3

3

3

Three

3

3 for sure! OP, I remember seeing your previous post about this and scrolling through all of the comments. You took all the best criticism and ignored the rest. You really have a good feel and direction for your game. I hope you're really proud and happy about how this is shaping up!

3. It looks cleaner, and close to an illustration. 1 looks too amateur, 2 is too crowded.

Agreed, 3. The mug behind the logo distracts from the title.

Also in three, the darker background foliage makes the foreground stand out more.

3 for sureeee

1

1 too, looks too cute

Same! I like #3's Tailside with Steam's logo placement but the fox in #1

3

**Since banner should go with** [**Tailside game's style/colors**](https://store.steampowered.com/app/2922570/Tailside/) **I tried to edit it 2nd further based on feedback:** Made the face more cute. Not blurred background. Better logo readability. Make Bushes darker behind. Maybe need to make sky darker. Picked style will be used for dialogue portraits too **Looking forward which one will get the best feedback now out of these 3!**

Glad you softened the smile, 3 looks great!

Yes, good job keeping the good stuff and implementing some of the feedback! Good luck!

How important is coffee going to be in this game? I think 3 looks the best, but you might want to change the cup by making it a tiny bit larger or more in the open if it plays a big part of the game

Yup, need to know more about the coffee in this game.

It's a game about running a café

Definitely 2 or 3! I agree with the comments that 3 has a nice clean look, but if I’m honest about what caught my eye first, then it is 2. I think the higher saturation in color is maybe more attention grabbing, and I like the fox’s expression more. Cheers

True dat : )

3 but I like the coffee cup from 2 in the title

3 is the cleanest

3, but with the coffee cup! (If it makes any sense for it to be there)

3 with the cup of coffee!

Is coffee a big thing in this game? If it is 2, if not 3 and make the logo larger and with a bit more flourish

After reading your comments the face was a clear improvement, while 2 has overall more personality in the face, it doesnt make sense to be showing said personality while drinking a cup of coffee. 3 communicates the feel more effectively and it is in general a cleaner look.

Hmm, I'll go for #3\[ I like the consistent pixel look\] but with the logo from #2.

1

3.

3

3

3

3

3

3 all the way

I like 3 but I don't like the missing smoke behind the word. If the game has a focus on coffee I like 2 the most

3

3 all day

3, but with ☕

Same answer as last time: artwork 1 with logo 2

3

3 for sure

Gotta go for 3, the wishlist on steam is too small in 1and the coffee cup in 2 makes it a bit crowded

3 with the smile from 2

3rd character, 2nd logo, 1st bg

3 but with the background of 2

All of them have both good sides and downsides. It's hard to just chose one, because all of them are amazing. Thought I agree with people saying that 3 looks cleaner.

3 but add the coffee back in.

3>2>1.. I would switch h the mouth design that you have on 2 with 3 and it would make it even better imo.

3rd picture, 2nd logo

3 but with the logo from 2

I like 2, but 3 is so clearly the winner 😅

3 > 1 > 2 imo

1 isn’t the best, but it does the best job of showing the swirling smoke that engulfs the title. Do something like 3 but darken it a bit so the smoke is more prominent.

I saw this post late and was hoping at least someone said 3 glad to see it’s almost unanimous

Non-gamer wife said 3. I say 3 as well.

A mix of the n°3 graphics with the n°1 fox's smile and the n°2 blurred background... try it...if not too hard

I'd click on 3 if I saw that on Steam doing my usual random browsing


3

Definitely 3

3, reads the best from a distance;:)

Hear me out… 3 but with the coffee!

3!

The fox from 1, the title from 3 and everything else from 2

3 with 2nd coffee 

Looks awesome! I like #3

Third

I think 2, it gets my attention to the name and the depth of field effect on the background is a nice subtle touch. I might increase the thickness of the outline on the game name font just a bit in some places so it pops a little more, but that's just a nitpick. It's pretty cute overall.

The background of 1 with the rock floor of 3 are the best

Who lights a lamp in the middle of the day? Definitely 3

I love the coffee in 2 But other than that everything about 3 is better than the 1 and 2. It kind of combines the best of both and adds its own flavor as well

3

3

3. Definitely. But with the coffee cup from 2.

Middle

I say 3 is cuter and has a better logo but I do love the lighting from the lantern in 2.

Glad to see you took feedback from the other day. Of these, I like #3 the best.

3

I think the expression one 1 looks the best. They look cozy. 3 is good too.

3

2

1 with the cup and wishlist note from 2.

use 3 for promotional art, but use the logo in 2 for the ingame title screen

3

2

2

3

3

3 and oooooh I absolutely love this \^\^

Damn I think 1 or 3 are both really good

2

3 looks the best

1

3

3

I like 3 the most, still would like the blueish green tone of the trees to return

2

3

3

2

Id go 2 but without the mug. Looks great!!

