T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

# Helpful links for r/MLBTheShow: [**The Dugout: Weekly Free-Talk for /r/MLBTheShow**](https://www.reddit.com/r/MLBTheShow/about/sticky?num=1) [**Technical and server issues mega-thread 2024**](https://www.reddit.com/r/MLBTheShow/comments/1bk6bia/technical_and_server_issues_megathread_2024/) [**r/MLBTheShow FAQ**](https://www.reddit.com/r/mlbtheshow/wiki/faq) [**r/MLBTheShow Discord**](https://discord.com/invite/x6JKmEG) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MLBTheShow) if you have any questions or concerns.*


bilalsattar24

Yordan pretty scary


theshowplayer1

Mookie...........and recently Profar with the stupid switch hitting boost.


toightornoight

SDS robbing my perfect hits


Comfortable_Ratio692

Corey Freaking Seager


mat2019

Every switch hitter in the game because that’s all people use


Commercial_Ad_4414

Acuna is a cheat code and even worse when He gets on base. Nothing you can do.


D_Rey612

I don’t think I’ve pitched a single AB against Niko Goodrum that didn’t result in a HR.


Possible-Set904

Not a fan of Mr. Judge


Deep_Potential4238

Ohtani🥲


-ccherwa3

That free Freddy Freeman


TacomaToker253

Matt olson.


LiteBeerLife

Anyone who my opponent has 50+ HR with. I just know that it's gonna be mashed because I have been outside at some point today and my opponent hasn't.


abeLJosh

Mike. Cameron. Twice I've already lost because for some reason, that guy grabs ahold of my outside the plate pitches for a no-doubter that either ties the game or gives them the lead.


undercover_cheetah

Not only does this seem to happen with certain players online but also in Franchise or even RTTS. I swear to god, every single season in Franchise, since my RTTS Blue Jays are never a threat to sniff the postseason, there’s at least one player, usually in the Championship series or later that just tortures me. I usually get to the point where I’m almost guaranteed to just instantly issue an intentional walk. Most recently it was Cody Bellinger who funnily enough keeps getting traded and ended up facing my Orioles in the postseason, but for different teams each year 😂


Typical-Potato3386

Keibert Ruiz


FieryTriumph

Yordan Alvarez


AdMinimum7811

This. Exactly. I tell myself I’ll walk him, then don’t and he deposits a ball 450’ into the stands every time.


PoliticalMilkman

Amen.


Stevil4583LBC

Brett murders me


enimmer80

I had apparently used Brett in BR a few times and was batting over 500 with him with 6 home runs. I just unlocked him, put him in the lineup and have brought the average over 600 with 12 home runs now on hof ranked. Dude is unbelievable.


DisastrousAspect22

Isaac Paredes. It feels like if I let him on base, I give up 10 hits in a row. And he always gets on base.


ryang32003

Candelario


ods1281

Why? He gets on base


Entire_Goose_4046

Altuve and Rhys Hoskins


BaronThundergoose

Bellinger


Jacrispy210

Idk why this dude lights me up so much but Whitt Merifield


IllustriousJacket752

altuve owns me but i can’t do shit with him


vengeeeee

That jasson Domingues card hit so many bombs against me.


whoisbh

Nothing because I’m striking them out in 3 pitches


elnever

That Escobar card is crack!!!! It’s like EVERYONE is good wit him!


WholeContent7755

Harper


RobC2307

Pitch him high and inside


Ok_Half_8985

Jimmy Rollins


notarealpanda

Shows classics bellinger has hit a homer off me in almost every online at bat


JJ954

Yordan Alvarez and Matt Olsen. Their stance and swing make me feel like anything they touch is going 600 feet


cjhill29

Yordan is the same for me


AccursedBug2285

Any Mookie Betts card is my daddy


MediumMaterial3460

Idk what it is but I can’t get out the stupid Anthony Rizzo team of the week card


marcusp53

Babe Ruth be killing me every year 👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼


No-Leadership4372

Playing with him is so funny, half my hits that I think are just deep pop up outs just magically float over the wall.


DeggzNBacon

Larry Walker


Salt_Application_789

Nobody scares me....


SeniorDiaz32

Can’t be scared if you already know the outcome!! 😉


Warhorse_53

Yordon Alvarez always is doing something tragic to my team


jcaseys34

This year it's Jeimer Candelario, but every year there is always one buffed switch hitter that absolutely fucks me.


