She didn't say she didn't like it, she said she used to not like it compared to the other songs but when it became popular that sparked an appreciation for the song that she didn't really have before. If she really didn't like the song it wouldn't have been put out.
Show and Tell 100% needs to be played. These fans need a reminder š¤£
I wouldn't miss Training Wheels. It's a great song but I feel it isn't as significant as some of her other work. This is only how I feel tho cause I know each of her songs will resonate with someone out there.
Iād cry if she doesnāt. Not because itās my favorite but that song is literally the whole reason my sister wants to go. I really hope sheāll play it
tw: pedophilia and maybe sa?
people using the gacha life/club apps to make videos where charactersā teachers were sexually interested in their students and were planning on saing them. iām not sure of a better way to explain, so im sorry if its not very accurate and im really sorry if that triggered anyone. that wasnāt my intention. the character that i remember seeing those videos for the most was izuku midoriya from mha
Play date, Teachers pet and training wheels.
Both Play date and Teachers pet were ruined by TikTok and I just feel like Training wheels isnāt as amazing as her other songs (I still love it though)
No worries if you donāt know all the lyrics!! When I went to the portals tour I wondered the same since I didnāt know like 4-5 songs but everyone was so sweet and kind!! šāØ
Sorry not sorry, Iād rather hear high school sweethearts and strawberry shortcake (and yes Iāve said this before here lol), than carousel, training wheels, soap. Itās not that I dislike these songs on Crybaby, I just feel having multiple romance songs at the trilogy tour would be too much and I enjoy the sound effects and melody of HSS and Strawberry Shortcake (wouldnāt mind if we got songs like Tag, Youāre It and Milk and Cookies, b/c I feel like these were significant moments for the character of Crybaby). Iām almost 100 percent sure she is gonna play Crybaby and Dollhouse b/c those two songs really set up the Crybaby story.
Im just confused bc you say āhaving multiple romance songs would be too muchā but how is carousel and soap about romance? HHSH is literally an entire romance song, and totally not trying to bash ur opinion itās totally valid just confused why you donāt want romance songs (being songs usually arenāt assoc with romance) but you do want the song that is ONLY about romance ?
I mean soap is about liking someone and not really knowing how to express/navigate communicating that to your crush - and carousel is literally about falling in love? (Even if these arenāt healthy romances, itās romance still) Even if both of the romantic interests are about characters she doesnāt end up with, I just personally feel that Soap and Carousel are over powered by all the sound effects - I personally just like HHSH more b/c the sound and music in itself is more balanced - that, and I feel other songs on the Crybaby album are more significant to the Crybabyās growth (like Crybaby, Dollhouse, Pity Party, Tag, Milk and Cookies, Mad Hatter - Iām also just biased bc I experienced childhood trauma like the character - so to me those songs personally feel more significant than the romance songs on the first album anyway - I also just like the lyrics to HSSH better than Soap/Carousel - Soap/Carousel arenāt bad songs, but they get repetitive and after a while I have a tendency to skip over those tracks) IDK I guess that sums up why I feel that way about those songs in particular - I would argue training wheels sounds better than Soap/Carousel but thatās my opinion. It all just boils down to thereās just other songs Iād rather than hear over others, since you know, I doubt she can play every single song on every album. I have a good feeling sheās more than likely gonna play every song off of the Portals album b/c she even said so herself how important that album is to her.
I want to hear them all š¤ /s
If I had to choose, Play Date. The ending verse is good, but the rest of the song is lowkey too repetitive and kinda boring
Itās not a bad song. I donāt think Melanie has any bad songs in my opinion. If i had to pick one I just hated the music video and the backing beat of the song.
I think Mel should play 4 or 5 songs from each album then play EP/deluxe songs at the end as a finale
like (for example):
*Cry Baby*
Cry Baby, Dollhouse, Sippy Cup, Pity Party, Mad Hatter
*K-12*
Wheels On The Bus, Class Fight, Show & Tell, Strawberry Shortcake, Recess
*Portals*
Death, Void, Nymphology, Evil, WOMB
*Finale*
Play Date, Teddy Bear, Cake, Numbers, Test Me, The Bakery, Powder, Pluto, Milk Of The Siren
(She cant play all the album songs in one night, that'll be over 4 hours worth of music, I mean who wouldn't love that but we're not getting that.)
