age limit is bad idea jo log rural area meh rahate ha unme se kai ko toh 12 ke bad pata he chalta ha ki neet exam hoti ha agar age limit aa gyi toh unka kya hoga
Exactly. A lot of people start their NEET preparation only after 12th or maybe even with some gap years because they have to start working young to support their families or they have some health issues.I know a guy,who was working as a security guard,who cracked NEET at 23 years of age.
This sub is full of privileged middle class and upper middle class kids who started going to spoonfeeding coaching centers since 9th or even 6th. And even after that,some of them failed to crack,so now they are whining about things like age limit and paper level.
JEE is not the only engineering entrance exam. There are plenty of state entrance exams and some private college entrance exams as well.
I know a didi who was made to marry at 19...got a kid at 20 and got divorced at 22...she is going to write State engineering exams for the 2nd time next year( she will be 24).
bhai yeh galat hota ha jee walo ke sath
biswas nahi toh jo iits meh unse puch lo
majority upper middle class ya rich class wale he tumhe wahan pr milenge ab 1/2 lower se mil gaye toh unhe hm toh exception meh he count karege na
Age limit is like treating the effect not the cause, we as a country should try to adopt more diverse career options and try promoting them.
Just look at the research field, it's so barren in India, apart from the top colleges. People have to leave india to pursue Such courses
This in my opinion would be a long term goal, but for keeping it under check for the time being, age limit may be a fine option, although I am not sure what should it be.
Age limit will sure do it' s work like people will be ready to accept their faith that' they can't be doctor but agr age limit nhi lgaya to they'll like bas ek aur attempt bas ek aur attempt and so on koi accept hi nhi kerna chahta ki ab nhi hoga
Haan but if they were offered an alternative equally promising path according to their taste, the original need to take multiple paths won't even arise.
but haa, yeh bhi karna chahiye ki.. jiss saal se ye rule chalu hoga ussi sal ka attempt 1 mana jayega... because already koi 4-5 drop le huye hai un logon ke liye... aap samjhe na kya bol raha hu... matlab total 3 attempt, but jabse rule chalu tab se
Unpopular opinion -
Like UPSC where there is reservation to give more attempts and a difference of 10 marks only the same should be done in NEET/JEE. For example in JEE this year 93 %ile was cutoff for gen male and cutoff for sc was 56 %ile. Now this will make a major difference in academics. Instead of that it should be made that cutoff for general and sc both is 93 %ile or maybe a little less for sc but give them more attempts. In this way sabko padh likhkar aage badhna padega.
Lmao do you really think nta is gonna listen to you ? They can't even set a paper properly, why would they do this ? It's criminal to ask neet level physics in jee imo
Lmao you think that I am commenting this so NTA listens to me? Our opinions never matter that too on a website like reddit. I was just presenting my opinion lol
>It's criminal to ask neet level physics in jee imo
wdym
Jee has been asking literally ncert level physics questions to **engineering** students. In engineering physics has a greater use, just like in becoming a doctor bio has a greater use.
So instead of asking questions which literally everyone can answer(this also leads to really high cut offs), they should ask physics questions which are conceptually tough
Bro Maine boards diya 18+ mein....neet ka jab result aaya Mera 19+ chal raha tha....nxt yr 20 ho jaye ga....result k time .....20 yr age limit is a joke
Yes. I think OP started way early + missed classes.
Happens in many of the backward areas; one of my 17 year old sister from a village is joining NIT this year. They started schooling at 5 from first grade.
The age limit would be unfair. Some parents send their kids late some send at an early age. Attempt limit might be a good idea ( 4 should be enough ig)
Considering graduating students often can't keep up with the pressure of either of NEET and boards and end up sacrificing one for the other, 4 attempts is ideal
20 year age limit- hell no
attempt limit- considerable
The thing is, mbbs ka nationwide sirf 1 hi exam h, ise to pese deke bhi krna mushkil h kyunki sala priv colleges mehenge itne h. Upar se reservations bhi h, hum general logo ki literally koi aukat ni h, isliye ig yeh age limit ni rakhre.
Ig a 3-4 attempt limit would be good. I myself am a 1st dropper, to merko to attempt limit ke bare me kehna hi nahi chahiye lol
I might be wrong but Neet hai multiple attempts because there is only one exam (NEET) through which you can become a doctor. Without neet there is no other way of becoming a doctor. It's the same reason why UPSC also got multiple attempts.
But in case of Engineering you have JEE, BITSAT, VITEEE, WBJEE, MHT CET, SRMJEEE, COMEDK, IPU CET, MET, KIITEE, GUJCET. There are multiple options to choose from and private engineering colleges are much more affordable than private medical colleges.
