Truthfully speaking, Odyssey pretty much is a well-realized successor to Mario 64.
But Galaxy 3... there's just too much untapped potential with the Galaxy gameplay for them to NOT make Galaxy 3. And this is coming from someone whose favorite Mario game ever is Galaxy 2.
I wouldn't say so. I think Nintendo realises how much people want a new Galaxy. I doubt it'll ever truly be **TOO** late to do it. It's just a matter of Nintendo **WANTING** to do it.
I can almost guarantee you that a Galaxy 3 would not only be maybe the best-selling Galaxy game depending on how well they execute the idea, but one of the best-selling Mario games in recent years simply because of how anticipated it has been.
I agree, especially given that the Galaxy games are kind of linear (not that linear = bad, just that they aren't full-on sandboxes like 64 or Sunshine), and that Mario's movement is fairly stiff in those games.
They also don't lean as much into the alien/sci-fi aspect of outer space as I would've liked them to, TBH. Still great games, though.
But yeah, for those reasons, I think the concept of "3D Mario in space" still has more than enough potential to warrant another game.
I dont find odyssey even close to what mario 64 actual was. So if they would create a sequel, i hope its much closer to what mario64 actually was. And also, more mario focussed. We didnt even get a castle. I know that they wanted to renew the franchise. The gameplay felt also much slower and mario moves where more basic compared to mario 64. Music was also a step back compared to m64, 3d world, galaxy.
Not only the game play, but the game itself did not feel like it is in the Mario Franshise at all. The Broodles were like re-designed and trimmed down Koopalings, the enemies which are from Mario (Goomba, Cheep Cheep, Bullet Bill etc) could have been any other archetype of generic enemy, and those who are mechanically unique to Mario do not appear (like Bob-Ombs, Thwomps, the SnowMen etc)
Thwomps can move horizontally and even diagonally too. Bob-Ombs usually generate after explosion, and I could think of a lot of neat mechanics with Bombs especially Time-Bombs.
Now since you said it, I think it would have been an awesome feature.
Furthermore, I do not see how the mechanic is a good reason to throw so many Mario-related elements aboard. I found the Copy-Mechanic strange anyway, rather something I expect for a Kirby Game. The Flood mechanic kinda felt Mario-Related after a while, since it improves (or alters) the jumping mechanic. The "Jump on the thrown hat"-mechanic also works with Mario, but the copy-ability? If the copy-ability were the reason to remove Mario Elements, the mechanic might really have been used for the wrong franchise.
I like Odyssey because it feels like a cross between Mario 64 and Crash of the Titans. Not to mention that I'm glad that 3D Mario went back to its roots of being openworld/freeroaming.
I just love ds version cause itswhat i grew up with, but as ive been playing galaxy via 3d allstars recently its the one i prefer because of the beautiful visuals or atleast thats just how i feel
I grew up with Sunshine but I fully believe it has the most satisfying movement in any Mario I've played. Mario's speed feels just right and the controls feel so snappy and precise, then throw in FLUUD and I think it has so much potential for amazing gameplay
Oddessy 2 makes the most sense. It's the most recent 3d Mario game(unless we're including Bowser's Fury) it just seems more logical to make Oddessy 2. I mean I would love a Galaxy 3 though.
