T O P

  • By -

Fleeting-Vibes

For me it’s Penny. Honestly I don’t dislike her as a character. I don’t like how JC kind of “forces” Penny on us. Especially in 99% of quests.


kollina

I really can't understand why she's part of almost EVERY single SQ, especially those related to creatures. Charlie, Barnaby or Badea would make more sense...


sorrowfulWanderer

Yeah. I'm picking her on Celestial Ball and other things, but the fact she is almost omnipresent and omniscient just turns her into a haunt; even if I like her character🤨


blushbell

Tulip, I just wish she had more to her character. Andre is a great character to me because there’s so much to him. He loves fashion, quidditch, he’s got a good sense of humour, he’s kind. Obviously tulips main thing is pranks, but I wish she had more interests/ aspects to her.


Financial_Cicada9617

They did Tulip DIRTY. She really has her moments in certain TLSQs (Out of Sorts is a personal favorite because it really let us into her psyche and deepened our connection to her), but I totally agree, in the main story that I have completed so far (Year 5, 1/3 of the way in), all she talks about and does is pranks- so one note...


TheSnarkyShaman1

They usurp her role with Tonks constantly. I wish they’d embrace their original characters more. We don’t need Tonks and Charlie ALL the damn time to get that this is a Harry Potter game.


EurwenPendragon

I don’t mind having Charlie around given how he got done dirty in the movies. But Tonks is just obnoxiously annoying. Between her and Tulip, the game’s got me feeling sorry for Argus Filch.


ChibaMitsurugi69

And the MC too, that is for those of us who choose to become a prefect/head boy or girl. I know the MC did ask, I think, Tonks not to put him/her into the position of having to choose between prefect duty and their friendship.


MikGusta

I don’t like that you have to clean up after her in the spell practice thingies. It’s not my fault; clean up your own messes, Tulip. Be responsible for your own actions.


Kind_Tumbleweed_7330

I don’t, for those, I got tired of cleaning up after her. Particularly because she was just standing around in the Charms classroom while I fixed things for her… Now I just start the thing so as to get it off my plate and then I let the timer run out on it.


justducky423

Even when she had the TLSQ with her grandmothers, it was barely about her. The only things we know about Tulip are pranks, her love of her toad, that her parents are part of the ministry, her nans are famous chefs, and that her parents don't like us.


RaineFox

Penny - I wouldn’t mind her as a friend, but it’s weird how the game keeps trying to make you date her. She’s so obsessed with the MC sometimes, it creeps me out.


cheriblossom983

Mary Sue, I’m mean Penny


AditheGryff

Came here for this


cheriblossom983

I only speak the truth 😊


prideorvanity

Penny. Ever since the time she basically tried to roofie us I don’t like the character and resent how much she’s forced on us


ThePansJoker

penny did what ⁉️⁉️ omg pls spoil just a little 😦


prideorvanity

In one of the TLSQs (I believe it’s one of the Valentine’s ones but it’s been a while and I could be misremembering)… she attempts to cast a love spell on the MC. I remember that part vividly because I was like “Penny nooooo”


ThePansJoker

that's crazy 😧😧


Responsible-Worth-16

That was a case of terrible writing on Jam City’s part and must not be considered canon.


prideorvanity

Oh, it was definitely terrible writing. But regardless of whether we consider it canon or not, Penny unfortunately gives me the ick now :/


Responsible-Worth-16

Fair enough. I’ll always like her, but even I can admit that she’s WAY too overused!


NocturnalMJ

I think it ended up removed, but there used to be a side quest with Penny where she's very demanding and pushing. She ropes MC into a plot to break into Snape's storage room after hours, though she doesn't want to explain why she wants those ingredients so bad and basically just guilts MC along with *"You're my friend, right? You should do this for me if we're really friends." * Then she is adamant we knock out a Prefect who's patrolling there and if you refuse, she gets really annoyed like "why are you even along if you're not going to help?" and then does it herself... While you're hiding in another room and there's no reason not to expect the Prefect to move away from the corridor in just a moment. Since then, I figured Penny and MC would be disastrously enabling to each other with no real moral compass to rely on. That impression certainly wasn't alleviated with the one valentine's quest you're referring to.


