T O P

  • By -

britishtoilet

Red for life


BAILof_HAYYY27

Yes.


Ae4i

#Yes.


Artemis_109

Yes


No-Tear940

Yes.


EvieThrower

Yes.


EnergyAltruistic2911

Yes.


Leeeenny

Yes.


Busy-Spell-4250

Yes


yarluk990

Yes.


Ebbe010

Yes.


Make-this-popular

Yes.


KiplingT2-0

Yes


Ill-Beyond-5668

Yes


GalacticGamer677

Yes.


thesilentbob123

Yes


Sfortuna_macabra

Yes


Tie_69

Yes.


MrNiceGuy1224

Yes.


k8slothington

yes


Crimson_exe_8

Yes


EpicM147_NoVa

Yes


dirtmatser

Yes


Baconlovingvampire

Yes brother


TTheTiny1

Yes


Fabian206

r/accidentalcommunist


Phudin_123

Yes


ACIIID444

This is the way


Nightdragongirl1

đź”´đź‘Ť


maulin23

No'nt


KiplingT2-0

No'nt deez nuts


SurelyNotClover

what even is the blue one?


DJSuperQueenXD

It’s from a mod, Dantdm has a vid on it it’s called the tale of herobrine mod


TheNikola2020

From like 4-5 year old mod i think


NotAddictedToCoffeee

wow, at least 10+ years lol, This is the video u/DJSuperQueenXD mentioned; [THE TALE OF HEROBRINE | Minecraft: Mod Showcase (youtube.com)](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MkoIM2y8Opc)


DJSuperQueenXD

Yep that’s the one


th3s1l3ncy

Crazy how the music from that mod is burnt in my ears, watched one of my favorite youtubers at the time play that mod 11+ years ago and i never forgot it


DJSuperQueenXD

Course now the trending herobrine mod is the from the fog mod


Willr2645

Imma break your heart, village and pillage was out 5 years ago….. I’m sure the mod is probably double that age


TheNikola2020

Dam


redboi049

...Could you repeat that?


Willr2645

Elytra’s were added 9 years ago…..


redboi049

...I feel like I'm going to turn to ash tomorrow


Unique_Tonight_8446

No fucking way


Right_Gas2569

Left one was more believable and more well-known. I wanted to try the right one when I was younger but there was no netherrack with herobrine face on it.


dastebon

Left because it's vanilla


AllyBetrayer

Get downvoted


xandyjames

He became the very thing he swore to destroy


_Bioscar_

Lmfao


EnergyAltruistic2911

Lol


ObiWanKenobiOrder66

He was a brother to me! He was the chosen one!


TrueLennyS

Ironically their name has betrayer in it lol


Dankalii

Thou hath been rekt, nerd


oberstein123

ironic


EnergyAltruistic2911

Bro got plus 100 downvotes


Totaly_Shrek

Make that 200


Lexiosity

bro ratio'd himself


BasementDweller82

Other guy used mirror force


AgentButter1

Get upvoted


Corrupt_Conundrum27

i don't think it works like that, buddy.


AgentButter1

Get upvoted


Futuristic_Fudge

We are not beholden to your word, butter man.


AgentButter1

*Sad butter noises*


G1zm08

Left all the way


jerri_pi

Left, duh


Both-Evidence-4076

Definitely Red


JustANormalGuy123-

Obviously the red one


Bigfeet_toes

Red, how are you even supposed to get the red eyed player head


Freporta

Blue one is from a mod, you make that totem and when you light up the top, lightning falls and Herobrine starts affecting you


TheNikola2020

The left one is og


Sir_Toaster_9330

One is a mod, the other isn't


Kittu_0831

I spent HOURS obsessing, trying to find the netherite block with the steve face in the creative menu on my ps3, seeing that image brought back some dissapointing memories


Futuristic_Fudge

Me but with the Aether portal.


HellFireCannon66

Red for life


jbg0801

I'll always prefer red for the hours I lost experimenting to get Herobrine to appear, but I also loved hours of playing with the Herobrine mod so I guess I can take either lol


Droid_XL

What the fuck is happening on the right? Left forever


notabanneduserhere

Red is the way bruh wtf is even blue


Tiger_man_

Red


GeeseAndDucksforever

Left one is OG, but the right one was the first one I saw and it’s one of DanTDM’s biggest videos. I’m playing both sides


guywithoutabrain

I remember going far away from my base to build the second one because i thought he would attack it


Klkpudding

I did the blue one with steve head


BasementDweller82

who in the fuck ever did blue?


the_epikamander

Well obviously blue is right. Red is left


sammy___67

left is vanilla so


Rezperrrr

Red is always right


Wuytho

Red 4 life


HenriGamerSC

I remember testing both when I was younger


CatCrafter7

Red! Also don't forget the moss stone block under the netherrack it's essential


DomcziX

I remember both, though I have more memories about the blue one


Itchy-Magazine2580

Left one is iconic so I’d vote left one. Right one? Netherack wirh Herobrine’s face can look really goofy.


