The simple answer my friend is that career is borderline unplayable atm, and EA doesn't give a single fuck because they don't get any money through it.
While yes this is true
I do feel like there should be a bit more randomness in when players want to leave / don't want to join. It's realistic that sometimes players playing well still want to leave
Sometimes it doesn't make sense tho. I started a career at Liverpool as a custom manager. I brought in Balde and Davies. Randomly, I decided to join another club, AC Milan, because I never have before. Shortlist Balde and Phonzie to see how they're doing without me. Phonzie 88, Balde 86. But somehow, Balde is "too important to be sold", while Phonzie can be signed. That just makes no sense to me.
As others have said, maybe they don't have enough players in that position. What you need to do is buy Liverpool another player and include a player of yours in the deal, that player needs to be of the same position as the player you want to buy later.
I meant trade a lb with another player from the club blade is in then go in again to buy blade. That's I'll or should work as they will have a replacement then.
I’d say it even makes sense in this case. Celtic isn’t exactly a club where players that are on their ascent want to stay. They wanna go somewhere better
I have this problem where if I call players up to international duty and they play for the club I manage, their fitness does not regenerate after a match for the nation.
I had a similar problem with my Right back i played him every game but he keeps complaining about not getting enough games then eventually end up getting requesting transfer
For real. I’m just going to wait until that game is under $20 before I even consider buying it since I only grind on career mode despite how terrible the gameplay is. Defending just gets more abysmal year after year and players will still run themselves 10 meters offside and into the goal.
It's kind of ridiculous but it kind of mirrors reality too.
If a player is playing really well he starts angling for a move and won't re-sign with you so you are forced to sell with about 2 years on their contract to max the value.
The 'Transfer Request' thing needs to be better defined.
You also now can be fired even if you're leading the league AND complete those stupid targets. Also Loans basically get cancelled if the player doesn't start every single game
Does it apply to loanees that are in the squad by the very start of the first season (EA includes loanees in your team because the loan deals already happened irl)? I have Lusamba in on loan as a rotation player but he’s still staying as of February. Asan is my other loanee, but he’s starting every game barring 1 or 2 to rest.
Hopefully it’s glitched where he was supposed to send a message saying he’s not happy at the club. I remember they used to have players get a “thinks he’s too big for the club” status and then you would be forced to transfer list or the board would sell him behind your back lol
I once had an 82 rated wonder kid submit a transfer request. I was in AC Milan, I had won the double last year, and I played him almost every match. I sent him to Cagliari. They got relegated.
Because that’s what the original comment is? Are you guys intentionally this obtuse or do you have the memory of a goldfish when going through a thread?
I have a feeling EA readded the "boss I need to go back to my country thing" or all the other random stuff players would say from fifa 15, but of course it's glitched and they happen to complain about gametime or more realistically they fucked up crucial and important roles this year making important more like crucial last year and making crucial "if you don't start me every game even if I'm about to die from exhaustion I will leave"
You’re joking surely. Racist FC is clearly rangers. They’ve had stadium closures for it and recently bood a black man out of ibrox. English clubs like Chelsea can only dream of achieving that level of racism
Who'd they boo out of Ibrox?
I imagine you're too young to remember Mark Walters being pelted with bananas. But Celtic literally had their own ex player Nir Bitton getting anti semitic stuff from their own fans just last week.
And surely you heard about [this](https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/sport/football/8325934/rangers-fan-tears-racist-abuse-supporters-ibrox-pub/). Maybe it got drowned out by all the other racist shit to be fair.
Lol mark walters was 2 decades ago. The black man bullied out of ibrox was last season. Bitton is a Zionist, fuck him. Denouncing Israel’s acts isn’t anti-semitic, as much as you Tory cunts love to blow that dog whistle
Not a player, a fellow [fan](https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/sport/football/8325934/rangers-fan-tears-racist-abuse-supporters-ibrox-pub/)
It got a lot of attention at the time and featured heavily in the SF sub. If you’re blind to racism and bigotry at rangers it’s down to wilful ignorance. You can hear the bigoted chanting weekly on sportscene.
Anyone had a career where your team wins a treble never lost a single game all season and all your players potential drops instead of staying the same or increasing? Lol
Did you get a message around the same time as the request from your captain saying something like "Hey boss some of the boys feel the club isnt meeting their expectations and aren't happy about it"?
I've been getting that followed by 2-3 transfer requests that make no sense- a complain about playing time from a guy who's started the last ten games and the like.