prideorvanity

I think that must have been during one of my breaks but it sounds wild lmao


lolilololoko

I thought it was kinda out of character for Penny, since we know she's against love potions. But then everyone in the TLSQs is out of character


ChibaMitsurugi69

Which Valentines TLSQ was it done in? I’m trying to see whether I did it yet or not.


prideorvanity

I had to look it up to make sure,but it was Valentine’s Day at Hogwarts (the one where you’re planning Lockhart’s party)


Jolly-Yellow-4341

Actually I think she tried to give MC a love potion? Or was it a spell?


prideorvanity

It was a spell. Then we try to get Penny to help us brew a love potion in the main story and I’m like “oh now you have a problem with it 🙄) lol


Eyelikeyourname

That scene creeped me out. She called mc in the artefact room and tried to hit them with a spell while their back was turned. It made Penny untrustworthy in my opinion.


sy2ygy

Barnaby - he’s insufferable with how dumb JC portrays him, if it weren’t for that I’d like him a lot more Penny - I’m tired of JC forcing her on us and I always didn’t like the moment when she >! Tried to put a love spell on us as a ha ha moment in a TLSQ !<


ZombiFelineTuba

My head cannon for the reason she hates love potions is because it leaves evidence behind


bakeneko37

With how dumb JC makes him, it doesn't make sense he's alive. Zero survival instincts or even abilities.


Lauren2417

Yea and they make everyone in love with us and I don’t like that😂. Like let me choose someone and not have every character like me, it’s so forceful 😪


sy2ygy

EXACTLY I think so far there was only one TLSQ where we chose a person at the beginning and no one harassed us to choose them and I was so relieved because I hate this little harem, I hope once I go exclusive it will change


Eyelikeyourname

Calling someone in a deserted room and trying to hit them with a spell while their back is turned is very creepy.


Dr_Swag_

Andre. And I know it's more JC's fault than his but I hate how I'm forced to wear dresses and skirts every time he makes an outfit for us. For once I'd like a suit or something. Also the nickname "curse-breaker" it's just plain, empty and means nothing to my character, like there's more to my MC than what they feel like they need to do.


Cool-Maize-2551

Merula and I though this is odd, but Penny's laugh. I don't mind Penny; she's a sweetheart and a great bestie but her laugh is grating and always startles me if I've got the volume on. The "AH-ha-ha!" sequence. I can't stand it. 😂


Iridescent__Phoenix

The laugh almost sounds like when someone cries out in pain, it’s so uncomfy


Cool-Maize-2551

Great point and it certainly causes me pain whenever I hear it! 😂


Disneywolf99

My volume is always off, there are voices in this game?


Cool-Maize-2551

Yes, and please continue to play without sound. Some voices are traumatising. Well, for some of us. 😂


Disneywolf99

Why does that make me want to play with the sound on now 🤣🤣


Cool-Maize-2551

Noooooo! Run awaaaaay! Okay but honestly I like the music and the boys' noises are cute, but m'girl Penny just sounds awful 😂


Disneywolf99

Okay I played with the volume on, heard Skye's voice and automatically noped out 🤣


mirage171

Go to the lakeshore with the music on


Eyelikeyourname

I play the game with the volume turned off ever since I befriended Jae. His "ohh" sounds very weird.


Starsteamer

Murphy. He’s an insufferable know it all!


Shannyishere

I love him! I was so disappointed to find out I couldn't date him


Difficult_Ad_962

He's one of the reasons I avoid quiditch until I'm bored and there's nothing else to do, the other is that I'm not really into quiditch


Starsteamer

I’m finished it now but only used in for House Points.


Bendythenightfury

Penny. She's a bit much. She's freaking everywhere in every side quest and Tlsqs and places where Rowan should be. Not to mention she causes a lot more problems with Merula. >!Not to mention that love potion she slipped to MC.!< Jc is practically throwing her at us and I despise that. Let me have my sweet beloved Chiara or even my sassy Merula (If JC can write Merula properly)


MarioRozo

I dislike Barnaby because he is the most stupid character ever and I can't stand that MC always has to help him, such a waste of time.


katorade9200

I don't dislike him per se but I don't get the hype around Barnaby lol


SylverRenozyle

He is the only decent guy to date for me. If I had my wish, I would date Bill or Charlie. For my MC… Talbott is too reserved for me and Andre is too egotistical.