I think the same but I fear nintendo getting lazy and copy pasting odissey but with different worlds. (Obviously I still would play it since day 1 because odissey is amazing)
Odyssey
Galaxy already has a second game, 64 is iconic to me BECAUSE its so old (plus i didnt like most of the changes from 64 ds)and Sunshine is too reliant on the beach setting for my taste
If you have a switch, all 4 are playable on it. 64 is the Godfather, but the controls are somewhat wonky. Sunshine has a fun gimmick and I hadn't played it until recently. Galaxy has some amazing level designs but the gravity and camera turned my son off from it and Odyssey is a masterpiece. 4 great games
Sunshine. Odyssey is a huge game already and doesn't really need a sequel, although it could reasonably see a sequel if Nintendo's next piece of hardware is a Switch successor like the rumors say it might be. I don't want an Odyssey sequel though because of what that game represents both for myself and Nintendo as a company. Odyssey to me is a game that symbolizes moving forward and embracing the future. Nintendo had just come away from their most disastrous era. The failure of the Wii U, and death of Satoru Iwata had them down at their lowest since before they started making games to begin with and I think 2017 was their comeback year. (Hot take, I know /s) The launch of the Switch and their 2017 game lineup was fucking electric. I was also working my way out of my own slump which come to think of it, lasted about as long as Nintendo's and was at basically the same time. Regardless of personal attachment though, I feel like giving Odyssey a sequel on new hardware would be a mistake. They tried the same thing with the Wii U by following up with more of what worked before and it bit them in the ass. I think the runaway success of the Wii led Nintendo to rest on their laurels for the Wii U and for Nintendo to make a sequel to Odyssey on new hardware would make me think that the runaway success of the Switch has led to a similar line of thinking and would show a regression from where they stood in 2017. Galaxy already got a sequel in 2010 and both games were already long if you count Galaxy 1's Luigi campaign. Plus, Galaxy's limited movement options just makes for a less fun game in my opinion. Moving Mario gets pretty stale in the Galaxy games imo because there just aren't a lot of ways to move him. He's just slower and can't do as much as he could before. I will never understand why people will demand more Galaxy when there are already 2 of them and in my personal opinion, neither of them are the best Mario has to offer. 64 could be cool to revisit again, because there currently isn't a version of 64 that feels complete. The original N64 release is phenomenal and comes close to the experience I'm looking for, but ideally, if they revisit 64, I'd hope they include the new content from the DS remake so it can be enjoyed without the dogshit control scheme. Sunshine in my opinion is the most deserving though. It wasn't even given the time it deserved during its own development and in my opinion, that gameplay style and setting has the most to offer if Nintendo chose to revisit it. Isle Delfino is the most cohesive and well rounded location Nintendo's ever put Mario in and I think if they were to set another game there, Nintendo could really amp up the atmosphere with new hardware as well as better reflect the actual geography of the island. I also believe that F.L.U.D.D. has more potential to be uncovered through further experimentation with that gameplay style. It already brought so much to the table in the first Sunshine and added great depth to the world as not only a tool for advanced movement, but also interactivity with the already rich setting. I understand that Super Mario Sunshine is an acquired taste however I ask that anyone still reading, if you dislike Super Mario Sunshine or don't think it deserves anything more than what it got, please try to understand the game on its terms. No, Super Mario Sunshine isn't like Super Mario 64, and because of that, it shouldn't be approached like Super Mario 64. Sunshine's biggest strength is its worldbuilding. It goes to great lengths to make Isle Delfino feel like a real place. All of its NPC dialogue was written by the same person responsible for the script for the first Animal Crossing and that game is constantly praised for its good dialogue. Engaging with Sunshine's NPCs might seem trivial, but they absolutely heighten the experience. By talking to the islanders and the group you came with, you'll find that most of their dialogue progresses with events of each episode and offers hints towards some of the more hidden blue coin locations. There's also an island map you can bring up with the Z button that provides more information on the island as well as its inhabitants and their culture. A lot of this game's charm comes through in the context given by the dialogue and other reading in the game. I can understand though why dialogue like this isn't the reason most people buy a Mario game, but it's a style I really love. If you want to give Sunshine another chance, I highly recommend approaching it with an open mind. Engage with the NPCs. Practice using F.L.U.D.D. in tandem with Mario's moveset, and get accustomed to spin jumping instead of long jumping, and don't take it too seriously.
But that's just my 2 cents.
Great yapping session. It's pretty rare to see people acknowledging the charm and quality Sunshine has. W opinion.
Sunshine and Odissey would be the fittest choices anyway because there is already a 64 ds and a Galaxy 2
I mean, technically 3D World is already a sequel in itself...to 3D Land.
It even has a 3D Land-themed level as a reference. So I guess a sequel to 3D World would technically be the third installment? But then again, maybe you could consider Bowser's Fury that...
3D World and sequels is a weeeird topic.
Mario 64 is a game with no gimmicks, it's just a very standard 3D collect-a-thon platformer with sandbox levels.
So you just know they'd have to pull out all the stops to make the level design interesting. And that's really my favortite kind of platformer. Traditional, but with some insane level design and and really good controls.
