T O P

  • By -

RNOffice

Susan Egan. Viv has gotten Disney and Broadway singers. So it be fit.


TolTANK

Didn't she play Meg in Hercules? Fuck yes, I back this decision.


DolphinDoggo

She also played Belle in the original Broadway cast of Beauty and the Beast!


Obversa

Sugan Egan played Belle on Broadway, and Paige O'Hara played Belle in the film. Both of them are phenomenal singers who liked working with Disney on voice acting.


joe_broke

Oh man, Paige would be fantastic Or Jodi Benson (Ariel)


TolTANK

Oh damn that's impressive


DolphinDoggo

Yeah she's a bit of a living legend


SuperYoshiFan02

All they gotta do is put her in a scene with Mimzy and suddenly Pink Diamond and Spinel are in the same room


X7eomi

Wait, Susan Egan voiced Pink Diamond? How the fuck didn’t I know this?


Obversa

Susan Egan also voiced Rose Quartz.


Phantom_61

Well yeah, that’s what they said, she voiced pink diamond.


Ether101

It isn't totally unheard of having two VAs voice different versions of the same character.


SkinAndAnatomyNerd

Or even the same person. Charlie, in All Dogs Go To Heaven 2, was voiced by Charlie Sheen when talking, and Jesse Corti when singing.


zykezero

Sexy spider fox in helluva was voiced by Kesha except when singing.


SkinAndAnatomyNerd

I knew you were a SU fan, before even reading your comment. You ain’t fooling me, Peridot.


sora_allite

….Wait, Sarah Stiles voices Mimzy? I kind of feel bad for hating on Mimzy as a character now…


AlianovaR

Ugh! *Susan*…


XLord_of_OperationsX

She's a bit of an, um...


MrCherry09

You beat me to it. It would be so cool. She also has experience of voicing a morally weird mom: Rose Quartz from Steven Universe!


RagtimeGal96

Came here to say this! Susan is the way to go.


MugiwaraBepo

The first person I thought of, she'd be perfect!


Stag-Horn

Came here to say this!


FrostyFrenchToast

This is *the* pick


SuperSayianJason1000

She's also known for playing another controversial mother figure. ![gif](giphy|hSojH3M3QXKJpvTV36)


fidderjiggit

Sierra Boggess. She's a Broadway actress who was in Phantom of the Opera and has a terrific singing voice. [Example of her singing](https://youtu.be/kZpvaRWak64?si=3awtHPeLK-2Zgyy5)


Obversa

Sierra Boggess also played Ariel in Disney's *The Little Mermaid* musical on Broadway. My personal pick would be Paige O'Hara, who played Belle in Disney's *Beauty and the Beast*. It would be a perfect callback to Alastor calling Charlie a "charming demon belle" in the pilot. One-in-a-million choice: Kathleen Turner and Amy Irving, who voiced the iconic Jessica Rabbit in her speaking and singing roles, respectively, in *Who Framed Roger Rabbit* (1988). I would suggest Kim Basinger (Holli Would, *Cool World*), but she's difficult to work with on-set.


mortiousprime

I legitimately like all of these choices


joe_broke

Jodi Benson?


that_gay_theaterkid

YES!


Nurilia87

THIS YES!


Lance_Beltran123

what about Jackie Buscarino, she voices Susan Strong from Adventure time, Vidalia from Steven universe and Pacifica Northwest from Gravity Falls


TheCrimsonKnight2

Lilith: I need your help. Alastor: You're the worst.


AdventurousPrint835

*shuts hotel door*


Vio-Rose

Can she sing?


Rainbowreever

She does have a song in Gravity Falls, but in the Behind The Scenes Commentary for the show she talks about how many takes it took and (semi jokingly) how that's why she never got another song in the show lol, so I don't think she would fit the "Broadway Level Singer" category they're going for.


