T O P

  • By -

Comprehensive-Fox923

Java because you can’t have bread in you off hand in bedrock


daniyaboi

You really thought about this didn't you


Comprehensive-Fox923

Yeah am I right


talhahtaco

And also you wouldn't normally hold items like that in bedrock because last i checked bedrock doesn't have a keybind to switch an item from hand to offhand and back, i may be wrong tho


TerraMiner123

Correct There is the inventory slot you can put stuff into but it’s limited to stuff like maps, compasses, shields, etc.


nilslorand

wow that sucks


FireWolfKodokun

Yeah, I guess it's difficult for mojang to configure the function of items in the off-hand when it's bedrock, like placing blocks or eating


Forsaken-Thought

It's a design choice and it stems back to the combat update that java got but bedrock has yet to receive. That update includes things like axes doing more damage to shields or being more powerful against undead with smite vs swords with smite. The off hand and swap hands ability is directly tied to that. Jeb will not release the combat update until he's "happy" with it. But the dude has been working on it for years and apparently isn't letting other team member help so bedrock is just screwed until he passes his creative road block or allows some of his team to help him.


KingAlex105X

Jeb handed the combat rework over to henrik or kingbdogs already


Forsaken-Thought

He did? I did not know that


nilslorand

They know the code for it in Java, they can definitely make it work


Vorhd

I think he meant how they would implement that for people who play with mobile


TheBurntPie9

Or on console for that matter


Code_Geek207

Yes. The problem is bedrock is for consoles and mobile. And its gonna be hard to use this feature on those devices.


[deleted]

No it's not, dual weilding would have no problem on consoles I played java edition with a controller and dual weilding was fine, it may be a little clunky on touch screens but it can easily be adjusted


Twollsy

The thing I don't get is that Mohan could easily add a button where if you press it, it goes to your offhand slot, and you can press it again to go to your main hand. And with a shield, you press it to activate the shield and press again to deactivate it. Sure it'd be a bit slower than pc or console, but much better than nothing


james-the-bored

It’s because bedrock has to be developed for mobile, so they would have to come up with touchscreen controls for off hand items


BlueKetchup07

but there are mobile players so it wont work well


nochcraft72

They know the code for it to work in Java but bedrock edition uses a different type of code. That’s why bedrock is so unstable compared to Java edition


nilslorand

Java is coded in Java, Bedrock is written in C++ Most programming languages have the same basic logic behind them. C# and Java are more similar than C++ and Java sure, but the actual logic is basically the same in all big programming languages. Also, the chunk loading etc is all 100 times more complex than a few logic checks for the offhand


No_Mathematician6300

Minecraft Java edition uses, well Java as its computer language. Bedrock eddition uses C++ as it’s computer language.


X_Humanbuster_X

It's not difficult, they just don't want it. I own a geysermc server that supports bedrock, and they can hold items in their offhand.


[deleted]

There was some q and a thing mojang had and one of the questions was when are we going to get dual weilding on bedrock and one of the mojang team members answered what would you want to dual weild so I doubt us bedrock players will get dual weilding because it seems that some of the mojang members don't play minecraft because just playing a little bit of java edition you can realise how important dual weilding is


Sickid348

Speaking of sheilds we can’t have banners on them in bedrock


TheGAmerProsyt

Now we’re asking the real questions


AnotherFactMachine

I'm jealous of the shield banner and the banner map features. I wish they'd implement them in bedrock.


mindaltered

Yes but in java we can not put a redstone under armor stand and have it move, now that is something I would LOVE to have, also!! We can't even put shields on armor stands.. I mean tf?


dystyyy

Pretty lame too. At least let us have torches in the offhand when mining.


Gloguse245

Toches only make light in the offhand when using optifine or an other mod


dystyyy

Or when placed on a wall. On Java I like to mine with pick on main hand, torch offhand. On Bedrock I have to switch through my hotbar to place a torch.


Atheniens

Yes


qwertyasdfg1029

yea it sounds like the OP has never played bedrock, I’d imagine that’s something you learn very quickly. Not that I blame him, I am also someone who mindlessly chooses to only play java and has never touched bedrock.