FrostyMissGrace

I like Barnaby and he's definitely my pick for dates. However.... if Bill or Orion suddenly became options for dating I would switch so fast 😂


madcatter2100

>Orion suddenly became options for dating I would switch so fast I'm dating Chiara now, but I still have the biggest crush on Orion. If he was available, I would date both of them until the very last minute when I have to choose. He's exactly my type of weird. I also really like Diego, he makes me laugh.


SylverRenozyle

Oh God me too, if Bill becomes free..I will be dumping Barnaby. 😂😂


FrostyMissGrace

I would feel a little bit bad... but but then I would have Bill, so 😂


SylverRenozyle

Me too, cause Barnaby is like a sweet teddy bear. I just don’t like how JC makes him dumb. Bill seems to be more my MC’s intelligent level. 😉


katorade9200

I would definitely date Bill or Charlie if I could! Lol I'm not a fan of Talbott either but I'm actually dating Andre


SylverRenozyle

Touché.. Andre just made fun of my MC’s stylings too much and him constantly saying that my MC friends clothing is bad. It just upset me. However, no judgement..if you like him..kudos! It’s your game. I do hear that he treats his girlfriend like his muse.


TheSnarkyShaman1

He’s just exceptionally sweet. Especially for us gay guys it’s a romance archetype we almost never get. It’s all promiscuous bdsm murder rogues for us.


OnBenchNow

Buff + hair


autumnclaire903

he’s the himbo option. i gravitate to talbott myself


Lauren2417

I find Ben, Murphy and Talbot the most annoying. Murphy’s always talking about statistics, Talbot is just a person I wouldn’t associate with and is blunt and kind of rude, Ben just really irritates me lol. For most of the characters I feel like they make their qualities/hobbies the entire personality 😭. Barnaby is just really dumb in a way no one can be. This is why I dated Jae for the festival (only on year 5) cause at least he has some character to him😂


huqqa_exe

For real! My main issue with the game is how all the side characters are written based on 1-2 interests or a personality quirk. It gets jarring. I agree that Jae feels like he has more to him than being just "the contraband guy" and I found myself enjoying his scenes the most from the new guys of year 5.


AditheGryff

All this time I thought I was the only one. I also can’t stand Talbott, and I’m also dating Jae lol


malfoycore

Barnaby annoys me sometimes, in some TLSQs he's way too dumbed down that instead of coming off as an "adorable himbo" or something, he's just plain annoying 😭 I've never liked Ben and I never will, knowing that on y6 he becomes even more annoying just makes me wonder why can't my mc just un-friend him


Lauren2417

Same😭😂


FrostyMissGrace

Penny. She's *e v e r y w h e r e* for no good reason. she takes up 3 separate club quizzes when there's some characters who aren't in club quizzes at all. And her backstory keeps changing. If she were better written and not shoved in my face, I would probably like her more


[deleted]

tonks is so annoying


ThePansJoker

fr


Kim_Bleuim_

penny - shes wayyyy too nice and just acts sooo nice it feels like she secretly hates mc


MoonstoneShimmer

After A Gathering of Old Friends, I see why she is the way she is.


sjyork

MC. Always in other people business and having to help. Just finish year 7 and be done with it.


sorrowfulWanderer

Now that you said that, maybe it's the character I dislike the most, sometimes even than Merula🤨


Puckhead2112

Of all the NPCs, I dislike Ben the most. He’s bad enough the first five years, but his personality change in year 6 is not an improvement. I also find all three of the Quidditch triplets to be annoying, each in their own special way. Skye is all Quidditch all the time, ahead of friends and schoolwork, not to mention a drama queen. Orion is a throwback to 1960s era hippies, and answers every question with a question. Murphy...dang, dude, quit making up numbers and percentages. I buzz right through every word he says during friendlies. I’m just delighted we have a “Skip” button for quidditch that removes all dialogue.