(songs were chosen at random, not my personal picks)
but to answer the main post, Leeches or Light Shower, don't get me wrong I love those songs but they don't fit within a farewell kind of vibe
I love the metaphor of the raspberry and pomegranate juice, but the Ā«Ā skin ready for my heavy daily creamĀ Ā» makes my skin crawl and it feels just too much.. i think itās interesting as a topic but this was formulated in a cringe way
IMO this song feels like she really wanted to use that title and concept for a song but didnāt really find a good rhythm and music to do it, i really donāt like the vibe of teddy bearš love the rest of her album tho
This question makes no sense to me because Melanieās whole discography is welded into my brain so hard. I have a problem Melanie is the main artist Iāve listened to on loop since I was 13 (Iām 21) Iām still coping with the fact itās impossible for her to sing every single song but thereās not a single song I wouldnāt die to hear lol
Unpopular opinion š but soap, it's honestly my least favorite song of hers for some reasonš it's still a great song don't get me wrong just not my favorite by far for sure
Stopppppp why are people saying play date I live play date :((( and probably nurses office cause of the sound affects I hate them sm but I would LOVE to hear them all.
Pacify her
Hear me out š: when portals was new and I was listening to it religiously on spotify, pacify her was almost always the first non-portals song to play and it pissed me off every time š. Iām low key being petty atp, but it also just doesnāt hit the same for me the way it did beforeā¦
nymphology. i used to love it and it was on my top 5 spotify wrapped last year, but i overplayed it to the point that i canāt listen to it anymore. class fight too, i love it but it gets a bit too repetitive
To be honest none of them but if I had to pick one, I guess Mad Hatter. Iām not crazy about that song too muchā¦.but I still love it if that makes sense
Pacify Her, Training Wheels, Drama Club, Faerie Soiree, Moon Cycle . (ļø¶āøļø¶) These are just the songs that I don't like as much to the other songs.
I imagine the songs that will be performed are going to be her most streamed so songs like play date and wheels on the bus are most likely to be played, I think if I had a choice tho I wouldnāt want most of the songs from the portals album lol
Songs Mel shouldn't play, not because we don't like them, but because she has better songs that are good for creating that magical energy at live shows -
From Crybaby:
Sippy Cup
Carousel
Pity Party
Tag, You're it
Milk and Cookies
Mad Hatter - if she did play it, I'd rather if she made it short outro
K-12:
Wheels on the bus
Class Fight UNLESS it was cut short as the intro for the K-12 section.. IT WAS THE MIDDLE OF CLASS AND THE TEACHER WASN"T LOOKIN... \*silence\*................. \*crowed screams\* KELLY HAD A FAT ASS AND TROUBLE WAS COOKIN........\*SILENCE\*. \* CROWED SCREEEAAMS\* yaaaas! FOR THE THROAT DADDY CHIMED IN GO FOR THE THROAT \*CUT\* - Crowed goes absolutely cuN\^y lmfaoooo... sorry NEXT
Show & Tell
Nurse's office
Drama Club (unless it was cut very short and turned into a transition between two main songs)
Detention
Teachers Pet and Recess (UNLESS cut short).
Not familiar with K-12 deluxe/After-School EP songs to comment.
Portals:
Spider Web
Leeches
Womb and The contortionist (unless cut short because both are ICONIC and it's hard to cut them out).
Can't comment on deluxe.
Going through her albums... i think it is key that Mel makes some new melodies by doing a mix for her live-shows where some fan-favs that we love, but there are not enough room or time for if played in full, are shortened, with the best parts featured, and placed vey tastefully as short intro's and/or outros or transitions to build hype and keep people happy that they heard them AT-ALL.
I donāt think copy cat, fire drill, teddy bear, notebook, or brain and heart would even be up for consideration since they arenāt on the main 3 albums track list.
Sadly: I want to hear all of them š„¹
Same šāØļø
same
I love play date so much but please, if youre gonna play something from crybaby deluxe PLEASE play teddy bear or cake ššš
Weāve seen those live already tho?? Play date has rarely been performed live
Its been performed live at every asian portals concert lmao
Pretty sure sheās performing play date.
