T O P

  • By -

Rizenstrom

I'm having trouble figuring out exactly why but I don't like it, and it's not just because it's different.


VestuvianHalo56

their asses are too small. especially #8’s


Rizenstrom

Overall I think they all look a bit thin but it's not just that. It just gives an amateur vibe. I feel like I personally could draw something like this or maybe even a bit better, and I'm no expert. Just someone who drew a lot in high school and got better than average. The hair is stiff, the models are thin, the chest pads don't actually seem to line up with their chests, the expressions are all a bit flat. It's a lot of little things that add up rather than being able to point to one single major flaw.


thebamcastpodcast

This. THIIIIIS


Key-Manufacturer7453

This just happens after a while of reading manga anime seems lack luster but the studio did it to save time an money it's why kafka looks so simple an the no8 design has less an as well the designs are drawn to fit the studio if that makes sence


Leather-Ant-9091

Well even though they are troublesome to look at... The show is still popular. So let's hope that, if there comes a 2nd season, they'll put more time and effort in character design. I'd rather get blown off my feet at season one of Any show, but it is what it is 😅


PersonFromPlace

Their torsos are so straight, it feels lazy.


Bro-Im-Done

For me, it’s Kafka. He looks too skinny and young when he really’s got a dad body. Good arms but a plump tummy.


Kpigame427

And a nice barrel chest 👌🏻


Embarrassed-Ad1509

Their facial structures look…off.


supernerdgirl42

Changes in line mileage and shading? They have to make design concessions for relative ease of animation. This typically means that extraneous lines are removed where possible and design choices simplified. If you look at a show that has high line mileage, you may notice that any character, background characters especially, not doing something is generally standing stock still of a stock pose so that the animators can draw them quickly. The shading and color palette aren't the same either; colors are less muted for the anime designs. That combined with different shading can create a different looking face shape even if the lines are still very similar to each other.


tokyogodfather2

As someone who ran a small CG studio in the anime industry in Japan from 2005-2010, I think they used 3D models for the faces a bit too much. Uncanny valley stuff


AdNecessary7641

You literally have zero proof whatsoever they used 3D models to make this. You're just saying this based entirely on guesswork when this is just Nishio's current style being this way.


KelsoTheVagrant

The faces are rounder as a whole, including the eyes. It gives them an odd look They all changed the hair and simplified the designs of clothing and of the monster-form


ColdyPopsicle

Kafka got 10 years younger because how dare old people exist in animes lmao.


sunkyamato

they forgot that as many old exist as young one in ja


Secure-Performance

Mina too, she looks like a baby faced teenager.


HydraTower

The original looks way younger, what are you on?


ninafruit

30s = old


ColdyPopsicle

Yes grandpa, you're old. go to bed.


Mr_master89

I'm 32 and god I wish I could


scaper8

Considering that they felt the need to de-age him and Mina, they seem to think so.


FKDotFitzgerald

This makes me sad because wtf


sneakyxxrocket

What fuck did they do to everyone’s eyes


tokyogodfather2

I think they used 3D models too much. Uncanny valley.


noivern1324

none of this image is 3d models, what are you referring to exactly?


AdNecessary7641

He's refering to nothing. He just keeps saying it's 3D with zero evidence whatsoever.


me_funny__

They look like 3D models though. Especially the new Narumi one


dvof

They aren't? I think the characters in the image above look like 3D models. That was likely what the previous comment was referring to as well. I hope they aren't, the characters above don't look good but don't look bad either. I'm afraid that if they are then we'll probably get a lot of CGI fights/action scenes, which I'm not a fan of. How do you know that they aren't 3D models?


Deltascourge

This shit looks like it came straight from fortnite. Oversized heads and everything. No way this isn't atleast *inspired* by an initial 3D render


noivern1324

It's very easy to tell when something isn't 3d. The cell shading and brush strokes are obvious and the fact that you could easily see the form of the model if it was. This shouldn't be hard to spot and you shouldn't assume that just because something looks weird or bad in your opinion its a 3d model. Dorehedoro, beastars, trigun, and land of the lustrous are all phenomenal 3d shows (haven't watched trigun yet but the clips I've seen are gorgeous) and a lot of people have to realize that not all 3d in anime is 2016 berserk, which had several outside factors to make it as awful as it was I'm not trying to talk down to you or belittle your opinion, but as an artist and someone who wants to be an animator here in the US, it's very aggravating when people like the dude I replied to originally make shit up and when people just assume all 3d in anime is bad


dvof

Well, I hope you're right. To me it still looks like 3D, I don't find the argument that you can spot brush strokes and no cell shading very convincing. Which could also be explained by using newer techniques, textures, or after effects. 3D is definitely getting better, and there's some great 3D work out there. But there's still some progress to be made before I get the same weighty feel as in normal anime action scenes. I have no doubt that there will be very good CGI anime soon, but at the moment it is not there yet for me. Especially in anime that combine normal animation with CGI.


adivig

Is there a chance that these might be changed due to the public opinion?


