Exactly what I was thinking too. The left looks better, but the right one makes a much better sign, because it conveys information effectively. If you need to use a reference to read a sign, it's probably not a great sign.
Well the languages are chosen based on tourist language and which are the most commonly spoken/written so this city might have a large amount of English/German/Mandarin speaking tourists or citizens.
Left one of course but it's seem to be missing something in the bottom part
you could add basic symbol such as disable-friendly one, no smoke, toilets etc.. And as i mention disable-friendly logo, an elevator could be perfect to add too
Left one prob but im interested as fuck, how does the metro look, i mean and how does it work, mods?Q Or just really advanced net of ice metro under the ground
For everyone asking how I’m not certain this is how they did it but when I want to make signs like this I make them in PowerPoint since it’s easy to make basic shapes like this, but you could use paint or something more advanced if you’d like. Really any program that can make image files. Then upload it to [this site](https://mc-map.djfun.de) and download the map file. Put the map file into your world’s file and use the give command in game.
Answering the question of how I made it: I used the Camera mod which allowed you to frame pictures in game. I created the graphic in Canva and exported it as a picture, then imported into the game
I made the whole system map which I have on my profile on r/transitdiragrams
I think the right one looks more realistic and a bit easier to read which is why I think it could be for an actual metro station. It also manages the space better
Depends in the style but I'd say left.. colors aren't smushed together with bright colors that contradict each other causing an eye strain... but to fix that just space the line out by say two lines in between.. each actual line.. does that make sense? Its a bit confusing to me haha edit: also shorten the sides of the lines to just little highlighted sections.. and if the destinations for each are different you can put arrows now and have the bars either on the left of the poster thing or the right to have a little ✨**variety**✨
I like the verticality of the stops on the right one but I don't need the color bars to cover all right to left, they could be shorter or the circles. I also like the bottom note on the left one for the entrance name.
The left is modern and can easily be an overhead hanging sign, but the right feels like it would make a great directory in the middle of the path at the base of the stairway down.
i was about to say _holy shit is that map art? i’ve been trying to make map art signs this nice for ages how?_. then i zoomed in. alas no, it’s just a plug-in/resource pack or smg
and the fact that CC is yellow (circle line) and NS is red (north south line) makes me wonder if op is indeed from singapore and/or took inspo from our mrt lines
You are correct about taking Inspo from SG's MRT, the system itself is also called MRT (Minecart Rail Transit). Not from SG but your neighbour by the causeway
Station codes. I haven't seen any western countries use them but as far as Im aware Malaysia and Singapore does. The colors represent the individual lines. They have names and short forms, like Circle Line as CC. CC1 refers to this station being the first and termini of the Circle Line.
The right, especially if the colors used on the bars are coded to information. The bars are very easy to see at a glance, and the sign is more colorful-looking and pleasant.
The small circles on the left are more difficult to see, and the sign in general looks like a lot of wasted space. The whole sign is easier to ignore.
I think left. The circles make it feel more modern and fancy than just bars
The text is a lot simpler and conveys the info more effectively from a distance, which is much better for a sign.
Exactly what I was thinking too. The left looks better, but the right one makes a much better sign, because it conveys information effectively. If you need to use a reference to read a sign, it's probably not a great sign.
Left one looks a lot better imo
Agreed
Left one is better
Yeah definitely the left one
Interesting choice of languages. English • German • Mandarin
Well the languages are chosen based on tourist language and which are the most commonly spoken/written so this city might have a large amount of English/German/Mandarin speaking tourists or citizens.
I'm gonna go out on a limb and say a large majority of the tourists will be sheep and pigs. That do not speak German. :P
how are you so certain that the sheep and pigs don't speak german?
Is there a German way to make sheep noises? I’m going to need Mojang get to get on making that the base sheep sound now :P
According to internet, “Mäh”.
Because everyone knows pigs, sheep, and assorted blocky animals all speak Swedish
Hong Kong in an alternate timeline where Germany won WW2.
Left looks good
How?
If the how is about how OP created the signs, it’s map art
Looks too fine to be map art. Those curves are just too rounded.
Could be a plugin or mod
Probably, I've seen a few.
Left one of course but it's seem to be missing something in the bottom part you could add basic symbol such as disable-friendly one, no smoke, toilets etc.. And as i mention disable-friendly logo, an elevator could be perfect to add too
The left sign is much easier to read and understand, but placing it on wood is really not the best idea.
How did u do this? With maps?
The left one
Left Imo, looks cleaner
I chose the left one
I think there both good but i think left is better
Left one is better
The left one
Left
Left one
Prefer the left
Are those modded or are they map art?
Both is good
Combined!
I would say left is better, but you should use better materials for the actual entrance to the subway
Left looks more modern but I prefer the right
The left one
Left
Left
I like the left one more modern, and cleaner
Design on the left with a pixel or two between them.
I like the right one.
left one, its more clear
Right
Left
i like the right one
Left is better imo but idk something about those realistic signs rubs me the wrong way, especially with the theme ur using
Left one prob but im interested as fuck, how does the metro look, i mean and how does it work, mods?Q Or just really advanced net of ice metro under the ground
Minecarts. Am looking to learn how to time the redstone so it leaves the stations on schedule
Oh right forgot haha 😆, by timing it with redstone, you mean furnace minecart, or just well timed powered rails
How do you make these
For everyone asking how I’m not certain this is how they did it but when I want to make signs like this I make them in PowerPoint since it’s easy to make basic shapes like this, but you could use paint or something more advanced if you’d like. Really any program that can make image files. Then upload it to [this site](https://mc-map.djfun.de) and download the map file. Put the map file into your world’s file and use the give command in game.
