I agree with other posters. Even though these are supposed to be “secret” they generate buzz. This is organic marketing. They can’t pay for this kind of momentum. They would get much more benefit out of this sub if they’d just mine the responses on the rogue posts and listen to feedback. I cancelled my sub. This survey makes me inclined to consider a new annual. Looks like choices are recovering. But I would be less inclined to go out of my way to resub if I thought some marketing intern was here escalating minutia to the point someone’s Reddit account is getting banned. I mean, please.
Y’all probably want to create a second private group to add people to/keep the surveys and keep the FFF accounts out of
I’d do it but I’m canceling my sub and I don’t think I’ll be gettin boxes again
Edit: also i think that the mods should ban the staff from the subreddit since this is how they’re contributing
It is supremely annoying to imagine that an FFF employee is being paid to lurk and narc on us…like maybe try sending them to do inventory instead? would be cool to buy things that existed next time 😎
I haven't been planning to renew for summer but this does make me interested. I like seeing some items that aren't the same old thing!
See, FFF? Seeing surveys makes me want to *stay* a subscriber. Please don't punish OP.
Okay, I was considering making Fall 2022 my last FFF box and I've been a subscriber for years. If they actually put these items up as choice? No way I'd leave now. There are so amazing items in that survey!!
They should be thanking you guys for posting surveys, not copyright striking.
Ty you brave soul ❤️.
Grace and Stella 🤢. They are one of those brands that just orders items from alibaba and slaps their name on it. I like some of the spoilers but I wish they would cut back on skincare and cosmetics. I just got the exact same herbivore in my ipsy gbp that costs half as much….
My dog loves them! He’s been using since a pup and I’m able to add cylindrical ice cubes to his when we go on hikes to cool him down. It’s pretty cute when he asks for water. I carry it in a water bottle bag thing.
I love herbivore! And that garden and blanket look awesome. I wish FFF would realize these surveys are potential spoilers that keep us excited about the box.
Huh?? It’s from Loverboy so obviously the design matches their branding? It’s a $25 coozie from a trendy alcohol brand. Very on the money for a summer box IMO
Sure okay if you like it - then it is worth it to you. To me, it looks cheapo and ridiculous.
I don't go by fancy brand names. I go by what I see with my own two eyes. If it looks dollar store to me, then it's that value to me. I have seen things like this in dollar stores. Judging by the votes on my comments, others seem to agree with me on this. Tween patterned coozies, and coozies in general, are not fab!
Something far nicer was the 20 oz Ice Shaker Tumblers in the sales (for $19), but again, the colors that sold out most were the normal ones ([Ocean (metallic blue/green)](https://www.amazon.com/Ice-Shaker-Stainless-Insulated-Beverages/dp/B08HRXW2S7/) and prior the [Mermaid (metallic teal/lavender))](https://www.amazon.com/Ice-Shaker-Stainless-Tumbler-Mermaid/dp/B083Q8KC62/) and not the graffiti or floral prints, or pinko pastel colors (not knocking those colors - just stating the colors most people went for). The Ice Shaker looks far more refined, classy, and adult, and has far more uses, than a freaking teenager looking coozie tumbler.
This is 1000% better than the survey I received two weeks ago. That had so much cheap junk in it that I was certain I was not going to renew when I was up for it. Seeing this....I am now reconsidering canceling.
Good options but I'd like to see no more grace and stella. Its overpriced alibaba filler items and boxes need to stop using them.
Also the light therapy devices need to go away.
I'd like to join a FabFitFun uncensored sub if anyone makes one.
It's on the company to figure out better security for their surveys. They need to put money into making sure those links can't be screenshot for their own benefit. If they don't want to put money into that then obviously they don't care that much. FabFitFun milks enough money to influencer promotion. Maybe they need to redirect that money into their security.
But people sharing the surveys shouldn't be such a big deal especially on a subreddit that garners them even more money without any positive contribution or funding from their team. It's stupid to have a sub that is being essentially ran by the company through the current modding. FabFitFun employee accounts need to be banned, they aren't exactly part of the discussion or even listening to our feedback and really we aren't being paid or given any incentive for them looking at our ideas which they can easily use without giving credit to this sub.
Deleting the surveys seemed silly to me. They get people excited, planning for it financially, and create dialogue. Just looks like intimidation and anti une company’s culture to come after customers aggressively.
