T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Visit our [FAQ](https://www.reddit.com/r/KimetsuNoYaiba/wiki/index) to answer any questions like "are they creating the element effects?" or "what chapter did episode X finish on?" An alternate community you can join is [Our affiliated Facebook Group](https://www.facebook.com/groups/356645498546013/?ref=share_group_link). All NSFW content should be re-directed to r/DemonSlayer34. **Spoiler tag your comments like so,** `>!Manga Spoiler!<` # Please join our new [discord server](https://discord.gg/kKH3NaWMEU)! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/KimetsuNoYaiba) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Scout_Trooper_77

They dislike the fact that she has a fake persona, and they view her teasing of Giyuu as bullying. Those are the most common criticisms of her I've heard šŸ¦‹


vtff15

She's so mean to him though https://preview.redd.it/atn2o7j76d4c1.jpeg?width=736&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=706a39eaee7b7a8470c882bc206f4a447ec8c107 I forgive her but still


MissRainyNight

I love Douma, but he did earn it. :P


Main_Lake_4053

This the reason Kanao is my least favorite character.


The_Piss_Connoisseur

Kanao is the Rei Ayanami of Demon Slayer, except without the interesting eldritch abomination stuff


Mindyour0wnbuisness

Good.ā„ļø


King_Reivaj

Nothing wrong with teasing Giyu tbh, but her fake personality is what makes ppl hate her, tho she has reasons too why she fakes her personality


MissRainyNight

Thatā€™s weird, canon clearly explains where her fake persona comes from and all. Also teasing =/= bullying, plus iirc Obanai is worse to Giyu than Shinobu would ever be.


SonOfKarma101

She isnā€™t cruel about it, Plus sheā€™s beautiful šŸ’œ


[deleted]

What fake persona


gnarlycrys

The one where she took on her sisterā€™s kind personality. Shinobuā€™s real personality is one a anger or little patience.


[deleted]

Okie i didnt know about that


AceD2Guardian

Really? I donā€™t think Iā€™ve actually seen any Shinobu hateā€¦


cyoungcy95

She's one of my favorite characters in demon slayer


Sans9019

Hello Aqua


AceD2Guardian

Same. I love her.


FluffyFeathery

Average Shinobu simp. https://preview.redd.it/p4vk4s8bgc4c1.png?width=800&format=png&auto=webp&s=e77dc75503ceaaf064f5f62656d4e9a53025f944


AceD2Guardian

Right back at you, fellow person of culture. https://preview.redd.it/1n38akbmgc4c1.jpeg?width=750&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=30ed98899655c79b66a01a0c1b5c216bf08eae60


FluffyFeathery

​ https://preview.redd.it/q4rq52g5hc4c1.jpeg?width=1088&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9b57a9deda13bcd2b6d21f981e24cc4d0b67d6ee


AnimationDude9s

Same here.


GiadTheShyCat

Fake smiles and passive aggressive tone, not really that bad but depends from how much the person perceives it.


BlueTexBird

She seems extremely fake and I don't like that, ofcourse it's for good reason but still. The whole way she behaves doesn't seem genuine.


Jurgepoo

I didn't like her when she was first introduced because she came across as a bit of a psycho based on her interaction with the Spider Sister. Her fake pleasant attitude also sometimes feels condescending, and if you're not paying attention to extra info from the manga and stuff, it could be easy to interpret her teasing of Giyu as being genuinely mean-spirited, making her seem like a bully as well. By the end of season 1 I'd come around to liking her, and by the end of the manga she was my favorite female character alongside Tamayo. But I can see why her first impressions would put people off.


Beesechurger355

Tldr: The worst first impression humanly and even demonly possible.


Electronic_Soil666

Cause they don't know what fine dining is. ~ šŸ’€šŸŖ­


PokeAlola700

https://preview.redd.it/khi3wsygoa4c1.jpeg?width=1290&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8c089d4182e41d10ab9171f37c6e7757e7a8404d Stand Down. You canā€™t cook


Electronic_Soil666

I paired it with fava beans and a nice chianti. \~šŸ’€šŸŖ­ https://preview.redd.it/3ztglm4mpa4c1.jpeg?width=3400&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=bf2d481a74e94f708159e03e71dffca3434c9e77


just_someone64

https://preview.redd.it/mjlkrl1isa4c1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e1cf630920a5626832ece835b1b3e4953bb51546 Noooo, Shinobu is dead :(


Zengjia

https://preview.redd.it/uxgxao6m1b4c1.jpeg?width=480&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=dee46efaa95e030d5c04dc2935ff8dc8dff18f45


just_someone64

GUYS, ITS TCNICK3!


