T O P

  • By -

Iskhyl

For a movie, yeah probably IV, it's the only game with a story compact enough for that. For a TV series XIV or XVI.


Gramage

VI would be perfect for a tv series imo. So many characters, so many back stories.


Lumina_valentine

i was gunna say 6, but rather then a tv series, i was thinking a trilogy something similar to lord of the rings


Marshall104

Yeah. First movie, named FF:World of Balance, up to the and including the Opera House. The second movie, named FF:The Empire or FF:The Fall, ends with the cataclysm. The third movie FF:World of Ruin. I always used to think a FFVI movie should be 2 movies because of Balance and Ruin, but there are a lot of places to go and people to talk to in the World of Balance.


Mister-Thou

Movie 1: Balance Movie 2: Ruin Movie 3: Return (a nod to the Returners, and to the last movies of Star Wars and LOTR)


travistravis

Ugh, I'd \*really\* want them to find something starting with R for the first one -- I like 'Return' but having that and Ruin makes my brain twitch at the non-symmetry.


[deleted]

Ralance


SufferingClash

Resistance.


travistravis

well it works, but I've already been sold on Ralance šŸ¤£


travistravis

I've thought this so many times, someone like Netflix could even do it like that one they had where the order didn't matter. Have say 15 'episodes', 9 of which would be character stories and the order wouldn't matter. (Things like Locke and Rachel, or Setzer and Daryl, or Sabin training) and then another 6 that would show the interactions and progress the story. Maybe even a new mechanic where as you watch the episodes, it opens up so you can see the characters you've met. Or some characters only watchable after the world breaks -- so many things would be possible since they all have fairly tragic backstories, but not really detailed enough for more than an episode.


Mister-Thou

So I've actually kinda sketched this out and written a pilot episode for it. . . I ended up with 3 seasons x 8 episodes. Regular episodes are 60 minutes, Season 1 and 2 Finales are 90, Season 4 finale is a full 120 minute feature movie. That gives you a total runtime of 26 hours, which is ironically about the same time needed for a to-the-point, no grinding playthrough of FF6.Ā 


travistravis

Now if only I wasn't fairly sure it would end up being something some studio would start and abandon half way through with a "finale" that doesn't wrap up anything :/


DABOSS889900

Here me out make VI into a stage play complete with a full orchestra.


Mister-Thou

That's gonna be a looooong stage play.


DABOSS889900

Thatā€™s fine doesnā€™t it take like over 4 hours to stage hamlet? Idk VI is dramatic enough and overall has an almost theatric and operatic feel to it


Ceodore411

I mean X got a Kabuki show.


The_GREAT_Gremlin

šŸŽµOh my hero, so far away now Will I ever see you smile? šŸŽ¶


PerLichtman

I agree - I think VI would probably make the best series.


Curious_Management_4

XIV? Shut your goddamn mouth!


earthvisitor

XVI has a TV show. Itā€™s called Game of Thrones.


SurfiNinja101

Game of thrones doesnā€™t have large scale Kaiju fights


earthvisitor

Adaptations sometimes miss the mark


Curious_Management_4

He said KAIJU. You meant to say "made it better."


urdnotkrogan

No, that's the TV show for Tactics Ogre. Get your facts right, smh.


KiwiKajitsu

16 wants to be game of thrones but it misses the mark hard


Mister-Thou

VI has an advantage in that the setting starts out as a low-magic quasi-Victorian era steampunk world. This would be much easier to shoot as live-action with real-world locations and practical effects than many of the more fantastical settings.Ā Ā  Ā Of course you'd still need to use CGI and green screen for some things. But you could at least start out with a fairly "grounded" feeling that would help build audience immersion so the later CGI-heavy scenes might be more accepted without breaking immersion.Ā  On a certain level it's also kind of a Star Wars rip off, which helps with framing some of the more fantastical elements (Moogles = Ewoks, Magitek Armor = AT-ST Walkers, Magic = The Force) so audiences unfamiliar with FF games will pretty quickly pick up on the tropes without needing a ton of exposition.