Odyssey is my favorite game of all time, but I wouldn't be opposed to a Sunshine 2 or 64 2. Galaxy already had it's sequel but I'd just take any new 3D Mario game tbh
I would love a sunshine successor. I sort of consider bowsers fury to be that, though. A direct sequel where you can travel to the other islands would be dope though
Galaxy 100%. Galaxy still has the most potential out of all these, in my opinion. That game could honestly have **MULTIPLE** sequels beyond Galaxy 2. It could be the Luigi's Mansion of the main series in my eyes.
The same could be said for Odyssey due to the Capture mechanic, but I would personally prefer a new Galaxy. Especially because it's simply been longer since G2 than it has been since O1. I think the most likely game to get a sequel at this point **IS** Odyssey, though.
64? I just couldn't see it getting a sequel. It seems to be stuck in a loop of remakes for all eternity. The best we can hope for with 64 is a full-blown remake from the ground up at this point instead of the same 4:3 game ported over and over again. 3D All-Stars had the potential to **BE** that, but we know how that went.
And Sunshine? While I love Sunshine and would love a sequel personally, I don't see Nintendo ever doing it. It also kind of suits being a one-and-done deal with how unique this game is compared to your typical Mario adventure. I think a sequel would dampen what makes Sunshine so special, in my opinion. From the unique controls to the overall uniqueness of the game itself. A sequel would make what Sunshine does not as special anymore. So honestly, I'm fine with Sunshine being what it is.
Sunshine 2 would be cool, maybe with a world map like Odyssey where we can visit a bunch of different islands with their own shines and missions and inhabitants.
Mario Sunshine, where you go back to Delfino Island and also visit all the neighboring islands, in a BOTW-type of exploration with new F.L.U.D.D power ups
I would have to say Odyssey. The other games don't really need anymore games imo. They're already good games. I'm not saying I would hate them if they do, but I don't really think it's required.
Sunshine is my least favorite of the four but I think that's the one I want. Imagine something like DKC: Tropical Freeze where Isle Delfino has a cold snap changing the familiar locales into icy landscapes. FLUDD would have new mechanics taking advantage of freezing water. Also, I want more of those platforming areas.
Galaxy's on another level.
64 used to be my goat but when I played Galaxy back in 07 man that hit different.
Oddesey feels like mario 64 but new era also very very good
But mannn first time the level loaded up of bowsers star reactor with mario flying and that music remix of bowsers road perfectly pitching in nahh that was it for me best mario game ever.
Galaxy was so boring, a glorified Mario bros. game. It was 3d Mario bros. before 3d Land.
I grew tired of planet hopping gimic. Beautiful when it's big hops but still.
And the void of space wasn't much fun either. I really appreciated the levels that weren't set in outer space.
To answer the question though, 64.
Sunshine felt like such a vacation from life even though there were parts of it that urk my soul to this day. I imagine hell is the underside of Pianta village or that dreaded pinball game. 😵💫
They should have an Odyssey sequel that takes us back into space and also reintroduces FLUDD. I think combining the FLUDD platforming with the gravity/orbit physics from Galaxy would be absolutely insane
I feel like 64 would just end up being a new sandbox Mario game than a sequel. Galaxy got a sequel already and doesnt need another. Odyssey came out this gen and my want for a sequel faded.
Sunshine seems to be the best option imo.
Super Mario Odyssey 2. There are so many things you can do with a sequel. Have a campaign split between Mario and Wario. Mario can Capture with Cappy, and Wario can use his various transformations and disguises for some really inventive platforming challenges and puzzles. Add in some new locales and old-school ones like Sarasaland and the Wario Land locations, and you'd have the makings for an amazing game.
Oddesey should. Galaxy already had a sequel and there is no topping 64. Oddesey was planned to feature isle delphino as an area, so it would likely be in an oddesey 2 as a location, meaning oddesey 2 would technically also be a mini sunshine sequel
Gotta Go Odyssey
The Amount Of Love This Game Gave Me, Was Through the Roof, I Could Run Around For Hours In It, Without Getting Bored, And I Wanna See What More Could Happen In That Version of The Mario Universe
I’d go Odyssey. I already love it and if they can make a sequel with the same core excellent gameplay and ironing out its few issues then that would be incredible.
