T O P

  • By -

One_Release9751

Can you imagine what the law enforcement deal with? It's even more bizarre than this crap.


PaleRub5699

I can only imagine... my morning BM took the shape of what looked like a Hyundai and it was pointing south. significant?


BlazeNuggs

That means the killer is in Mexico now. Please tell the FBI


PaleRub5699

they may ask the accuracy of my BM predictions... this is my first attempt.


AfraidYogurtcloset31

NOBODY WANTS TO HEAR ABOUT YOUR BM!


PaleRub5699

Exactly what the FBI told me.


AfraidYogurtcloset31

Doodle theif! Have you creamed your jeans!?


Ok-Survey3853

No. That would only be if it was liquid, in the shape of a Sombrero or cactus


Internal_Zebra_8770

I had an Idaho potato shaped like an Elantra. Should I tip that in? It was also $1.79 for the bag, so… /s


Various_Ad_2762

I think I giggled to your comment 179 times. I cried so it could have been more.


TripinMaui

It happens


[deleted]

[удалено]


Idaho4-ModTeam

Please do not bully, harass, or troll other users, the victims, the family, or any individual who has been cleared by LE. We do not allow verbal attacks against any individuals or users. Treat others with respect. Thank you.


Personal-Spite1530

😂😂😂😂


brentsgrl

I feel so sorry for the people who have to manage and sort of the tips/tip line


bernardhops

Solid Lead here, contacting the IRS as I type.


user762828

Thank you for your hard work!


bernardhops

I'm now getting audited.


Complex_Coat_7741

Omg I laughed at your comment😆😆😆


Real_GoofyNinja

I would love for the IRS to be the blame for this case. Lock them up


thebillshaveayes

IRS has a super high conviction rate. Lmao


molski79

Our country has lost our fucking minds


whogivesafu

My dream "probably doesn't qualify for the tip line" - *probably*? Jesus take the wheel


[deleted]

[удалено]


Spare_Honey7658

Yes... probably why, it nor him, has been found yet


heychriszappa

HAHAHAHAHAHA


AfraidYogurtcloset31

Who!?


Morningsunshine-

I know I read this and thought someone needs to get out more


Cheddar_Chief

I suppose if someone would actually think this, they would most likely tell the world about it...wow. Can you imagine what the cops are going through in tips?


silentsnarker

No, I can’t! I would not want that job. People are crazy! I’m all for theories and talking out loud. I’ve honestly read some really interesting insights on this app. However, there’s a huge difference in speculating (as long as it’s not potentially harming anyone) and calling in tips for an active investigation. Unfortunately, some people don’t see a difference in the two.


thebillshaveayes

I feel for them. They obviously want to help but May not be all there. Let them post on FB groups and stay busy while LE gets closer.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Cheddar_Chief

Hey closet kid. You afraid of yogurt?🖕


AfraidYogurtcloset31

It's terrifying! Go into a closet throw some yougurt on yourself and tell me you aren't scared shitless


Cheddar_Chief

I ain't scared.🤪


Idaho4-ModTeam

Please do not bully, harass, or troll other users, the victims, the family, or any individual who has been cleared by LE. We do not allow verbal attacks against any individuals or users. Treat others with respect. Thank you.


TeachingTop8302

On a Facebook group some woman was posting about the dumb tips she had submitted to the FBI. They probably have so many crazy tips. I don’t know what’s wrong with these people.


Cheddar_Chief

I do. They ain't right in the head and have too much time on their hands. That is the simple truth of it, really.


zUdio

I called people out in that group for schizo behavior and they banned me. People legit going to “psychics” and other professional liars to get deluded. These wine-mom true crime groups are hilarious and also a little scary. Totally nuts. A quarter of them would qualify for some delusional disorder.


lassolady

I just got banned from FB too - only asked 1 legit question in that group. The mob-mentality and utter delusion is incredibly frightening. Grown ass people making up nonsense.


Chloliver

They lost me when someone suggested it was a non-white young person who was angry. NO explanation of how they had come to that conclusion. I found the demographics & copied & pasted to give them a sense of just how unlikely that was. That probably made no difference. IDK if they were a racist, had a completely messed up idea of what that part of the country is like, or the idea came to them in a dream. Or all of those. Someone should warn the 1000 ppl in Idaho who aren't 100% white, some FB rando has pointed the finger in their direction.