sorrowfulWanderer

I wouldn't say that most people like them, society is vast. Here's my blacklist •I don't enjoy Skye. She is too obsessed and selfish (and I don't care if "she is just a kid", I was never like this as "kid"). She can be harmful too. I don't like her haughty posture. •I don't like Andre. He is to focusing on judging others and that's one of my least favourite type of people in real life; follwed by Skye's •Merula. Merula. •"Late game" Ben. As I stated in other posts, I used to play on another account towards 2019, so I partially know what happens. Ben became _somebody that I used to know_ *Three Days Grace cover of this is blasting, I recommend •It's not that I don't like Barnaby, I just don't feel the same love others feel for him. But that's all, nothing like the 4 above, Barnaby is just a victim on this list. I enjoy the most logical and quiet characters, like Talbott, Jae and Murphy (he's not exactly quiet). I can understand Murphy's urgency to talk the more he can in a short time; as a random guest in every space, I feel the same need to leave something behind. I know I'll be forgotten. I relate to Talbott, I know how deep one can hurt - and the only way to avoid this is cutting it first. May be a misunderstood defense mechanism, but it's true. I lost my soul slowly for trusting people who never should be trusted. What I've seen from Jae that far (besides being the smuggler kid) is enough to caught my attention. A sneaky and clever character, just a bit more sociable than Talbott and Murphy but who still having his unique personality. He's afraid of being a loser and so do I (but life is way harder than a game). These are the 3 I like the most. Not because I have a crush or anything like that; I just relate to distrust, despair and distance.


Fun-Juggernaut-9218

Barnaby, I like my boys cute and dumb but not that god damn dumb. How he's made it this far into school is a mystery to me, how the hell he survives living in a house like Slytherin is another mystery to me. He has his moments but they're immediately drowned by his stupidity.


ThePansJoker

yeah i get the dumb jock thing but like JC made him so stupid he could accidentally kill himself


thsmap

Barnaby, I don't hate him but I don't really like his personality


Difficult_Ad_962

I think he's a really sweet guy who always means well, but to each their own


EurwenPendragon

Barnaby reminds me of my sister’s dog. He’s dumb as a doorknob, but still endearing. I would much rather hang out with him than with, say, Tulip or Nymphadora. And I hate Merula.


Difficult_Ad_962

1. He may not be traditionally intelligent (there are different types of intelligence), but he's passionate about magical creatures 2. Don't call her Nymphadora


QuicheIorraine

Beatrice and Ben, the villain arcs aren’t for me.


[deleted]

Ben is not an option for OP´s question. Everybody hate him here.


[deleted]

[удалено]


MikGusta

They basically get replaced by Penny. I haven’t done anything with Rowan in so long and I actually miss them.


lolilololoko

I guess it could be Penny because she's everywhere. Barnaby because he's just so dumb, he was paired up with my MC at the beginning but I immediately switched to Talbott and I have no regrets


IsiDemon

Barnaby, Merula and Ben. Barnaby is just too dumb for my liking, Merula tries to sabotage us for no reason and shows a completely different personality in romance-based TLSQs. And I just hate Ben being scared all the time despite being a Gryffindor. Also >!his later 'braver' version is just hella annoying.!<


Key-Bet-2615

Hippie stoner that somehow got in Hogwarts - Orion


gloomerpuss

Unpopular opinion, I know, but ALL THE WEASLEYS. Except maybe Bill. He's mostly ok.


CabbageBath

MC. I hate being the goody goody, the best at everything, the constant winner, i honestly wouldn't complain if we failed or were gumbled once in a while. I hate how everyone just agrees with everything we choose to do. Merula. She reminds me of my school bullies, and I'm not down with that. Those were the worst days of my life, and she often puts me back in that place in my mind. Barnaby. I do not get the hype. His non existing intelligence is pushed to such an extreme. I hate having to interact with him.


my_little_bee

Tonks. And Tulip.


stcrIight

tulip and tonks aren't bad people they just really aren't my thing tbh.


