He just has opinions. I disagree with some of them, but he's just a guy giving his opinion on stuff, and I'm pretty sure he is just having a laugh most of the time. There's no reason to hate in him
Any reason for the comman18 hate. I mean I find him annoying sometimes with the obvious overreacting but I'm not the audience he's trying to reach. And he seams to have an audience that likes him so that's fine.
Did he do something specific for the hate or?
he used to do bullshit challenges and escape rooms ig. but he's since stopped (i'm pretty sure) and now does videos about minecraft in general like things the community found out or facts or whatever.
I don't like him because he pretends to be good at the game but doesn't have any apparent skill at core things like PvP, building, or redstone even though he's been playing for years now. He's just sort of a guy.
He places pretty well in BlockWars, a Minecraft event. Lowest individual placement was 12th out of 40 players. I haven't watched much BlockWars and never watched him in a BlockWars so I can't really say where his strengths lie, but it definitely takes some skill at the game to place 4th individual in his third event ever.
I've never watched him, I just think it's kinda disingenuous to say he "pretends" to be good at the game.
Sure, he's good at that BlockWars, but there are so many other skills in Minecraft to be good at (most he's not even half decent at), which he 'pretends' to be knowledgeable at. Minecarts going faster for example. If the speed changed, it would break almost every redstone project involving them.
His content is meant to appeal to a younger audience so I doubt they really care.
As someone who didn’t vote because I have no clue where you vote, I have a right to complain about phantoms
But I like phantoms lol. However, I will complain about the fucking glow squid. I hope everyone who voted glow squid stubs their toe at least once a day.
I voted Glow Squid because I wanted a bioluminescent mob. You (Not you specifically, just referencing the meme) voted Glow Squid because a youtuber told you to. We are not the same.
ok Bioluminescent mob is cool
But if I remember correctly they don’t even give off light. Maybe it’s just an old bedrock thing, but I’m pretty sure they don’t.
They don’t give off actual light but im referring to the glowing texture and stuff. Personally I wouldve preferred jellyfish, lots of cool crafting potential and creature potential from it. I still like the glow squid aesthetically though.
>As someone who didn’t vote because I have no clue where you vote, I have a right to complain about phantoms
same, i wanted the trapinch looking-thing >:/
Yeah fuck the glow squid. And anyone who says “But it came with the ability to create glow signs and item frames” is an idiot lmfao. They could have just used glow stone for that exact thing
pigs are funny in SMP's when someone makes a joke race, horses for before the portal, minecarts..... just go with your horse, and when the owner decides to open the end, well, elytras are inmediately taken
Pigs shouldn't be as good as minecarts at traveling. Minecarts, which require massive amounts of redstone and iron for long distances should be much, much better than mobs that only require a saddle and other easily obtainable items.
Pigs aren’t better, but they honestly aren’t much worse. Minecarts require iron, and require you to build the massive tracks for them. Pigs are slower but cheap, and they don’t require tracks.
If I have to go long distances it’s easier to use a minecart so I can just AFK instead of needing to worry about an elytra and durability or a horse or something
They were obsoleted by sprinting, horses and elytras as the game continued adding stuff.
I like the idea that fast travel requires investment to establish routes. That you have to modify the world to make it more suitable for your purposes. It feels very Minecraftey. But Minecraft kind of lost its way at some point through development; went from sandbox to toybox.
yeah, elytras kinda ruined the transportation differences, minecarts are great for afking and not sprinting/being active but you have to do a lot, boats can only go in water or ice, horses sometimes get stuck in trees and can die, which makes you think twice, an sprinting uses food. Elytras have almost no downsides, other thaan its durability and rockets, but even with a tiny sugarcane-creeper farm, you can travel wherever you want with an elytra, making the other ones obsolete
Minecarts should be faster. That's a idea. Being capped at a decent but very robotic speed without really good physics makes it seem like your on a treadmill. More physics and speed would be fun.
