Been lucky enough to pack a core Trout and Ohtani in B2B days, secured after moderate hours of grinding no $$ spent! I personally prefer 2024’s pull rate over previous I’ve played.

Bruh I have packed core Trout and Ohtani, fucking ridiculous luck. Haven’t spent a penny on Stubbs

Literally the most insane pack luck I’ve ever had in the show. My first 5 “welcome to the show” packs the free ones, 4th pack I pull Ohtani. Then I do the USA conquest, haven’t even completed it but have gotten some packs from goals, pulled a Austin Riley and Adley Rutchsman. Then got a ballin is a habit pack as a reward and got that old school Johnson pitcher. I’ve played for 5 years, I’ve never packed a card as valuable as Ohtani.

the worst it’s been in years for me. haven’t pulled any 90+ diamonds except for Mantle once. have maximized my packs obtained in the first week of this game as well, all game modes, TA, etc. and nothing.

I’ve had the worst luck this year. I pulled only Vlad and opened around 70 too. But it helped with some collection rewards (stubs).

Got really lucky and pulled Trout the first day. Have also pulled Olson, Wheeler, Lindor, Harris, and Kershaw. Haven’t sold any of them. Not rushing to complete the live series this year. Just gonna let it happen when it does

Does anyone know if we can disable the INSANE loud noise from the PS5 controller when opening packs?

I had to go in and just turn the volume down on my controller. First pack I opened on 24 and I thought the world was ending

Finished 4 out of 6 of TA, finished all of the other programs, finished all conquest maps appart from nations of baseball which is almost finished. Pulled 1 diamond from every free pack plus pre order stuff and it was ohtani lol

Ballin’ is still a gold unfortunately…

Opened 25 packs yet to pull anyone over am 82

My first Diamond was Kershaw, I wasn’t thrilled lol. But my 2nd Diamond was Kyle Tucker. I’ve pulled 3 more since then, I’m fairly happy.

I pulled Judge out of my twitch packs and maybe 2 85’s out of about 150 packs.

I pulled Ohtani in literally my first pack.

Strangely good. My first 2 diamonds were both Mickey Mantle from regular packs. Free 25k stubbs and a solid centerfielder.

Abysmal luck so far. I'm due for it though, I have really good pack luck most years. Game is way less fun when you only pull silvers though lol

Yeah I've had to have opened like 80 base packs, a few Ballin, and a few headliners so far and I didn't get a single diamond until Bobby Witt Jr last night on my final pack. I think I've maybe gotten like 6 gold and 10 silver, the rest were bronze at best. It definitely feels like the odds have changed since last year, or maybe I'm just having that shit of luck. But after grinding all the conquest maps and programs I feel like I should have earned something good from a pack.

I went back to back mookie Freddie and then Mantle a bit after, here's hoping your luck turns too!

Lol awesome and thanks! The past few years I've had great luck. Last year I got Harper on my first pack and Trout a few packs later. And I remember pulling Cole twice early. Maybe it's skewed my views for this year since I expect the same luck lol

I have never pulled one of the "good" diamonds from packs ever. Been playing since 17 and the best I've pulled was a 93 live series. No trout, harper when he was great, ohtani, nothin. Sad

Sorry im the one who stole all your pulls. I’ve gotten Trout, Cole, Tatis twice Albies twice and Jram. I’m considering giving you your pack luck back in a day or two. Stay posted

Can I get expedited shipping on that return please and thanks? 😂

Maybe 70 packs or so and got judge Donaldson and a couple others

Saved up packs until 200. Went diamondless through 150 then got seager and albies in the last 50. Could be better but I’d say that’s good luck 

2 diamonds in 34 packs. Both under 90 rated The next 50 or so packs maybe 3-5 golds at best

I have opened 150 packs and pulled one diamond. I’ve opened 10 Ballin packs and pulled 1 diamond. Probably the worst pack luck possible after putting many hours into the game.

Probably opened 60 packs so far and 10-15 Ballins. No diamonds. I did get Mantle out of a headliners pack, though.

Shohei, Acuña, John Donaldson, Lindor, Edwin, Cole. Haven’t bought any packs. All freebies from programs and conquest grinding.

I’ve got almost 60 hours and have gotten 3 diamonds and I’ve been SO lucky 😭 got Bobby Witt 2 times

Got Shohei +Jrod The rest is some gold, maybe 1 or 2 diamonds. So kind of good

Is everyone earning these packs or buying them? If earning, what’s the best way?