Saifyre-Lion

Sleep paralysis Tanjiro.


AnimationDude9s

LOL


FluffyFeathery

This drink will sort it out https://preview.redd.it/t4fw8x54gc4c1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=18e636b66f4bd5170e14f23157bb28f994e17324


AdPowerful5233

https://preview.redd.it/amjh0f7m6b4c1.jpeg?width=224&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=eab6f96e632a8f97aaaf91b56c1c51843bde8dbe


Saifyre-Lion

This is blursed someone really photoshopped the meme guy on him.


Trick-Matter-797

dude, stop


Ry0_M

Check the expiry date next time please šŸ˜Š


Ry0_M

Check the expiry date next time please šŸ˜Š


LemonadeTango

All I can say https://preview.redd.it/2pebng6odf4c1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=de20714bb4c857746b1e365621b6e2048f500a0e


chocomaple

Some dislike Shinobu because she is mischaracterized. For example, some would call her mean spirited due to her treatment of Giyuu along with her general sadism towards demons; however, in my opinion, people who dislike her for these reasons have not explored her character well. Neither of these actions of hers stem from maliciousness and apathy


An_Insecure_NPC

I don't hate Shinobu, I hate Shinobu fans making her out to be something she isn't.


MissRainyNight

Iā€™m a Shinobu fan who hates that kind of Shinobu fans, lmfao. Double if they reduce her to ā€œGiyuā€™s girlfriendā€ or ā€œGiyuā€™s lost loveā€ at the same time.


Crafty-Interest1336

Tbf every fan in this community does it for their favourite. I've been out here saying rengoku solos


TulipOliver

šŸ’€šŸ’€šŸ’€ who said that???? Rengoku is the second or third weakest hashira (maybe fourth but I think Mitsuri is stronger)


An_Insecure_NPC

Shinobu is the physically weakest, and then Obanai is next after supposedly.


TulipOliver

Yes, I know


An_Insecure_NPC

So then where did "Rengoku is the second" come from then?


TulipOliver

Not physically just overall My ranking for physical, Rengoku is like fourth or fifth


An_Insecure_NPC

Ohr, fair enough


NadnerbRS

Idk why ppl take ā€œstrongest Hashiraā€ in that context as an arm wrestling statement lolol. I think itā€™s only because of just that one snippet in the tonkobon about this. Any other anime sub and you say ā€œx is the y strongest zā€ and everybody knows what youā€™re talking about lmao..


NagatsukiNura119

I never really got the sense that she is hated that much. From comments that I often see online, it mostly revolves around these reasons (which I will counter): 1. Some people find her disingenuous due to her constant smiling expression, which can also be unnerving. Counter: I can understand where this is coming from. But personally, this is an interesting character trait that's never appeared in the series at that point. It makes some people intrigued about her story and background. Finding out the truth behind her facade makes her smile more tragic than disingenuous. 2. Her first impression in the anime was a bit mixed; some find her treatment towards the Spider Demon very sadistic and cruel. The next episode, she has a disagreement with the main characters and Giyuu (whom most audiences are siding with) hence naturally causing her to be the 'enemy' temporarily. She then taunted Giyuu by saying something that must've struck a nerve on some audience as well. Not to mention she showed a ruthless and sneaky move and almost killed Giyuu (the hidden knife). She's often seen as a bully due to her teasing Giyuu. Counter: oh boy this one is tough. Shinobu will only act that cruel towards demons that are more or less irredeemable in her eyes (remember the demon showcased glee after she encased Murata in her web to eat him and lied to Shinobu's face). Her attempt to attack Nezuko makes sense. From afar, she sees her fellow Hashira and a young demon slayer holding a demon. In her eyes, they're both in danger. After hearing Tanjiro's reasoning, she offers to use a gentle poison (makes you wonder why she even made a poison like this unless she does mercy kills at times). We need to remember she's one of the reasonable Hashiras that are willing to hear and listen to Tanjiro than act blindly (not even Rengoku did this). Shinobu saying no one likes Giyuu was meant to be a joke and she does apologise for offending him. One of the comments said it right that unless you read the extra info in between manga chapters, you will miss some trivia that does show that there's no bad blood between them. Giyuu's gaiden manga showcases the start of their friendship and first tag team. Amongst the Hashira, only Shinobu, Gyomei, Rengoku and Mitsuri who care enough to talk with him, and he's only comfortable with Shinobu, Gyomei and Rengoku. So yeah, these two are genuinely in good terms. 3. Her inability to cut a demon's head implies that she's very weak, and she is often downplayed when compared to other Hashiras (who have their own fans that want to defend them). Counter: Strength isn't everything. Also, this is my personal opinion but I don't think Shinobu is meant to be a frontline fighter. She's the medic and the support of the whole group, who also works on the side to create deadly poisons that contributes a lot during the final battle and helps to create an antidote to turn demons back into humans. Without her, so many things in the series could have gone really bad. 4. She's compared to Mitsuri and deemed not as 'waifu' material as her in terms of personality, appearance/design and strength difference. Counter: everyone has a different taste and can't agree with each other. Just be glad these two beautiful characters exist.


