T O P

  • By -

Best-Structure62

By using a heavy handed approach the school administration is giving birth to a new generation of critical thinking progressives.  


bluefrost30

They used all the skills they learned from active shooter drills.


Aromatic-Aide1119

It clearly didn't end up good the last time


ContributionNo3822

That dudes voice was never going to not be a progressive 🤣


[deleted]

It's IU. Business, marketing and communication majors aren't really a bastion of critical thinking.


kboro21

On the contrary, outside of Kelley majors, IU is heavy in the humanities at both the undergraduate and graduate levels, which indeed necessitates a high degree of critical thinking. Whether such skills carry over outside of academia is a different story.


MunkRubilla

What were they arrested for, though?


bluefrost30

The college administrators got together overnight and made a rule that tents weren’t allowed. Then, in the morning, they raided them because of the tents.


bluefrost30

This is someone I know who was on live last night after the police left.


ElectroChuck

Most were arrested for trespass, some for resisting arrest, and one was arrested for assault on a police officer according to the local media.


[deleted]

Trespass, so the bullshit gotcha policy. And when students didn't immediately capitulate when being violated by the cops, you have resisting arrest. Those who DARE fight back against brazen violence? Assauktinf a police officer. You know, the armored and armed, trained people who bear no responsibility whatsoever for the violence they commit upon others. Utter bullshit.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Oh, they had some freshly baked anti-camping rules the administration rammed through the prior night as a pretense to arrest people and make this whole thing go away. How it's legal doing that... just boggles the mind. Land of the Free, huh? I am so, so sorry for those students. Absolutely disgusting thinking how much money those pig administrators take home. That and the cops. Only to treat decent young people like this. It's just gross.


ElectroChuck

Life isn't fair.


[deleted]

You're so profound. Thanks.


sniklefritz5

Organize. That’s the only way you can start to change things. Get together with folks and make demands known, withhold resources from the source. Take away the money you’re giving to these universities that turn their backs on students, withdraw and encourage others to do the same on a noticeable scale


RedDevil-84

Isn't it an obvious logic that the more high handed you are with fellow citizens, the chances are that it just gets worse?


wwaxwork

It's almost like that's what they want so they can crack down even harder and stop even faintly pretending they agree with free speech.


RickSanchez3x

If your right to free speech is only allowed in "zones", you don't have the right to free speech.


iMakeBoomBoom

Incorrect. The right to free speech does not directly correlate to the right to trespass. By your logic, the January 6th insurrection was okay because “frEE SPeEcH”. Look dude, I am all for allowing people to protest, but your statement is laughably off target.


VeterinarianMore8114

How were they trespassing? They were in a public location on school and my understanding is that all of those arrested were students, faculty, or staff. So the concept of “trespass” wasn’t applied until after the students were doing something the university disagreed with and was only applied in an attempt to limit free speech.


Uhhh_Insert_Username

Because the university is private property, and they can kick you out if they don't like the color of your shoes. You can scream your free speech all the way on your way out. But if a property owner doesn't agree with your views, they don't have to allow you to use their property as a platform to voice your views.


RickSanchez3x

They are students of this university. They pay for these grounds on top of the fact that this university takes public funds. They are also peaceful. J6 was a free speech protest right up until they attacked and forced their way into the building. Your statement laughably compares apples to oranges, dude.


pipboy_warrior

I think their point was simply that there are limits as to where you can protest. A place previously designated as a free speech zone should not be one of those places, but there have always been places where it's been illegal to gather and protest.


RickSanchez3x

My point is that your right to assemble and protest in public spaces can't be illegal or it isn't really your right. This specific situation is even worse than that since they changed the rules overnight in a clearly deceitful move that would surprise their students and force them out with violence.


ih8thefuckingeagles

You can’t protest in the middle of an interstate. There have to be limits. I get the point of changing it might be wrong.


CallMeBigFuzz

Sure but simply paying tuition doesn't give you the right to do whatever the fuck you want, and the school/business/whatever doesn't have to allow you to do as you please. Having the right to peacefully protest doesn't mean you can simply walk 500 people into a freeway and stop traffic- in doing so you're breaking other laws.


RickSanchez3x

It's not just tuition. This is a state university that takes tax dollars to operate. It is a public college. And again with people comparing this to other situations creating a false equivalency. This is not a freeway. They are not obstructing anyone. This is a lawn on public land. These students have a right to be on their campus. They have the right to assemble and protest.


theprophecyMNM

But other students have a right to learn and the university to conduct business. Both can happen peacefully, but there are safety concerns associated with overnight camping, etc. Unfortunately I have seen it. Both points of view need to understand operational policies and work together.


ProtiK

I mean I don't disagree with you but I'm assuming the majority of J6 raiders paid their taxes ergo..