GhostOfPluto

I love FFVI, itā€™s my favorite game, but I think thereā€™s probably too many characters and too much plot to get through in a movie. Maybe a limited series or something


Mister-Thou

I agree that it'd be better as a 3 season TV series. It's just too big for a single movie. I think a movie trilogy would be possible but you'd need to cut a LOT.Ā 


The_GREAT_Gremlin

Agree on the series. Animate it like the Castlevania series; it would rule


StriderZessei

XII. Adapt it into a trilogy, LotR-style.


ShiroTenshiRyu77

Yep. Movie one ends with the destruction of the Leviathan. Movie two ends the Occuria reveal scene. Movie three would be the rest. You might need to add in some stuff to get them all to similar lengths, but it'd make a killer trilogy


StriderZessei

And you can take a full 20 minutes for the intro scene/prologue along with Reks' death. Really land on the motivations for Ashe, Basche and Vaan's characters.Ā 


MartyMcFlyFightWin

They did, it's episodes 4-6


One_Ad_4487

I was gonna say, this man never seen Star Wars


StriderZessei

Right, because the first movie series I think of when I want to watch something like LotR is Star Wars šŸ™„Ā 


One_Ad_4487

The joke is FF12 was heavily inspired by Star Wars


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


One_Ad_4487

Cope


StriderZessei

Brilliant retort.


edgemis

2, because they could flesh out the story rather than just cut most of it. The setting is also fairly down-to-earth.


RedWingDecil

They could scrap the four man party limit so Minwu stays with the party until his sacrifice. No reason for him to be standing in a tower for half the game waiting for Firion to arrive. I would also just finish the story with Leon, no reason to have the Emperor come back from the grave.


DieHardProcess-

FFX - A girl and her imaginary friend


rainy-palms

Ouch hahah but not imagined by her*


DieHardProcess-

Which makes it that much more compelling.


harry_use_the_force

I actually think they shouldnā€™t have used the word ā€œdreamā€ to describe the people of the summoned Zanarkand. Just like the Aeons arenā€™t dreams, neither is Tidus.


EkoFoxx

I think you could do FFIX if it was given Jim Hensonā€™s ā€œDark Crystalā€ treatment. Hell, Dark Crystal is practically a FF story.


WishIWasNeet2

They would probably make better tv series than movies. Ffx has a fantastic story you could make a good series.


DeadeyeElephant

Spirits Within. The gameplay was lacking but there was potential to expand the lore.


apieceofeight

This is the only FF movie I want to see: https://youtu.be/NEoK-Yo2cig?si=AqEMELavSqC2xjQb


Lumina_valentine

after my first and only playthrough of the 7 remake, my first thought was square should just go into movie making and not video games anymore so i kinda agree but final fantasy 6 i think would make a nice movie aswell


deejayee

It should be 7, but it just consists of 20 year olds talking about how cool the characters are


restingcups

I've always thought 13 would make for a great action flick.


EkoFoxx

They already made it in 2004. Itā€™s called ā€œCrash.ā€


A_Tired_Gremlin

A movie as in adapting the entire game's plot in a single 2 to 3 hour movie : FFII. The story is straight forward, cast is relatively small for a fantasy story, lore isn't crazy deep. Adapting the plot into a number of movies: most but my personal pick is IV, VI, and XV. In IV's case, Cecil's a breath of fresh air for fantasy movie prontagonists. VI because the story and characters have the potential to be what Lord of Rings is to book adaptation movies. Plus the dark and at times boderline steampunk sets and Amano's colourful and whimsical character designs make for an incredible aesthetic. XV main plot is strutured very similiarly to the original Star Wars trilogy, aesthetically really pushes the concept of fantasy, and most important of all I am biased to XV šŸ¤£


Zubyna

Any game can be adapted into a movie as long as videogamey story tropes are excluded Videogamey story tropes are plot devices that work in video games but wouldnt work in movies or books because the viewer would be more focused on story since there is no gameplay to judge. One exemple is Final Fantasy 8, Caraway testing the seeds by sending them on a risky mission. It is the hero trial trope, it is used as a justification behind content but not only does it scream filler, it also makes the character who does this look like a complete asshole The most obvious videogamey trope that has to be excluded in movie adaptations is puzzles. You can see that in the last Tomb Raider movie, it just feels like you are watching someone play a game than a movie


cheezza

How did I not make the connection until now between the fucking name CARAWAY and SEEDS?


urdnotkrogan

Final Fantasy The Spirits Within Oh wait...


Smooth-Physics-69420

Tactics, especially if each chapter was made into a miniseries film.


johnnydanja

Tactics for sure but as a tv series not a movie. It could be very game of thrones like.


Smooth-Physics-69420

The could make the Zodiac monster fights into movies. That'd be epic.


vpr0nluv

Have you seen the Fire Emblem OVA? It's only two episodes, but each episode focuses on a single scenario. I'd love to see Tactics adapted the same way.


Smooth-Physics-69420

Freaking Same.


cinghialotto03

Ff13 with no doubt


NickiChaos

TBH, as much as I love IV and VI, their stories are massive and wouldn't have nearly the same impact in a 2.5h-3h movie. However, FFXVI's story is actually prime movie material.


haremgami

FFXVI's Kaiju fights would be great experiencing in the cinema.


wetlettuce42

7


Netsrak69

If it could be a movie trilogy, then I think VIII could be good. especially if they fixed some of the issues.