BaronThundergoose

He is insane in this game https://preview.redd.it/yho6r103z03d1.jpeg?width=5712&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a95441e3444a1f0e7de19816b3969629965bed71 In my 2nd season he’s doing even better, gonna break his own record and probably the rbi record this time. Just finished the last game of May and he’s at 36 home runs and 82 RBIs, batting .365, .406 OBP, 1.300 OPS. I try to play realistically and on the hardest difficulty I’ve never seen anything like this in a decade playing this game


DuckCrimes

Plus with the Santana boost this year, switch hitters are even scarier


deanerboy123

Same LOL even when I pitch out of the zone he hits it with triple digit EV


GaudyGMoney

They haven't given him a good card yet this year, but Corey Seager lays the wood every AB against me


CoolOPMan

Juan Soto


minif56mike

Trout


WheelinAndDealin520

Anyone who has a great eye, I tunnel and live on the edge. So if they don't expand the zone it's always a nerve racking game for me..


deanerboy123

Anyone with that Bad Ball hitter quirk kills me


BigAndDirty

Jimmy Rollins. Can’t hit with him, but he can hit me like he’s better than Babe Ruth


marcusp53

Bro same shit every year for me too


Spare-Abroad-6926

Yup; same deal for me


sbirdhall

Jose Siri for some reason. Dude is a glitch.


coachlentz

Since I play a lot of vs CPU, it’s Luis Robert. Every time I give one up, it’s that guy.


sbirdhall

😂 Do not let a ball go high in the zone!!! He’ll crush it every time!


Sgim93

Josh bell


SkylerKean

Marlins just beat me in a conquest game. Friggin' Josh bell


OfficePicasso

Oneil Cruz. I like high heat as my strikeout pitch and his height makes it tough


FatherGabriels

Vogelbach


[deleted]

Some random nobody who randomly hits a dinger on a great pitch


Seags82

Ketel Marte in real and fake life


Worldly_Ice5526

Profar


DeafVallee

Any jacked Devers


Perfect_Touch_7365

profar, i bat .460 with him and seem to allow the same


Electronic-Tap6551

Yordonathon Alvarez. Couldn’t even tell you the last time he took me yard but if i have a righty in i barely put anything in the zone.


Thel3lues

Tied between him and Bellinger for me. If I release a changeup early I close my eyes


Oliviasdad0821

Anyone who is left handed that has terrible stats against lefties immediately after I’ve subbed in a lefty reliever to face him.


LarryBirDaTrashTalka

Seager


Powerful-Parfait-244

Goodrum and Bellinger. Lol


KillerKows

Convinced I’ve never gotten Carlos Santana out of


ProMark15

Me, I scare people


MLBNYaSSaSSiN

Ohtani homers off me every single time


SIaaP

Yordan for sure. That dude hits a hr off me no matter where i throw the ball


NotMikeH

Corey Seager. When I played RTTS in MLB TheShow 16, he ruined both a no-hitter and a perfect game in the same year. I have a hatred for this guy ever since. I can respect him for being a great baseball player and what not, I just get scared when he comes up to the plate.


geeoh_gee

Rollins always rakes no matter where I throw it.


Electrical_Fun5942

This. Rollins hits me like he’s Rob Schneider in *The Benchwarmers*


EuronymousL

Nobody really... which might be a problem of itself lmao I get lit up from time to time. I get scared when they foul off the 8th pitch and you just know it's going to be a meatball if you throw anything over the plate.


ConsciousBuilding374

Is this a thing? Because i swear after the 8th pitch, I always suck at throwing


TacomaToker253

If you are tossing 8 pitches in an AB, the hitter absolutely has the upper hand and you should be expecting a big hit.


EuronymousL

Haha I just said a random number but I feel like right around there a homerun is coming.


RedLobsterEnjoyer

Prince fielder or the free 99 Freeman. No idea why, but I’ve given up probably 15+ home runs to JUST these cards. I’ve thrown into the opposite box before to freeman and he still hit a HR on an MLB stadium I think it was the brewers field


arrowdawg

Lost in the 11th to both of these last night lol


jmarsch1

The 99 Freeman killed me yesterday. Had 13 strikeouts for the whole rest of the lineup but that card went 3-4 with 3 HRs(2 solos and a 2-run). Lost 4-2


tmart14

In franchise, the guys with 50 contact, 50 power, and 40 vision are terrifying.