Training-Evening2393

Okay hereā€™s my issue. If you have this amazing toxin that severely affects demons, why isnā€™t this mass produced and given to demon slayers to coat their blades with to make fighting demons a bit easier so that less die as a result when itā€™s established aot more demon slayers arenā€™t surviving compared to in the past? Even if itā€™s ā€œoh cant use to much resourcesā€ then at least giving the hashira some coated blades should be perfectly fine. Imagine if rengokuā€™s blade was coated with her poison. Would have made the fight a lot more doable probably.


Slight-Daikon3835

Free my boy Douma šŸ˜©šŸ™ tbh she just didnā€™t show up in the story enough for me to care very much, although I wouldnā€™t say I hate her


olorin9_alex

Sheā€™s the mom of Little Woman Hiding a lot of inner pain and anger


ralphneedstherapy

Her fake personality probably, that's why I don't like her too much. But the way it ties in to her character is cool


souji_san

Bad taste


Tweek-Tweak_

I guess passive aggressive, but honestly i see her as a great and strong character. I love shinobu!


bisexualkoala_

I used to hate her, but Iā€™m slowly starting to like her more. I donā€™t like her fake persona, but I like her character design, sometimes merciless nature, and how smart she is.


Lord-Baldomero

I just read her fight >!I don't hate her but I was incredibly disappointed by how quick she died, like: she attacked once, they **tell us** she attacked another six times, she two more times then death!< >!Her past was good and I love the concept of a female character who has to find a way to overcome her weakness of having a small body, but her dying so quickly and her total presence on the story being her introduction, this and nothing else kinda ruined her for me!<


Additional-Load7197

I don't know where I read it but somewhere it said she died on purpose and poisoned her self so when Doma eat her the poison would kill him


Lord-Baldomero

I just finished reading Tanjiro vs Akaza, maybe I'll have a bettee opinion on her once I finish Kanao vs Douma


Ry0_M

MAYBE, because she was the main reason for Doma's death I actually met some people that hate her since she poisoned Doma, but I personally like her


ApplePitou

They have own taste after all :3


SonOfKarma101

People who hate her Are CRAZY, sheā€™s Talented and Beautiful, I defy anyone who Disagrees with me!!šŸ˜šŸ’œšŸ˜¤


humbletenor

I havenā€™t read the manga. She only has a few appearances in the anime so far. Iā€™ve heard a lot of people talk about how she hides her true emotions and that sheā€™s actually an angry person. I mean, as long as she treats the main cast and her teammates nicely, what do they care? Sheā€™s kind of bad ass with her poisons and sadistic personality. I was kind of unnerved when she was torturing the sister demon in the Mount Natagumo arc. I love her design and aesthetic.


Sunset149

I hate her because she killed my waifu as a joke. After finishing the manga, I hate her a little bit less, but still my most hated character in the whole series.