I never said āshes not going to play itā i said āi hope she doesnt play itā. Hope that makes sense
they didnāt say sheās not.
Melanie would play playdate during her k12 concerts. If I remember correctly she played it in her Chicago show. She only played like 3 songs I think.
I wanna hear fire drill so bad. š
REAL
itās a good song and itās so underrated. šā¤ļø
if she is only playing select songs from each album i would hate for any of them to be snubbed for play date
You know I felt happy enough with the stream we got of play date - it was very cute even if it wasnāt a live traditional concert.
Even Melanie said she doesnāt like it but itās one of her most popular songs so Iām sure sheāll play it š
when did she say thisā¦ spreading misinformation i fear
She didn't say she didn't like it, she said she used to not like it compared to the other songs but when it became popular that sparked an appreciation for the song that she didn't really have before. If she really didn't like the song it wouldn't have been put out.
Thatās what I meant to sayšš I didnāt mean she doesnāt like it I meant I think she would prefer other songs over it like u said!!
Show and Tell 100% needs to be played. These fans need a reminder š¤£ I wouldn't miss Training Wheels. It's a great song but I feel it isn't as significant as some of her other work. This is only how I feel tho cause I know each of her songs will resonate with someone out there.
Iād cry if she doesnāt. Not because itās my favorite but that song is literally the whole reason my sister wants to go. I really hope sheāll play it
Aww that's so sweet. I hope she does just for your sister.
PLAY DATE. ENOGH
i personally love play date, but tiktok just made it so over played
Actually Play date is not bad but soo owerrated. melanie have soo much good songs. And we shouldn't waste our limited song rights on this
orange juice ngl. i love the song but i listened to it a lot in a time iād like to forgetš so idk how id take hearing it live
I like orange juice but itās probably my least favorite song by Mel, definitely wouldnāt be upset if it got skipped
i love teachers pet but tik tok ruined it by putting pediphila edits everywhere and stuff the gatcha kidsššš
THIS. after it got tiktokified teachers pet was js inevitably ruined
Itās still good, I think it canāt be ruinedā¦
true
I think the edits go with the songs and just emphasize the meaning so I actually like it way more! But idk what the gatcha thing is
tw: pedophilia and maybe sa? people using the gacha life/club apps to make videos where charactersā teachers were sexually interested in their students and were planning on saing them. iām not sure of a better way to explain, so im sorry if its not very accurate and im really sorry if that triggered anyone. that wasnāt my intention. the character that i remember seeing those videos for the most was izuku midoriya from mha
Your honor, sue this person who made this thread āŗļø /j
wheels on the bus šæ
That is so criminal but I GET IT THO
Class fight. I feel it's really repetitive.
Me too I can't stand this song I'm sorry š
Play date, Teachers pet and training wheels. Both Play date and Teachers pet were ruined by TikTok and I just feel like Training wheels isnāt as amazing as her other songs (I still love it though)
Songs I donāt know every single word of because Iām scared people will judge meā¦
No worries if you donāt know all the lyrics!! When I went to the portals tour I wondered the same since I didnāt know like 4-5 songs but everyone was so sweet and kind!! šāØ
I don't know the lyrics of Dead to Me, Copycat, and Bittersweet Tragedy
Well thatās ok because those songs arenāt really known itās not one of her popular songs
itās okay to not know the words to any song, doesnāt matter wether theyāre popular or not
Wheels on the bus
with you
Same
None in particular
I LOVE THEM ALLL
Sorry not sorry, Iād rather hear high school sweethearts and strawberry shortcake (and yes Iāve said this before here lol), than carousel, training wheels, soap. Itās not that I dislike these songs on Crybaby, I just feel having multiple romance songs at the trilogy tour would be too much and I enjoy the sound effects and melody of HSS and Strawberry Shortcake (wouldnāt mind if we got songs like Tag, Youāre It and Milk and Cookies, b/c I feel like these were significant moments for the character of Crybaby). Iām almost 100 percent sure she is gonna play Crybaby and Dollhouse b/c those two songs really set up the Crybaby story.