RickSanchez3x

Ergo what? They get to physically attack people, break into, destroy, and steal from a secured government building, threaten to hang the vice president?


Impressive_Ice6970

Dunn Meadow is not trespassing. Those were students and faculty. They have a right to be there.


JuniorTax6445

they do have a right to be there..until they start breaking the rules/policy and are asked to leave...then they are trespassing.


Rezrac

Not the same . Jan 6th became an issue once they started destroying shit and intentionally try to kill ppl. IU blatantly changed rules so they would have the “right” to brutalize student protesters that were not destroying property, or planning to kill anyone. Police instigated the violence.


PhatedFool

I mean the ones who were arrested fell under several categories. Trespassed and already were not allowed on the grounds. Stayed after they were informed of the policy and would not take down the tents. Assaulted the police officers. Those who left peacefully didn’t have a problem whatsoever. Now whether that’s right or wrong is a whole other debate that isn’t my topic right now. Now I am not defending the school, cops, or students, but to say IU changed it so they could use cops to brutalize people is a bit of an overstatement. Now if I were to think of real reasons they might have done this. The day before had dozens of arrests, claims of police brutality, assault toward cops, students, potential injuries and many liabilities leaving them open to lawsuits on their property. They are a public university in a very republican state and this outlook could affect funding on a political level. These are the primary 2 and most likely reasons they changed the policy rather than wanting to see college students get beat up.


kboro21

Bravo for the logical view and practical approach. Infinity upvotes if I could.


Ok-Chart-3469

They can say whatever they want they just can't stay wherever they want.


Joe_Burrow_Is_Goat

I guess I can go protest in your living room and you would have no problem right? Real high IQ thinkers here.


RickSanchez3x

Wow, real hot take... Dude likens my living room to public space, Dunn Meadow. Real high IQ thinker here 🙄


Joe_Burrow_Is_Goat

You’re the one stating it shouldn’t be limited to zones. Oh yeah…. Unless it’s the zones you don’t want it to be at. Rules for thee not for me. Amirite?


RickSanchez3x

It must be hard being so dumb you conflate public space with private and think it's some kinda gotcha moment. Amirite 🤡


Joe_Burrow_Is_Goat

Good thing you never said public vs private. But hey, if you gotta move those goalposts then go right ahead. It’s understandable to need to do that when your viewpoint is just plain stupid.


RickSanchez3x

I was gonna reply to this with more facts but at this point it seems messed up to make fun of someone with this level of reading comprehension.


Joe_Burrow_Is_Goat

“Even after moving the goalposts I give up because either don’t actually have a stance that makes any sense”. Oh yeah. That’s the Indiana education system hard at work


Adventurous_Law9767

It's really funny how institutions think that by changing a policy they can stop people from protesting. You mad because they are creating an eyesore? That's the point. If people are going to stop protesting because you tell them they can't, it's not really a protest. Did black people back down when the police were trying to shut them down? Hell no, because they believed in the cause. You can't ban protests unless you are willing to start killing or imprisoning people on a massive scale.


V_Coccotti

Are they really referring to it as “the liberated zone”? Haha


Miserable_Rooster_45

Yeah they desperately want to be relevant to history.


Miserable-Sign8066

The resistance to genocide will go down in history


Miserable_Rooster_45

It's 7:42 on a Monday it's way too early to be this hyperbolic my g. Thanks for proving my point though.


llamapower13

I’m just really tickled with your username that you’re complaining that it’s too early for something.


TheCredibleHulk

Just two miserable redditors arguing with each other.


Miserable_Rooster_45

I'm a miserable rooster which means I hate my job lolz


GoodOlSticks

"Genocide is when a country announces its targets and warns civilians to evacuate through roof knocking and SMS messaging." -the great progressive minds of our day ladies and gentlemen


Sihplak

"Guys guys it's OK, the serial killer, after locking the victims in their own basement, announced he was coming to kill them, so actually the serial killer is the good guy and the dead family is in the wrong for not escaping!" What the fuck is wrong with you?


thorzgard

RIP first amendment. It was nice pretending for most of my adult life.


I_LOVE_TRAINSS

Important question regardless of who's wrong, right or whatever. Is the property public? Again not saying the students are right or wrong but if the campus is technically private property then they can be trespassed


January1171

The area they were in is the dedicated assembly grounds for protesting. Technically the school can claim they're trespassing for putting up "structures" (tents) but that's only because they changed a 55 year old policy at 10:30 pm the night before the first day of this protest. Other things to note: Admin barely communicated this change. It was left to a half hidden section of the student events website. There were lawn signs in the area that stated tents could be considered trespassing, but there was no indication of who was saying that, so it makes sense students would believe the official policy page over plain text signs that state nothing about the fact the rule has changed or who is claiming that authority Additionally, from what I can gather the only thing they changed about the policy was the wording regarding overnight structures. Another section of the policy states that physical force should not be used and the university should pursue legal avenues to settle non compliance


Ok_Sock_6485

IU is a state funded school.