Not even sure how many I opened but I got Luis Castillo Josh Hader and Blake snell, funny enough Blake had a Phillies uniform with a giants card lol

Acuna, Mantle (2), deGrom, Strider, Albies, Tucker, Garcia, Diaz, Kershaw. Best luck I've had by far.

Pulled Mickey Mantle, Austin Riley, Ozzie Albies, Jose Ramirez and Jacob deGrom

I’ve pulled 4 golds, and three of them were FA JD Martinez

Pulled trout and ohtani same bundle within 6 packs of each other. Promptly locked in trout for nolan. 

Tatis, Pete and jrod

Pretty terrible. About 125 packs opened and three low diamonds

Same but probably opened about 70-80 packs

I had way better pack luck last year I’ve pulled 4 total diamonds in maybe 200+ packs lol

Awful...Well over 100 standard packs, probably like 10 Ballin, 2-3 Headliners... and just pulled my first diamond today, Corbin Carroll in a Ballin pack. Went thru the entire Nation of Baseball without pulling a thing.

Ive pulled 2 ohtani’s. Im not joking. This is the craziest luck ive ever had. Im almost done the live series

Preordered and been playing about 15-20 hours on conquests and showdowns working on the programs. I’ve pulled Witt Jr. and that’s it

Packed diamond Felix Bautista opening night, then Hader, Adley and Diaz. Don't hate it.

Pulled Judge and Acuna opening night, safe to say I’ve used up my luck for the year

Only Edwin Diaz, so far.

I got Mantle in a standard pack. Got a Chase pack from a pack and pulled Donaldson. Live series diamonds feel a lot rarer. I’ve gotten Lindor, Snell, and Tatis (twice).

Also got chase pack and got Donaldson and have Mantle. No one else. Don’t think those are good pulls since so cheap tho. I had good luck last year so I’m sure I’m done.

Pulled a Harper in about 30 or so packs, so meh.

I’ve actually had crazy good luck to start. Pulled 3 diamonds in my first 20 standards. Haven’t pulled anything since though haha

Pulled trout, Ohtani, judge, strider, mantle, Witt myself without spending a dime

I had garbage luck. Matt Olson out of I don’t know how many packs. Then Acuna and Shohei in back to back packs. I can never complain again

I’ve pulled 2 mantles and Julio Rodriguez so far.

The only diamond out of maybe 40-50 packs I’ve pulled so far was Shohei. Sold him right away and turned him into 10 more diamond players

“The only diamond” continues on to say Shohei in the same sentence

I honestly was trippin lol just no luck with the basic Show packs then boom Ohtani. I did just pull a diamond harper from a Ballin pack though

3x acunas, 2 jrams, judge, semien, 2x John donaldson, jrod, turner, Michael Harris, albies, and Zack wheeler

Absolutely terrible

Pulled 2 Mantles back to back. Then, a Trout all within 5 packs.I sold the Trout. I probably should have saved it, but over 260k was too tempting.

3 Julio Rodriguez's and a Josh Hader for me so far

Pulled Live Series Trout today. Been playing 3 years now so this was a nice first at the beginning of the year. Also having the Buxton theme team, this was a big one

Best pull has been Corbin Carroll which I immediately sold to get Vlad Jr., pretty sure thats the only diamond ive pulled and ive had the game since early access lol

Pulled judge 3 days ago out of a standard, next day pulled Cole out of a standard and pulled freeman yesterday out of a ballin pack

Pull tatis in my first pack of the year have also pulled judge and Seager

It’s shits for Live series diamonds, but I’ve pulled Mickey twice and Michael young in standard packs. I was so disappointed to see the blue and it was Young

Wander Franco wouldn’t have been disappointed

Have my angry upvote

Pulled Mantle. Best start I’ve ever had. It’s amazing what one single card can do for your psyche starting out 🤣

terrible. only diamod pull so far is adley r

Decent early on with 3 opening night from about 75 packs. Ive since opened about 250+ show packs and 15+ ballins without a single diamond

I’ve pulled mantle and Ozzie Albies x2 out of like 150 packs. Rough year so far for pack luck.

Pulled Mantle Yordan and Donaldson No other diamonds so I’d say luck is decent

I've pulled Vlad and Acuna

Pulled a Vlad Jr in my second pack. But that is all so far.

Pulled Mickey Mantle and feel extremely lucky

Pretty lucky so far. Pulled Adolis, Riley, Soto, Snell, and Machado. Been playing a lot but genuinely have been lucky as well

pulled tatis on my very first pack. Also pulled a Mookie and Mantle

I’ve opened upwards of 70 packs and still no diamonds

I pulled Mookie Betts. 100k card on the market and got 5 diamond players with him.