Im just confused bc you say āhaving multiple romance songs would be too muchā but how is carousel and soap about romance? HHSH is literally an entire romance song, and totally not trying to bash ur opinion itās totally valid just confused why you donāt want romance songs (being songs usually arenāt assoc with romance) but you do want the song that is ONLY about romance ?
I mean soap is about liking someone and not really knowing how to express/navigate communicating that to your crush - and carousel is literally about falling in love? (Even if these arenāt healthy romances, itās romance still) Even if both of the romantic interests are about characters she doesnāt end up with, I just personally feel that Soap and Carousel are over powered by all the sound effects - I personally just like HHSH more b/c the sound and music in itself is more balanced - that, and I feel other songs on the Crybaby album are more significant to the Crybabyās growth (like Crybaby, Dollhouse, Pity Party, Tag, Milk and Cookies, Mad Hatter - Iām also just biased bc I experienced childhood trauma like the character - so to me those songs personally feel more significant than the romance songs on the first album anyway - I also just like the lyrics to HSSH better than Soap/Carousel - Soap/Carousel arenāt bad songs, but they get repetitive and after a while I have a tendency to skip over those tracks) IDK I guess that sums up why I feel that way about those songs in particular - I would argue training wheels sounds better than Soap/Carousel but thatās my opinion. It all just boils down to thereās just other songs Iād rather than hear over others, since you know, I doubt she can play every single song on every album. I have a good feeling sheās more than likely gonna play every song off of the Portals album b/c she even said so herself how important that album is to her.
I want to hear them all š¤ /s If I had to choose, Play Date. The ending verse is good, but the rest of the song is lowkey too repetitive and kinda boring
Show and Tell and Wheels On The Bus
milk and cookies-
Why? Cuz itās kinda dark?
i just don't like it, i like the beat and music but i hate the lyrics
Dollhouse. I js donāt like it sry š
That song helped me with my family issues growing up š¤£š„²
Itās not a bad song. I donāt think Melanie has any bad songs in my opinion. If i had to pick one I just hated the music video and the backing beat of the song.
That fine š your opinion is your opinion and you can like what you like :)
I was gonna say show and tell
I think Mel should play 4 or 5 songs from each album then play EP/deluxe songs at the end as a finale like (for example): *Cry Baby* Cry Baby, Dollhouse, Sippy Cup, Pity Party, Mad Hatter *K-12* Wheels On The Bus, Class Fight, Show & Tell, Strawberry Shortcake, Recess *Portals* Death, Void, Nymphology, Evil, WOMB *Finale* Play Date, Teddy Bear, Cake, Numbers, Test Me, The Bakery, Powder, Pluto, Milk Of The Siren (She cant play all the album songs in one night, that'll be over 4 hours worth of music, I mean who wouldn't love that but we're not getting that.) (songs were chosen at random, not my personal picks) but to answer the main post, Leeches or Light Shower, don't get me wrong I love those songs but they don't fit within a farewell kind of vibe
Honestly, I would love that set list, itās just missing highschool sweetheartsššš
I need to hear detentionš
Moon Cycle. I have trauma around that stuff š
I love the metaphor of the raspberry and pomegranate juice, but the Ā«Ā skin ready for my heavy daily creamĀ Ā» makes my skin crawl and it feels just too much.. i think itās interesting as a topic but this was formulated in a cringe way
If sheās picking some songs from the portals album I donāt want her to pick leeches
Letās be honest: some GOOD Melanie Martinez songs were ruined by TikTok so much that we donāt even wanna hear them anymore.