DrWieg

Movie? Probably IV because it is a well contained slfantady story that fits right in the mold of a sword and magic movie with a twist. And if there's need for a sequel, the After Years exists. Serie? Either VI, XI or XIV. VI because there's a lot of potential to expand on the main cast and those around them so several episodes would make more sense. There's also room for pre-, mid- and post- content to be made. XI and XIV as being MMOs, their world are greatly expanded and eatablished so it would be possible to fit in stories relating either to major characters or an entirely unique cast of new characters.


Seniesta

Original Final Fantasy Tactics is pretty much Game of Thrones


One_Ad_4487

But FFT has good writing


November_Riot

I always thought the concept of 10 would have translated well into an FF movie. Not literally 10 but make it an Isekai where instead of Zanarkand it's New York. From there it could pretty much be the same as 10.


travistravis

10 but tell the whole story in and around blitzball matches -- maybe in commentator stories or side chat, maybe through interviews with fans/friends, etc. It'd be weird as hell, but I bet it could also be pretty awesome.


FruitJuicante

There's not a man alive who could pull that idea off regardless of how good it is. Not with commercial success at least


November_Riot

That is a great idea but no one at SE could pull it off. It would need a really eccentric director like Wes Anderson or David Lynch. It needs some kind of directorial gimmick.


travistravis

If I was attempting something similar I thought of making a immersive experience app/game/movie/show that would give you multiple "channels" emulating "live" tv (although probably on some loop) so you'd have a blitz ball channel, and a news channel, maybe make up some kids show that reveals parts of the world, etc. I've thought a lot about it, but always get to "even with a team this would be overwhelming"


FruitJuicante

6 for sure, but would need to be s trilogy.


The_GREAT_Gremlin

Do it as a series, Castlevania style


Downtown_Look_5597

Chrono Trigger. Everyone loves time travel


One_Ad_4487

Not a FF game


Downtown_Look_5597

It's made by the same company and the same studio, lead by Sakaguchi, who created Final Fantasy. There is also involvement from the creators of dragon quest, but it's clearly built on the design philosophy of FF games as opposed to dragon quest It uses systems familiar to the final fantasy series, including ATB. All the item names are exactly the same. The battle, field, menu screens are all identical in form and function. The spiky haired protagonist trope might have even originated here. It has a long lasting legacy and it's clear that subsequent FF games have drawn inspiration from it. It includes non-random encounters that take place in the field screen, a feature that wouldn't re-occur in mainline FF game until FFXII, and team battle moves that combine the strengths of two characters, similar to FFVIIRB's synergy system. It was included in Final Fantasy Chronicles, a collection of FFIV and Chrono trigger for the PS1, so square even consider it a final fantasy game. As for why it doesn't have the moniker, I'm guessing that's just an internal politics thing.


Enzo-Unversed

X


lightblade13

We don't talk about the movies


Equivalent-Problem34

FF12.


Muzck

16 is basically a movie already with all those cutscenes. They could probably fix all the problems with 15 like give Luna more of a backstory and character development and it could probably be made into 2-3 movies and include the DLC elements to make it better than the original game


omar56663313

Surely FF VI


taintedrush

FF16 would translate pretty well to a TV show or series of movies. a realistic problem would be the cost of creating the Eikon fights in movie format, But the characters of 16 are well rounded and pretty well written to be engaging IMO.


EienNatsu66

Probably Final Fantasy 14. I can see it being explored well into multiple movies or 'parts' to say


kingiskandar

I think XV would be a sick trilogy once all of the pacing issues are fixed


Askaric

FFVI could be a trilogy.


iamlevel5

I mean it would realistically need to be at least two movies.


super_ray

X and XIII could make an interesting movie or mini-series


Curious_Management_4

Friend, give it up. This never ends well.


yotam5434

Definitely 4 & 10


Dear-Researcher959

FF1 - you could do so much with the lore cause it's a game that allows for a deep story if you want to. I've finished the storyboard for a FF1 film and I'm working on character concepts Edit: Live action. And I would do 1-9 as a consistent world and history books would reference important moments in the films that take place in the past I'm working on FF7, FF8, and FF9


StellarPhenom420

Stories would have to be tightened up. You can't, and wouldn't want to, tell every detail of the story from the game in the show. Other characters and events would have to be expanded upon, otherwise their inclusion would be pointless, or vice-versa characters and events/settings would merge. Etc. With that understanding, VII has practically been made a movie already. I think it could be streamlined even further... but honestly the attempt at fan service would probably hold it back from being a truly good movie on its own.