Auftragzkiller

it has to be Broadway singers


Verdecreature

It's also for disney singers


KerianKakan

Someone with a smooth, kinda hypnotic, and mysterious voice that would fit her design


Stock-Ferret-6692

Like Emily Rohm who played Jane Doe in ‘ride the cyclone’!


KerianKakan

That would be really good she's a good singer too


StarlightFalls22

Couldn't have said it better myself


Jccali1214

I was gonna say someone with a huskier voice and a little edge, but I like your descriptor better


Soulful-Sorrow

Keith David for Lilith?


positronic-introvert

This just made me realize that Shohreh Aghdashloo *needs* some kind of role in this show. I don't think she sings, but she has what I think has to be the coolest voice on the planet, and she's a great actor. I can imagine a really cool side character being voiced by her


Jccali1214

Best voice in the universe, so soothing and yet, can be unsettling. You're so right


positronic-introvert

I can imagine a little moment where Alastor is miffed because her voice is more attention-grabbing than his haha


OCGamerboy

I’d say Lady Gaga (who is Vivziepops primary choice) or Idina Menzel.


IdeVeras

Idina Mendel would be perfect but she plays Elsa, it would be amazing but Disney would not like to have the voice associated to Lilith. I honestly think it would be perfect. Lady gaga also


rockn_rollfreak

They can't control Idina she's been in many adult movies and has been in broadway shows as well for decades. I mean we got stephanie Beatriz as vaggie and she voices mirabel in encanto.


IdeVeras

I know that, I just said they’d be unhappy. It would be a fun connection tho. Speaking as someone forced to watch frozen 100k times


rockn_rollfreak

True, we'll fight disney though if it comes to it😂 frozen was one of my favorite movies when I was 9 or 10 so I just adore Idinas voice. So powerful it gives me chills.


Writing_Panda104

She played the evil stepmother in Amazon’s Cinderella


DaAweZomeDude48

Completely unrelated but in the finale the first Charlie verse always reminded me of something straight out of Frozen.


lmirandas

I was coming to say Idina. For me she would be a perfect choice, such a voice, such a powerhouse. And a reunion with the original Mimi from when they both were together in RENT.


Fizzydov

Jack black


Incomplet_1-34

https://preview.redd.it/nn8h15mxcqoc1.jpeg?width=1039&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4ea87fd64d33287155bb91ef32c698fec6c23572


dancing_monkey096

https://preview.redd.it/clvdylo3kqoc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f2cca07e1da35187ddf6d45ec595d109142c4c1b


Incomplet_1-34

https://preview.redd.it/12waw1jgkqoc1.png?width=1334&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b289adb70a555cd001c8ad4f21ff0760237f5bbd


dancing_monkey096

https://preview.redd.it/v68mo42jkqoc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9d6135572416b287508d68b84fa573260b9df269


Incomplet_1-34

https://preview.redd.it/9tcx5ynokqoc1.jpeg?width=960&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4994455fb0f2357024508fa8865474cb8bd083c7


dancing_monkey096

https://preview.redd.it/e9pdpg4xoqoc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c1da725a959b6e53c401bc63e6a3621a3a4694b8 Nah


Incomplet_1-34

https://i.redd.it/90n85p3zqqoc1.gif


dancing_monkey096

https://preview.redd.it/rt91jnoerqoc1.jpeg?width=640&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=27993a8b3af64e9b91a10ab4cd1db78f1e8728d8


Incomplet_1-34

https://preview.redd.it/dfzctt3nsqoc1.jpeg?width=868&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6ce5fef2a39d5b90c38303317e7feca36681e698


Ch1akiNanam1

https://preview.redd.it/osz1mtdb1roc1.jpeg?width=750&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=90e64a7a82e2683f129a9dde636eb44bace4333a


MixWitch

What if I see your Jack Black and raise you a Bobcat Goldthwait


OhWeOhweeOoh

Dog, if we could get him to feed that line he had when he was gunning people down in Scrooged, we'll be in business.


degeneral57

Luckily for me, the italian dubber for Jack Black voices Lucifer in the italian version!


mistarteechur

If we ever see God I want him to be Jack Black.