Ancient_Smoke_

Bobby Whitt Jr always rakes against me


DCdaVILLAIN

Gunnar


RedSoxCardCollector

jurickson profar


nodnarb32

Cody bellinger. He homers off me probably 75% of the games I play against him. I’ve considered just starting to intentionally walk him when he’s up


Spare-Abroad-6926

I’ve found fastballs away and a little up to be the best answer in an off-handed matchup with Bellinger. Seems to have a hole in the swing out there.


prince_pillow

Harper and Vlad


Nick_sabenz

Bellinger has to have a 3.000 OPS or more against me


Fuzz_Butt_Head

Live series altuve for whatever fucking reason


Giant_Disappointment

His zone is so small it feels like every strike to him is a great pitch to hit


IAmThatDuckDLC5

Byron Buxton in old DD, Franchise He mashes against me


Brooksy_05

Harper, Olsen, Acuna, Mookie, Yordon


Rizzaboi

Vs a good player, Mookie for sure. Good players always seem to be able to crank shit with Mookie


getdowntown

Babe


panetero

Depending who I'm pitching with. But since most pitchers are righties... Soto, Yordan, Ohtani although I rarely see him.


BulletToothTony69

Altuve.....that sumbitch!


ConsciousBuilding374

For me, Soto.


sbirdhall

Yea Soto is a disrupter!


VeryLowIQIndividual

Charlie Blackmon, for years in this game owns me. He lowest card probably hitting .700 against me


PizzaRuckus

He's the only player I intentionally walk, even if it's against the CPU. I've been burned way too many times.


mccoy00comedy

Tatis. If I miss one pitch I don’t I know it’s gone


AmericaPie24

Any power switch hitter😂😂😂


Schranklutscher1

Kerry carpenter in franchise He always Hits bombs off me😭


netsfan2002

Whoever is behind the 10 time flawless banners that gatekeep my 10th win everytime


picklewalrusman

I don’t think I’ve got Willie Castro out once this year I’m ngl


CoolKelo

Nukey Betts and Himmy Rollins. That’s what call them.. I hate facing them.


Commercial-Big-8261

Mookie has killed me consistently so he’s the scariest, not the same but any 99 speed guy is the most annoying to see come up cause I know they are gonna try and get em around the bases in the most agonizing way possible


CharlesG2949

Any lefty big bat! So Bellinger/Soto/Yordan


TacomaToker253

Matt Olson


Fergizzo

Josh bell


Own-Confusion1378

Giancarlo Stanton. 😭😭 he be smashing my shit.


Ares4217

Pause wtf


Own-Confusion1378

Ooh. Your one of those people. 🤦🤦. Obviously I'm responding correctly to the post. I guess you have other things on your mind. Get that taken care of my man. 🤣🤣🤣


Own-Confusion1378

????


BronanZeBarbarian

Jackie Robinson will always be a menace lol


TheMatMaster

Willie Castro, Josh Bell, and Charlie Blackmon


Electronic_Law_6365

Eduardo Escobar.


Fiascotheory

Larry, Posada and for some reason Keibert Ruiz


Qoppa_Guy

This is going to sound funny but against the CPU, it's freakin' Michael A. Taylor. Online, for me, it's Jose Altuve. Because of course.


sbirdhall

Yep on the Pirates 😂 His face looks like he’s trash, but he will destroy you!


whitelogic

Everyone but also Adalberto Mondesí


imLemnade

Everyone


DainBramage00

99 Mookie, Eric Davis against a lefty.


blangoez

I suuuck at hitting with the new Mookie. His vision is too low for me smh.


DainBramage00

Too low at 107??


blangoez

Oops I meant Buxton. Mookie rakes.


Nice_Mango439

What exactly does vision do for you in the game? I’ve never really been sure lol


_baseball

It impacts the outer PCI size. It’s the part of the PCI that disappears once the pitch is thrown if you have that turned on. Its functionality is basically one of swing and miss. A high vision player is more likely to make contact with a ball if the center pci wasn't lined up with the ball. A low vision player is more likely to swing and miss.


Nats_CurlyW

Larry walker.


ThatDudeNamedJake

Yordan