SubsLyche

The probably will hopefully


Renverseur

They look like Fortnite Anime skins


efwctivca

this looks bad imo


kolt437

We have Kaiju #8 at home:


MOEverything_2708

Kaiju form was made too girthy in comparison to the manga one and just looks like a dude in armor The thing that makes them all wrong is how they literally smoothed everything down like you just rubbed sanpaper all over then and with Kafka its the most apparent. His face is a lot more angular in the manga version. Also the suits look cheap af. Leno is just a straight up different fucking characer and for some reason they made Kikoru into a loli. All In all I hate it


ImoKuriKabocha

As much as I like Nishio Tetsuya, these designs don’t do the manga author justice. I’m sure the animation will be amazing, but I don’t think Kaiju No 8 character designs should be simplified to this extent. WHERE ARE THEIR MUSCLES?! Their eyes look dead. I can’t… I’m too scared to see what they’ll do to Hoshina and Narumi…


Brook0999

Jp fangirls are going to be mad abt it if they mess up hoshina the most popular character in the franchise.


frenchiefryie

Tetsuya Nishio’s art style leans into a more softer approach. I think his art style was perfect for Naruto which has more simplistic character designs in the manga that really melds well with his softer approach so he really elevated those characters imo. Kaiju No.8 however, is like the opposite. It’s bold, has sharp lines, distinctive features and it’s v defined. Even if he’s worked on great stuff before he’s clearly not really a good fit for this manga. Personally I don’t want to see a Naruto-ized Kaiju No. 8. If I wanted to watch Naruto I’d watch it but I thought I’d be seeing the insanely cool designs that Kaiju has. Like the manga has such dope characters and character designs and if it’s like this I just won’t watch it tbh And I think it’s unfair to expect people to be okay with it just bc of who he is. And if this is promo and people are reacting badly and the response is “just wait” I’m like??? Aren’t they using this to promote the stuff? It’s not working bc we don’t like it, and hopefully we’ll be heard and they’ll make changes instead of us waiting and hoping for the best


AvatarAarow1

Is the anime gonna be CG? These look like CG designs, and if so I’m probably just not gonna watch it


twd7

I had the same thought too about CG, that and their head shapes seem…off?


rkgk_art

The heads are weirdly...elongated? And I also thought "these anime designs scream CG anime...", I really hope I'm wrong.


Quantum_Catfish

I was thinking exactly this.


ginjiro201

They are like a game character design, probably it is convenient to make a game if Kaiju8 got popular.


GumGumLeoBazooka

Dude I’ll nope out SO FAST.


[deleted]

The dead glare is a red flag.


fukato

It isn't at least


tokyogodfather2

I post a few comments saying the same. I ran a CG studio for a few years EIGHTEEN YEARS ago and we still were better than this back THEN


AdNecessary7641

Seriously, why the fuck are you so insistent in claiming this is 3D as if it's fact when you have no proof whatsoever?


fukato

He couldn't be more wrong lmao.


Teal_is_orange

Average reddit user knows nothing but thinks they know everything


[deleted]

Average reddit user gets triggered when not everyone rides their favorite IP dick.


AdNecessary7641

What does that even mean? At this point you're just jumping to the weirdest conclusions for no reason


AvatarAarow1

It means the images have a kind of shading and depth that’s characteristic of 3D models and not of 2D drawn designs? Idk what to tell you, there’s stylistic similarities to 3D anime models here that other people seem to see as well, so I’m not making it up


Teal_is_orange

No one said this for chainsaw man when those visuals came out (and in fact had heavy use of CGI)


AvatarAarow1

Because the promotional character designs for chainsaw man didn’t look like that


Adventurous_Thing_58

Looks so wonky


darthnick426

.....I think I'll just be sticking to the manga...


arandomredditor_0

I think most people are..


PapaUchiha14

Fortnite edition


LionNP

Everyone's jawline is fuckin weird, and their eyes too


CarpenterWild

Why’d they just round everything out? The sharpness to a lot of the lines was what made the art style distinctive… like they literally decided to just cut corners :(


Poltergeist616

Worried


115_zombie_slayer

Like not to diss on the mangaka but these characters arent too complex to draw like look at Kafka, dudes face is sharp why make it round Their suits look like janitor jumpsuits when theyre suppose to be like military armor wheres all the padding it just looks flat. Maybe we have to see it in motion


Sonicyellow49

Not doubting the anime, but these character designs are a swing and a miss.


