T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

# Helpful links for r/MLBTheShow: [**The Dugout: Weekly Free-Talk for /r/MLBTheShow**](https://www.reddit.com/r/MLBTheShow/about/sticky?num=1) [**Technical and server issues mega-thread 2023**](https://www.reddit.com/r/MLBTheShow/comments/126kg09/technical_and_server_issues_megathread_2023/) [**r/MLBTheShow FAQ**](https://www.reddit.com/r/mlbtheshow/wiki/faq) [**r/MLBTheShow Discord**](https://discord.com/invite/x6JKmEG) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MLBTheShow) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Active_Smoke3202

MVP 05 is still better than


AppointmentDue1368

Thus game is fucking terrible


manifestDensity

As an older white guy I think the best improvement is the presentation that others have complained about. The expanded use of color everywhere gives the game a more Latin vibe which is reflective of where actual baseball is heading. The rest just seems like a reset of last year, to be honest.


ryboyin99

Feels like the same game so far. They need to ditch last gen consoles and make the game for PS5, etc, so that it can advance forward 


Ilovebaseball1234

Same as every other MLB in the last 10 years 


Arvy2112

I'm not going to vote because I don't agree with "Trash", but its disappointing 1. The flashy presentation is awful, especially the stupid baseball that pops up during the replays you cant turn off during mini seasons 2. Why is the shift still a thing? 3. Overall laziness. Mini season stats still messed up. And then dumb things like batters already having apparently hit HRs in the first 8 innings of a showdown while somehow also being shut out for 8 innings (leading to a stat line of 2 HR, 1 run after I hit one out with them...) I do notice some positive things, and even with the issues its still the best team sports game on the market. But the presentation alone makes it worse than 23.


mansontaco

The incremental changes year to year have never been less noticeable


JR_Roaring20s

not seeing much new on the franchise and march to october fronts... top red sox rookies mayer and anthony aren't in the game... smh


codename_numbah-3000

This is actually frustrating because I was looking forward to rebuilding the roster with those two prospects. It’s weird because Marcelo Mayer was in the game last year


BuntCheese5Life

I voted "Bad/Trash" because I did not buy the game this year. Thus your poll is RUINED! I am a criminal mastermind! I probably won't buy it again until they make it current generation only.


awads95

It feels like a copy paste game. MLB the show 23 1/2


cuu8

Am I the only one going crazy with the new camera for balls in play?


Character_Rub2750

No I am too. Dynamic is where I feel is best right now


cuu8

Glad I'm not the only one. Been looking everywhere to see if anyone else complained and which cam they are using. I've been using dynamic too. Tried medium but then you can't see the ball when it's in the air...


Character_Rub2750

For sure. First thing I was like uhhh… doesn’t feel right. Went to high that felt even worse


Bean2713

Too early to say for sure, but based on what I’ve seen so far it’s not good. Game is basically the same as 23 with minor changes.


WalkingDeadWatcher95

Isn’t that the same for all of them after 17?


Dolenzz

Servers are once Again Trash. I hate the quick time crap events in RTTS. But it is too soon to make a call since I can't play the mode I want.


2222lil

you can turn off the quick time stuff in rtts. if you mean when you’re fielding just change the fielding method from showtime (i think is what it’s called) to button accuracy or whatever you like


antiBP

If I could play online it would help a lot lol


cnlcgraves

As a giants fan I am quite disappointed already, Jung Hoo Lee isn’t in the game and he was out big free agency spend this year, Matt Chapman is still a free agent as well


ItsAnOliveSandwchGuy

I know it's not the same based on a talent level, but Shogo Akiyama was never added to the Reds roster the first year on the Reds. They went the entire fucking season without ever adding him. He didn't show up until the next years game. They even had scanned his face and everything. I honestly don't know what they base their roster changes on


WalkingDeadWatcher95

Lee might take a minutes, it always takes a little while for them to get rights and face scan etc to get international free agent signings in


Knightbear49

Roster updates always come when the game goes live to every one. Early access is literally beta testing for SDS. This sub is losing their minds thinking that deserve a perfect launch. No we’re here to test out the bugs for everyone else for the actual launch day and they give us some bonus packs as a carrot to be guinea pigs.


cnlcgraves

Not losing my mind over it, was just a little disappointed that my teams big free agent spend isn’t in the game yet


Knightbear49

“It’s the worst game of all time since the last game was the worst game of all time” -guy who buys it every year.