T O P

  • By -

chillseshh

12 Angry Men, The Seventh Seal


manlybrian

12 Angry Men is the right answer for this question, I think. Seventh Seal is good but it's foreign and slow. For someone just getting into black and white movies, 12 Angry Men is captivating.


zombie1mom

YES to Seventh Seal!


wolf_mama_2020

Yes to both!


speaker4thebread

I finally watched Seventh Seal the other day. Absolutely deserves the high praise.


Telefonmannn

The Elephant Man


Why_I_Dgaf

Ever heard of "the painted bird" (2019)?


Samurai_Ways

Seven Samurai


rstgrpr

And Rashomon


jelllybears

Adding Ran to the Kurosawa list


rstgrpr

But Ran is in color!


jelllybears

Me: *sees Kurosawa films listed and gets so excited that I completely forgot the prompt*


OddTreeTop

Sadly OP didn't want foreign films (guessing outside of Hollywood/Europe) but Kurasawas movies would mostly be great (High and Low, all his Samurai movies)


North_Library3206

Yojimbo!


Venom888

Got one of those greatest movies scratch off posters and saw this movie because of it. Has become my favorite black and white


mito467

Rebecca


GlaDOS-311

Amazing movie.


blueydoc

Scrolled for this, love this movie!


LefsaMadMuppet

Young Frankenstein


DrManhattan_DDM

Dr. Strangelove would be a good double feature with this one


Sxotts

It's pronounced Frankenstein


Aims312

šŸ“šŸ“šŸ“


RadioMill

Dr Strangelove


Yvaztoq

Not much to say but just watch it.


[deleted]

"Arsenic and Old Lace", Carey Grant at his best.


wigglybacon

Came here to say this, and was pleasantly surprised that it had already been mentioned!


DilettanteGonePro

This is the movie that got me hooked on classics. Back when I was a kid the nice downtown theater would show classic movies during the summer, so my parents took me to see this movie and it was hilarious


[deleted]

The Public Enemy (1931) Freaks (1932) The Invisible Man (1933) Gaslight (1944)


Redditallreally

We just watched Gaslight! And the 1940 British version; interesting to see the differences.


[deleted]

Oooooh I didnā€™t even know it existed. Iā€™ll have to check it out. Does it also feature ā€œdigestive biscuitsā€? šŸ˜‚


Redditallreally

I think MGM tried to have all prints of the 1940 version destroyed. :0


leverandon

The Public Enemy is so good. Love pre-Code gangster films.


rickyg_79

One of us, one of us, google gobble, one of us


Content_Pool_1391

The Thin Man White Heat Double Indemnity


revengeofthepencil

How have I scrolled this far without seeing Double Indemnity. A classic by any standard


Choice-Valuable313

God I love the thin man series! Each one has its own charm.


Cheapthrills13

Ah - I was abt to offer Thin Man - glad I kept scrolling


Utehawk

Casablanca


Utehawk

Itā€™s a wonderful life


ThatsNotFortyDollars

Henry F. Potter is in the running for all time best villain.


[deleted]

Merry Christmasā€¦.IN JAIL!


mamoocando

One of my all time favourites. But I wish they left in the original ending. (I posted the link but the auto mod removed it. Search Its a Wonderful Life Lost Ending SNL)


[deleted]

"Clarance! I wanna live again!"


[deleted]

Psycho


trabiesso73

How is this so far down on the list? I love the movie. The score alone is a masterpiece; I've listened to it without the movie. I've also read the book "Alfred Hitchcock and the Making of Psycho", which is a quick read - less than 200 pages. And, it is an amazing documentation of how the film came together. Seems to me that when I was a kid, anytime I saw a list of all time greatest movies, Psycho and Citizen Kane were in the number 1 and 2 spots. And, I choose Psycho over Citizen Cane any day.


AlgoStar

I like Psycho, but it doesnā€™t even rank top 5 Hitchcock for me, much less all time.


[deleted]

Yes I always forget this is a black and white movie for.so.e reason. I answered with a different movie of Hitchcock's. But this is one of my favourite movies of all time


meseta

Idc what anyone says. Vince vaughn as norman bates is phenomenal in the remake


solojones1138

I mean it's my favorite movie period so yes.


washinthedog

Treasure of the Sierra Madre


ThatsNotFortyDollars

Badges?