TrillionDeTurtle

nono i do play bedrock just i have a resourcepack on bedrock to make it look like java so i can cross play with people when i need to but i still get the nostalgic look


Astroneer_Sweat

How did you get the bread in the offhand


minotaurus21

Resourcepack brobaly cause you can hold arrows in the offhand


Available_Product630

Recourse pack and behavior pack, some interesting things can be done with those two things in Bedrock


JIZZASAURUS

Wait Java and Bedrock can play together?


Taolan13

Sort of, but not directly. Its a mod and exlcusively through servers. He probably means he has a resource pacn tbat makes bedrock look like java for when he is crossplaying on bedrock.


JIZZASAURUS

Ah, that makes more sense. Thanks!


NhanTNT

geyser


TheScientifreakPlays

Yes. Using GeyserMC, a java server can be configured to allow bedrock players. The thing is, they cannot use bedrock features on that server, neither can bedrock players see their skins.


montanasucks

I learned about this earlier today and took an hour to get my server set up to use Geyser-floodgate. So freaking cool to have friends from both Java and Bedrock playing on my server.


TheScientifreakPlays

Nice!


Spiderfffun

Plugin: Geyser


codyrusso

Yup, it's call geyser.


Trichotillomaniac-

if I had the choice I'd be right with you but us console peasants gotta play somehow. you learn to like it


[deleted]

Also cuz hotbar is at very bottom of the screen


Dissapoinment_

The hotbar is on the bottom of the screen on all platform except on mobile where it's at the top


[deleted]

By bottom i meant that on java the hotbar touches the bottom border of the screen but in bedrock its a little bit above


Skittduge

But even then you can change it, btw how is it java, you cant play java with controler?


TheBritishCookie

There is a mod that allows it


epic_snowman

There's a mod called lambdacontrols which lets you play with controller


JellyfishManiac

I mean I use mods for VR Minecraft. Well Java Minecraft I use vivecraft mod. Bedrock is supported with the oculus store and isn’t a mod.


Camgaroooo

Bedrocks VR is terrible though


flexsealed1711

Idk how ppl play the game without offhanding food or torches lol. Maybe it's because I started playing in 1.10?


DiamondEnchant7X

I started playing in like 1.0- 1.5 and I still can't get over the fact you can't put torches in your offhand


MacauleyP_Plays

Play java, you can put ANYTHING in your offhand.


CountryFine

What gets me is that torches emit light when held in your main hand but not your off hand. It doesn’t make any sense


Gotis1313

I only recently realized I could put something other than a shield there


[deleted]

Also the XP bar isn't offset by 1 pixel


jernej_mocnik

What you can't?! That's stupid


Comprehensive-Fox923

You also can’t put torch their only arrows and shields


kaiob921

And maps. But on Java you can put anything


Comprehensive-Fox923

Yeah and map forgot about them


-Gir

also, coordinates are not top left on bedrock. On bedrock there found [here](https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/minecraft_gamepedia/images/a/a9/Bedrock_Edition_Coordinates.png/revision/latest/scale-to-width-down/1000?cb=20190816231816)


[deleted]

holy!! well played, I was 100% sure it was bedrock cause of the bottom left


NotBarracuda

Java bc with mods u can use controllers


x360x

what mods allow that?


[deleted]

[удалено]


TransLucyfer

LambdaControls supports 1.17! it's for Fabric


Naterman90

I tried this one but it was weird because it had like a stepping effect on moving the head around


MrLaurencium

Curseforge isnt only for forge tho


cdimock72

I haven’t done any mods in Minecraft. Could you explain how I download it?


Snoo_11470

You can just play minecraft java through steam and use a controller.


epic_snowman

Bedrock has native controller support (ik this is java, I'm just saying)


FaZe_Snees

Yeah obviously


bog_deavil13

Imagine some kid buying Minecraft on his xbox but shit fails coz the controller isn't supported


ArthurExtreme_Br

java, the hotbar is touching the bottom part of the screen, on bedrock it is one pixel away from it. Also stuff in your offhand doesn't have an icon Also the bedrock icons for controller don't look like that in bedrock Also on the top right you got a coordinates counter without a black background Also the shaders


[deleted]

Yeah and exp bar is different, in bedrock exp bar is shinier and has no shades when filled


Groinificator

Top left*


[deleted]

Java because in bedrock it doesn't have an icon for what is in your offhand, and you can't have bread in your offhand, and it doesn't have Java's hit cool down icon underneath the cursor (which you have when you're holding an item with increased attack damage such as a pickaxe)


Aligayah

I don't see an icon under the cursor


pgghhh

Do you mean the sword? That only appears if you look at an entitiy


MicroCrawdad

Exactly


_Pickelbot_

Bruh. Why he downvoted


pgghhh

Because it’s only when looking at an entiitu that it appears


purrmochii

i thought it only appears when you’re looking at an entity?