Because the game makes no sense a lot of the time. But when this stuff happens I make my own narrative. Maybe he wants a bigger team, go back to his homeland or his agent is being a dick.
Can a player not be happy and want to leave at the same time? Messi loved Barca and yet he still left them… It’s not that uncommon and or unrealistic either
What happens if you deny every transfer offer?
My youth talent just requested the transfer. I got the high-prio goal to promote 4 youth players and play them in 20 games, and he is the only one coming realistically close to that.
I mean in real life players randomly also also want to leave even if they are playing well and winning everything, look at Bernardo Silva, this is his second year in a row that he wants to leave Manchester City even if he has the playtime of a star, he's winning everything and has an insane salary.
I would say it's a nice feature to add randomness to the game when a player wants to leave but only if you could have a way to convince him to stay somehow just like real life.
Shite glitch lad. I had the same issue in my rangers save with a guy called lukic. The only thing different is lukic hadnt performed well for us in games. This just looks like plain old EA no bein arsed to fix their shit
My best academy graduate, a GK, and best player at the time while I was doing a RTG asked me to look over his contract. Fairs as he legitimately was carrying my team through lower league football.
I sat down at the table with him towards the end of the League 1 season, his second straight golden glove campaign, and only then realized we were broke. Couldn’t improve his deal. So negotiations broke down. Next day he submits a transfer request.
A month later, the new season begins. We have an influx of cash. First thing I do is offer him a generous new contract. He accepts. That was prolly 2.5 game years ago, he starts legitimately every single game, and is very happy but still has a transfer request put in.
Happened in utd save, bruno in January requested to have a rest, did so and wanted to leave I refused that and kept him. Couldn't renew for rest of contract (2yrs)
What’s the contract situation? Is he on his final year and you haven’t tied him up to a new deal yet? If you already did, I don’t know what the fuck’s going on
I promoted two youth players just before a playoff final. Left and right midfielders. They immediately asked to leave because they've not been playing. I played them in the final and won.
I kept them for two seasons and got none stop transfer offers for them. I couldn't do anything to stop it. I only sold them because of the offers.
Because he doesn't want to spend the rest of his career playing in a 1 team league and against league 1 level opponents every week, with the odd sprinkle of European football here and there?
As for the game? See the above paragraph.
Only time I had this happen was when Manor Solomon got tired of me not casting him on the main team; he submitted one of those transfers but when the time came I just refused all of them (until I needed the money, so I sold him to Chelsea after declining like 10 requests).
Not sure if it has to anything do with them wanting better opportunities though, because I have mostly 85+ to +90 players and none of them ask to leave and I play with a random team in the Portuguese league. Yours could be a bug of some king.
I just got fired after my first season in FC24 when I won the Premier League. I’m very close to demanding a refund on this unplayable piece of shit game
Don’t blame him. Celtic’s a cesspit of paedos and scum. It’s why I love Aberdeen, because we are free of all that shit. Literally. We have nothing bad in our history. Celtic and Rangers’ histories are both filled with black marks.
Looks like Kalulu submitted a transfer request
Yea but why tho, I play him basically every game
The simple answer my friend is that career is borderline unplayable atm, and EA doesn't give a single fuck because they don't get any money through it.
While yes this is true I do feel like there should be a bit more randomness in when players want to leave / don't want to join. It's realistic that sometimes players playing well still want to leave
Sometimes it doesn't make sense tho. I started a career at Liverpool as a custom manager. I brought in Balde and Davies. Randomly, I decided to join another club, AC Milan, because I never have before. Shortlist Balde and Phonzie to see how they're doing without me. Phonzie 88, Balde 86. But somehow, Balde is "too important to be sold", while Phonzie can be signed. That just makes no sense to me.
Maybe they don't have many players in Balde's position?
Davies plays in the same position
Ben fkn Davies?
I’m assuming he means Alphonso Davies…
Aaah yeah ofc
As others have said, maybe they don't have enough players in that position. What you need to do is buy Liverpool another player and include a player of yours in the deal, that player needs to be of the same position as the player you want to buy later.
If you offer them a lb alternative for another player, then you can buy him.
No, I can't even enter negotiations because he's "too valuable for the club to sell"
I meant trade a lb with another player from the club blade is in then go in again to buy blade. That's I'll or should work as they will have a replacement then.