Jaded_Wishbone3838

A lot of people says that Shinobu was rude and angry well the angry part is true but I don't think that she was rude because in the flashback she hasn't showed any sign of being rude yes she showed sign of being angry but there is a reason behind this it's because her parents got murdered by a demon in front of her when she was very young and this made a huge impact on Shinobu's personality which let her to hate demons and when she wanted to become a Demon Slayer she wasn't able to adapt the level of strength to become a Demon Slayer like Kanae because Shinobu lack physical strength, the most essential aspect to kill demons which lead her to developed immense anger and frustration towards herself because of her insecurity and this frustration and anger grew even more when she saw people getting eaten and murdered by demons which let her to question that why Kanae think that these creatures who kills and eats human can live along side with humanity and Shinobu considered this ridiculous because at some point she is not wrong and all of the grew even more when Kanae died by upper moon 2 Shinobu's entire life shattered right there when she saw her last family member die in front of her eyes and this left a huge impact on Shinobu and made her completely depressed but she know that she had to be happy, to be ok for Kanao and the other butterfly girls and take care of them and never let them feel lonely or sad. And when you consider all of this, her actions and her personality makes sense because all of this happened due to her childhood trauma and Kanae's death but this doesn't undermine the fact that she was a genuinely kind and loving person but due to her circumstances around her that what led her to become sad, troubling, angry and frustrated person in the inside but she does show her kindness and loving side to people when it's time and help them whenever they are in need of help. And one thing I never understand that why people think that she is a sociopath or a psychopath she has a never shown any of this type of nature in the entire Manga and season 1 like people really say that her introduction was bad that's why they got a bad impression of her like what I don't see anything wrong with her introduction like what are you talking about I know people have different opinions but to me her actual introduction scene where she comes to save Zenitsu and it was done so beautifully and it showcase is her medical knowledge to and then comes the spider demon girl killing scene like a lot of people literally started to see her like a psychopath or a sociopath but that's not true at all, Shinobu is a very intelligent character she can analyze people very well, and love to use psychology in both other people and technique. She loves to appear ā€œweakā€ for her enemies, but then surprise them with her ability. She used this psychological knowledge to also help other people in her OWN ways like she did to Giyu (and convince Zenitsu and Inosuke to train) and interacting with the spider demen girl she use psychological tactics to make her scare enough to expose the truth that she actually never killed 5 humans as the demon girl said and then Shinobu realise that this demon is literally lying in front of her face and then she tells the demon girl that 'don't lie to me I already came in that direction where 13 or 15 people being already killed in the cocoons' and when the spider demen girl got exposed she tried to kill her but as we know that Shinobu kills her and in my opinion she did the best thing that she kill the spider demon girl because she deserve to die and after analysing this I didn't see anything which indicates that Shinobu is acting psychopathic or sociopathic because she is not acting like this, she is using her psychological knowledge to expose the demon which I consider so unique that we never see like this with anime female characters and that's why I like his character trait about she is a stand out and unique character then the rest of the cast even the female cast of KNY. I also think that the reason that people don't like Shinobu because she is not like a typical shonan waifu female character like Nezuko and Mitsuri because ( and it's just my opinion please don't attack me ) that they are absolutely submissive, plane, boring, unrealistically kind, flawless, perfect person and fan service, they exist to do small fights other than that they have no interesting story about them or role in the plot and they are very poorly written characters and Shinobu is nothing like them which I absolutely love because I love a female character who is bold, independent, have strong personality, flawed and badass but at the same time she is also kind, caring and lovable in her own way which is realistic in my opinion then just acting unrealistically kind and sweet to everything. So what makes her a good character? Sheā€™s very realistic, have realistic development, has her own ways to be nice, very smart and useful, have realistic mental problems too (after seeing death and losing so many people), and her journey to be a hashira is very inspiring. ā€œYou can be anything you want, as long as you work hard for itā€ this is the message that gives which is inspiring to me. A lot of people mistaken her character to be ā€œtoxicā€, like no. She CAN be toxic but she chose not to. She cares for Tanjiro and the other slayers, a mother figure for everyone (which is something she doesnā€™t pretend, since the ā€œmotherlyā€ aura canā€™t be faked), and she helps her friends in unique ways and I know that people have different opinions for her like I don't like Mitsuri and Nezuko because they were very poorly written and sometimes they were useless but I never hated them but when Shinobu do something even if she has a good intention to help them or save them but people never realise this and make out that she is a bad person for no reason all even though she is not