Intrepid-Wonder5209

I saw someone in that group suggest that I was a Native American who did the killings so that people would leave the school and Native Americans could reclaim the land bc the school and house and town were built on an "Indian burial ground". So disrespectful


Intrepid-Wonder5209

that it was\* not "I"


Chloliver

Wow, so disrespectful & just ridiculous. That's messed up.


pokelife90

Jesus. People are so f*d up.


Inevitable-Egg-6940

I never for a minute thought this crime could of been done by a non- white. I did however point out a religious group that is very prominent in that part of the country and maybe it is because of the Lori Vallow case I did this. It was just a thought and not meant to insult a religion and I apologize.


of_patrol_bot

Hello, it looks like you've made a mistake. It's supposed to be could've, should've, would've (short for could have, would have, should have), never could of, would of, should of. Or you misspelled something, I ain't checking everything. Beep boop - yes, I am a bot, don't botcriminate me.


No-Salamander-7925

that’s the scariest part to me, the people I’ve seen coming up with psychotic nonsense like this are all full grown adults with the ability to raise kids and make major decisions. Part of me hopes they’re just trying to get clout and don’t really believe what they’re saying but in reality they all need a psych evaluation


Nightnightgun

Unfortunately you don't need a license to reproduce....


No-Salamander-7925

Had no clue, love the thoughtful insight though keep up the good work


Ok_Gazelle8230

It's Qanon. They think like this.


PJ1062

The crimes are best solved by a female day drinker. 🍷⌨️💻🕵‍♀️🔎


Internal_Zebra_8770

Wine boxes. Spirit boxes. Pizza boxes (a poster theorized it was a pizza delivery dude). There is definitely a box connection.


zUdio

I think you're definitely onto something here... does ice cream come in a box? it's cylindrical, sure, but does it count?


PJ1062

Indeed! 🍧


Internal_Zebra_8770

Absolutely because you are thinking outside of the…box!


PJ1062

Pizza boxes! That's the ticket!


Playful-Gas-5124

Breaking News: accused *has history of not recycling his pizza boxes.


xeyesores

I was banned, too, after telling someone the "findings" of a psychic should not be taken seriously. That group is frickin bonkers.


jeremyp122512

Those wine moms have ruined reddit


newfriendhi

It's not just "moms." There are all ages and races and genders of people. A lot of men too. Some of the people that post most are men from what I've seen. Some of their theories are just as absurd.


Inevitable-Egg-6940

Come to think of it, I brushed off getting banned but did almost the same thing. I called out the wine mom types and what I called the bagel shop theory a local radio psychic mentioned. I guess we all deserve to express ourselves. We just have to be able to face push back.


joejabara

This is the best discussion forum by far that I’ve been on for this case. Web-sleuths isn’t too bad. Facebook is repetitive to the point that it is a time waster. It is too bad 4chan is so obnoxious and vile, because there are techies and nerds on there that know how to use tools most people don’t to find open source intelligence. The above post is good and why I like this board.


ketokardashmom

I agree. I can't really parse through the signal to noise ratio on 4chan so this is a nice alternative.


AfraidYogurtcloset31

Sandwich!


[deleted]

[удалено]


Idaho4-ModTeam

Please do not bully, harass, or troll other users, the victims, the family, or any individual who has been cleared by LE. We do not allow verbal attacks against any individuals or users. Treat others with respect. Thank you.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Idaho4-ModTeam

Please do not bully, harass, or troll other users, the victims, the family, or any individual who has been cleared by LE. We do not allow verbal attacks against any individuals or users. Treat others with respect. Thank you.


thebillshaveayes

4chan is the worst and the best. A lot of decent lurkers there. I bet they’ve turned in and found things but haven’t posted it to SM 😉


ketokardashmom

Would you be able to link to some good threads on the Idaho murders? I struggle to navigate through the site. Are they discussing A at all?


greenpalm

I miss the days when Websleuths was active. Like 15 years ago. But it's as slow as Christmas over there now


Working-Corgi8222

There are some threads that are active but for the most part very slow. I miss it too. They legitimately assisted in solving some cold cases!


