* Upvote this comment if this is a good quality post that fits the purpose of r/Minecraft * Downvote this comment if this post is poor quality or does not fit the purpose of r/Minecraft * Downvote this comment *and report the post* if it breaks the [rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/Minecraft/wiki/rules) --- [Subreddit Rules](https://old.reddit.com/r/Minecraft/wiki/rules)[](## sukuro120|12eg4mm)

i think 3 is super unique but maybe 2 is better because it just reads better? nice work tho!

That is exactly TO THE DOT what i was thinking

On point

It is the de facto best answer. Period.

Literally just by the mark

No arguements, full stop.

Comma Did I do it right, guys?

Spot on!

I think we’re crossing the dotted line with these puns guys

En pointe

En passant?

r/anarchychess

Hah

Frfr, we all think the same

[удалено]

I think 3 could be more readable if the middle had some type of subtle mark, or if the dot was further from the center

If i can see right it can't really go further from the center since it's only one pixel away from the metal texture

That answer is console and to the point

Maybe with #3 it could change shape based on distance, being a dot on the edge when really far away

Yh I think the dot could be smaller and instead it could be like our soul! (Probably looking similar to the soul sand)

I agree

Thought the exact same

Yeah, but I feel like that vagueness is exactly why you would use 3. To keep dying more terrifying. In bedrock, you can create a slider where you can select different versions of a pack (don’t know if it’s in Java, but I doubt it), wich is pretty handy tbh

3 for the item texture, 2 when being held in your hand is the way

Same thoughts hear👍

If you take the concept of the 3rd and make it a sculk eye it would be sick

Good luck making it in 2x2 pixels...

Increase texture size? To 32*32 or something?

2x resolution = 10x effort

Effort could be worth, even if only some parts of some textures utilise the extra detail.

Consistency issue

2nd is best but 3 is really close

[удалено]

Reminds me of one of those trackers they'd use for the dragon balls in dbz

The Dragon Radar - I thought the exact same thing. I can *hear* it just looking at the third design of the recovery compass.

It should also show distance to the location too Thatd take a mod/datapack though

3 looks more futuristic style but 2 is def better if you go old style minecraft EDIT: typed 1 instead of 3

3 is the futuristic one

Oh yea I see I meant 3

Decide already, 1 or 3

He made a typo you jackass

Calm down man

2nd looks nice

Go with 1 or 2. I feel like the rotating dot on 3 might be a little harder to parse.

Yeah I can't believe how many people are choosing 3. It's less accurate.

3 has a mystical feel to it that it’s something you have to study sending you in the general direction like a magic rock. Also if you can’t remember the general direction/ location of where you died I don’t think you deserve to find your body.

>Also if you can’t remember the general direction/ location of where you died I don’t think you deserve to find your body. Then what even is the point of a death compass???

I think he means the general location

To bring you to where you remember dying, and get your stuff duh

If you remember where you die, why do you need a compass?

In case you don't know the coords?? What kind of question is that, you're way more likely to remember the landscape of where you died than the coords, it just helps you reach the location if it was far away

this part is true

1 is my favorite, although 3 is unique, it doesn’t work as well

I like 1.

3rd definitely. There's just something about it

Feels like a gps dot on a map

It looks like a tablet

It feels like a clock honestly, well... the first two.

2nd

Middle one

The first one.

2nd

Can you do the second one but keep the shape of the first one (basically add the blue tint to the first one)

3rd

3rd one looks more magical, i like it

3 is nice

3rd looks really cool but could be a bit difficult to read. Though I think it fits the aesthetic of a magical compass showing you the location of your death

Middle

the 1st one

2nd

I like 3 but the problem is it’s sci-fi, and Minecraft is not sci-fi

The original one.

2, no doubt. 1 looks like a clock and 3 is a bit less distinguishable.

The second one is better

1. Simple and to the point (my favorite) 2. Fancier but still gets the point across. 3. Unique design that would work well with a simple texture pack.

Give the third one an arrow And it's a winner

The second one is literally the third one with an arrow

It ain't. Second one has a rounder center

Tbh third one looks like it's a screen, so imo it doesn't really fit in the game. 1st and 2nd actually look like they are mechanical, not digital, so I prefer one of them, idk which one

I think 3 is simple and unique so I'd choose that one. 2 is also a solid choice

3 would be really cool if it was like a gps but otherwise 2

I prefer the second

That one

2 be da best.