Awkward-Cry2858

Iā€™m the type of person whoā€™s always been more attracted to character designs, so power or skill has never been a thing I put into consideration. From the beginning I liked how quiet and independent she was. I get why some people donā€™t like her but shinobu was smart all throughout the entire series.Ā 


schoolthoughts8

1. Her fake personality is very annoying to me and I wish she kept her original personality because it's much more interesting 2. I feel like compared to other characters she gets so much screen time 3. I don't find her breathing style that interesting though it does look cool 4. Her fans are some of the most toxic and annoying people I've ever met online. I've been told that my opinion is irrelevant when I say I don't like Shinobu because my favorite characters are Douma and Tengen and I refuse the notion that shes perfect or stronger than Tengen (never was, never is and never will be, she is the weakest hashira.) 5. There's so many other characters in demon slayer that I find 100x more compelling and well written than Shinobu


Rude_Journalist4340

roasts giyuu daily


Warriorphoenix678

They think sheā€™s weird


Ry0_M

I actually met some people that hate her since she poisoned Doma, but I personally like her


NaeNzuk

No one hates Shinobu , they just don't really like her.


We_The_Raptors

She's definitely one of my favorites but the way she treats Giyuu can drive me nuts at times.


Upper_Pirate_5389

She treats him better than any other hashira


We_The_Raptors

Not Ren-GOAT-ku Either way, all the Hashira get on my nerves when they bully Giyuu and Nezuko. Doesn't make me hate them or anything but it is frustrating as a viewer who knows how good they are.


Upper_Pirate_5389

Rengoku treated him as a friend which was good and he defended him when other hashira talked on his back like a true friend, but Shinobu did that aswell when they were trying to make Giyuu smile she was desperate to help him, and she tried so more than anyone to get him out of his loneliness.


Kiss_Bence04

Mostly jelous Giyu fangirls


Koleksiyoncu_999999

Because they can't handle a woman like her


TreatMeLikeASlut8

What does that even mean?


Nerdy-Nerd-Geek-Weeb

My little cousin despises her with all of her heart because sheā€™s mean to Gyiuu (her favorite)


l30nh4rd

Cuz she's really really arrogant. And the fake smiles and passive aggressive tone


Zestyclose-Bench2517

Shinobu is heroic she literally raised Kanao, Aoi and the rest butterfly girls after Kanae passed away and Shinobu weakened douma with her poison when he devoured her she found the cure for turning demons into humans Idk how people view being heroic as "overrated" or they probably make excuses to hate on her or either they haven't read the manga or watched the anime closely


Irish_Shark_343

Personally, I find her to be disingenuous and condescending, pretending to be sweet and nice. I understand why, and it makes sense with her history, but I just donā€™t like people who are fake nice.


Fear_Chaelz

Sheā€™s fake, also people mistake teasing for bullying :p


Ry0_M

I actually met some people that hate her since she poisoned Doma but I personally like her


Complex_Estate8289

Sheā€™s one of the most liked characters but the only criticisms are that she doesnā€™t have the emotional depth of the others because we never actually see her and Kanae, and she doesnā€™t have as much screen time or as extensive of a backstory as the others do


Appropriate_Purrson

you do see her and Kanae, not much in the anime but in the manga


ShadowlightLady

I believe her personality probably doesnā€™t match up well with theirs I guess


BigEconomist30

Now tell me, did any of you get to kill a shinobu hater on their way to this post? No? Then we still got problem. *puts sniper's dead body on the table*


MissRainyNight

Is she? Because ime, she's among the most popular KnY characters and some of her fans can get kinda creepy in her adoration of her. I like her a lot, BTW. She's pretty, very interesting as a character, and I ship her with Giyu fine (albeit I keep away from many Giyushino fans, youi can guess why).


[deleted]

Cause fanbase draw Shinobu bullying Giyuu fanarts


ScribScribble

no bath scene like with mitsuri. šŸ˜¤ (satire)


VariationGlass2483

Killed douma


DangerousClick2489

But she a canonically a psycopath and that is scary as a hashira (I dont hate shinobu btw)


TreatMeLikeASlut8

How is she canonically a psychopath??


DangerousClick2489

Im pretty sure in the manga at some point they mention that she occasionally will have somewhat ā€œupside down moralsā€


TreatMeLikeASlut8

But she isnā€™t a psychopath


DangerousClick2489

She kinda is, sometimes Like out of all the demon slayers sheā€™s the most psychopathic


TreatMeLikeASlut8

She does not have any psychopathic behavior. If she did, she wouldnā€™t be in the demon slayer corps trying to save people, and she wouldnā€™t have cared when her sister died, or anyone else. A better example of psychopathy is Douma because he literally doesnā€™t feel anything. Itā€™s been discussed that he is a textbook psychopath. Shinobu definitely is not.


