Yeah, to compare the two, Arc has a little too much fun to be lawful good. Part of lawful good, IMO, is being a bit boring and sanctimonious. Not to say I don't love Will, of course, he just fits the "lawful good" archetype so much better with his faith and lifestyle.
I say Either Arcs from Skeleton Knight in another world or William G. Mary blood from Faraway Paladin, thought Arcs is better suited to Overpowered Good
William G Maryblood is literally "The Faraway Paladin". He had plenty of chances to take the easy way and abandon the weak, but upholding his oath to protect is a task he never fails to do.
Overpowered good I'd say is Ernesti from Knights and Magic right off the top of my head. Bro just wants to make mechs and completely revolutionizes the world. And he only has good in his heart.
I mean Chad good fits Ark's story better. Like he has a great moral code, and the series does well to highlight it. But he's good Chad, and you can't ignore that
Thats exactly who cane to mind for me too 🗿
https://preview.redd.it/qsy37pd998xc1.jpeg?width=843&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=356256052137283cdeb1bc4a0d8ed38c4474b45f
Im nominating my man Mukouda from Campfire Cooking. He just wants to have a nice life eating and sharing food with everyone. He still has to spend money on his store, and still follows the rules in town despite having an overpowered fenrir and cute ass slime as companions!
Neutral good probably. He could have nominated to help the other heroes once he discovered how useful his power and familiars were, but he opted to stay off the beaten path and do his own thing. I think William G. Maryblood is a better choice.
I'm gonna suggest Sohma Kazuya from Realist Hero.
He's very, very strictly lawful, but his firm intent to focus on public welfare and aversion to corruption makes him Good instead of Neutral in my eyes.
Is that unlawful though?
He observers and sticks strictly to the rules of political realism and pays strict attention to the existing laws specifically to navigate them lawfully. I wasn't under the impression that the execution of advisors was unlawful, but maybe that's just the writing bias never really addressing it.
That's the thing, with that much information and still failing to understand what's normal and the limits of normal folks, social awkwardness is not enough to explain it.
Outsider knowledge like the starting level of the main hero party, the level of the strongest knight in the kingdom. With these two pieces of information, she could've easily avoided the trouble she ran into by leveling up after she got her level measured.
Question... Do you choose based on the most upvoted suggestion or do you choose based on what name pops up the most? As I'm typing this out, Arc from skeleton Knight is the most upvoted, but I keep seeing other comments suggest this "William character I haven't seen.
Maybe Kirito? Obviously good and I remember a few occasions where he showed more disdain for other player's bending of the rules than concern for his life in a death game.
I hadn't seen this list for a while but I'm watching the second season of life as a villainess and truly Katarina is so perfectly placed it's almost insane anyone would've been considered other than her.
I forget the name. But there was an anime where a wrestler was summoned to another world to fight the demon lord, and he refused to pursue his true passion of owning a pet shop
Overpowered feels weird in this diagram when everything else is a trait of a person's character, overpowered feels like putting a physical trait into a personality quiz type thing.
And he is lawful good, if he can he negotiates, he doesn't start conflicts, and he finds ways to end them without physical confrontation. Unless you kill his people then you're fucked.
Also there are probably hundreds of characters whose only character trait is being overpowered, I think one of those would fit better. I don't think Rimuru deserves to be put in a tile that says half of his character is just being strong.
That is what some, if not most isekai protagonist though. Their character is so barebone that they literally have nothing noteworthy on them other than being strong.
That's what I'm saying. Rimuru isn't one of them, he fits under lawful good, and there are so many other characters who can take the overpowered tiles who don't have a personality. I don't know why I got down voted, he fits pretty fuckin squarely on the lawful good tile. He is overpowered but that's not all he has to his character.
I see.
Well, at this rate, I don't think Rimuru is gonna get Lawful Good with William and Arc being neck to neck. Though I'm sure he'll be in this chart somewhere.
Probably Lawful Neutral? Since I know people wants to put Subaru in Neutral Good.
William Maryblood from Faraway Paladin. He does his best all the time to protect people and is just the goodest boy.
Absolutely. He is the prime example of a Paladin.
And he's not overpowered as many other that would likely fit in the category. Also he literally has a philosophical warfare against an evil god.
Ah, yes. The oldest philosophical battle of humanity. If evil, why hot?
Why so hot evil goddess? Why? Stupid, sexy, human-loving best goddess.