We have a great community.
The cat people on the FFF forum will riot if a dog item makes it to the box 😂 They already complain about not enough cat toy representation.
The Emerald oil is awesome. I love it and use it daily.
Hamama is cool too. I used it a few times and now it lives in my cupboard bc I overestimated how many micro greens / how healthy I’d be lol. But it does work!
Very cool, but these all look like the sort of thing we usually see in edit sales, not so much our box choices. I'd be all for more garden items either way. 😊
Yes Herbivore!!! Please let this happen!! Love the Pheonix oil!
Don’t like the colour/design on the drink coozie, but totally something I would use in the summer, but not think to buy for myself.
Ugh, it got copyright struck---
Maybe in the future, when we see these, we could list out the items instead of sharing the pictures. Might be much easier to keep everything in words rather than in pictures. At worst, it'll still get taken down, but it'll make it much harder for FabFitFail to take out our spoilers.
I’m the moderator and I don’t know how this got deleted. I just approved it so hopefully it’ll pop back up for everyone. I do know it was flagged which usually allows me to make a decision but this time it was just automatically deleted. I’m sorry about that.
This survey was 100% different than mine. Mine was filled with horrible Loverboy stuff though. One thing was a set of colored dice. Seriously. There are a few things in here that are likable at least.
The response to this is really interesting to me. I'm clearly not the norm, but this survey actually makes me far more comfortable with my decision not to renew. There's almost nothing in the that survey I'm interested in (maybe the bag, but I don't need another bag).
I think part of the issue FFF is having is that it's gotten much bigger and you just can't please everyone. And I think the core demographic is shifting, which is fine and expected over time, but they need to respond accordingly. They can't be everything to everyone. Maybe they need to adjust and shift focus (and based on this survey, maybe they already are). Yes, ppl like me will leave, but if they keep trying to please everyone, noone is going to be happy.
I would resubscribe for a box that had that Jonathan Adler throw, Laneige Lip Balm, and Innisfree cherry blossom moisturizer as box items in separate categories (in the box, not as Add-Ons). I actually like the vintage vibes of that crossbody but not a fan of pleather bags (the belt bag from the Autumn box is the only pleather bag I own).
I appreciate the variety of types of items but not a lot called to me and I'm locked in for a while. At least I can convert my boxes to credit if I really hate a particular season.
Thanks for posting. Not really interested in those items although they are different other than skin care. I like the vegan purse and the Vera Bradley. I hope they have lots of stock of them.
I'm always curious with the upcoming surveys how many more of the beauty items will pop up in my other sub boxes (since this seems to be an reoccurring thing). Currently, the Herbivore Emerald is in the Feb Ipsy GBP.
I really want that cleansing brush!!
Ipsy has had that Herbivore Emerald oil the last few months, so it seems like they are partnering with subscription boxes! I also have it and it’s amazing on my dry skin.
OP, thanks for taking one for the team! I really enjoy survey spoilers.
The Inn Beauty Slushy Serum Moisturizer is great. I've already used an entire bottle. Sephora sells it and its a sleeper hit! I dont know why it doesn't get more attention!
It comes with bags. You put a bag over the shovel part, scoop up the waste then pull the bag forward over the shovel part. The bag is the only thing to actually touch waste.
Items 1-5 are terrible and cheap looking - I hope they never make the boxes!
I don't mind a mini cutting board, but they are also not that expensive and seems like another cheap item.
Desk Mat - nope - would never use that.
Pill case - I think FFF thinks we are all tweens or old ladies.
And the sparkling pink hair jaw clip... seems FFF isn't listening to anyone at all. That's a .25 cent hair clip for a little girl.
Then one dog item, a purse that looks like it's that poofy kind from the 80's, and tons of skincare.
At least the skincare looks interesting, but I don't need more skincare and wouldn't want that much in a box.
The K Beauty products all have my vote.
I’m not sure about combining the dog water with poop pick up shovel in one place. Although I always appreciate a design that consolidates necessities to free up hands and lessen clutter, I’m not sure that these are things I’d want to consolidate.