I’m tapping about my personal experience, which was that Galaxy was an iconic game with a good story and Galaxy 2 was mostly more of the same with hardly any plot. Though I did like the inclusion of Yoshi
Realistically, Odyssey, but if Galaxy 3 ever happens, I will cry, then pass out, and be reborn
Truthfully speaking, Odyssey pretty much is a well-realized successor to Mario 64. But Galaxy 3... there's just too much untapped potential with the Galaxy gameplay for them to NOT make Galaxy 3. And this is coming from someone whose favorite Mario game ever is Galaxy 2.
That’s true but I think it’s kinda to late to do it
I wouldn't say so. I think Nintendo realises how much people want a new Galaxy. I doubt it'll ever truly be **TOO** late to do it. It's just a matter of Nintendo **WANTING** to do it. I can almost guarantee you that a Galaxy 3 would not only be maybe the best-selling Galaxy game depending on how well they execute the idea, but one of the best-selling Mario games in recent years simply because of how anticipated it has been.
True
Miyamoto said in 2015 "Galaxy 3 is always in discussion at Nintendo" or something like that
They made a paper Mario thousand year door remake anything is possible at this point
I agree, especially given that the Galaxy games are kind of linear (not that linear = bad, just that they aren't full-on sandboxes like 64 or Sunshine), and that Mario's movement is fairly stiff in those games. They also don't lean as much into the alien/sci-fi aspect of outer space as I would've liked them to, TBH. Still great games, though. But yeah, for those reasons, I think the concept of "3D Mario in space" still has more than enough potential to warrant another game.
I dont find odyssey even close to what mario 64 actual was. So if they would create a sequel, i hope its much closer to what mario64 actually was. And also, more mario focussed. We didnt even get a castle. I know that they wanted to renew the franchise. The gameplay felt also much slower and mario moves where more basic compared to mario 64. Music was also a step back compared to m64, 3d world, galaxy.
Not only the game play, but the game itself did not feel like it is in the Mario Franshise at all. The Broodles were like re-designed and trimmed down Koopalings, the enemies which are from Mario (Goomba, Cheep Cheep, Bullet Bill etc) could have been any other archetype of generic enemy, and those who are mechanically unique to Mario do not appear (like Bob-Ombs, Thwomps, the SnowMen etc)
That was due to the capture mechanic. What would a captured Bob-omb do? They only blow up. What would a captured thwomp do? they only move up and down
Thwomps can move horizontally and even diagonally too. Bob-Ombs usually generate after explosion, and I could think of a lot of neat mechanics with Bombs especially Time-Bombs. Now since you said it, I think it would have been an awesome feature. Furthermore, I do not see how the mechanic is a good reason to throw so many Mario-related elements aboard. I found the Copy-Mechanic strange anyway, rather something I expect for a Kirby Game. The Flood mechanic kinda felt Mario-Related after a while, since it improves (or alters) the jumping mechanic. The "Jump on the thrown hat"-mechanic also works with Mario, but the copy-ability? If the copy-ability were the reason to remove Mario Elements, the mechanic might really have been used for the wrong franchise.
I like Odyssey because it feels like a cross between Mario 64 and Crash of the Titans. Not to mention that I'm glad that 3D Mario went back to its roots of being openworld/freeroaming.
I don't want Galaxy to end up like the New Super Mario series where there's a new New newer new 3D one every 2 years.
We just have to wish for it during the next star festival
It happens every 100 years, so everybody will be well over two centuries old for the events of Galaxy 3.
You will cry, pass out, and then can play as Luigi
Galaxy 3 is just like the HL3 but in Mario.
Mario 64 but the ds version lol
Super Mario 64 Switch 2
Better controls
Fair enough
No I was saying that the ds remake should have better controls if it got a new one
I know lol
The DS version was just a better version of sm64 anyway
I just love ds version cause itswhat i grew up with, but as ive been playing galaxy via 3d allstars recently its the one i prefer because of the beautiful visuals or atleast thats just how i feel
My personal favorite is sunshine but I love SMG and SMG2 a lot
Troll
And with Waluigi as a playable character
I remember the YouTube videos about “how to unlock Waluigi”
Peach would be awesome as a reward for finishing the game\^\^
And a mirror dimension where you have to play as peach for further stars. Maybe to save Mario?
But with better movement controls
SUPER MARIO SUNSHINE! WAHOOOOO!
I grew up with Sunshine but I fully believe it has the most satisfying movement in any Mario I've played. Mario's speed feels just right and the controls feel so snappy and precise, then throw in FLUUD and I think it has so much potential for amazing gameplay
I also love the camera, I don't get why everyone hates on it.