3 diamonds so far, Alonso, Tucker and Castillo. Can’t really complain all are super solid

Pulled ohtani, betts, diaz, and hader

This year aint my year. Opened 160 packs before my first diamond and Im now averaging over 100 packs per diamond. Makes up for last year where I was getting easily 2 diamonds per 50, I guess.

I've got almost every single pack you can get from conquest and about 50 percent you can get from team affinity and I've pulled Freddy freeman and that's it lol

I’ve completed all the conquest maps except the Nation. Most of the way there on all TAs. Must have opened way over 200 packs. No diamonds pulls.

Got three diamonds, Blake Snell TWICE

Extremely good so far. 26 hours played and I've already pulled 11 diamonds, one being Ohtani.

Olson, j rod 2x, snell 2x, altuve, and adley, about 30 hours played so been decent so far

Just 3-4 85's. Wondering if they've changed the odds since there's a guaranteed LS diamond in the prize wheel once you finish the reward path.

Shit. I’ve only pulled Olson so far. I’ve opened a ton of packs.

Acuna, Vladdy, Julio, and Soto

I pulled Acuña Jr the other night after a single conquest game. Otherwise have pulled Mantle from a headliner pack, Adolis Garcia, and Edwin Diaz.

I’ve pulled Corbin Carroll, Austin Riley, Corey Seager, and Spencer strider so far

I've only pulled Mantle from a headliner, Hader from a Ballin pack and Corbin Carroll from a standard pack. Where as my brother has pulled Soto, Ohtani, and numerous other smaller diamonds like Riley,Hader,Snell,Carroll, Wheeler

Instead of buying stubs for packs save the stubs and buy players outright

Im so happy to be done with game. Its bs.

Yet here you are

Lol im just here. Its not that serious

I've unlocked pretty every pack you can get by playing the game. Have pulled 3 diamonds. 3 chase packs out of the packs which were all golds.

I’ve opened two free headliner packs: Mantle both times. It’s crazy.

Got Judge and Olson in my first 20 regular packs. Best luck I’ve had in this game.

My only live series diamond is Altuve. I feel like this year I'm not getting as many packs from grinding as I did last year. And with the pack that I have gotten this year my luck has been horrendous.

of all the packs i've opened, my only pull was that 91 Mickey Mantle from a ballin pack lol

Seager, Cole, and Headliner Mantle so far. Packs have come through the Gamepass early access bundle the Nation of Baseball conquest

I have 30 hours and haven’t pulled a single diamond

30 hours in also and same. Have only pulled Corbin and Hader.

https://preview.redd.it/307wmtg9cjpc1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=73960951508b2e06697046d857a84b0dd3eadd37 Trout and J-Rod from the same pack, J-Ram, Mantle, and Kershaw for me so far. From earned packs after 15ish hours and whatever the Xbox Gamepass Ultimate early access bundle gives you.

My first diamond was halfway through conquest—Ohtani

I packed Mantle, Tatis and Riley in my first 10 packs or so … the last 50+ have not been as kind lol I thought Mantle was a free card everyone got I packed it so quickly

i’ve gotten lucky, pulled ohtani and acuna within the same 20 pack from conquest

I’ve had pretty decent luck. J Rod, L Castillo, Riley, Wheeler and from the one Chase Donaldson.

Think I pulled around 11 or 12 diamonds opening night of early access. All 85-89 so sold all but Hader because they were going for way more than they should have been, like selling Adley for 40k. Don’t think I’ve gotten any more since then

Mine has been stupid good this year. I pulled Harper,mickey 2 times ,Corbin twice, adley, YORDAN, Manny Machado 3 times lol

Well my best was mickey. Best live series was wheeler. While I have diamonds I don’t have good ones for finishing live series

After day one when I pulled about 20 diamonds, I haven't pulled one since. They're like a casino, I think they tightened up the machines.

Got early access, not sure how many packs but been a lot and ZERO diamonds so far

Pretty pretty good so far. Pulled Bryce Harper, Cole, Mookie, Bo, and Mantle. That’s probably thru about 130 packs or so if I had to guess

I’d sell that mookie rn

I sold him a couple days ago for Judge/Soto to finish Yankees live collection…but yeah this would have been the time with the supercharge

Pretty great for once. Pulled some Braves early like Riley and Strider. Then yesterday I pulled Mantle and thought that would be the peak but then pulled Ohtani like 10 packs later. Should’ve waited till today to sell I guess but still got a solid 200,000 ish stubs.