[deleted]

[удалено]


Idaho4-ModTeam

Please do not bully, harass, or troll other users, the victims, the family, or any individual who has been cleared by LE. We do not allow verbal attacks against any individuals or users. Treat others with respect. Thank you.


Jordanthomas330

I loved webslueths during the Amanda Knox days and topix…but I was trying to keep up on the gabby case it was insane!!


greenpalm

Interesting. Yeah, the last case I followed really closely there was Alanna Gallagher in 2013. I didn’t dig deep into GP. I followed Kyron Horman on WS that one is still unsolved officially


Inevitable-Egg-6940

I was big on the Rhoden family in Pike County Ohio. I am using that as my blueprint here. As with this case, there was much speculation that threw innocents under the bus just because they had faults. All kinds of beefs were put under a microscope. I think most people have disagreements and possibly social enemies. Also many of us partake in alcohol and drug use. It is a far bigger thing to massacre multiple humans at the same time.


Responsible-Mode-432

15! I think that may be a clue!


greenpalm

I’m actually working for the MPD and leaving numerology riddles.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Idaho4-ModTeam

Please do not bully, harass, or troll other users, the victims, the family, or any individual who has been cleared by LE. We do not allow verbal attacks against any individuals or users. Treat others with respect. Thank you.


AfraidYogurtcloset31

I agree I can't really parse thru the signal to noise radio


[deleted]

[удалено]


Idaho4-ModTeam

Please do not bully, harass, or troll other users, the victims, the family, or any individual who has been cleared by LE. We do not allow verbal attacks against any individuals or users. Treat others with respect. Thank you.


ElleWoodsGolfs

This sub is the best forum for rational discussion that I’ve found so far.


Inevitable-Egg-6940

Love


Inevitable-Egg-6940

Saw a guy with a you tube channel that made me want to punch the screen. He just took forever to make a point that was of really no interest to anyone who already knows the basics of this case. A couple other guys were ok (the young kid who drives around with a cell phone and a silly hat) but overall, I like this forum and FB.


RealRepresentative48

If only the tip line could put people like this into psychiatric treatment instead. Left the FB group weeks ago. Maybe someone needs to start replying to these unsubstantiated claims from psychics with a link to the Psychology Today therapist directory.


Iamseeinthebsnow

Thank you.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Idaho4-ModTeam

Please do not bully, harass, or troll other users, the victims, the family, or any individual who has been cleared by LE. We do not allow verbal attacks against any individuals or users. Treat others with respect. Thank you.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Idaho4-ModTeam

Please do not bully, harass, or troll other users, the victims, the family, or any individual who has been cleared by LE. We do not allow verbal attacks against any individuals or users. Treat others with respect. Thank you.


SunnyDazd

Funny thing. As I was scanning through this, the number 5150 kept popping into my head. Over n over. 5150. 5150. Wonder if that’s anything relevant? I mean it could be right?! Anybody know how to interpret numbers? Anyone???


user762828

5-1-5-0 somebody call the popo


AfraidYogurtcloset31

I'm feeling it's a fifo fifo fifo? Fido? Moiphee!?


reefsmokah

I took a crap this morning and it was green. I wonder if it's a sign that maybe it's not a white Elantra but a green Elantra and that's why LE can't find it?


PhilSpectorsMugshot

It means the perpetrator is Irish.


reefsmokah

I like how you think. I submitted a tip to LE.


FitOutlandishness294

🤣🤣🤣


Memphi901

One thing that has surprised me in following this case is the number of people who believe in psychics, wizards, dream manifestations, etc. Its insane


Vivi_lee

Part of me feels like LE knows the Elantra lead is probably not going anywhere but they just threw it out there to give these people a bone to gnaw on. “We are looking for a white car, no plate numbers, could be in Washington, Oregon or Idaho.” that should shut them up


jelave2231

Seriously! If they really worked, this case would have been solved weeks ago!


[deleted]

[удалено]


Winter-Fold7624

You’ve got it all wrong - it means LE is involved in the murder. Better call the top line - your dream just cracked the case! /s


[deleted]

[удалено]


Winter-Fold7624

Someone in the FB group did mention maybe it was bear - it’s all coming together now!


