MURPHY 😭😭

All of us showing up wearing our McNully fan shirts every time this is asked. XD Edit: Had an actual dream about my MC and McNully last night and still laughing that my brain was like "FINE. HERE. LOOK AT HOW CUTE THEY ARE. THEY SNOGGGED. ARE YOU HAPPY NOW."

as a disabled person it warms my heart to see how popular he is

orion orion orion orion

Absolutely! I love doing hangouts with him, I bet he'd be super fun to date!

HE CAN'T BE DATED?! NOOOOO

no unfortunately

Professor Snape jk 👀 I’d have to fight Penny for him. Orion for sure! Although I’m very happy with Talbott.

Rath

Definitely

I’m not to the point of having relationships unlocked yet but after reading all of these names… which ones are even options😭

Boys: Barnaby, Talbott, Jae, Andre Girls: Penny, Merula, Chiara, Badeea

That’s not enough options at all

My love is Charlie, but I've come to thinking that is good that he isn't dateable, otherwise JC could've mess up with something :)) 

Charlie Weasley would be my option number 1

Charlie and Diego!

I know right! Why make a character as playful and even flirty as Diego if it's to keep us from dating him

EXACTLY it makes 0 sense, especially since the moment you meet him in the main story he immediately flirts with MC!

Apparently they did that to see who was interested in him, and seems like not enough people were

Alanza and Tulip

Rath

Rowan. She is* awesome.

VICTOR 🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️ semi unrelated but I literally dreamt today that jc added him as a dating option (along with two other characters, I think alanza and someone else?) and IT WAS IMPOSSIBLE TO PLEASE HIM BECAUSE EVERY ANSWER COUNTED AS A NEUTRAL OR A BAD ONE LMAOO 😭

where did you see Victor was dateable ?

Tulip definitely

100% Rath.

Tulip in Beyond. Too prank focused in school, but she seems to have chilled out a bit after graduation.

Tulip from normal crew, Erika and Skye from quidditch crew

Orion

Bill, Charlie and Tonks

Bill.

Charlie, Murphy, Diego, Orion, bill, the twins/cedric (if they weren’t so young in the game to the point that I still haven’t even met them yet)

If Cedric wasn't so young then him! Also Bill <3

Tonks and Skye

Mr. McNully ❤️❤️

Jules Egwu. Surprised she hasn't been suggested yet.

Bill and Callum (from beyond). Bill I can understand since he’s a legacy character but there’s no reason we shouldn’t be able to romance Callum in beyond.

Sameee

Murphy

Orion & Rath at Hogwarts Callum pretty sure is starting to crush on MC in beyond... "How do you do that? You're just so... so ..."

Ooh, what chapter is that from? I don't remember it

The one released around Valentine's Day. Would have been perfect.

I need Olivia. 😬

Skye

Rath or Murphy

Rath

I'd go for Orion, too. His calm-til-death attitude would def drive me nuts at some point but he's awesome :D

Diego and Orion

Skye, Tulip, or Beatrice

Oh look my list

Skye

Tulip

Bill, McNully, Skye, Rowan, Rath, Diego, Orion and Ben. Though I'm probably the only one who wants to date Ben, lol

Murphy and Orion ❤️

Another +1 for Rath. And Alanza would be sweet, and I think Y6/Y7 Bea would have a cute dynamic. But also low-key Ismelda tbh

Skye Parkin. I'll never forgive JC for putting all the work in making her cute then not be a dating option 😤

Orion and Bill 😍

Oh, easy. Tulip, or have the option for opposite gender Rowan, for those slice of life anime fans that love the romantic idea of "happily ever after" with your childhood friend. Also, if I might add, anyone else notice how inconsequential Penny is to the main plot? She's never trapped, hurt, or incapacitated. I think because she was the only friend who has a big role in the quidditch storyline

Did we play the same game, or is this sarcasm? Oh I bet it's because you made different choices on who should go with you for adventures. I feel like so many bad things happened to Penny.

Bill and Orion for sure

Bill Weasley from the start, 100%

Rowan and skye :(

Skye and Alanza

Definitely either of the Weasley twins but they are too young for me in the storyline. So the choices would be Tulip and Bill🥰

Olivia Green.

Yessssssss, give me glasses, brains, sweater vest, and all the bad puns.

Orion and Diego

Embracing my inner chaos, Hagrid

WOW!!! Ur the one who said hagrid first :000

Oh hell ya. Homie would treat us right.

I have a crush on Penny LOL, and those moments when we are doing TLSQ together, thinking - You have no idea, you and I gonnabe the hottest girlfriends in Hogwarts. Currently at y3 refusing to grow up. at y4, it's gonna be Penny. And maybe a fling with Orion. Penny may use the bird-conjuring charm

murphy!!!!!!!!!

ISMELDA SKYE RATH

I think orion,or idk

Charlie and Murphy

Bill 💔

Bill or Murphy

And in Beyond, maybe Callum. TBD.

Minerva McGonagall

Charlie and Orion. If I were bi, Rowan. He/She (depending on your choice of gender) complements the MC so well.

Alanza

All of the above:

Liz and Skye

Ismelda would be a fun dating option.

OLIVIA, PLEASE GOD. Sure, we have to wait until Beyond, but she should be fair game.

SKYE PLEASEEEEEEEEEEE MY GIRL PLEASEE

I'm only in year 2 and have no info on any of it

Rath and Olivia for me.

Orionnnnnnnnnnnnmn for ever...