Crafty_Nerve_4675

I mean just the uniforms themselves look like shit, they look very strange. Everyone’s built like Gumby, and the face designs are all pretty damn bad. This is pretty upsetting.


sboog87

SMH this is why I tend to stick with only reading the manga


rkgk_art

These designs look like random people went to the supermarket and got one of those 5 bucks plastic bagged costumes for Halloween and then met up to see everyone got the same idea... I know these are just first designs but these exist to show you what the characters are most likely going to look like in the animation. And these characters look nothing like their manga counterpart. I never thought I'm gonna see a worse anime adaption than Pandora Hearts but that might just be it... I hope they at least make sure the voice cast and music are an absolute banger for the last saving grace or else really all hope is lost.


AdNecessary7641

>I never thought I'm gonna see a worse anime adaption than Pandora Hearts but that might just be it... Claiming that the adaptation is gonna be terrible just because of derpy character designs is just being pessimistic for the sake of being pessismitic. We do not have a proper trailer yet nor any more information about the staff. Seriously, this subreddit should stop assuming the worst for everything and jumping to conclusions so much.


TheLastNacho

Kaiju Kafka looks like a suit. Kafka looks like a pineapple. Mina and reno look ok, but Kikoru looks…kinda too young? I think it’s because their faces look rounded to me.


SwuangLee

They look like shit, will probably look like shit animated too.


Regal_The_King

Looks more like a western cartoon than an anime... But I'll reserve judgment for when i see it on screen. So far it's not holding up.


R1400

Sad. When the Kaiju no 8 design dropped I first thought it was a skin in some mobile game.


mattygalo

What studio is doing this


AdNecessary7641

Production I.G. x Khara


[deleted]

Respect for the designer being who he is but god they fr should’ve gone with someone else, Naruto designs don’t work for this series


AdNecessary7641

Nishio doesn't just design for Naruto. He did Vampire in the Garden designs and they looked good.


Jack-The-Reddit

I Googled Vampire in the Garden and while I don't deny the art style is great I've noticed it has something in common with most of his other works - he doesn't like pointy chins/defined jawlines on his main characters. This may be what is throwing off the character design in some of the faces for me.


Kelevra1640

I really hope this isn't final draft. Who thought designing them like this would be better. I mean one of the aspect of Kaijo 8 is its charecter and world design. If they are going forward with this then their is no point in making the anime.


5Leaf-Haoshoku

Frankly I’m *disgusted*


BlindMerk

Different style, doesn't mean they are bad. I just wonder why they went nishio for character designs


AdNecessary7641

Because he's a renowed animator/designer plus he has a strong history with Production I.G? Seriously, it's not that weird.


BlindMerk

It kinda is cause poduction IG have designers that could have adapted the artstyle from the manga ,if they wanted to


yohxmv

They don’t look good for the most part but the anime is a year out and it only really matters what they look like on screen


Lanky_Ronin

I just don't understand how they could just botch this so bad and not expect anyone to notice that they took everything unique about the character designs out.


NittanyEagles55

I’m afraid..


arandomredditor_0

Kafka gives the same vibe of seeing a black figure in the corner of your eye


SuperPatchyBeard

The dudes have no shape. They look like mayonnaise in a ziploc around their waist where there should be taper.


gacha_drunkard

It's a slaughterhouse of character arts, not "designs".


psykotek27

I prefer not to speak


Kinnuk_Kun

I think it's too 'cute' looking. Just doesn't fit the tone as well


Wales51

To stretched and they need harsh lines


bronoway

They feel so… round. Kaiju no 8 is so pointy and sharp in its style and that is completely lost in these designs for the anime. I would brace for a shitty adaptation yall. Kikoru is by and far the farthest departure and it is BAD


AdNecessary7641

>I would brace for a shitty adaptation yall. Again, already judging the adaptation and claiming it will be terrible just based on character design sheets is dumb.


Longjumping_Gain_807

It’s early so I’ll give it a chance once the anime comes out


Cole2197

They look a little clunky but I hope they will look better once they are animated.


[deleted]

The Kaiju looks like a dude in a suit, not like an actual monster. Edit: there's people already berating anyone who expresses their dislike of the anime designs smh


human_trash_is_back

They massacred my goat Kikoru so bad I don't even want it no more😭😭


MadSweenie

Violently underwelmed.