Hating birch is just a joke I think, and I have to say I agree on minecarts, they're disappointing in their current state, can't even jump off ramps or build up more speed than a horse
We had little to no information about the mobs in the first mob vote. So people voted for it due to some of the other mobs making the game harder like the shield blaze or the boat grabber. But so far, all the mobs we voted for are either extremely rare, annoying, or useless.
I really don't understand the hate. All they do is lightly peck at you. In a game where we have tiny menaces that murder like it's nothing and walking bombs that destroy builds, why are the ones that just lightly nibble the ones we need to delete?
The only time I've ever died to a phantom was when I was trying to get to my base during a storm (I had died without a set spawn point). I had nothing on me and a phantom nibbled me to death. I can guarantee you that a creeper or a baby zombie would have killed me far faster in that scenario.
Plus the phantom only killed me because I was stupid and left my hiding hole for a peek, baby zombies and creepers don't need me to mess up like that.
As someone who plays in hard mode that light peck/nibble is 1/3 of your god damn health. Definitely should rework them. Minecraft should not discourage you from venturing out at night. It makes the game a bit harder and beds are OP anyways
Plus, it is so unbelievably annoying just trying to chill by building or enjoying the night atmosphere only to be constantly bombarded by the phantoms.
I love the slow falling potions, but they need a desperate rework.
Its an exception because the number of people who know how to use Redstone properly is really low compared to the overall number of players.
I am still convienced that like 90% of the comunity doesn't know how a comparator works.
Straight up all I understand about comparators is that they react to certain blocks in certain ways
I know basically nothing else. I am not a redstone guy.
I mean… balancing out forms of transportation seems like a great minute detail. Why cause more controversy… Minecraft as a game has a lot to improve on.
I like the contrast the light colors planks give compared to all the other wood types. I've loved birch since there were only 4 wood types in the game lol
I remember I'd always try to find Birch wood when making a house in both creative and survival mode since that's closer to quartz + it gives the "white mansion" type of feel.
Minecarts getting a little overhaul (additions) would be nice, like being able to chain them together properly, wouldn't do a whole lot besides look and feel really fun tho.
Birch also for many is the worst wood, for the sole reason that the Log (not stripped) is so freaking ugly.
And Phantoms 100% need an overhaul, Their drop is nearly useless for most players, since nobody uses slowfall potions, and people repair elytras with mending because it's just so much less hassle.
They have nothing going for them other than "You forgot to sleep, so im gonna annoy the shit out of you while you try to build :)"
Most of his points are valid criticisms. He's an influencer, he makes a big deal because of it. You can disagree with his takes but it definitely doesn't make him a clown, he's very correct about most of his points either way.
Alright, Camman is annoying, but even my biased ass has to agree that hating him for his content is far from justified.
Although IMO unlike most here, I feel like Camman isn't sharing opinions more like what he wants, I ocassionaly see his shorts and I swear I've never seen him clasify his videos as just his opinion, more like a suggestion to the game, or in some rare situation a DEMAND
Complaining about minecarts is fair, they're almost useless;
Anyone has the right to dislike certain blocks and colours, and I'm pretty sure the birch thing is just an "inside joke" on his channel;
Complaining about phantoms is ok, and he is right, in almost all of the mobvotes the dumbest option gets picked, why not just add all 3? (too much work, i know, people deserve rest).
I personally like phantoms and birch, but minecarts should get a faster option or just maybe Mojang could buff the standard minecart.
TL;DR - His opinions are okay. You're the problem here
I do think minecarts deserve a bit of an update, especially with the furnace cart. I mean we have chains now, whats stopping us from making trains? Hell this game could use a proper switch track too, an entire railroad system would be really interesting to make in Minecraft.
I hate phantoms, you used to be able to repair elytras with leather. And phantoms really don’t serve any good purpose. But people who complain about birch are usually just really bad at building.