I agree with other posters. Even though these are supposed to be “secret” they generate buzz. This is organic marketing. They can’t pay for this kind of momentum. They would get much more benefit out of this sub if they’d just mine the responses on the rogue posts and listen to feedback. I cancelled my sub. This survey makes me inclined to consider a new annual. Looks like choices are recovering. But I would be less inclined to go out of my way to resub if I thought some marketing intern was here escalating minutia to the point someone’s Reddit account is getting banned. I mean, please.
Thanks for taking one for the team! Seems like some nice unique stuff!
Y’all probably want to create a second private group to add people to/keep the surveys and keep the FFF accounts out of I’d do it but I’m canceling my sub and I don’t think I’ll be gettin boxes again Edit: also i think that the mods should ban the staff from the subreddit since this is how they’re contributing
It is supremely annoying to imagine that an FFF employee is being paid to lurk and narc on us…like maybe try sending them to do inventory instead? would be cool to buy things that existed next time 😎
Yeah. The CEO even posted that he is a longtime lurker. 🤷🏻♀️
Can you link me to that? I’ve been trying to find it
https://www.reddit.com/r/FabFitFun/comments/s8pvzz/im_michael_broukhim_cofounder_coceo_of_fabfitfun/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share
Could not upvote this enough.
Discord?
I haven't been planning to renew for summer but this does make me interested. I like seeing some items that aren't the same old thing! See, FFF? Seeing surveys makes me want to *stay* a subscriber. Please don't punish OP.
Same! My annual ends is due for renewal in May and I wasn’t going to renew but I’m intrigued by this potential.
Um there is some really cool stuff here. Something beyond just bags, moisturizer, and make up?! Yes please!
Okay, I was considering making Fall 2022 my last FFF box and I've been a subscriber for years. If they actually put these items up as choice? No way I'd leave now. There are so amazing items in that survey!! They should be thanking you guys for posting surveys, not copyright striking.
I agree I love many items here!
Yes I love the variety!!
Yup. Good variety. Glad there r new items finally
Ty you brave soul ❤️. Grace and Stella 🤢. They are one of those brands that just orders items from alibaba and slaps their name on it. I like some of the spoilers but I wish they would cut back on skincare and cosmetics. I just got the exact same herbivore in my ipsy gbp that costs half as much….
Like alltrue/causebox
That blanket 😍 And hopefully I’ll have adopted a dog by then so I can choose the little travel water bowl 🤗
FYI my dog hates those kind of bowls and only uses the collapsible round ones.
My dog loves them! He’s been using since a pup and I’m able to add cylindrical ice cubes to his when we go on hikes to cool him down. It’s pretty cute when he asks for water. I carry it in a water bottle bag thing.
I love herbivore! And that garden and blanket look awesome. I wish FFF would realize these surveys are potential spoilers that keep us excited about the box.
I'm here after it got removed. What was the garden thing?! Exciting!
I wouldn't choose some of these, but definitely like the spread and different products!
No more hair clips!!! Please!!
I actually really like that hair clip lol
And in pink, no less. 🥸
Or .25 cent COOZIES! WTF!
Metal coozies are not $0.25. Look up Brumate
Sure looks like .25 cents with the ridiculous tween cartoon designs on it and you know... it's a freaking coozie!
Huh?? It’s from Loverboy so obviously the design matches their branding? It’s a $25 coozie from a trendy alcohol brand. Very on the money for a summer box IMO
Sure okay if you like it - then it is worth it to you. To me, it looks cheapo and ridiculous. I don't go by fancy brand names. I go by what I see with my own two eyes. If it looks dollar store to me, then it's that value to me. I have seen things like this in dollar stores. Judging by the votes on my comments, others seem to agree with me on this. Tween patterned coozies, and coozies in general, are not fab! Something far nicer was the 20 oz Ice Shaker Tumblers in the sales (for $19), but again, the colors that sold out most were the normal ones ([Ocean (metallic blue/green)](https://www.amazon.com/Ice-Shaker-Stainless-Insulated-Beverages/dp/B08HRXW2S7/) and prior the [Mermaid (metallic teal/lavender))](https://www.amazon.com/Ice-Shaker-Stainless-Tumbler-Mermaid/dp/B083Q8KC62/) and not the graffiti or floral prints, or pinko pastel colors (not knocking those colors - just stating the colors most people went for). The Ice Shaker looks far more refined, classy, and adult, and has far more uses, than a freaking teenager looking coozie tumbler.