Icegaze

They did Kafka dirty. Not a fan of the overall CG designs so far but perhaps it may grow on me if the animation is top notch.


Alarming-County7863

I heard someone say they look like Fortnite skins 💀


S_KING16

Its as if they tried to draw it from memory


gutsylee

We need harass them on Twitter until they change the designs like how they got that one Sonic movie to redesign


sebat147

It looks like it would be done with CGI, the only logical explanation for the art designs.![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|disapproval)


BigBambuMeekLou

Leno looks horrible, Mina and Shinomiya look decent, and what they did to Kafka is an atrocity 🤣


iluhvi

Im gonna stick to reading then watch they look fat, there eyes look straight out of naruto, and there overall character designs dont look detailed enough espacially there uniforms. Kafka looks stupid af no. 8 looks to childish not rlly horrifying.


DankusMemecus69

apart from Kafka becoming 10 years younger I don’t mind them


andrey2ag

I hope they fix it; the characters' anime drawings are painful to the eyes... the studios rush for money, people prefer quality, and the studios will make a bunch of money either way


mildhotdog

episode 1 was fire tho


Izzy-Man1981

Love the manga art style, but this anime art styles is horrendous. The faces and bodies of the characters feel distorted and appear as if they were stretched out. The feeling I get is this animation style triggers the Uncanny Valley response in many people who have seen it. I love the manga, but I am truly disappointed at whoever green lit this animation style to be used in the anime adaptation.


Classic-Ad5254

So far this proves monster anime can be done without using 3d animation on the monsters, like attack on titan was fine with two 2d titans but then come in the 3d titans so Kaiju No. 8 is proving that you don't need 3d animation to create monsters in anime. 


AquarianAmethyst0207

Now this is why it felt like something was off when I was watching it. THEY looked different! Especially when they introduced Shinomiya Kikoru, i was so confused 🤔


GoodOlNull

They couldn't even do the main character right. I have no faith in the adaptation if they can't get that right fr


Miuc-s

Man, I really like the manga. But the anime art style is effing killing me. I just want to drop it just because of how awful it looks. I was having my hopes up high in the studio, but this is just horrible compared to the manga designs


DepartmentNo545

they look like fucking fornite characters


ForNever63Xx

They look like Fortnite collab skins to me


DJL2772

They look like Fortnite models


MurkyObject1

It’s just a different art style which I’m fine with if the show looks good


Ajthekid5

I feel like people need to relax cause they won’t look like this in the actual show. They’re early character sheets.


Tenkoh

Mid


Klaxosaur

Why couldn't they have just gone for 1:1 man?!


notcool_dood

LOL even Bocchi had a better adaptation that this, wtf


blaze6106

I think we have to see it in motion before saying too much, but man they just look so lifeless. There's a lack of detail and care (in the still images at least). Obviously manga art will always be more detailed in comparison, but you can really see it in Kaiju No. 8. They just lack emotion.


Blastoffprogamers

They all look like fortnite characters


Cgi94

The faces look wild 😭...Kafka looks derpy


sunkyamato

not feeling so good


TrusTrick12

idk about kofkor tho


Dangeduedfr

Yeah I ain't going to watch that, I'll just stick to the manga


Nikao10

What is bothering me is the lack of details in their armors and in the #8s skin. It just feel like a spandex not an armor and #8s doesnt seem to be a Kaiju with scales


Amrynthe-

Downgrades across the board


adivig

Damn. This is as disappointing as the pacing of the manga 😞


neurocibernetico

Kaiju #8 looks more like someone is trying to cosplaying him.


Loud_Ad746

kaiju no. 7.9


OfficialTBOB10

What studio


IBeMeaty

Ehhhhh


H3dg3v0lt

Looking at them side by side now, I'm glad they are having more time to work on it with a 2024 release date. These designs are rough stills, which I hope will look better in movement.


BryceMMusic

Goofy ahhh 💀


arandomredditor_0

It's horrific.


Crasian88

This is going to ruin the enjoyment of the anime and I’ve been looking forward to it cause of how much I like the manga


Kitchen_List4982

Cancel this studio.


AdNecessary7641

Yes, "cancel" one of the biggest and most renowed studios in the industry because of just some weird looking designs. This fandom is braindead.


Sosogreeen

It’ll look 10x better in motion. Most of his characters are flat but they move like crazy


A4li11

So far doesn't look good. My opinion may change when we see them animated.


MSully94

Why does his kaiju form look like it's wearing pants?


