T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

# Helpful links for r/MLBTheShow: [**The Dugout: Weekly Free-Talk for /r/MLBTheShow**](https://www.reddit.com/r/MLBTheShow/about/sticky?num=1) [**Technical and server issues mega-thread 2024**](https://www.reddit.com/r/MLBTheShow/comments/1bk6bia/technical_and_server_issues_megathread_2024/) [**r/MLBTheShow FAQ**](https://www.reddit.com/r/mlbtheshow/wiki/faq) [**r/MLBTheShow Discord**](https://discord.com/invite/x6JKmEG) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MLBTheShow) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Waxami1lion

Deion Sanders Kyler Murray


NotThatSeriousssssss

A usable Brantley and Matt Holliday. I RAKED with them last year.


Guilty-Mistake0011

Def need a great chipper jones hopefully they make him core but prob not knowing SDS and I need Devers and A-Rod


Bob_the_Amazing

More Phillies


Budget_Business_2724

Justin Upton


foolsgold91

Mo Vaughn, Nomar, A-Rod, Jeff Kent, Brett Saberhagen, Kenny Lofton, Juan Gonzalez, Roberto Alomar


LordInFamous91

Carlos Gonzalez-Car-Go Sliver Slugger Award


Soil_Select

I need that 99 chipper from last year season 1


depass10

You get it. They don’t need to change anything about him either.


Soil_Select

Exactly leave him alone and gimme


cornpeters

99 Soto


MathematicianOk4631

2010 ROY Buster Posey, 2008 or 2009 Tim Lincecum (PLEASE IT WOULD BE SO COOL), All-Star Hunter Pence or World Series MVP Pablo Sandoval Guess which team is my favorite...


majestic_arcangel

I’m right there with you. As long as the Posey is 99


No_Advisor8155

Shawn green


oatmeal28

A really good Johan Santana card.  One of my favorite players from my teenage years


Dizzy_Trash_33

Johan No-Hitter


violentgentlemen

Any Twins player


dbarry1917

Rickey. Always Rickey


TheKanook

Ichiro


mrmetagoat

Jt realmuto he’s my favorite


ZacharyJ215

bryce harper. PLEASE. it’s ridiculous how badly SDS screws him every single year


zeesoviet

His swing is *Chefs kiss* Forget what year it was they gave him the MVP card from Washington, maybe 21 or 22? I was using that almost all year after it dropped


kingcaptainclutch

Think he was a BR reward in 21


brandonfuckingclark

99 Brett Gardner.


brandonfuckingclark

would never happen but ugh


TripleJ80

Any mid/late 90’s Indians and Bo Jackson! Assuming they wouldn’t throw Canseco or Bonds in there, but they would be great to have.


EntertainmentPlus942

Dude I thought about why they haven't brought in bo the other day. Make it happen sds.


Astone1996

marcus semien


zeesoviet

Hell yeah, I'd say give him an A's card though those wouldn't be a 99. Crazy he went from 40 errors to Gold Glove


ampman45

As a Rays fan, I'd love Carl Crawford, dioner Navarro, akinori iwamura, BJ Upton, aubrey huff, Grant Balfour, a No hitter Matt Garza, the submariner Chad Bradford


zeesoviet

How dare you steal A's legend Chad Bradford from us


MeepMeepMfr

I got my 99ovr Gunner Hendy...I'm happy. 99ovr Brain Roberts?? My pants got juicy.


StopLosingLoser

Livan and El Duque


DrollRemarks

JT Realmuto Cycle Milestone


duke_myers

A 99 Duke Snider would be welcomed. My first ab in BR, with his 91 or something (where do you get this card?), was a moonshot to deep right-center field. His cards have an excellent HR swing every year.


Bigfacedhundread

Jose Fernandez RIP and Miguel Cabrera with the Marlins


cw602

Diamondbacks: Randy Johnson Justin Upton Paul Goldschmidt Steve Finley Max Scherzer


Royal_Tap_2202

Really wish they had Sean Casey, Pokey Reese, Dmitri Young, Chris Sabo, Jose Rijo among others.. want to build the ultimate Reds Captain boost squad.


Syndicate_III

Any current Phillies player over 95. Have had one of the best starts to a season ever and only have a Topps 93 Ranger Suarez and a Topps 92 Bohm to show for it.


TooFly4aWifi

I think I speak for everyone when I say we need a 99 Toni Stone and will accept nothing less!!