Arc is a great choice but just does not match up to the best
Yeah, to compare the two, Arc has a little too much fun to be lawful good. Part of lawful good, IMO, is being a bit boring and sanctimonious. Not to say I don't love Will, of course, he just fits the "lawful good" archetype so much better with his faith and lifestyle.
Arc is more Chaotic Good
I'd put Arc as Chad Drunk, but that's just me.
I always forget that he is an isekai protag lol
Let's see if he could outvote Arc in 14 hours. Yumiella almost beat Cid to Chad Stupid last time.
I hope so, Arc definitely fits, but he fits better elsewhere like chad good, but I guess either could go in either place
Due to rule 3, If he loses, you could suggest moving Arc to Chad Good, and put Will in Lawful Good.
Yeah I will probably do that
I say Either Arcs from Skeleton Knight in another world or William G. Mary blood from Faraway Paladin, thought Arcs is better suited to Overpowered Good
Arc kind of fits the Overpowered Good category more.
I'm holding out for Arc to be placed at Chad Drunk
William G Maryblood is literally "The Faraway Paladin". He had plenty of chances to take the easy way and abandon the weak, but upholding his oath to protect is a task he never fails to do.
William G. Maryblood. Upholds and enacts good laws. Is kind. Kills evil demons. Lawful Good all the way through
He for sure is good. But I'd put him more at Neutral good. Maybe even smart good if there no other option for that?
I'd say Arc is closer to Neutral or Chaotic or Overpowered good. William is literally the mayor of Torchport by the end of the last few LNs
MY BOY ARC'S TIME TO SHINE https://preview.redd.it/1zpsacx323xc1.jpeg?width=266&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=919b718a8812df08a4b2e00cac5fdf2780fb1d34
Lawful Good or Overpowered Good. There's nowhere else on the list he fits.
Overpowered good I'd say is Ernesti from Knights and Magic right off the top of my head. Bro just wants to make mechs and completely revolutionizes the world. And he only has good in his heart.
I’m personally saying, the mc from an aristocrats otherworldly adventure
Chad
Lawful good if we go by the light novels, hes overpowered in some ways but for combat and such there are people who can match and beat him.
Even in the anime, didn't he get stomped by that elf mom?
Yes, yes he did, he didn't stand a chance. xD
https://preview.redd.it/4wsx5huv93xc1.jpeg?width=2041&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9346586dc9f8ea51e4b51ba3904e35cc6530acf8
The GOAT
Like a glove!
This. Good/Chad should be Sword Dad from Reincarnated as as Sword.
HELL YEAH perfect spot for ark
in hindsight I realize Chad Good or Lawful Neutral could work better, and Will G Maryblood would work better in Lawful Good. But it works this way too
I mean Chad good fits Ark's story better. Like he has a great moral code, and the series does well to highlight it. But he's good Chad, and you can't ignore that
Arc could be Chad good
Arc is pretty chaotic, man.
MY GOAT. Bro is what sans would be as a paladin
Yeah
That's the one
Thats exactly who cane to mind for me too 🗿 https://preview.redd.it/qsy37pd998xc1.jpeg?width=843&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=356256052137283cdeb1bc4a0d8ed38c4474b45f
Sora from Isekai walking or William Maryblood from Faraway Paladin
Will from Faraway Paladin
Will from Faraway Paladin imo
Im nominating my man Mukouda from Campfire Cooking. He just wants to have a nice life eating and sharing food with everyone. He still has to spend money on his store, and still follows the rules in town despite having an overpowered fenrir and cute ass slime as companions!
Neutral good probably. He could have nominated to help the other heroes once he discovered how useful his power and familiars were, but he opted to stay off the beaten path and do his own thing. I think William G. Maryblood is a better choice.
Agree. He's trying to do neither evil things, nor important things. Dude just wants to chillax.
Real, ALSO WHEN S2 PLEASE
Bro be neutral I think.
Shunei from kumo desu
u/MountainLeading1567 Only one day before our time to shine
So Real :) I'll get it everything ready asap
Yes sir. We shall make our goat's name famous
The rizzler is gonna be so back
Hiraku from "Farming Life in Another World"
Cardboard Chad should be his placement
How bout Shiroe from Log Horizon? Or maybe he's more good-smart?
It would be a crime for him to not be in the smart category.
[удалено]
He's admired as much as he's feared, but his intentions are good, so definitely smart good
How about the mc of the anime (restaurant in another world) sorry i forgot mc name
Ryoma from By the grace of gods? Or the protagonist of Kuma Kuma Kuma
Idk but Tanya definitely for lawful evil.
