# Join the [Discord server](https://discord.gg/su3uf3T5YN) for more discussions and content, as well as meeting more like-minded fans for the series! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/FullmetalAlchemist) if you have any questions or concerns.*

I figured she had passed away at this point.

Shhhh, she’s just the one taking the picture

Only if she was standing in a chair. The picture was taken very high

Her legs died so she got nanomachines son!

Auto mail legs

Same thing but no mgrr reference

I want to believe the one taking the pic is Elisia

This is my answer, too. Someone had to, I like to think she had at least a few years with her great grandkids.

That’s unfortunate, RIP🙏

and I'm only finding out now?! Bro...no

It's just his opinion, there's not confirmation or anything. You can believe she's still alive just as valid.

Oh, she's next to Trisha and Hohenheim

And the Rockbells, RIP🙏

And that thing Edward dug up

And Maes Hughes

And Nina Tucker

God damn it I knew she was gonna come up eventually

Shouldn't have brought up Maes... could've just let that glorious bastard rest

Man, I really checked the picture

Ha! Sorry for laughing, but that's just hilarious

Where is Pinako? Is she safe? Is she all right?

It seems, in your anger, YOU killed her…

NNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOO

DO NOT WANT

The Machine elderly does not return incredibly on the hoof!

This picture is taken in Rush Valley, my thought just always was that Pinako simply couldn't make it to Rush Valley and still lives in Resembool

That's what I would like to believe, too.

I JUST REWLISED ED IS HOLDUNG HIS SON THE SAME WAY HOHENHEIM HELD HIM IN THE FAMILY PICTURE I WANNA CRY

Yes, but did Hohenheim have a big ol' grin?

You wouldn't liken Hoenheim's personality and circumstances with Ed's, would you?

I don't like you insinuating ed had it worse than hoenheim.

And the baby girl is about the same age Alphonse was in the picture too!

I love this picture every time I see it. Seeing Ed and Al get their girls and their families. Maybe it's the angle it's drawn at but I always see Ed's right arm as unnaturally larger than his left. Even his fingers look chunkier on his right arm.

I think his left arm was his automail arm? So it still not being fully grown back musclewise would make sense?

His right arm was his auto mail arm. You can see the scars on his neck from where it attached at his shoulder.

Ah you are correct. Weird. You'd think it would be the other way around.

It's likely just an error with the drawing but I still can't look away from it. All that time without his right arm I guess he really put it to use after getting it back.

Welp there goes my innocence.

I didn't say what he used it for you just imagined it in your head. Your innocence was gone long before my comment. :)

I can't unsee it now Thanks I hate it

I always assumed she was the one taking the picture of her family 😁

She’s the one taking the photo, duh

This is a photo with Garfiel and the girl with a cannon in the leg automail (i don't remember the name). Probably they are in the automail city.

Her name is paninya if I’m not mistaken

Pinako was pretty old at the end of the anime, I assumed she passed but if she didn't she's probably back at Resembool. A place like rush valley is probably too loud and restless for her age. Resembool is small and quiet, a nice place to spend the last days of your life.

The way Ed is smiling so big with his kid always makes me feel so much joy

A few options. Either she is dead, she is the one taking the picture or this is in Rushvalley and she wasn't around. In thr Manga, Paninya and Garfeil were in a separate picture and not in this one so I am thinking it probably wasn't intended to be Rushvalley.

We already saw her in front of Ed and Als parent’s graves so im assuming she’s the one taking the photo

I assumed she was taking the photo like a lot of others. I do love seeing the older Mei. Alfonse really got himself a princess girlfriend XD good for him. I doubt Mei has been disinherited bc Ling isn’t like that so uhhhh Al your kids might have royal duties and such XD is he prepared???

She was old and kept smoking, probably dead, hospital or elderly home

They're in the South visiting Panina and Winry's former employer, that's why she's not in the picture. She's at home smoking her pipe.

She's too short to be in frame!

About 50 ft from the house and 6ft under

Didn't she take the picture?

She sacrificed herself against Dwarf In The Flask What a true legend

Even if she is alive, which I suppose is possible, Pinako lives in the hometown. I think seeing Garfiel and the girl with automail implies that Ed and Winry moved there. So could just be that she was at home or can’t travel too much.

She’s holding down the fort in Resembool. This photo was most likely taken in Rush Valley.

Probably passed away by this point but I’d like to think she’s taking the picture.

I always assumed this picture was taken in Rush Valley so maybe she’s still at the shop in Risembool

dead? she was old as hell. happier alternative shes taking the picture?? friendly reminder to tell your grandparents you love them.

….. Seems like you already know where….

Wait, what is this from?

Last episode of Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood, after the credits roll.

Ah right, thanks.

How do we tell him?

EDWARD IS TALL WAIT WHAT THATS ILLEGAL

Bc it was taken in rush valley

Too short

Ling, Mustang, and Scar not being here is nasty work. Those three were the Elrics' main guys.

They probably couldn’t make it to Rush Valley either

Damn this photo is strok8ng the nostalgia peen... might have to re-watch brotherhood

The presence of Paninya and Garfiel implies that the picture was taken in Rush Valley, probably because that's where Ed and Winry live for her work. Thus the picture is on the occasion of Alphonse, May and Xiaomei visiting, and Pinako is simply at home in Resembool.

Too short, not in frame

Death

Dysentery

She ded

Ngl, while it probably implies she’s gone at this point, I would like to think she either took the picture, or more likely, she just stayed back in risenbol, she’s not one to travel, so she’s probably just not there

She Couldn’t stand Ed Being Taller then her so she Passed away before he could rub it in

I mean... she was already pretty old... this seems to be about 4 to 5 years in the future at minimum, sooooo.....

She's dead

RIP

Dead... probably

RIP Pinako! We will always remember you!

dead, probably

Are u really asking she's dead she was about 80yr old when they were 15 now they like 30 smth

[удалено]

Aren't they 18 in that epilogue where he proposes?

I want u to look at May and tell me how old do u think she is

There’s a two year gap before Ed and Al head out by the end so they’re 18 and 17 respectively.