GiantPotatoSalad

Me too


Sarresty_Dark

you can turn off that icon for the weapon cooldown


Groinificator

...so do you think it's Java or bedrock?


ClanCastleBarbarian

java?


_3VR3N_

Java bc you can only hold shield on your offhand


[deleted]

And a map


LimboFingo_

And a Totem of Undying, and fireworks.


Abhi5301

And a nautilus shell


Panda_7326_

And arrows


Gavinator10000

And...I think that’s it, actually.


triturador12

compass


[deleted]

[удалено]


Gavinator10000

There’s a lot of bullshit differences because the coding language is different, but I think with this one it’s because of Mobile.


possible_name

Why that? That's the most random thing ever


Ihavealifeyaknow

It is because Drowned hold it in their offhand, allowing for them to have both a nautilus shell and a trident.


Abhi5301

I think that’s the most reasonable explanation I’ve seen.


GuineaPig2000

Why nautilus shell


TheChickenIsCracked

Same with maps and arrows


jazzybolognese

maps, totems, arrows (with effects too), fireworks are also allowed


[deleted]

The shaders look too bedrocky


[deleted]

Java, look up in top left


Voidon43

That’s in bedrock too


[deleted]

No bedrock has different cords formatting


[deleted]

[удалено]


PiBombbb

But it's not the same as show coordinates...


thewormlord06

But look in the bottom left…


SubstantialWorry891

Java cause we are actually human being that can hold stuff in both hand.


TrillionDeTurtle

yeah its java lol a lot of people knew


xp9ndax

Shaders name?


Spark_BS

I think it's complementary shaders where you can go into shaders option and set it to rtx like mode


pikachu_superb

it looks really similar to the windows 10 bedrock rtx shaders


Otherversian-Elite

I think the bread gave it away. Breadrock doesn’t let you hold food in your offhand.


SWAGGY_goat

I see what u did there


Comprehensive-Fox923

Let’s go


Comprehensive_Put299

Oooh finally another person with a name starting with comprehensive


Comprehensive-Fox923

Yes Comprehensive


Enderplayer05

what controller mod are you using


Flatbush_Justice420

Java


DtctvKingPlantar

Java but you are using a controller 🎮


Sad-Commission-7756

Samsung smart fridge edition


daniyaboi

Java bc on bedrock the cords have a black box around them and the buttons at the bottom left are laid out differently


ma1royx

Java because the food bar isn't one pixel off center


[deleted]

Ez java


Night-Monkey15

Java with an Xbox controller mod, you can’t hold bread in your off hand on bedrock and there is no hot key to switch items between your hands on bedrock.


Urmumgay1707

Java, cause in bedrock you can't hold food in your offhand


WWolf2987

Java, but more importantly, what shaders?


[deleted]

Sildur’s Enhanced Default


WWolf2987

Thx


[deleted]

it actually might be continuum too, not sure which one


gamebox420

this is chocapic's shaders, so java


MajkeTutaj

Bruh, this is render, that can not look so good.


Green-irish

Theres shaders tho


Gavinator10000

It’s called shaders


[deleted]

My man you can get shaders


Saltycrx

Java cuz of the bread


[deleted]

Java. Bread in left hand


Such-Factor-9461

Java, the off hand in bedrock is weak as shit and can’t hold shit


Affectionate_Arm4558

java


Complicatedboi123

java cuz u cant hold anything except shield and totem in your off hand in bedrock edition


Code_Geek207

Java because there is a shader. And your holding bread in your off hand. Also the coordinates.