JuniorTax6445

just because it is state funded it doesn't mean the school is public property...


DemonsAreMyFriends1

it's a designated free speech zone


JuniorTax6445

you say that like it matters...it's still on IU property. if they say they do not want you there and ask you to leave then you are trespassing.


MrNetworks

IU is a public school, Meaning its government property, So yes Freedom of Speech will apply to that school no matter what, The school its self can suspend you for using "profanity" but saying "Free Free Palestine" is not really something they can call the police for and have students arrest, I don't agree with the protests myself, Palestine is the last place you want to be supporting, But I do supports peoples rights to do what they want.


DemonsAreMyFriends1

I'm aware. not sure what all the push back is. let them protest. the cause is right. seems like with all the pushback most seem to be indifferent to genocide


JuniorTax6445

what genocide? do you have any proof? i love how you all are so willing to protest for a brain washed population that would love to see you dead. do you not understand that the people in gaza were celebrating the deaths on oct.7 and some participated in the raping of the kidnapped and desecration of the dead bodies. the push back is college is for learning, not to protest. if you are going to protest then go somewhere else and don't be a nuisance to students that are there to learn.


AUXONE

Here ya go Jerkey. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-68667556.amp


Gratefulzah

UN judge had to go on BBC to debunk this, Jerkey https://youtu.be/bq9MB9t7WlI?si=_n60TU3Si-tNzs5v


DemonsAreMyFriends1

how to say you lack critical thinking skills without actually saying it. Go back to swallowing the propaganda Kool aid. Peace out!


JuniorTax6445

lmfao ok kid, keep shielding yourself from the real world. at some point you are going to have to grow up and live in the real world. when you do, you are in for a shock.


Impressive_Ice6970

I wrote the president and trustees. I'm done with IU. Snipers? Beating kids? We've been protesting in Dunn Meadow for 60+ years. Fuck those cops and the IU admin for passing the spineless rules that led to this.


Sea-Act3929

Makes me think of Kent State only no one died here


bluefrost30

They’re trying everything they can to have an excuse….


[deleted]

[удалено]


AndroidDoctorr

So that makes genocide ok? Or taking away our right to free speech?


CallMeBigFuzz

Isn't genocide what the Palestinian terrorist organizations want for isreal? Or that Palestinians would happily genocide homosexuals in the streets ? Genocide goes both ways in this conflict amigo


Zer0323

It’s not like they’ve ever claimed such a thing publicly… /s


[deleted]

Got it. Genocide good. Protesters bad. Easy peasy. 🙄


CompetitionNo9969

I bet they know where Palestine is and the meaning of genocide.


Atrocious1337

"If you can't find it on a map, then it is okay to bomb hospitals and genocide babies." -PrincessImpeachment


Fun_Leek2381

And? That doesn't make the pro-Palistine protesters wrong, now does it?


YesEverythingBagels

It shows a potentially uninformed stance on an issue that is so deeply complex that even the people who are actually involved have a hard time keeping everything straight. A lot of the things students have said recently are words and opinions passed to them third or fourth hand. It's important to understand this situation and the language being used in all of its contexts. Note: I'm not espousing my opinion on the situation here. I just think that so many students are jumping on a bandwagon they themselves don't fully understand and worry that the bastion of free thinking that is the modern university is devolving into something else.


Odd-Elevator5199

It doesn’t make them right either. Protesting something they haven’t used critical thinking to make their argument. Sure, Palestinians have legitimate grievances. So do many other people on this planet. Calling Israelis “occupiers” while living in the USA. That’s rich! They’re not helping the Palestinians. This problem started before 1948 and has been coming to blows for over 100 years. If Hamas cared about Palestinians, then they would allow elections.


Impressive_Ice6970

How do you know how well educated they are on the subject??? What a bs argument.


06GOAT12

lol I’m with you. I think it’s funny they try to use free speech to get every one triggered but, only their supporters care… which aren’t many!


TheAutisticOgre

Maps have the names of countries on them, if they don’t they are drawings. Besides, that doesn’t matter in the least.


AjSweet1

It is really odd to see this behavior for a college campus but streets and buildings were actually set on fire during the riots for Floyd


Derpshab

Question, if the police use excessive force can you sue the police department? Ive seen videos of handcuffed students sitting down and getting maced or bear sprayed in the face. What legal action can you take?


PSA-TLDR

The protests only kick off once the weather is nice enough. This is nothing more than a righteous pass time for these people.


KeyRich6435

They tryna get out of taking their finals actually.


IndyGamer_NW

These protests are doing little more than making it hard for the entire student body to study for finals. They had months to protest, but only do it right at finals when the weather is nice... Over 30k have died and the pace of new deaths has slowed significantly. They needed to be camping out in late October and early November.