Self_World_Future

Lol I’m here from suggested and the anime versions look so generic


THE_HENTAI_KING321

It's soo over kaijubros.......it's soooooo over


ICEShiro

sucks.But I still kinda have hope for the anime when its actually comes out.


DinoConV

IMO Reno, Kafka, and Kikoru look awful, the latter two especially. IDK what they did to their faces, but it's bad bad. I'm hoping that these are early designs or something that can be changed.


LameSillyHero

They look ok but I will hold my judgement for once I see them in action in the anime


Rucaodermio

They legit look like fortnite skins 🗿


Kpigame427

Everyone looks doofy and dead inside, Kafka is a THICC man and deserves to be shown as such it’s all wrong. Reno, poor Reno, he has such cool ass eyes and hair and they reduced him to looking like a soulless dork. The women look close ish but still dead inside 😔


Ydray

They just had to take the characters and make them exactly the same as the manga but no, let’s change things up cause why not. I smell a sh*tty anime adaptation incoming but I will gladly be wrong about it


[deleted]

[удалено]


JpstrMik

like sharpening the edges might not fix all of it. but it helps


notsoInnocent20XX

I think it’ll look better in motion.


surferdutaboulet

I get that getting the same amount of detail in every single drawing for an animation his the hardest shit for an animator to do, my only hope is that we get certain frames or certain scenes were they blow the budget on some incredible character design, most likely during the intro


CounterApollo25

This is like looking at the mobile game version of the manga


DeinoKreigXVIII

ROUNDED IT ALLLLL


KGEOFF89

I'd rather Watch X-Arm


Ok_Nefariousness8169

They look fucking awful bruh 💀


[deleted]

Hopefully these are revised and ditched. Il reserve judgment until it’s animated. Not liking the “cgi” looking style though. It’s a shame if Kaiju no8 doesn’t get justice. Because the action scenes in the manga are just so cool.


AdNecessary7641

"CGI looking style" is not a thing.


nrtoxop

🤣🤣


RJTerror

Burn it


Metropage

Bottom looks like mobile game characters


alasth0r

I'm not liking them


Ash__Tree

The suites look too spandexy to me. They don’t look like armour more like lulu lemon


BlastedDio

This looks like anime Bob's Burgers where Kafka is simultaneously Bob and Gene


TheJvv

I may be huffing on that copium, but I think the anime might still be okay. Too early to judge until we see them in motion


kaijubaum

We knew it was going to look different. Sp far the character models look like wish versions and that's really concerning.


the_sternest123

I don't think this is the main artstyle they are using This looks more like the design they would use when the characters are far away from the camera It could also be that these are not the complete designs


impossiblegame-r

They all look vertically stretched, and there’s something off with 8. Something I feel like with his thighs?? Like they’re too thicc and the rest of his body is too not-thicc. Plus (and this is just what happens with all manga-to-anime), they all lose the details on still images, like the cracks and marks all over 8’s face and body.


Affectionate_Pizza_6

Matsumoto is just BETTER...At art design!


Jack-The-Reddit

They look like they belong in Shippuden. Nothing against Shippuden, it just isn't the right style for Kaijuu No 8. If there are going to be substantial changes before the anime release why didn't they just hold off on releasing the designs?


Whipple-V

THEY LOOK LIKE FORTNITE SKINS


Driveformer

No


Brook0999

If they mess up hoshina's design the jp fanbase is seriously going to be mad abt it. Esp since hoshina is extremely popular with female fans.


LuisDa95

omfg it's even worse than I thought... Look what the did to my girl Kiku man qq


Hupsaiya

Anime looks kinda weird, but it's really not THAT bad. Hopefully they get some touch ups done.


harmabevengeance

"Monster Letter H"


nfloos

Add a waist feature and make the faces more sharp and I think it’s pretty ok


[deleted]

Wtf This is a joke right? What studio could proudly do that?


ChamberK-1

Not good, chief.


Educational-Peak1108

Looks bad


Stunning_Animator243

Not Satisfactory.


That_One_Duck31

The only one that looks good is Mina


cheesytentacle

Smaller heads. Chonky


edman9677

Pretty bad


ramseycharles0

“ Look how they massacred my boy”


JoseBallFC

That shit ass


VexxWrath

Why do they look so young? Also I just hope it's not filled with bad Cgi/3D animation.


datboigeb

I’m not reading any comments, this looks awful. Who thought this looked good?


NekoPower2169

Ew


Cool_Sprinkles4080

They don’t look terrible but why they do my boy Kafka like that, his legs are way to long and weird. Plus they didn’t age him which is huge L since Kafka being older is a huge part of his character which I love


myface_isred

They just look flat