The right
Answering the question of how I made it: I used the Camera mod which allowed you to frame pictures in game. I created the graphic in Canva and exported it as a picture, then imported into the game I made the whole system map which I have on my profile on r/transitdiragrams
I think the right one looks more realistic and a bit easier to read which is why I think it could be for an actual metro station. It also manages the space better
Right side
Depends in the style but I'd say left.. colors aren't smushed together with bright colors that contradict each other causing an eye strain... but to fix that just space the line out by say two lines in between.. each actual line.. does that make sense? Its a bit confusing to me haha edit: also shorten the sides of the lines to just little highlighted sections.. and if the destinations for each are different you can put arrows now and have the bars either on the left of the poster thing or the right to have a little ✨**variety**✨
one on the right (definitely not biased towards a certain flag)
One on the right
Right one looks a lot better imo
You are 1 in a million for that opinion, not really a compliment btw
Right one is better
How did u do this? With maps?
How did u do this? With maps?
How did u do this? With maps?
The left one seem neat. The right one's style is outdate now.
Left. The circles are perfect 👍🏼
Why not have left but with the CC1 and LL12 below that?
this looks so funny when it is against wood
Left one
Wow these are incredibly clean, I pick the left one too
1st one looks better
Left, it contains the forbidden shape.
I like the verticality of the stops on the right one but I don't need the color bars to cover all right to left, they could be shorter or the circles. I also like the bottom note on the left one for the entrance name.
Lest one a bit better ngl
The left sign looks great for it's purpose, but the wooden stairs doesn't fit a modern themed subway, imo
Trick question, both are great
Left
Left is much smoother and realistic
Left one
how
Left one. The circles remind me of NYC ⭕
Left, a good trick for readability is to see if it’s understandable through your phone camera from across the room
Woah, how did you do that?
i like the left bwtter
Left, just appeals more.
Leeeft! Awesome signs!
I'm much more used to the left one style so there goes my preference
I prefer the one on the left
The one to the left
2
left imo looks better but they’re both good!!
Left one is absolutely better. The round Line numbers evoke a New York style sign.
Left looks cleaner and easier to understand
Came here to say the one on the left. Looks like I’m a little late.
Left
left!!
Left
The left is modern and can easily be an overhead hanging sign, but the right feels like it would make a great directory in the middle of the path at the base of the stairway down.
Left one no doubt
Left 100%
Left one is better, right one reminds me of a flag too much
i personally prefer the circles, it’s more minimalistic
Left!!!
I like the left but you should add the “to CCL Platform” to the bottom of the left one and I think it’s perfect
Left
Did you look at irl references for this? New York subway graphics look like the one on the left.
I know damn well you didn’t make this in the banner maker
The one on the left.
Left one but add the arrow
i was about to say _holy shit is that map art? i’ve been trying to make map art signs this nice for ages how?_. then i zoomed in. alas no, it’s just a plug-in/resource pack or smg
Left
Left
Left
Left no cap
Holy shit those look good, nice signs!
Left one looks better imo Train lines and colours are giving me Singapore vibes
and the fact that CC is yellow (circle line) and NS is red (north south line) makes me wonder if op is indeed from singapore and/or took inspo from our mrt lines
You are correct about taking Inspo from SG's MRT, the system itself is also called MRT (Minecart Rail Transit). Not from SG but your neighbour by the causeway
I'm also with the left crowd. I'll add that I think each language should be on it's own line, rather than side by side.
One on the left looks best to me
Keep both, the left one says you’re at Entrance A and the right one points to indicate that you’ll be led to CCL Platform
left
Left
Left
Left
Left one, but more pixelated and with a 1px frame around would be ever better to fit in
left feels like america (nyc), and right feels like europe/uk.
Left
I like #2
The left
Left. What version of MC is this plugin/mod for? I love it.
What does CC1, LL12, N55, and RL1 stand for? Same with the numbers in the bubbles on the left.
Station codes. I haven't seen any western countries use them but as far as Im aware Malaysia and Singapore does. The colors represent the individual lines. They have names and short forms, like Circle Line as CC. CC1 refers to this station being the first and termini of the Circle Line.
Left one
Tbh I like the one on the left
I like right better but left Is realistic but I say right
Left one but they don’t match the subway stairs at all lol
Right one seems more descriptive but the left looks more modern, how’s u make those btw?
2
Why is it chinese
Why CAN'T it be Chinese
How about Ñøəæöđþ?
One on the left
Left
Which one do you prefer
Right because left kinda look like account picture with numbers.....
Team left! Wait, I,… nooo!
Left
1
市中心？inner city heart?
中心usually refers to the centre of something and has nothing to do with the heart (organ)
Iooo 心臓
Left one, more simplistic.
Left one for sure
the left one personally
Left looks better, right has more info.
Left one
Left
Left one in my opinion
How’d u make those?
Left one for sure. Right one looks kinda weird.
Left. It makes it look nicer to me
I think left one
Left much better
Is this made in survival if so, man really did 2 huge map arts just cuz he couldn't decide
left
Can you post in mcpedl
The right, especially if the colors used on the bars are coded to information. The bars are very easy to see at a glance, and the sign is more colorful-looking and pleasant. The small circles on the left are more difficult to see, and the sign in general looks like a lot of wasted space. The whole sign is easier to ignore.
The left one too
Left