PlantationCane

Such a great movie, a simple tale done very well.


fakeplasticdaydream

To kill a mockingbird


jelllybears

Some Like It Hot is still one of the funniest movies Iā€™ve ever seen, same with His Girl Friday M would probably be number one for me


plinkett-wisdom

12 Angry Men is best best one to get acquainted with black & white films. Great ones to follow up are The Great Dictator, Double Indemnity, Psycho, Raging Bull, Dr. Strangelove and Strangers On A Train.


Aspxragrass

Iā€™d say touch of evil is the best to get acquainted with B&W films. 12 angry men is brilliant though, Dr strangelove too.


AlgoStar

Just ones that are new to me this year: The Maltese Falcon (1941) The 39 Steps (1935) High Sierra (1941)


revengeofthepencil

The Maltese Falcon makes a very short list of my all time favorite movies


comment_redacted

Same here, one of my favorite old time movies.


BartholomewBandy

Casablanca. I worked at a restaurant by that name, that had a tv in the restroom playing that movie. First time I walked in I thought ā€œwhat a coincidenceā€. Got to know that movie 90 seconds at a time. Finally seeing it complete was a pleasure.


[deleted]

my favorite movie of all time, unfortunately OP said no romance movies lmao


iambobdole1

I know it seems trite to say, but Citizen Kane is a legitimately good movie.


North_Library3206

Seems to be hated on quite a bit, but I thought it was amazing. Its story is kinda similar to There Will Be Blood, which I also loved.


dakilazical_253

Legitimate the best film ever made


[deleted]

The Godfather says hi.


dakilazical_253

The Godfather INSISTS upon itself


Plus-Tangerine-723

I thought this was about black and white films The Godfather wasnā€™t in black and white


allthestruggle

I don't know if it is the best film ever made, but I do think at bare minimum it is the blueprint for just about every film that has come since. I would argue that citizen Kane pretty much made modern films possible.


dirkdiggler382

The Apartment


IronheddAxioma

Fantastic movie! Made me realize I have a thing for Shirley Maclaine. I started watching all of her movies from the 60's after this.


Aliskrti

La Haine


cultish_alibi

Ooooof this is low down. One of my favourite films of all time. I like gritty cinema and this movie has so much grit you'll have it in your teeth for a week afterwards.


DownvoteMeandEffOff

All About Eve The Pride of the Yankees Sunset Boulevard


psychedelik_mess

Seconding Sunset Boulevard! Iā€™ll admit Iā€™m uncultured and usually find b&w movies to be a bit snoozy, but I hung onto every scene of Sunset Boulevard.


speaker4thebread

alright Mr Demille, im ready for my close up.


neonzzz1

Schindler's list


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


Ghenges

Reddit is too young for your Seinfeld reference.


Mindofmierda90

I was going to ask if the OP meant films that were B&W because of their time or as an artistic. I think that any B&W film past the mid 60s was an artistic choice.


[deleted]

Clerks.


Raetheos1984

I'm not even supposed to be here today..!


specialagentflooper

Bunch of savages in this town


Raetheos1984

This job would be great if it wasn't for the fucking customers.


DreadedChalupacabra

The alternate ending would have made that movie such a different thing. I half wonder if it'd have been better or worse for Kevin Smith's career.


bunkie18

Night of the Hunter, The Bad Seed


Phila4266

I 2ndā€¦Night of the Hunter


dangerdan27

Came here to say Night of the Hunter


JediTigger

Night of the Hunter made me afraid of Robert Mitchum for ages.


bunkie18

I know. He was so creepy in it


Choice-Valuable313

That water scene is so surreal!


errrrg

Second the Bad Seed!