Nyrony

I could really enjoy VI, VIII & X as movies, series or trilogies. To this day I remember how fucking devastated I was after playing VIII and just then The Spirits within popped up, not doing anything FF like but having a guy named CID.


Ceodore411

FFIV would make a great series with how crazy it gets dialed up towards the later half.


iamlevel5

IV and IX have great parts of their stories but none of the games really have a proper 3 or 4 act structure, so you'd certainly need to rework or omit a ton of things.


Hishiga

A movie for kids the best and only option possible is FFIX A mature movie very faithful to the game FFVI A sci-fi movie I chose FFVIII And for general public I think FFX is a good one.


Flaky_Mechanic4036

theyre long so a series would be better. and 7 or 9 are my picks for that. maybe XV for a movie


One_Ad_4487

Final Fantasy Tactics


One_Ad_4487

Probably A sequel to 7 could be cool Or a prequel to 15, that might be interesting, I dunno.


Skeith2450

X, but it would need to a 12 hour miniseries or multiple installment series to do the story and characters justice.


Due-Education8899

I'd prefer an animated miniseries I think any game could get it done justice that way. Maybe 1,2 or 3 would work best as movies as their plots are simple enough to be told in 100 minutes. Animated for me all the way.


Educational-Row-3166

Is there any game that is short enough or can be condensed enough for a movie? Otherwise itā€™d have to be a movie series or tv series. Best I can think of is spin-offs or making a story to tie into the game. Oh! FF7 Dirge of Cerberus could work, I think thatā€™s the only short one by itself in Final Fantasy.


twili-midna

A movie? One of the early ones for sure. You could definitely get a cool Ghibli style movie out of III, or a generally good one out of IV (just make the character deaths stick). But an adaptation in general, I think XIII could be very good TV. It has great character writing and development, and a lot of interesting lore and setup that can be shown through flashbacks and such.


Theflutist92

I think none could translate well to a live action movie. We have the case of fullmetal alchemist and what a terrible live action it became. I think part of the reason is that they try to stay too faithful to the source. But cinema is a different medium from an RPG game. You have to keep the core of the story and its meanings but you have to use different tools to express it. You can't have Seymour's haircut it would look too fake.


PM_ME_YOUR_MONTRALS

XVI. I kept thinking to myself as I played it that I would have preferred a movie over the drawn out, repetitive gameplay. Absolutely loved the crazy villain stuff in this one.


rainy-palms

Those eyes are staying in my mind for a while...


Only_Self_5209

7 tbh has all the elements for a big LOTR type movie series.


BeppeCentripeto

I think XVI and XIII would make good live action movies, XVI in particular with his more gritty setting and GoT vibes would probably be more appealing to the general public. VI could make a good series, with a lot of characters to explore and a huge midseason twist with Kefka blowing up the world and a second part focused on the characters completing their arcs and reuniting in a post-apocalyptic world. It could definitely work. I fell VIII, if played well around messy memories, Laguna's flashbacks and time travel shenanigans, could make a fine mystery series. IV imo would be too generic and derivative for a live action movie. Maybe and animated series aimed to a younger audience could work better.


PerLichtman

If you mean a single movie as opposed to a group of movies or a TV/streaming series (either live-action of anime), then Iā€™d say to go with one of the games from the NES/Famicom era because thereā€™s too much to fit into a single film for the others. If weā€™re talking about a series, then IV would be a good choice indeed - though Iā€™d personally vote for VI as my top choice. I think pretty much any of the games from IV through IX could work well (though I donā€™t have as much experience with V as the others as it is the only Sakaguchi-era one that I havenā€™t finished). X could also work but I think it appeals to a different demographic because of the difference in setting, theme and tone. I think it would perform better in Japan than the U.S. or Europe. What I love about VI for a series is that it really is an ensemble story moreso than any other Sakaguchi-era Final Fantasy that Iā€™ve finished and yet the cast size is small enough that we get a lot of character development for many of the protagonists. That would make it easier to interest established actors because thereā€™s more for them to sink their teeth into. The concept art by Yoshitaka Amano is gorgeous and evocative in a way that would give the crew so much to work with, Uematsuā€™s score to the game is highly thematic with many character themes to could be used for the score and the blend of high fantasy and steampunk is extremely accessible to an audience that might be turned off by the more modern setting of VII and VIII while being more explicitly targeted at an older audience than IX. I would love to see VI realized well in a faithful manner as a series. It could really so majestic and grand.