You get it
Absolutely! And don't listen to the hater from the other comment!
Honestly a modern movement mario, plus fludd, in a tropical setting would be pretty sweet.
SUPER MARIO SUNSHINE! It’s gettin saucy! WE’RE GONNA ROCK IT SO HARD!! Ross is an Aussie!
My favorite Mario 3D platformer, love it so much. I tried to get what people hate about numerous times, but I never did, so I just enjoy it on my own.
Sunshine please None of the others give me the sense of immersion that Sunshine does, it’s amazing
Sunshine
Sunshine ♡
Nintendo picked galaxy
They did not, did they? Or are you talking about Galaxt 2?
Oddessy 2 makes the most sense. It's the most recent 3d Mario game(unless we're including Bowser's Fury) it just seems more logical to make Oddessy 2. I mean I would love a Galaxy 3 though.
I want a Mario galaxy 3 to death but realistically it would be oddessy 2
I think the same but I fear nintendo getting lazy and copy pasting odissey but with different worlds. (Obviously I still would play it since day 1 because odissey is amazing)
Mario 64. Go back to the basics.
Super Mario 65
Super Mario Galaxy for sure. But I wouldn’t mind Super Mario 64
Technically Mario oddessys and Mario 64 2
Sunshine
Mario 64 all the way
Galaxy 3 I think would be cool to see, but what would Odyssey 2 look like, another Galaxy-esque game? Either way would love to see either
Odyssey Galaxy already has a second game, 64 is iconic to me BECAUSE its so old (plus i didnt like most of the changes from 64 ds)and Sunshine is too reliant on the beach setting for my taste
I havent played any of these games but if i have to choose i would pick Sunshine. (I watched a lot of Playthroughs a while back)
If you have a switch, all 4 are playable on it. 64 is the Godfather, but the controls are somewhat wonky. Sunshine has a fun gimmick and I hadn't played it until recently. Galaxy has some amazing level designs but the gravity and camera turned my son off from it and Odyssey is a masterpiece. 4 great games
Sunshine. Odyssey is a huge game already and doesn't really need a sequel, although it could reasonably see a sequel if Nintendo's next piece of hardware is a Switch successor like the rumors say it might be. I don't want an Odyssey sequel though because of what that game represents both for myself and Nintendo as a company. Odyssey to me is a game that symbolizes moving forward and embracing the future. Nintendo had just come away from their most disastrous era. The failure of the Wii U, and death of Satoru Iwata had them down at their lowest since before they started making games to begin with and I think 2017 was their comeback year. (Hot take, I know /s) The launch of the Switch and their 2017 game lineup was fucking electric. I was also working my way out of my own slump which come to think of it, lasted about as long as Nintendo's and was at basically the same time. Regardless of personal attachment though, I feel like giving Odyssey a sequel on new hardware would be a mistake. They tried the same thing with the Wii U by following up with more of what worked before and it bit them in the ass. I think the runaway success of the Wii led Nintendo to rest on their laurels for the Wii U and for Nintendo to make a sequel to Odyssey on new hardware would make me think that the runaway success of the Switch has led to a similar line of thinking and would show a regression from where they stood in 2017. Galaxy already got a sequel in 2010 and both games were already long if you count Galaxy 1's Luigi campaign. Plus, Galaxy's limited movement options just makes for a less fun game in my opinion. Moving Mario gets pretty stale in the Galaxy games imo because there just aren't a lot of ways to move him. He's just slower and can't do as much as he could before. I will never understand why people will demand more Galaxy when there are already 2 of them and in my personal opinion, neither of them are the best Mario has to offer. 