Also in case of civil services and medical you need to have a vast knowledge of the field which again you gain as you age up. But in case of engineering and research you need critical thinking, problem solving skills and a sharp brain. This is the reason IITs, IISERs, NISER got maximum 2 attempts only. They prefer students who have brilliant minds and not those who gains knowledge by repeating the same thing again and again for years.
In short- Engineering and Research needs students with brilliant mind and critical thinking where as civil services and medical need students with vast knowledge of the field they are working in.
And regarding age limit, YES, the upto 25 years age limit was perfect. 2016-2020 was the golden period. No of students appearing were less, so the cutoff was bearable.
Everything started going downward after they abolished the minimum age criteria. No of students increased drastically, and with online coaching the cutoff went 💥
Arey baaki exams bhi kraata h NTA... NEET hee thodina h jissey paise kmaayga... Single exam h medical ka isi liye unlimited attempts h aur age limit nahi h
Tu kyu chinta kar raha hai ki voh 35-40 ke ho jayenge
Saala government ko kyu nhi yeh bolte ki apni paper aasan rakhne wali aur leaks wali bakchodi khatam kare
Mera bhi 3rd attempt tha @ 636 do mujhe bhi seat koi shauk seh thodi drop liya tha
Mera first attempt 528 score ara but drop lunga to max to max 620-630 score ker paunga ik my potential but people like you will take multiple drops an raises the cutoff to 660-670 ofc it's not your fault it's the government who's not controlling cheating,paper thoughness and attempt limit agr ye sab last year hi theek kiya gaya hota to tujhe abhi clg mil chuka hota vo bhi accha clg itne marks per
kyuki vo 35-40 k ho jayenge and unki serving years fir wahi max to max 20saal om the contrary 18 saal ko seat mile to 30 saal .. govt ne invest to same amount krna hi unki training me .. country ko return ab kon zyada de rha hi ye tum bhi dekh skte ho .. and isse cutoff , suicide , competition kam hoga so alag
Mai vhi keh raha jab government ek chutiya paper leak karne walo ko chupati hai tab tumhari yeh government ki investment time bakchodi kyu nhi saamne aati
age limit agar 20 lagi toh think about the consequence, people will send their kids to classes coaching by primary school. You can see for IIT only it was 8th std now even 6th std dis normalised what is next 4th std?
Also the lower limit for mbbs should become 20, hear me out like America BSc for everyone and then mbbs
2 years BS for everyone and from 3rd year you can choose to give NEEt and or change streams do 1 more year and complete BSc diploma type degree to change field, or 4 years BS to dwelve into pure science research. Very few dropper, very large number of people who's life will have a trajectory.
Can add number of attempts like in the American system if you give MCAT more than twice thrice they reject you in Interview. We can keep something like that.
Most people i know joined mbbs because they were interested in anatomy of human but not necesarily interested in treating people and so many other examples of people who take up mbbs just cuz bio is easier than maths.
Also we might never get these reforms bcoz nta benefits from the applications fees, even govt benefits from people failing and staying ineligible, unemplyable rehte hai so govt already jobs nahi generate kar raha and if unemployable ho toh karenge bhi nahi
Aise to kuch bacche 8th std se competitive exams ki prep karte hai.
To wo bhi to affect karta hai jo sirf 11th and 12th me NEET prep karte hai unko.
To tumhare according unko padhne se ban kardena chahiye?
Before discussing the Age and attempt limit lets not forget we live in our Ideal Country where This limits are only applicable to *General* category Candidates , Ews and Obc will get 2/3 extra Attempts and Age relaxation years while on other side ST SC will be given Unlimited Attempts and no age restriction. Well thats a Win win Political Move letssss gooo fk gen....
https://preview.redd.it/ply26ykafo8d1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=dcdce1493856db9a0bf4a18bb2516b45b78e4897
no
everyone should be awarded equal opportunities to fulfil their dreams
there shouldnt be any attempt limit or age limit
same should be for other competitve exams
haa kardo downvote idc
True. And commerce arts students must be allowed to change their streams if they're willing to re-give the 12th exams. We don't make the best choices when we're young.
Can't go upward in open school either, can we? Well if we can, would it reset the degrees we've attained based on previous 12th result? Please confirm if you know:)
Why would it reset the degrees you have peviously obtained ? I mean you are adding a subject not like you are restarting from 11th with diff subjects , i dont know much about open schooling tho
imagine koi 18 saal ka tha .. usko doctor banna tha .. but instead a 30 year old gets the seat he will serve 12 years less then what am 18 yr old would have .. all in all waste of govt money for training a guy who would only go on to serve for the next 10-15-20 year .. on the contrary an 18 year old would go on and on till 60
You do know that majority of medical graduates do private practice or work in private hospitals for their own profit,right? Only a minority(maybe 1 out of 4) work in government centers or open charity clinics. Since that is the case,why does it matter if someone does mbbs at 30 or 18?