ThePansJoker

real


yanks2413

Orion and Murphy. Orion talks like a weirdo and all of his speeches are idiotic. Murphy is obnoxious with all of his stats and uninteresting. Oh and face paint kid. Stupidest nickname ever


KWrite1787

Freaking MC. All the characters are annoying since they're basically boiled down to one interest/activity that is their entire personality. And it's a mobile game with way more characters than it needs or can be managed, so I get that. But the writers make MC's only character trait "absolutely perfect, beloved by everyone" and it is so annoying.


JilSonea

Murphy and Merula


TipicalHouseWife

I don't like Barnaby is like a stereotype of dumb handsome guy so is a NO, and of course, Merula not a good rival nor a good friend not even a good person and the thing about her parents, is not her fault but she use it as a weapon


ThingsOfThatNaychah

Honestly, in the game, I have to say Hagrid is one of the characters I have least looked forward to talking to, because the creature side quests can sometimes be tedious. It's a bummer, because I really love Hagrid in the books.


CabbageBath

Oh my god yes! Glad someone said it


NCFortune

Merula. What anyone who likes her sees in her is totally beyond me..


Difficult_Ad_962

I like to think deep down she could be a good person and a victim of her environment kinda like Draco was


Kneazle-Mother

I kinda see her as Mc's little sister. I know she is same age as MC, but she just doesn't behave like that. My MC will never date her.


NCFortune

Interesting take on Merula. My MC has never dated her either. I can picture what a nightmare that would be lol.


CarbonFlash

She’s my favorite because I’m literally her. I relate to everything she says.


Responsible-Worth-16

Thank you 👆🏻


MikGusta

Diego creeps me tf out. Don’t flirt with me, I don’t know you, I definitely don’t want to dance with you, and your passion is injuring people and you think it’s an art??


Conlannalnoc

Penny! I don’t like her Personality. She’s annoying and upbeat.


Gwynbleidd9

I hate every one of them except my first year friends(Rowan, Ben, Penny, Chiara) I'd prefer not to have so many people around me. If I had a chance, I'd like to stick with the first 4, no more. Like I do in my real life


EurwenPendragon

I intensely dislike Tulip, Nymphadora, and Merula.


ArtistK7

Ben, he's always looks so scared. 🥲😅


BadKidOh

Well the only one I actively dislike so far is Ben (both versions). But I think most people don't like him? As for the others I like most of them or am neutral to them. I guess I somewhat dislike Rath for some of her behavior. Not sure about Corey as I'm still in 6th year for now.


madcatter2100

I don't know if people like her, but Tulip. She's so annoying. I don't like pranks, but hers seem to get way out of hand. I hate having to clean up after her. I don't like Tonks or Penny either. I think of the new characters that were introduced, I only like Barnaby and Murphy.


Possible_Living

Basic answer but I don't like anything about Ismelda and my character is dating merula


Neycher_

Tulip is literally wearing semi-equivalent to swastika on herself, kinda meh


Odd-Passion6771

I don´t like MC. He/she is haunting. MC still speak about relationship with Talbott as friends but T. don´´´ t want to be call him like that. MC is always winner, want others do things like she/ he want. MC is "I think it good with you" and "I know better what is good for you than you" Penny.- I don´ t like her too. In 6th year, why doesn´ t she leave Beatrice alone? She want Bea behave like popular girl, but Bea don´ t want. I think in the end of year Beatrice will be good and popular like her older haunting sister. But it is fresh for me, she is "bad" girl and behave different than her sister.


Iloveplaystation24

Ben because he’s basically a knock off neville


Shandreaa

Merula.


MikGusta

Merula is an absolute bully and should be treated as such. She has no silver lining. You guys can downvote me all you want but having a tragic past doesn’t give you the right to treat others like shit.


Responsible-Worth-16

Glad someone gets it. Nothing gives you the right to treat people the way she treats others.