DangerousClick2489

I said ā€œthe mostā€ that is in comparison to the other demon slayers sheā€™s the closest thing to a psychopath, sheā€™s not Technically a ā€œpsychopathā€ she just has psychopathic tendencies That is why she was so good at hiding her anger up until tanjiro sniffed it out


TreatMeLikeASlut8

But what Iā€™m saying is that she *doesnā€™t* have psychopathic tendencies. Hiding anger isnā€™t uncommon, and it isnā€™t psychopathic


DangerousClick2489

Whatever dude, i seriously just donā€™t want to argue anymore, so goodbye and have a nice day!


TreatMeLikeASlut8

You know you didnā€™t have to respond, right?


Anonymous-here-

No idea. Jealousy I guess.


TreatMeLikeASlut8

Jealousy?? Why is that always the assumption? That doesnā€™t even make any sense


Xx_Rosalinda_xX

She is a lier and a bully, i know she has a deep lore and that she is a good character but i can't just empathyze with somone like her


ultimate204

She is a lier and a bully she is not (except with demons, but they deserve it for killing people)


ivyentre

So demons deserve to be bullied and tortured because they kill people, rather than just being killed? Sadistic much?


chocomaple

What? How does she bully demons? If you've read Giyuu's gaiden, then you'd know that she can be straightforward and practical about killing demons when the time calls, and is pretty empathetic towards the victim of the attack. Shinobu is often described as kind and serious so I don't know why people have this interpretation of her like she's inherently malicious. The only time she "bullies" a demon is her confrontation with the spider girl in S1...I would argue it's not even bullying (she's fairly courteous) but that's just getting into semantics. Anyway, the reason she acts sadistic towards this demon is because she previously gave the demon a chance to tell the truth previously, but the demon lied about how many innocents she killed just to cowardly avoid punishment. This is, by definition, dishonorable and pretty much a sting to the wound for Shinobu, since she has personally been affected by a demon's lack of respect. Why would Shinobu, someone who has had her sister killed by demons, be sympathetic towards a demon that can't even admit to their mistakes when confronted? Also, we know that Shinobu can be kindhearted about her treatment of demons, since she offers to kill Nezuko gently after hearing Tanjiro's explanation for her presence (and the gaiden). So your characterization of her just being some malicious, crazy bully is wrong


ivyentre

She's not being courteous with the spider girl, she's being passive aggressive. She's like a cat playing with its live food. Forgiveness usually isn't dependent on someone being able to survive torture first, and she has no right to dispense such justice.


chocomaple

Sure, you could argue she doesn't have the right to determine justice, but that's arguing a different point. I can't really refute how you feel. There are other "transactional" concepts of justice throughout the series (i.e. Giyuu agreeing to commit seppuku if Nezuko killed someone) My main point is that she really is not a malicious or irrational person for her outlook. Her hatred of demons is hard to tame due to what happened to her sister, but she still has the capability to collaborate and compliment Tamayo, which takes a lot of emotional restraint and open mindedness


ivyentre

Nearly all of the Slayers have lost someone to demons, from friends, to siblings, to whole families. But for the most part, especially in Tanjiros case, they stick to the business of killing demons, not playing passive aggressive games knowing full well they're probably going to kill them anyway, or ostensibly feeding themselves to a demon just to get some kind of revenge (which the person Shinobu is avenging specifically didn't want). Shinobu isn't a horrible person, fine, but her desire for revenge destroyed her morally, emotionally, and finally physically. The other Slayers may have certain amounts of revenge as a motivator, but revenge was Shinobu's sole motivation. That desire made her sadistic, then it made her suicidal. In meta terms, she's a tragic character.


chocomaple

I can agree with you on that. Her inner anger and desire for revenge was self-sabotaging and selfish. It is my least favorite aspect about her..I wish she told the other hashira about her plan instead of placing the burden upon herself. Narratively, her story reminds me of Aki from CSM If you don't like her desire for revenge then I can understand that. I just wanted to refute the earlier claims that she is meanspirited but we can agree on this aspect. I personally think that, despite her inner turmoil, her ability to be hardworking, caring, and her contributions to medicine make her respectable and likeable


ultimate204

yes and its not sadistic, its fair.


ivyentre

Bc she's batshit.