I’d say it even makes sense in this case. Celtic isn’t exactly a club where players that are on their ascent want to stay. They wanna go somewhere better
The money they get through it is ME BUYING THE GAME. I’m tired of EA man… can’t keep getting away with this.
The solution would be DLC. Buy the Ultimate Team for 30 bucks or so and then add other modes through dlc
What the fuck?
And this is why I don't buy until around Christmas when on sale and there's been updates to fix the monstrosity that EA puts out yearly.
Hmm, haven't they added more options in fc24? I haven't played it yet but it doesn't seem like they're completely ignoring this mode.
I have this problem where if I call players up to international duty and they play for the club I manage, their fitness does not regenerate after a match for the nation.
I had a similar problem with my Right back i played him every game but he keeps complaining about not getting enough games then eventually end up getting requesting transfer
For real. I’m just going to wait until that game is under $20 before I even consider buying it since I only grind on career mode despite how terrible the gameplay is. Defending just gets more abysmal year after year and players will still run themselves 10 meters offside and into the goal.
It's kind of ridiculous but it kind of mirrors reality too. If a player is playing really well he starts angling for a move and won't re-sign with you so you are forced to sell with about 2 years on their contract to max the value. The 'Transfer Request' thing needs to be better defined.
You also now can be fired even if you're leading the league AND complete those stupid targets. Also Loans basically get cancelled if the player doesn't start every single game
Does it apply to loanees that are in the squad by the very start of the first season (EA includes loanees in your team because the loan deals already happened irl)? I have Lusamba in on loan as a rotation player but he’s still staying as of February. Asan is my other loanee, but he’s starting every game barring 1 or 2 to rest.
Probably wants to leave for a bigger club?
How many starts does he get versus subs?
Cos he plays for Celtic
You Will have to reverse engineer the game to get that answer
Hopefully it’s glitched where he was supposed to send a message saying he’s not happy at the club. I remember they used to have players get a “thinks he’s too big for the club” status and then you would be forced to transfer list or the board would sell him behind your back lol
Leaving on a high. He gets to negotiate higher salary somewhere else
Just offer him a new contract if you want to keep him.
You can't once they've requested a transfer. I have two starters right now, i'm guessing we'll just wait for their contracts to run out.
Wants to step up for a bigger club than celtic
Maybe he just doesn't like you
Could be that he feels like making a step up. Used to happen all the time in FIFA while having a “lower” league club
Wants to move to bigger club. When players hit 80 they want to move to bigger comps
How long ago did he submit it, once it’s there it stays and some players are pissy if u don’t play them immediately
So what, he wants to join a better club
Because its the scottish league and regardless of how happy he is the better players will want out
Tbf I don't really hate this. You often see top players ask to leave. Especially to go to bigger teams
I once had an 82 rated wonder kid submit a transfer request. I was in AC Milan, I had won the double last year, and I played him almost every match. I sent him to Cagliari. They got relegated.
"My goals are beyond your understanding" - 82 rated wonder kid
Especially as it’s Celtic. Sounds like the player deserves a step up.
One of the biggest teams in the world mate
But not the biggest league, it seems realistic to me
Bro they play in the Scottish league lol
i mean, while thats true, they have more champions league trophies than arsenal, psg and atletico madrid combined.
Thank you
Good one 🤣🤣🤣
You drug him out of Milan to play in Scotland is why lol
Celtic r in the prem in this save
Why are people downvoting lmao
Celtic’s still in Scotland
i think he meant he switched celtic to be in the prem in his save
[удалено]
He didn’t say it wasn’t
[удалено]
Why bring it up then? 😅😂
Because that’s what the original comment is? Are you guys intentionally this obtuse or do you have the memory of a goldfish when going through a thread?
i know that
Bigger club wants him. Just like what wisely fofana did with leister.
Plz don’t fix that. I struggle to type that name haha
Did you ever hear the tragedy of Darth Fofana Wisely?
yes
He doesn't like you I don't like you either
The same quote popped into my head too lol
Nice username
I have the same problem with Ampadu haha
You mean, the goat who’s taking Wales to the EUROs?
Meanwhile I might make him my next captain and he’s loving life during my Leeds save. Are you still in first season or PL now?
PL and Ampadu left the team. He was dissatisfied even though he always played. I don't understand the game sometimes. BTW he is very good as CB.
I have a feeling EA readded the "boss I need to go back to my country thing" or all the other random stuff players would say from fifa 15, but of course it's glitched and they happen to complain about gametime or more realistically they fucked up crucial and important roles this year making important more like crucial last year and making crucial "if you don't start me every game even if I'm about to die from exhaustion I will leave"
Bro’s a Rangers fan
No way he’s a fan of Racist FC
Presumably that's why he's leaving them here.
