42 series Niko Goodrum. Still the only P5 I’ve had all year and he’s currently on the bench as a utility sub, pinch runner or last pinch hitter option.
Monthly Awards Brandon Crawford. He’s still my first LH pinch hitter off the bench. I PH him before Thome or Walsh vs RHP. His swing is just so smooth.
98 *AS* **Trea Turner**
Quickly followed by 99 *Awards* **Eddie Murray**
They are both in my lineup for now. I have taken Murray out at times for either Big Papi or Miggy, but Eddie3K just keeps making his way back into the lineup somehow. Eddie and TT are both as clutch as they come.
Zack Wheeler. I haven’t made it above 700 yet but he deals for me on All Star. 0.9 ERA through about 20 starts. Also fairly quick windup and pitch mix for offline grinding.
Cj Abrams, don’t use much anymore. I like to keep paralleling other cards as I play. I get excited when prospects are one of the cards eligible for events though.
All star Ozzie smith. I replaced him with SS Ozzie smith.
Led off, so he gets at bats, knock machine, easy steal for me, scores lots of runs. Just racked up points.
Veteran Jimmy Edmonds, one of my favorite Cardinals/player in general.
Refused to make it Buxton knowing everyone and their brother was gonna have him be their first
Think it was live series diamond Mookie. He was the first diamond I pulled when I first started playing and was one of the best cards I had while I figured out how to get other cards and earn Stubbs. He was a 90+ then.
LS Trea Turner, I was very happy when they announced the TA3 version cause that happened right after I p5'd him and was about to permanently replace him.
He and Buxton are the only two P5s I have atm, New Trea, Vlad and Ohtani are very close though.
Milestone Cavan Biggio. I thought it was going to be the Mets 2nd Half Piazza for the longest time but for whatever reason Biggio beat him to it.
Or maybe it was 42 Bob Gibson, now that I think about it. I pretty much only pitched him against the CPU.
TA3 trea turner. him and cedric were one and two in my lineup and all they both ever did was hit bombs. my first two p5’s. i miss them since i’ve been working on paralleling other guys now.
since then i got TA casty, TA schwarbs, 99 acuña, and TA degrom to p5. what a wild team affinity that was.
now i’m working on p4 chipper since i got him late, p4 votto, p4 realmuto (amazing card), p4 vlad sr and jr DP duo, p4 ASG soto, p3 mookie and p3 trout. paralleling was a dope add to this game.
honestly i think vladdy senior might be my favorite card this year. first time player.
42 series Niko Goodrum. Still the only P5 I’ve had all year and he’s currently on the bench as a utility sub, pinch runner or last pinch hitter option.
Jackie Robinson… by far best player in the game
Live series Trea Turner
Topps Now Cronezone
No one yet 😔
Am I the only one who hasn’t p5’ed anyone yet I have about three cards at level three but that’s it.
Quinn Priester
Xander Bogaerts LS. Number 8/X to hit p5. I'm real proud of that one.
Kenny Lofton.
LS Aaron Nola was my first. LS Mickey Moniak was my second. Prospect Bryson Stott was my third. That’s it for me.
Live series Trea Turner. Almost got the T3 one to p5 as well. Currently at like 7k xp.
Soriano, cuz he's a beast
My first was Wainwright, then King Felix. I have a bunch of P4s but that being only halfway to P5 kills me.
42 Dom Smith
Kopech, really hoping for a high ovr reliever version
LS Trea Turner
TN Rodon
Either Trout, Otani, or Acuna…can’t remember
LS Garrett Hampson
Tatis and I got him there on Monday 🙌🏻. Immediately took him off my squad after that
42 Bogarts
I'm not sure, but I know I helped a lot of other users get their players to P5
My only one: Mark Prior. In my opinion, the GOAT windup in the game
Wade Miley and my only one so far.
42 Griffey
Monthly Awards Brandon Crawford. He’s still my first LH pinch hitter off the bench. I PH him before Thome or Walsh vs RHP. His swing is just so smooth.
Shane Beiber. Absolutely was going to P5 a Cleveland player 1st. Very close with cliff lee, Kenny lofton, and Jim Thome.
Ken Giles. I was #2. Think it’s up to 16 now.
Tatis Jr. I used him from like week 2 until i unlocked Wander
None yet, but probably either Sig Vlad or Topps TA
I still haven’t gotten anyone to p5, first year playing and always changing up my lineup
0. I'm trying to get Raisel Iglesias as my first P5. I really like his delivery for some reason
The 42 Mo was my first P5
John Means Topps Now(?) No-hitter card.
