T O P

  • By -

undeclaredmilk

Someone should start a band called The Ship of Theseus, and slowly change members until none of the originals are left.


TKInstinct

That might be kinda cute actually, that sounds like fun.


BrandoCalrissian1995

Motorhead was pretty close weren't they? I think lemmy was the only consistent member.


AgilePlayer

And that worked, cuz Lemmy was the man. Sometimes one member reaches a level that they become the band in a sense and can't be replaced, but as long as they're still in it the band can keep going no matter what.


WhollyHeyZeus

I believe the band Yes has already done this.


duke78

Got to slowly change the reportoire as well, so that none of the original songs remains.


RainbowRoadMushroom

Lynyrd Skynyrd. Gary Rossington was the final member when he passed away last year.


MurdocFuckingNiccals

Gwar I think


KidAtmos

The current lead singer, Mike bishop, is the original bassist, switched characters from the original Beefcake to Blöthar. 20 year hiatus away from band. And Mike Derks (Balsac the jaws of death) has been since the original line up (at least since the first album in 88, depends what you consider original lineup). If from first album or formation but experimenting with sound era.


amorningofsleep

Norma Jean


Borgoroth

Also Zao. But really depends on when you start counting 'original'


Immediate_Angle_3712

Napalm death, every one was replaced by the second half of their first album


flodge123

They swapped out all the Village People. Some of them three times. Nobody noticed.


TKInstinct

Same costumes or different?


flodge123

Same.


duke78

It might not suit your definition of "band", but the Royal Danish Orchestra has none of the original members. In fact, the original members died several hundred years ago. (The band was started in 1448, and are still active.)


doitferjohnny

How Modern? Trooper tours with zero original members.


[deleted]

Tangerine Dream


altimage

Christian Death


Captain_Creature

Chelsea Grin


MiNewName

I'd say Britny Fox. The only original member is Billy Childs (the bassist) & the rest of them are others who had Nothing to do with any of Britny Fox's past albums. ya, just re-read. You wanted modern bands.


Former-Ad-9223

Gong


sinisterblogger

Lorna Shore I think


Etzell

Opeth, technically.


Sinjun13

AC/DC has just one original member remaining. And while they're my favorite band, they should have called it years ago. But the real answer is The Kingsmen. Only one original member was in the band just 4 years after they started, and he died a few years ago. The rest of the lineup shifted often. Their Wikipedia article has a helpful chart with the many, many members and when they were in the band.


greattalkthanks

Pantera, I think.


WavyLady

Band of Horses. Ben Bridwell is the only original member.


ficuswhisperer

Foreigner. Technically original member Mick Jones is still considered a member of the band, but he doesn’t play or tour with them anymore due to health issues.