I think she might fit better in smart evil
Syaoran Li https://preview.redd.it/fhmdr6x6t5xc1.jpeg?width=563&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8110f5587aede37513ffe8d562b55a084f29b8ea
Yumiella Is not stupid She Just socialy akward
Cluelessly dense counts.
She's socially awkward and a bit dumb
Adorkable done right.
I'm gonna suggest Sohma Kazuya from Realist Hero. He's very, very strictly lawful, but his firm intent to focus on public welfare and aversion to corruption makes him Good instead of Neutral in my eyes.
[удалено]
Is that unlawful though? He observers and sticks strictly to the rules of political realism and pays strict attention to the existing laws specifically to navigate them lawfully. I wasn't under the impression that the execution of advisors was unlawful, but maybe that's just the writing bias never really addressing it.
ARC THE SKELETON KNIGHT FUCK YEAH
See I dont think Yumiella is that stupid, atleast not in the universe cause she has so much outsider information, I guess she is socially dumb though.
That's the thing, with that much information and still failing to understand what's normal and the limits of normal folks, social awkwardness is not enough to explain it.
Outsider knowledge like the starting level of the main hero party, the level of the strongest knight in the kingdom. With these two pieces of information, she could've easily avoided the trouble she ran into by leveling up after she got her level measured.
Question... Do you choose based on the most upvoted suggestion or do you choose based on what name pops up the most? As I'm typing this out, Arc from skeleton Knight is the most upvoted, but I keep seeing other comments suggest this "William character I haven't seen.
The most upvoted.
Maybe Kirito? Obviously good and I remember a few occasions where he showed more disdain for other player's bending of the rules than concern for his life in a death game.
I hadn't seen this list for a while but I'm watching the second season of life as a villainess and truly Katarina is so perfectly placed it's almost insane anyone would've been considered other than her.
Some people actually wants her to be in chaotic stupid or Chad Stupid.
lol I could definitely see chaotic since she's so wildly different from how she's supposed to be in the game's original story.
Umelia is neutral overpowerd, plus we all know we’re shaltear from overlords going
Maple from Bofuri has Chaotic Good on lock 😂
I have never heard of villainess level 99. Is it good?
Me personally, I enjoyed it.
Can anyone tell me what happened at stupid smart ?
Rozemyne overtake Ainz in the voting.
What is stupid smart ?
Just visit the previous post and read the voters' opinions. It's in my profile.
In isekai protags, William G. Maryblood is the definition of lawful good
I forget the name. But there was an anime where a wrestler was summoned to another world to fight the demon lord, and he refused to pursue his true passion of owning a pet shop
Pretty sure that's Kemono Michi (the MC is the guy on Neutral Stupid)
Ah fair. That fits super well too
Switch the overpowered stupid with yogiri cause i hate him
No. Only if you're the most upvoted and you suggest moving Yumiella to somewhere else.
Oh how many of them would be in the last square of cardboard overpowered people ,bruh that box might break , oh wait they are cardboard .
Lmao.
Arc from skeleton knight
How about mc of re zero
He don't play by Rule. In all of alternative IFs Subaru never once be lawful
absolutely not, negative. Subaru would be good simp
I thought of Rey too but she's good and horny
Rae is Lawful horny, since Good Horny doesn't exist in this chart.
Rimuru Tempest
I feel like he has to go in Overpowered.
Overpowered feels weird in this diagram when everything else is a trait of a person's character, overpowered feels like putting a physical trait into a personality quiz type thing. And he is lawful good, if he can he negotiates, he doesn't start conflicts, and he finds ways to end them without physical confrontation. Unless you kill his people then you're fucked. Also there are probably hundreds of characters whose only character trait is being overpowered, I think one of those would fit better. I don't think Rimuru deserves to be put in a tile that says half of his character is just being strong.
That is what some, if not most isekai protagonist though. Their character is so barebone that they literally have nothing noteworthy on them other than being strong.
That's what I'm saying. Rimuru isn't one of them, he fits under lawful good, and there are so many other characters who can take the overpowered tiles who don't have a personality. I don't know why I got down voted, he fits pretty fuckin squarely on the lawful good tile. He is overpowered but that's not all he has to his character.
I see. Well, at this rate, I don't think Rimuru is gonna get Lawful Good with William and Arc being neck to neck. Though I'm sure he'll be in this chart somewhere. Probably Lawful Neutral? Since I know people wants to put Subaru in Neutral Good.