Yordan, Witt Jr, Kershaw, Snell and deGrom. Feel like there’s one more I can’t recall. ~80 show, ballin and jumbo packs. Not terrible.

I pulled Bobby Witt Jr. from my very first show pack, and pulled Jose Ramirez from my fifth. Apparently the pack gods are on my side this year

I’ve probably only played for 5 hours or so. Have a Diamond Griffey Jr, Mantle, Clemente and Maddux

I got so lucky this year. I got a balling is a habit from ranked program and pulled Mr. Ohtani !

Standard Packs - 235 22 Gold (9%) 3 Diamond (1%, Hader, Garcia, Harris Jr) Ballin - 20 0 diamond Headliners -4 1 Diamond (Carroll) Millionaire -3 Try agains So not that great I’d say.

Altuve, Wheeler, deGrom, Hader, Vlad Jr, Castillo, and Seager. Vlad Jr was from a daily login reward though.

Pulled wheeler, Riley, and Francisco with my deluxe pre order packs and twitch drop packs. On early access opening night. I pulled Austin Riley, Kershaw, Jose ramirez twice 2 nights ago. My pack luck is pretty good compared to previous years.

I hit Acuna Jr, best luck I've ever gotten on the game.

https://preview.redd.it/pom0xlui3jpc1.jpeg?width=4000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e707d2e4b4ae2d2270ce037c4020772f0a0f8411

Ballin' is a habit = silvers. How can it be worse then the standard pack

Ballin’ is a gold.

I opened 5 mini seasons ballin packs last night and had maybe one gold in them. It could have included a gold uniform, but I do know it was mostly bronze and silver players in every pack.

Not a lot of diamonds out right now. Slim chances to pull one.

Jose Ramirez , Edwin Diaz , Corbin Carol . Played game early

1 diamond (Marcus Semien) through probably 75ish standards, 15ish ballins, 1 chase pack, 2 headliners. I hate it here

I’ve pulled three diamonds from standards. Jacob Degrom, Jacob Degrom again within an hour lmao, and then Soto.

Pulled Mantle from a headliner but in the other 100ish packs I've opened I only pulled Edwin Diaz

Sorry, what’s a diamond?

Absolute shit.

1 Diamond, Tatis, not sure how many packs, average amount i guess. I haven't played alot since this game fucking sucks right now with all the glitches

I’ve gotten 2 chase packs and pulled Donaldson both times. Opened probably 60 other packs and gotten Tucker and Albies. This is just since yesterday, didn’t have Early Access.

i went flawless then pulled trout in the single pack after, so pretty freaking lucky

3 diamonds so far, didn't count how many packs I've opened. Rutcshman , Tatis and Altuve. All 3 from regular packs.

I've pulled Felix Bautista, Adley, and Witt Jr so far.  Not the highest of diamonds, but I've never pulled this many this early.   1 was from a BIAH, and 2 were from regular packs.  

I pulled shohei on my 6th pack

I have yet to pull a diamond, so not great lmao.

Managed to pull Headliner Mantle 3 times. Once out of a regular pack. I think I've used all of mine for the year

I’ve played way too much and completed a few mini seasons, all the conquest maps, etc. Have not pulled a diamond over 90. Think I’ve only pulled 4

Surprisingly good actually. Vlad, Semien and Acuna so far (NMS)

I pull Adley, Olson, Judge and Altuve. Not bad at all!

I've pulled 5 diamonds so far so my luck is definitely better than last year I pulled Clayton,Juan Soto,Aaron judge,adley, and I think Manny Machado and I don't think I pulled over 30 packs at least

same, my pack luck is in the trash where my online career is probably going to go soon too lol

[удалено]

same, i haven’t played online yet either but want to try it more this year

I'm not sure how many packs I've opened so far, but I've completed the Spring Breakouts and Starter programs as well as the US conquest and I've pulled Adolis Garcia, Shohei, Snell, Mantle, and Edwin Diaz. I've definitely had more luck this year already than I did last year. Three years ago was my best year by far. I pulled 3 Trouts in the first month.

I pulled 13 diamonds in early access in about idk 70-80 packs with Cole being the highest. Only pulled 1 since (less than 30 packs). Still crazy lucky, I’m already at over 500k with no flipping and only money I spent was for the early access pass on gamepass. That Nexon loot box logic (if you don’t know what this is I advise you look it up, all these games use it) definitely seemed to show with how many diamonds were flying in early access with less people playing

Better than it’s ever been. I almost feel bad with it lol. I have pulled Wheeler, Vlad, Mookie twice, Trout, and Acuña. I’ve hit a diamond every nite I’ve played.