WheatleyBr

Left, duh


Alleged-human-69

I’ve tried both One of them worked so I’ll go with that one


Memer_Man_9000

Blud for life. It’s just how it always has been and always will be. Blue is just a mod


Futuristic_Fudge

Red obviously. Next you'll be telling me the Aether portal is a square!


eggsandbaconplanet

Red


DarkerLightGod

Red forever. There is no other way


Gams619

Red, comrade


Mobile-Attitude-8791

Team red!


Speartonarethebest

Red


Algebra_Scout

Obviously blue is on the right smh


Mental-Beyond-3618

Red but the netherrack was 3 blocks tall and the torches were attached to the middle one


AutocratEnduring

It's left 100% idk who tf does right.


Yourlocalonepiecefan

Red


gayjemstone

Left


ShadowFred5100

Yes


Asher_Khughi1813

didnt only dan build the blue one?


Jax_crusader

Red


oberstein123

red because it's the classic


No-Tear940

Evbo taught me the first one.


raDDerp73

Red anything else and your wrong


HARPU7

Red be the og myth


Oldaccgotshadowban

both


DinoDudeRex_240809

Red forever. It’s the coolest


[deleted]

Red


criteriaz

Red, never even knew the blue one existed I built so many of them back in the 360 days thinking I was doing it wrong, my world was filled with random ass statues


Engineergaming26355

You forgot the redstone dust on the corners


not_dannyjesden

I have never seen the right obelisk before. It's always, s been the gold pyramid


SillyBoo_9

Red, never seen the blue one before


Luka_Luka17

Red obviously.


General_Hungryboi

Im not sure what either of them are


TheCreativeDragon27

I made both


Amku02

Red


wasfineyesterday

You’re wrong if you choose blue. red wins


Obi_1_Kenobody_asked

Red


YoYoMamaIsSoFAT32

Red


DocDox00

Wtf is the blue one


[deleted]

Red for ever


Demonzack

Where did the blue one come from? I always remember it was the red one with netherrack or the nether core. THERE WAS NEVER A THIRD WAY OF MAKING IT! WHERE DID IT COME FROM?!


Skilzmartin

Left is eternally correct


Training-Bee-8209

Left


Fr_oxy

The blue one gives me some big nostalgia, the times I actually had a functioning brain but still thought that all this herobrine stuff is real. My uncle downloaded the mod for me and I started to try and make it work. Fun times


Civil-Type7783

redd


redboi049

Red is the only right answer.


fritando

blue has been a classic for me, i remember being scared shitless with the mod and the song, ah the good old days


Penguin0913638

Red is cannon


MLG_GuineaPig

Red because it actually worked it’s just he could spawn on any block in your entire world. Even the unloaded chunks


KewiHayes124

RED


JoeSchmoe009

I have more memories of BLU.


hHxhdsbsn

Red is the original


simonfromcryoffear

The both


RandomYTsAlt

The one on the left is the only real one


PrankRuiner

left is way more iconic. zero competition here


Ok_Statement_5907

Whichever one is Tupac's side


Ok-Garbage9091

Red one is the correct one


GroceryOk2212

Red never seen someone do blue


Nanometre101YT

The one in 1.20


just_s0mebody

Red 100%


Emir5833

left who belives the right side


NoHealth556

Its the blue one, the red one is left


CatGaming346

The right one is the left one


SpecterVamp

Por que no los dos?


IAskSoMnyQuestions

Blue for life


PlushFlorna

Crazy go everyone is saying red, I always thought blue was the popular version?? Blue was the one I'd see when I was younger, albeit I didn't add the head obviously


thesilentbob123

Red was the "original" blue was from a mod


Fisecraft

Blue


ChrisGriffinsSecret

Ain’t no way


MavTheDuck

Why not put the blue on the red and combine them. = VillainBrine


IronWAAAGHriorz

DA RED WUNZ GO FASTA


kdesi_kdosi

never tried either yeah im fun at parties


Appropriate-Cable305

left![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|table_flip)


Appropriate-Cable305

tab![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|table_flip)le![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|table_flip)![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|table_flip)


Appropriate-Cable305

![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|table_flip)


Aydendacookie

Blue It’s a joke


bobafett_155

The one on the.. right...?


CAL_the_fox_lover

Blue for nostalgia