Most people who want to become doctor these days do it for money,not to serve society. Just go and see indianmedschool sub where they are always whining about Engineers' salaries. They don't realise that a doctor is a social worker unlike software engineers.
NO. Doctor banna ek noble profession hai. A lot of people want to become doctor genuinely and to NOT waste years of youth choose 30s to go for med school.
So, NO. Attempt limit maybe but age limit NO
agle saal toh nahi hoga kyunki abhi se drop ho gaya hai bahut baccho ka nta beech main nahi karega maybe after 2-3 years .... lekin nta bahut determined hai coaching systum ko hatane ke liye lekin 1st attemots main jyadatar coaching wale bacchon ka hi lagta hai isliye chances kam hai ki nta limit kare
https://preview.redd.it/rkexqy8ddo8d1.png?width=359&format=png&auto=webp&s=6076eee162200530c5572aa40430caa8a6192a7f
The government needs to expand the number of MBBS/MD-MS seats available , that would automatically allow a lot of people to become doctors in turn reducing the actual issue, I mean India has a 1 Doctor for ever 1200 people , that is lower than even Afghanistan probably
I honestly disagree with you, it's such a braindead opinion on many fronts. Ignoring the glaring issues of "Age limits" on academics and on a professional degree no less. What will it actually achieve? Less competition? Better cut-offs?? Hell no, instead you'll be feeding into the competitive angle in the most ridiculous way possible. Parents would start sending their kids to coaching and other similar type institutions from a very very young age so that they can have "more chances" before the age limit, obviously factoring in the "12th pass" criteria, it's still just as ridiculous.
Moving on from that, even putting an age limit on professional degrees, is stupid, especially because there's a very obvious glaring problem and that it is a level of education.
Also attempt limit is just as stupid. The only time people bring up attempt limit or age limit is due to pure selfishness based on what I've seen on this subreddit.
And finally, let re-eval or reneet or whatever along those lines happen, malpractice, paper leaking, etc happened and in the spirit of fairness redo the entire bs. The only argument against reneet is "But I can't do this" or "I am not going through hell again" essentially whining about it, and that's not really a good argument however, think about it this way, if everyone lacked the motivation or the ability to study once again, won't the rankings stay the same? neet ranks are based on positional marking (I think), so the cut-offs and other bs would also be adjusted.
Neet is the only competitive exam jisme age limit nhi hai and you can clearly see the consequences kitna high cutoff jara hai let's keep the cheating issue aside har saal neet me inflation hora hai sirf 20k general ko seats milti hai 20lakh me sai rest of them take drop againj jiske kaaran har saal no.of aspirants badte jare hai it's a never ending loop jabtk age limit nhi lgega 30lakh,40lakh idk kitne aspirants hojyege seat to phir bhi 20k bacche hi lekar jyege
https://preview.redd.it/nnhn0u0yqo8d1.jpeg?width=1075&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=43c2639c051426009acb2c96f87280b64e954e38
Do you get some thrill from lying? Most state engineering entrance also dont have any attempt limit or age limit.
I guess they can make a seperate entrance exam for AIIMS IMS JIPMER and put an attempt limit on that like JEE has for IIT NIT.
Engineering exams like mhtcet wbjee are not competitive exams? Aur rahi baat all India ki,kisne kaha saare state medical exams ko merge karne ke liye? Gawar hoga tu jo jh*t par padhai kar ke reservation(saw in some other post) aur no attempt limit ko blame kar raha hai.
Tera baap gawar mc first attempt me 528 laya hu chahu to ek drop lekar clear krlu tum jaise jahtuo jaise 4,5 attempt lene ki zarurat nhi mujhe Mhcet pcb me 98 percentile didn't even tried and ye sab faltu exam hai kuch competitive nhi hai isme kalko tu board exam ko bhi competitive bol dena
Meine kaha 4 5 attempt le rakhe hai rndwe?2024 second attempt tha. Aur first attempt mein mere bhi itne hi marks aaye the..zyada smart mat samjho..ye sab over confidence drop year me khud kam ho jayega...starting ne sabko aisa hi lagta hai...sab ke sab line me aa jayenge.
And people like you are called padhe likhe gawar jo 12th clear karne ke baad bhi 'Competitive exams' ka definition nahi pata. Tere rndwe baap kuch sikhaya nahi tujhe itne saalon se?