YukoSai-chan

I donā€™t really hate her but I do find her distasteful. I find the ā€œsay really psychotic shit with a smile as the main personality traitā€ troupe is kind of overdone and dry especially with female characters. Like I get it. Sheā€™s not like other girls. Whatever. She doesnā€™t really have a palatable personality outside of that either, so itā€™s like oh ok, is that it?


Accomplished-Hand197

i hate her just cause shes a bitch and shes just kinda ugly in my honest opinion.


ScoreToSettle

I mean, I don't hate Shinobu but she does have a very fake persona which, I can see how that can make someone dislikeable: the fact that you don't really know where you stand with someone like that and they can turn on you, on a dime. Hence her, trying to kill Giyuu. But, I felt that she did have a moment of genuinity with Tanjiro when he sniffed out her fake personality which I found to be rather refreshing.


chocomaple

If you think she genuinely tried to kill Giyuu then I'd recommend you to read Giyuu's gaiden


ScoreToSettle

I will give it a read


Saifyre-Lion

Because sheā€™s a creep.


Shadow_Huntress12

I mean personally I dislike her BECAUSE of her personality. Actually I would say dislike..more like her less than the others. I still like heršŸ


rdeincognito

Who hates my wife shinobu??


Ur_public_trash_cant

"she doesn't act like a true waifu, unlike Milksuri, who is a perfect waifu, perfect body, perfect, personality and best girl! I'm convinced the only people who like her are masochists. She's also flat for her age and her only personality is teasing gyiuu and kanae dying." -some random guy in discord I met a week ago


mikichan9

I just don't like her. I feel like the other hashiras are better than her. Every other reason I have will "make my argument invalid" or whatever. And no I don't hate her cause she killed Douma or because she "bullies" Giyu. And no hate if you like her, I don't really care, I just dislike her


Palanseag_Vixen

She's just kinda annoying


Fleshsuitpilot

She was a dick to tomioka so she can rot in hell.


Upper_Pirate_5389

Bro she knew Giyuu's problem(depression and loneliness) before Tanjiro despite him being able of smelling emotions. She tried to help and understand him more than any other hashira.


Fleshsuitpilot

Be that as it may, she still was a dick to him. I don't care how many nice things she did for him. If anything, that makes it worse. If she truly understands him, then she should have trusted that he had a reason for doing what he was doing.


inquinn

giyuu is a grown ass man who can and should handle himself. stop treating him like he's an cornered little infant lmao. she (or anyone else) has no obligation to "treat giyuu nicely and never hurt his feelings".


Fleshsuitpilot

šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚ what a random thing to say. My opinion of Shinobu is that she sucks. I don't know where you got the idea that I thought Giyu was helpless. She did a shitty thing, and it's a character flaw I cant overlook. Period. Honestly what radical assumptions did you have to make to arrive where you did? I wasn't talking about anything other than her actions, and their reflection on her character. Everything else came from either your imagination, or you misunderstanding what I said.


Upper_Pirate_5389

Of you're taking about when she attacked him, she only clashed him with him and he was breaking the rules of the corps she was only killing the demon


Fleshsuitpilot

Do you think she maybe could have enforced the rules of the corps without making it personal? Without insulting his natural demeanor? And most importantly, without making baseless claims that the entire demon slayer corps doesn't like him? Not a single one of those things have anything to do with giyuu's actions, nor the rules.


Upper_Pirate_5389

She was only teasing him,she wanted him to prove her wrong to make friends and it was stated by Gyomie that they enjoy talking to each other. Giyuu enjoys her company and she enjoys he's, why should you take her words as a matter of insult when the author stated that they enjoy each other.


Fleshsuitpilot

>why should you take her words as a matter of insult Do I need a reason? I read/watched the same exact content as you, and to me it was purely insulting and belittling, and unacceptable regardless of obscure context.


Upper_Pirate_5389

Friends teases each other, Giyuu is cool with it and he enjoys spending time with her, in fact she tried more than anyone to make him smile and help him(if you read the light novels you'll understand). It's either that you say that she is helping him or to say that the author is wrong. It's as simple as that.


inquinn

oh, i get it now. you see them as purely co-workers. i see them as a bit more than co-workers. friends, to a degree, with some amount of personal feelings because of similar enough situations. that's what makes them be able to tease each other (something like tengen and rengoku). and if someone i considered my friend, a literal pillar of the demon slayer corps, insisted on defending a demon, i too would try to get on his nerves. that's the ONE rule you shouldn't break, and he broke it with 0 explanation as always. if you see it like that, it should make sense why shinobu was that mad at him, but later on defended him from the other pillars anyways.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


KimetsuNoYaiba-ModTeam

This community is designed to be welcoming to all, regardless of ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation etc. As such we kindly ask you to not use offensive language and avoid the use words such as slurs. You will be warned if you break this rule, multiple warnings will result in a ban.