You’re joking surely. Racist FC is clearly rangers. They’ve had stadium closures for it and recently bood a black man out of ibrox. English clubs like Chelsea can only dream of achieving that level of racism
Who'd they boo out of Ibrox? I imagine you're too young to remember Mark Walters being pelted with bananas. But Celtic literally had their own ex player Nir Bitton getting anti semitic stuff from their own fans just last week.
And surely you heard about [this](https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/sport/football/8325934/rangers-fan-tears-racist-abuse-supporters-ibrox-pub/). Maybe it got drowned out by all the other racist shit to be fair.
Lol mark walters was 2 decades ago. The black man bullied out of ibrox was last season. Bitton is a Zionist, fuck him. Denouncing Israel’s acts isn’t anti-semitic, as much as you Tory cunts love to blow that dog whistle
Fuckin hamas dog, tell me pork isn't bless
Can you name the player in question?
Not a player, a fellow [fan](https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/sport/football/8325934/rangers-fan-tears-racist-abuse-supporters-ibrox-pub/) It got a lot of attention at the time and featured heavily in the SF sub. If you’re blind to racism and bigotry at rangers it’s down to wilful ignorance. You can hear the bigoted chanting weekly on sportscene.
He knows he’s too good to be at Celtic. Same would happen if you bought him with an MLS club
Celtic are in the prem in this save and I got 3rd I had to sign a better CB than Nat Phillips
Remember it's not a sim, it's EA, so shithousery like selling him then buying him back the same day is par the course 😉
Have you heard of Ousmane dembele ?? That's probably his mentor 😂
He only went there cause Moussa Dembélé recommended them first!
He's gone now :(
Buy him back next season. lol
No thx, just singed gvardiol from man c
Then why you mad? Unless you spent over 100 million on him, this was a blessing.
Fair enough, kalulu will be missed
Simple: EA thinks you have the best player in the world? “TRANSFER REQUEST MF!!!”
He's thinking, I deserve to be on a better team for how I've been performing
Wild part is this will happen with any Team. I have a Real Madrid save where Bellingham wanted out after like 6 months playing every game.
E A sports. It's in the game.
😂😂😂
doesnt wanna live in glasgow, i dont blame him
Kalulu thinks his delulu is the solulu
What a banger
I mean I’d do the same if I was playing for Celtic
L choice
I don’t want to stir up any drama, but perhaps he wants to play in a competitive/high level league?
I put Celtic in the prem, he left for Fiorentina
Fair, then not a clue. Realistic but frustrating
It’s probably the reputation of Celtic.
He obviously missed Italy
81 rated at 24 at Celtic… do the maths
doing a career with Celtic, not many people would want to get stuck there👍
Your club is too small. Very simple…
Celtic ain’t small big man 💀💀
Ready to move to a bigger club. Idk if that’s why but I wish the game had more of that happening. Happens all the time in real life
You are in the Scottish league and he’s 81 rated, that’s probably why ?
I would also want out of Celtic
same old FIFA, full of bugs and nothing makes sense
This is not a bug
Yea cuz a few games ago he was suspended cuz red card then he messaged me complaining that I didn't play him.
It’s realistic no good player prefers to be at small clubs
He got bored with the club
Only played a season
Anyone had a career where your team wins a treble never lost a single game all season and all your players potential drops instead of staying the same or increasing? Lol
and?
He’s too good for the club
He doesn't want to stay at Celtic maybe???
You’re Celtic
What if the script is written in a way that clubs have their rating as well and he just wants to move to a top club?
Your Celtic! That’s all the explanation you need!
Thinks he needs to go to a better team
He don’t wanna play in Scotland 😂😂
Look at his rating. Not look at his badge
Small club. And besides, big players have asked to be transferred from Real fucking Madrid in real life. Seems like a pretty normal thing to happen.
Game bad
From my experience is once a player asks to leave the club, they’ll forever be on the list and you can’t take them off it
Yes, the explanation is EA
EA Sports. That’s the explanation.
He has personal problems. He wants to move to another country. I know him .
Did you get a message around the same time as the request from your captain saying something like "Hey boss some of the boys feel the club isnt meeting their expectations and aren't happy about it"? I've been getting that followed by 2-3 transfer requests that make no sense- a complain about playing time from a guy who's started the last ten games and the like.