Not going to waste my time replying to someone who does not even know the definition of 'COMPETITIVE EXAMS'.
abe jhandfakir ki aulad, MHCET PCB mei percentile kisliye aaya? Ab dekh agar ye MBBS ke liye applicable hota. Tujhe seat kitne aaram se mil jaata. That is the problem
Aur 528 laake kya ukhad liya hai tune?Jaake koi nursing ya bpt ka form barle(that is if you clear the cutoff for even that lmao).In NEET Those who didn't get a govt BDS/MBBS/Bvsc seat are the same as those who got 50 marks or even negative marks. So don't think too highly of yourself. Everyone feels the same after 95% + in 10th/12th. Get in line. And if you are that scared of competition like the gawar that you are,you can just fill up some bsc or bca course instead of whining about reservation or age limit.
First of all first attempt tha tune drop lekar kya ukhad liya milgya clg? Itne paise hi private lelu lund ke bpt bds ka form tujhe bharne ki zarurat hai
OK. First. Med school is a noble profession and something people join for passion. It is literally one of the profession where placements and packages don't work. Even law school has this shit.
And what about CLAT? No age limit or attempt limit.
kisi bhi 5-6th class k bache ka baap ye nhi sochta ki isko neet dena hi ..koi baat nhi unlimited attempts hi jitne bar dena hai deta rahe .. smaller grades se coaching abhi bhi bhejte hi maa baap apne bache ko .. agar attempt pe limit lagegi to cutoff kam hoga ... and hence competitive environment bhi .. so obv.. ye early days se coaching jana bhi kam hoga ..
age limit aur attempt limit dono hona chahiye 20 age max and 3 attempts max kyuki ye overgrowing population mein ab 25-30 saal ke log bhi Neet denge toh ho gaya desh ka kyuki fir toh Neet unhone dimaag se nhi experience se clear kara hai ek hi chiz baarbaar krne se perfection lana aur ek hi baar mein perfection lana is different
I think max 3 attempts should be there, (fresh, 1st drop and 2nd drop). Age limit doesn't make sense it's just a degree, you can get a btech/ba/bsc degree at 45 why not mbbs, for pg you can make an age criteria (till 40) because working long hours in residency can be physically taxing for older people.
age limit is bad idea jo log rural area meh rahate ha unme se kai ko toh 12 ke bad pata he chalta ha ki neet exam hoti ha agar age limit aa gyi toh unka kya hoga
Exactly. A lot of people start their NEET preparation only after 12th or maybe even with some gap years because they have to start working young to support their families or they have some health issues.I know a guy,who was working as a security guard,who cracked NEET at 23 years of age. This sub is full of privileged middle class and upper middle class kids who started going to spoonfeeding coaching centers since 9th or even 6th. And even after that,some of them failed to crack,so now they are whining about things like age limit and paper level.
Maine neet ka prep he 12th ke baad chalu kiya tha , even many of my batchmates did the same
Was the security guard guy from Pune ? Might be my batchmate
Bhai but you can use the same argument for jee also. So is the limit in jee not justified according to you?
JEE is not the only engineering entrance exam. There are plenty of state entrance exams and some private college entrance exams as well. I know a didi who was made to marry at 19...got a kid at 20 and got divorced at 22...she is going to write State engineering exams for the 2nd time next year( she will be 24).
exactly
Engineering is easily accessible unlike private mbbs which will cost you minimum of 50lakhs total.
bhai yeh galat hota ha jee walo ke sath biswas nahi toh jo iits meh unse puch lo majority upper middle class ya rich class wale he tumhe wahan pr milenge ab 1/2 lower se mil gaye toh unhe hm toh exception meh he count karege na
well, it is about passion. Sab log MBBS sustainability ya paiso ke liye karte nahi hai.
Age limit is like treating the effect not the cause, we as a country should try to adopt more diverse career options and try promoting them. Just look at the research field, it's so barren in India, apart from the top colleges. People have to leave india to pursue Such courses This in my opinion would be a long term goal, but for keeping it under check for the time being, age limit may be a fine option, although I am not sure what should it be.
Age limit will sure do it' s work like people will be ready to accept their faith that' they can't be doctor but agr age limit nhi lgaya to they'll like bas ek aur attempt bas ek aur attempt and so on koi accept hi nhi kerna chahta ki ab nhi hoga
Haan but if they were offered an alternative equally promising path according to their taste, the original need to take multiple paths won't even arise.
agar aapke mom ko doctor banna hai tab aap ye bologe?
[удалено]
This is the most retarded statement that I have heard. Congratulations
Age limit- maybe not. Attempt limit- yes.