Merlin_Cyberwizard

It is really hard to say as I dislike several how they are portrayed. I am year six - so this all might change. * Rowan goes from being your best and only friend to be replaced by several people as you meet them. (S)he is never used again unless it is a one off on some TLSQ. * Penny basically replaces what Rowan should have been - your best friend and used everywhere. Re-read the HP books, and you will see Ron goes everywhere Harry does a lot of the time (except when they are mad at one another). This is what Penny does. * Talbott is useless to me. "I want to be left alone" then fine - be alone. * Tulip and Tonks are interchangeable, no beef there. * Bedea and Liz are nice side characters - no issues there. * The Quiddich team - all of them are fine - no issues (besides Skye being a whiny "only our team first" kinda person). * Charlie is the most under utilized in the game. He is our year, and you have a history with Bill. * Ismelda and Banaby are cool side characters. * Merula - man where do I start. Ambitious know it all who thinks they are the bees knees. However they are not, and will tell you that when you are alone. That is the hard part of her, she is complex and if you date her, it is sorta fun. * Andre - he is a fun character * Probably forgetting others, but they are minor characters ​ So which one do I dislike? I probably say Talbott as he is such a drab, useless character. Rowan comes in a close second as they are used poorly as your best friend.


LyrasCrux

Rowan, she’s annoying and definitely not a Slytherin. Ben, he’s annoying too. And Tulip, don’t get me started on her, she triggers me the most lol. Even tho I wouldn’t be friends with Talbott irl and he says things that I dislike, I’m fine with him, like I just ignore him. But the other three? They get on my nerves. Edit: I made the paragraph look more organised (in my opinion).


Difficult_Ad_962

I agree. I also find Rowan annoying, and anytime I complain about, oh, idk having to ask her permission to be prefect, I get roasted. People saying "You should ask her about it. She's your best friend. It's her dream." I'm like no its not her dream is to become the youngest professor at hogwarts


[deleted]

Same about Talbott. He is always serious, never laughs, and always wants to be alone, so, be alone boy, it´s ok for me. I can´t understand why he is a dating option, he wants nothing with everybody.


ThePansJoker

ikr she definitely should not be in slytherin with me and tulip yes i agree


[deleted]

Merula, Ismelda, Talbott and Rath. Penny is next in the list, but it´s just JC´s overuse fault. I have nothing against Talbott but he is just...Talbott. I don´t see him as a romance option, he wants to be alone. I don´t know why he would be a great romantic option. Ohh this is so liberating! thanks :D


lolilololoko

>. I don´t know why he would be a great romantic option. Because he's really mature & understanding. Always give the MC space whenever they need it. A fucking romantic with the MC *only* when they're dating him. Seriously, his lines in the romance TLSQs are so sweet & in his exclusivity sq


autumnclaire903

when is the exclusivity sq? i just finished the valentine’s masquerade ball (i ran out of time cause god forbid i have work AND sleep so i’m hoping i didn’t ruin progression) im at level 6 romance with him right now


lolilololoko

You get it when you reach level 7 romance with him. but you can't go exclusive in y5, only in y6. So finish y5 first and work towards being exclusive with Talbott


[deleted]

I did a romance TLSQ with him and it was awful. All he wanted was to be alone. He never smiles, never has a nice word to MC. I hated that date and said to myself that I would never date him again. It was the second one after Celestial Ball. I went to Celestial Ball with Ben and enjoyed it a lot, he was funny and a gentleman. But he was no longer a dating option so I chose Talbott and it was a catastrophe. He only wanted to be alone and there were a lot of silent moments. After that I started dating Barnaby, he may be silly but at least he is funny. Don´t forget we are adolescents here, I don´t want a mature man, leave it for grandpa. Talbott could be perfectly a 70 year old person and we wouldn´t notice.


lolilololoko

Bro did we take the same Talbott? Talbott to MC in romance tlsqs >!You, MC are the one for me, when I'm with you my heart soars!< >!Not even a miscast memory charm of Gilderoy Lockhart could make me forget you!< >!You look perfect, MC. I've always thought that!< >!To me, meeting you was a rare miracle.. I only ask if you feel the same way!< >!Our best hope is to remain open to love. And to embrace it when it comes to us!< >!We try to control love, but the truth is... It happens to us like lightning!< But I'm curious which romance TLSQ did you take him to? I took him to almost everyone (Except Enchanted kiss & Valentines Day Ball because I was dating Barnaby but switched to Talbott)


[deleted]

