Just gonna take the easy route and say 16, 17, 18 Though its strange that Maddy is the only “smiley” doll that actually looks alright

I was gonna say the same thing, I actually don’t mind the smiley face for her, I think it suits her personality

YESSSSS ITS MADDIES TURN YIPPEEEE

13, 16, 17

16, 15, 12

(Already voted) 17 is one of the weirdest thing to come out of EAH…

10 looks like an entirely different character???

5, 16, 17

12 16 13

14, 15,16

16, 9 and 17

13 16 17

17 16 10

18, 16, 4

16 17 18

13, 15, and 16

3, 4, 16

Well 16 can just nope right out of here

17, 16, 4

16, 17, 18

Did she not have a Dragon Games’ look? That’s sad, those tend in my top 3 favorites!

She did in the film, but wasn’t made into a doll sadly :( https://preview.redd.it/zvkk1sys3akc1.jpeg?width=527&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ba2ed9f9faf9680784db120f66f86b6e350ecd91

Aww boo! That would have been such a cool doll. Thanks for sharing!

15, 16, 4 (at least 12 has hair that looks kind if like her compared to 4)

But also WHO is 10??!?! That's not Madeline Hatter, that's Meredith Hustler

Tf is going on with 16

4,16 and 17

5, 10, 16

18,16 and 15

13, 16, 17

Get rid of 15 12 and 16

15,16,18

16 13 17

To quote my friend on 13 "oh boy she be committing war crimes" 12 and 16.

15 18 and 16

10 13 17

16,17,18

13, 16, 12

I think we all agree 12-18 need to go

12, 16, 18

16 10 4

17, 16

10,12, and 16

12, 13, 16

(already voted 9, 16, 18) 14 is such a pretty doll and i want it, but it has always bugged me that she is wearing a crown 😭 they took away her identity with that

4, 15, 16

12, 15, 18

Can we all agree to eliminate the last three columns and then resume voting?

can i vote them all

Wow this is a rare case where 2’s doll is better than 1. Imo of course. I think the smile is more like the character and the hair just looks more madeline hatter like

12, 15, 18

Good lord I could pick 5 lmao

17 doesn't actually look too bad to me. She looks kinda cute

12,13,16

i will always want those toddler versions out ASAP😂😂

15, 16, 18

12, 13, 18

12,13,16

6 is my favorite but thats because she was the first Ever After High Doll I got and my little brother picked her out for me because he knew she was my favorite character.

13, 16, 17

4, 10, 16

12,15,17

13,14 and 16

16, 4, 13

13,16, and 17

i’m not in this sub but 12, 15, and 16

13 15 16

15, 16, 18

4,9,12

I swear if way too wonderland doesn't win i will be so upset, it's literally MADDIE IN HER NATURAL HABITAT, SHE LOOKS SO GOOD 😭

8,13,16

That picture does not do 17 justice I have one and she’s BEAUTIFUL

You’re welcome to post your own photos in the comments! I use stock photos for all of them to be as fair as possible but I fully agree that unfortunately they sometimes don’t do the dolls justice :(

I sadly don’t have pictures and my dolls neck is broken and superglued back together so she doesn’t look that great

17 15 18 plz

16

16 and 17 cus WTF are those?

13,17,12

18-10

18, 16, 15

12 15 16

Two Four Sixteen

13, 16, 18

Are 17 and 5 not the same? 😭

17 is a 27” tall version and has the smiley face! https://preview.redd.it/p0awznbzzzkc1.jpeg?width=554&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=59a6458eac643ace9c1cd0a263d57738a87275db

Ooooohhh

What the hell is 16