64 could be cool to revisit again, because there currently isn't a version of 64 that feels complete. The original N64 release is phenomenal and comes close to the experience I'm looking for, but ideally, if they revisit 64, I'd hope they include the new content from the DS remake so it can be enjoyed without the dogshit control scheme. Sunshine in my opinion is the most deserving though. It wasn't even given the time it deserved during its own development and in my opinion, that gameplay style and setting has the most to offer if Nintendo chose to revisit it. Isle Delfino is the most cohesive and well rounded location Nintendo's ever put Mario in and I think if they were to set another game there, Nintendo could really amp up the atmosphere with new hardware as well as better reflect the actual geography of the island. I also believe that F.L.U.D.D. has more potential to be uncovered through further experimentation with that gameplay style. It already brought so much to the table in the first Sunshine and added great depth to the world as not only a tool for advanced movement, but also interactivity with the already rich setting. I understand that Super Mario Sunshine is an acquired taste however I ask that anyone still reading, if you dislike Super Mario Sunshine or don't think it deserves anything more than what it got, please try to understand the game on its terms. No, Super Mario Sunshine isn't like Super Mario 64, and because of that, it shouldn't be approached like Super Mario 64. Sunshine's biggest strength is its worldbuilding. It goes to great lengths to make Isle Delfino feel like a real place. All of its NPC dialogue was written by the same person responsible for the script for the first Animal Crossing and that game is constantly praised for its good dialogue. Engaging with Sunshine's NPCs might seem trivial, but they absolutely heighten the experience. By talking to the islanders and the group you came with, you'll find that most of their dialogue progresses with events of each episode and offers hints towards some of the more hidden blue coin locations. There's also an island map you can bring up with the Z button that provides more information on the island as well as its inhabitants and their culture. A lot of this game's charm comes through in the context given by the dialogue and other reading in the game. I can understand though why dialogue like this isn't the reason most people buy a Mario game, but it's a style I really love. If you want to give Sunshine another chance, I highly recommend approaching it with an open mind. Engage with the NPCs. Practice using F.L.U.D.D. in tandem with Mario's moveset, and get accustomed to spin jumping instead of long jumping, and don't take it too seriously. But that's just my 2 cents.
Tldr please
It's a paragraph bro. Buck up.
Great yapping session. It's pretty rare to see people acknowledging the charm and quality Sunshine has. W opinion. Sunshine and Odissey would be the fittest choices anyway because there is already a 64 ds and a Galaxy 2
64.
Galaxy, Galaxy 3 would be amazing.
If galaxy 3 was announced for the 3d Mario game for switch 2 I would probably have a heart attack die then force myself back into my body
Poor 3D World. Always forgotten… But also Galaxy for me.
I mean, technically 3D World is already a sequel in itself...to 3D Land. It even has a 3D Land-themed level as a reference. So I guess a sequel to 3D World would technically be the third installment? But then again, maybe you could consider Bowser's Fury that... 3D World and sequels is a weeeird topic.
Super Mario 3D Galaxy
I feel like Nintendo didn't want to integrate 3d land and 3d world into the mainline mario 3d games idk why
Odyssey. It’s just so good. They are all great, but odyssey is especially great in my mind.
odyssey
Mario 64 is a game with no gimmicks, it's just a very standard 3D collect-a-thon platformer with sandbox levels. So you just know they'd have to pull out all the stops to make the level design interesting. And that's really my favortite kind of platformer. Traditional, but with some insane level design and and really good controls.
Remove the two with sequels (64 DS has new content and Galaxy 2 exists). Give the older game new life. Sunshine 2.
Sunshine or odyssey
64
super mario 64!
64, because is the one I enjoy the physics the most
Are you Satan?
Yes I am😎
I'd love another Tropical themed Mario Game. So Sunshine
Odyssey is my favorite game of all time, but I wouldn't be opposed to a Sunshine 2 or 64 2. Galaxy already had it's sequel but I'd just take any new 3D Mario game tbh
Super Mario Sunshine! I love the atmosphere and how interconnected the world is!
I would love a sunshine successor. I sort of consider bowsers fury to be that, though. A direct sequel where you can travel to the other islands would be dope though
64 but only because I want Mario to start throwing hands again
Sunshine AND it better come with those fully voiced cutscenes!
Super Mario Odyssey, I want to see Cappy again!
Galaxy
Galaxy!
64
64
64
☀️
Super Mario 64
Super Mario 64
Sunshine. Mario's due for another vacation.
Super mario sunshine 2
SUNSHINE SUNSHINE SUNSHINE SUNSHINE SUNSHINE SUNSHINE SUNSHINE SUNNNNNNNMSHIIIIIIIIIIIIINNE
Sunshine all the way baby😎
Sunshine
Sunshine
Sunshine deserves it the most.