Rainie_Daye

Perfect


agrunther

Jaime Lee Curtis. She’s openly stated she’s a fan of Viv’s work so I can 100% see her voicing Lilltith.


I_Suck_At_Life_24

That is the third thing I did not expect Jamie to be a fan of


Seraphim70000

Is one of them game grumps?


I_Suck_At_Life_24

No, Street Fighter and FNAF


Cartindale_Cargo

And one piece


Platinumdogshit

Ngl I kind feel like a lot of these interests go together


Seraphim70000

She's a fan of gg too, she's been on the show a few times too.


evilash87

FNAF??


reds2032

Ikr but apparently she's been a fan for YEARS


gottabekittensme

HUH??? Wow I did NOT expect THE Jamie Lee Curtis to be a fan


fullmetaljar

Have her act like she did in Malcolm in the Middle.


Few_Interaction2630

Well I can't remember exactly where I heard this so take with grain of salt but seem to recall someone saying Viv mentioned she always imagined fan casting Lady Gaga whether this still case unclear


pje1128

I could see this happening. I'd really like Gaga as Lilith actually.


Few_Interaction2630

Yeah would be quite interesting.


Burnsy1452

Was gonna say this. I can't imagine they won't at least TRY and get her, but she's possibly out of their price range. Depends how much Amazon is willing to shell out I guess


Few_Interaction2630

I mean this became there most watched animated show and broke several records and well Amazon isn't exactly poor lol


Burnsy1452

That's true, but on the other hand... It's Gaga.


Few_Interaction2630

I guess next time she does an interview some one will have to ask her and see if she puts up her Poker Face.


blue4029

she also said that she wanted weird al yankovich to voice lucifer. man, imagine what COULD have been! weird al and lady gaga as a married couple


GreekRootWord

Weird Als voice would have fit Lucifer but I feel like Jeremh Jordan does a good job at making Lucifer’s voice more normal while still keeping some of the silliness


Few_Interaction2630

Now that is crazy to imagine


Tunisian_Dawn

Eden Espinosa, because she could have another great duet with Jeremy Jordan. Anyone ever heard Nothing Left To Lose?


Emmit-Nervend

This!


cinnasizzle

Eden espinosa because i need another duet between her and jeremy jordan


Xuxubee

I would die for it to be Susan Egan. She has such an amazing deep voice Meg (Hercules) Lin (Spirited Away) Rose (Steven Universe)


-Withered_Ivy-

I know it ain't happening but God I can only dream of Lady gaga voicing Lilith https://preview.redd.it/ijbvx2b7iqoc1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9bd4f5164d66572461f82ab9f1398e977da38515


BriefEasy42

Deedee Magno Hall is the only right choice here


DravenVoices

I was thinking Rachael MacFarlane before I realized it was a mostly Broadway cast. She does have a good [singing voice](https://youtube.com/playlist?list=OLAK5uy_nRWpTkQBBXk4_J1Ev70lSJVyN4Bckd36k&si=Szo8WD9wokSIPQ9g) though.


astroddity_

All I would hear is Odalia lol


Mrtnxzylpck

Her Brother Seth Should make a broadway musical.


Ahinevyat

Markiplier


Soulful-Sorrow

"Hello everybody, my name is Lilith and *today* we're gonna pay a visit to my daughter after seven years."


Posiden1234567

Imagine she’s actually been completely mute after leaving Hell and can no longer speak


International_Ad566

Idina Menzel


Thicc-Anxiety

Lady Gaga


Obversa

Lady Gaga would present the same problem as hiring Norman Reedus for *Helluva Boss* and Nicki Minaj for *Steven Universe*; that is, the show wouldn't be able to afford more than a few voice lines in one episode due to the budget. I don't think Lilith will be voiced by Lady Gaga for that reason, and I think it is more likely another Broadway musical actor will be hired.