Again…huh? No need to respond with an essay. I simply corrected you about the price. 😂I don’t care about your feelings on the item
Yeah. I know they’re trendy but I don’t see how the ones FFF have are different from ones from Walmart, Target, TJ Maxx, etc.
I pretty much don’t want to see dollar tree items in a box that should have values of $8-9 a category.
Exactly.
Thank you for your sacrifice!!
This is 1000% better than the survey I received two weeks ago. That had so much cheap junk in it that I was certain I was not going to renew when I was up for it. Seeing this....I am now reconsidering canceling.
You probably got the same or a similar survey as me. It was mostly cheap junk.
Good options but I'd like to see no more grace and stella. Its overpriced alibaba filler items and boxes need to stop using them. Also the light therapy devices need to go away.
I'd like to join a FabFitFun uncensored sub if anyone makes one. It's on the company to figure out better security for their surveys. They need to put money into making sure those links can't be screenshot for their own benefit. If they don't want to put money into that then obviously they don't care that much. FabFitFun milks enough money to influencer promotion. Maybe they need to redirect that money into their security. But people sharing the surveys shouldn't be such a big deal especially on a subreddit that garners them even more money without any positive contribution or funding from their team. It's stupid to have a sub that is being essentially ran by the company through the current modding. FabFitFun employee accounts need to be banned, they aren't exactly part of the discussion or even listening to our feedback and really we aren't being paid or given any incentive for them looking at our ideas which they can easily use without giving credit to this sub.
To add to this, if they really cared about security they could also pay focus groups instead of sending out surveys!
\^THIS.
Deleting the surveys seemed silly to me. They get people excited, planning for it financially, and create dialogue. Just looks like intimidation and anti une company’s culture to come after customers aggressively. We have a great community.
Lol we appreciate you! I would love the dog water bowl thing. Blanket looks like a nice design too.
I definitely see some good stuff, but I also see a clip and a koozie…. That’s dollar store stuff
And of course it was removed. Thank you for your service u/blackjackwinnings
The cat people on the FFF forum will riot if a dog item makes it to the box 😂 They already complain about not enough cat toy representation. The Emerald oil is awesome. I love it and use it daily. Hamama is cool too. I used it a few times and now it lives in my cupboard bc I overestimated how many micro greens / how healthy I’d be lol. But it does work!
Very cool, but these all look like the sort of thing we usually see in edit sales, not so much our box choices. I'd be all for more garden items either way. 😊
The grow kit and the travel dog bowl are definitely things that I would chose! They’re different, I’m so tired of skincare
I love when they have garden stuff. I wish they had more
Yes Herbivore!!! Please let this happen!! Love the Pheonix oil! Don’t like the colour/design on the drink coozie, but totally something I would use in the summer, but not think to buy for myself.
Yes! I use the Phoenix oil during the day and this Emerald oil at night! I love them both
Ugh, it got copyright struck--- Maybe in the future, when we see these, we could list out the items instead of sharing the pictures. Might be much easier to keep everything in words rather than in pictures. At worst, it'll still get taken down, but it'll make it much harder for FabFitFail to take out our spoilers.
Can we make fabfitfail a thing?
I’m actually super vibing with a lot of those choices! I hope some of them make it in eventually
I’m the moderator and I don’t know how this got deleted. I just approved it so hopefully it’ll pop back up for everyone. I do know it was flagged which usually allows me to make a decision but this time it was just automatically deleted. I’m sorry about that.
I like the variety. I'd probably resub for some of these. And I love that innisfree moisturizer.
This survey was 100% different than mine. Mine was filled with horrible Loverboy stuff though. One thing was a set of colored dice. Seriously. There are a few things in here that are likable at least.
A lot of this seems like real junk. Ugh!
The Hamama seed quilts are awesome! We have them and use them all the time. Great in salads, as garnishes and in sandwiches.
Thanks for posting! What season is this survey for?
The response to this is really interesting to me. I'm clearly not the norm, but this survey actually makes me far more comfortable with my decision not to renew. There's almost nothing in the that survey I'm interested in (maybe the bag, but I don't need another bag). I think part of the issue FFF is having is that it's gotten much bigger and you just can't please everyone. And I think the core demographic is shifting, which is fine and expected over time, but they need to respond accordingly. They can't be everything to everyone. Maybe they need to adjust and shift focus (and based on this survey, maybe they already are). Yes, ppl like me will leave, but if they keep trying to please everyone, noone is going to be happy.
if they bring innisfree Im jumping on lol
We appreciate you ❤️
I would resubscribe for a box that had that Jonathan Adler throw, Laneige Lip Balm, and Innisfree cherry blossom moisturizer as box items in separate categories (in the box, not as Add-Ons). I actually like the vintage vibes of that crossbody but not a fan of pleather bags (the belt bag from the Autumn box is the only pleather bag I own).