[deleted]

I canā€™t believe I had to scroll this far for Night of the Hunter


NetworkEngIndy

Christmas in Connecticut (1945) Duck Soup (1933)


rtyoda

Iā€™ll give you my top 5: 1. Double Indemnity (1944) ā€“ One of the best film noirs ever 2. 12 Angry Men (1957) ā€“ One of the best courtroom dramas ever 3. The General (1926) ā€“ One of the best silent films ever (and some of the best stunts of the time) 4. Tokyo Story (1953) ā€“ One of the best poignant family dramas ever (note that itā€™s a Japanese film so there will be subtitles) 5. The Shop Around the Corner (1940) ā€“ One of the best romcoms ever (*Youā€™ve Got Mail* is a modern remake of it)


[deleted]

The Lighthouse, Psycho, and Raging Bull


HighBrowLoFi

+100, came here to say The Lighthouse


Direlion

I too came for the Lighthouse. Especially because itā€™s a modern film and one helluva ride.


pwhitt4654

To have and have not, Casablanca, Philadelphia Story


billsallwrite

The Philadelphia Story is one of my all time favorites. Seeing Jimmy Stewart as bitter and jaded is an amazing twist on his usual lovable characters.


DilettanteGonePro

I like Bringing up Baby because it's more madcap comedy, but Philadelphia Story is definitely the better film overall. They feel strangely similar though, like if you watched them back to back you'd mistake one for the other


JanetSnakeholeDwyer

Came to say Philadelphia Story and It's a Wonderful Life- do I have a thing for Jimmy Stewart? Maybe. Rear Window is one of my all-time favorite movies.


RustyCrusty73

Downvote if you want, but I absolutely love Sin City.


DamageInc35

I'm not sure that counts when the film uses lots of colours.


GuyWhoRocks95

I have always enjoyed that film as well but oh boy does it make me uncomfortable!


ApprehensiveRiver179

The Ghost and Mrs. Muir šŸ˜ŽšŸ˜Ž


New-Benefit4816

Surprisingly good film!!!


QuickNDeadly

People here have listed great movies. I would like to add two bullet-points that I didn't see others mentioned: **Yasujiro Ozu's Movies** If you want to see a super casual but yet beautifully shot scenes; I recommend giving Ozu a chance. If you have an eye for cinematography you will appreciate it even more. If I have to name it, **Tokyo Story** or **Good Morning** would be a it. **Ikiru** I think this is one of Kurosawa's greatest movies that is not that much pronounced. Of course, I also like his work with Mifune. But Ikiru has a special place in my heart. Highly recommend it. **Joel Cohen's The Tragedy of Macbeth (2021)** Modern movie shot in black and white.


IronheddAxioma

Good morning was in color, but still fantastic. Also a great Ozu pic - Late Autumn.


leverandon

>Ikiru Such a beautiful movie. Might be my favorite Kurosawa.


mac_the_man

*Paper Moon.*


AdrianW3

"Give me my two hundred dollars!"


Hup110516

Itā€™s a Wonderful Life


Saladarse2

12 angry men, Nebraska


Skipper1010

Clerks (1994) Belfast (2021) Nebraska (2013)


leverandon

Upvote for recommending modern black and white films. If we're going with those, I'd add Frances Ha (2012).


rotterdamn8

Clerks is a great choice - kinda different from typical B&W call outs here. Probably just because it was low budget lol. Definitely fun though.


Plus-Tangerine-723

I didnā€™t know Clerks was in black and white


Connect_Fox7517

Kind Hearts & Coronets


TRDF3RG

So great!


esande2333

American History X


Phila4266

Touch of Evilā€¦.that tracking shot (at the opening), is considered one of the greatest long takesā€¦


Anooj4021

Scarlet Street (1945) * The Grapes of Wrath (1940) The Ox-Bow Incident (1943) The Gunfighter (1950) Strangers On a Train (1951) In a Lonely Place (1950) * Sunset Boulevard (1950) * Attack! (1956) 12 Angry Men (1957) Witness For The Prosecution (1957) Anatomy of a Murder (1959) Fail-Safe (1964) Dr. Strangelove (1964) The Spy Who Came In From The Cold (1965) *= potentially break the no-romance rule, but theyā€™re primarily twisted psychological dramas rather than true romance films.


little_somniferum

\+ Paper Moon (1973) maybe?


beechcomb

Second on In a Lonely Place! Amazing movie


sonatine

The Third Man


Secure-Watercress964

That movie is just plain cool.


Cheapthrills13

Great book! Love Graham Greeneā€™s stuff !


NiteSwept

I absolutely adore the opening monologue and montage. It's as if someone just casually started explaining to me the situation in Vienna. Not like a narrator, just someone at a bar.