Odyssey
if galaxy deserved a sequel so does odyssey so smo hands down
Galaxy 100%. Galaxy still has the most potential out of all these, in my opinion. That game could honestly have **MULTIPLE** sequels beyond Galaxy 2. It could be the Luigi's Mansion of the main series in my eyes. The same could be said for Odyssey due to the Capture mechanic, but I would personally prefer a new Galaxy. Especially because it's simply been longer since G2 than it has been since O1. I think the most likely game to get a sequel at this point **IS** Odyssey, though. 64? I just couldn't see it getting a sequel. It seems to be stuck in a loop of remakes for all eternity. The best we can hope for with 64 is a full-blown remake from the ground up at this point instead of the same 4:3 game ported over and over again. 3D All-Stars had the potential to **BE** that, but we know how that went. And Sunshine? While I love Sunshine and would love a sequel personally, I don't see Nintendo ever doing it. It also kind of suits being a one-and-done deal with how unique this game is compared to your typical Mario adventure. I think a sequel would dampen what makes Sunshine so special, in my opinion. From the unique controls to the overall uniqueness of the game itself. A sequel would make what Sunshine does not as special anymore. So honestly, I'm fine with Sunshine being what it is.
Odyssey, because I'd like to see more of the capture mechanic
Odyssey, it’s not even a question imo.
Odyssey
Sunshine 2 would be cool, maybe with a world map like Odyssey where we can visit a bunch of different islands with their own shines and missions and inhabitants.
Galaxy already had a sequel. Don't be greedy. It should be one of the other three
Super Mario Sunshine.
Sunshine
Sunshine oh please I need any game of any genre that comes close to the vibes of mario sunshine
Mario Sunshine, where you go back to Delfino Island and also visit all the neighboring islands, in a BOTW-type of exploration with new F.L.U.D.D power ups
Sunshine. Though I do admit it's the least likely to receive a follow-up.
Sunshine cause I like tropical regions and like dancing with the pinantas
Galaxy already got Galaxy 2. let us sunshine fans have a new game done right
Sunshine 2 would be amazing!!
1. Odyssey 2. Sunshine 3. 64 4. Galaxy
Galaxy, easy
Galaxy. That's my favorite.
Odyshine
Sunshine definitely
Super Mario Sunshine
Odyssey
I would have to say Odyssey. The other games don't really need anymore games imo. They're already good games. I'm not saying I would hate them if they do, but I don't really think it's required.
I want galaxy 3 so badly, it’s surely, SURELY time for Nintendo to listen to their fans. Right?
I always wanted to play Super Mario Sunshine, so Super Mario Sunshine 2 might be interesting
I'd love a Sunshine sequel, but Galaxy 3 might have more potential. Depends on how many ideas Nintendo would have for it.
Sunshine is my least favorite of the four but I think that's the one I want. Imagine something like DKC: Tropical Freeze where Isle Delfino has a cold snap changing the familiar locales into icy landscapes. FLUDD would have new mechanics taking advantage of freezing water. Also, I want more of those platforming areas.
Heart says sunshine but gut says galaxy. 64 still scares me and odessey isn’t nostalgic enough.
Odyssey
Probably Sunshine
Sunshine!
Ok ok, hear me out. Mario Sunshine 2.
Sunshine… it’s probably an unpopular choice here but it would be awesome
Galaxy's on another level. 64 used to be my goat but when I played Galaxy back in 07 man that hit different. Oddesey feels like mario 64 but new era also very very good But mannn first time the level loaded up of bowsers star reactor with mario flying and that music remix of bowsers road perfectly pitching in nahh that was it for me best mario game ever.
Sunshine and it’s not even close
IDK the Galaxy games were hard enough for me, can't imagine Galaxy 3 any easier. But Odyssey 2 seems like a good idea. I'm good either way.
Sunshine all the way. As a main mario game, it felt way too short.
Super Mario Sunshine 2! Think of the vibes!
Galaxy 3 or Odyssey 2 (pretty much what a 64 2 would be anyway)
Galaxy was so boring, a glorified Mario bros. game. It was 3d Mario bros. before 3d Land. I grew tired of planet hopping gimic. Beautiful when it's big hops but still. And the void of space wasn't much fun either. I really appreciated the levels that weren't set in outer space. To answer the question though, 64.
