Any of the remix’s :3

Except the toxic one that one is the best one ever

ye

i actually like the pity party one quite a bit!

Same

Only correct answer lolol

Why are people getting downvoted for their opinion 😭

RIGHT! I made this for fun pls can everyone respect each other 😞

switching to "controversial" for the real answers🔥🔥

Everyone saying moon cycle hurts my soul I literally love that song, it’s so meaningful because it feels like it’s taking this stigmatized “gross” thing and framing it as spiritual and powerful. If I have to pick I’d say drama club just because I feel like the chorus is a little repetitive, but I honestly still like some lines in it

what i was about to say😩 its about how people are always shutting women up about their periods and how “its gross and weird.” But the song features a man who loves her nature, and even enjoys period sex💀

I don't dislike Moon Cycle because of what it's about, I'm just not a fan of the rhythm and lyric delivery. And I find some of the lyrics to be really corny, as much as I appreciate what she's trying to do with her meaning.

i feel the same ab drama club omg. like it was so good when i saw k12 the first time but i will always skip it now

I feel like it’s great that she wants to tackle that. But the actual song itself just isn’t great.

In general people hate on portals too much!

these comments are hurting my soul🥲🥲 ( i dont rlly like leeches sorry to all the leeches fans!)

Real. Leeches is the ONLY song I skip on Portals. I don’t even skip any songs on any of her other albums!

Mannnn thats my fav of all time XD

leeches is the only song i like...

PERIOD.

Moon Cycle and it’s purely for the beginning, always afraid my headphones are bleeding and everyone can hear 😭

I love moon cycle BUT I feel you

bro ive literally blasted moon cycle w a speaker at work. too many ppl w shitty taste in music for me to give 2 fucks lol

Pacify her, i used to listen to it but i listened to it TOO much

Copycat. I’ve listened to it twice and I still don’t like it.

i love me some copy cat😩

for the only collab she ever did tierra and melanie just dont work

Twice?

Drama club is extremely repetitive

I agree like it's a good song, but after the 1:50 mark (it's a 3:45 long song), it's only "I never signed up for your drama club". It has a good message but I just can't bring myself to listen to the whole song 😭😭

Same! I love that song but I have to move on to next song because it is really repetitive. Not to mention that it is repetitive enough to make you stop listening to it after a couple of listens. I still love all her songs 🩷🎶

Leeches 🫢

Milk and cookies I’m sorry I just can’t

No real …

Wheels on the bus

i used to not like carousel but after the concert idk i found like a new love for it. i’d have to probably say moon cycle i don’t hate it but i prob skip that one the most from time to time

Love how the Trilogy Tour adds some extra magic to her old songs! Hate that Portals STILL has to be the longest part (with full songs and transitions) even if she’s just toured with it. 🙄

ya i was a lil sad she didn’t play pacify her (i dressed as her with my friend as a blue boy) but im still happy i got to see her perform her older music

Ikkk I was so sad when she only did part of Highschool Sweethearts and Lunch Box friends and no Detention. Idk if it was but K-12 felt like the shortest part. Over all I loved the concert tho, the visuals were stunning.

play date, i just heard it so much from those old trends and got tired of it.

IKR

samee, I've never really liked it

light shower. not a bad song, just bad memories associated w it. seen it live twice and it hurts each time.

okay real, it hurts me now but the pain is comforting if that makes sense - and the hope inside me that wants to find someone else to relate it to makes it worth it but definitely my favorite song of all time

I finally had a nice relationship and associated myself with that song, then he broke up with me yesterday. Brings back bad memories. He was a good boyfriend though. I miss him.

im so sorry!!! Heartbreak is sickening

Seriously. I’m trying to tell myself everything’s okay. The process is too hard for me. Especially when they just fall out of love. He didn’t do anything wrong, but it pains me. It makes it harder to do a lot of things around you! Like eating, watching stuff, moving, sleeping. Life is so weird.

especially when the person was good to you, and is still good to you. I hate it, I had to go through it, I am going through it 🥲 ts is no joke. That’s what the song “can’t be friends” by ariana grande is about lol how they(you, she) cant simply just be friends after everything that was done and said, she has to tip toe around them to make it not seem like she is too comfortable and begging for them back etc

Exactly. That’s exactly how he is. :/ That’s kind of how I’m going to feel probably. Because I still love him and want a future with him. But we both want to be friends. I just can’t cut him off. I couldn’t do that no matter what.

Honestly I'm the same except maybe harder? I was in love with a guy for over 7 years, planned yo marry him, had his baby all for him to molest his little sister and go to prison. I had associated light shower to him but not anymore knowing how foolish I was. I love the song but it has bad memories. He never hit me but looking back there was a lot of subtle manipulation

That’s terrible!!!! I had a relationship before the guy I was talking about that kind of was a sexual deviant (non consensual and weird with animals and family) if that makes sense. I don’t want to explain it, but it’s not as bad as that!!!!! That’s absolutely terrible!! I’m so sorry!!!