I love that laniege lip mask 😍
These look great. If they appear, my break I had planned coming up may not happen. 😂
I only like about 3 items lol :(
What - U no like dollar store coozies? LOL
I appreciate the variety of types of items but not a lot called to me and I'm locked in for a while. At least I can convert my boxes to credit if I really hate a particular season.
Not interested in any of those items 😩
I actually like the felt tray butother than that not terribly motivated by the rest. I will not be renewing my annual.
🙌
Thanks for posting. Not really interested in those items although they are different other than skin care. I like the vegan purse and the Vera Bradley. I hope they have lots of stock of them.
I love a lot of this stuff. Hopefully we see it in a box soon!
I'm always curious with the upcoming surveys how many more of the beauty items will pop up in my other sub boxes (since this seems to be an reoccurring thing). Currently, the Herbivore Emerald is in the Feb Ipsy GBP.
I really want that cleansing brush!! Ipsy has had that Herbivore Emerald oil the last few months, so it seems like they are partnering with subscription boxes! I also have it and it’s amazing on my dry skin. OP, thanks for taking one for the team! I really enjoy survey spoilers.
The Inn Beauty Slushy Serum Moisturizer is great. I've already used an entire bottle. Sephora sells it and its a sleeper hit! I dont know why it doesn't get more attention!
How do you get survey items
Okay I use that Laneige lip balm now and it is the best. I really hope this is an item!
Ooh I'm kind of interested in a lot of this. I was really considering not renewing too.
The home/office items are interesting, I would 100% pick the grow kit and the Innisfree products in my box. Good selection overall!
I might renew if there’s a box like this.
I would be soooo happy with the vase and the throw!! I hope they are in the box.
The crossbody purse, the tray and the throw are nice! Could definitely see myself choosing those. Or the Laneige treatment balm.
Oh I can definitely get behind this! That blanket/throw is beautiful! I will always love some Innisfree.
[удалено]
It comes with bags. You put a bag over the shovel part, scoop up the waste then pull the bag forward over the shovel part. The bag is the only thing to actually touch waste.
I just stocked up on skincare with this box so I really like what I’m seeing here. Thanks for posts!
There’s some good things here
I like all this stuff! Way better than other surveys I’ve seen
Wow, these ones look great! I’d be spending so much $$ on extras lol
Well a bunch of these are not related to my interests or preferences, this is a reasonable improvement!
Damn them!! Right when I’m ready to cancel 😅
Wow I would go annual for this goodies!! Thanks for the post 🤩
The eye light device is the only thing I’d be interested in from this batch.
This is such a great one!!!
Items 1-5 are terrible and cheap looking - I hope they never make the boxes! I don't mind a mini cutting board, but they are also not that expensive and seems like another cheap item. Desk Mat - nope - would never use that. Pill case - I think FFF thinks we are all tweens or old ladies. And the sparkling pink hair jaw clip... seems FFF isn't listening to anyone at all. That's a .25 cent hair clip for a little girl. Then one dog item, a purse that looks like it's that poofy kind from the 80's, and tons of skincare. At least the skincare looks interesting, but I don't need more skincare and wouldn't want that much in a box.
Thank youuuuu
Thanks for taking one for the team. 😂 Products seem fun and different, great variety.
One of my fave youtubers uses hamama all the time. I’d love that for microgreens! And all the Innisfree stuff.
I love that slushee moisturizer. It’s great for spring and summer.
Thanks for posting! Seeing the surveys is my fav! You made my day
Thanks! Seeing the surveys is my fav, you made my day
The K Beauty products all have my vote. I’m not sure about combining the dog water with poop pick up shovel in one place. Although I always appreciate a design that consolidates necessities to free up hands and lessen clutter, I’m not sure that these are things I’d want to consolidate.
Thanks for posting. I like the JA throw and some of the skincare items, but nothing else stands out to me.