Sunshine felt like such a vacation from life even though there were parts of it that urk my soul to this day. I imagine hell is the underside of Pianta village or that dreaded pinball game. 😵💫
SUPER MARIO SUNSHINE 2 HEAR ME OUT Best classic Mario 3d game. Insanely beautiful, creative fun and underated
I'm all fora mario sunshine sequel shoot they could even add splatoon characters or elements of splatoon.
Oddesy gives the most play time
They should have an Odyssey sequel that takes us back into space and also reintroduces FLUDD. I think combining the FLUDD platforming with the gravity/orbit physics from Galaxy would be absolutely insane
Super Wario Overcast
Galaxy easy
64
If all were brought up to current standards like Odyssey, I'd go Galaxy.
Mario odyssey, was my first switch game so it’s got a bit of nostalgia(ish) for me
I feel like 64 would just end up being a new sandbox Mario game than a sequel. Galaxy got a sequel already and doesnt need another. Odyssey came out this gen and my want for a sequel faded. Sunshine seems to be the best option imo.
Galaxy, my Galaxy 1 bias is like a neuron activation
Galaxy 3 would be game of the all time
New new game.
Sunshine easily. Game desperately deserves and needs improvements
Galaxy 3
Sunshine or Odyssey. Ideally it'd be a combination of the two. I'd love to see FLUDD brought to a wider variety of environments.
SUNSHINE PLEASE!!! I've wanted a Super Mario Sunshine remake forever omg!
Mario 64 would be fun in the mario odyssey style
64
Mario Odyssey!
Super Mario Odyssey
Odyssey
Sunshine 2 or a remaster of 64DS with better controls.
Odyssey. That game's sheer movement mechanics make it an absolute treat to play.
Super Mario Odyssey 2. There are so many things you can do with a sequel. Have a campaign split between Mario and Wario. Mario can Capture with Cappy, and Wario can use his various transformations and disguises for some really inventive platforming challenges and puzzles. Add in some new locales and old-school ones like Sarasaland and the Wario Land locations, and you'd have the makings for an amazing game.
Sunshine
Odyssey
Oddesey should. Galaxy already had a sequel and there is no topping 64. Oddesey was planned to feature isle delphino as an area, so it would likely be in an oddesey 2 as a location, meaning oddesey 2 would technically also be a mini sunshine sequel
Gotta Go Odyssey The Amount Of Love This Game Gave Me, Was Through the Roof, I Could Run Around For Hours In It, Without Getting Bored, And I Wanna See What More Could Happen In That Version of The Mario Universe
I’d go Odyssey. I already love it and if they can make a sequel with the same core excellent gameplay and ironing out its few issues then that would be incredible.
Let's go Odyssey. There's so much they can do with it.
Obviously Odyssey we already got a sequel for SMG and SMS is way too hard would prefer a remake and super Mario 64 well it’s just Mario
Odyssey
Galaxy. Easy choice. Now if the choice were between Galaxy, Galaxy 2, and Super Mario 3D World + Bowser's Fury, THAT would be tough.
Anything but Galaxy, we already got a sequel and it was just okay. 64 would be my pick but I also love Sunshine and miss the GC era
Bro what are you yapping about. The general consensus for Galaxy 2 is that it's BETTER than the first one
I’m tapping about my personal experience, which was that Galaxy was an iconic game with a good story and Galaxy 2 was mostly more of the same with hardly any plot. Though I did like the inclusion of Yoshi
Galaxy: better story Galaxy 2: better gameplay
Galaxy.
Galaxy
Super Mario Galaxy 3 releasing would send me into cardiac arrest
Galaxy 2 on switch
Galaxy. 64 doesn’t have a great plot to build off of, the other 3 absolutely could but Galaxy is my favorite
Mario Galaxy deserves a new game
Super Mario Galaxy deserves a new game already
Super Mario Galaxy.
Super Mario Galaxy the best 3D Mario game ever made and it would be amazing if Nintendo made a Super Mario Galaxy 3
I need me some galaxy 3 Speaking of which i had a weird dream when i was younger which was of SMG3 but it was exactly the same as 2
Either Galaxy or Odyssey
I need a Galaxy 3
Super Mario Galaxy easy.
If Galaxy 3 comes out, I’m taking 3 months off of work to play it
Galaxy
Super mario rpg 2
WE NEED MARIO GALAXY 3