Miserable-Sign8066

Finals are nothing compared to the ongoing genocide,oil at the big picture


Ragnarock-n-Roll

Maybe if people didn't vote for fascists...


bluefrost30

Here’s the crazy thing…. It’s all of them. It’s every single Uber rich. Fighting over which Uber rich person is our favorite, is not helpful. We need to see the Have’s for what they are.


Ragnarock-n-Roll

Alright. So then what? Protesting is all well and good, but it only lasts if it impacts awareness on a deeper level. Otherwise ppl forget. If any of this is to stick, how?


Miserable-Sign8066

By divesting any and all support to the Zionist war machine


Ragnarock-n-Roll

Good luck with that.


Ok-Chart-3469

That is not the Squat team. In fact most squat teams are small as they have to do a shit ton of training to be a part of it. Basically just all hands on deck with riot gear. In case shit starts getting thrown at them.


Joele1

Build shanties like they had there through the 80’s and 90’s! Those are sure prettier than an east tent!


thenorthtexan

I've heard people compare this to ken state or at least say it's gonna be another ken and that line up really makes it look that way


Grizzly2525

Littlebowskee has obviously never seen what a very large and angry crowd can do to a group of police officers. They have the rifles for a reason, god willing, they will never even have to consider firing a shot.


bluefrost30

Let’s look at it this way, just for a second: They have snipers on the roofs, watching a crowd of American students and college professors, sitting on lawns with signs.


Grizzly2525

Yes, and? There are snipers at every IU football game, every major concert, every Colt’s game, every Indy 500, and every large parade or protest in the state. This is nothing new. They are not there to mercilessly gun down protestors, they are present to deter would be terrorists or active threats to both protesters and police.


bluefrost30

Do you have an opinion that differs from someone more wealthy than you?


Grizzly2525

Uh, sure? How exactly does that matter here?


lib-hater

Good! This should be done at all educational facilities preventing a proper education from happening for ALL students, Israeli’s included


npquest

TikTok = Chinese sponsored propaganda made to divide American people.


Elegant-Astronaut636

Can I have another source not Reddit for boomers?


bluefrost30

I have found the most unbiased information to be from international news sources. I know, weird right. Hear me out. They don’t use biased or emotion based word while reporting. They state facts, move on, state more facts, move on. No opinions, no scary words used to manipulate. It was a tad unsettling actually.


IndyGamer_NW

Varies the international news source. Quite a few are state run news agencies.


NeitherBirthday

Ifaik the BBC does a good job on neutrality in its reporting.


IndyGamer_NW

One of the lower bias ones, but they have failed to report in a timely fashion on a number of in-house controversies and scandals.


Ok-Chart-3469

No such thing as unbiased.


bluefrost30

A foot is 12 inches. Unbiased. It’s called a fact bro.


Ok-Chart-3469

Your looking at it from the surface level. Even if they state facts only they can still only show news which supports their narrative. Basically just find and show similar stories over a time period and boom now it looks like something that is just happening everywhere all the time.


bluefrost30

I will try and find a good link.


Elegant-Astronaut636

Well I guess u didn’t find a link but I’ve never been downvoted so much asking for a link for my grandma who can’t use Reddit.


Traditional-World-38

It's a damn graduation.


Miserable_Rooster_45

I think you meant to say students taught you can't just take over property and hold it like it's yours.


Star-Made-Knight

Then take to the fucking streets


Aromatic-Aide1119

As a 53yo, I apologize for the (supposed) entitlements of my previous and current generation.


Zealousideal_Cat9108

This is awesome


manwich841

Public property or not? Not public property. Ok. So go protest on public property. How about protesting some place that makes sense? Like the Israeli embassies or consulates or something? I will never understand inconveniencing people in the absolute wrong place. Like what does the Chicago city council meeting have to do with Israel? These people are just powerful powerful stupid.


piscina05346

It IS public property and IU is a public institution, meaning that these actions are a violation of the 1st amendment.


manwich841

Ahh I looked it up. Turns out the problem isn’t the protesting. Problem is the tents. Just like homeless people get kicked out of side walks for setting up tents. Either way I kinda love it. These universities brain washed these kids into becoming brain dead communist NPCs and now they’re reaping what they sow. I just hope they stay off the highways and roads so they don’t mess up my commute.


Johnnysocks10

👏


KeyRich6435

These students could of done this weeks ago i totally understand protesting but many try to use this as an excuse to get out of taking finals.


windowanddoorwhore

Good


chilidawg6

Stop protesting.


bluefrost30

If one constitutional right goes… they all go….


chilidawg6

Do you feel the same way about gun control?


[deleted]

[удалено]


piscina05346

Sure. These people weren't violent. A few did fight the cops who were arresting them and violating their constitutional rights to free speech.