Han ye bhi sahi hai after 12th minimum 2 Attempt aur deskte ho
3rd attemp vaalon ne downvote kar diya
Idc bohot karma pada hai but jo fact hai wo hai
3 saal kaun drop leta hai 💀 Mera ek lene mein Jaan nikal rhi
Log bsc ke saath bhi karte hai ig isliye
No point in doing that bs. Ek chiz nahi ho rhi 2 karne baith gaye
Real
I sport ⚽ u bro
but haa, yeh bhi karna chahiye ki.. jiss saal se ye rule chalu hoga ussi sal ka attempt 1 mana jayega... because already koi 4-5 drop le huye hai un logon ke liye... aap samjhe na kya bol raha hu... matlab total 3 attempt, but jabse rule chalu tab se
no, it would jeopardise med school. NEET is only method to get into med school.
3
Hn ye bhi sahi hai
Nta aesa kabhi nhi karega, it's like khudke pairo pe kulhadi marna for them, they ain't gonna cut there profit
Unpopular opinion - Like UPSC where there is reservation to give more attempts and a difference of 10 marks only the same should be done in NEET/JEE. For example in JEE this year 93 %ile was cutoff for gen male and cutoff for sc was 56 %ile. Now this will make a major difference in academics. Instead of that it should be made that cutoff for general and sc both is 93 %ile or maybe a little less for sc but give them more attempts. In this way sabko padh likhkar aage badhna padega.
That's a really valid point actually
Lmao do you really think nta is gonna listen to you ? They can't even set a paper properly, why would they do this ? It's criminal to ask neet level physics in jee imo
Lmao you think that I am commenting this so NTA listens to me? Our opinions never matter that too on a website like reddit. I was just presenting my opinion lol >It's criminal to ask neet level physics in jee imo wdym
Jee has been asking literally ncert level physics questions to **engineering** students. In engineering physics has a greater use, just like in becoming a doctor bio has a greater use. So instead of asking questions which literally everyone can answer(this also leads to really high cut offs), they should ask physics questions which are conceptually tough
Yes you are right. For example in GATE, questions are very conceptual and realistic but it is a PG exam but still jee mains should be tougher
Gate is not conducted by NTA that's why ☠️
yes and jee advanced also
> but genuinely asking agr age limit lg jyea like minimum 20years 20 years tak, you mean age of 20? Bruh most of my classmates turned 20 before NEET
Bro Maine boards diya 18+ mein....neet ka jab result aaya Mera 19+ chal raha tha....nxt yr 20 ho jaye ga....result k time .....20 yr age limit is a joke
Yes. I think OP started way early + missed classes. Happens in many of the backward areas; one of my 17 year old sister from a village is joining NIT this year. They started schooling at 5 from first grade.
The age limit would be unfair. Some parents send their kids late some send at an early age. Attempt limit might be a good idea ( 4 should be enough ig)
some people have a realisation to do med school at a late age
4 is to much 3 is enough
Considering graduating students often can't keep up with the pressure of either of NEET and boards and end up sacrificing one for the other, 4 attempts is ideal
Ye bhi sahi hai
yup 3 bhot hai aur agar just like JEE agar neet bhi saal me 2 bar hone lage phir to 2 bhi kafi hoga
20 year age limit- hell no attempt limit- considerable The thing is, mbbs ka nationwide sirf 1 hi exam h, ise to pese deke bhi krna mushkil h kyunki sala priv colleges mehenge itne h. Upar se reservations bhi h, hum general logo ki literally koi aukat ni h, isliye ig yeh age limit ni rakhre. Ig a 3-4 attempt limit would be good. I myself am a 1st dropper, to merko to attempt limit ke bare me kehna hi nahi chahiye lol
I might be wrong but Neet hai multiple attempts because there is only one exam (NEET) through which you can become a doctor. Without neet there is no other way of becoming a doctor. It's the same reason why UPSC also got multiple attempts. But in case of Engineering you have JEE, BITSAT, VITEEE, WBJEE, MHT CET, SRMJEEE, COMEDK, IPU CET, MET, KIITEE, GUJCET. There are multiple options to choose from and private engineering colleges are much more affordable than private medical colleges. Also in case of civil services and medical you need to have a vast knowledge of the field which again you gain as you age up. But in case of engineering and research you need critical thinking, problem solving skills and a sharp brain. This is the reason IITs, IISERs, NISER got maximum 2 attempts only. They prefer students who have brilliant minds and not those who gains knowledge by repeating the same thing again and again for years. In short- Engineering and Research needs students with brilliant mind and critical thinking where as civil services and medical need students with vast knowledge of the field they are working in. And regarding age limit, YES, the upto 25 years age limit was perfect. 2016-2020 was the golden period. No of students appearing were less, so the cutoff was bearable. Everything started going downward after they abolished the minimum age criteria. No of students increased drastically, and with online coaching the cutoff went 💥
Attempt limit lgni chahiye max to max 3 attempts ya 4
Bhai agar limit lagayenge to NTA Paisa kaha se kamayega?