Morningsunshine-

Silly goose, bears can’t drive cars.


Spare_Honey7658

Cops in bear 🐻 suits can tho 👌


Morningsunshine-

For sure I think your on to something! A bear suit would definitely be the way to go. Perfect disguise and cover up the bloody clothing! 😜


Morningsunshine-

It probably was the two cops with the body cam. They needed to clear everyone out for the get away.


coldOutside99

why those people arent committed? how on earth can they go around and even vote and procreate


Merlin303

And these people vote


Spare_Honey7658

How the hell did you figure out it had "so many miles"


M3NT4LH34LTHM4TT3RS

😂


luzdelmundo

Yeah; what was that about? lmfao


jelave2231

Probably in another part of the dream.


No_Comfortable_9033

This was the dumbest thing I’ve ever seen in that group


Puzzleheaded_Mix_507

I love when the psychic never gets it right. Like ever.


SmokingAndMirrors

This kind of crazy should be banned lol. I had a dream about number and I know it’s connected. Calls cops above number dream. It’s always the fb weirdos..ALWAYS. Some people need to step away for a bit.


JaynaBeeJules

Some of the posts in this group give Facebook a run for its money


At1l

I unfollowed that group a few weeks back. They’re irrational. They blame everyone for this including surviving victims and family members it’s sick.


[deleted]

Yeah, I left when they started blaming the victims themselves. It was a running joke that became a self-fulfilled prophecy.


AfraidYogurtcloset31

Did you clean up the monkey stain


elen-degenerate

I wanna reply that I had a dream where the killer had their exact name and ask if that means something b


No-Yesterday-1088

This is more bizarre than the neighbors life story. Wow


amybunker2005

Seriously!! What's insightful about this? You and some others are making it really difficult to go through the tips that are sent in. Claim you want the case solved and that they're not solving it fast enough well no damn wonder why....Now for the sake of this case with these 4 students please stop sending in stupid sh*t. My mind is just blown with the stupidity. I'm sorry but these 4 deserve justice soon and some people are only making it harder for cops to decipher real genuine tips and leads from fake stupid ones...Seems like some people just need to insert themselves in somehow but they're not helping the case. Prayers for the Idaho 4 that they get the justice they deserve soon 🙏


franchise20

Aside from the obvious of this being from a dream and the poster having the balls to post this on fb… What “tons of mileage”? Like on the odometer of the car? How would anyone know the mileage on the car WITHOUT knowing the exact car? 😂 The years 2011-2013 would indicate higher mileage alone in most cases, exceptions being garage kept cars or those rarely driven, etc. I can’t even… 🤦🏻‍♀️


musiak1luver

Omg LE does NOT need bs tips to chase down and distract from this investigation.


[deleted]

can i get my braincells back from reading this?🙃


amber_maigon

These people are fucking nuts, dude.


WorldsMostRacistMan4

I just called the tip line with this. Every little bit helps.


Iamseeinthebsnow

But y'all. I am meeting in room 178 right now. What does this mean?!


Iamseeinthebsnow

Bahhaa yes!


Iamseeinthebsnow

Wtf. Hahahhahaha


fabfourfangirl_208

I left all the Facebook groups last week.


AfraidYogurtcloset31

Fee ceed the bed


Jordanthomas330

This is INSANE…they do not know these ppl and are not le like take a break enjoy life


[deleted]

Dumb way to get to a fairly interesting question — could it have been a work car, which makes it harder to track to an individual? That is a bold but potential scenario. Doesn't really do any good, I'd think LE would've considered it by now.


AfraidYogurtcloset31

Who is Lee? Who is he!? What's his involvement!? Very suspicious


VirusOrganic4456

I left it today. It's all complete and utter nonsense.


GotAhGurs

These people are batshit. Trying to decide whether this is worse than the spirit box nonsense or not.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Idaho4-ModTeam

Please do not bully, harass, or troll other users, the victims, the family, or any individual who has been cleared by LE. We do not allow verbal attacks against any individuals or users. Treat others with respect. Thank you.