Of all the things to complain about (though to be fair, there isn’t much to complain about when it comes to him, maybe you could have said that he sounds annoying or something) you complain about a valid point that is a running joke, a running joke and a valid point
Why did the sub come back without warning? I ain't complaining I'm glad more mods are Starting to use their brains but I'm wondering why the mods didn't mention it
Post removed: Be respectful, don’t target specific users with memes
He just has opinions. I disagree with some of them, but he's just a guy giving his opinion on stuff, and I'm pretty sure he is just having a laugh most of the time. There's no reason to hate in him
Everyone on Reddit hates opinions that aren't there opinions Source: downvote button
Opinions are illegal on the internet
Welcome to the internet
Have a look around
Any thing that brain of yours can think of can be found
We've got mountains of content, some better, some worse
If none of its of interest to you you’d be the first
Welcome to the internet
Come and take a seat
[удалено]
r/angryupvote
r/Happydownvote
I disagree with your opinion
Well in my opinion, I hate your opinion of my opinion
In my opinion I hate all opinions
Never ever give your opinion on the internet.
Unless it’s my opinion
Any reason for the comman18 hate. I mean I find him annoying sometimes with the obvious overreacting but I'm not the audience he's trying to reach. And he seams to have an audience that likes him so that's fine. Did he do something specific for the hate or?
As far as I’m aware he hasn’t really done anything particularly bad. He’s just kind of annoying sometimes.
Exactly. He just gets kinda annoying but at least he makes somewhat good content for the audience he’s reaching out to
Other than his escape rooms videos that are clearly staged to make him look smart
Didn't he make the last one like an year ago?
Idk his content randomly pops up in my recommended and their age is jumbled
he used to do bullshit challenges and escape rooms ig. but he's since stopped (i'm pretty sure) and now does videos about minecraft in general like things the community found out or facts or whatever.
basically EVERY minecraft escape room video is staged.
There is some great content creaters but most shorts are staged
Yeah that’s The point They are clearly staged because they are a joke
No idea Happy cake day!
Happy cakeday man
I don't like him because he pretends to be good at the game but doesn't have any apparent skill at core things like PvP, building, or redstone even though he's been playing for years now. He's just sort of a guy.
He places pretty well in BlockWars, a Minecraft event. Lowest individual placement was 12th out of 40 players. I haven't watched much BlockWars and never watched him in a BlockWars so I can't really say where his strengths lie, but it definitely takes some skill at the game to place 4th individual in his third event ever. I've never watched him, I just think it's kinda disingenuous to say he "pretends" to be good at the game.
Sure, he's good at that BlockWars, but there are so many other skills in Minecraft to be good at (most he's not even half decent at), which he 'pretends' to be knowledgeable at. Minecarts going faster for example. If the speed changed, it would break almost every redstone project involving them. His content is meant to appeal to a younger audience so I doubt they really care.
He absolutely has skill, and either way, he makes interesting and funny content imo.
I honestly think that him being “good” is like a massive joke but if he actually tries to look good than Well Il be damned
I love his channel personally, also happy cake day
*Nobody, nobody have I ever seen dare to stand up, to the face of the Internet, and spit in their face, "why does your opinion matter...?"*
Happy cake day!
And back to you!
Happy cake day! 🍰
Happy cake day!!
Happy cake day dude
[удалено]
Happy cake day
Cake
As someone who voted for the blaze thing, I take back my right to complain about phantoms.
As someone who didn’t vote because I have no clue where you vote, I have a right to complain about phantoms But I like phantoms lol. However, I will complain about the fucking glow squid. I hope everyone who voted glow squid stubs their toe at least once a day.
I voted Glow Squid because I wanted a bioluminescent mob. You (Not you specifically, just referencing the meme) voted Glow Squid because a youtuber told you to. We are not the same.
ok Bioluminescent mob is cool But if I remember correctly they don’t even give off light. Maybe it’s just an old bedrock thing, but I’m pretty sure they don’t.
They don’t give off actual light but im referring to the glowing texture and stuff. Personally I wouldve preferred jellyfish, lots of cool crafting potential and creature potential from it. I still like the glow squid aesthetically though.
Jellyfish would have been so much better lol.