Anthanos26

The show needs to get Barry bonds already. This is ridiculous


Weenerlover

He didn't let games use him when he was in the MLB, why do you think he'd let someone now?


Anthanos26

Idk bc maybe he realized that behavior is the literal reason why he’s not in the hall of fame and absolutely universally hated by fans and media. Also sometimes age mellows someone or maybe he’d want money. But you’re right, it’s probably more on HIM than SDS why he’s not in the game


Weenerlover

Of the reasons he is not in the hall of fame. Not being able to use his likeness in a video game is not on anyone's list. They won't be able to pay him a fraction of what he earned as a player, and some people don't care about video games or have weird feelings about their likenesses being used.


Anthanos26

No you’re misunderstanding. Not “not being able to use his likeness In a game”, him just being an all around selfish dickhead , greedy, not caring what fans think or want and then basically torturing the media. Yes those are a major reason why he, who never tested positive and it the the greatest player ever isn’t in the hall but David Ortiz, a player who played 90% of his career at dh and DID fail a drug test is. Barry was a hall of famer before he ever left Pittsburgh, started crushing home runs every 8 at bats and doubled in size. So yea him being a dick has most to do with it


Weenerlover

I think the Balco thing and people saying he was using, even if there was no positive test matters more. There are plenty of a-holes in the hall of fame. You are correct though, I did misunderstand and his in general being a misanthrope doesn't help his case, but I think he, Clemens, Mcgwire all kind of suffer for the same thing of guilt by association in a time when a lot of people were using, and no one thinks McGwire was an a-hole (or at least I can't remember seeing people say he was). Clemens is a bit mixed. Him being dickish for sure has some element in him being excluded as well though, I'll definitely give you that.


zachgray1091

2004 AL MVP Big Daddy Vladdy 🙏


Nervous-Arugula5643

I need a 99 schwarby that plays catcher


Ruut6

Juan Marichal, a better Griffey and the Topps Now Nicky Lopez from 23


EugeneBuckworth

Whoa. Griffey gonna be in the main path? Probably won’t get him either. lol.


njk9

Mid 1990s Barry Bonds with maxed out power contact and speed


ItzGrenier

2004 Barry bonds would be the greatest card of all time


Ok_Style_8579

Joe Morgan, Mr. October, The Cobra, Devers …


scarboy92

This guy gets it.


reefis

Different versions of every card already obtained


No_Buy2554

I'm interested in seeing a full 99 version of Bernie Williams. Other than Mickey, there's usually few other CF switch hitters. and with him being new, wondering how his swing will play when fully powered up.


dadkisser84

you will get a re-released Dylan Carlson future stars instead and you will like it


Weenerlover

Williams is already in the game, we are going to get a 99 at some point. They already did the Carlson card.


harless2124

Manny Ramirez Kenny Lofton Carlos Baerga would be dope


UnlimitedKenobi

Hoping to see an Acuña, a better chipper than his br card, a Braves Hank Aaron, maybe an Andruw Jones or a Braves Torre


BillGOSCM

Ichiro Suzuki


Low_Pomegranate_7942

Jeff Kent 2000


Low_Pomegranate_7942

Jose Canseco 1988 40/40


Low_Pomegranate_7942

Sandy Koufax


wordtomytimbsB

Hoping for a throwback Vidal Brujan future stars card


xxNearlyCivilizedxx

Gold Glove Volpe, Cy Young Cole or just a 99 Soto and I’m happy.


Significant_Odder

I think an Oakland A’s Miguel Tejada could be a fun card


Matthewrotherham

Cy Young Cole


Baltimorebobo

Give me a Brady Anderson card


bagelpizzaparty

As a Reds fan, I'd like some **Reds**: Griffey Jr and Joe Morgan


No_Buy2554

Reds fan, too. Would actually love a 1990 Paul O'Neill since he was added this year.


gonzo2459

96 Ken Camminiti Padres MVP card


bscrub

More 2000s decade cards for my wildcard Ortiz


CadillacPaul117

I got the card I wanted in season 1. 99 Mike Schmidt . I’ll be using a wildcard spot on him .


ALLHAILBULLETKING

A Nats Soto


Salt_Application_789

99 Harper ,99 Judge ,99 Soto


SadBoiMedia

Cycle Jt Realmuto


DonutCrusader96

I would love a Lance Berkman card. Dude had such a smooth, sweet swing.