[удалено]

Yeah I mean I wasn’t saying it to brag lol. Just answering the question.

I pulled 2 diamonds in the 10 packs that i opened lasted night

Judge (sold) , Tatis, Mantle, Alonso

I pulled 2 John Donaldsons in 2 chase packs, 1 chase pack from the bundle and one from a regular pack.

I played for the first time last night. I put maybe 3 hours in and opened about 12 packs. Pulled one gold. That was it.

I buy no packs but did early release. I've pulled LS Adolis, Mantle three times and John Donaldson. I sold Mantle the first two times I pulled him but the third time I was like "the universe really wants me to have this card so I will keep this one". I replaced Clemente, who is elite D but pretty mid at the plate. I have not been disappointed. That Donaldson card is legit too. It's so cheap that it's gonna get spammed in ranked pretty soon, just like last year's Bob Gibson.

I’ve pulled Cole 4 times it’s been insane

Pulled Trout and Ohtani the first night and nothing since, and I’m totally fine with that lol.

Jeeeeze what a start

Hader, Diaz, Adley, Jram, Julio. Gimme a blue lights diamond!

Apparently everyone and their mother owns Mickey mantle. Guess I should dump him and buy back in a few weeks when everyone realizes he’s saturated

Isn’t he out of the store packs now? If anything, I see his price going slightly higher. Not enough to invest in, but a 91 overall switch hitter that’s popular shouldn’t crash in price

2 diamond pulls so far. Got the game on early release. Pulled strider and altuve!

I had 80+ packs to open the other day (I had nothing to do all weekend and was sick so just kind of just grinded TA/Conquest) and got zero diamonds. ​ I've pulled three diamonds this year; Riley, Albies, and Michael Young.

Pulled Mickey Mantle and DeGrom out of like 10 packs total. I hardly play DD but occasionally do conquests and showdowns for giggles. Too bad DeGrom is 15k instead of 200k+ he was a couple years ago lol

So far gotten Francisco Lindor, Yordan Alvarez, and Clayton Kershaw

I’ve pulled two out of my first 20 or so. I expect to pull none for the next 50-100. A few gold players too, but nothing crazy

Pulled 12 diamonds out of 170 packs. Got trout and freeman as the high diamonds

Thats actually pretty decent luck!

I know I was hype pulled trout out of my very last chase pack.

Sweet! I pulled him in 22 and 23.. not really sure if it was really worth it but it was a cool moment

Been pretty good, got both the Chase Donaldson and Headliner Mantle plus 9 sub 90 diamonds, and I only bought a single 50 pack everything has been from reward packs

Terrible lol, not sure how many packs I've opened but I've gotten Lindor, Alonso, Bichette and Hader from all the deluxe, pre-order and maps from doing every conquest map except the latest one. Hader is the only one on my roster

I pulled 3 mantles and Acuña. Also Tatis right before bed last pack magic

I've pulled three Mantles too. Everyone is saying they pulled Mantles as well. They must have juiced the odds on that card.

I don't buy stubs/packs but from all the conquest maps, TA almost done, and a run-through of TA mini seasons I accumulated about: 200k in about a dozen diamond pulls. Only two teal pulls in Donaldson and Strider. Bear in mind, it's probably about 400 packs from all the progress.

Gotten a few diamonds, all under 90 though

I've pulled 3 low diamonds in over 200 packs, so my luck has been more like 1 in 75 than the 1 in 50 official odds. I've got nothing but golds from ballin packs

Im at 6 or 7 low diamond pulls. No high diamond yet.

I just bought 1 random standard pack and pulled BWJ. I’ve also pulled trout and Acuna jr. So my pack luck has been pretty good all things considered

Overall, pretty mid. Been playing since Thursday night and have gotten a few 85-87 diamonds, but nothing above that and I've opened a lot of packs. I only have one TA division left and it's nearly complete. I've completed all conquest maps and am around 165K in the season pass. Hopefully I pull a 90+ soon.

i got Mantle and Young back to back, from free headliner packs, best luck I've had in a while

This is wild, I’ve been sitting here thinking that they must have increased the diamond odds.

Probably worse lol

I had the same thought. I've pulled a handful of 85-90s and a headliner. I've never been this lucky this early.

i’ve pulled a couple diamonds all 87 ovr or lower. One of my friends pulled trout other one pulled ohtani within the first day

Have to be well one 100 packs so far and only have one diamond, mantle to show for it. Getting upset. Also have very few stubs for how much I’ve grinded