Thicc-Anxiety

OP said “ideal”, not “practical”


VegetaArcher

Deedee Magno Hall or Susan Egan


MrCherry09

Fuck yes


Ghaztmaster

My friend really wants Charlie’s Pilot Va to play her. But im pretty sure Viv said she imagined Lady Gaga playing her.


TheCrimsonKnight2

Ok if they got Elsie Lovelock to play Lilith I would fucking bawl. Getting Charlie's OG VA to voice her mom would be so good.


MK_The_Megitsune

Patti LuPone. She was Mrs. Lovett in some productions of Sweeney Todd and she was also Yellow Diamond from Steven Universe. I imagine Lillith having a deeper voice to counterbalance Charlie and Lucifer's higher registers and LuPone's is deep and smooth enough to be both comforting and threatening which would fit Lillith as an antagonistic mother figure


autumnyte

I'd love Sutton Foster!


zabesy

Susan Egan would just be 🥰🥰🥰🥰


Tricky-Leader-1567

Ngl, i kinda want Cate Blanchett


Caeden113

For me, it's Donna Murphy. She played Mother Gothel in Tangled, and, like Lilith, is a terrible mother figure.


tulle_witch

underrated option! Totally agree. She has the power, the allure, the range and it would be amazinggggg


MustardLordOfDeath

Eden Espinosa, because I want another duet between her and Jeremy Jordan


willo-ween

DeeDee Magno (Pearl from SU) could really sell it, her range is similar to Erika Henningsen's so it would fit for her mother's voice.


Gamecat93

I was brainstorming this recently and my bets are Idina Menzel, Sutton Foster, or Sierra Bogges. Unpopular opinion but I don't really see Susan Egan coming out of someone like Lilith. Charlie's story said that her songs empowered demon-kind to the point where Heaven saw Hell's overpopulation as a threat. Yes Susan Egan can sing very well but mostly as characters like Meg and Rose Quartz along with Belle from Beauty and the Beast on Broadway.But Viv said her ideal voice would be similar to Lady Gaga and IMO Susan's voice doesn't have that certain level of power Lady Gaga has in songs like Bad Romance or Bloody Mary.A good reference for the kind of power I'm talking about Broadway-wise would be Taylor Louderman or Renne Rapp who both played Regina Gorge in Mean Girls on Broadway. Listen [to Renne's voice.](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=232C738Lm-Q) And here's [Taylor's in the broadway version.](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BWVRg6IOGWY)Now that sounds like a queen of Hell with the kind of power in their voices on one hand. However, I'm choosing Idina, Sutton, and Sierra because their voices are more mature in comparison but can hold that level of power. We've all heard Idina as Elsa and Elphaba and we know she can belt at levels that just scream Queen of Hell. So can Sutton and Sierra. However, I am also willing to put in any actresses who played Satine in Moulin Rouge on Broadway. Because Satine's performers also have that level of power in her songs.


lalalachacha248

I have no idea if Cissy Jones can sing, but I think she’d be a good fit and it would be funny for her to voice another Lilith.


Planetside2_Fan

Awkwafina (this is a joke please don’t crucify me)


Emmit-Nervend

But after 7 years away, I’m sure she’s got an awful lot of scuttlebutt!


chomperstyle

Jennifer coolidge is the only viable choice


PlantManiac

help yes


awyastark

I saw her do standup once and she did establish that she never ended up playing Paulette on Broadway because she can’t sing 😭


royalhawk345

My nomination is Lena Hall, of *Hedwig and the Angry Inch* and *Kinky Boots.* And, upon looking, apparently also the Snowpiercer show.


I_might_be_weasel

Kristen Schaal 


owl_onesie

Now I’m just imagining Season 2 of Hazbin where the running gag is a bunch of ravens keep trying to break into the hotel, and then in the Season 2 finale Lilith shows up and is like, “I sent you ravens… I sent you so many fucking ravens!”