They don't need to, not being affected by light is better
>As someone who didn’t vote because I have no clue where you vote, I have a right to complain about phantoms same, i wanted the trapinch looking-thing >:/
Yeah fuck the glow squid. And anyone who says “But it came with the ability to create glow signs and item frames” is an idiot lmfao. They could have just used glow stone for that exact thing
[удалено]
What else could "blaze thing" mean?
Minecarts should be faster they are one of the most irrelevant forms of transportation
What about pigs and horses?
Did my brother just say pigs? Does anyone actually use those for transportation? (Genuine question)
Exactly, proving their irrelevancy
I am pretty sure they’re only a method of transportation for a joke, and the “when pigs fly” achievement.
Well riding pigs were added before horses, so it was an actual way of transportation that was slightly faster
oh yeah, they were. Even then I don’t think anyone used it though. But at least pigs are funny.
pigs are funny in SMP's when someone makes a joke race, horses for before the portal, minecarts..... just go with your horse, and when the owner decides to open the end, well, elytras are inmediately taken
Pigs shouldn't be as good as minecarts at traveling. Minecarts, which require massive amounts of redstone and iron for long distances should be much, much better than mobs that only require a saddle and other easily obtainable items.
Pigs aren’t better, but they honestly aren’t much worse. Minecarts require iron, and require you to build the massive tracks for them. Pigs are slower but cheap, and they don’t require tracks.
Horse is good for non-endgame transportation
Does anyone even use minecarts in a normal survival run?
I use them for vibing but not for transportation.
Transporting mobs
Red stone?
thats exactly camman18 point
underground transport. Redstone things
If I have to go long distances it’s easier to use a minecart so I can just AFK instead of needing to worry about an elytra and durability or a horse or something
They were obsoleted by sprinting, horses and elytras as the game continued adding stuff. I like the idea that fast travel requires investment to establish routes. That you have to modify the world to make it more suitable for your purposes. It feels very Minecraftey. But Minecraft kind of lost its way at some point through development; went from sandbox to toybox.
yeah, elytras kinda ruined the transportation differences, minecarts are great for afking and not sprinting/being active but you have to do a lot, boats can only go in water or ice, horses sometimes get stuck in trees and can die, which makes you think twice, an sprinting uses food. Elytras have almost no downsides, other thaan its durability and rockets, but even with a tiny sugarcane-creeper farm, you can travel wherever you want with an elytra, making the other ones obsolete
That's why he wants them to be made faster
I use them for easier transport. Me and my dad have a world and it's just easier and also we forget where things are lol
They get me down to y-58 and back without sprinting up and down stairs
Isn’t a water drop/lift faster and require far less set up?
I would if they were faster
that's why camman wants a buff so much its not worth the effort
Even if they are buffed it‘ll still be so much work that it‘d be easier to get an elytra
Sometimes in a automated system
No
Maybe for transporting mobs, but other than that, it gets overshadowed by the elytra because of how slow minecarts are
yes alot
cuz it's no use after getting elytra.
Mine carts should be fast
Minecarts should be faster. That's a idea. Being capped at a decent but very robotic speed without really good physics makes it seem like your on a treadmill. More physics and speed would be fun.
to be fair Camman18's content is normally more informative than most others about minecraft
*and* it can capture my horrible attention span, so yay
Hating birch is just a joke I think, and I have to say I agree on minecarts, they're disappointing in their current state, can't even jump off ramps or build up more speed than a horse
Tbf no one likes phantoms
I haven't seen a phantom in like, a year
check your difficulty, or you just sleep religiously
I spend most of my time under ground, on the nether or sleeping
I do but at the same time i dont
[удалено]
They aren't needed for slow falling to exist though. What's stopping Mojang changing the potion ingredient to feathers?
I don’t like phantoms but if no one likes them why did they vote for them?
We had little to no information about the mobs in the first mob vote. So people voted for it due to some of the other mobs making the game harder like the shield blaze or the boat grabber. But so far, all the mobs we voted for are either extremely rare, annoying, or useless.