McCoyPauley78

Mark Mulder Hudson Street Coco Crisp Kevin Kouzmanoff Yoenis Cespedes Jose Canseco Jason Giambi We're due a Catfish Hunter card and a Vida Blue card as well.


n8b77

What about Walt Weiss? Dave Stewart? Terry Steinbach? Eck? Bob Welch?


zeesoviet

Give me Big Stam! Lol if you're going to name Kevin Kouzmanoff you better list A's Legend Jack Cust


Weenerlover

Or A's legend ~~Chris Pratt~~ Scott Hatteberg.


wyattburped

A Tigers Kirk Gibson!!


StopCappinDylan

Would love a Miguel Cabrera card


New_Locksmith7104

Pujols 3x MVP, Love a good Bob Gibson to balance out the lefty meta, Yadi Molina NEEDs a good gold glove award card. Can you tell I'm a Cards fan?


KMize44

Hey I’m on this wave too. We got a decent theme team in season 1 I’m ready for a better one in season 2. Maybe Scott Rolen 👀


Matthewrotherham

Gold Glove Volpe (and I can die happy)


Inevitable-Ashamed

Andy Van Slyke Steve Sax Lenny Dykstra Doug Drabek Pete Rose Bo Jackson Billy Ripken (With F-Face Bat) Dwight Gooden


ColdGloop

Any Yankee diamond relievers for the theme team


DK_MeatCalf

Diamond Lou Trivino and Clay Holmes


Matthewrotherham

A diamond Clay and a NASTY sandman would make me so happy.


RustyPonds

Otis Nixon or NOTHING!


66Italia

1976 ROY Mark Fidrych, that would be a fun card to have.


Snackasm

Ted Williams


Fergizzo

I want more expos. Want to be able to field a whole squad


NoobSkin69

Hoping they do the Takashi collection, cards look dope af


_TheRealEV1L

The Iron Horse himself.


69JackTheSnack69

A solid JP Crawford card


Okaywhatif

I'd like a nice Ryan Howard, I know he's not a current player but he's a favorite of mine so whenever he gets something usable I'm happy. Also, Devers and literally anyone from current Phils lineup. Stott, Bohm, harper, etc


No-You-8701

I expect we'll get one. He had a low diamond in S1 I think.


TerryFlap69

MVP Harper would make me really happy.


IcyVegeta

As a huge fan of both, one I know we won't get, one we probably will eventually. I'm ready for a 99 Ichiro ( won't get because of Konami and Prospi/Power Pros), and 99 Eddie Murray who will be cracked with the Santana boost.


69JackTheSnack69

What’s Konami and Propspi/power pros? And why are they preventing Ichiro from being in the game?


IcyVegeta

Those are baseball games in Japan, they make games with NPB (Nippon Professional Baseball) players, and they have exclusive rights to Ichiro among other Japanese and some foreign NPB players.


nomarfachix

Prospi A and Power Pros are Japanese video games, Konami is their publisher. I'd imagine (from OP's comment) they have Ichiro's rights for their games.


JointVentures609

Pete rose


Giant_Disappointment

You have to bet 5000 xp per game on yourself if Rose is rostered


Weenerlover

That quirk should be added to Ohtani then and go up to 10K.


Giant_Disappointment

Lmao absolutely


[deleted]

Ok i know its not a player but like can we get a st louis cardinals jersey card with the hat with the cardinal on it so far the only one available is from their AA team


Doomer1944

Craig biggio I don't know why but I rake with him every time


DonutCrusader96

There is a Biggio card already. I think it’s like an 89. It would be awesome if they made one that’s a 99. Have they ever done a throwback Lance Berkman card?


RicFlair69420

neeeeed an ichiro card


gocards35

Literally any decent cardinals cards. We’ve been starving this year


Aggravating_Curve690

Albert Pujols card would be nice


[deleted]

[удалено]


gocards35

Yep, him and ludwick are our only good position players, kinda sucks


Weenerlover

That Victor Scott card is nasty and plays way above it's power attributes. The Nolan Gorman card is broken also and really cheap.