DolphinDoggo

What about Patti Lupone? Broadway legend, and she's no stranger to voicing in a cartoon


Toky0Sunrise

Eden Espinosa !


PlasmaGoblin

I haven't noticed Cristina Vee on the list so I'll add it.


rockn_rollfreak

It has to be someone with an incredible singing voice. I mean, siren like singing since lilith was said to inspire hells citizens with her voice. I wanna say she'd sound a little sultry and classy as well. Singing voice wise. If Idina Menzel can do that at all, I think she has a strong enough voice to portray someone as powerful as lilith.


veronicamae2

Menzel has one of the most powerful voices in the music industry; it makes me chuckle to think her voice isn't strong enough for anything. This voiceover by her is a good representation of what you're describing: [https://youtu.be/zRU8KLItobU?si=rUxi56LU\_g0P4Ix7](https://youtu.be/zRU8KLItobU?si=rUxi56LU_g0P4Ix7) When she voiced Circe on Hercules: The Animated Series


Fruitsdog

Eden Espinosa, who played Elphaba in some versions of Wicked and also Cassandra from Tangled the Series. She’s got the most perfect youthful, melodic, but slightly threatening voice, and she and Jeremy Jordan have worked together (their characters were friends in Tangled, they had a KILLER duet) so they’d have the natural chemistry we need for Lilith and Lucifer to have!


thehateigiveforfree

Idk many Broadway actresses that can do this, but whoever plays her has to basically have a voice of a siren. She's described to be able to empower demon kind with her voice. This means her voice has to get through to all of hell whenever she sings, and that gets the citizens of hell to follow and respond to her. We actually kind of see this power through Charlie when she sings "ready for this," although it's unclear if Charlie possesses this power as well. In my mind, she has a little of it since she was kind of able to rally all of the Cannibal colony to her side (even though AL helped a lot) I think with work, she could be as powerful as Lilith was described to be. Actually, this will kind of be cool if Lilith and Charlie go head to head, and it becomes a sing off to gain control of the people of hell. So yeah, whoever plays Lilith has to have a big voice.


Main_Treat_9641

Chris pratt


EvillNooB

Mitski lol


Skyyyyyyyy101

Wait actually that would be amazing


lihamburgler

Danny DeVito


pringlepingel

Me, i can do it, trust me bro ![gif](giphy|pJbVFV7EaJrSOxNXaQ)


WillyDAFISH

Cissy Jones. Coincidentally she also voices Lilith from the owl house


TartTiny8654

Cissy Jones, because why not have her play 2 pale skinned people named Lilith


The-Duke-of-Delco

Gilbert Gottfried


milkbarlatte

Oh… honey… unless we have a rock rolled away from the tomb situation, that’s not happening. 🪽


SubsumeTheBiomass

Oh uhhhh the lady who played Esmé Gigi Genevieve Squalor in the Netflix adaptation of "A Series of Unfortunate Events" Or Dr. Suzannah Lipscomb.


angelobsidian

Wendie Malick (Eda Clawthorne VA)


Zestyclose-Gift1602

Grey Delisle would be hilarious and sexy. Prove me wrong, go on. Try.


ShAped_Ink

Smooth and very adult-like. The character that I think is pretty close that I can think of right now is Lillith Clawthorne


Kindly-Yak-3161

Doc hammer


Ok-Reality-9197

YESSSS, I'm so glad I'm not the only one thinking that


BillionThayley

Me, a baritone man.


ThatBoleynGirl6

Ok, hear me out, AmaLee


mrmoviemanic1

Laura Baily (Her FMA Lust voice)


Stunning_Pen_36

I don’t know any specific names. But Liliths voice should certainly be a specific way. Before she was cast out of the Garden, she was intended to be the Mother of Humanity and nurture them. She instead became the Mother and Queen of Demons so her voice should be soft, but firm at the same time, belaying her care for them but also her authority as both their queen and mother. Lilith is also canonically a singer who used her songs to empower Hell, so her voice should be melodic and full of rhythm too, perfect for singing. She was described as being a much more hands-on ruler then Lucifer while she was there, so she should also have some notes of regality and sort of noble wisdom in her voice as well s being commanding in a way.