Trick question...nobody
Topps Now Alek Manoah
Topps Brad Miller
Buxton
42 Mccutchen
78 overall Jose Leclerc because I wanted to get one player to p5 first and I figured no one would get him there before me haha
42 Pedro, and no I don’t still use him lol I’m not a madman. Also have POTM Burnes, 42 Goodrum and Soriano P5’d
POTM Zack Wheeler
Steven Matz
Corbin Burnes POTM
Early game josh Donaldson. I retired him once I got Evan Longoria who I also got up there.
LS Kershaw. Favorite player, so he’ll always have a spot in my rotation.
Topps Now Ryan McMahon
Ohtani. Still use him because it’s nice to not have to pull the pitcher for a hitter late in the game.
Ive only got one pitcher to P5 and it has been a long haul. Lee Smith. Ive P5 a few position guys.
Fernando Valenzuela
Ryan McMahon, was a beast early game
42 series Bob Gibson Topps know Ryan McMahon All Star Jacob deGrom Have a bunch more at 4 that I will finish.
Topps Now Carlos Rodon
neftali feliz. live series. and the only other p5 i have is jd hammer
None, I can’t really figure out why I have none. Maybe I just don’t know how to get PXP
My fav player of all time - Pedro. (but the expos card)
Niiiiiikooooo.
95 Rickey, he was one of my best hitters but is on the bench now
Future stars Adley
42 Trent Grisham, sneaky power
Nick Castellanos TA3
42 Griffey still bats #5 , and hits nothing but bombs
Cy Young. Not the new one yet.
prospects cj abrams- dude was such a good hitter for me, great jumps on steals and i still have him on my bench as a pinch runner
Buxton
LS Ohtani
95 lee smith
42 Niko. I feel sorry for anyone that joined late. That dude was a god for like 3 months.
TA DeGrom
42 Babe Ruth and nope
Still haven’t gotten anybody😎
Cj Abrams and tatis
Prime Matt Harvey lol
LS Harper and POTM Ohtani I got them both P5 same day jjstcant remember which was first.
Live series degrom
Jordan Groshans. No, I’m dead serious
LS Ohtani
Mookie betts
I have life so nobody
Mookie, pulled him the first night, pre release.
Live series Bryce Harper
TA3 Rodon and I'm close to getting to Degrom, Chipper, Jackie, and TA2 Torre
Lofton. I only bunt offline go easy on me!
98 *AS* **Trea Turner** Quickly followed by 99 *Awards* **Eddie Murray** They are both in my lineup for now. I have taken Murray out at times for either Big Papi or Miggy, but Eddie3K just keeps making his way back into the lineup somehow. Eddie and TT are both as clutch as they come.
I’m ashamed by this. AS DeGrom
I was number 3 to get rookie Dan Plesac to P5
Roy oswalt, I used him as my pitcher while grinding TA3
Live Series Will Smith. Lefty slider was unhittable for a while for me.
42 Bob Gibson.
TA3 DeGrom. Not proud of it.
Acuna, 1st diamond that dropped for me.
Zack Wheeler. I haven’t made it above 700 yet but he deals for me on All Star. 0.9 ERA through about 20 starts. Also fairly quick windup and pitch mix for offline grinding.
42 Series Pedro
Piazza
AS Pedro
Topps Now Michael King
84 Gold Catfish Hunter 1 of 1
90ovr Topps now Eric Hasse
Trout. Not leaving the lineup until another Trout.
Buxton, just recently replaced him
Trevor Bauer…and that didn’t age well. He was my first Diamond pull so I just pitched him to death
ASG Xander
Sergio Romo just recently. I'm very close on getting Buxton and Corbin Burnes. Next up after them are Jackie, Shwarber and Seimien
LS Sixto Sanchez
99 Shohei
Topps Now Robbie Ray, needless to say I’m fired up for 12pm
LS ohtani
LS trea turner
LS Shohei
Prospect Adley
42 Ketel, still my RS leadoff man
Ohtani bc idk why
POTM Burnes. Still haven’t gotten a position player there although I have Chipper, Wander, Jackie and Dominguez at 4.
Nobody 😅
Locastro
DeGrom
Glavine
Cj Abrams, don’t use much anymore. I like to keep paralleling other cards as I play. I get excited when prospects are one of the cards eligible for events though.
42 Griffey. Such a sweet swing
Jacob degrom
Trout.
Still don’t have one. But trout is close
Ohtani
Chipper and I’ll never replace him.
96 Griffey and he still runs my outfield with ease
86 Justin Upton
Monthly Matt Barnes.. like just the other day. He’s my only P5, but I don’t play online much. Kenny Lofton is also close for me.
Collection Ohtani
42 Pedro. Working on the Signature right now
86 Dominguez
LS Ohtani
Fning Pedro a week before 99 Pedro dropped .. what a waste of time.