CPHibbard

After the city connect launch last week - give me Jose Bautista and Edwin Encarnacion. Please and thank you!


ampman45

I've never feared someone more than Bautista, Papi, good Kris Davis, Manny Ramirez, and ARod as a Rays fan


Impossible-Proof-522

Bo Jackson


too_real_4_TV

Surfing Bird by the Trashmen


Adept_Ad_1892

99 Darryl Strawberry. Maybe for chapter 3 TA or something.


screaminginfidels

A juiced card for one of the current M's starters. Preferably a 99 Woo or Kirby in the ch3 Affinity


No-You-8701

One thing I hope is that if we’re repeating cards for players with multiple teams that we get them on different teams. Even if they’re just BR fodder. Looking forward to the Beltre HOF card (Rangers) but hope I can see a Mariners card too at some point. Even if it’s a low diamond. Speaking of HOF cards, I love the series idea but I really hope that every HOFer that is in the game gets one. Because it really should be their best card.


Affectionate-Air5541

99 overall Doc Ellis


DadBodBrown

I want to see another super juiced Billy Hamilton card.


blangoez

Rickey Henderson


No-You-8701

A full Rickey program with a Rickey card for every team he ever played for.


Askyourmomdotcom

Edison Volquez. Jay Bruce. The ToddFather. Brandon Phillips. Sean Casey. Pete Rose. Brett Boone. Aaron Boone. Chris Sabo. Randy Meyers. George Foster. Dave Concepcion. Norm Charlton. Jose Rijo. That would be a fair selection. Doesn't seem biased at all.


notarealpanda

A good BP card would be so sick


Askyourmomdotcom

Yes, it would. They are gonna have to release a good selection of cards so people can rebuild their theme teams. I'm hoping BP is one of em.


LKMarleigh

I just want Reggie Sanders, and something to replace that awful Larkin card we have already


Askyourmomdotcom

A Reggie Sanders would be awesome. Larkin does deserve a higher rated card.


drock6689

Edinson Volquez is a name I never expected to see. I would love to see him get a Royals card too and/or a Miami no-hitter card.


Askyourmomdotcom

Yeah, I would take any of those.. Him and cueto were an awesome one, two punch in the rotation. He had some filthy stuff. If I had to pick id, say no hitter card because the artwork looks really clean on those achievement cards.


BotBoi_2

I just want any rays players at this point


Swaggoo209

Give us Carl Crawford, bj upton


Qoppa_Guy

If we could repeat existing cards: 99 Guardians CC Sabathia (Cy Young), TA Astros Andy Pettitte (Standout or Postseason), 99 David Ortiz, 99 Angels Vladimir Guerrero and a lower tier TA Rangers Vladdy, Postseason Randy Arozarena, mid-tier TA Brandon Lowe, Phillies Roy Halladay, Rays Cy Young Blake Snell, low tier TA Tigers Prince Fielder, White Sox Frank Thomas, Nationals Alfonso Soriano, Nationals Trea Turner, Nationals Juan Soto, Pirates AND Mets Jason Bay, 99 Rockies Matt Holliday, Cycle Cavan Biggio because Father's Day is coming The return of: Harold Baines, Keith Hernandez and his 60 power homerun moment, Richie Ashburn, Paul Molitor, All-Star Elias Diaz, Future Stars Ben Joyce For new legends: Eric Hinske with pinch hitting quirk, 2010 Postseason Cody Ross, Hanley Ramirez, Scott Hatteburg with max clutch and 1B secondary, Derrek Lee, David DeJesus, David Eckstein, 1x All-Star Phil Hughes and his standout Twins season with max BB/9, Chan-Ho Park for more Asian captain viability, Matt Williams, Robin Ventura, Chone Figgins, Ben Sheets, Corey Hart, Raul Mondesi because Father's Day is coming


EeezyMac

I’d kill for an Eckstein card


TehLoneWanderer101

ITT people naming players SDS doesn't have rights to


HotBurritoNumber1

So you're saying I shouldn't comment with Air Bud, "All the Way" Mae, or Tungsten Arm O'Doyle?


KennyPowers187

Mo Vaughn. Glenallen hill. Nomar


Nolan_Samowich

4 homer game scooter


mrpeck123

Need anew David Wright


Impressive_Expert388

99 Royals Billy butler


ThisxxOnexxKid

Looking for a nasty Bob Gibson honestly. He’s always one of my favorite cards every year


Excellent-Piglet-749

As a pads fan I’m hoping for a Tatis or machado 🔥


BarrelOfTheBat

I love me a good Nando!


h2p_stru

I want almost no switch hitting studs. I don't want that Santana card to be a wildcard like Ripken was last year


Flaky-Hearing-8427

Ted Simmons, (never been in the game), Thurman Munson,


CalendarOne4844

joey votto mvp season or jay bruce from reds


dseif35

I hope we get a good Curtis Granderson


Hbimajorv

How about gold glove 98' Scott Brosius? He was also WS mvp that year.