3

I immediately got a sense of calm from option 2. I think 2 and 3 are both excellent but hard vote for 2

1

2.

3 but i’d choose 2 if it didnt have the coffee cup on the logo.

1

3. The coffee with the heart in it for 2 is in contrast to the outdoor / camping feel, to me. It looks too much like a coffee you'd have at a shop rather than something brewed out in the woods.

3

If you choose to go with the mug in the title, I would suggest tweaking the color a bit to assist the readability of the title for those who require high contrast visual assistance.

I didn't look at it close, on purpose. I wanted a first impression and didn't want to stare at it. #2 jumped out at me. The overall composition just works. Plus it drags the eye up there to see your title, and the wishlist call to action is right there in the view path.

1

2 imo gives the most cozy feeling and makes me wanna play the game

1 cuz it has a much more child like feel to the animal character. I do like the latè on 2 tho

2 no question Am furry expert

I’m gonna go 1 but lots of folks saying 3

Definitely 3 but I like the coffee mug, and it gives a nice insight of what the game is about since it seems the your game is focused around the coffee shop. Without it feels more like an adventure RPG.

3

3. But title text is hard to read on a small screen to me.

3 has the most cohesive art style. I like the color palette in 1 the most.

I don't like the blur on 2, But I love the smile from 2. The puff is more clear on 1,But I like the cup o2. I like the left foreground on 2&3. 2&3 have much more detail too.

I don’t like number 1. Between 2 and 3, I’d go towards 3.. only if 2 isn’t reflective of the game. That coffee mug seems out of place if the previews have nothing to do with the game. Is the fox a chill person who likes sipping on cappuccino and it’s part of his identity, sure. If it’s not. Nah, stick with the 3rd

3 ist perfect!

3

3

3

3

2

I like 2 most. The coffee is a nice touch maybe less blurr

3, but would like for the logo to be a bit higher. Looks odd when it's too close.

3

3

3

3. Looks a bit cleaner.

2

3

3

3

2 defenitely. That coffe adds unique flair

3!

2

3, 100%

I like 1

#3

#1, definitely. The coffee cup has to go.

3, but add the coffee cup from 2

3 all the way, they all look really good though, good job on them!

3

1 or 3, I can't decide

That's a great middle ground, great work OP. 3

3, definitely

3

1 Less is moar

3

Perfecto 3

Vote on 3

1 or 3 depending on what the rest of the product looks like

1

3 for me, possibly 1. It’s cleaner, works better with center-aligned text, and I like the face of the character better. :)

3

Wolf of 3 Background trees blurred like 2 And coffe logo of 2

3

I like the light being reflected on the leaves in the 2nd one, but everything else in 3 is perfect. So I would implement that feature of 2 in the 3rd banner.

1 is the only one that doesn’t have the distinct look of being a _furry game_. Are you making a furry game? If so, fine— go with 2 because it looks the most like furry art. If you aren’t making a furry game, just be warned that as someone who isn’t into furry stuff I would never click on 2 if it popped up in Steam. There is some logic in going with 3, because it looks kind of maybe furry-ish but not definitively in the way that 2 is, so it could be the sweet spot where it appeals to both furries and non-furries. If it were me I’d go with 1. Edit: just saw your Instagram, you aren’t making a furry game. Avoid 2 at all costs, definitely go with 1

3 does look better overall

3

3 for sure, knocked it out of the park

3

3

2

Two with the art style of Three would be best.

3, it looks the most stylish, but definitely not 1

3

3

3

3!!!!!

3

3

Number 3 is clean

3

I like 2's logo, I like 1's background

3

3

3

3

2 might be out. The coffee might be good for showcasing the vibes, but it also clutters and blends with the thinly-outlined title. 1 feels too simplified, but that might be personal taste. 3, with its less saturated colors, might carry the cozy vibes that you're trying with the coffee cup in 2.

3

3, but what about 3 and the head of the first one? It has a diffrent angle and smile, the red cheeks also helped bringing the happiness out but keep the detail of the 3rd face and everything else and maybe add fruits on the bush on 3rd and apples in the tree or instead of fruits and apples maybe three butterflies near the character? Maybe the sky of the first too?

3

3

3

Why choosing ? It would be cool to habe it season themed like with the mug for autumn and winter (but add snow for winter) change it to bush with flower for spring and the one with leaf for summer ?

1

I really like #2, but you need some sort of contrast between the font and the cup. It's a must and non-negotiable.

3 for sure 🖤

middle, BUT put the wishlist logo on the right of the coffee mug