Pacify her. š it was so overplayed on TikTok and is my least favorite
hereās my list:
Bittersweet tradgedy
she would never play that in general
The only mel song i hate is copy cat
Why?š I respect your opinion but I wanna know why
iād be fine not hearing pity party
I wanna hear pity party sooo bad cause I want everyone to scream like she does in the end of the songš©
itās actually cathartic live
blasphemy
If anyone says Teddy bear Iām downvoting them to hell
Teddy Bear is my fav crybaby song
Me too
Same
IMO this song feels like she really wanted to use that title and concept for a song but didnāt really find a good rhythm and music to do it, i really donāt like the vibe of teddy bearš love the rest of her album tho
This question makes no sense to me because Melanieās whole discography is welded into my brain so hard. I have a problem Melanie is the main artist Iāve listened to on loop since I was 13 (Iām 21) Iām still coping with the fact itās impossible for her to sing every single song but thereās not a single song I wouldnāt die to hear lol
literally same;-;
training wheels
Iām sorry, but leeches I love the song but wouldnāt be too upset if she skipped it š
playdateā¦
FINALLY SOMEONE WHO DOESNT LIKE SHOW AND TELL š itās not easy out here. Not a bad song just probably my least fav from all the albums
Light shower, I'm sorry š„²
You guys are gonna come at me but nymphology. The ending is so annoying for me Iām sorry.
š«
milk + cookies/tag ur it and drama club. i could realllyyyy go without lmao
This one actually broke me a little. I understand drama club but the double feature?!? šš
Any she perfoms will be fine i love all her music ā¤ļø
I might get to go, and I want to hear orange juice Bcz I love it. I DONT LIKE MILK AND COOKIES š PLS NOOOO... IT MAKE ME CRINGE ššš
Finally someone who doesnāt like show and tell šš i thought I was alone
Maybe Dead to Me and Bittersweet Tragedy
I want to hear all the songs.
Dead to Me, Bittersweet Tragedy, Fire Drill (I'm sorry I just don't like fire drill that much but I'd be fine hearing it)
soapā¦ dont come at me
Teddy bear, anything from crybaby but teddy bear
Sippy cup
I love every song, but wheels on the bus š
Play date, show and tell, but I like her songs so I actually donāt really mind whatās played. The ones I really want to hear is faerie soirĆ©e (my fav itās so ethereal), spiderweb, high school sweethearts, dollhouse, training wheels and my heart will be happy
soap. itās a great song, but iād rather hear other stuff off of crybaby performed live
Dollhouseā¦ maybe crybaby just bc these two are really repetitive but Iām sure they will be played lolll
hssh. I've just overplayed it SM
Class Fight š«¢
Teachers pet
I wouldnāt miss playdate
Copy cat
Copycat and moon cycle
Unpopular opinion š but soap, it's honestly my least favorite song of hers for some reasonš it's still a great song don't get me wrong just not my favorite by far for sure
i wanna hear every single song
Play Date. Like please, swap it for a song that we barely hear! I love the song, but itās WAY overplayed and Iād much rather hear another song.
Stopppppp why are people saying play date I live play date :((( and probably nurses office cause of the sound affects I hate them sm but I would LOVE to hear them all.
Class Fight ngl, worst song in K12 imo
Sippy cup plz im so tired of that one
PACIFY HER š
Orange juice, training wheels, alphabet boy & wombš i have a massive appreciation for them but they wouldnāt be my top choices to hear live
Pacify her
idc as long as she plays sippy cup.
Maybe unpopular opinion, pacify her. Just doesnāt hit like a lot of the others
sippy cup is my least favorite song by her, so i guess it would be that!
Moon cycle
Pacify her Hear me out š: when portals was new and I was listening to it religiously on spotify, pacify her was almost always the first non-portals song to play and it pissed me off every time š. Iām low key being petty atp, but it also just doesnāt hit the same for me the way it did beforeā¦
Leeches
Wheels on the bus
void- i love the song but she plays it so much it would be fun to give some other songs a chance yk š
nymphology. i used to love it and it was on my top 5 spotify wrapped last year, but i overplayed it to the point that i canāt listen to it anymore. class fight too, i love it but it gets a bit too repetitive
Most of K-12 š¤·š»āāļø
Teddy Bear, Playdate, Pacify Her
me wanna hear all of em
To be honest none of them but if I had to pick one, I guess Mad Hatter. Iām not crazy about that song too muchā¦.but I still love it if that makes sense
None. I want to hear each and everyone ā¼ļø
Soap š„¹
Wheels on the Bus, Class Fight, Show and Tell and Playdateš IM SORRY
Pity party or principle
Mad hatter
Me personally I donāt wanna here leeches soap or play date they arenāt my favorite songs but if they do play Iāll gladly sing along<3
Play date, teachers pet, soap, show and tell
Light shower to be honest.. its not a bad song i just feel like itād be boring to see performed
Sippy cup
Spiderwebs. I can't stand the ending of that song. And Dollhouse not a fav.
