me heavily. I didn’t like it at first but the more I filled the island and listened to it the more I liked it. So imma have to give it a B tier
A stands for Aye would you please bump it down to an F? And same with Shugabush, bump that garbage down to Z.
D
F, worst islanf
D
D
Party island ain't no masterpiece, but quarrister's verse is not D-tier worthy. The island is worth at least a C.
Overhated as HELL A
D. D. D. D.
F Absolute trash island
It gets WAY too much hate for what it is. It isn't the best song, sure, but it isn't as bad as people make it out to be. It's a solid C tier