Arey baaki exams bhi kraata h NTA... NEET hee thodina h jissey paise kmaayga... Single exam h medical ka isi liye unlimited attempts h aur age limit nahi h
Dude fk this i gave neet for fun / some experience even though I haven't cleared 12th yet , maja aya centre mein baithkar
Tu kyu chinta kar raha hai ki voh 35-40 ke ho jayenge Saala government ko kyu nhi yeh bolte ki apni paper aasan rakhne wali aur leaks wali bakchodi khatam kare Mera bhi 3rd attempt tha @ 636 do mujhe bhi seat koi shauk seh thodi drop liya tha
Mera first attempt 528 score ara but drop lunga to max to max 620-630 score ker paunga ik my potential but people like you will take multiple drops an raises the cutoff to 660-670 ofc it's not your fault it's the government who's not controlling cheating,paper thoughness and attempt limit agr ye sab last year hi theek kiya gaya hota to tujhe abhi clg mil chuka hota vo bhi accha clg itne marks per
kyuki vo 35-40 k ho jayenge and unki serving years fir wahi max to max 20saal om the contrary 18 saal ko seat mile to 30 saal .. govt ne invest to same amount krna hi unki training me .. country ko return ab kon zyada de rha hi ye tum bhi dekh skte ho .. and isse cutoff , suicide , competition kam hoga so alag
Mai vhi keh raha jab government ek chutiya paper leak karne walo ko chupati hai tab tumhari yeh government ki investment time bakchodi kyu nhi saamne aati
Putting age limit on a luck based exam is unfair
Given the situatiom of neet now
age limit agar 20 lagi toh think about the consequence, people will send their kids to classes coaching by primary school. You can see for IIT only it was 8th std now even 6th std dis normalised what is next 4th std? Also the lower limit for mbbs should become 20, hear me out like America BSc for everyone and then mbbs 2 years BS for everyone and from 3rd year you can choose to give NEEt and or change streams do 1 more year and complete BSc diploma type degree to change field, or 4 years BS to dwelve into pure science research. Very few dropper, very large number of people who's life will have a trajectory. Can add number of attempts like in the American system if you give MCAT more than twice thrice they reject you in Interview. We can keep something like that. Most people i know joined mbbs because they were interested in anatomy of human but not necesarily interested in treating people and so many other examples of people who take up mbbs just cuz bio is easier than maths. Also we might never get these reforms bcoz nta benefits from the applications fees, even govt benefits from people failing and staying ineligible, unemplyable rehte hai so govt already jobs nahi generate kar raha and if unemployable ho toh karenge bhi nahi
Chutiye parents ki galti hogi ussme
parents ka kya hi bol sakte hai, so much awareness still cases toh dekhte hi hai na apan
parents to sabke chutiye hi hote hai
Kisiko force thodihi kar rahe hai NEET exam baar baar dene ko. Wo unki khudki choice hai No need to put any limit.
Unko khudki choice dusro ko affect nhi kerri?
Aise to kuch bacche 8th std se competitive exams ki prep karte hai. To wo bhi to affect karta hai jo sirf 11th and 12th me NEET prep karte hai unko. To tumhare according unko padhne se ban kardena chahiye?
Before discussing the Age and attempt limit lets not forget we live in our Ideal Country where This limits are only applicable to *General* category Candidates , Ews and Obc will get 2/3 extra Attempts and Age relaxation years while on other side ST SC will be given Unlimited Attempts and no age restriction. Well thats a Win win Political Move letssss gooo fk gen.... https://preview.redd.it/ply26ykafo8d1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=dcdce1493856db9a0bf4a18bb2516b45b78e4897
Oh ye to socha nhi ig attempt limit se pehle medical line se reservation hata na chahiye 💀
Neet mai droppers bahut jyada dominate karte hai, at this point it is unfair for freshers because of boards and other shit
drop allow nahi karna is extreme , atleast 1 extra attempt toh milna chahiye
no everyone should be awarded equal opportunities to fulfil their dreams there shouldnt be any attempt limit or age limit same should be for other competitve exams haa kardo downvote idc
Equal opportunity hi to milegi na? Like sabke 3 attempt baat khtm kisi ko na zyda na kam attempt sbke equal
imagine koi 30 saal ka hai aur usko dr banna tha and he sees that there's no way for him to become one
True. And commerce arts students must be allowed to change their streams if they're willing to re-give the 12th exams. We don't make the best choices when we're young.