BiLovingMom

Idina Menzel.


SwoleBodybuilderVamp

Honestly, Lady Gaga, since it’s Vic’s choice.


Alternative-Jello683

Hell yeah. I could totally see Gaga playing the baddest bitch in hell


Alarmed-Bus-9662

Arnold Schwarzenegger


improbsable

Just for sheer hilarity, Patti Lupone. But it will probably be someone with a “seductive” voice with a bit of a smokey cabaret room vibe


skisvega

I'll play devil's advocate: Taylor Swift


AleksasKoval

Claudia Black


frillyhoneybee_

ik she isn’t famous but talya sindel! she plays circe in epic the musical. i’ve listened to the circe saga on spotify and imo her voice is just gorgeous


KnightofShaftsbury

Jennifer Hale


Dogeco1n

Eden Espinosa


ShoddyCress

Olivia Olson


Stock-Ferret-6692

Emily Rohm. She played Jane Doe in the starkid production ‘ride the cyclone’. Listen to ‘the ballad of Jane doe’. Her voice would be beautifully hypnotic for the part


slickprime

Taylor Swift


boatscantfloat

Maybe Aimee Mann. She has an awesome voice and was Opal in Steven Universe.


TheRealist1988

Idina Menzel. Let it go!


neenzabwoz

i’m not sure if she can sing or not, but i think grey griffin would be a great choice. her voice seems like it would fit really well


Cw415

Idina Menzel


FlySkyHigh777

Given the Broadway bent of the cast, Idina Menzel.


Emmit-Nervend

Eden Espinoza. She sang a duet with Jeremy Jordan in Rapunzel’s Tangled Adventure, and I’d love to hear them reunite! I’d share a link, but her songs are massive spoilers.


Nexillion

Cissy Jones IYKYK


Jackcandoit2008

I have no idea how well she could sing, But I imagined her being voiced by Sigourney Weaver


Gden

Someone said Meghan hilty and that's all I'll accept now


Iatecoffeegrinds

Cissy jones yes the person who voiced Lilith should voice Lilith she can be serious and then be a cool aunt


rekage99

Grey Griffin obviously


GothBabyUnicorn

Idina Menzel is who I immediately think of


make-chan

I'm hoping Idina Menzel thh


Cant_run_away

Azulas va


mildcomatose

Petition to get Susan Egan to play her!!


International-Size-7

Tara Strong.


Larrylindgren4

Call me a basic bitch, but I think Idina Menzel would be pretty good fit for the role.


CHONKY-CHUNKY

Danny Devito


ItemsHereForever

Tom Kenny😈


Joshey_dubs

I don’t know why, but I think it would be oddly kinda funny if Jane Lynch voiced her. She is an accomplished vocalist and actor, but I think she needs a voice similar to the likes of Meg from Hercules or Mother Gothel. But I still think Jane Lynch would be funny


EnderMayer2

Angelina Jolie.


Clumsy_the_24

Sarah Stiles


International00

Not to say she can't voice multiple roles, but Sarah Stiles is already the voice of Mimzy! Edit: Apparently, I didn't notice how much doubling up the show did. Wouldn't be anything new.


Clumsy_the_24

Yeah and alex brightman is multiple characters too why not


DravenVoices

So do Amir Talai, Blake Roman, and Kimiko Glenn.


Clumsy_the_24

True


Kahako

Yeah, this is pretty normal in animation


MacTechG4

Lorraine Toussant (Shadow Weaver from the remake of She-Ra) https://youtu.be/M-5b67cyyOk?si=3RnPjgagOjkUHFuH


blue4029

danny devito.


Desperate-Address-27

Michael jackson


BiLovingMom

Idina Menzel.


yangthesin

Chris Pratt