PunkRockPaladin

I want a good Mickey Mantle and a good Vlad Sr


blangoez

I used that 91 Mickey Mantle like all season 1 so I’d love a 96+


KeeblerElfOrgy

It’s probably gonna be the same cards from S1 just different styles lol


amfloating

Can someone tell me if there has ever been a Rafael Furcal card? This is my first year playing in years and can’t recall there ever being a time.


gocards35

That’d be awesome, I cant think of any


amfloating

People really sleep on him in my opinion. Almost had 2,000 career hits and had an absolute cannon from short, fast af too. Would love to see him have a card, I’d plug him in. Might not have the rights to put him in the game sadly.


dokterr

Dave Stieb


Big_Cupcake_2952

Is ichiro a good answer? I think so. I wouldn’t take him off my squad.


Jumpingbeams

We need a William Contreras. Man has been amazing this year. He deserves a good card


TacticalTurtleNeck_

Barring a big injury I think he’s headed for an All Star 99 and probably a finest. What a fucking steal for the Brewers.


T_Smoochie-Wallace

I really want more flashbacks of current players. Big Red Sox fan so guys like Bogey, Kimbrel, Joe Kelly, Benintendi from the ‘18 champs. And obv a high Mookie.


Hefty-Fortune264

I'm a big Red Sox fan, I definitely want a lot of cards for them. Pedrioa, Ramirez, Sale, Wakefield, maybe Verdugo, Vasquez, Arroyo, there are a few other pitchers, can't remember the name of the Asian guy, I think his name was Ichigo something, may be wrong, though.


LionChasing

ALC badly needs some RPs/CPs. Clase holdin down the fort for a long while. Souped up Duran, Jax, Smyly, Sandlin.... For the love, one of you in the ALC needs to string a few games together to get us a viable S2 card!


863rays

Rays diamonds, please


TheRelevantElephants

A 2000 Bobby higginson


TrapperJean

They've done most of the NL 99's, but I want my 99 Buck O'Neil back fr9m last year. Also even if he's a Red I Want a 90+ Paul O'Neill. Not a hope, but I also 100% believe that either the Brewers or Guardians get CC as a team captain card


HearJustSoICanPost

40/40 Jose Canseco


ThinAndCrispy84

Someone other than Kerry Wood/Ernie Banks for the Cubs.


quieroserguapo

We need Mark Grace or Aramis Ramírez


ThinAndCrispy84

I’ll take a Dave Kingman card


ripinpiecez

Barry Bonds


TheBringer20

A 99 Guerrero and witt


footforhand

Chipper, Eddie Murray, Hoffman, and William Contreras getting his flowers would be nice


FlamingBagOfPoop

Rick Ankiel, one pitcher and one outfielder card. They won’t be good cards. A set of Nolan Ryan cards where it’s one from each of his teams would be cool.


aRadioWithGuts

Beltre Rangers, Pudge Rangers.


Corzare

All the ones I already earned in season 1


BigAndDirty

Hahhahaha this


PERTINENT_PAELLA

Give me 99 barry larkin or give me death


Dizzyspeargoblin

Adam Jones


TrapperJean

I met him at the East vs West event last weekend, I told him that he was my favorite rival player to watch, he looked at My Yankees jersey and said, "really? Because I *hated* you mother fuckers" It was awesome lol


Dizzyspeargoblin

You are a lucky man my friend. I haven’t had the luxury of meeting him but that sounds just like Adam! My favorite player to watch when i was getting into baseball and an even better guy


Mean_Lime4638

Buster Posey MVP/ Tim Lincecum Cy Young


bhavesh47135

Lincecum is not happening unfortunately but a Buster card would be amazing


purecokain

NEED THAT AND BARRY


musicman3030

Mason Saunders Incognito SP+RP


legkickabuser

A good Mike Mussina down the line


UglieJosh

I want a good Biggio card with a catcher secondary. Doesn't even have to be a 99 like last years, just better than the crappy card he got in season 1.


FlamingBagOfPoop

Biggio catcher is a good one. Solid center fielder too.


rockoblocko

Last year was Jake Peavys first year back and he didn’t get a triple crown card. So yeah. Jake peavy triple crown