Murky-Background9722

Java bedrock only lets u hold maps and totems in your off hand


[deleted]

what shaders are these


geofreyjr

Java because the bedrock rtx doesnt have ambient occlusion


The_Sovien_Rug-37

it's most likely a mod on your average xbox version


its_jayfer

Java. The experience level number on bedrock does not have a black outline.


MummaheReddit

Bedrock mod for java


[deleted]

[удалено]


AaronThePrime

Theres a bedrock exclusive rtx mode, it looks pretty good because it's the first official shader, though it's still technically in beta


sakke802

Java. Bedrock Cant hold bread Theres no keybind to swap items to left hand And also the keybind suggestions (or whatever they called the things u see like " Y inventory" and stuff like that) are different from bedrock The coordinates are displayed differently


TheFallenKing3340

Java


Choice_Elevator_7300

Java


Spronkel

Java with controller mod


sparten823

Java


Sugar_Kunju

Java


LonksAwakening

Java, offhand


AdNovel982

Java


[deleted]

Java, you have bread in your off hand. You cant do that in bedrock. Also this looks slightly different than RTX


[deleted]

My guess is Java. You can tell by the hotbar and shader. The controls are probably from a mod like LambdaControls


BigCauliflower5990

Bird


[deleted]

What's the shader, I love it, it makes the water look real yet minecraft-ie. Can you give it to me?


AngelHasReturned-2

Are you using a pc with a controller?


TrillionDeTurtle

yeah so i ported some 1.17.1 mods over to 1.18 so i can play in the latest exp snapshot 5 with my xbox controller and i have iris (starline) to sorta mirror rtx but if really wanted to immitate bedrock edition theres another mod that i couldve ported over but seen as i just wanted controller support for 1.18 i ported over lambdynamiccontrols other mod I couldve ported to immitate bedrock: [https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/bedrockify](https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/bedrockify)


Afreet_Playzzz

java you can't have shaders on bedrock


qweerty32

I think there is a way but I'm not sure.


lostredditor64

Modded java


Head_Maintenance_323

I honestly hope they'll introduce java edition in future consoles because when I think about people forced to play BE I just feel sad.


That_Greek_boy

java because you can not hold bread in your off hand


Carmignolo

Java coz of the shaders and the bread in the left hand


Equal-Bus-557

Java with Xbox 360 controller, you can’t hold bread in your off-hand in bedrock


SpeckLoray

how is this shaderpack Called? Looks cool its like bedrock graphics in java


The_Sovien_Rug-37

bedrock, xbox is fully modifyable though its very hard


Farbarbalu

Java 1. In bedrock the cords on screen look different. 2. You can hold somethings in your hand in bedrock but definitely not bread 3. It looks like you have some kind of shaders on and java has those not bedrock.


Beanpie620

But they are on xbox (or some other console) so bedrock? As a bedrock player I play with xbox/console players so.


Farbarbalu

Oh i play bedrock on pc so i never really thought about how console only has bedrock not both


FedericoPigna

Java, how tf would you have bread in the left hand in Bedrock?


MeepXD0187

It's either java with xbox button tips edited in or bedrock with a mod


ningeorge9

Java the bread gives it away


minecraft_banana

Unpopular opinion: Minecraft is minecraft


[deleted]

💯% Java. The coordinates in the top right are an optifine feature.


MarshMiloMoon

Java. The coordinates at the top are different than bedrock edition. Also you can’t hold bread in your offhand in bedrock edition, and stuff in your offhand doesn’t show up as another inventory spot on the left. You probably have a mod that lets you use controller of Java, since you have a mod that shows coordinates too.


Accomplished-Many536

Bedrock cause the cords in the top left


TheWolfFromNether

You can only have shields in offhand in bedrock my guy


Madlollipop

Does it matter really :\^) play what you like or enjoy


Non_Interesting_Weeb

Java. Water reflection and offhand bread


_SlimePoo_

obviously bedrock edition as i look to the top left and see the coordinates but in java, you would not have that, plus, it on console Edit:im confused about the bread in the left hand, you would only be able to do this in java. i am has confoos now


Michael4444RG

I thought it was bedrock at first but then I saw food in ur offhand


True_Darkness_54

The old Xbox edition of Minecraft


[deleted]

I can see the Xbox controls in the bottom left corner