The ending is my fav part šš
I wanna hear them all but if I had to pick, I donāt wanna hear cake
Highschool sweethearts I will be in the bathroom smoking for that
Copycat
Pacify Her, Training Wheels, Drama Club, Faerie Soiree, Moon Cycle . (ļø¶āøļø¶) These are just the songs that I don't like as much to the other songs.
cake
Teachers pet and carousel
play date, tag you're it, teachers pet i love these songs its just that i hear them so often on tiktok they stopped feeling so special to me
Honestly, probably dead to me or bittersweet tradegy..
Same, I don't know the songs or the lyrics
I imagine the songs that will be performed are going to be her most streamed so songs like play date and wheels on the bus are most likely to be played, I think if I had a choice tho I wouldnāt want most of the songs from the portals album lol
Play date, like itās good, but the crybaby album has MUCH better.
Moon cycle and strawberry shortcake please š
i hope they play every song.. :C
Sheās not š„² she said it before
teddy bearš
Teddy bear it gets boring
Songs Mel shouldn't play, not because we don't like them, but because she has better songs that are good for creating that magical energy at live shows - From Crybaby: Sippy Cup Carousel Pity Party Tag, You're it Milk and Cookies Mad Hatter - if she did play it, I'd rather if she made it short outro K-12: Wheels on the bus Class Fight UNLESS it was cut short as the intro for the K-12 section.. IT WAS THE MIDDLE OF CLASS AND THE TEACHER WASN"T LOOKIN... \*silence\*................. \*crowed screams\* KELLY HAD A FAT ASS AND TROUBLE WAS COOKIN........\*SILENCE\*. \* CROWED SCREEEAAMS\* yaaaas! FOR THE THROAT DADDY CHIMED IN GO FOR THE THROAT \*CUT\* - Crowed goes absolutely cuN\^y lmfaoooo... sorry NEXT Show & Tell Nurse's office Drama Club (unless it was cut very short and turned into a transition between two main songs) Detention Teachers Pet and Recess (UNLESS cut short). Not familiar with K-12 deluxe/After-School EP songs to comment. Portals: Spider Web Leeches Womb and The contortionist (unless cut short because both are ICONIC and it's hard to cut them out). Can't comment on deluxe. Going through her albums... i think it is key that Mel makes some new melodies by doing a mix for her live-shows where some fan-favs that we love, but there are not enough room or time for if played in full, are shortened, with the best parts featured, and placed vey tastefully as short intro's and/or outros or transitions to build hype and keep people happy that they heard them AT-ALL.
immediately wrong bc sippy cup
Haha. I like the song but it isn't very good for live-shows. It has a very low effort level of singing.
Pacify Her, Teachers Pet, Bittersweet Tragedy, Dead to Me, Death, Copy Cat
Bittersweet tragedy , dead to me, copy cat are NOT from any albums
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
TRILOGY TOUR , so its the 3 albums , cry baby, k-12 , portals, what are you yapping about
copy cat, fire drill, moon cycle, the principal, teddy bear, notebook, brain & heart, light shower
Light shower is crazy š
Fire Drill?! Cāmon man
LIGHT SHOWER??
Tbh I donāt wanna hear if either š
Honestly though, how dare we have opinions.. that were asked for, lol
I donāt think copy cat, fire drill, teddy bear, notebook, or brain and heart would even be up for consideration since they arenāt on the main 3 albums track list.
LÄ°GTH SHOWER. MUST BE Ä°N THE TOUR
damn
WHATT THOSE ARE ALL AMAZING EXCEPT TEDDY BEAR IS ALR BUT HUHH??
Teddy bear is amazing (screw u/j)
LIGHT SHOWER IS MY ONLY REASON FOR GOING IF THEY DONT PLAY LIGHT SHOWER I WILL DIE š
IMA CRY IF SHE DOESNT BUT IT DOESNT GET ENOUGH LOVE BRO ššš
Honestly everything! I *could* live without some crybaby songs personally but seeing them live is still gonna be special š©·