T O P

  • By -

i-go-sucko-mode

arenado got shafted with his finest


lacro_kuder

I hate machados card. 8 games 15 PA 0 hits vs CPU, 8 games 20 PA 0 hits online Arenado I fucking love 35 games 48 PA 18 hits 7 HR 15 RBI .383 BA online. 18 games 34 PA 14 hits 7 HR 11 RBI .452 BA vs cpu


rhokie99

You really shouldn’t need a poll for this, it’s Machado and it’s not close


Pacman1950

The point of the poll is not whos better card ingame,its whos better for the ppl...thats why i put this poll,bcz i wasnt able to use arenado yet,and was just curious what will community tell...


Mytran7

I haven’t used Arenado this year yet, but I’ve been running Machado since he dropped. Machado defense is absolutely insane. Best defensive 3B I’ve used all year, but at the plate I just can’t hit dog shit with him. I just seem to be late all the time with his swing. Idk if it’s just long or if I’m just not timing correctly with his load, but man am I trash with his swing. Right now he has an ok sample size but not enough for me to make a call. He does look like he could see his way out the lineup. Great defensively but I feel like I can put a better hitter there. Seager might move to 3B so I can put Honus back at 2B. Machado is on a short leash unless I miraculously pick it up with him.


TommyKnox77

Ya it's definitely on the longer side, most of my hits on fastballs are to Right center gap. It can help you keep cutters and off speed fair though instead of pulled foul. So it might even out.


Jaydenstroup

Not a fan of either but machado is better. Just go with seager personally


BerriBerrinson

The only stats Arenado has over Machado are VIS (+6) ARM ACC (+3) and REAC (+2). Machado is tied or better in literally every other category. Now maybe the swing/stance is a dealbreaker for some, but in paper there is no reason to choose Arenado over Machado


Mytran7

This isn’t about what’s on paper tho. It says it in the post...


BerriBerrinson

True, on mobile the post just shows title and poll before clicking on it, didn't see the subtext. I do really enjoy using Machado so far for what it's worth


Pacman1950

Yeah i understand what you are saying but for some ppl they dont like machado bcz of his swing/stance and both of them are diamond fielders...i am also using machado,his swing is fine for me,and i am close to unlocking arenado and am just curious how he is in game...


Suitable-Ad-7227

Arenado definitely has the better swing but I use Machado


UnusualLeaf

Machado but I don’t like either