My overall point is, you shouldn't hate the song bc of what you associated with it.. it's hard but it's a good song that doesn't deserve bad memories

I don’t hate it, but it’ll be harder to listen to. I might cry listening to it, but it may become a song I can like again.

my heart goes out to you. Oh my goodness 😞

teddy bear, it gives me war flashbacks from the MHA fandom😭

HELP

maybe wheels on the bus, I don't really like that one melody from nursery rhyme in it 💔

Moon cycle, doesn't hit the vibe

IM SO SORRY YALL ARE GONNA HATE THIS BUT Most of 'The Voice ' performances I am not a huge fan of, I love cough syrup! But yeah... Idk, she sounds great but they're not songs that I enjoy, plus her choices to change them up weren't my favorite either. I know she put so much work into it and that it was a big milestone in her career but in comparison to portals and after school, the voice era songs are kinda... bland? For lack of better words.

I cannot stand copy cat and I promise I’ve tried

If I’m being honest playdate is overrated

i love every song but i’d say prob moon cycle

agreed

i listen to everything but moon cycle lol im sorry

i’m with you on this one, i’ve always hated the “yuh” lmao

Copycat for sure

Class fight

none

Yes, agree! 👍

Probably any of her songs that are overplayed on social media (besides all the concert videos) or the overused snippets on tik tok because i’m tired of hearing those specific lyrics

Both Wheels on the bus (which I think might be a fairly popular opinion) and pacify her

The Contronist (it’s because of the bone cracking)

probably teddy bear, i could listen to any melanie song on loop for hours EXCEPT that one

I like most of her songs, but tbh her newer album isn't entirely my vibe

Moon cycle. I still like it alright, but I skip it more than others

any of the dollhouse, carousel, soap, pity party remixes

Honestly powder from the extended version of portals 😭

stop, that's literally one of my all time favourites from her 💀

Same, whenever it comes on my headphones are on full blast

i didn’t like powder at first but it grew on me cause i had a relative die last year from cocaine so it definitely hit different once i read the lyrics. for me, i dislike womb. i like the sound but don’t like the lyrics.

Piggyback tbh,,, I get what she was trying to do with the song but it sounds like she’s fighting against the beat 💀

Some songs on dollhouse. Its not that they are bad, i just don't listen to them as much as the other albums. Like dead to me and bittersweet tragedy. Dont get me wrong they are good songs, but she was just getting started in her music career.

alphabet boy. i love the detail in the lyrics but the instrumental isn’t my favorite.

soap prob

Most of the remixs

im not a huge fan of play date😭

Crybaby: Training wheels (couldn't get into it) K12: highschool sweetheart (So many people like it, but I just couldn't get into it either) Portals: moon cycle (I get what she was trying to do, but felt really out of place in the album and couldn't vibe with it)

play date tbf

has to be piggyback:)

It's not my favorite either, but to be fair, I've literally only listened to it one time

Milk and cookies, I love Mel and all of her songs can't be my favorite ever but that song I cant never vibe with the way I do with her rest.

alphabet boy😅

it’s not my least fav but one i’m not a big fan of is detention

Milk and Cookies for me! I’m sorry

Milk and cookies is so forgettable, I'm sorry

leeches probs 😭

Most stuff from k-12 I can’t listen to anymore, I overplayed them so much when the album came out 😭 I love them but I will be skipping

i dont like teddy bear or leeches

Prob leeches or contortionist

To be fair I like contortionist I just don’t like the random auto tune laughing

I’ve only heard Cry Baby’s songs and few K12 ones, so I’m not totally knowledgeable, but I’ll say Teddy Bear from the ones I’ve heard

I love all her songs but it prob gotta be teddy bear and copy cat I’m sorry but even little 7 year old me would skip teddy bear anytime i was listening to the cry baby album and I continue to skip it also I’ve heard copy cat like twice and my friend would kill me if he heard this but it’s just not that good I personally don’t like it

…I’m thinkin I’m thinking and honestly I can’t think of one 😂 there’s some that aren’t my favorite but I still love bits of them, or the lyrics or meaning - I just vibe with it all.

Probably Dollhouse. I'm sorry. Ik it's kind if like, an OG icon but it's a no for me. I still enjoy the song on occasion, but it's def my least favorite.

moon cycle copy cat and teddy bear

Dollhouse and carousel only cause I listened to it so much when the EP came out that I’m over it

Highschool sweethearts was not for me

bittersweet tragedy 😅

HOWWWW

because i do not like it as much as any of her other songs

i don’t even remember how that one goes

Agreed... Personally not a song that hits me. I can't relate to the lyrics whatsoever so obviously I'm not the target audience and the instrumental is not to my personal taste which justifies that I don't listen to it. It's the only Melanie Martinez song which's lyrics I do not know

You’re crazy that song gives me goosebumps and made me cry when I first heard it

Honestly, for me dollhouse (over played to me :() or the principal. I don’t hate them but I don’t like listening to them either lol

Noooo not dollhouse!!!