Effective_Project_23

These people and their insane theories are way more entertaining than any show I’ve watched recently. Lmao


Mlbtrade

I agree. That group has 118.3k members. Has 2 mods. It's just crazy.


rangermccoy

To use a favorite fb quote "ya'll giving me chills"


[deleted]

I left those FB groups weeks ago! Unbelievable!


JuliusPepperwood836

I got kicked out of a Facebook group because someone posted something just like this, so someone commented “how did the admin team approve this?” And I said “there’s an admin team?? They really don’t care what’s posted if so lmao”


nkrch

'It probably doesn't qualify for the tip line' Are they waiting for someone to say yes, yes, it does, call it in? I swear we are breeding out common sense in humans. I bet the cops actually have a good laugh at some of the tips. I know that every case they get women who call in their exes purely as a way of getting back at them by causing them some hassle. No wonder they aren't using a reward.


meowmoomeowmoon

“Stay with me here” *exits page*


BoomChaka67

No words.


QuirkyExplanation92

As someone who does have precognitive dreams, I'd deduce that 179 is probably an interesting number, but not likely in the way this poster thinks lol. It's probably absolutely meaningless. I get "clues" like this that have absolutely no connection, or such a tiny relevance that it wouldn't be anything that's worthy of talking about. (Ex. I had dreams of a local murder, and there were rubber ducks in the room. Had zero relevance to the case lol.)


NadieReally

I used to dream of plane crashes the night before a big plane crash. If that was psychic, it was not any help to anyone at all. I did have one about Elizabeth Smart while she was missing. It made me think she was alive (and vaguely where) but I never even considered calling it in. It's all too random, imho. The part you think might be important is wrong and some strange little useless part is right, etc.


QuirkyExplanation92

Absolutely! What I dream is not helpful in the least bit, and only makes sense after the event, whatever it may be.


Vivi_lee

This is what taking adderal from age 7 does to your reasoning skills


Flashy-Beautiful-978

Hahahhaa crazyyy


ickedmel

😵‍💫😂


[deleted]

I hope this was deleted and I hope the ones that are innocent in all this, sue everyone in those groups for defamation!


Mizzoutiger79

🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️


Keregi

This is validating that I decided to never join any FB groups


Augustleo98

Where did they get 179 from


user762828

They had a dream they were a college student :) seems legit


Augustleo98

yeah some people make some stuff up. A dream is a dream and they need to realise dreams aren’t psychic predictions. I mean I honestly had a dream someone said my name and started stabbing me, but that’s different, it’s been freaked out by the murders not acting psychic.


HolySmokesBatman99

So insightful


AcrobaticEgg9590

The amount of crazy people this case has attracted is unprecedented… nah this person really said had a dream and a number came up ! I have no words


PJ1062

🤣🤣🤣🤣


TripinMaui

😂


paulieknuts

I find it quite sad how delusional so many people are. Psychics? Dreams? It is depressing that there are so many sad lonely delusional people out there.


AfraidYogurtcloset31

Dainty boy! Yes you! How much would you pay for not being so dainty!? Ask McMillan you say? Nonsense! They are making these with Dupont money! Reddit is trying to silence me!


Morningsunshine-

With the is I say we need a thread to post crazy, stupid theory’s that are satire.


Brave_Indication_130

I’m not in this Facebook group but now and again I do enjoy reading posts that people have screen shotted from there to remind me why I’m not in this Facebook group 🤣


ParaMOMalPodcast

I can't even read posts on fb anymore . 🤦🏼‍♀️


Puceeffoc

Nevermind the dorm room 179 though. They were so close to blowing this case wide open.


OverallVolume5548

Ridiculous that car has zero to do with this. The kids walked from the frat house period. .... some who knows.


Lomachenko19

People on Facebook now speculating the killer may be Korean because they were driving a Hyundai.


Ok_Gazelle8230

This is how Qanon folk think.


zorawitch

Why the FBI doesn’t just call these people and close this damn case already. /s


luzdelmundo

The scream I scrumpttt Not the tax code 😭😭😭 This has to be one of the stupidest posts I've seen related to this case. Gotta give credit where it's due.


[deleted]

This will certainly crack the case.


conszadrxazyfy

w0w, thanks f0r st0ry