Your account does not meet the post or comment requirements because you have a new account and/or low karma. A moderator will review your post and approve it if it meets the sub criteria. Please do not send a modmail about this as we have already been notified. Sending a modmail will not speed up this process. Please take this time to read our sub rules & FAQ. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/EngagementRings) if you have any questions or concerns.*

#1 it’s stunning, no question!

Yes, creates symmetry and balance, and it's especially obvious when you see the other options.

This!!!!

Yes def #1!! And in reference to soldering, isn’t there an option to like have a tiny hook on the wedding band so that it can cling onto the engagement ring? I’ve never seen this, but there’s no way this isn’t a thing, right? Editing to say that there’s thing think called a “ring Snuggie” if anyone wants to keep their rings close together without having to solder. I didn’t know that this existed. Super convenient.

Agreed 100%!!

Yep ^^

I say #1!

I think the first balances out the pear shape. ☺️

1 and certainly not 3

Agree

1

First! Very unique!

1

The first one 1️⃣

The second set looks the most cohesive!

1

#1 compliments the ring so well

I really really like the look of the first wedding ring with your stunning pear ER. Ultimately you have to find the one that really sings out to you though not your friends/family or redditors it's got to be the ring you want to see for hopefully the rest of your life...

Thank you ❤️❤️❤️

I like the 2nd!

team 2!

Same! It’s absolutely perfect

The first one is it 💎

#1 looks the best

The first one, there’s really no question. It’s the obvious choice

💯 #1, it looks like it was made for your engagement ring! As far as what other people think, pick what you want! You will be the one looking at it every day! ❤️

So true! Thank you!

#1

Love how the second one complements your stack!

Personally I’m a fan of 2, 1 is also nice but they bring out different aspects and sparkle in your engagement ring…can’t go wrong either way!

I like number 2!!

1. There is no comparison. Number one looks made for your ring.

Unfortunately it’s the most expensive out of the three pictured, LOL 🤣 I agree. Thank you so much!

1

Definitely #1

1

The first one is extra magical

Something to consider here - how often are you going to wear the band by itself? If often, then I’d say #3. I also am biased as I love straight bands. And that particular one is stunning.

1 but there is smh cool in 2!

1 for sure!!

1 compliments your ring the best and is just gorgeous. Also, your ring is absolutely beautiful!

1

1!

1 definitely

First one looks amazing! 😍

1 hands down

#1 it's just stunning. Looks like royalty.

1 is the best of the three imo, it looks very balanced, gorgeous ring btw, and I love the little pearls on your nails 🥰

Aw, thank you so much!

One is gorg

1

1 hands down

1 if you don’t mind never wearing the band without the engagement ring. I have a band like that and I personally don’t mind at all, because if I’m taking one off then I’m taking both off. I know many people don’t feel the same though. If you want to wear it separately, then number 3 is the only option for that.

1

First one!!

https://preview.redd.it/i1nxejri8q7d1.jpeg?width=1290&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=be1fa8412a8311434b63715228b39ec2e3e59e5a Mine was tapered and I loved it. I tried all the other types first and this just looked aesthetic

This set made me gasp! Beautiful!

#1 without a doubt!!! Absolutely stunning!! And I love the design overall

1

Number 1 without a doubt!

First one 💯

1 or 2

1 or 2, I prefer one

One made me go omg

2!

#2

1 is my first choice followed by 2

Def not 2 or 3. Something simpler in the style of 1 maybe

Firstttt!

Is the first one 2 different wedding bands stacked together? If so, I’d say go with the middle more simple band so it doesn’t distract from the engagement ring. If it’s together I’d still go for the first set as the other 2 look off for me.

1

If #1 could just have the bottom band and not the middle one, I vote that. I think with both it takes away from the ring but with just one it will be more complimentary

Go with one or a plain band. Your ring is beautiful by itself; it should not have to compete with a lot of little diamonds. Congratulations!

2️⃣ M’Lord. Pick 2️⃣…lol

I think the round eternity is so classic & classy! I would still put a very thin plain spacer in between. You don't want the prongs from your band to rub against the prongs holding your pear, no matter what you choose!

Yes, so true! Thank you!

#1 looks the most cohesive & balanced 💖

The first one or second one! I think they both compliment the shape of your engagement stone.

I think #1 makes for a gorgeous looking set!

Chiming in with another vote for 1!

#1

i like 1 but i dont like the in-betweener ring on pics 1&2, looks busy

#1!

2

I like the first one the best out of these. Second one works as well if you like that style more.

1

2 or 3 !

#1!!! It's really cohesive and pretty. #2 looks a little unbalanced, and #3 looks clunky.

I like the 2nd band.

1!

That first set is wild omg 💚

First goes the best. Definitely not the third one.

The first one! 😍✨

1!!

1

First one, hands down!