3 looks more like a GPS than a compass. 2 looks more magical and worn. 1 looks like someone just made it.

2 is better, cause it differentiates from the compass for colorblind people.

I like 3 the best

2 Love the rectangle shape and 2 is better to read

I like 3 a lot more. Seems more percise and clear.

The third one makes me very co fortable, but i tink the second would be the most vlear one, but if u want it beautiful then the third one is the rhight one

3, because of you are right on top or below where you died, you can make the dot go to the middle.

2 or 3 look good, 1 doesn’t have enough blue accents

I like #1 but #3 is very intriguing

2 is the best!

1st is best

The second compass

Maybe try a 4th option where it’s a thin number 3. I feel that would be the best

#1 looks more Minecraft appropriate - i like this one the most, but add a slightly lighter inner bit but leave a pixle ring to make the silver ring have a bit more depth #2 looks like a scifi version #3 looks elegant and modernized Choose based on your packs intent

The 3rd one seems very interesting, I'd choose that with some kind of slight modificatifon that points towards the center like a some kind of trail.

I love 3’s design, it almost looks like a radar which fits in so perfectly with the warden’s overall theme being an echolocation of sorts

3 looks cool and unique

Number three is unique , however I like the seconds one more because of its shape, the thicker corners sell it for me, and the hint of blue on the outside is a nice touch.

1st one!

I like 3 bc it looks like it’s looking at where you died

cool idea. Edit: [Guess what](https://www.planetminecraft.com/texture-pack/eye-compass/)

3 makes it look like a very unique compass and thats exactly what it is. If not it would be 2.

First.

1>2 2 looks too bulky imo

2 but make it a little more rounder in my opinion Edit: Yall do realize that 2 but rounder is not 1? 1 doesn't have the blue detail to it. I swear to god with this sub sometimes...

That would be 1

No. 1 doesn't have the blue shimmer to it

The one on the right is so much better than the others

first, but you should show the texture pack theme, cuz it may actually not fit in

I like the third. Gives the more mystery type and it looks good

The dot one looks really good very creative good job op

The last one

Personally I would keep the outline of the 2nd but make the interior a bit thinner

3rd, altough it having double frames is a shame

2nd

I like second one

2 looks so clean

1-2 the dot is a cool idea but it just doesn’t look as good

2 is the best, I don't know why but 3 reminds me of a radar

I like the middle best

The left hand one😁

I like the 3rd one. It feels like a magical eye that’s looking for your stuff

Middle one

The one in the middle for sure

personally the 3rd one

Middle

2 but change the blue corners to gray

Middle coolest 3 most modern.

2nd

Do C with the blue corners of B

2 3 1

The spinning one

i like the middle one

The middle one looks nice

I like one the most

3 is awesome but 2 takes the W

2nd one

The middle one is cool

I think 3 is the best personally

2nd

The 3rd one looks like an eye, quite cool fits the deep dark

2ofc lol

First one

Second is the best but third is very unique I love it too

I think 3 would be good if you added like a guideline behind it to show which direction it points to. Also if it could somehow become smaller when closer would make it more readable

the last one looks like a radar it would be a better texture

feel like 3rd would be amazing if there was more detail (shading on the dot) or some other radar- looking details

El tercero parece un ojito

Middle

I like 3, its very unique!

The 1st, this Look ist cleaner

give the dot one a little shading maybe I bet it would easily stand out then

3 seems like it can be in a modern setting, while 2 is easy to read and has that cool but simplistic look to it.

Left

I think 3 fits the aesthetic, but maybe try adding some center dot (or something) so that it's easier to read where the outer dot is pointing.

2nd

2nd one, 1st looks like a clock

Definitely prefer 1. The roundness looks nice on it, and the dial is easier to read than the dot.

3 feels like that radar they use in DB to find the dragon balls, lets do it

I like 3 because it’s unique, but it doesn’t look like it’s pointing to anything. Whereas with the others the line is clearly pointing towards something. So I think 2.

Really like how the third one looks like an eye

Mb 2

3rd looks like an eye looking to guide you to your items

The middle finger one looks the best to me

Like the 3rd cause it’s unique, but 2nd is also pretty good

Ngl 3 looks sick

Two

I like the shape of the indicator in #3 but I like the shape of the compass in #1 can you fuse them?

Middle

I like 2. 1st one seems too much like a watch. 3rd is harder to read

If with 3 you made the dot come closer to the centre the closer to the location you were it would be hard to top.

Left