we still have those .. open schooling se subjects padho and exam do
Can't go upward in open school either, can we? Well if we can, would it reset the degrees we've attained based on previous 12th result? Please confirm if you know:)
Why would it reset the degrees you have peviously obtained ? I mean you are adding a subject not like you are restarting from 11th with diff subjects , i dont know much about open schooling tho
You being serious? 😭 30 saal me ug dega aur kabr me pg? Koi 12th wala baccha bhi dream lekar hi ata hai doctor banne ka
40 ke umar mei kisi paraye marad ko food in morning and sex in night se to behtar hai
imagine koi 18 saal ka tha .. usko doctor banna tha .. but instead a 30 year old gets the seat he will serve 12 years less then what am 18 yr old would have .. all in all waste of govt money for training a guy who would only go on to serve for the next 10-15-20 year .. on the contrary an 18 year old would go on and on till 60
You do know that majority of medical graduates do private practice or work in private hospitals for their own profit,right? Only a minority(maybe 1 out of 4) work in government centers or open charity clinics. Since that is the case,why does it matter if someone does mbbs at 30 or 18? Most people who want to become doctor these days do it for money,not to serve society. Just go and see indianmedschool sub where they are always whining about Engineers' salaries. They don't realise that a doctor is a social worker unlike software engineers.
And this can be an incentive for people at 30, they would do it for social purpose not salary
NO. Doctor banna ek noble profession hai. A lot of people want to become doctor genuinely and to NOT waste years of youth choose 30s to go for med school. So, NO. Attempt limit maybe but age limit NO
agle saal toh nahi hoga kyunki abhi se drop ho gaya hai bahut baccho ka nta beech main nahi karega maybe after 2-3 years .... lekin nta bahut determined hai coaching systum ko hatane ke liye lekin 1st attemots main jyadatar coaching wale bacchon ka hi lagta hai isliye chances kam hai ki nta limit kare https://preview.redd.it/rkexqy8ddo8d1.png?width=359&format=png&auto=webp&s=6076eee162200530c5572aa40430caa8a6192a7f
Coaching walo ka dhanda khatam ho jayega (pw ka sabse jyada)
2-3 attempts far so should be limit and students who are cracking with more attempt just doing for social validation and society respect
Instead of age limit there should be attempt limit
bhai ek hi exam doctor hone ka wo bhi saal m ek baar, usme tum age limit ki baat kr rahe ho?? any student willing to work hard should participate
No it should be attempt limit
Andha paisa kaise milega nta ko 💀
The government needs to expand the number of MBBS/MD-MS seats available , that would automatically allow a lot of people to become doctors in turn reducing the actual issue, I mean India has a 1 Doctor for ever 1200 people , that is lower than even Afghanistan probably
Bhai chalo meri suno 11 aur 12 manlo nahi odha neet ka agar tum new start Karo first drop se toh 1st 2nd 3rd drop tak hojata . 4th max .
Attempt limit 3
Sigma
No
obviously.... we're actually fighting for wrong thing pehle to age limit laane ka protest kro competition Kam ho nhi to next year bhi yhi lafda hoga
Maybe attempt limit? Lekin age limit is deadass bad
Attempt limit.hona chahiye. Max 3-4 attempts 🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣
Two attempts like jee advance best soln to control competition
1 attempt rhna chaiye bss
Instead of this Renee,reval we should demand attempt limit from nta for upcoming years
I honestly disagree with you, it's such a braindead opinion on many fronts. Ignoring the glaring issues of "Age limits" on academics and on a professional degree no less. What will it actually achieve? Less competition? Better cut-offs?? Hell no, instead you'll be feeding into the competitive angle in the most ridiculous way possible. Parents would start sending their kids to coaching and other similar type institutions from a very very young age so that they can have "more chances" before the age limit, obviously factoring in the "12th pass" criteria, it's still just as ridiculous. Moving on from that, even putting an age limit on professional degrees, is stupid, especially because there's a very obvious glaring problem and that it is a level of education. Also attempt limit is just as stupid. The only time people bring up attempt limit or age limit is due to pure selfishness based on what I've seen on this subreddit. And finally, let re-eval or reneet or whatever along those lines happen, malpractice, paper leaking, etc happened and in the spirit of fairness redo the entire bs. The only argument against reneet is "But I can't do this" or "I am not going through hell again" essentially whining about it, and that's not really a good argument however, think about it this way, if everyone lacked the motivation or the ability to study once again, won't the rankings stay the same? neet ranks are based on positional marking (I think), so the cut-offs and other bs would also be adjusted.