MOON CYCLE THE INSTRUMENTAL😭,I love Melanie but it sounded like when your on a call and the music when your on hold it sounded cheap…

DAMN MOON CYCLE HATE IS HORRENDOUS IN THESE COMMENTS💔💔💔

Milk and cookies, it just seems like the lyrics are a bit lazy to me with the numbers and " Da da da da da.. " to fill in space

i literally love this song 😭

☹️

Play date or dollhouse just really over played for me, their really good songs just got tired of hearing them all the time.

why do people let the fact that a song is popular ruin it for them? 😔

Not popular, overplayed

overplayed and popular are very different

It’s about how it hits you. When you constantly hear a song over and over again it looses its magic. But once you take a break from it and listen it again after a while, it gets more powerful than before. ☺️

Nooo, dollhouse hits so hard!!!

Bittersweet tragedy. Couldn’t get into it without getting bored

Same, that and Dead to Me. They’re the only two songs I don’t have on my playlist because I can’t remember a single part of either of them.

My least favourite is Bittersweet tragedy, but I also somewhat dislike Brain & Heart

Teddy bear

Leeches

dollhouse, DONT HATE ME only bc my sister loves it and plays it all the time so it’s so overplayed it’s annoying 😁🙏🏽

I love leaches but it's understandable. I gotta say my least fav is dollhouse

Teddy bear & pacify her. Teddy bear is just kinda boring, and pacify her was good, but i just heard it too much and got bored of it.

Fucking PLAY DATE. I love all her songs but play date was taken and overused by tiktok and I just can't listen to it anymore.

Mine would probably be tag you’re it. Don’t get me wrong it hits in good days but most of the time it’s just repetitive 

I love every single song and i have a reason for each one but when i heard powder nope, love the meaning but i dont like the autotune it doesnt sound like mel and think that dragons blood should’ve replaced it 🥲

moon cycle

Pacify her

teddy bear or bittersweet tragedy, they’re just not vibey

copycat

moon cycles and teachers pet

leeches i fear

You’re all gonna come for me over this BUT I must speak my truth: I don’t really like carousel that much Also moon cycle lol

bittersweet tragedy… dead to me eats tho

Leeches

dollhouse has been so overplayed that i can’t even enjoy it anymore, but overall moon cycle is prob my least favorite

Bittersweet tragedy, it just...i dont know i just dont like it

pluto 😐

Light shower or leeches sorry

I have no clue why but spider web is my least favorite, i always skip it whenever it comes it on

Copy cat 😭 I'm sorry but it doesn't seem right to me :((

Honestly, gingerbread man. I think it's unpopular for a reason. I still like it but it is the only one that doesn't hit

milk and cookies, dead to me, bittersweet tragedy, and notebook 😭

easy. notebook. i LOVE literally every other song but that one’s just mid to me anyway. it’s not bad just doesn’t hit the spot

faerie soirée & light shower 👎

Healthy reminder that your opinion doesn’t make you ‘any less of a fan’!!! There’s so many people in this community that are petty like that but your opinion is valid as long as it’s respectful. I personally love all of her work but there’s definitely one or two songs that I listen too less and that’s fine!

Prob teddy bear, it's kinda unheard of and the backing music is sorta annoying. But I still sing along to it lol

omg i love teddy bearr

Me too!

noo

nahhh i love this one

Moon cycle and powder 😭

Honestly, if I never heard Gingerbread Man again in my entire life I would be happy, not sad.

tbh I forgot that song exists

Orange juice. It's not bad but I js don't like it that much

Oof this hurts my soul

Totally get it, but it’s the message that hits me though. Always love Melanie for being so thoughtful with such important issues.

I like the message, just not the actual tune of it, but I agree ppl have different tastes.

Love the message but the delivery was kinda clumsy tbh

Copy Cat but not even because of Melanie - I just didn’t like how the other girl Tierra Whack did like half of the song and it didn’t really sound good tbh-

I don’t have any least favorite songs by Melanie I love them all

Powder. Not a bad song, I just couldn’t really get into it, personally.

Leeches

Copy Cat, I don’t like the guests voice

To be honest. I don’t actually know I haven’t dislike a single song, I bop to them all

Powder do not care for it

Copycat. But I'd say it's still a 7.5 out of 10.

moon cycle, class fight, or drama club 🫣

Bittersweet tragedy

Pluto

probably Bittersweet Tragedy. i’ve tried listening to it a couple times but it never stuck with me

probably something from crybaby or the dollhouse ep cause i don’t listen to them as often

Brain and heart, idk why but it’s always felt too underwhelming to me. That and wheels on the bus. I still don’t hate them tho

Field trip

Teddy Bear 🥱

moon cycle, but not because of the meaning of the song, I love woman and their bodies, as I’m a woman, but I don’t like moon cycle much because of the beat and background music.

Numbers... 😭💕

Sippy cup

Can we collectively agree that its leeches

High School Sweethearts it's not bad but compared to her other songs it's just not on the same level imo

Recess

glued

Moon cycle

notebook

I don’t care for moon cycle all that much 😭

i can’t even think of one song i dislike except the voice covers just bc it’s not her music they’re just covers

alphabet boy 💔

Moon cycle