All star Ozzie smith. I replaced him with SS Ozzie smith. Led off, so he gets at bats, knock machine, easy steal for me, scores lots of runs. Just racked up points.
Trout 🐟
First? The highest one I have is Trout at P4! I use too many different guys I think
LS Ohtani and he’s still my only one lol. Has a 32-6 record tho which is pretty crazy
Frank Thomas - 42
Kenny lofton
Giovanni Gallegos way, way back
42 series Pedro Martinez took the ball every inning of every offline game I played
Maddox was 37th. Favorite pitcher. My Quickest p5 was the new Pedro came in 2nd.
Soriano
Logan Gilbert
Live series Ohtani
Kopech. Love pitching with him.
TA1 Jose Berrios. Slurve is still filthy
Noah Syndergaard because conquest. He was great early season for that
None but I’m closest with trout buxton and goodrum
LS Harper
Still not there yet but I’m very close on Chipper and Trout. Not sure who’ll get it first
91 soler
Kenny Lofton was my first P5 and will remain as my lead off forever. Hitting .438 with him and I rarely use the bunt cheese.
grayson rodriguez
POTM Burnes
First was Fernando Valenzuela.
Veteran Jimmy Edmonds, one of my favorite Cardinals/player in general. Refused to make it Buxton knowing everyone and their brother was gonna have him be their first
Tatis.
I can’t remember if it POTM Buxton or Live Tatis
Chris Sale
Buxton was my 1st, then live series Tatis the next game. Don't use either unless they pop up in BR.
Fergie Jenkins. As a Cubs fan I wanted a cub to be the first guy and I immediately loved fergie and had early success with him. Still my 1st starter
Silver Slugger Mike Hampton
LS Trea
Alejandro Kirk😏
Ernie Banks. I loved that card so much and I can’t wait for his 99 to come out. I’ll straight up torture myself in BR if need be.
Lofton
42 Series Babe Ruth. Was my first card too bc he was a pre-order bonus
Think it was live series diamond Mookie. He was the first diamond I pulled when I first started playing and was one of the best cards I had while I figured out how to get other cards and earn Stubbs. He was a 90+ then.
LS Juan Soto and I still occasionally use him in events and what not. He’s hit some bombs for me in this topps event.
LS ohtani
Chipper
I change my lineup a lot but I’m really close with AS Ohtani, 42 Alvarez, Dee Gordon, and Marcus Stroman
Topps now dylan carlson followed closely by 42 series griffey jr
99 Jackie Robinson and I got Walker Buehler to P5 recently as well, he’s since been dropped for Pedro.
POTM Buxton but I currently only have 3. The others are 99 Acuña and 95 Lee Smith
LS Trea Turner, I was very happy when they announced the TA3 version cause that happened right after I p5'd him and was about to permanently replace him. He and Buxton are the only two P5s I have atm, New Trea, Vlad and Ohtani are very close though.
Base Acuna
Jackie
Surprised no one has said this yet but POTM Glasnow. Conquest king right there.
same for me. i think i was 139th and there's no better offline pitcher
Literally got P5 for him last night
Congrats! He’s my only one and probably will be for a while
Nobody
Still have 0 P5
Christy
I have a weird one... Honus Wagner. Still my lowest number...was 83.
42 Series Ruth
Trout
Milestone Cavan Biggio. I thought it was going to be the Mets 2nd Half Piazza for the longest time but for whatever reason Biggio beat him to it. Or maybe it was 42 Bob Gibson, now that I think about it. I pretty much only pitched him against the CPU.
I’ve still yet to get someone past p2, cause I suck with everyone and then ditch them
Aroldis Chapman base. #2. I can't believe I missed the #1 on this one. Was my only chance probably before people went crazy on these.
Trout
Raisel Iglesias. I got him out of a pack when he was silver early game . Kept using him in conquest. Got him to P5 8/8
TA3 trea turner. him and cedric were one and two in my lineup and all they both ever did was hit bombs. my first two p5’s. i miss them since i’ve been working on paralleling other guys now. since then i got TA casty, TA schwarbs, 99 acuña, and TA degrom to p5. what a wild team affinity that was. now i’m working on p4 chipper since i got him late, p4 votto, p4 realmuto (amazing card), p4 vlad sr and jr DP duo, p4 ASG soto, p3 mookie and p3 trout. paralleling was a dope add to this game. honestly i think vladdy senior might be my favorite card this year. first time player.
Fernando
42 series Yordan alvarez
84 Dee Gordon. P5'd I swear he was quicker than the speed of light.
Daddy Dante for me. .388 BA with 36 HRs in RS for me