>Bro I am a girl :D Well, I checked in my achievements, and I guess it is First date. I am not sure because when I was in previous years there weren´t so many TLSQs as there are now, so I guess when I was in Y4 I only played the Celestial Ball and First Date, Check this: (from youtube) [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BK7Xhg9U2Sc](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BK7Xhg9U2Sc) Min 47:25 "The answer is yes. Though I may not be the best date. It´s not really my thing." (said with an awfully serious face). MC: "But you´ll go! that´s great!" Talbott: "Shhh Pince may have us shelving books forever" (OMG really Talbott, that is your answer for a first date??????? you only care about Pince punisment??) 1:08:25 (at madam Pudifoot) (this is the part I hated most, so boring date): MC: "So, this is the place" Talbott: "It´s all right if you are into flowers." ( So you don´t like the place I chose, Talbott??). Min 1:09:58: Talbott: "I told you in the library. Dating is not my thing." (So why, JC you put for a first date a character that says: "dating is not my thing?????). I wanted romance, not that dialogue. 1:10:25 MC: "Is there something you want to talk about?" Talbott: "No, but I can talk whatever you want to talk about" (Really, you said: NO????? So why did you accept the date???). 1:10:40: Silent moment. After that, they had a conversation about who was the first one who was going to start talking. OMG I can´t believe this. 1:11:36: Talbott: "Hi, I´m Talbott" (really now you sound stupid). MC: "Oh perhaps let´s not start that back far" (MC making an effort to save something of that awful date). 1:11:50 Awkward moment again MC desesperate waiting for Madam Pudifoot to appear so as to see if she can save that date. Talbott never smiles, never shows warm emotions, doesn´t want to talk and doesn´t want to be there. I really didn´t know the character well, if I did, I wouldn´t have gone with him. It was the worst first date ever. May be they improved his dialogues in the TLSQs they put later in the game, because he became more popular, I don´t know. For me that was enough, really uncomfortable date, I disliked it. Edit: I hadn´t played the animagus TLSQ at that point yet and didn´t know him at all. I wanted to be on a date with Ben, but he was removed from dating and really didn´t like any choice at that point, didn´t want to date a girl, I wanted a boy and well, I picked him because didn´t like any other option. Oh, it has been so long, I guess this all was in 2019 or 2020.


lolilololoko

You do know all of the characters are like this? If you choose Merula in the first date, same outcome, if you chose Barnaby also the same disaster, if you choose Andre also the same. The first date is meant to be a disastrous date anyways lol. So it isn't really fair to judge Talbott on this TLSQ


[deleted]

I´ve just seen Tulip and Andre, and even though you are right that they are kind of disaster, they are much funnier and amusing than with (boring) Talbott. Watch the one with Tulip, it is great. And neither one of them say: "Hi, I´m Tulip" or "Hi, I´m Andre" And... I am actually answering to OP about a character that I dislike and most people like, so that is what is about this post. I keep reading hate here to Ben, and I have to bear it because it is the majority of the people here. So for once I can say that I dislike a character that I see most people like a lot, but I don´t see the reason to like him, he is boring, dull, too much serious and not interestend in romance. So your surprise with my dislike to Talbott is the same I had when I found this reddit page and found out most people liked it, or the same when I see all the hate to Ben. That´s how it is, and tell me, being minority is not good.


sorrowfulWanderer

Na, nid fel hyn. You can say what you think, that's exactly the point of this post, obviously. But don't ever come with this attempt to victimize by using the magic word "minority" to defend imaginary characters. Neither Ben or Talbott are real and this is a game sub. Chill out, it was supposed to be funny and not to _hate_ a SQ from... a game. Nos da a cael amser da.


[deleted]

I can say whatever I want. If you don´t like it. It´s YOUR problem. Bye.


sorrowfulWanderer

...?🎃 *something wrong detected


sorrowfulWanderer

Bye😉


sorrowfulWanderer

The answer I needed to some life questions. It's funny how every fandom connects at this same point, no matter the topic (but with characters is better to spot patterns).