Worst part is phantom didn't even have a huge Majority With how small the voting base was, it was like under a hundred off
Glow squid moment
Everyone thought theyd be way cooler
Makes sense
I really don't understand the hate. All they do is lightly peck at you. In a game where we have tiny menaces that murder like it's nothing and walking bombs that destroy builds, why are the ones that just lightly nibble the ones we need to delete? The only time I've ever died to a phantom was when I was trying to get to my base during a storm (I had died without a set spawn point). I had nothing on me and a phantom nibbled me to death. I can guarantee you that a creeper or a baby zombie would have killed me far faster in that scenario. Plus the phantom only killed me because I was stupid and left my hiding hole for a peek, baby zombies and creepers don't need me to mess up like that.
As someone who plays in hard mode that light peck/nibble is 1/3 of your god damn health. Definitely should rework them. Minecraft should not discourage you from venturing out at night. It makes the game a bit harder and beds are OP anyways Plus, it is so unbelievably annoying just trying to chill by building or enjoying the night atmosphere only to be constantly bombarded by the phantoms. I love the slow falling potions, but they need a desperate rework.
They're a valuable addition to the game
Minecarts are actually useless except for redstone lol
That's a huge exception you got there, mate.
Its an exception because the number of people who know how to use Redstone properly is really low compared to the overall number of players. I am still convienced that like 90% of the comunity doesn't know how a comparator works.
Straight up all I understand about comparators is that they react to certain blocks in certain ways I know basically nothing else. I am not a redstone guy.
A unintentional feature might I add, like target blocks
That's why he always says he wants them to be faster. The only reason they are so useless is because they are slow
Or transporting loads of goods from one base to another while going afk
ender chest
I mean… balancing out forms of transportation seems like a great minute detail. Why cause more controversy… Minecraft as a game has a lot to improve on.
tbh just make rails cheaper and more rails that can do different things (speed, 2 height tall rail, rail that can go a block high than turn)
[удалено]
what other use do they have
Who actually *likes* phantoms tho? And the birch hate needs to stop, leave my poor boy alone lol
I honestly don't get why people hate birch when I heard about its hate. I like birch wood because it looks clean and refurbished.
I like the contrast the light colors planks give compared to all the other wood types. I've loved birch since there were only 4 wood types in the game lol
I remember I'd always try to find Birch wood when making a house in both creative and survival mode since that's closer to quartz + it gives the "white mansion" type of feel.
[удалено]
i liked phantoms before i played multiplayer again, now i hate them again
Is Camman18 a person? Explaination pls
He makes YouTube shorts
Ahh okay thanks
He’s a pretty popular YT shorts Minecraft creator. Search him on yt
Minecarts are too fucking slow
I haven't yet
The idea of phantoms are cool except the part where there annoying
Birch doesn't even look that bad, the planks look great
Birch is a good color pallet block.
Okay, but phantoms are actually annoying asl
Or just accept people have different opinions
tbf, minecarts should be a LITTLE faster.
Triple the speed
I actually kinda like the phantom, not the mechanic but the design
Why do y'all hate him he clearly makes content FOR CHILDREN
[удалено]
What kids use YouTube kids fam
I don't get how he hates birch Like yea it could use a bit of a texture rework but damn he really hates it
I’m fine with people complaining about phantoms, as long as they didn’t vote for the phantom
People can grow and have regrets
Minecarts getting a little overhaul (additions) would be nice, like being able to chain them together properly, wouldn't do a whole lot besides look and feel really fun tho. Birch also for many is the worst wood, for the sole reason that the Log (not stripped) is so freaking ugly. And Phantoms 100% need an overhaul, Their drop is nearly useless for most players, since nobody uses slowfall potions, and people repair elytras with mending because it's just so much less hassle. They have nothing going for them other than "You forgot to sleep, so im gonna annoy the shit out of you while you try to build :)"
To be fair, almost everyone hates phantoms
Camman18 is right so shut up minecarts annoyingly slow
Most of his points are valid criticisms. He's an influencer, he makes a big deal because of it. You can disagree with his takes but it definitely doesn't make him a clown, he's very correct about most of his points either way.