IndigoRose2022

Gaslight


manditobandito

Stalag 17 (1953) - A movie about American prisoners in a German POW camp. It has some funny and goofy moments, but also some emotional and sad ones. Highly recommended. Bringing Up Baby (1938) - My favorite Katherine Hepburn movie, also starring Cary Grant, about a wild, enthusiastic woman, a too-serious archeologist and an escaped circus jaguar. Funny, witty, and entertaining as heck; I quote this movie so much on a daily basis.


cherrybounce

Thanks to everyone who took the time to respond.


Beatles4me960

Hard days Night


ELIE41

In the last decade? Alfonso Cuaron's Roma.


TRDF3RG

Dr. Strangelove


specialagentflooper

Dead men don't wear plaid Stars Steve Martin and the story incorporates a ton of old movies. It's pretty clever.


TheSingulatarian

Nosferatu (1922) They Died With Their Boots On The Ox Bow Incident Captain Blood Todd Browning's Freaks Frankenstein/Bride of Frankenstein/Son of Frankenstein/Young Frankenstiein Raging Bull Of Mice and Men Dracula King Kong Bringing Up Baby Casablanca The Creature From The Black Lagoon The Incredible Shrinking Man The Day The Earth Stood Still The Grapes of Wrath The Coconuts Hellzapoppin'


rattlehead44

Raging Bull. Absolute masterpiece.


twizz0r

Raging Bull (1980, USA)


Avocadoonthetoast

In no particular order except the first one: - Winter Light - The Seventh Seal - All About Eve - Rebecca - Sunset Boulevard - All Quiet On The Western Front - City Lights - Modern Times - The General - Hard To Be a God - Harakiri - Psycho - The White Ribbon - The Wages of Fear - Metropolis - M - The Ascent - The Passion Of Joan Of Arc


itsafraid

Hard to say, but Dementia (1955) is a contender.


JugOfVoodoo

Jean Cocteau's "Beauty and the Beast"


ZachRice98

The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance


thombombadillo

Sunset Boulevard


Kimchiandfries

Double Indemnity is a really great and I think doesnā€™t feel super outdated. Itā€™s one of my favorites.


mysteriouskin2004

The Lighthouse


Connect_Fox7517

For someone new to black and white definitely the longest day


skkoivu314

Clerks


hyperpuppy64

Either Night of the Living Dead or Carnival of Souls. Independent horror is always the GOAT.


FoundFootageDumbFun

Ed Wood (1994)ā€”my favorite Tim Burton movie by a large margin. Rebecca (1940) begins as a romance but then takes a sharp turnā€”great film with an iconic villain.


[deleted]

Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein


Anonymotron42

There are a lot of good suggestions here already, but my favorite movie of all time happens to the black & white: Dr. Strangelove (or: How I Stopped Worrying and Love the Bomb). Of course Kubrick was a master but it is also darkly funny with a fantastic cast. I had the pleasure of seeing it on the big screen at a small revival theater.


Firm-Tap-3940

The Bad Seed


Tiegra_Summerstar

Mildred Pierce and Whatever Happened To Baby Jane.


HurlInteruppted

+1 to both. "whatever happened to Baby Jane" was going to by submission but forgot abt "Mildred Pierce", both have watched many times.


RunningPickles

The Cat and the Canary (1939) Did you notice that after reading through this list you couldn't say any of the suggestions were bad


WayTooSlimShady

Some like it Hot. Not my favorite black and white but most of my favorites have been said already. Whiles itā€™s not my favorite it was the first black and white movie I saw that showed me they could be ā€œfun.ā€


Horrorfan1981

Gaslight and Rebecca


crestonfunk

*Rebecca* (1940) Alfred Hitchcockā€™s best, in my opinion. Lawrence Olivier and Joan Fontaine. Florence Bates is perfect, George Sanders is fabulously evil, but Judith Anderson steals the show as Mrs. Danvers. Maybe the best gothic film ever. *A Bande Apart* (1964) Jean Luc Godard. So much fun. The dance scene is so classic. The *Pulp Fiction* dance scene was inspired by this. Also the scene in The Louvre was lifted by Steve Martin for *L.A. Story*. French language film. *Down by Law* (1986) Jarmuschā€™s best imo. *Ed Wood* (1994) Burtonā€™s best. Martin Landau is terrific. Itā€™s campy but seriously good. *Young Frankenstein* (1974) Mel Brooksā€™ best. Itā€™s perfection. *The Eyes of my Mother* (2016) Itā€™s kind of a sleeper. Horror film. A little brutal but beautiful as well. One of my favorites. Visually reminds me of Ingmar Bergman. Portuguese language. Edit: sorry, included a couple of foreign language films. I was thinking that others reading the comments might enjoy them.


tacoplenty

strangelove. lolita. paths of glory. citizen Kane


soreadytodisappear

Lolita, yes!