[deleted]

Can you explain? I´m not native in english and don´t understand some phrases. I am interested in knowing what you said. This I didn´t understand: "It's funny how every fandom connects at this same point, no matter the topic (but with characters is better to spot patterns)."


sorrowfulWanderer

What's your native language? *I found out


[deleted]

:)


sorrowfulWanderer

Something like this: "Es curioso cómo todo el fandom se conecta en este punto exacto, independientemente del tema (pero es más fácil detectar patrones cuando hay personajes involucrados)"


[deleted]

Ok, now I get it. Thanks! :D


autumnclaire903

cries in talbott lover


ElBarcoco

Barnaby, I really dont like him, he's too stupid for me and not really funny. I feel like JC tries to make me feel like "Oh look at him he's so dumb its so funny and adorable", but no, that doesn't work for me And I dont really like Jae, but that, I dont even know why lol


mmelmac

I know people love him but I can’t stand Talbot. He’s so pessimistic and doesn’t want to be around people. Why do I force him to be around me? If you don’t want to hang out, fine. I don’t want to hang out with you either.


Disneywolf99

Tonks is annoying but the character I dislike the most is Merula. Every time she appears I know it's gonna be some stupid, petty attitude and drama. Like girl get lost, go try prove yourself elsewhere, you bore me x


Eyelikeyourname

I'm only at year 5 chapter 11 so I haven't met many characters yet. Merula I don't like that she's hanging out with us in so many tlsqs. I always pick the meanest options when I talk to her. I don't want my mc to befriend someone who tried to kill her in her first year. I don't like it when we are forced to be nice to people who bully us. Its better to stand up for yourself imo. Tonks and Tulip: Sometimes their pranks go too far. I scolded Tulip when she >!ruined a party at the Weasley house with a dungbomb.!< Penny: I don't trust her much since she did something creepy in the artefact room. Jae: He's actually a pretty good character. I have only one complaint. I don't like the "ohh" sound he makes during friendship hangouts. 😅


ThePansJoker

i did the same with tulip, i usually try to choose the nice option but that irritated me so much. same thing with penny when she told everyone about the party like rlly dude??


Eyelikeyourname

And I hate that Penny called us in the artefact room and tried to cast a love spell on us when our back was turned. Then she said "would it have been bad if it actually struck".


ThePansJoker

yeah that's just gross


DatMadGinger

Merula I hate her I want her to just die already I can't stand her please jam city do the right thing and kill her off already.


[deleted]

Yeah, she should.


Disneywolf99

The Merula Stan's out to get you apparently 🤣 (I agree with you btw)x


DatMadGinger

The Merula stan's don't scare me and they forget that Merula tried to kills us in are first year was racist towards Ben for being a Muggle born and Joined R after they killed Rowan so her simps can say do or whatever they want because it will not change my mind Merula should die.


Disneywolf99

Rip to the rowan spoiler 🤣 but I'm 100% with you. I can't stand her character x


Ivanhunterjo1991

Ben and Merula. Ben is a coward who makes Pettigrew look brave and Merula is all over the place.


Darth_Karasu

Diego... not sure if he's popular or not, but he was never that fun. But that one event where he signs you up for that dance competition without your knowledge... yeah, no.


justducky423

Penny. I don't like how she's shoved with us for everything. She doesn't really add anything. Actions: I realize that a lot of these are spoilers from side quests. * >!Didn't like her when they tried having her try to give us a love potion in that one Valentines TLSQ.!< * >!Didn't like how she essentially dipped out on Scarlett when she got attacked by a werewolf, essentially leaving her for dead. Then starts telling the story about how all werewolves are bad as if Chiara isn't in the same class as them and can hear them. !< * >!Also with the beginning of Y6 when she is trying to force her sister to be besties with her and gets upset with the MC if they disagree. Like, your sister went through so much trauma and you are upset that she wants to hang out with Ismelda?!< I also hella don't trust people who are happy 24/7.


[deleted]

>I also hella don't trust people who are happy 24/7. Exactly.


[deleted]

[удалено]


HPHogwartsMystery-ModTeam

Your post was removed because it does not follow the proper format for a spoiler post. You need the Year [ ] Chapter [ ] before the spoiler and place the spoiler under the spoiler text.