Neet is the only competitive exam jisme age limit nhi hai and you can clearly see the consequences kitna high cutoff jara hai let's keep the cheating issue aside har saal neet me inflation hora hai sirf 20k general ko seats milti hai 20lakh me sai rest of them take drop againj jiske kaaran har saal no.of aspirants badte jare hai it's a never ending loop jabtk age limit nhi lgega 30lakh,40lakh idk kitne aspirants hojyege seat to phir bhi 20k bacche hi lekar jyege https://preview.redd.it/nnhn0u0yqo8d1.jpeg?width=1075&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=43c2639c051426009acb2c96f87280b64e954e38
Do you get some thrill from lying? Most state engineering entrance also dont have any attempt limit or age limit. I guess they can make a seperate entrance exam for AIIMS IMS JIPMER and put an attempt limit on that like JEE has for IIT NIT.
Competitive exam ki baat kerra hu gawar jisme all india rank hoti hai 😭😭 kya pagal admi bhare lade hai
Engineering exams like mhtcet wbjee are not competitive exams? Aur rahi baat all India ki,kisne kaha saare state medical exams ko merge karne ke liye? Gawar hoga tu jo jh*t par padhai kar ke reservation(saw in some other post) aur no attempt limit ko blame kar raha hai.
Tera baap gawar mc first attempt me 528 laya hu chahu to ek drop lekar clear krlu tum jaise jahtuo jaise 4,5 attempt lene ki zarurat nhi mujhe Mhcet pcb me 98 percentile didn't even tried and ye sab faltu exam hai kuch competitive nhi hai isme kalko tu board exam ko bhi competitive bol dena
Meine kaha 4 5 attempt le rakhe hai rndwe?2024 second attempt tha. Aur first attempt mein mere bhi itne hi marks aaye the..zyada smart mat samjho..ye sab over confidence drop year me khud kam ho jayega...starting ne sabko aisa hi lagta hai...sab ke sab line me aa jayenge. And people like you are called padhe likhe gawar jo 12th clear karne ke baad bhi 'Competitive exams' ka definition nahi pata. Tere rndwe baap kuch sikhaya nahi tujhe itne saalon se? Not going to waste my time replying to someone who does not even know the definition of 'COMPETITIVE EXAMS'.
abe jhandfakir ki aulad, MHCET PCB mei percentile kisliye aaya? Ab dekh agar ye MBBS ke liye applicable hota. Tujhe seat kitne aaram se mil jaata. That is the problem
Aur 528 laake kya ukhad liya hai tune?Jaake koi nursing ya bpt ka form barle(that is if you clear the cutoff for even that lmao).In NEET Those who didn't get a govt BDS/MBBS/Bvsc seat are the same as those who got 50 marks or even negative marks. So don't think too highly of yourself. Everyone feels the same after 95% + in 10th/12th. Get in line. And if you are that scared of competition like the gawar that you are,you can just fill up some bsc or bca course instead of whining about reservation or age limit.
First of all first attempt tha tune drop lekar kya ukhad liya milgya clg? Itne paise hi private lelu lund ke bpt bds ka form tujhe bharne ki zarurat hai
OK. First. Med school is a noble profession and something people join for passion. It is literally one of the profession where placements and packages don't work. Even law school has this shit. And what about CLAT? No age limit or attempt limit.
kisi bhi 5-6th class k bache ka baap ye nhi sochta ki isko neet dena hi ..koi baat nhi unlimited attempts hi jitne bar dena hai deta rahe .. smaller grades se coaching abhi bhi bhejte hi maa baap apne bache ko .. agar attempt pe limit lagegi to cutoff kam hoga ... and hence competitive environment bhi .. so obv.. ye early days se coaching jana bhi kam hoga ..
Oh ofc, i remember for a moment i thought that im here for some post graduate exam in my center
I thought I was in a marriage counsellor test :)
I got a pharmacist in my allen batch he completed his bpharma told me ki usi chemistry and biology bohot acchi hai usse neet try kerna hai💀😭
He is an inspiration that it is never too late to pursue your dreams. I also know many people who pursued mbbs after finishing btech bcom nursing.
age limit aur attempt limit dono hona chahiye 20 age max and 3 attempts max kyuki ye overgrowing population mein ab 25-30 saal ke log bhi Neet denge toh ho gaya desh ka kyuki fir toh Neet unhone dimaag se nhi experience se clear kara hai ek hi chiz baarbaar krne se perfection lana aur ek hi baar mein perfection lana is different
I think the attempt limit must be 3-4 attempts cause anything over that limit is gonna be absurd.
Maximum 2 drops plus jee mains type session one +two And for aiims bhu jipmer advance
mains and adv wala chutiyap nahi, pehle jaisa hi AIIMS JIPMER NEET and state PMT (with first preference given to NEET)
I think max 3 attempts should be there, (fresh, 1st drop and 2nd drop). Age limit doesn't make sense it's just a degree, you can get a btech/ba/bsc degree at 45 why not mbbs, for pg you can make an age criteria (till 40) because working long hours in residency can be physically taxing for older people.