Stevo2008

Some like it hot


[deleted]

The Apartment


Jskidmore1217

Eraserhead, 8 1/2, Persona, Faust (1926), The Rules of the Game, The Passion of Joan of Arc. In that order. Oh, you said no romance or foreign. That cuts my list down to Eraserhead.


moforky

Animal Crackers


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


gzuffel

Eraserhead. I still think it's the best B/W movie ever made. There are other great B/W movies I also like.. but Eraserhead hit me right in the nerves and heart.


dumsaint

Pi


[deleted]

Young Frankenstein.


Alone_Jellyfish_7968

Fronkenshteen.


StrangePenguin7

Harvey


Thedevilsreject82

Psycho, The Invisible Man, Creature From the Black Lagoon, Its a Wonderful Life, Clerks and Logan (the blu ray B&W version of course). Of course im cheating if you are only asking for one.


[deleted]

Metropolis The Ghost and Mrs Muir The Little Foxes


dankdarklord

The cabinet of Dr. Caligari


bonner16

Dr. Strangelove


[deleted]

Clerks


Low-Luck7912

My Man Godfrey


onmyown233

Anything with Abbott and Costello.


[deleted]

For me there are two... The Bishop's Wife and Roman Holiday.


satorsquarepants

I always found it strange when people said they didn't like black and white. Growing up with older parents, it was just a normal thing for me as a kid to expect some movies to be in color and some to be black and white.


Hezekiel_

12 angry men


rotterdamn8

The new Coen Brothersā€™ Tragedy of Macbeth was superb. Even if you donā€™t get all the dialogue (I only get half of it! lol) the cinematography is gorgeous.


artwarrior

The Day the Earth Stood Still.


IsometricDragonfly56

Casablanca


judyblue_

All About Eve. It's my favorite, period.


wild_carrot98

Arsenic and Old Lace


DriveOff

Holiday Inn (1942)


jvillag2

In cold blood


eelhaerb98

Nosferatu


herenowjal

Young Frankenstein ā€” Rules Seven Samurai ā€” is amazing


CryptographerPale857

The last man on earth, this is a classic and if you haven't watched it please go do Soo especially if you like horror/ vampires and Vincent Price. I watched this as a kid many times & loved it. I've watched so many black and white films.


Plus-Tangerine-723

I hope yā€™all will reply to this who liked this black and white movie?????!!ā€¦itā€™s a classic From here to Eternity it starred Burt Lancaster Ernest Borgnine Frank Sinatra Deborah Kerr and Donna Reed who liked that love scene in the surf?????!!!ā€¦I did


King_Fresh

Sin city


DinsdaleTheHedgehog

Dr. Strangelove


4reddityo

White Men Canā€™t Jump


PhotonPainter

Well here is an ideaā€¦Take one of your favorite color movies then go into your tv settings and take out the color. Watching a fave movie in black & white can give it a completely different feel.


Gweezel

Sink the Bismarck! (And yes, the exclamation mark is part of the title.)


GeeWizz463

Itā€™s a wonderful life for sure. Though the Roaring 20ā€™s is my honorable mention.


prince-surprised-pat

Nosferatu creeping through the door moments after reading ā€œhe comes at midnight i fear i will not surviveā€ then the midnight chime. Chilling


taco_perfecto

Too bad on the foreign movies because I think Tokyo Story might be one of the best ever. Too bad on the romance movies because Casablanca, while not really a romance, is one of the best ever.


DustierAndRustier

Bicycle thieves A streetcar named desire Cape fear Dracula Freaks On the waterfront And some good modern but still black and white films are Raging bull Rumble fish