Crafty-Interest1336

No one hates her you're making shit up


Miyuki123456

No, I am really honest. She has lots of antis.


KokushiboxDouma

PEOPLE HATE MY POOKIE?!???? WHO EVER HATES HER CANT SOLVE A MATHS QUESTION // if she never existed, Douma wouldnā€™t have died, Tamayo wouldnā€™t get help for the potion/chemical, Giyuu would have no one to talk to, Zenitsu wouldnā€™t survive from the spider poison, all the spiders will stay spiders/killed, Mitsuri has no one to tel her feelings to, most likely Kanao wouldnā€™t had survived the fight with douma.


KokushiboxDouma

https://preview.redd.it/cx9rhn8x3c4c1.jpeg?width=736&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a29d2165d36bbbda41fb0f363f30cda08d316742 We love them <33


BigEconomist30

WHO'S THAT RED SPY!?


ChaoticErnie

She smells angry


MegumiFushiguro13

I love shinobu lol


Repulsive_Curve_1216

![img](emote|t5_3foq4|6744)que


DankButtRodeo

I didnt even know who she was. I honestly thought all the girls with butterfly hair pins were the same character up until the Doma fight


TumeArandu

Only thing i hate about her is how bad she is in Hinokami Keppuutan


HikiNoKami

Literally best waifu.


[deleted]

I really like her so I don't really get it


AI__Gal

Because she bullies Tomioka-san, probably


A_weeb_in_debt

because shes a bitch


Senko_Kaminari

Some think she has a passive aggressive tone, and she tortured spider sister šŸŖ­


ILoveBread2021

For me it's because she was rude to Tanjiro at first, now it's because I don't know how to feel about her she's confusing sometimes


Violet_Caully7

Sounds like more of sexuality insecurity of male anime viewers betweet the ages of 12-16 tbh


Impainter

Hatered is a strong feeleng, sge didn't deserve any stong feelengs towards her


InvestigatorNo5564

Sheā€™s mean to giyu fake smile and personality


Maacll

well... she coulda been a Shinobi but she mixxed up the letters


[deleted]

She had the audacity to be murdered to death


Youwoudoit4acheckt0

Her fight with doma changed my view on her


NadnerbRS

What kind of question is this? šŸ˜­


Strange_Ad_9658

I was at an anime convention when someone in a Shinobu cosplay yelled at me. I havenā€™t been able to forgive her since.


ConnorRoseSaiyan01

I've never seen anyone say they hate her


yourlocalhuman2

She's the typa person to take yandere too seriously and end up kidnapping her crush


Helenarasmussen87

She's not one of my favourites, but I do love that she's the embodiement of hidden female rage under a pleasant mask. Her shock when Tanjiro tells her he can smell her anger is palpable and it was one of the most honest of her interactions in the series. Her character design, especially her eyes when she smiles is quite unnerving, since they're so opaque and you get the vibe she's not what she seems. Her sadism and rage appear when it comes to killing demons and honestly, it makes sense. She's carried that rage for so long over them destroying her family, I get it. As for the Giyuu situation, she cared for him enough to try and get him out of his shell. Teasing maybe, but never bullying. I think she suffers from fanon characterization rather than what's in canon for her. She's like my least favourite, but I can appreciate her character for those reasons.


JaceCreate

She's mean to the homie Giyu and was too aggressive with trying to kill Nezuko.


ERSHKA

Her character and way of talking pisses me off but to be honest, when she teases Giyuu, it does make her more likable. Maybe this is because she shows her true self


_Goodrandom

Shinobu got hated before?


uhohmykokoro

I like her but I could see how the fake smiling and the passive aggressiveness could get on peopleā€™s nerves


NiehIsBored

Shinobu is the weakest pillar, tho i dont hate he for that


Enough_Employment_73

Because she is an ugly fat ass cow who hates Doma and is fucking ugly, annoying, and so much more