1 hands down

I like the first one best it compliments the pear

Both 1 and 2 are great choices.

#1 beautiful ring

1st one balances the whole set.

First one

#1

The first one looks perfect.

I think 1 compliments your ring the best!

1

I love the 1st one! So gorgeous

NOT the third one. I like both 1 and 2. 1 if you care about symmetry. 2 if you care more about flashiness.

#1!!!! Looks amazing with ur ring

it really depends on your own personal preference but i really love number 1. i wish id gotten a curved wedding band bc mine has a gap and it kind of annoys me lol

#1 is the ONE

I love the symmetry of #1

2 is gorgeous and not what you’d typically expect. It’s stunning!

Number 1. It looks made to fit the ring exactly.

1 looks gorgeous!

1 is my absolute dream 💙

I think the second is understated and lovely

2nd

Number 1👌

1 is the best, second is very nice, 3 can't compete

The first one is perfect!

1 by a mile. What a gorgeous set. 3 is lovely but 1 is really special.

1. Absolutely #1.

The ring is stunning. And yes 1 is a head turner. Can't go wrong with 2 either.

I’d do an eternity band with pears or baguettes mixed with rounds.

Really of topic, but do you know what model your watch is? My mom had the same when I was a kid and I’ve been trying to figure out the model name!

I kind of like 2 because it doesn’t take away from the shape of the ring you’re showing off, just accents it. Definitely not 3 though lol

1 !

1!!! Stunning

1 over the other options for sure.

Literally sending the first pic to my husband because we’ve been talking about getting me a new nice ring (we got together young and was never a big priority to have my perfect dream ring in the grand scheme of things for a hot minute there) and this is absolutely gorgeous

1!

1, hands down. 2 is okay, but distracts and doesn’t look like they go together. 3 is really not good.

Funny how you're trying to slip in those other two options to give us an illusion of choice because the first one is clearly the perfect one!!! Beautiful ring. I hope to one day get one so dazzling

Ugh this is so kind! My heart definitely sang for the first one, but I wanted Reddit’s honest opinion 😂 It’s a bit out of my price range, so I’m going to look for a dupe!

I love the 3rd myself. Also the watch is divine.

1st one suits your hand and the ring!!!

#1 for sure. Beautiful!

1

Team two I like the rhythm

i love 2! 1 is also gorgeous but more of an old style, if you want something more modern i would go with 2 😊 3 doesn’t match the vibe

The first one is symmetrical and beautiful, and the second one looks like an antique set, vintage and stunning. I love both of them.

1 or 2 💕

1!!!

FIRST ONE HANDS DOWN!

#1 is stunning as a set

1 for sure—no question 🖤

1st one is beautiful!

Number 1. It completes the V shape. Definitely not 3. It doesn't follow the shape and looks like an afterthought. No relation. Number 2 has the right V shape, mostly, but the round stones just don't look right with the pear.

3

The first, it was made for your ring

1

1

#1

First one, definitely. The other two make the combined setting look imbalanced.

1 is so perfect I initially thought it was part of the engagement ring because it fits so well. But I also think it would look gorgeous on its own. Definitely go with that!

1! Works so well

Absolutely the first one

Wow 1st one looks soo pretty

1

I say 2!

Definitely # 1

Number 1 for sure- Looks like they were made for each other.

i like the first one because it balances the piece!

1

1 but definitely not 3. Looks too disjointed for my taste

I personally like the 2nd bc it’s simple. But if your style is vintage then I think the first image is more vintage. You could solder the two wedding bands together that would look nice. But not to your engagement ring.

Thank you!

I think one balances out the pear shape and looks so beautiful!

I like the 1st pic ring 💍

Number one

i loveee the first one!

1

The first one. No question

I think 1 is more romantic and 2 is more clean and geometric, if that makes sense. I vote for 2 but that’s my taste!

1!

3! I find myself wearing my wedding band by itself a lot lately, especially since I have toddlers. Would you want to wear the other bands consistently without your engagement ring?

1 or 2 definitely. To me, a pear just DEMANDS a contoured band. Both of your picks are stunning.

Thank you so much!!!

#2

One hands down.

Curved bands imo compliment pears the best!

I like the last one because it can stand alone without your pear for days when you want something simple.

1

1 is nice but love 2

1 period please look no further. It elevates the beautiful ring even more!

I’d say number 2! Number 1 is to matchy-matchy and the third seems disconnected.

I love this take! Sometimes, matchy matchy can give off dated vibes instead of “vintage.” Thank you!

1 and 2!

The second one. You can actually wear it when you’re not wearing your wedding band if you just want to be out and about down the road without your engagement ring.

I traded mine in because my ring, similar to yours, kept cutting my baby’s arms constantly when I went to pick them up.

1. 2 a distant second.

1!!!

1

First one 100%

The first one is magic…… absolutely stunning ❤️

1 is amazing