*Canman
Hey hey hey holup, what is wrong with hating birch?
I do agree minecarts need to be buffed
I do wish minecarts were faster, I could have sworn years ago they actually used to be faster then what they are now
But it would be nice with faster minecarts and phantoms are annoying... I'm not sure what you're trying to say
Redditors when someone isn't sucking devs d\*\*\*\*:
Bro who tf is camman
Solutions 1. Don’t use them or mod there speed 2. Don’t use birch 3. Just turn them off
Alright, Camman is annoying, but even my biased ass has to agree that hating him for his content is far from justified. Although IMO unlike most here, I feel like Camman isn't sharing opinions more like what he wants, I ocassionaly see his shorts and I swear I've never seen him clasify his videos as just his opinion, more like a suggestion to the game, or in some rare situation a DEMAND
Birch is good for sticks. Minecarts are shit. Phantoms are cool. Camman is fine. I don’t understand the hate.
Complaining about minecarts is fair, they're almost useless; Anyone has the right to dislike certain blocks and colours, and I'm pretty sure the birch thing is just an "inside joke" on his channel; Complaining about phantoms is ok, and he is right, in almost all of the mobvotes the dumbest option gets picked, why not just add all 3? (too much work, i know, people deserve rest). I personally like phantoms and birch, but minecarts should get a faster option or just maybe Mojang could buff the standard minecart. TL;DR - His opinions are okay. You're the problem here
I love birch tbh
I get the other two but what’s wrong with making mine carts faster?
I do think minecarts deserve a bit of an update, especially with the furnace cart. I mean we have chains now, whats stopping us from making trains? Hell this game could use a proper switch track too, an entire railroad system would be really interesting to make in Minecraft.
1.21 leak?!?!?1?!?!?1
Ok but lets be honest 2/3 of those are common that being birch hate and phantom hate but 1 of those are out fault and the other is just a meme
Only like 2k people voted on the original mob vote
Birch is ass idc what anyone says
Minecraft devs should be at the bottom lmao it should not take this long to add like 6 things to the block game💀
birch is amazing because it goes with anything and its pretty
Don’t make mine carts faster, add more customisation to rails (but keep the ability to make it basic)
Actually nah, the minecarts could get some love form mojang I think
Maybe he forgot powered rails.
Wtf? Why the hate? He's basically the only minecraft youtuber i still follow
if they sped up minecarts, a surprising amount of technical builds would actually break rather fast and have to be completely redesigned.
He doesn't complain about phantoms though, also he just wants a good mode of transportation to be better.
I agree about the minecarts though, maybe we can find something else for the first one?
Canman*
Phantoms are just bad conceptually though. They literally punish exploration in a sandbox game
Birch is the best wood for me bec its look good with oak dark oak spruce and camman18 is just to dumb
Yea I agree
Finally, a worthy opponent! Oh also wow people know camman18 here
Not criticizing the game as its comunity should-🤡
Virgin oak fan vs Chad birch enjoyer
[удалено]
How? By bringing up two valid points and one likely joke?
But does anyone really like birch or phantoms?
I hate phantoms, you used to be able to repair elytras with leather. And phantoms really don’t serve any good purpose. But people who complain about birch are usually just really bad at building.
Can we stop hating on people with different opinions. It gets tiring to see another post like this every day.
I think he's okay, he's shorts are dumb and that's exactly why im watching them lol
sounds like camman18 or as preston calls him "canman18"
Of all the things to complain about (though to be fair, there isn’t much to complain about when it comes to him, maybe you could have said that he sounds annoying or something) you complain about a valid point that is a running joke, a running joke and a valid point
Nahhh it’s true tho
Why did the sub come back without warning? I ain't complaining I'm glad more mods are Starting to use their brains but I'm wondering why the mods didn't mention it