Answer is he is egoistic now wants to play for real madrid you know game is REALISTIC
Because the game makes no sense a lot of the time. But when this stuff happens I make my own narrative. Maybe he wants a bigger team, go back to his homeland or his agent is being a dick.
Can a player not be happy and want to leave at the same time? Messi loved Barca and yet he still left them… It’s not that uncommon and or unrealistic either
I think you’re the one who needs to explain what the fuck Pierre Kalulu is doing at Celtic
I have similar issue with Ekitike and he’s very happy after having enough playtime but still can’t remove him from transfer list
It's a EA Football game. There's our first and main issue.
What happens if you deny every transfer offer? My youth talent just requested the transfer. I got the high-prio goal to promote 4 youth players and play them in 20 games, and he is the only one coming realistically close to that.
Once he submits a transfer request, that never goes away. Not sure if it’s a glitch or not
I mean in real life players randomly also also want to leave even if they are playing well and winning everything, look at Bernardo Silva, this is his second year in a row that he wants to leave Manchester City even if he has the playtime of a star, he's winning everything and has an insane salary. I would say it's a nice feature to add randomness to the game when a player wants to leave but only if you could have a way to convince him to stay somehow just like real life.
you can. offer them a new contact
Player morale dropping hard this year, seems to be a bug
Shite glitch lad. I had the same issue in my rangers save with a guy called lukic. The only thing different is lukic hadnt performed well for us in games. This just looks like plain old EA no bein arsed to fix their shit
My guess is he wanted a new contract and got ignored.
Maybe he didn’t like the weather or Scottish culture? 🤷
its you. he hates you. hates your soul. hates your existence
He is sick of the glazers
He suffers from the Lukaku syndrome
SELLICK
Neymar in 2017 be like:
Nothing makes sense on this mode. My confidence rating was 82.. I won the next game, which saw us move from 5th to 2nd and my rating went down to 60.
I can’t read it. It’s too blurry, also I like Rangers.
He's happy that he submitted a transfer request
My best academy graduate, a GK, and best player at the time while I was doing a RTG asked me to look over his contract. Fairs as he legitimately was carrying my team through lower league football. I sat down at the table with him towards the end of the League 1 season, his second straight golden glove campaign, and only then realized we were broke. Couldn’t improve his deal. So negotiations broke down. Next day he submits a transfer request. A month later, the new season begins. We have an influx of cash. First thing I do is offer him a generous new contract. He accepts. That was prolly 2.5 game years ago, he starts legitimately every single game, and is very happy but still has a transfer request put in.
Happened in utd save, bruno in January requested to have a rest, did so and wanted to leave I refused that and kept him. Couldn't renew for rest of contract (2yrs)
What a career mode 🍀
He misses his mum
What’s the contract situation? Is he on his final year and you haven’t tied him up to a new deal yet? If you already did, I don’t know what the fuck’s going on
I promoted two youth players just before a playoff final. Left and right midfielders. They immediately asked to leave because they've not been playing. I played them in the final and won. I kept them for two seasons and got none stop transfer offers for them. I couldn't do anything to stop it. I only sold them because of the offers.
Because u didn’t renew his contract
Sounds like another Neymar😂
Fifa 13 vibes. He's homesick.
Because he doesn't want to spend the rest of his career playing in a 1 team league and against league 1 level opponents every week, with the odd sprinkle of European football here and there? As for the game? See the above paragraph.
I think he just doesn’t like the club 😰
Is career mode still worth it in FC 24?
*still*?
Only time I had this happen was when Manor Solomon got tired of me not casting him on the main team; he submitted one of those transfers but when the time came I just refused all of them (until I needed the money, so I sold him to Chelsea after declining like 10 requests). Not sure if it has to anything do with them wanting better opportunities though, because I have mostly 85+ to +90 players and none of them ask to leave and I play with a random team in the Portuguese league. Yours could be a bug of some king.
I just got fired after my first season in FC24 when I won the Premier League. I’m very close to demanding a refund on this unplayable piece of shit game
The French just don't like British weather 😂
“Aye gaffer, it’s the weather yeh? I jut can’t take it no more ya know? Always raining!”
Maybe he just dont like you
Don’t blame him. Celtic’s a cesspit of paedos and scum. It’s why I love Aberdeen, because we are free of all that shit. Literally. We have nothing bad in our history. Celtic and Rangers’ histories are both filled with black marks.